|
|
2010 Annual Meeting
Meeting Begins: 11/20/2010
Meeting Ends: 11/23/2010
Call for Papers Opens: 12/15/2009
Call for Papers Closes: 3/1/2010
Requirements for Participation
|
|
Meeting Abstracts
Childhoods A.D. 400: Three Saints on Christian Upbringing
Program Unit: Children in the Biblical World
Reidar Aasgaard, University of Oslo
Around A.D. 400 three men – all church celebrities and saints-to-be – spent considerable time and energy in producing works on children. Drawing on their own childhood experiences and more or less close familiarity with children's lives, they reflected on the problems and potentials of this stage of life and offered abundant advice on how children were to be brought up.
Although these three men knew of each other, they penned these works quite independently of one another, and also in different genres. In Asia Minor, John Chrysostom (347-407) wrote his pedagogical treatise Address on Vainglory and the Right Way for Parents to Bring up Their Children. In Palestine, Jerome (347-420) in a number of letters – e.g. Letter 107 – presented his ideas on the Christian formation of children. And in North Africa, Augustine (354-430) in his Confessions told and reflected on the story of his own childhood years. Whereas Chrysostom mainly commented on boys, Jerome gave his advice on girls, while the object of study for Augustine was himself in retrospect.
In their works, these three figures show that they had several ideas in common as concerns children, many of which were characteristic of their times. Still, their thinking about childhood and children's Christian formation differ in perceptible ways.
In this paper, I shall focus on how each of them warrants their attitudes to children and their upbringing. In particular, I will analyze their use of the Bible. What texts did they draw on as concerns children? What aspects did they focus on in the biblical material? How did they apply the biblical advice in their own contexts? What does this tell about their understanding of children as human beings? And how are their views related to their more general personal, pastoral and theological interests?
|
Decolonizing the Reading of Psalm 91 in an African Perspective
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
David Tuesday Adamo, Kogi State University
The purpose of this paper is to discuss critically the Eurocentric reading of Psalm 91 and then offer the alternative reading in African perspective. This paper is based on the field research conducted mostly in Nigerian indigenous churches, South African indigenous churches and Kenyan indigenous churches.
It will also demonstrate the fact that such African approach to the interpretation of Psalm 91 has not only spread across the sea, but it is as legitimate as other Eurocentric interpretation.
|
The Burning Bush, an Ecological Sin? An African Reading of Exodus 3:1–3
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
David Tuesday Adamo, Kogi State University
This paper is a critical examination of the Euro-American interpretation of Exodus 3:1-3 and provide a decolonized Afrian interpretation. The author uses his experience of bush burning in Irunda village, East Yagba Local Government, Kogi State, Nigeria as a background to this interpretation.
In light of the consequence of bush burning in Irunda village (possibly in all Nigeria) today, could this passage be taken as a warning against the consequence of bush burning? Yet the early missionaries who came to Irunda never taught us of the consequence using the Bible. Can we go beyond the traditional Western interpretation of the passage of burning bush and interpret Exodus 3:1-3 as warning against the ecological sin in African perspective? If such interpretation had been taken into consideration by the missionaries, could we not have avoided the present consequence of bush burning in Irunda and all over Africa?
|
"Things That Are" and "Things That Are Not": Cosmological Rhetoric in 1 Corinthians 1:27–29
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Edward Adams, King's College London
This paper is one of three invited papers, including papers by Troels Engberg-Pedersen and Stanley Stowers, for a session on ancient cosmology and the Pauline epistles.
|
Family Life
Program Unit:
Samuel Adams, Union Presbyterian Seminary
Family Life
|
Luke and Greco-Roman Education: Luke’s Education and Its Influence on the Selection of Genre
Program Unit: Formation of Luke and Acts
Sean A. Adams, University of Edinburgh
Although often take for grated, the nature and role of education in the ancient world had a profound influence on the literature produced within an epoch and geographic region. Similarly, cultural preferences, from both dominate and subordinate ethnic powers, shaped the development and character of prestigious and low literature alike. Accordingly, investigations into progymnasmatic texts, as well as the educational writings of Cicero and Quintilian provide insight into the educational world in which the New Testament writers were educated and the New Testament documents were penned.
Dialoguing with the progymnasmatic works of Kennedy and others, as well as the modern studies on Luke, this paper seeks to re-investigate the enigma of Lukan education and the affect of said education on the Lukan writings. While identifying Luke’s educational influences is an important endeavour in its own right, the results of this investigation provide an important platform into the examination of Lukan style, the relationship of Luke-Acts to extra-biblical texts, and the identification of the genre of Luke-Acts. While these three aspects are important, it is particularly with the later that the application of this investigation will focus on.
|
The Septuagint of Hannah's Psalm
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Historical Books
Anneli Aejmelaeus, University of Helsinki
This paper functions as an introduction to the Septuagint of Hannah’s Psalm (1 Sam 2:1-10) as well as to the discussion of the different versions of this text in the workshop session of Textual Criticism of Samuel – Kings. It includes a description of the translation character of Hannah’s Psalm in the Septuagint and reviews the textual differences in comparison to the MT, which in this case has a shorter text. As a poetic text and a psalm, Hannah’s Psalm has been widely used by Jews as well as Christians, and this is reflected in its frequent quotation and the complexity of its textual history.
|
Where Do Doublets Come From? A Problem of the Septuagint of 1 Samuel
Program Unit: Transmission of Traditions in the Second Temple Period
Anneli Aejmelaeus, University of Helsinki
In principle, doublets are created in the textual transmission of the Septuagint as a result of comparison with the Hebrew text and consequent new translation or recensional activity. If the alternative translations are different enough – or indeed translate different formulations of the source text – a scribe whose work is confined to the Greek material may copy alternative readings, one after the other, thus expanding the text. In many cases, the emergence of doublets can be observed and traced back to certain recensions. The Greek text of 1 Samuel is, however, rich in doublets that have come about so early in the transmission history that their origin is not visible. Is this phenomenon in 1 Samuel a result of early recensional activity? Or should we perhaps think that the original translator – hesitating between alternative translations – created doublets?
_______________________________________________________________________
|
Defenseless Flower: Jorge Mesters and Brazil
Program Unit: Latino/a/e and Latin American Biblical Interpretation
Efrain Agosto, Hartford Seminary
Defenseless Flower: Jorge Mesters and Brazil
|
Memory as an Indicator of Belief in the Oracle of Trophonius
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
Stephen P. Ahearne-Kroll, Methodist Theological School in Ohio
Pausanias describes the process of consulting the oracle of Trophonius as requiring the inquirer to drink from the Waters of Oblivion (Lethe), in order to purge the mind to receive Trophonius’ communications, and then to drink from the Waters of Memory (Mnemosune), in order to remember what will be communicated by Trophonius. After descending into a chasm where the inquirer purportedly interacts with the god, the inquirer then ascends from the chasm and is seated on the throne of Memory (epi thronon Mnemosunes) and “debriefed” by the priests. Memory plays a key role in the inquirer’s ritual experience at the oracle, but memory also stands as a key intellectual, cultural, and religious category in Greek tradition found as far back as the archaic period. In Mnemosune, epic poets ground their ability to tell authoritative stories of the gods (i.e. through the Muses, daughters of Mnemosune, thus arbiters of memory; Hesiod, Theogony 29-34, Works and Days 1-2; Hymn to Hermes 1, Hymn to Aphrodite 1, et al.). Initiates utilize the Bacchic gold tablets as memory devices to negotiate the afterlife properly, including the choice to drink from the Waters of Memory resulting in a happy afterlife with the memories of their of lives intact (Tablets 1, 2, 8, 25). And Plato formulates an epistemology that includes recollection of things already known (Meno), but he also imagines a process of perfection and ascent through remembering what was beheld by the soul in hyperouranos (Phaedrus 246A-250A). Clearly, memory has a consistent cultural history of facilitating contact between the divine and human worlds, and it taps into authoritative and foundational knowledge of these worlds. The evocation of memory in the oracle’s ritual should be viewed as an indicator that the inquirer assents to memory’s power to facilitate contact with and epistemological transformation by Trophonius.
|
At Home In Babylon: “Israel” and “Jacob” in Second Isaiah (Descendants of 597 and Descendants of 587)—The Group That Did NOT Wish to Return
Program Unit: Exile (Forced Migrations) in Biblical Literature
John Ahn, Austin Presbyterian Theological Seminary
Carefully examining Israel and Jacob passages in Second Isaiah (40-55) reveals that the two characters, though one person or nation, are quite distinctive, leaving markers that represent two different socio-economic groups from the southern kingdom of Judah in 597 and 587/582. Applying the threefold “straight-line, bumpy-line, and underclass” assimilation theories on Second Judeo-Babylonians, this paper suggests Israel as those assimilated with some modicum of success (middle/upper class) and Jacob as those still in corvee, "by the irrigation canals of Babylon" (underclass).
|
Isaiah 42:6b Revisited: Judeo-Babylonians as Light to the Enigmas
Program Unit: Covenant in the Persian Period
John Ahn, Austin Presbyterian Theological Seminary
The predicative imperfects ???? and ???? coupled with the construct clauses ????? ?? and
???? ???? have been difficult to translate with precision (JPS, NRSV, NIV, NJB, etc). The
antecedent of the 2/m/s pronominal suffix further raises the question (1) who is the “you”
referring back to, which then raises the larger problem of (2) the function of the suffering
servant introduced at the outset of the chapter—clearly identified as a single individual.
In order to address these problems, I offer as an interpretive key the Judeo-Babylonians
who represent the true recipient of the covenant, those that function as “light” to restore
all displaced and resettled Judeans (and Israel) throughout the coastlands, Egypt,
Samaria, Babylon, and elsewhere.
|
The Construction of Relational Space in Luke’s Narrative
Program Unit: Space, Place, and Lived Experience in Antiquity
Yong-Sung Ahn, Presbyterian Theological Seminary (Seoul)
This presentation explores the narrative construction of space in Luke-Acts, utilizing David Harvey’s notion of relational space and Henri Lefebvre’s analysis of the production of space. For Harvey, space does not exist outside the processes that define it. Thus, one cannot understand an event at a spatial point by observing only what exists at that point without taking into consideration other diverse influences through the past, present, and future. For Lefebvre, space is not a pre-established entity just outside of us but a social product. He attempts to analyze the actual production of space using triad moments of perceived spatial practice, conceived representation of space and lived representational space. Spatial practice includes “the production and reproduction and the particular locations and spatial ties characteristic of each social formation.” Not only the spatial practice but also its symbolic representation serves to maintain the space. Along with the representation of space, which is the frontal expressions of the relations, Lefebvre calls attention to the “clandestine or underground side of social life,” i.e., the representational space.
After summarizing the theories of Harvey and of Lefebvre, I describe how their analysis of spatial production can help understanding Luke’s narrative construction of space. Through a textual analysis focused on Jerusalem in Luke-Acts in general, the spatial matrix of Luke is shown as regards its relational spatial practices, relational representation of space, and relational space of representation each posited in the narrative. And then, the textual analysis is narrowed down into Acts 3:1-4:31 to explore how Luke constructs the Temple and the city of Jerusalem as two spaces in contrast. On one hand, the Temple is constructed as a space favorable to Jesus through the connection with the Jewish collective memories. On the other, the city of Jerusalem is represented as hostile to Jesus, as the city in which Herod and Pontius Pilate, the imperial powers, collaborate with the Gentiles and the people of Israel to oppose Jesus (4:25-28). Through the double representation of Jerusalem, Luke presents an aspiration for an alternative world in a covert way, in Lefebvre’ terms, in a way of represtational space.
|
Augustine’s Imagined Community of the Dead: Commentary on Post-tractum 142 De sepultura catechumenorum
Program Unit: Religious World of Late Antiquity
Mika Ahuvia, Princeton University
While the burial practices of second-temple period and first century CE Palestine have been studied, the evidence for mortuary rituals in Late Antique Palestine has not received enough attention. Moving away from approaches that are focused on comparison of theological attitudes or limited to examining one cemetery, the present study seeks to place Jewish burials in the context of the Late Roman Mediterranean. While ancient spectators could likely distinguish between a Jewish and a Roman funeral, upper class Jews and Romans shared the majority of their funerary practices in the diverse cultural atmosphere of Late Antique Palestine. For this reason, the physical remains of burials do not stand out as distinctive products of Jewish culture. It seems that socio-economic considerations primarily determined burial practices. Furthermore, contextualizing the literary and archaeological evidence suggests that the attempt to categorize burials along religious lines in Late Antique Palestine is misleading. Beginning with polemical religious texts of the ancient world frames our studies in terms of the categories of Jewish, Christian, and Polytheistic. Indeed, only such preconceptions may be preventing us from finding mixed burial grounds in Late Antique Palestine. A closer study of the literary and archaeological evidence related to burial practices suggests a shared cultural milieu for the inhabitants of this region in the Late Roman Empire. In support of these assertions, literary evidence about Roman and Jewish funerary practices will be examined alongside archaeological remains from the Roman and Palestinian context.
|
A Paranoid Gospel: Jude and the Abolition of Difference
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
George Aichele, Adrian College (Retired)
The so-called "Catholic Epistle" of Jude tells a mythic story of a great struggle between the faithful followers of the "only Master and Lord" Jesus Christ and those "who long ago were designated for ... condemnation" (vs 4) because they "revile the glorious ones" (vs 8). Jude cites apostles, Jewish scriptures, and the book of Enoch, and it announces a "common salvation" (vs 3). Yet this richly metaphorical text is deeply troubled throughout by the possibility of difference among the "saints" in "the last time" (vs 18). In this it is anticipated by other New Testament texts such as Galatians 1:8 or even John 20:30-31. Furthermore, considered apart from its canonical location and Christian tradition, this text tells the reader very little about the others who must be rejected, or even about the beliefs of Jude or his addressees, opening the way for a generalized reading of Jude by any Christian against any others. My analysis of this book draws upon critical insights of Barthes, Kristeva, Foucault, and especially Deleuze and Guattari, among others.
|
Placing Christian Origins into the Ordinary: The Hellenistic Meal and the "Birth of Christianity“
Program Unit: Romans through History and Cultures
Soham Al-Suadi, University of Basel
The “Birth of Christianity” is usually characterized as a single event of extraordinary significance for the ancient world and for future generations, and it is often related to the figures of Jesus or Paul as relevant founders. This interpretation still implies that the „Birth of Christianity“ has taken place somewhere between the historical Jesus and Paul, and is to be identified in the Biblical text.
Recent socio-historical scholarship has shown that the “Birth of Christianity” can be located in the overall social practice of the Hellenistic meal, which was not an identity marker for Christianity but a performance for social, political and religious experimentation (H.Taussig). Taussig understands the Hellenistic meal as a semi-private social act, which allowed the participants to experiment with social variables so that they could put new social alternatives into practice. Consequently this interpretation is analyzing not one single “Beginning of Christianity” but many. Considering that the beginnings of Christianity can be found within this social practice, this paper argues to place Christian Origins into ordinary dining practice.
For that reason it examines the dining structures of daily life in the Greco-roman culture to focus on the social practice of the Hellenistic meal. It discusses the time and location of these meals to argue for an understanding of cultural codes, which allowed social, political and religious transformations. The analysis is based on socio-historical studies (E. and W.Stegemann) and will examine the features of daily life in the letters of Paul to illustrate how Christ- Believers were able affirm and transform shared values at the same time. It will focus particularly on Romans 14 to study the historical perspectives of the ordinary to serve a social, political and religious transformation. This paper appreciates the ordinary as a place for social, political and religious transformation and the “Birth of Christianity” within the Hellenistic Meal.
|
Dining-Identities: How Dining with Jesus and Sarapis Influenced Identity Formations
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Soham Al-Suadi, University of Basel
The Hellenistic Meal was composed of several ritual actions that effected changes in status, affiliation and social identity. The festive meals of communities were part of a highly developed cultural performance, which allowed affirmation and transformation of shared values at the same time.
New Testament scholars like M.Klinghardt and D.Smith began to study the Hellenistic Meal with socio-historical methods (E. and W.Stegemann) and combined it with archeological or anthropological data. Ritual theory was recently used to analyze the New Testament in its ritual world (R.DeMaris) and to place the Lord’s Supper within the Hellenistic meal (H.Taussig). Considering that the beginnings of Christianity can be found within this social practice (H.Taussig), scholars can now examine how ritual actions operate and influence participants' political, social and religious collective identities.
This paper examines the meals of the Sarapis cult and the Jesus movement, and identifies differences and similarities regarding ritual features and effected changes in status, affiliation and social identity. The analysis is based on ancient descriptions of the Sarapiscult and Paul’s characterization of the Lord’s Supper in Romans, Galatians and 1 Corinthians. The paper will argue that the ritual, as a grammar of written and social practice (J.Lieu), influences the participants experiences the most by flexible contextualization. Socially this contextualization can be described as Hellenization, but for the individual communities it contained a great deal of communal participation, which included the participants as well as their families or the koinonia. Knowing that political, social and religious transformations were expressed by the use of the body, the choice of food, the singing of hymns, and other actions encourages one to understand the changed social identity of followers of Sarapis and Jesus.
|
"Were You There?" The Uses of Sacred Time in Conversation with African American Preaching
Program Unit: Academy of Homiletics
Jared E. Alcántara, Princeton Theological Seminary
*
|
Remembering Where We Are: The Evolution of Memory Studies and the Religious Landscapes of Antiquity
Program Unit: Memory Perspectives on Early Christianity and Its Greco-Roman Context
Susan Alcock, Brown University
Abstract to be available by meeting.
|
Faithfulness in the Things before God: Caleb Typology in the Letter to the Hebrews
Program Unit: Hebrews
David M. Allen, Queen's Foundation, Birmingham
Research into Hebrews’ use of the Jewish Scriptures is a long-standing discipline, and one which is commonly focused around the epistle’s appeal to key characters such as Moses, Abraham or Melchizedeck. A primary figure in this retinue is Joshua; consideration of how Hebrews links him with Jesus is particularly invited by the epistle, partly because of the common name, partly because of the tantalising reference of 4:8, partly because of the deafening silence of 11:29-30, and partly because the mantle assumed by Jesus bears such a strong resemblance to that bequeathed to Joshua upon entry into the land. The association, however, only works up to a point; the Joshua typology sits well with the hortatory aspects of the letter, but less easily with its doctrinal portions. To put it another way, Joshua imagery works well for Jesus’ archegos role, but is less compelling in its insights for his archiereus function.
This paper will explore this other high-priestly aspect, and tease out whether Hebrews has a similar OT prototype in mind for the role, beyond the obvious affinity with Melchizedeck. In particular, it will examine the suitability of Caleb for this function; as the one who shares, with Joshua, a leadership role upon entry into the land, to what extent does Caleb inform Hebrews’ portrayal of Jesus? To what extent does Caleb complement, shape or supplement the Joshua typology, and can one even talk profitably about a Caleb typology? As such, the paper will explore the Caleb tradition in more depth, particularly the extent to which he may be said to bear a priestly – or high-priestly? – mantle. Is he indeed one who ultimately deals with “things pertaining to God” (Heb 5:1; cf. 2:17)?
|
The Sabbath and Her Sisters: Circumcision, Sacrifice, Ceremony, and Sabbath in Justin’s Dialogue with Trypho
Program Unit: Sabbath in Text and Tradition
Edward Allen, Union College
Justin Martyr’s Dialogue with Trypho provides plenty of evidence for those who seek to find or deny a “parting of the ways” between Judaism and Christianity in or before the middle of the second century C. E.. Although certain elements of the Dialogue are contrived, there appears to be some historic core to its presentation of Judaism. It also gives a snapshot of the practices of second century Christians in relationship to the Jewish Sabbath and other practices. The Sabbath is mentioned in nineteen passages in the Dialogue and, except for three minor instances, it is always referred to in the context of its sisters: sacrifice, ceremony, and in every case, circumcision. This suggests that from both a Jewish and Christian perspective in the second century, the Sabbath was seen as a Jewish boundary marker inseparable from circumcision, feasts, and other ceremonies. Gentile Christians are seen as outside this boundary while Jewish Christians are recognized by both Jews and Christians as being within the boundary. The tone of the Dialogue is irenic, focusing on many areas that Christianity and Judaism had in common, but the boundary marked by the Sabbath and its sisters gives evidence of a sharp divide between those on each side, suggesting that the parting of the ways had already occurred.
|
Is Hebrews a Supersessionist Text? Sabbath Theology in 3:7–4:13 as Test Case
Program Unit: Sabbath in Text and Tradition
Michael Allen, Knox Theological Seminary
Many have assumed that the anonymous Letter to the Hebrews is the most supersessionistic text in the entire New Testament. Recent studies by Gelardini, Eisenbaum, and Anderson have shown that the socio-cultural context of Hebrews was far more complex than scholars previously grasped, resulting in a very different picture regarding Hebrews’ portrayal of Israel: Jewish-Christian relations were disturbed and disjointed, and the search for religious identity was ongoing (not settled). Such studies have shown the nuance in the anonymous writer’s approach to thinking about the Jewish religion in light of Jesus of Nazareth.
This tendency to rethink Hebrews in light of its socio-cultural context might be supplemented by turning focus to another topic (too often overlooked in discussions of supersessionism in Hebrews): the Sabbath. What if the standard supersessionistic reading of Sabbath in Hebrews was wrong (in light of the canonical sequence implied by the quote from Ps. 95 in Heb. 4:3 as well as the formal structure of this section of the letter)? Might this shape our understanding of Jewish-Christian self-understanding in the latter first century? This paper explores these possibilities by offering an exegesis of Hebrews 3:7-4:13 and then attempting to assess the validity of reading Hebrews as supersessionistic. It considers this section within the argument of the whole letter (looking especially to the programmatic comments in the exordium as well as the imitative exhortations found in chs. 11-12). It will be suggested that grasping the relationship of Hebrews to supersessionism involves coming to terms with the nature of typology in this Epistle.
|
Human Rights and Noahide Theology: A Canonical Development of Rights and Responsibilities
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible and Political Theory
Michael Allen, Knox Theological Seminary
Where might one find biblical precursors to the modern human rights tradition? Martin Luther King, Jr., and many activists look to texts in the prophetic corpus. Might we find deeper roots in the law itself? Many have suggested that the creation of humanity as imago Dei serves to ground an ethic of human rights. Such proposals begin with the creation account of Genesis 1 and trace the imago Dei theme. However, the imago Dei is underdetermined in Genesis 1, so much of this form of argumentation quickly turns to a priori reasoning regarding what it means to be human (e.g., rationality, gender, relationality, dominion, etc.). Surely a more textually-regulated manner of approach is possible.
Some (like J. Levenson and P. Miller) have argued that the Deuteronomic law sustains an open approach to the ‘common good’ that flows far beyond any parochial interest of Israel; others (like W. Harrelson) look to the legal code in Exodus. This is very helpful, yet I wonder if texts earlier in the Pentateuch might begin this process. This paper explores the possibility that the Noahide laws in Genesis 9 begin a canonical reinterpretation of the imago Dei, providing such a textually regulated approach to thinking about rights and serving as a hinge between the relatively underdetermined imago Dei texts found early in Genesis and the later prophetic teaching regarding social justice. This fulcrum-like function of the Noahide teaching can be textually justified, in as much as there are clear intratextual links between Gen. 1 and Gen. 9 and then between Gen. 9 and Isaiah 24-27. By considering how Isaiah reads Noah, we may gain traction in understanding how an internationally conceived theology of human rights and responsibilities can find biblical precursors.
|
Aššur and Enlil: Typology and Assyrian Theology
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Spencer L. Allen, University of Pennsylvania
When heaven and earth were created, Enlil was king. The patron deity of Nippur, he presided over the divine assembly at his court in Ekur. He appointed kings and gods over mankind. His name became synonymous with the highest rank (illilu), and his essence was identified with executive power (illilutu). Imperial gods would eventually overtake his position at the top of their pantheons, but Enlil’s reputation and name remained.
Little surprise that Assyrian scribes likened their patron deity to Enlil. Šamši-Adad I built Aššur his own “Temple of Enlil” in Assyria, and Shalmaneser I proclaimed it “Ekur.” Tiglath-Pileser I announced Ninlil as Aššur’s consort. Later, Aššur took Enlil’s horned cap, his tablet of destinies, and his city Nippur. More importantly, Aššur’s capital took on Nippur’s toponyms: Ešarra, Ekiur, and even Nippur’s nickname, “the Inner City.” For these reasons and others, numerous scholars argue Aššur and Enlil were syncretized.
However, Aššur was not Enlil (nor the Assyrian Enlil) in the Mesopotamian mind as most Assyrian texts distinguish between the two until the 7th century. Neither equated nor syncretized, the Assyrians indentified the two gods typologically. As a hermeneutical tool, typology links the two historical persons or events (or in this case, gods) without dissolving the reality of the type (Enlil) and simultaneously honoring the antitype (Aššur). Through typological presentation, Aššur became not just the head of the pantheon; he became the exalted king and king maker. The Assyrians did not replace Enlil with Aššur nor deny that he was a separate entity; rather, they looked back to the past and found a model for their time and their god, increasingly integrating the names already associated with Enlil to help heighten Aššur’s status as their empire’s ambitions grew.
|
The Jesus Tradition in James 4:1–12
Program Unit: Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
Dale C. Allison, Jr., Pittsburgh Theological Seminary
James 4.1-12 is intertextually rich. It consistently interaacts with the Jewish Bible--borrowing several scriptural idioms, quoting an unknown "graphe," citing Prov 3:34, and interpreting Lev 19.15-18--and further makes good use of the Jesus tradition. V. 3 ironically takes up the Q text in Mt 7.7-8 = Lk 11.9-10. Vv. 11-12 interpret Lev 19:15-18 through the lens of another Q text, Mt 7.1-5 = Lk 6.37, 41-42. And 4.20 might be partly inspired by Lk 6.25 (Q?).
|
Jesus, Isaiah, and the Day of the Lord: The Christology of Isaiah 13
Program Unit: Theological Interpretation of Scripture
Geth Allison, Vance-Granville Community College
In Isaiah 13, the prophet utters the oracle against Babylon promising the wrath of God upon the guilty nation. In particular, Isa. 13:6,9 warns of the impending day of the Lord for all of the earth. According to Mark 13:24-25, Jesus alludes to the imagery of this passage and identifies himself with its divine activity, thereby assuming himself as the referent of Isaiah’s prophecy. His self-understanding is as the divine agent of judgment promised on the day of the Lord. Jesus adopts the day of the Lord imagery to identify his own coming, providing the precedent for such NT formulations as “the day of Jesus Christ” (Phil. 1:6). Thus, the theology of Isa. 13 provides important insight into Jesus’ understanding of himself as divine, eschatological judge and savior. Connecting the roots of Jesus’ proclamation to the theology of Isa. 13 provides canonical context to the earliest christologies of the NT. In particular, three important correlates from Isa. 13 to NT christology are that 1) Jesus embraces Yahweh’s universal mission of judgment as his own, 2) Jesus embraces Yahweh’s wrath as his own, and 3) Jesus defines himself as equal to Yahweh. By a fundamental embrace of the role of Yahweh, Jesus defines himself as the necessary agent to secure the salvation and restoration of the world, a vital concept in developing a biblical christology.
|
Jesus, Justice, and the Day: Paul’s Christology in Acts 17:31
Program Unit: Christian Theology and the Bible
Geth Allison, Vance-Granville Community College
An important component in the theological interpretation of Acts is understanding the canonical developments of its apostolic theology within Christian scripture. In his speech at the Areopagus, Paul proclaims that God “has set a day when he will judge the world with justice by the man he has appointed. He has given proof of this to everyone by raising him from the dead” (Acts 17:31). The aim of this paper is to explore and define the roots of Paul’s theological affirmation in canonical context. Accordingly, there are two key sources to Paul’s christological affirmation. First, he is dependent upon the Hebrew scriptures for developing his theology of justice. His proclamation of a set “day” in particular is rooted in the yom Yahweh theme of the Prophets, wherein Yahweh acts decisively as universal judge and savior, dispensing his wrath and establishing justice. Secondly, Paul’s christology is clearly dependent upon Jesus’ self-understanding as the final judge of the world as recorded in the Gospels. Jesus proclaimed that as the Son of Man he would return in cataclysmic judgment, marking the eschatological fulfillment of God’s restoration of the earth (i.e., Mark 13:24-27). Paul recognizes an apparent synthesis of the Old Testament theme of Yahweh’s judgment upon the set “day” and Jesus’ early affirmations of his coming return in judgment. Ultimately, Jesus Christ is established as the executor of eschatological divine judgment confirmed by the definitive authority of God’s resurrection.
|
Something to Chew On: Reading the Meals in the Old Testament and its World
Program Unit:
Peter Altmann, University of Zürich
This paper will outline the recent developments and challenges for the interpretation of eating and drinking in OT/HB texts. Beyond merely identifying the important role of commensality and food and drink metaphors—an important development in and of itself—what are the promises and difficulties involved in understanding these texts and their language? The following issues will be addressed: 1) the role of the practicalities of human biology; 2) modern anthropological insights into the centrality of commensality for identity; 3) identifying faunal and other archaeological remains in relation to particular OT/HB texts; 4) the relationships between eating and drinking in the surrounding cultures of the ancient Near East and those of ancient Israel and the OT/HB. The paper will conclude by addressing broader methodological issues such as bridging the gap between social scientific studies and biblical texts.
|
What Do the “Levites in Your Gates” Have to Do with the “Levitical Priests”? Towards a European-North American Dialogue on the Levites in the Deuteronomic Law Corpus
Program Unit: Cultic Personnel in the Biblical World
Peter Altmann, University of Zurich
Wellhausen’s analysis of the divergent understandings of the priesthood found in the Levitical priests of Deuteronomy and in the differentiation between priests and Levites in P (also Ezekiel and Chronicles) continues to serve as the starting point for current treatments of the historical background of the Deuteronomic law corpus’ Levites. Beginning from a comparison of the entries concerning “Levites” in the most recent English (NIDB: 2007) and German (RGG, 4th ed., 2002) encyclopedias, this paper will discuss the contrasting streams of scholarship from the (broadly-speaking) European and North American approaches to composition-critical analyses of the Levites in Deuteronomy 12–26. One particular difference to be discussed is the tension between the "Levites in your gates" and the "Levitical priests" more closely tied to the central sanctuary: where do the methodological assumptions diverge, what can be seen as common ground, and where are potential avenues for future dialogue?
|
The Authority to End Taxes and Slavery: Romans 13:1–7 as Resistance Literature
Program Unit: African-American Biblical Hermeneutics
Richetta Amen, Graduate Theological Union
According to Leela Ghadi, “Texts, more than any other social and political product, it is argued, are the most significant instigators and purveyors of colonial power and its double, postcolonial resistance.”1 My belief is that the Bible contains both texts that promote colonial power as well as texts that contain hidden transcripts that function as texts of resistance. This paper examines Romans 13:1-7 claiming that it falls into the category of resistance literature and its primary purpose is to convey a political message to the oppressed. It is my assertion that Romans 13:1-7 operates as a public and a hidden transcript. Even though, on the surface, it appears that Paul is asking for obedience to the Roman imperial government, I do not believe that Paul is asking everyone to subject themselves to an unjust Roman government. In this regard, I agree with those scholars who believe that Paul was politically conscious and that his gospel opposed the Roman imperial order, not his own Jewish people.
Method. Abraham Smith, states, “Generally speaking, postcolonial analysis examines the historical and discursive ways in which the colonial or imperial powers seek to subdue other peoples, and the historical and discursive means available to subjected peoples to resist such domination.”2 Using a postcolonial analysis, my research will show how Paul drew discursively on the Israelite tradition of resistance in Romans 13:1-7 by not only appropriating scripture but also by appropriating the received tradition regarding Jesus Christ. Dividing the text into three parts, I will examine the concepts of "authority" in Romans 13.1-2, the "sword" in Romans 13:3-4 and "tribute taxes" in Romans 13:5-7. Additionally, by citing ancient Greek biblical and non-biblical texts, I aim to show that the "authority" that Paul is referring to is not the Roman political leaders but those who are zealously resisting the Roman Empire.
|
The Development of Unintentional Homicide and the Asylum Towns Law
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Aryeh Amihay, Princeton University
The law of unintentional homicide appears in three different places in the Pentateuch: Ex.21, Num. 35 and Deut. 19. Each one of these texts raises a set of problems: on a religious and theological level, there is a question as to the reasons that intention is a significant characteristic in cases of homicide. This is an issue relevant not only in a religious sense, but also for the philosophy of law. These two different aspects meet on several matters concerning intent, but the difference between them, especially in the context of the debate on the relation between law and morality is quite telling. Second, there is the question of discerning intent, and the relation between intent and action. This is both a philosophical problem and a pragmatic problem of jurisprudence. These issues will be addressed using philosophers of intent, such as Anscombe, Audi and Duff, as well as legal theorists, including the works on biblical law of Daube and Jackson. Other issues to be addressed, time permitting, include the sociological impact of an institution as asylum towns, the culpability for negligence, and the general problem of evil, raised especially in the wording of Ex. 21:13.
In addition to these philosophical and legal aspects, there is the historical problem of textual development. Following the work of Stackert on the composite nature of Num. 35, as well as the work by Levinson on legal revision in the Bible in general, I suggest that vv. 30-34 belong to the original layer of vv. 9-15, with the later interpolation of vv. 16-29. The concerns of these passages are also composite, including the jurisprudential concern of determining murder (30, 16-23) and the intricate relation between sin, purity, blood and morality (31-34, 20). This raises once more the debate on the conceptualization of purity in P and H (as seen in the works of Milgrom, Knohl and Schwartz) and its relation to ethics.
|
Kinship and the Land: Themes in the Prophetic Depiction of Edom
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Bradford A. Anderson, Durham University
Much has been made of the harsh words which the prophetic literature directs toward Edom, as well as whether or not these were warranted. This paper argues that there are recurring themes in these oracles which may offer clues as to why Israel’s prophets were so stinging in their critique of Edom. These include the motifs of kinship as well as Edom’s relationship to the land, both its own and that belonging to Israel. As such, Edom’s offenses are against both their kin Israel, as well as YHWH, who has apportioned the lands. Taken together these may help us make sense of Israel’s assessment of its neighbor. Moreover, when read in this way, the prophetic castigation of Edom has resonance with the prophetic critique of Israel, which also is punished for its inability to live up to covenantal obligations to both God and humanity.
|
Divine Appropriation: A Paradigm for Conceptualizing the Biblical Portrayal of the Collapse of the Pantheon into Yahweh
Program Unit: Unity and Diversity in Early Jewish Monotheisms
James Anderson, University of Sheffield
Two mutually exclusive paradigms account for the emergence of monotheism amongst biblical scholars today. An early-monotheistic Yahwism paradigm understands a pure form of monotheism originating with Moses that was later corrupted by contact with the Canaanites; a native-pantheon paradigm, an alternative view, holds a native Israelite-Judahite pantheon headed by Yahweh and Asherah collapsed into Yahweh. For the first paradigm, textual or artefactual evidence associated with Israel or Judah that does not cohere with this hypothetical ‘pure’ monotheism is classified as syncretistic or reflective of popular religion. For the latter model, evidence of polytheism is understood to reflect ‘official’ belief systems and practices during the monarchic period, that is, Iron Age II. Though there exists a multitude of treatments exhibiting nuanced and variegated accounts, including those that emphasize monolatry and henotheism, ultimately, each can belong to only one camp, even those that seemingly harmonize the two paradigms. Both camps share an understanding that a degree of appropriating activity on the part of Yahweh was a requisite development for the emergence of monotheism; naturally, the extent of Yahweh’s appropriating differs, and a significant disagreement exists as to whether the deities being amalgamated into Yahweh were foreign intrusions or native gods. Although recent years have witnessed several new publications pertaining to the subject of monotheism, precisely how biblical authors and editors went about displaying Yahweh’s appropriating has not been fully explicated. There often is a simple admission that Yahweh appropriated, accrued, took on or was endowed with traits, imagery, epithets, functions or motifs that belonged to other deities. The purpose of this paper is, thus, to examine how biblical authors and editors tangibly went about displaying appropriation, and this in turn presents a typology for classifying such instances that should be amenable to both camps. The model will be delineated using a few examples from the Hebrew Bible where Yahweh usurps the domains of Baal and Asherah. It will simultaneously be argued that a Persian period context provides the most likely setting for the employment of such texts that sought to address an ideological debate by advancing Yahweh’s takeover of the pantheon.
|
Replaying the Fool: Esau vs Jacob and YHWH in Gen 32–33
Program Unit: Pentateuch
John Anderson, Augustana College
The Jacob narratives in Genesis are among the most troubling theological texts in the Hebrew Bible for the way in which they portray characters actively engaging in deception, often of one’s own family. Esau arguably suffers most, losing not only the right of the firstborn (Gen 25:27-34) but also the paternal blessing (Gen 27:1-45) to Jacob’s clever and calculating ways. The response of Esau is clear: he plots to kill his scheming brother. Later in the narrative, however, in the reconciliation scene between the two brothers, Esau’s murderous anger is conspicuously absent and instead replaced with a seemingly affable, forgiving demeanor. Scholarship has traditionally noted that Jacob’s worry at the impending reunion is in vain and highlights all the more his problematic character, especially in light of the nocturnal wrestling match he has with God. It is this contest with the divine that traditional readings of the Jacob cycle will argue leads to a change for the better in Jacob’s character. Such a reading, however, cannot be sustained against a close scrutiny of the text.
This study is part of a larger project looking at the role and function of God in Jacob’s deceptions. Here specifically I will argue that Jacob by no means repents of his deceptive ways but rather continues with them, at the expense of his brother yet again. Jacob’s encounter with his besmirched brother will be read in parallel with 25:27-34. Esau again plays the fool, just as he did with the right of the firstborn, on a variety of levels: he accepts Jacob’s ambiguous offer of the “blessing” (33:11, cf. 32:29) and he ends up separated from his brother yet again by means of Jacob’s trickery (33:15-20). The main contribution of this study is the recognition that God is deeply connected with these deceptions (Gen 32:22-32), and a close literary reading of the text will offer new interpretive possibilities for understanding not only the Jacob and Esau dynamic but also the Jacob and God dynamic. I have dubbed this a theology of deception.
|
A Theology of Deception: Towards Understanding YHWH’s Use of Deception in the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Theology of the Hebrew Scriptures
John Anderson, Augustana College
Within the Hebrew Bible YHWH is portrayed as either using or availing himself of deception in nearly every part of the canon: the Pentateuch, the Deuteronomistic History, the Prophets. In these occurrences YHWH engages in deceptive activity for manifold reasons: to assist in ancient Israel’s escape from Egypt, to protect Israel in the wilderness from enemy nations, to punish a false prophet, to kill a wicked Israelite king, or as an accusation from a suffering prophet. While scholarly discussion on this topic remains inchoate, I have argued extensively elsewhere that this phenomenon of YHWH as Trickster is perhaps most strikingly manifest in the book of Genesis, specifically the Jacob cycle (Gen 25-35), as a means of advancing the ancestral promise (Gen 12:1-3; cf. 26:2-5; 28:13-15). Scholarship has yet to address this complex and manifold characterization of YHWH in the Hebrew Bible. I have dubbed this phenomenon a “theology of deception.”
This paper will attend to this issue by attempting to provide adequate theological voice to YHWH as Trickster in the Hebrew Bible. It will be proposed that despite the likely unpalatable nature of this image for contemporary readers, the portrait within the Hebrew Bible attests to a deity that employs deception in the interest of the covenant and the covenant people. Attention to this oft neglected characterization of YHWH through literary readings of the biblical text (akin to Alter and Sternberg) with theological aims (akin to Brueggemann) will be seen to provide a fuller picture of who God is in the Hebrew Bible, a picture lacking in the majority of the classic Old Testament theologies to date (Eichrodt, von Rad, Childs, etc.). I will also suggest some avenues for future study, moving toward the possibility of speaking of a canonical theology of deception.
|
The Dialogical Autonomy of the Fourth Gospel: A Theologically Engaged Jesus Tradition and Implications for Jesus Studies
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
Paul N. Anderson, George Fox University
For nearly two centuries and spanning the first three quests for Jesus, one judgment has remained largely constant among critical scholars: the quest for the Jesus of Nazareth ought to be conducted untainted by the Fourth Gospel’s potentially distortive influence. While reasons for excluding John from Jesus studies are understandable, they bear new sets of critical problems making such an operation finally unsatisfactory. Despite the Johannine tradition’s highly theological character, its mundane and distinctive features call for the questioning of its historical exclusion bolstered by the following bases. First, the dialogical autonomy of the Fourth Gospel invites its consideration as an alternative Jesus tradition with its own plausible contributions to perspectives on Jesus. Second, a Bi-Optic Hypothesis accounts for major similarities and differences between the Johannine and the Markan Gospels in ways that have literary and critical integrity posing a challenge to the programmatic rejection of the one tradition claiming direct access to the ministry of Jesus. Third, new criteria for determining historicity with John in the mix deserve consideration, potentially leading to a fourth quest for Jesus—one that welcomes all suitable resources for critical analysis, including the Fourth Gospel.
|
The Parable of the Great Banquet in Early Christian Writers
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Gavril Andreicut, Marquette University
This paper deals with the history of interpretation of Luke 14:16-23. This passage is especially interesting because Augustine used it to support the use of force against the Donatists. First, the paper shows how the passage was interpreted by the early Christian writers until Augustine. Second, since none of the writers before Augustine used the Parable of the Great Banquet to support compulsion, the paper shows Augustine's interpretation of the passage and the context in which he used it to support the use of force in conversion. Particularly, this paper shows that the Parable of the Great Banquet was interpreted by the early Christians writers depending on the circumstances in which they found themselves. As one might expect, the ante-Nicene writers found litlle use of the command "compel people to come in" in Luke 14:23 because before 311 Christians were the ones compelled to renounce their religion. Therefore, the references we find are rather to the Great Banquet generaly than to Luke 14:23. We find references to the Great Banquet in Clement of Alexandria, Tertullian, and Origen, but none of these writers interpreted the passage as a way of supporting the use of force. After Nicea, we find references to the Great Banquet in Gregory of Nazianzus, Ambrose of Milan, John Chrysostom, and Jerome. As before Nicea, none of these writers thought to see it as a support for the use of force against schismatics. This paper shows that the Parable of the Great Banquet was interpreted by the early Christian writers depending on the circumstance in which they found themselves and according to the interests they pursued.
|
St. Augustine: "Love and Do What You Will"
Program Unit: Ethics, Love, and the Other in Early Christianity
Gavril Andreicut, Marquette University
"Love and do what you will" is a famous saying of Augustine in "In epistulam Johannis" 7.8. Read in its context, it is Augustine's defense of the use of force in the service of love. This paper discusses a less pleasant and much-debated episode in Augustine's life: his support of the use of force to convert the Donatists to the Catholic Church. In trying to heal the schism in North Africa, Augustine believed that compulsion is a justified mean to achieve unity. To prove his arguments about he use of force as a way toward conversion and unity, Augustine appealed to the authority that the Church had obtained by the authority of Scripture. As Christ used violence to make Paul a believer and one of his best disciples, Augustine believed that the Church was following Christ in forcing the Donatists into the unity of the Church. This paper shows both Augustine's support of the use of force as well as the role and the function of love in his arguments for unity. According to Augustine, schismatics cannot love outside the Catholic Church. Bringing schismatic groups back into the Church through compulsion meant that their lost ability to love would be reestablished and that their acts of love and good deeds would finally work from the root of love, that is, the Church, the only place where the Holy Spirit works and true Christian love can take place. Thus, in the Catholic-Donatist controversy, Augustine believes that the end justifies the means. This paper shows how Augustine responded to a delicate situation in sensitive times and circumstances. However, Augustine's arguments that the end justifies the means could not be sepparated from the Catholic-Donatist controversy.
|
Reading through Trauma in Eikhah Rabbah
Program Unit: Midrash
William A. Andrews, Chicago Theological Seminary
One scholar of rabbinic literature refers to midrash as a “hermeneutic of recovery and recuperation.” That is, it places in a narrative context a rupture present in or implied by a biblical text—which corresponds to some historical crisis—and imaginatively draws out meaning from the verses in question and more generally restores the Bible in the life of the reader. This dynamic is not unlike the therapeutic process described in Sigmund Freud’s seminal writings on trauma and further elucidated by critical scholars appropriating his work in recent years. This correspondence is especially evident in Eikhah Rabbah.
The destruction of the Second Temple in 70 CE may be said to open up “gaps” in meaning that exceed the limits of memory and challenge foundational assumptions concerning the community’s relationships to God and the world. In response to this and subsequent traumas the authors/compilers of Eikhah Rabbah work through a verse-by-verse reading of Lamentations, a book which itself responds to the devastation of the First Temple (ca. 586 BCE). They employ diverse literary forms that bring the traumatic wound to consciousness and invite the reader/listener to re-experience the gaps in meaning and hopefully find resources for survival.
My discussion of this testimony focuses on passages that deal explicitly with the activity of reading scripture. From a position of displacement by historical trauma, these pericopes construe a sort of exegetical displacement in order to exploit the gaps of trauma as openings for new possibilities and recovery. Thus, the authors emphasize the centrality of Torah in the absence of the Temple cultus and commend reading as a response to the tragedy and ongoing trauma of the destruction of the Temples.
|
Divine Silence, Metaphor, and Mental Spaces in Selected Psalms of Lament
Program Unit: Cognitive Linguistics in Biblical Interpretation
William Andrews, Jr., Chicago Theological Seminary
Although several linguists working outside of biblical studies have demonstrated that silence is a significant element in human communication, the topic has been largely neglected in biblical studies. There exists only a handful of partial treatments of the silence motif in the Hebrew Bible and just one monograph attempting a comprehensive survey. While each of these investigations makes a contribution, none adequately considers silence as a divine metaphor and explores the cognitive world that gives rise to its use. Such an interpretive course would be especially fruitful for the study of lament psalms in which situations of suffering and distress are so determinative of the petitioner’s descriptions of the deity.
The present study demonstrates that the motif of divine silence in selected lament psalms provides useful insight into the cognitive world of the psalmist. After a brief description of the semantic field of silence in the Psalter, the verbal metaphorical expression al teherash (Pss 28:1; 35:22; 39:13; 83:2; 109:1)—which may be translated “do not keep silent”—is considered more closely within the frameworks of cognitive metaphor and mental space theory. In this way it becomes clear that this characterization of God is not only intricately related to the psalmist’s experience, but it also functions effectively as a speech act. By evoking a negative mental space in which God is silent, the petitioner simultaneously and necessarily calls to mind a positive space in which God speaks. It is this implied
|
The Archaeology of Bethsaida and the Gospel of John: Convergences and Divergences
Program Unit: John, Jesus, and History
Rami Arav, University of Nebraska at Omaha
Bethsaida, “the House of the Fishermen,” is the most frequently mentioned site in the Gospel narratives after Jerusalem and Capernaum. Archaeologically, it is unique because it is the only site that was visited by Jesus and is available to archaeological research. Unlike other Galilean sites such as Nazareth, Chorazim and Capernaum, Bethsaida was never disturbed by Byzantines masonry and its first century stratum is the first under the top soil. The excavation of Bethsaida since 1987 has yielded finds that may present areas of converges and diverges with the Gospel of John. This presentation aims to shed light on these areas and suggests a few implications to the study of John.
Convergences include:
(1) Some scholars suggest that John was familiar with the Dead Sea Scrolls. Bethsaida too has some common denominators to Qumran, one for example is the unique cemeteries.
(2) Another is the small finds. Recently, the scraped spout “Herodian” oil lamps were proved to be manufactured in Jerusalem. These oil lamps make the vast majority of the first century oil lamps of Bethsaida and other Jewish sites.
(3) Limestone vessels were also found in Bethsaida and testify that the site of Bethsaida, together with Capernaum and Nazareth were thoroughly Jewish and that Jesus visited Jewish settlements.
(4) The parable of the carpophores dying grain (John 12:24) may allude to familiarity with the Roman Imperial cult center of Livia/Julia in Bethsaida.
Divergences include:
The Gospel of John demonstrates acquaintance with the topography of Jerusalem; yet, he refers to Bethsaida as a Greek city, “polis,” and places it in Galilee. This information created a long debate over the identification of the site.
|
The Worship Scenes in the Apocalypse, Effective History, and Early Pentecostal Periodical Literature
Program Unit: Society for Pentecostal Studies
Melissa Archer, Bangor University (UK)
History of effect is a recent methodology being used as a means to discover the ways in which readers are influenced by biblical texts. This essay seeks to discover how the early Pentecostals were influenced in their worship by their reading of the Apocalypse. Early Pentecostal literature is filled with references to the worship practices and experiences of the early Pentecostal communities. The literature, which is largely testimonial in nature, indicates that the early Pentecostals were deeply influenced in their worship by the Apocalypse. This essay provides a survey of both Wesleyan-Pentecostal and Finished Work periodical literature from 1906-1916.
|
THe Age of Innocence: Biran's Excavations at Iron Age II Tel Dan
Program Unit:
Eran Arie, Tel Aviv University
This paper reexamines Biran's preliminary reports on his excavations at Iron Age II Tel Dan. Scholars generally agree that the site was continuously occupied throughout the whole of the Iron Age. From the days of Jeroboam I until Dan's destruction by the Assyrians and even later, the site is regularly referred to as a large city and as a cultic center.
Contrary to the conventional scholarly opinion and to Biran's view, this paper suggests that during the Iron IIa, Dan was either deserted or was a small rural site, and that Stratum IVA should be down-dated to the beginning of the Iron IIb (end of the 9th/beginning of the 8th centuries BCE). The paper posits that Stratum IVA was an Aramaean rather than an Israelite city, that it was constructed by Hazael, king of Aram-Damascus, and that Hazael’s stela at Dan was erected in celebration of the construction of this city rather than to commemorate its occupation. These conclusions have far reaching implications on the biblical materials which refer to Dan and for reconstructing the history of northern Israel and southern Syria in the Iron Age.
|
Resistance to the KJV
Program Unit:
Chris Armstrong, Bethel Seminary
*
|
The Marriage of Isaac and Rebekah: Reflections on Ritual and Gender
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Russell C. D. Arnold, DePauw University
Isaac and Rebekah provide a unique example of a biblical marriage, in stark contrast to the marriages of the generation before and the generation after them. This paper investigates the portrayal of their marriage from two overlapping perspectives: gender roles and ritual. As such, we will focus our attention on the representations and interplay of gender roles in the context of the primary rituals that frame their life together: betrothal and marriage (Gen 24) and the blessing of their children (Gen 27). We will move from discussion of the rituals as described in the biblical text to some of the ways interpretations of these chapters have informed the history of the ritual practices of marriage and blessing among Jews and Christians.
|
Paul, Hybris, and the Super Apostles
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
Jeffrey Asher, Georgetown College
The identity of Paul’s opponents in 2 Corinthians has been a fundamental interpretive paradigm in Pauline studies. Building on a suggestion of Margaret Mitchell that the so-called super apostles may have been a rhetorical construct of a specific Corinthian, this paper will explore the role of honor and shame in understanding the apostolic alternatives to Paul. Specifically, this paper will argue that the Corinthians may have perceived Paul’s shaming language in 2 Corinthians 8 as an inappropriate affront to their honor and, as a result and as dictated by the requirements of honor, sought revenge by similarly shaming Paul. As a result, Paul is forced to address an affront to his own honor when compared to the super apostles in 2 Corinthians 10-13. This is not to suggest that the super apostles did not exist. Rather, it suggests that they existed collectively only as a rhetorical alternative to Paul and as an appropriate reciprocal response to the injury and insult that they believed they experienced when Paul attempted to shame them. Perhaps, the Corinthians misunderstood Paul’s behavior to be a case of hybris, especially if they believed that he was trying to inflict shame through public humiliation.
|
Kenyan Christian Compassion: Caring for Victims of HIV/AIDS
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Don Ashley, Wayland Baptist University
This qualitative research project explores the lived experience and worldview of people involved in the ministry of a local protestant church located in a slum in Kenya's Central Provence. The project's goal is to more deeply understand how scripture influenced the origin of this ministry and its role in continuing to motivate caregivers and people living with HIV/AIDS (PLHA). Data was gathered through semi-structured interviews of three caregivers, six PLHA participants and a focus group of ten PLHA participants in January 2010. The research evaluates the textual and contextual impacts biblical passages make on this culture via study participants perspective on language and cultural context as a part of overall human experience; reviews the essential questions raised by this study in order to deepen the understanding of place in time and culture.
|
Teaching Exegesis in Historically Black Theological Schools
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
James Ashmore, Shaw University
This paper reflects on the findings of the Wabash Grant awarded to Shaw University on Teaching Exegesis in Historically Black Theological Schools (HBTS). After the initial presentation by the principle recepients, the follwing response and discussion will involve some of the particiants of the three conferences held between 2007 and 2010.
|
Greek Manuscripts from Coptic Egypt
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Christian Askeland, University of Cambridge
Coptic Christians copied and used many of the Greek manuscripts which are now cited in modern critical editions of the Greek New Testament. Additionally, perhaps, as many as ten percent of all extant uncials and papyri are Greek-Coptic diglots. This paper will examine the influence of the Coptic Christians in the transmission of the Greek text of the New Testament. The peculiarities of these Coptic influences inform not only the dating of these Greek manuscripts, but also the origins of their Greek variants.
|
The Infinity of Love in the Song of Songs
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Elie Assis, Bar Ilan University
There is much debate in modern scholarship regarding the question of unity in the Song of Songs: Is the Song of Songs one coherent work or is it an anthology of various love poems. I will address this question by a close reading of the 2 poems that are considered by many as dream love poems: 3:1-5, and 5:2-8. A close analysis will show that the two poems display literary affinity, but also as significant differences. It will be claimed that the poems were meant to stand as a pair and only an understanding of the development within the poems can explain the similarities as well as differences between them. The main ideas of progression within the book will be demonstrated.
|
Can We Solve the Riddle of the Hebrew Verb?
Program Unit:
George Athas, Moore Theological College
Can We Solve the Riddle of the Hebrew Verb?
|
A Quest for Certainty: The Epistemological Basis for Asphaleia in Luke-Acts
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
J.D. Atkins, Marquette University
In the preface to his gospel, Luke promises asphaleia to his readers (1.4). Much scholarly effort has been aimed at answering the ‘what’ question: “What is Luke providing certainty about?” Comparatively little attention has been given to the ‘how’ question: “How does Luke attempt to establish the promised asphaleia for his readers?” This paper represents a fresh attempt to answer the latter question in the light of a variety of verbal parallels both within and outside of the Lukan writings. This study will explore the potential roles played by four suggested epistemological bases for asphaleia in Luke-Acts: the written medium, the arrangement of the material, the fulfillment of prophecy, and the testimony of (eye)witnesses. After evaluating each of these possibilities in light of extra-Lukan usage of asphaleia and its close cognates in antiquity, this paper will assess the significance of such usage for the interpretation of Luke’s preface in light of Luke’s use of asphalõs and asphales in Acts 2.36, 21.34, 22.30, and 25.26. The study will conclude that the primary means by which Luke intends to supply asphaleia to the reader is through a concerted, two-fold appeal to the fulfillment of prophecy and to the testimony of (eye)witnesses, whereas the written medium and the arrangement of the material only contribute to asphaleia in an ancillary way. Furthermore, Luke’s means may provide a clue to his ends. Given that little consensus has been reached on ‘what’ Luke-Acts is providing certainty about, further study on Luke’s use of fulfilled prophecy and eye-witness testimony may help to highlight the key issues for which Luke felt a more robust defense was required.
|
Understanding Josephus’ Narrative Structure of the Hasmonean Period: The Puzzling Episode of John Hyrcanus’ Participation in the Parthian Campaign of Antiochus Sidetes
Program Unit: Josephus
Kenneth Atkinson, University of Northern Iowa
Understanding Josephus’ narrative structure is critical for using his accounts of the Hasmonean Period. Rather than recording events chronologically, Josephus often groups episodes thematically. He is a creative author who skillfully uses rhetoric to fashion portraits of the Hasmonean rulers. His historical writings are as much original literary compositions as they are historical narratives. Josephus’ War and Antiquities may be viewed as “Tragic History,” which is a genre that allows the writer to incorporate his own voice into the narrative. This is particularly true of Josephus’ portrayals of the Hasmonean period, and most notably his accounts of John Hyrcanus’s relationship with Antiochus Sidetes.
This presentation will examine Josephus’ narrative structure of John Hyrcanus’ reign by focusing on Antiochus Sidetes’ Parthian expedition. It suggests that Josephus models John Hyrcanus after himself in his War to portray this ruler as a great warrior, priest, and prophet. He merely alludes to the Parthian campaign since it could have potentially caused his readers to question the loyalty of the Jews to Rome. When he wrote his Antiquities, however, the question of the relationship between the Jews and the Parthians was causing many to doubt the loyalty of Jews to the Flavians, particularly Josephus. Josephus reshapes his narrative of John Hyrcanus’ reign in this book to deal with these rumors, and to show that he was loyal to his new homeland. Through comparisons of Josephus’ accounts with works such as Josippon, Diodorus, and the Epitome of Pompeius Trogus, this presentation will not only offer a historically accurate reconstruction of John Hyrcanus’ relationship with Antiochus Sidetes and the Parthians, but also show how, and why, Josephus has altered the narrative structure of his sources. It suggests that Josephus’ activities during the Judean War shape his narrative structure of the Hasmonean period.
|
"Woe to Those Who Write the Book with Their Own Hands” (Al-Baqara, 2:79): Biblical Textual Criticism as an Aide to Dialogue between Muslims and the “People of the Book”
Program Unit: Qur'an and Biblical Literature
Kenneth Atkinson, University of Northern Iowa
The Qur’anic claim that the “People of the Book” have corrupted their Scriptures surprises, and even offends, many Jews and Christians. By exploring the means by which Jews and Christians have preserved their sacred texts, I hope to support both this Qur’anic assertion and show how it can foster interreligious dialogue. Once Jews and Christians recognize the problematic textual base of their Scriptures, they cannot criticize the Qur’an as a later inferior revelation that merely copies from their texts. The academic study of the transmission of these writings, moreover, can aide interrreligious dialogue by highlighting those elements common to the Abrahamic faiths. This presentation includes insights from the author’s recent work as a translator for the New English Translation of the Septuagint and his involvement in the Iowa Dialog Center, which is a Muslim-founded group dedicated to fostering interreligious dialogue based on the teachings of Fetullah Gülen.
The first portion of this presentation introduces the textual history of the Bible used by Jews and Christians. It highlights the difference between Scripture and Canon, and shows that the Jewish and Christian Bible is a fairly recent creation that postdates the final compilation of the Qur’an. The second section discusses how the textual history of the Jewish and Christian Bible supports the Qur’anic claim that Jews and Christians have corrupted their Scriptures. The conclusion suggests that Jews and Christians, because they cannot claim to possess an uncorrupted Scriptural text, should be more open to Islam’s teachings, and not criticize the Qur’an as a later inferior revelation that merely copies from their Scriptures. The result is the opening up of a dialogue that focuses on those elements common to all three Abrahamic faiths, namely compassion and prophets. The presentation concludes with suggestions as to how an academic study of the sacred Scriptures of Judaism, Christianity, and Islam can facilitate interfaith exchanges.
|
Editing the Gospel of John: An Exegete's View
Program Unit: Novum Testamentum Graecum: Editio Critica Maior
Harold Attridge, Yale University
This paper will discuss the significance of the new critical edition of John for exegetical scholarship.
|
Social Status in Luke’s Infancy Narrative: Zechariah as 'hiereus tis'
Program Unit: Social Scientific Criticism of the New Testament
Esa Autero, University of Helsinki
This paper investigates the social status of Zechariah in Luke’s gospel using Lenski’s social stratification model. While many scholars have vaguely placed Zechariah within a social stratification scale, this paper aims to give a more accurate analysis of Zechariah within the highly stratified Early Roman Empire and Palestinian temple state. Beyond this macro-sociological setting, we will conduct a multidimensional analysis of Zechariah’s social status. Zechariah’s place in the Judean priestly hierarchy is investigated using Lucan narrative presentation and Josephus’ testimonies about social conflicts between various priestly groups within the first century Judea. The narrative clue about “priestly order of Abijah” has been ignored by most scholars but it will be argued that this is an important detail regarding the placement of Zechariah in the social stratification system. Thus, it is posited that Zechariah does not come from an upper stratum priestly class and that placing him in the retainer class is also doubtful. Rather, Zechariah is depicted in Luke’s narrative as a humble, lowly priest with no wealth to speak of, who nevertheless maintained rather high social status due to his priestly pedigree.
|
What's Not So Secular about Introductions to the Hebrew Bible?
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
Hector Avalos, Iowa State University
Despite the claim that historical-critical methods are being employed in introductory textbooks to the Hebrew Bible, we still find many theological and apologetic features in most such textbooks. These range from suggesting the superior ethics of monotheism, to the mitigation of slavery in the Bible. The paper will explore some of the main theological and apologetic features of these introductory textbooks, and it will discuss the ecclesial-academic complex that still plays a significant role in publishing and marketing.
|
Pidray, Tallay, ’Arsay, and the Window in Baal’s Palace
Program Unit: Ugaritic Studies and Northwest Semitic Epigraphy
Richard E. Averbeck, Trinity Evangelical Divinity School
One of the most important, intriguing, and difficult features of the palace building account in the Ugaritic Baal myth is the concern over having a window in the palace (KTU 1.4 vi 1-15; vii 14-37), and the relationship this has to Baal’s daughters: Pidray, Daughter of Light, Tallay, Daughter of Showers, and ’Arsay, Daughter of the Wide World
(KTU 1.3 i 22-27; iii 6-8; iv 49-51; and esp. the apparent threat to the daughters in KTU 1.4 vi 10-11). The names of these daughters of Baal and the regular sequence of their appearing is reminiscent of the pattern in Psalm 104 and Genesis 1: first, light (Psalm 104:1b-2a; Genesis 1:3-5,
day one), second, the sky with its clouds, winds, and lightning (Psalm 104:2b-4; Genesis 1:6-8, day two), third, dry land (’eres//’Arsay; Psalm 104:5-9; Genesis 1:9-10). This correspondence suggests a certain pattern of what the ancients considered to be the primary foundation of
the ecological system basic to all other natural functions necessary for human fertility and prosperity, including Baal’s rains. Thus, Baal’s concern about having a window in his palace relates to the maintenance and stability of that basic underlying ecological system. In the end, the inclusion of the window and its opening, although necessary for Baal to function, also opens up threats to Baal and the entire ecological system.
|
The Performative Nature of Naming in the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Cognitive Linguistics in Biblical Interpretation
Yael Avrahami, University of Haifa
The expression “to call X in the name Y” appears dozens of times in the Hebrew Bible and refers to people, places, artifacts and nations. It is used when giving a name for the first time (i.e. to newborns, a new cultic site and so on) but also when changing a name for a place or a person. This expression is a typical performative as the description of the speech act (to call out a name) counts as the actual naming. Furthermore, the person/group uttering the expression holds social authority which authenticate the naming, very much like institutional authority needed for other performatives. It is also possible, that naming functions as a performative in a more complex way, and causes not only the existence of a name, but also an inherent quality given to the person/object named, similarly to a blessing. This second outcome of naming is achieved through non-linguistic metaphors (laying a baby on the knees), and through linguistic metaphors (the meaning of names, in this case, the name can be understood as another mental space (=representing) in addition to the act speech of naming).
In this paper, I would like to analyze different types of naming, using the cognitive linguistic terms of mental space and blending. Each “type” of naming will be represented graphically and discussed. I will than ask few questions: What inputs can we find for each type of naming? Is there a relationship between different types of naming, e.g. does renaming use newborn naming as one of its inputs? In what cases naming has multiple outcomes (=blends)? How does the nature of the named (person, object, place, nation) influence the input and the blend? Lastly, I will suggest that the model taken from cognitive linguistics and applied to naming in the Hebrew Bible demonstrates once again, how performativity in the Hebrew Bible “works” due to common cognitive structures rather than “primitive thinking”.
|
Women at Elephantine and Women in the Land
Program Unit: Literature and History of the Persian Period
Annalisa Azzoni, Vanderbilt University
The paper will offer some reflections on the relevance of the Elephantine documents for illuminating the socio-economic standing and legal rights of women in Persian Judah. While the virtual absence of contemporary extra-Biblical sources from Judah justifies the attempts, in recent literature, to use the Elephantine data to fill the gaps, this paper will discuss methodological issues raised by this approach. By focusing on the legal texts, and in particular on the matter of inheritance, the paper will review the nature of the data and the contexts of Persian Egypt and Judah respectively.
|
Aramaic at Persepolis
Program Unit: Paleographical Studies in the Ancient Near East
Annalisa Azzoni, Vanderbilt University
The Persepolis Fortification Archive counts at present almost 700 Aramaic tablets, or dockets, and about 200 Aramaic glosses on Elamite tablets. This paper will offer an updated overview of the Persepolis Fortification Aramaic Tablets and the Aramaic epigraphs on Elamite Tablets discussing several issues, primarily focusing on the following: the place and function of Aramaic epigraphs in a mostly Elamite archive; the typology of the Aramaic tablets in comparison to that of
the Elamite tablets; the language of the Aramaic tablets in comparison
with other Imperial Aramaic archives.
|
Back to the Sources: The Revitalization of the Documentary Hypothesis
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Joel S. Baden, Yale University
Although the last thirty years have seen a significant move away from the classical source-critical model for the composition of the Pentateuch, recent American and Israeli scholarship has seen a renewed interest in the Documentary Hypothesis. This paper will address the problems that developed in the application of the Documentary Hypothesis in the early to mid-twentieth century, as well as the recent trends in non-documentary scholarship. It will then discuss what has come to be termed the Neo-Documentary Hypothesis, the classical theory revised and rehabilitated in current scholarship.
|
The Priestly Etiology of Skin Disease
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Joel Baden, Yale University
Skin disease in the Hebrew Bible (s?ara‘at) is commonly understood to be a divine punishment for sin. While this understanding is supported by most descriptions of skin disease in biblical narratives, the priestly laws in Leviticus 13–14 present a different picture. When read on their own terms, the priestly laws do not attribute skin disease to sin, but rather to natural processes. Despite the evidence of varying conceptions of the origin of skin disease in the Bible, interpreters employing a variety of hermeneutical approaches read sin into the priestly text. In this paper we will closely examine the priestly laws and the way they have been read (or mis-read) by pre-critical interpreters, historical critics, and scholars of disability studies.
|
Putting Jesus in His Geographical Place or What does Capernaum Have to Do with Jesus of Nazareth?
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
Rene Baergen, Emmanuel College, University of Toronto
In a discourse notorious for disagreement, the extent to which scholars agree on placing the historical Jesus in and around Capernaum is remarkable: it is his centre (EP Sanders), hub (J Reed), and headquarters (R Horsley), emblematic of his kingdom (JD Crossan) and constitutive of his career (S Freyne). Nonetheless, reconstructions of Jesus routinely privilege other sorts of place (especially social, cultural and religious) at the expense of local geography. In other words, the announcement that Capernaum and environs matters to the quest has yet to be translated methodologically in such a way as to occasion a reading strategy correspondingly sensitive to geographical place. My paper is an attempt to address this lacuna. By analogy with G Theissen’s criterion of historical plausibility and especially in light of the close association of place and memory articulated by such theorists as M Halbwachs and E Casey, I propose something of a geographical criterion- in short, that we make historically significant that memory of Jesus which is fastened resolutely on an experience of local geography of the sort which the quest has found otherwise significant. In the end, I hope to make clear the effect of such a criterion by re-sorting the usual suspects (Q, Thomas, Mark and John) accordingly.
|
'In Whom' Did Sin Exist? Origen Reads Romans 5:12–14
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Stephen Bagby, Durham University
Jaroslav Pelikan once stated, “Although Tertullian seemed to have the makings of a doctrine of original sin, he did not have its necessary corollary, the practice of infant baptism; while Origen, on the other hand, affirmed the apostolic origin of infant baptism, he did not formulate an anthropology adequate to account for it.” This paper sets out to challenge this assumption in light of Origen’s reading of what would become the locus classicus of the subsequent nature/grace debates: Romans 5:12-14.
Citing and building upon C. P. Bammel’s work, this paper will demonstrate that Origen had a more robust anthropology than previously considered. Origen understands Romans 5:12-14 within the economy of salvation whereby Paul, through the careful crafting of his rhetoric, understands Adam is the progenitor of sin, leading to its universality and dominion. But he also understands the universality of sin due to the individual choices through the freedom of the will. These sins are known through natural law and exercise dominion until stemmed incrementally by Moses, the prophets, and finally and fully, through Adam’s contrary, viz., Christ. The universality of Adam’s sin is found both by way of his progeny and through instruction. The universality of Christ’s restoration is tempered by Origen in favor of a disciplined outworking of salvation by the individual without recourse to God’s necessary favor.
Origen in fact had a more vigorous anthropology to account for infant baptism than previously considered. While his language concerning inherited guilt is underdeveloped, it nevertheless accounts for a significant development in early Christian anthropology. The Augustinian/Pelagian debates of the early fifth century only serve to highlight this discussion, as both sides incorporated Origen’s exegesis of Romans in their respective arguments.
|
A Construction Grammar Analysis of IDOU and IDE ‘Behold’
Program Unit: Biblical Greek Language and Linguistics
Nicholas Bailey, SIL International
Exegetes and lexicographers are often at a loss with what to do with the particles IDOU and IDE, and the translation of these particles is often stilted or unidiomatic (e.g. behold). In this talk, an integrated analysis of these particles is presented that assumes (at least) five different uses (i.e. ‘grammatical constructions’ in terms of Construction Grammar, a current linguistic theory developed by Fillmore, Kay, Lakoff, Goldberg, Lambrecht). Although each of the five uses are cognitively related to each other, they nevertheless differ significantly in function and syntax such that no one use can be entirely predicted from the others. The differences in the five uses is reflected in their functional differences in information structure and deixis. This analysis serves as a major refinement of the entries of these particles in the standard lexicons (e.g. BDAG).
|
Jesus, Paul, and Piaget: Teaching and Learning in Biblical Studies
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Coleman A. Baker, Brite Divinity School
In this paper, I explore the implications of Jean Piaget's contribution to "student-centered" education and discuss its implications for teaching biblical studies in both university and seminary settings. I will attempt to draw some practical conclusions that may provide examples of how biblical studies faculty can incorporate Piaget's perspectives in the classroom.
|
Still Life: Negotiating the Boundaries of the Human in the Rabbinic Law of Corpse Impurity
Program Unit: Religious World of Late Antiquity
Mira Balberg, Stanford University
The biblical notion of corpse-impurity, i.e., the idea that the dead body is highly polluting, presented the rabbis of the Mishnah with the task of defining what a dead body actually is. More specifically, since the paradigmatic rabbinic corpse is “a body in ruins” which is in a constant process of disintegration, decay, and coalescence into its human and non-human environment, in discussing corpse-impurity the rabbis were confronted with the question at what point the corpse can no longer be seen as human, and can be regarded as mere organic matter and thus as devoid of impurity.
A careful reading of the second chapter of Mishna Oholot reveals the rabbinic struggle to invest the corpse – and thereby, the materiality of the human body in its most bare manifestation – with humanness and meaning. In this paper, I try to decipher the principles that underlie the mishnaic text and to analyze the intricate negotiations between limits and limitlessness, unity and fragmentariness, separateness and infusion that constitute the rabbinic discourse of corpse-impurity. My argument is that for the rabbis, the way of dealing with the fragmentariness and fluidity of the corpse is by devising a system in which bodily elements are considered ‘impure’ only inasmuch as they can function as signs or symbols of a presumed corporeal humanness. In contrast, body-parts that cannot be ‘translated’ into an abstract image of a human body are considered ritually pure, i.e., they are not seen as ‘a corpse’ any more. The most fundamental principle in this system is the corpse’s ability to signify life. Paradoxically, I argue, for the rabbis the ultimate corpse is the living body.
|
Women Prophets/Maenads Visually Represented in Two Roman Colonies: Pompeii and Corinth
Program Unit: Art and Religions of Antiquity
David Balch, Pacific Lutheran Theological Seminary
Corinthian Christian women prophets experienced ?enthusiastic? speech, as did Dionysian female maenads. This paper examines Roman domestic art as a means of inquiring into similar phenomena among Dionysian and early Christian women. Frescoes on Pompeian domestic walls visually represent maenads killing king Penthus of Thebes as well as Dirce, queen of Thebes and a maenad, being killed. H. G. Beyen, an art historian, describes these two frescoes as amphitheater art. Since both Pompeii and Corinth were Roman colonies founded in the first century BCE and both had amphitheaters, I argue that such Dionysian amphitheater art would have been painted on the domestic walls of Corinthian domus. This leads to an investigation of the myths, rituals, and visual representations of the cult of the Roman Dionysus compared and contrasted with the myths, rituals, and verbal representations of Pauline Corinthian Christians.
|
Character Ethics in the Book of Job
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Samuel E. Balentine, Union Presbyterian Seminary
This paper will consider how ethical character is being formed in the book of Job.
|
The Testimony of the Prophet Jeremiah in Relation to 2 Kings 24–25 and 2 Chron 36
Program Unit: Exile (Forced Migrations) in Biblical Literature
Klaus Baltzer, University of Munich
Special for the political structure of Ancient Israel is the fact of a threefold top:
King - Priest - Prophet. Their funktions are different, but they overlap in some aereas.
This implies tension and conflict. All of them have a different base in the populace. All
of them have a scribe. Their texts are preserved in the Hebrew Bible.
The starting point for my contribution is the text of the book of Jeremiah ( see spec.
Jer. 36; 51-52 ).It is a witness to the catastrophe of prophecy, of the experience of forced migration and the experience of
salvation and hope.
|
The History of Reciprocal Constructions in Hebrew
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Elitzur Bar-Asher Siegal, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
The study of reciprocal constructions received much attention over the last decade, especially in the recent publication of the five volumes of the seminal typological study by Nedjalkov in 2007. Despite this abundance of information, not many studies have focused on the diachronic aspects of this topic. The hesitation to deal with this issue from a historical point of view is explicable in light of two facts: 1) We rarely have a good synchronic description of reciprocal constructions for a given period of a language, making the consequent historical discussion practically impossible (in fact at the moment there are only very few studies dedicated to an examination of this issue in Semitic languages); 2) The study of reciprocal constructions involves the intersection between morphology and syntax, an area rarely touched by classical historical linguistics, and consequently the usual methodological tools are not as useful for this endeavor.
In my paper I examine the various constructions evident for the expression of reciprocity in all periods of Hebrew (Biblical, Mishnaic and Modern) and analyze the changes that occur over time. On the one hand, I will demonstrate how a single construction may occur with different elements in different periods (such as changes in the reciprocal pronouns) and yet function in a similar way. And, on the other hand, I will show how similar forms (such as the t-stem) may have different semantics in different periods. I will also describe the developments from one period to another, both at the syntactic and the semantic level, while discussing how such diachronic processes should be portrayed and analyzed, methodologically speaking.
|
Subordinating Conjunctions in Biblical Hebrew
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Elitzur Bar-Asher Siegal, Hebrew University of Jerusalem/ Yale University
The subordinating conjunction ’ašer in Biblical Hebrew, as is the case in other Semitic languages, is also used in adnominal possessive constructions, as the following examples demonstrate:
(1) ’iš ’ašer yomar
“a man who will say”
(2) ’iš ’ašer la-melek
“The king’s man”
Every linguistic theory that takes (1) and (2) as if they stand in a paradigmatic relation needs to treat one of these constructions as the basic one. Since (2) does not seem to contain a dependent clause, there is a long tradition of taking (2) as the basic structure (Ungnad 1903-1905, reintroduced by Goldenberg 1995, and more recently by Cohen 2008 and Pat-El & Treiger 2008). Since it seems unnatural to refer to ’ašer in (2) as a conjunction, it is therefore analyzed as a determinative pronoun ((this theory also relies on some accounts such as Huehnergard 2006 as to the diachronic origin of this so-called pronouns). Besides the ambiguity as for the function of such a pronoun, in my paper I will argue that this approach suffers from many internal problems, including the fact that this analysis cannot account for the use of ’ašer at the beginning of non-adjectival dependent clauses. Thus, considering (2) as the basic construction, appears implausible.
Consequently this paper proposes to pursue another direction, taking (1) as the basic construction, and to analyze the adnominal possessive construction (2) as a dependent clause (compare with Stassen forthcoming). Accordingly, this should be taken as a dependent clause expressing predicative possessive construction.
Thus, I will argue that the structure of (2) is (3):
(3) ’iš ’ašer la-melek (null) (null)
man *that to-the-king man EXIST
This analysis relies on a typological treatment of Predicative-Possessive-Constructions (Stassen 2001) and it is also significantly instrumental for our understanding of similar constructions (with some differences) in other Semitic languages.
|
Interpreting History with Verbal Precision: Examples of Problems with Understanding the Time and Mood of Verbs in Ancient West Semitic Sources
Program Unit: Ugaritic Studies and Northwest Semitic Epigraphy
Krzysztof J. Baranowski, University of Toronto
The correct understanding of verbs is indispensable for historians as they rely heavily on written sources. In dealing with texts in ancient West Semitic languages we struggle with the peculiarities of their verbal systems. However, in spite of the imperfections of our linguistic theories and grammars, we assume that we are able to translate verbs correctly and even render their nuances properly. Our feeling of security stems from the fact that the flow of a narrative and the general context of texts usually allow a reasonable interpretation of verbal forms. The goal of this paper is to challenge our self-confidence and remind us that we must always remain open-mined.
The discussion will cover three case studies in which the proper understanding of the verb is difficult: the Old Aramaic Tel Dan inscription, Amarna letter no. 161 and the Phoenician Karatepe inscription. It will be argued that common interpretations of these texts are based not only on the grammar but they are also influenced by other factors. Certain interpretations are favored because of their historical implications. In other cases we are faced with objective difficulties because of the poor or fragmentary state of preservation of an inscription and because of the imperfect knowledge of the context which hinder the reconstruction of a coherent narrative. These observations indicate the need for a re-examination of the methodological principles of reconstructing the verbal systems of Ancient West Semitic languages.
|
Weblogs and the Academy: The Benefits and Challenges of Biblioblogging
Program Unit: Blogger and Online Publication
Michael Barber, John Paul the Great Catholic University
A growing number of scholars have entered the world of academic blogging. Indeed, the influence of “biblioblogs” in the scholarly community is becoming increasingly evident in a number of ways. Alongside the names of the institutions where they teach and the titles of their previous books, academic publishers are now including the internet addresses of scholars’ weblogs on the book covers of their recent monographs, somewhat blurring the lines between print publications and on-line offerings. Moreover, a careful analysis of the blogosphere reveals ways in which scholars are “testing out” hypotheses prior to publishing them in academic journals. The on-line academic blogging community has thus become an important sounding board for scholars, at times playing an important role in influencing material later published in peer-review sources. Other benefits may also be recognized, e.g., humanizing scholars, drawing attention to important works published in obscure places, etc. At the same time, there are certainly pitfalls involved with engaging the blogosphere. Above all, blogs are not “peer-reviewed” sources. Identifying helpful sources from unhelpful ones is sometimes a difficult challenge. Moreover, while information produced by bloggers may be retrieved through search engines, finding the most helpful material often requires sifting through a great amount of material, taxing the patience of researchers. This paper will analyze the academic value of blogs, discussing ways to maximize the benefits of such websites while also offering suggestions regarding how to deal with the challenges inherent in consulting them as academic resources. In particular, the presenter will draw from his recent experience of completing a Ph.D. dissertation on the historical Jesus and the way his participation in the academic blogging community enhanced his work.
|
Respondent
Program Unit: Philo of Alexandria
John Barclay, Durham University
Response to papers on 'Philo and the Roman World'
|
The Retelling of Chronicles in Jewish Tradition and Literature
Program Unit: Midrash
Pamela Barmash, Washington University
This paper will present a critical review and discussion of "The Retelling of Chronicles in Jewish Tradition and Literature," by Isaac Kalimi.
|
Midrash Halakhah: Between the Bible and Mesopotamia
Program Unit: Midrash
Pamela Barmash, Washington University
The analysis of Mesopotamian influence on midrash halakhah is warranted by two pieces of evidence: 1) parallels between midrash halakhah and Mesopotamian law which do not appear in the Bible; and 2) the parallel use of particular interpretive methods in both midrash halakhah and Mesopotamian texts.
|
How Much Did Later Christians Know about the Apostles and Evangelists?
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
Timothy D. Barnes, University of Edinburgh
This paper explores the probable consequences of three propositions which I believe that I have proved in the first chapter of my recent book Early Christian Hagiography and Roman History (Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2010). They are:-
(1) The apostle Peter was burned alive, though in a symbolic posture of crucifixion, as part of Nero’s programme of public entertainments after the great fire of Rome in 64;
(2) The apostle Paul was released from custody and went to Spain, where he was executed by a Roman provincial governor;
(3) The book of Revelation is datable with complete certainty to the later months of 68 or the beginning of 69, and there is no compelling reason to deny that the same John later wrote the fourth gospel. From (1) it follows that the burnt corpse of Peter was probably thrown into the River Tiber; from (2) it follows that the story that Paul was martyred in Rome is an invention of the middle or later decades of the second century; and from (3) it follows that Irenaeus lacked any genuine information about John the evangelist except what he could deduce from the text and the attribution of the fourth gospel and Revelation. I shall conclude by asking what difference this makes to the central enterprises of New Testament scholarship.
|
Did Matthew Misunderstand Mark? The Shema in the First Gospel
Program Unit: Intertextuality in the New Testament
Lori Baron, Duke University
Matt 22:34-40 reports Matthew's version of Mark 12:28-31 (cf. Luke 10:25-28), in which Jesus cites part of the Shema (traditionally Deut 6:4-9 plus other scripture passages), an ancient prayer central to the Jewish liturgy and to the confession of monotheism. This paper will argue that Matthew's redaction of the Markan pericope, and the way the evangelist "alters" the OT citation itself, misses the christological implications of the Markan Shema.
|
Hosea 2 and the Five Levels of Metaphor
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Rob Barrett, Georg-August-Universitaet Goettingen
The powerful marital metaphors of Hosea 2 have captivated both other biblical authors and centuries of interpreters. Recent Hosea scholarship has begun to recognize the metaphorical distance between the adulterous wife’s offenses and Israel’s sins, thereby opening up a space where the prophetic accusation against Israel need not be identified with a sexualized fertility cult. Hosea can, therefore, be understood to be decrying not a Baal cult, but social injustice (e.g., Yee) or political alliances (e.g., Kelle). I extend this approach by teasing apart the five levels of metaphor or indirection associated with this chapter: (1) the wife’s sexual misdeeds; (2) Israel’s 8th century “prostitutions” and “adulteries” along with (3) the particular acts so presented; (4) the recontextualization of the prophetic message within the Persian period where the story has already been played out; and (5) the application of this scriptural text to later, even modern, situations as demanded by the book's postscript. The complexity of this series of metaphorical moves highlights the importance of exploring the structural features of the metaphors within the text, rather than seeking to ascertain its “original” meaning alone. To that end, I explore the particular concepts and behaviors attacked in the text by means of metaphor: for what exactly is Israel faulted? The accusations center on the recognition of material provider, seeking after provision, and the movement between providers. The persistent nature of these activities, while making the metaphors’ original historical message difficult to discover, illuminates the way the metaphors can transcend a single setting in order to function in new ways.
|
What Does it Mean to Follow Other Gods?
Program Unit: Unity and Diversity in Early Jewish Monotheisms
Robert Barrett, Georg-August Universitaet-Goettingen
The exclusivity demand for followers of YHWH and the associated overwhelming punishments for disloyalty emphasize the extreme importance of understanding what is meant by following other gods. Unfortunately, such apostasy is often described within the biblical literature in only the most general terms: having, following, turning to, clinging to, or worshiping these other gods. In this paper, I survey the book of Jeremiah and describe the particular activities
that are subsumed under these general headings in order to clarify what exactly the text understands to constitute following other gods.Some of the activities are acceptable when offered to YHWH while others do not display such verbatim parallels. This suggests a distinction between practices that are condemned because of what they are and those rejected only when they are directed toward gods other
than YHWH. This textual approach to exploring the differences between YHWH-worship and its alternatives simultaneously relieves somewhat the difficulties of historically reconstructing actual religious practices
and illuminates the differences that most exercised the biblical authors. Building such a catalog is, however, only a first step toward understanding the difference between what is approved and condemned within the literary world of Jeremiah.
|
How Do We Judge What Role Scripture Played in Paul's Theology?
Program Unit: Paul and Scripture
Matthew Bates, University of Notre Dame
In terms of method, Richard Hays' influential intertextual model as set forth in "Echoes of Scripture in the Letters of Paul" focused almost exclusively on Paul's use of the Septuagint. There was nothing wrong with this decision in and of itself. The Septuagint is indeed the most prominent text for Paul regardless of the intertextual model adopted. The problem, however, is that subsequent scholarship has by and large become stuck on the Septuagintal Vorlage as Paul's 'pre-text,' without considering how other texts might inform Paul's use of the scriptures. This is a problem which transcends Pauline studies and is indicative of the whole enterprise devoted to studying how NT authors use the scriptures. A more robust intertextual model (drawing on Kristeva and others) recognizes that a 'text' is not only informed by its 'pre-texts' but also by 'co-texts' and 'post-texts.' The utility of this methodological proposal will be illustrated with several examples showing how paying attention to 'co-texts' and 'post-texts' rather than just the 'pre-text' forces a reassessment of Paul's exegesis.
|
The Proto-Creed in Rom 1:3–4: A Tool of Reconciliation? Evaluating the Proposal of Robert Jewett
Program Unit: Romans through History and Cultures
Matthew W. Bates, University of Notre Dame
Building upon his own previously published proposal, Robert Jewett in his recent commentary on Romans (Hermeneia, 2007) has put forward the suggestion that Paul received an early Christian confessional formula which he placed at the head of Romans in the exordium. Jewett has argued that Paul did not passively receive this creed, but actively redacted it by adding clauses to the proto-creed in order to promote reconciliation between "the strong" (predominately Gentile-Christians) and "the weak" (predominately Jewish-Christians). This paper will evaluate the Jewett's proposal and find it wanting. Although Paul does obviously desire reconciliation between these two groups, it is unlikely that he redacted a received confession in order to achieve this aim.
|
The Impact of an Urban Setting on Jesus Traditions in James
Program Unit: Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
Alicia Batten, University of Sudbury
Although little consensus exists as to the provenance of the Letter of James, scholars have noticed details in the missive, such as the references to fine clothes, rings and crowns, and thematic elements, including allusions to philosophical concepts, that support an urban setting. The rhetoric and overall elegance of the document also suggests that it was written for an audience that would have appreciated such literary sophistication. This paper begins by reviewing some of the thematic and literary aspects of James that point to a city or town as its site of origin. It then turns to some of the parallels between James and teachings associated with Jesus (the paper concurs with many scholars that there are connections between a form of Jesus sayings and James) in order to analyse how James’ urban environment has influenced the manner in which the author adapts some of these antecedent traditions.
|
Between Nationalism and Sectarianism: Political Identity in Ezra and Nehemiah
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible and Political Theory
Richard Bautch, Saint Edward's University
In the books of Ezra and Nehemiah, political identity is a dynamic interplay of forces such as kinship, economics, ethnicity, religion and, of course, politics. Imperialization and decolonization are additional forces salient in the process of identity formation that is evidenced in these two biblical books. After recognizing the complexity of identity formation in the political world of Ezra and Nehemiah, this paper focuses on distinct social entities, or groups, that populate this world and provide something of a window on Yehud in the 5th century. Specifically, there is analysis of three accounts of covenant making by groups prominent in Ezra or Nehemiah. An initial conclusion that covenant plays a significant role in forming each group’s political identity leads to further considerations. Incorporated into the study are the phenomena of Jewish nationalism, as it is conceived by David Goodblatt, and proto-sectarianism, as Joseph Blenkinsopp has described it. The paper concludes that covenant making was likely a crucial exercise for political groups in Yehud. For a given group, covenant making can mediate the tension between nationalism and nascent sectarianism and thereby serve as an index of the group’s political identity in the postexilic period.
|
Horses of Heaven: Equine Imagery in John’s Apocalypse
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
Leslie Baynes, Missouri State University
Who rides horses in the Greco-Roman world? In Israel? In Jewish and Christian apocalyptic literature? This paper will examine ancient equine imagery, horses heavenly and earthly, focusing on how it functions most especially in Revelation 6:1-8 and 19:11-14. While donkeys and mules could serve multiple purposes in antiquity, horses were the animal of choice on the battlefield, particularly, though not solely, in harness. Nonetheless, many ANE figurines representing horses with riders have been unearthed, and some of these may demonstrate a connection with solar deities. This paper probes that connection and argues that the glorified warrior Christ rides his white horse as a new iteration of a sun god.
|
Enoch and Jubilees in the Literature and Life of the Ethiopian Orthodox Church
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Leslie Baynes, Missouri State University
This paper investigates the place of Enoch and Jubilees first in the Ethiopian canon and then in the literature and life of the Ethiopian Orthodox Church. Since very few western scholarly sources have explored these issues, the paper works not only with such traditional Ethiopian texts as the Fetha Nagast, Kebra Nagast, Mashafa Berhan, Mashafa Milad, and Mashafa Mestira Samay wemedir, but also includes interviews with Ethiopian scholars, clergy, and average church members.
|
Canonization and Spiritual Experiences
Program Unit: Construction of Christian Identities
Giovanni B. Bazzana, Harvard University
The formation of the Christian scriptural canon has to be considered an extremely important step towards the definition of a Christian religious identity: the present paper aims at showing how “spiritual” experiences (mainly visions and revelations) played a key role in the process that led to the identification of a set number of texts as inspired and authoritative.
Some examples from the second and third centuries will be presented and then a series of more general historical conclusions will be tentatively drawn. Apelles, the Marcionite teacher, in his book significantly titled Phaneroseis, relied on the charismatic experiences of a prophetess, Philumene, to judge on the trustworthiness of biblical pericopes. A similar phenomenon can be detected in the Pseudo-clementine novel, but there charismatic authority is not a still active power, because it has been restricted to the “true prophet,” who alone can identify those “false” pericopes that have been hidden within the sacred Scriptures. Finally, Origen, in some writings of his (for instance, the Commentary on John), invokes spiritual experiences akin to prophecy as the basis that allows Christian communities to accept some books within the canon while rejecting others.
However, Origen’s conception already hints at the future developments: he does not speak any more of prophets within the Christian groups, but transfers the entire weight of the charismatic authority on exegetes and teachers, who act in the church and explain away problematic passages in the Scriptures by having recourse to allegorization. After the eclipse of charismatic authority in Christian groups in the second half of the second century, the process of canonization will become a matter of rationality and historical reconstruction (as it is well illustrated by Irenaeus’ stance on the issue).
|
Neo-Marxism, Language Ideologies, and the New Testament
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
Giovanni B. Bazzana, Harvard University
The present paper will take into consideration the study of language ideologies, a branch of linguistic anthropology, and the impact that it may have on biblical research. Language ideology has been defined as “the cultural system of ideas about social and linguistic relationships, together with their loading of moral and political interests”: the contemporary work on language ideologies has been profoundly influenced and shaped by neo-Marxist theorists (Gramsci, Althusser, Bourdieu) and by their reflections on cultural hegemony. Correcting an early Marxist tendency to conceptualize cultural phenomena as mere superstructure, neo-Marxism has recognized the key role played by cultural constructs in strengthening domination and in disciplining dissent. Linguistic anthropology has transferred such theoretical insights to the study of speech performances and grammatical structures on the assumption that there one may see the most significant intertwining of cultural and socio-political phenomena.
The study of language ideologies offers two obvious advantages to biblical criticism: first, it is perfectly designed for those scholars who have only written sources to deal with, but who nevertheless recognize the role of power relationship in shaping the very texts they use and their audiences, ancient and contemporary. Second, focusing on language ideologies avoids the pitfalls of “agency” and “awareness” (so prominent, for instance, in James Scott’s model of hidden/public transcripts), since linguistic domination can be exercised and it is effective both above and under the threshold of consciousness.
After this theoretical section, the paper will end with a case study, the Lord’s Prayer, a text that has been frequently considered a primary example of cultural and social counterculture for its idealized representation of divine kingship over against human sovereignty. However, a close examination of the syntactic structure of the prayer will reveal that it upholds an authoritative ideology originating in the Hellenistic notions of basileia.
|
Recent Developments and Ongoing Debates Concerning the Calendar Tablet from Gezer: A Summary of the Scholarly Discussion
Program Unit: Paleographical Studies in the Ancient Near East
Adam Bean, Emmanuel School of Religion
This paper engages current discussions of the well known inscribed limestone tablet discovered during Macalister’s excavations at Gezer in 1908. This inscription, which describes an annual cycle of agricultural activities, has typically been dated to the 10th century and was for a long time often given the title of “earliest surviving Hebrew inscription.” While the date of the inscription has not been greatly debated, its classification as a Hebrew text has come under serious scrutiny in recent years. Joseph Naveh began his discussion of the Hebrew Script with the Gezer Calendar, but promptly stated that “no specifically Hebrew characters can be distinguished” in the text. Others have concluded, as John F. Healey stated it, that it is a “Hebrew inscription… in the Phoenician script.” Most recently, Christopher A. Rollston has analyzed the typology of the script, concluding that it does not exhibit any of the diagnostic features of the Old Hebrew script. Thus, in terms of classification of the script, a new consensus appears to be emerging in favor of Phoenician, though P. Kyle McCarter prefers the designation “South Canaanite.” While the case may still be made that the inscription reflects the Hebrew language written in a Phoenician script, there are also arguments emerging for classifying the language of the inscription as Phoenician. Dennis Pardee argues in a forthcoming article what he has suggested in print only briefly before, that “according to presently known data, the paleography, orthography, morphology, and syntax of the Gezer Calendar correspond only to the norms of Phoenician.” Pardee’s argument, which has not yet been scrutinized by the scholarly community, will be summarized and brief, initial observations will be offered. Because of the Gezer Calendar's historic importance in discussions of Northwest Semitic script and language, and especially because of the new data emerging from recent epigraphic discoveries at Tel Zayit, Kfar Veradim, and Qeiyafa, the position of the Gezer Calendar's script and language within the epigraphic corpus must now be carefully (re-)evaluated.
|
The Deification of Mary Magdalene
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Mary Ann Beavis, St. Thomas More College
While academic feminist biblical scholars and theologians have focused on the role of Mary Magdalene as a disciple and leader in the kingdom of God movement, popular culture and scholarship have been more adventurous. Not only has Mary been identified as the wife of Jesus and mother of a messianic heir, but she is widely regarded by contemporary devotees as either a “temple priestess of the goddess” or even as a goddess herself. This paper will document the development of these radical, popular understandings of Mary, and probe the reasons for their appeal.
|
The 'Thrice Holy Hymn' in the Divine Liturgy as Biblical Exegesis
Program Unit: Bible in Eastern and Oriental Orthodox Traditions
Bruce Beck, Holy Cross Greek Orthodox School of Theology
In many of the early Byzantine Divine Liturgies of the Eastern Orthodox Church there is an ancient tradition of reciting the so-called “Trisagion” (thrice holy hymn): “Holy God, Holy Mighty, Holy Immortal, have mercy on us.” This paper will examine the ways in which this petition is itself an exegesis or expansion of Isa 6:3, the vision of Isaiah seeing God seated in the heavens on his throne, where the seraphim above him sing “to another … ‘holy, holy, holy is the Lord of hosts; the whole earth is full of His glory.’” How and why did this hymn get expanded to its present form, adding an attribute after each kadosh (“holy”)? Do these attributes each correspond to one of the Persons of the Trinity, and if so, was this always the case in the history of this tradition? In what way is this expansion typical of patristic exegesis?
Certain historical and exegetical questions proved to be generative for this ancient and foundational prayer within the Divine Liturgy. This paper will also attempt to show, in particular, how the attributes that appear in the chant of the seraphim of Isa 6:3 were drawn from other scripture, thus illustrating a type of liturgical exegesis on the Isaiah pericope. I will draw from certain patristic authors, such as St. Clement of Alexandria and St. John of Damascus, on these questions.
Lastly, I will conclude with some broader, phenomenological observations based on the Trisagion hymn about the way the Divine Liturgy seamlessly combines scriptural phrases from diverse biblical settings into the fabric of the Liturgy. What is indicated here about patristic understandings of the nature of scripture and how it should be interpreted, especially in the context of the Liturgy?
|
Israel and the Nations in the Book of Micah
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Bob Becking, Utrecht University - the Netherlands
Both Israel and the Nations are depicted differently throughout the Book of Micah. Israel is seen both as the object of divine wrath and punishment and as the object of divine love and grace. The Nations are at some instances cast in the role of the executors of divine wrath. In othre texts, however, they are depicted as coming to Jerusalem to seek God and his justice. These anomalies have often been solved by assuming a process of redaction of the text of Micah in various stages. I would like to embark on a different solution: Could it be possible that the Book of Micah is referring to two different stages in times to come?
|
Zedekiah, Josephus, and the Dating of the Books of Chronicles
Program Unit: Chronicles-Ezra-Nehemiah
Bob Becking, Utrecht University
This paper starts in two seemingly unrelated questions. (1) How come that 2 Chron. 36,14 is the only place within Chronicles where priests are assessed negatively? (2) How come that the second request by the Yehudites from Elephantine to rebuilt their temple is no longer addressed to Johanan and other priests in Jerusalem, but to Bagoses and the sons of Sanballat in Samaria? The Bagoses story from Josephus, Antiq. XI 297-301 turns out to be helpful for both questions. Rainer Albertz has argued that the events narrated in that story fit very well the developments in Jerusalem in the final decade of the fifth century BCE (question 2). I will argue, that the report on the conquest of Jerusalem in 2 Chronicles 36:11-21 can be seen as a key that matches the historical lock that is evoked by Josephus. As a result, I would argue that this report was composed in that very period as a mirror for the infidelity of some priests (question 1). In generalizing the proposal: if the entire Books of Chronicles were composed at that time, a good argument for the silencing of Samaria is found.
|
Meetings with Unremarkable Men: Dialogic Constructions of Authority in the Life of Apollonius and the Kephalaia of the Wisdom of My Lord Mani
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
Jason BeDuhn, Northern Arizona University
The Kephalaia of the Wisdom of My Lord Mani is an as yet unpublished anecdotal narrative about the life of the 3rd century founder of Manichaeism, fragmentarily preserved in a 4th century Coptic codex in the collection of the Chester Beatty Library, Dublin. An international collaborative project of which I am a part is currently editing the text for publication. One of the major themes that serve to structure the work is encounters between Mani and other sage-like figures, through which Mani demonstrates his superiority and establishes his authority. While overawing one’s opponent in real or imagined debate on core ideological differences is a common polemical literary device, the Kephalaia displays little of such oppositional sharpness. The wide-ranging conversations in which Mani engages, typically ending in a meeting of minds, are more akin to the exchanges in Philostratus’ Life of Apollonius. Through an examination of comparative examples from both texts, this paper explores their common narrative strategies. Both works assert the superiority of their respective heroes, and in this way establish the authority of these remarkable men. Yet they share a universalizing ideology that gives qualified acknowledgment to prior traditions of authority, rather than demonizing the less remarkable figures with whom they engage as representatives of falsehood. Both heroes are positioned as charismatic reformers in continuity with ancient traditions that have become corrupted in the hands of routinized authority. In their dialogic demonstration of mastery of those traditions, they assume control over them, framing religious innovation in terms of restoration of the tradition’s original form.
|
Visionary Legitimation and Its Discontents: The Cases of Paul, Marcion, and Mani
Program Unit: Construction of Christian Identities
Jason BeDuhn, Northern Arizona University
This paper addresses the use of visionary or revelatory claims to supersede authority rooted in structures of succession, and how the latter resisted the value of such claims. Paul provides the most familiar case in his struggle for authority against those who rested their authority on the mundane transmission of religious knowledge. Starting from this familiar ground, the paper probes the degree to which similar conflicts over vision-based authority were involved in the cases of Marcion and Mani. Both figures saw themselves in continuity with Paul; both positioned themselves as reformers and safeguards of prior revelation rather than as innovators; and both positioned their authority over against successionist institutions of leadership they regarded as corrupted. Mani certainly claimed independent visionary authority of his own, and this claim stood at the center of his efforts to redefine the nature of succession to religious authority as we see it in such works as the Cologne Mani Codex, the Kephalaia of the Teacher, and the (unpublished) Kephalaia of the Wisdom of My Lord Mani. It is much less clear whether claims to direct revelation were involved in the conflicts over Marcion’s authority. The question depends on how we read our polemical sources, on how we take the exordium of his Antitheses, and on to what degree the figure of Simon Magus in the Pseudo-Clementines is meant to represent not Paul, but Marcion. The Pseudo-Clementines provide the strongest early Christian articulation of an ideological rejection of visionary legitimation, one that may have served equally well the opponents of all three figures.
|
Scripture and Other Voices in Paul’s Theology
Program Unit: Paul and Scripture
Linda Belleville, Associated Mennonite Biblical Seminary
A common approach to analyzing Scripture in Paul’s theology is to identify explicit texts and implicit allusions or “echoes” and to consider their impact on Paul theological thinking. The underlying assumption is that Paul's theological Sitz im Leben was primarily if not exclusively that of the Hebrew Scriptures. This assumption results in a leap-frog hermeneutical approach that overlooks the rich tradition of theological traditions and interpretations in which Paul stands and the impact of these “other voices” on Paul’s theology. This paper will focus on the “other voices” and their contribution to some of Paul’s most distinctive theologizing and re-reading of Scripture.
|
Biblical Transparency, Cornel West, and American Historical Amnesia
Program Unit: Theology of the Hebrew Scriptures
Jason Bembry, Emmanuel School of Religion
The Hebrew Bible provides a candid portrayal of Israel’s mistakes throughout its existence. This transparency about their foibles and failures is seen across source critical lines, and it touches on a number of thematic registers - patriarchal deception (Genesis 12, 27), violence against the vulnerable (Judges 19), and sexual misconduct (Numbers 21, 1 Samuel 11) to name but a few. This stance is seen in the Pentateuchal sources, the Deuteronomistic History, and the prophetic works, pre-exilic and exilic. That this candid approach to Israel’s past is so widespread in the canon suggests that there may be greater significance to it than mere internal rivalry whether among the tribes or even the tradents. The prophetic recollection of and reflection upon these troubling stories from Israel’s past, seen most clearly in Hosea and Jeremiah, strengthens the case that these stories were remembered with intentionality. Such a transparent stance about the past stands out in the ancient world. In fact, no other ancient culture parallels the level of introspection and self-critical awareness expressed in these multiple episodes written in the Hebrew Bible. The candor fostered humility within the Israelite group identity, maintaining an admission of fallibility stitched throughout their foundational stories. Building on the work of Cornel West, this paper suggests that the theological implication of this facet of the Hebrew Bible calls for all peoples to be transparent and self-critical of themselves, individually and corporately. West’s critique of American “historical amnesia” and his call for Americans to keep track of the “nightside” of their past are placed alongside the transparency of these biblical narratives to serve as a theological lens through which a model of self reflection can be seen. Such a stance could be applied to the scholarly community, the religious community – church, synagogue, and mosque, and even national and ethnic communities.
|
Hazor in the Iron II
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Doron Ben Ami, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
The importance of sites such as Hazor lies in their dense stratigraphy, ranging throughout the Iron Age II. The thick accumulation of Iron Age II remains—a direct consequence of the uninterrupted occupation—points to the intensive settlement at Hazor. This sequence, which is estimated to have lasted approximately 200 years, is of great significance in any consideration of the relative chronology of the first Israelite city at Hazor, particularly with regard to the time of its construction.
The archaeological remains suggest that Hazor became a well-planned, fortified settlement in the early stages of the Iron Age II (Strata X-IX). Its fortification system included a six-chambered gate and a casemate wall. In addition, parts of the residential quarters of this fortified city were unearthed. The information that has accumulated in the course of the renewed excavations suggest that the first Israelite city at Hazor belongs to a group of settlements with “peripheral planning”, in which the buildings were arranged in large 'belts' around the perimeter. The outline of the outer fortification wall is not elliptical, as in most Iron Age settlements, but is composed of sections built in straight lines. Such a plan was often preferred in settlements of social, political, or military importance, as it made the settlement more prominent in relation to its environs. This well-planned fortified city served certain administrative purposes and played an important role in the crystallization of urban life in Iron Age Israel.
Sometime during the ninth century B.C.E. the casemate-walled town of Strata X-IX was replaced by a new city. Stratum VIII witnessed a completely new architectural complexes built over the remains of the former city. The domestic nature of the Strata X-IX buildings is now replaced by some monumental structures of public characteristics. These large-scale architectural units are centered together and occupy almost the entire excavated area. Once the layout of the new city was established and defined its general plan and principal buildings continued to serve, although with several changes, throughout the ninth and well into the eighth century B.C.E.
|
Prophetic Memories in the Deuteronomistic Historical and the Prophetic Collections of Books: Their Sitz im Diskurs and Social Circumstances
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Ehud Ben Zvi, University of Alberta
Most of the books in the deuteronomistic historical and the prophetic collections emerged in the early to mid Persian period. First, the paper deals with the conceptualization of prophecy and the memory of prophets of the Persian period. For instance, the paper examines the features commonly associated with the prophets of the monarchic period, and the roles and function that constructing and remembering prophets in such ways played in the general discourse of literati— namely, those for whom authoritative prophecy was a set of prophetic books to be read and reread and for whom the past was imagined mainly through the frame of the deuteronomistic collection. The deuteronomistic collection itself often carried a voice similar to that of the prophet Moses, and of its later reverberation (within the community’s past) in the (partial) voice of Jeremiah. Second, this paper addresses the question of why particular memories and features of past prophetic characters were preferred and what this preference may indicate about the society in which these collections emerged, and why they did. Finally, this paper deals also with links and associations between the literati and the prophet, that is, a) the literati who wrote and read this literature and who identified with and even “embodied” the speaking voices of various prophetic characters and b) the “prophets,” to whom they gave a voice, and the ways in which the interplay between similarities and dissimilarities contributed to the formation of the prophetic literature and its relation to the deuteronomistic history. This analysis leads to historical questions about the range of meanings associated with terms such as prophet and prophecy in that society and about ways in which the prophets of the past (as remembered by the community) and prophecy were both “historicized” and “de-historicized” within the social memory of the community and as reflected in its literature.
|
The Parts of Heaven and Earth according to 1 Enoch 77 (Aramaic and Ethiopic)
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Jonathan Ben-Dov, University of Haifa
A well-rooted misunderstanding of 1 Enoch 77:3 has led scholars to deduce a sevenfold division of the world from this passage. This notion led to a presumed connection with the so-called ‘Babylonian Map of the World’, a connection discarded since then. While word šb‘, ‘seven’ in the Aramaic copy 4Q209 23 9 was considered strong evidence for the sevenfold division, this word appears exactly where the three(!) parts of the Earth are designated. The crux can be solved and the division of the world sorted out by suggesting a new interpretation for the problematic word šb‘. This interpretation requires some text-critical work with regard to the Ethiopic versions of 1 En 77, where many textual variants are to be found.
The new interpretation results in a clearer separation of heaven and earth. In chapter 77 heaven is divided into the four winds, which are strictly to be seen as rwhy šmy’ ‘the winds of heaven’. There is no fourfold division of the earth in this passage! In contrast, the earth is divided into three parts according to the dwellings of human beings and other worldly entities.
Finally, the cosmological background for the divisions into four (heaven) and three (earth) will be further explored. The fourfold division of heaven concords perfectly with the interests of the Astronomical Book elsewhere as well as with its Mesopotamian forerunners. The tripartite division of the earth, in contrast, is far more difficult to account for.
|
‘Sacred’ in the Eye of the Beholder? Another Look at ‘Nomina Sacra’ in Documentary Papyri from Christian Egypt
Program Unit: Papyrology and Early Christian Backgrounds
Rick D. Bennett, Jr., Accordance
Although the scribal convention of writing certain words as ‘nomina sacra’ in Biblical manuscripts is relatively fixed, their counterparts in the documentary papyri reveal a different story. Forms used with regularity are absent, while a small number of forms found in the papyri are not present in any Biblical manuscript. It will not suffice to relegate these occurrences in the documentary papyri to footnotes or appendices within discussions of the larger phenomenon of ‘nomina sacra.’ They witness to a distinct strand, and their frequency signify their importance. But, are they ‘sacred?’ The way forward in discussions of ‘nomina sacra’ point toward a delineation of those occurrences which are sacred, and those which are not; those which occur in sacred writings, and those which do not. Herein lies the ambiguity presumably faced by those who employed these forms and those who seek to interpret them today: are they merely sacred in the eye of the beholder?
One recent study has treated the subject of ‘nomina sacra’ in documentary papyri within a larger discussion of Christianity in Oxyrhynchus up to the pre-Constantinian period (Luijendijk 2008), and another as an indicator of ‘belief’ in fourth-century papyri (Choat 2006). This paper will seek to bring focused scrutiny on occurrences of ‘nomina sacra’ within documentary papyri identified as bearing a Christian significance up to the fifth century CE.
|
Situation Aspect and the Piel-Hiphil Distinction in Ernst Jenni
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Richard C. Benton, Jr., University of Wisconsin-Madison
Situation aspect plays a role in the Biblical Hebrew binyanim, but the extent of its role is not yet clear. In my previous work I have demonstrated that situation aspect, the semantic distinction between states and processes, helps distinguish the function of the Niphal and Hitpael, as well as the Pual (Benton 2008, 2009).
We can see evidence of situation aspect in Jenni's study of the Piel and Hiphil (Jenni 1968). He defines the Piel as the stem that causes the state indicated by the root (1968:275). On this point IBHS explains, "[T]his state can be expressed in terms of an adjectival construction" (24.1f). For those roots that are intransitive in the Qal, Jenni refers to them as "factitive" in the Piel, while Qal transitives are "resultative" in the Piel (1968:275). At the same time, the Hiphil, in Jenni's system, expresses causing a process ("Vorgang") or action ("Handlung"), as opposed to a state in the Piel (1968:276; see also IBHS 27.1b).
Since Jenni's terminology coincides closely with that of situation aspect, but without formal linguistic analysis, my paper will examine whether the observations Jenni makes about the Piel-Hiphil distinction can be attributed to situation aspect in the modern, linguistic use of that category. One problem with Jenni's work, as stated by Hillers is that, "[T]he grammatical and semantic categories with which he operates are ill-defined, and used in an arbitrary and insonsistent way" (Hillers 1969:212). Situation aspect has been defined by scholars such as Comrie (1976), Smith (1991), and Dobbs-Allsopp (2000). Thus situation aspect offers a more widely accepted category for analysis of the Piel and Hiphil, one that appears well-suited to Jenni's observations.
|
The Temporal Function of w- in the Epic Poetry from Ugarit
Program Unit: Ugaritic Studies and Northwest Semitic Epigraphy
Brendon C. Benz, New York University
In any language, the meaning of particles such as prepositions and conjunctions is largely determined by the immediate grammatical context in which they are located. Determining the semantic range of a particle, therefore, often requires that its function in these contexts is analyzed on a case by case basis. This study will explore the function of the Ugaritic particle w- when it links two finite verbs that occupy the same poetic line in the texts of Aqhat, Kirta, and The Baal Cycle. It will argue that under these conditions w- has a specifically temporal function, indicating that each verb within the line marks a different poetic moment or temporal frame within the sequential progression of the narrative. The benefit of establishing this function is threefold. First, it will provide a more nuanced understanding of the semantic range of w- in these texts. Second, it will offer insight into the semantics of poetic lines that contain multiple finite verbs that are not linked by a w-. Finally, it will demonstrate that by being attuned to this function, one can arrive at greater clarity regarding a number of syntactical, semantic, and structural difficulties in this corpus.
|
The Varieties of Sociopolitical Experience: Late Bronze Age Syria-Palestine and the “Insider” Status of Early Israel
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Brendon C. Benz, New York University
In the tradition of the longue durée principle, it has become a customary practice to reconstruct the sociopolitical landscape of the Levant during the Late Bronze Age in order to understand better the origins and nature of early Israel. Common to many of these reconstructions is the idea that this landscape was dominated by small city-states in the lowlands of the coast and valleys, and larger territorial kingdoms in the eastern highlands. In both cases, the sociopolitical structure was defined by a particular urban center from which power was administered by a small cadre of political elite over and against the large sedentary population. This backdrop is frequently made a foil for the phenomenon of early Israel. A number of critical dichotomies have come to represent this reconstruction, including sedentary v. non-sedentary; tribe v. state; hierarchical v. egalitarian; and ultimately, “Canaanite” v. “Israelite”.
This study will argue that the sociopolitical landscape of the Late Bronze Age Levant as attested in the Amarna letters was quite variable. Rather than being dominated by hierarchically organized, city-centered states, there was a strong collective political heritage throughout the region. In addition, political relationships between urban centered polities and polities that did not identify themselves with a particular urban center are attested. A comparison of this variability with the biblical depictions of early Israel will suggest that though elements of early Israel certainly consisted of geographic, socioeconomic, and sociopolitical outsiders, a strong contingent was continuous with the landscape of the Late Bronze Age, constituting a group of geographic, socioeconomic, and sociopolitical insiders.
|
Islamic Origins and the Nature of the Early Sources
Program Unit: Qur'an and Biblical Literature
Herb Berg, University of North Carolina at Wilmington
This paper examines on the various historical, conceptual and literary problems inherent to the traditional Islamic sources regarding the study of Islamic origins. It argues that those scholars who seek to extract historical information about Muhammad and his early followers from these sources are constructing figures which the sources do not describe. The sources describe only theological entities, not historical ones.
|
Universal Human Sinfulness in the Hodayot and Paul’s Letter to the Romans
Program Unit: Qumran
Shane Berg, Princeton Theological Seminary
One strategy for comparing the Dead Sea Scrolls to the literature of the New Testament has been to look for genetic connections—places where the Scrolls have “influenced” some feature of a New Testament text. But increasingly scholars are recognizing the fruitfulness of making comparisons between the Scrolls and the New Testament that do not depend on genetic connections but rather on broader similarities in patterns of thought. This paper proposes to explore just such a similarity.
The so-called community hymns of the Hodayot portray humans in a striking way. Prior to God’s intervention, humans are in a state of sinfulness and ignorance due to the vulgar raw materials from which they are constituted (dust, clay, etc.). Only by receiving a spirit (or spirits) from God are they able to overcome the limits of their natural state in order to achieve knowledge of God and therefore obey and praise God rightly. In Paul’s letter to the Romans, humans are also portrayed as universally sinful and unable to achieve communion with God without God’s initiative and intervention.
The paper will examine what theological and rhetorical effect is achieved in these texts by asserting universal human sinfulness and ignorance. How does such an assertion relate to the broadly apocalyptic Jewish context that these texts share? It will be argued that while each text develops and deploys the notion of universal human sinfulness in unique ways, there is nonetheless an underlying sectarian goal in portraying all of humanity as estranged from God. It creates the possibility for an author to articulate his own vision for how humanity overcomes that separation.
|
Isaiah 53: A Reading beyond Individuality or Collectivity
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Ulrich Berges, University of Bonn
Since the very beginning the history of interpretation of the fourth Servant Song is marked by the contrast of individual -mainly christian- versus collective - mainly jewish - interpretations. Where does that come from? Perhaps the reasons lay not only in religious contrasts but also in the text of Is 53 and its inmediate context in the Book of Isaiah. The paper proposes a reading that goes beyond the dichotomy of individuality or collectivity.
|
“The Stick of Ishmael”: A Latter-day Saint Perspective of the Qur’an
Program Unit: Qur'an and Biblical Literature
James F. Berlin, The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints
As with Muslims, Mormons, or more correctly, Latter-day Saints (as members of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints prefer to be called) recognize that the Tawra and the Injil form only part of God’s written word to mankind. Latter-day Saints accept the idea expressed in Luqman 31:27: “And if all the trees on earth were pens and the Oceans (were ink), with seven Oceans behind it to add to its (supply), yet would not the Words of Allah be exhausted.” With this willingness to receive all God’s word wherever it be found, Latter-day Saints interpret biblical expressions such as Ezekiel’s “stick of Judah” and the “stick of Joseph” (see Ezekiel 37:15-20) as referring respectively to the written record of Judah (the Bible---Tawra and Injil) and the written record of Joseph (The Book of Mormon---a volume of holy scripture comparable to the Bible, recounting God’s dealings with some of the ancient inhabitants of the Americas). As more Latter-day Saints become familiar with the Qur’an, they are asking themselves the question, “How does the Qur’an harmonize with other revelation?” This paper will discuss one LDS perspective of this question, and propose that like its sibling scriptures, the Qur’an---or “the stick of Ishmael”---is yet another sign of God’s revelation to mankind, witnessing to the truth that God “shall also speak unto all nations of the earth and they shall write it” (Book of Mormon, 2 Nephi 29:12).
|
The Hittite Provenance of Deuteronomy 13
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Joshua Berman, Bar Ilan University
For over forty years the dominant view within scholarship has maintained that Deuteronomy 13 is a composition of the seventh century BCE. Remarkable similarities of language and norms exist between the apostasy laws of Deuteronomy 13 and the disloyalty provisions set out in section 10 of the Vassal Treaty of Esarhaddon of 672 BCE. So compelling are the parallels of phraseology, so clearly defined is the historical setting, that Richard Nelson speaks for the consensus when he writes in his Deuteronomy commentary, “[Deuteronomy 13] breathes the atmosphere of Assyrian treaty documents, paralleling the requirements for loyalty found in them… The similarities between this chapter and VTE are so close that a deliberate imitation of Assyrian forms is nearly certain.” In this paper I propose that a more compelling backdrop for the apostasy laws of Deuteronomy 13 can be located in the Late Bronze Hittite vassal treaty tradition. Although Hittite treaty forms were a subject of keen interest in the 1960’s, crucial material has come to light since that has been largely ignored by the scholarship until now. I will draw attention to the sedition stipulations of the Hittite treaties that closely match the apostasy laws of Deuteronomy 13. In case after case we may see that the Hittite parallels are closer in content and in form to the laws of Deuteronomy 13 than are the parallels from the Neo-Assyrian tradition.
|
From Historical Criticism to Historical Materialism in the Study of Early Christology
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
Jonathan Bernier, McMaster University
In this paper I will re-articulate certain recent trends within scholarship on Second Temple Jewish monotheism and early Christology in dialectical terms, wherein structurally the divine is poised in opposition to the human and so-called “mediator figures” are understood to serve as spaces wherein ancient Jewish thought could mediate the tensive relationship between these opposites. I will further argue that what Hurtado calls “the Christian mutation” in Christology was the unprecedented identification of this mediatory space with a specific historical figure of recent memory, i.e. Jesus of Nazareth. Finally, I will argue that this transcoding from the historical critical methods of “New History-of-Religions” school to those of dialectical analysis constitutes a necessary base towards a genuinely historical materialist study of early Christology.
|
Genre Just Gets in the Way Anyway: Reading the Genesis Apocryphon Multigenerically
Program Unit: Qumran
Moshe J. Bernstein, Yeshiva University
One of the questions that has concerned students of the Genesis Apocryphon ever since its publication in the mid-1950s is that regarding its genre. We suggest that too focused an approach to this issue is an impediment to a comprehensive understanding of the Apocryphon.
In the earliest stages of scholarship, the debate was whether it was a targum or a midrash. In 1961 Geza Vermes classified the Apocryphon in his new category “rewritten Bible.” Careful analysis of the Apocryphon, however, shows that it is not all cut from the same cloth, and that the first and second sections are clearly not the same type of “rewritten Bible,” but resemble Enoch and Jubilees, respectively. We have further argued elsewhere that despite our ability to point to sources and compositional disunities, the Apocryphon nevertheless exhibits a unity that makes it worthy of literary analysis as a story virtually independent of the Bible.
A multigeneric approach to the Apocryphon allows us to classify it under a number of generic rubrics for different aspects of our analysis. We can call it a biblical commentary, and compare it with other commentaries. We can call it re-written Bible and compare its technique with that of others that fit that rubric. We can look at it as a Mischgattung, composed of an Enoch-like first part, and a Jubilees-like second. We can examine features of the Apocryphon that appear similar to those that we find in targum or midrash. Finally we can ignore almost all of its connections with earlier and later works and read it as its original audience might have been expected to, as a literary entity. A fuller appreciation of the Apocryphon will come from a judicious employment of this multigeneric approach than from the standard approach that treats generic classifications as mutually exclusive.
|
Jesus as the Child, the Child as Jesus: Using Mimesis to Understand the Child in Matthew 18:1–5
Program Unit: Children in the Biblical World
Sharon Betsworth, Oklahoma City University
In Matthew 2, after the opening verse Jesus is referred to only as “the child” for the remainder of the chapter. By the end of chapter 2, Matthew has constructed an image of who “the child” is in his Gospel: the child is vulnerable, threatened with death and dependent upon others (especially God.) This image is then illustrated by means of several narratives about children. By the end of the Gospel, Matthew’s adult Jesus takes on the characteristics of the child. Thus, the child and Jesus become intertwined images in Matthew's Gospel. In 18:1-5, Jesus sets a child before his disciples, telling them that they must become like children to enter the Kingdom of Heaven. Drawing upon the Greek concept of mimesis -- imitating or representing someone or something in action, speech, art or literature -- I will demonstrate that for the disciples to become like a child is at the same time to become like Jesus.
|
Common and Different Views on Babylon’s Fall and Its Aftermath in Isaiah 13–14 and Jeremiah 50–51
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Willem A. M. Beuken, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
A semantic comparison of the two oracles against Babylon in Isaiah 13-14 and Jeremiah 50-51 demonstrates that the terms used for Yhwh’s activity are rather similar, although more in the statements in which God himself speaks than in those in which there is talk of him. This indicates a gradually growing theological discourse on divine judgment in the (post)exilic era. The oracles, while having much in common, describe the consequences of Babylon’s fall quite differently, pertaining particularly to Babylon itself and Yhwh’s people. The “day of Yhwh” motif and the infernal fate of Babylon’s king, a prominent theme in Isa 13-14, are lacking in the Jeremiah oracle, whereas the restoration of Zion and the return from exile to this city, topical in Jeremiah 50-51, are absent from the Isaiah oracle. Moreover, the very term “Israel” has different meanings in the two oracles. It covers the whole of the people of God in Isa 14,1-2 (// “Jacob”), where in Jer 50-51 (passim) it stands for the inhabitants of the Northern kingdom. The Isaiah oracle speaks only of the re-occupation of the land of Israel and the submission of the former oppressors (Isa 14,1-2), compared to the Jeremiah oracle that offers an integrated view on the re-union of Israel and Judah, the remission of sins, and the return to Jhwh in Zion (Jer 50,4-7. 17-20. 28. 33-34; 51,5-6. 10. 49-51). From a diachronic point of view it seems that the Jeremiah oracle represents a later stage of exilic theology, while the Isaiah oracle’s lack of “theological maturity” is compensated for by its placement in the over-all redaction of Isa 1-39.
|
Different Texts and Different Interpretations of "Exile"
Program Unit: Exile (Forced Migrations) in Biblical Literature
Stefan Beyerle, University Greifswald
Ever since modern critical Exegesis has detected the importance of text-critical and text-historical studies, the Book of Jeremiah counts as a test case for the relevance and efficiency of these methods. Especially the Jer-LXX and some biblical evidence of Jer from Qumran lead to a discussion about the earliest textual form of the Book of Jeremiah – in German speaking scholarship, Georg Fischer and Hermann-Josef Stipp among others are involved in this discussion. Within this debate, Jer 52 (MT) is of special interest. As opposed to recent developments, especially in German scholarly discussion, this paper understands all different "variants" of Jer 52, and also of 2 Kings 24 – 25, as different autonomous texts that represent various historiographical and theological interpretations of "Exile."
|
My Face Shall Not Be Seen: The Mediated Presence of God in Ritual and Cult
Program Unit: Theology of the Hebrew Scriptures
Bryan Bibb, Furman University
This paper explores the dynamic mediation of God’s presence in biblical passages related to ritual, temple, and cult. In the mythic world of the Torah, the re-production of the Ten Commandments reveals a transition from the presence of God experienced immediately by the people to a situation in which God’s presence is mediated through tablets inscribed by Moses rather than God. This process continues by means of ritual and ethical laws relayed by Moses to the people and through a corpus of laws that is recorded, systematized, and canonized. As Moses delegates his responsibilities and invests particular authority in Aaron, priests, Levites, and elders, he establishes a system by which the presence and revelation of God are housed within the ritual and cultic system, are controlled and mediated by religious professionals, and are eventually encoded within the textual tradition. In order to bring a word of judgment to bear against Israel and Judah’s leadership and institutions, the prophets pierce the mysterious center of Israel’s cult and emerge with narratives of direct access to God and to God’s revelatory will for the people. Prophetic critique of religious and political leadership depends upon the prophets’ direct access to God’s presence. The rhetorical effect of this unmediated divine access is apparent in passages such as Amos’ terrifying tableaux of destruction, Isaiah’s vision of God “high and lofty” in the temple, and, above all, Ezekiel’s fantastic exploration of priestly corruption and God’s exit from the holy precincts. The theology of the Hebrew Bible, therefore, preserves a delicate and dynamic balance between a) traditional authority structures that serve an important role in mediating access to the Holy and b) the radical freedom of God that transcends and relativizes those necessary human institutions.
|
Bloodless Sacrifice and the Fulfillment of the Mosaic Law of Sacrifice
Program Unit: Latter-day Saints and the Bible
Michael Biggerstaff, Vanderbilt University
In discussing the fulfillment of the Law of Moses by the atoning sacrifice of Jesus Christ as found in 3 Nephi 9, Hugh Nibley alludes to the Mosaic law of sacrifice being fulfilled, but not the eternal law of sacrifice. Nibley quotes Christ as saying he no longer desires sacrifices or burnt offerings, but wants instead a sacrifice of “a broken heart and a contrite spirit” (3 Ne 9:20). He goes on to identify this “new” sacrifice Christ desires as being a verbatim quote from Psalm 51:17 (which is a plea for expiation) and thus exemplifying a non-blood requirement associated with every sacrifice. Leviticus 17:11 is often taken as the scripture explaining how the expiatory sacrifices worked and the role of blood in the effectuating of them. The result is a mistaken belief that it was solely the blood of the sacrifice that effected atonement on behalf of the offerer. This paper will examine the Mosaic law of sacrifice and elucidate factors outside of blood that were requisite for expiation to take place. For example, Leviticus 5:5 necessitates a confession prior to expiation; without that confession, the ritual would not have been complete, therefore no expiation could have been effected. In addition, Leviticus 5:11-13 permits flour to be offered as a sacrifice of expiation. That blood is not the pivotal requirement in either of these examples suggests that something else fulfills that essential role. Through analysis of the Hebrew Bible and Book of Mormon, this paper will demonstrate that it was the material offering of the Mosaic law of sacrifice which was fulfilled by Christ, whereas the intimate offering brought by each offerer was never rescinded.
|
Irenaeus and the Other Books: Non-canonical Christian Texts in His Polemic
Program Unit: Function of Apocryphal and Pseudepigraphal Writings in Early Judaism and Early Christianity
D. Jeffrey Bingham, Dallas Theological Seminary
Irenaeus, in his polemic against his opponents, appeals to a variety of writings at his disposal in order to ensure a compelling argument. Citations or allusions to this literature, since he writes to aid a member of his community, could reflect a collection accepted not just by him, but also the Catholic Christians of Gaul. Also, since he has his origin in Asia Minor, under the tutelage of Polycarp, and has represented his community and the Asian one before Rome, this collection might represent a more broad assembly of recognized books. This assembly of literature included, of course, books within the Hebrew Bible and the New Testament as well as apocryphal and non-canonical texts (e.g., Wisdom, Susanna, Baruch, 4 Esdras, Hermas). This paper will study the way in which Irenaeus uses Christian non-canonical texts (in particular, Hermas and other second-century writings) to aid his polemic, the manner in which he represents their place in the community’s structure of authority (naming some as Scripture, graphe), and compare his engagement with these texts to the manner in which he handles texts from the Hebrew Bible and New Testament.
|
Irenaeus and Hebrews
Program Unit: Hebrews
D. Jeffrey Bingham, Dallas Theological Seminary
Despite the early recognition by Eusebius that Irenaeus quoted Hebrews in works which are now lost, scholars have been less willing to see the Letter making its mark in Adversus haereses. Although there are exceptions, some, for example, acknowledge the presence of Hebrews 1:3 in book 2, views to the contrary are stated plainly. It is difficult to find contemporary confidence in Irenaeus’s use of Hebrews in his extant writings and most deny it a place in his “canon.” Even if recognized, the place of the Epistle in Irenaeus’s constructive theology is minimized. In this paper, an analysis of Irenaeus’s knowledge and use of Hebrews, I hope to begin a challenge to such opinions. I don’t intend here to insist that Irenaeus revered Hebrews as a sacred text, the same way in which he sees the Spirit speaking through the prophets, the evangelists, and Paul. But I do wish to demonstrate that his thought is dependent in important degrees upon its language and teaching. Hebrews 1:3, 8, 9, 2:10, 3:4, 5, 5:9, 14, and 8:5 contribute in important ways to his view of creation as the act of the Father with his Son and Spirit; the uniqueness of the Father and Son; his notion of martyrdom; the contrast between the true God and the idols; Mary’s recapitulation of Eve; anthropological immaturity and need for progressive growth to maturity; and a hermeneutical framework for his understanding of the relationship between the two economies, between prophecy and fulfillment, between the Law and grace, the earthly and the heavenly. I will conclude, that although perhaps in a different manner than Eusebius knew it, Adversus haereses also provides evidence of the important place of Hebrews in the work and possibly the canon of the bishop of Lyons.
|
Colonial and Ecclesial Construction in Roman Corinth: 1 Cor. 3:5–4:5 and Inscriptional Evidence
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Bradley J. Bitner, Macquarie University
Most of the attention paid to the Apostle Paul’s agricultural, architectural, and other metaphors in 1 Cor. 3:5-4:5 has been focused on the analysis of individual terms. Viewed as generic and mixed metaphors, they are passed over quickly en route to a rhetorical analysis of the discourse unit. If they are dealt with at any length, it is almost always with reference to ancient literary rather than documentary texts. In this paper select documentary sources (IG VII 3073, P.Oxy III 486, and IKor 8, 3 131, 152, 156 & 158) related to Roman Corinth are examined. These form the basis for proposing that the Roman colonial, social, and especially legal fabric of Paul’s Corinth has been insufficiently noted as a necessary and fruitful context for interpreting this section of the letter, and perhaps the entire Corinthian correspondence. The careful manner in which Paul in 1 Cor. 3:5-4:5 goes about constructing the framework of the Corinthian ?????s?a within, and to some degree over against, the political ideology of the Corinthian ??????a provides a suggestive test case for this hypothesis and offers a methodological corrective to rhetorical and other background approaches which tend to be reductionistic.
|
When Babylon is Not Babylon: Psalm 137 and the Caribbean Hermeneutical Space
Program Unit: Biblical Criticism and Literary Criticism
Fiona C. Black, Mount Allison University
This paper considers the multi-positionality of lament discourse via a reading of Psalm 137, "By the Rivers of Babylon." The psalm's play with ideas of place and space suggests a useful heuristic for thinking about the ways that lamentation intersects with different, often conflicting, interests, particularly those of insiders (exiled) and outsiders (enemies). Discussion will be framed against Caribbean hermeneutics and the experiences of present-day insiders and outsiders, that is, exiles and immigrants. The psalm serves here both to explore the contours of the Caribbean immigrant experience and some of the benefits and failings of Caribbean hermeneutics.
|
Deification and Colossians 2:10
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
Ben C. Blackwell, Durham University
In Colossians 2.9 the author makes a striking statement about Christ: ‘in him all the fullness (pleroma) of deity dwells bodily’. The meaning of this claim is much debated, with primary evidence being the close parallel in Col 1.19, the nature of ‘deity’ and the function of the adverb ‘bodily’. However, this ‘fullness’ is not limited to Christ alone because the author subsequently states that the Colossian believers ‘have been filled (pleroo) in him’ (Col 2.10). With the parallel use of filling, it appears that believers are filled with deity through Christ, but this exegetical option is often quickly denied by most interpreters. Accordingly, this essay will explore the referent of this filling with regard to the Colossian community. Importantly, this exploration will add to the growing discussion regarding deification, or theosis, in the Pauline corpus.
|
"If Your Vaginas Could Talk, What Would They Say?" An Interview with Hagar and Sarah
Program Unit: Feminist Hermeneutics of the Bible
Kathryn D. Blanchard, Alma College
In preparation for the writing of her controversial 1998 play, The Vagina Monologues, Eve Ensler invited more than 200 women to answer the question, "If your vagina could talk, what would it say?" The result is a collection of about a dozen monologues that have now been translated into 45 languages and performed in more than 100 countries around the world. It is also performed on numerous college and seminary campuses across the country, sometimes every year. This paper begins biblical exegesis of the Hagar-Sarah narrative with Eve Ensler's provocative question. Such an interpretation necessarily involves not only the imagined responses of these two women, but also the centuries of women and men who have sought to understand the painful interactions and hopeful consequences of their story.
|
Refusals of/in Sexuality: Reflections on Pasolini’s Paul and the Political Afterlives of Paulinism
Program Unit: Gender, Sexuality, and the Bible
Ward Blanton, University of Glasgow
In a moment when critical theorists and continental philosophers like Jacob Taubes, Giorgio Agamben, and Alain Badiou have once again discovered surprising resources in the figure of an early Christian Paul, Pier Paolo Pasolini’s screenplay of an unfinished film about the apostle invites us to steer these recent readings in important new directions. In this presentation I want to focus on how Pasolini’s gay Paul makes an important contribution to our understanding of the work of Michel Foucault, particularly inasmuch as both Pasolini and Foucault were trying to grapple with the question of a post-repressive, post-Oedipal network of diffuse, unlocalized power that operates not by overt prohibition but the production of normalized or docile desires. Against this backdrop, I then want to present several ways in which Paul’s peculiar ‘apocalyptic sexuality’ opens up new modes for us to think the sexual and the political under the aegis of the emancipatory.
|
The Invention of Biblical Studies as a Modern Enterprise: The Case of the "Critical"
Program Unit: Redescribing Christian Origins
Ward Blanton, University of Glasgow
By now several crucial nineteenth century associations about biblical scholars and biblical scholarship tend to go unremarked, naturalized, and undertheorized. Here I will provide a genealogy of the way this field and its laborers came to be called ‘critical’ and, as a further determination, ‘historical-critical’, these terms standing in for something about the ‘modern’ which could be relinquished only at the peril of academic biblical scholarship. As an act of clarification and (re)politicization of these designations, this paper will trace the academic and political history of these terms. I am particularly interested in the way 19th century biblical scholarship appropriated these names from other cultural fields, often working them over to produce shrewd politicizations of their own work, investing biblical scholarship with that elusive object of desire: relevance.
As part of the astonishing de-politicization of this academic field over time, biblical scholars began increasingly to praise the idea of subtracting themselves, their interests, or their ‘own time’ from their representations of ancient religion and society. This triumph of positivism resulted in a now standardized procedure of looking ‘back’ to 19th century scholarship, pointing out its interpretive investments, and then declaring that some new interpretation overcomes or finally forgets the modern investments of the interpreter. As a model of disciplinary self-description, the history of the term ‘critical’, however, invites other thoughts: it is not that the nineteenth century ‘invested too much’ or that, by the same token, contemporary interpreters should finally overcome their own desiring gazes (whether we name this affective comportment as “prejudice” or “theology”). Instead, I want to argue: in relation to the ‘critical’, we should learn a 19th century trick we have since forgotten: how to politicize biblical scholarship.
|
Syncretism in Africa and in the Bible: A Cognitive Explanation
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Regina Blass, Africa International University, Nairobi
Syncretism in the Bible, worshipping other Gods besides Jehova, has been the reason for Israel's downfall in the Old Testament many times. It is a scriptural phenomenon.
Some countries in Africa, e.g. Kenya, are vibrating with evangelical mega churches. Christianity seems on the rise. However, with the appearance of AIDS and other sources of suffering in Africa, the practice of African religion is on the rise also.
How can two contradictory beliefs exist together? My explanation will come from a cognitive approach.
|
How Orality Affects the Use of Pragmatic Particles, and How It Is Relevant for Translation
Program Unit: Bible Translation
Regina Blass, Africa International University, Nairobi
Many pragmatic particles are used only or differently when used orally. For instance, if someone tells a story in Sissala (a Niger Congo, Gur, Language) he might use 'ha' from time to time to hold the addressee's attention. In translation they would be only used in audio or audio visual scripture, but they would have to appear.
Other particles are used in writing, as for intance the intensifier 'de'. However, tests have shown that they are used much more often orally when there is an audience. Again audio scripture would divert form written scipture.
Again other particles are usually used in colloquial speech which is normally not written, while there are alternatives particles for the written version. My claim will be that translators have to be very much aware of the oral use of particles in translation and choose what is appropriate for audio translation and written translation.
|
Can Ahiqar Tell Us Anything about Personified Wisdom?
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Seth A. Bledsoe, Florida State University
Porten and Yardeni’s third volume of Textbook of Aramaic Documents provides a highly regarded edition of the Aramaic Ahiqar narrative and proverbs that has implications for how scholars of wisdom literature incorporate Ahiqar into discussions of personified wisdom. The most intriguing result of the new arrangement centers on Saying 13 (TAD:3 lines C1.1.79 & C1.1.187). The two lines of Saying 13 have traditionally been key for attesting the view that personified wisdom is in Ahiqar. In this new edition, however, the couplet has a very different meaning, and it is not even clear that the two lines should be read in sequence. I argue that the relationship between Ahiqar and the biblical wisdom literature, namely Proverbs, must be reassessed in light of this new evidence. First, I will briefly review how Ahiqar has been used by scholars of wisdom literature, focusing primarily on recent discussion surrounding the figure of personified wisdom. Then, I intend to present in a clear and concise manner the textual issues above, namely the arrangement of the columns and the reconstruction of the lines in question. I will offer some comment on the analysis and interpretation of each line respectively. Finally, I will discuss what can be said about Ahiqar’s relationship to the Personified Wisdom Tradition. It is my contention that personified wisdom cannot be found in Ahiqar.
|
Thaumaturgical Mediation: Conflict Resolution in the Family of God
Program Unit: Psychology and Biblical Studies
Kamila Blessing, Blessing Transitions Consulting and Mediation Services
As previously shown, biblical anthropology defines human being as thaumastos, body and soul. However, throughout sacred history, the families of God have had only one other thing in common: conflict. Conflict is inherent in the sacred history, as God repeatedly chooses the younger child over the older, and invites the Gentiles into the People of God. The result is a continual re-forming of the sacred line, but what of the people who are injured, psychologically and socially, in the process? Does it negate, after all, the basic thaumaturgical makeup of the human soul? We propose that thaumaturgical humanity is also a social healer in God's image, specifically, a mediator. Mediation is an urgent social topic today, with our overloaded courts. Finding a model that addresses essential humanity will be of great consequence. Given that much of our legal system derives from biblical law – particularly regarding family relationships – it is appropriate to look to the Bible for such a model. The Bible does in fact offer such a model, one that is not so much Jewish or Christian as consonant with human nature. Yet legal scholars, while looking for a spirituality to support their work, are largely unaware of the connection. Mediation remains unaddressed as Bible scholarship, as well. A careful but nontraditional analysis shows that the role of mediator is a thoroughgoing aspect of biblical anthropology. This conclusion is paradoxically present in a prevalent misunderstanding of God's own nature: the most complete and accurate translation of "Paraclete" is neither "comforter," nor "judge" (as in the OT), but, in fact, "Mediator." Mediation is not a concession, but a design and gift, as God exercises this role, with a specific twist: God mediates teleologically, not solely to end dispute, but to approach ever closer the ultimate design of humanity, including its social self-healing capacity. A corollary is that the human mediator is never alone in the task. It is an essential aspect of humanity's relationship with God.
|
The 3 m. pl. suffix -mw and Its Implications for Dating Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Yigal Bloch, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
This lecture will take issue with the theory of Early Hebrew Poetry, which holds that some poetic works in the Hebrew Bible – chiefly in Genesis-Samuel – exhibit linguistic features dating the composition of those poetic works as early as the 13th-10th centuries B.C.E. This theory was formulated over sixty years ago by William F. Albright and his followers (mainly Frank M. Cross and David N. Freedman), and the most systematic examination of the linguistic evidence adduced in its favor was carried out by David A. Robertson about forty years ago. Robertson’s study lead him to conclude that of all the linguistic features, claimed to indicate an early date of composition of the poetic sections in Genesis-Samuel, only two are significant for dating: the use of short prefixed verbal forms to signify past situations without the conjunction w-, and the 3 m. pl. suffixed pronoun -mw (-mô/-mû).
Having examined, in a recent article, the chronological distribution of short prefixed verbal forms without w- signifying completed events in the past in Biblical Hebrew poetry, we will turn now to the 3 m. pl. suffixed pronoun -mw. We will point out the probable development of this form from the Proto-Canaanite form of the 3 m. pl. suffixed pronoun, and we will explain why the form -mw is to be considered typologically archaic compared to the more standard forms of the 3 m. pl, suffixed pronoun in Biblical Hebrew: -hem/-h_m and -m. On the other hand, we will enquire into the distribution of the suffixed pronoun -mw in the Hebrew Bible, and we will demonstrate that the use of this form continued at least until the 8th century B.C.E.; consequently, the use of the 3 m. pl. suffixed pronoun -mw cannot be considered evidence for dating any biblical poem to the 13th-10th centuries B.C.E.
|
Methodological Considerations in the Identification of Christian and Manichaean Letters
Program Unit: Papyrology and Early Christian Backgrounds
Lincoln Blumell, Tulane University
With the discovery of Manichaean texts from places like Kellis, Oxyrhynchus, Lycopolis, and Medinet Madi there has been a growing interest in Manichaeism in Egypt in late antiquity. In light of such finds a few recent studies have made attempts to reclassify certain documents as “Manichaean,” which were formerly thought to be “Christian,” since both groups share a number of similarities and tended to identify themselves using similar terminology and vocabulary. This paper will therefore seek to consider the issues that are of central importance in the classification of both Manichaean and Christian texts in the documentary papyri. More specifically, this paper will consider such issues by reference to two fourth-century letters from Oxyrhynchus (P.Oxy. XXXI 2603 and P.Oxy. LXXIII 4965) where a Manichaean context has recently been proposed.
|
Faith and the Historical Jesus: Does A Confessional Position and Respect for the Jesus Tradition Preclude Serious Historical Engagement?
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
Darrell L. Bock, Dallas Theological Seminary
The issue of possessing a hermeneutical point of view is a given in literary studies today. Questions about such a point of view and how it impacts historical work are significant, especially when the topic is the much discussed historical Jesus. My essay shall look at how evangelicals approach this topic, examine the strengths and weaknesses of this way of historical Jesus engagement, and what it offers to historical Jesus studies in general. Examples will come from the recently completed IBR Jesus project volume, Key Events in the Life of the Historical Jesus. WUNT (Mohr/Siebeck, 2009), an international collaborative effort that has been at work over the last decade.
|
Historical Results of the Project
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Darrell Bock, Dallas Theological Seminary
*
|
Personal Afterlife in the Scrolls and the New Testament
Program Unit: Qumran
Markus Bockmuehl, Oxford University
It is well known that Second-Temple Jewish views about life after death are highly diverse, ranging from a mainstream Hellenistic existential pessimism all the way to articulate beliefs about bodily resurrection or even a millenarian renewed Jerusalem.
For the Dead Sea Scrolls, texts like Daniel, Enoch and Jubilees are widely recognized to be among the formative influences on the eschatology (or eschatologies) encountered in the Dead Sea Scrolls. In this short paper I explore the implications of this influence for views about a personal afterlife that surface in these writings and in the New Testament. It will be suggested that the unresolved tension between assertions of belief in a heavenly afterlife and in bodily resurrection is in fact part of a dialectic widely shared in the Scrolls and in early Christianity.
|
Ritual Defecation in OB Mari, Hittite, NB Akkadian, Hebrew, Greek, Aramaic, and Talmudic Texts—Between Metaphor, Symbolic Act, and Ritual
Program Unit: Hebrew Scriptures and Cognate Literature
Daniel Bodi, Paris School of Oriental Studies - INALCO
In ancient Near Eastern literature one finds a number of texts describing ritual defecation. References to acts of defecation are examined in various texts in chronological order: in two Mari OB texts, in a Hittite text, in a NB Akkadian text dealing with ritual practices related to the
Ištar festival, in Hebrew biblical texts, in an Aramaic incantation, in a Greek text from a temple in Athens which throws light on the presence of excrement in temple precincts, and finally in the Mishnah and the Babylonian Talmud mentioning pagan acts of worship implying ritual defecation. Scholars are divided about the way these texts should be understood. Should they be taken simply as metaphors, symbolic gestures or as actual rituals? This article first analyzes the texts where defecation is mentioned and then attempts to suggest which texts should be taken either as metaphors or symbolic gestures and which might refer to definite ritual acts. One has first to determine the meaning of the act of ritual defecation and then trace the transformation of its original meaning and its
reutilization as a metaphor in subsequent ancient Near Eastern literature.
|
Abijah’s Elevated Rhetoric and the Civil War of 2 Chronicles 13
Program Unit: Chronicles-Ezra-Nehemiah
Keith Bodner, Crandall University
Scholars are increasingly devoting attention to the Chronicler’s literary techniques and narrative artistry. A prime site for such analysis is 2 Chronicles 13, and in this presentation I will unfold a reading of this chapter that focuses on issues of plot, character, irony, satire, wordplay, and spatial settings. Since the parallels with Kings are negligible for the bulk of this chapter, it provides a useful test case for such analysis. The two areas that I will mainly investigate are, first, the long speech of Abijah to his northern counterparts in 13:2-12. In this speech from an elevated vantage point, Abijah deploys a host of rhetorical moves designed to impress his audience. There are a number of substantial matters that arise, including the indirect characterization of Jeroboam and the appraisal of northern cultic innovations. The second area of the chapter that I will discuss is the resulting civil war of 13:13-19, itself described in less narrative space than Abijah’s speech. The paper will conclude with an assessment of the broader contribution of this chapter to Chronicles as a whole.
|
Why Would the (So-Called) Deuteronomists Include the Strange Episode of the Old Prophet from Bethel?
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Keith Bodner, Crandall University
By any measure there are some bizarre stories in the Deuteronomistic History, episodes that feature strange characters and unusual plot twists. For instance, in a JSOT article of a decade ago, Thomas Römer has drawn attention to the chilling story of Jephthah’s daughter and postulates a number of possible reasons as to why this story is included and how it was shaped over time. Taking my cue from that intriguing article, I turn to the equally odd account of 1 Kings 13, a chapter that features a torn altar, a withered hand, two unnamed prophets, a bewildered donkey, and a dangerous lion that manifests startling self-control. After the dramatic confrontation with Jeroboam, the story of the man of God from Judah and the old prophet of Bethel in the second half of 1 Kings 13 seems oddly placed at first glance, as it apparently interrupts the Jeroboam narrative. In light of recent debate over the composition of the Deuteronomistic History (and here I am also using Römer’s 2005 book on the subject), it seems that the time is right to investigate this account afresh: what are some possible reasons why this story is included in the received tradition? This presentation has two parts. First, I will survey some recent scholarship on this episode, and include a number of studies that deploy several different methodological perspectives. Second, as the paper draws to a conclusion, I will argue that 1 Kings 13 makes an interesting contribution to the debate over the composition and provenance of the Deuteronomistic History, and I will consider the role of this account both in the Jeroboam narrative (where it is embedded) as well as the larger contours of Joshua-Kings.
|
Too Many Dicks at the Writing Desk, or, How to Organise a Prophetic Sausage-Fest
Program Unit: Prophetic Texts and Their Ancient Contexts
Roland Boer, University of Newcastle - Australia
The key issue for this paper is the role of writing in both the production of and instabilities in prophetic masculinity. I draw upon three sources: the work of Lévi-Strauss concerning the ‘writing experiment’, Christina Pettersen’s exploration of the role of writing in constructing the ruling class in colonial Greenland, and some of my older work concerning the auto-referentiality of references to writing and scribal activity in the Hebrew Bible. Armed with these theoretical strings, the paper has two phases – what may be called ‘organising the sausage-fest’ and ‘too many dicks at the writing desk’. The first concerns the production of masculinity, the second its problems.
So, in the initial sausage-fest I argue that the subtle and over-riding process of producing masculinity in the prophetic books is through the representation of the act of writing – what may be called the act of the spermatic spluttering pen(ise)s. In attributing writing to the writing prophets (Isaiah, Jeremiah and Ezekiel), rather than merely ‘recording’ what they said and did, the scribes write themselves into the story. Not only do scribe and prophet merge into one, with the written and writing prophet acting as a cipher for the scribe, but the scribe easily slips into the zone of absolute power, one in which even God obeys his dictates. No wimps here, no effeminate and weakly scribes (contra Boyarin); writing is the means of constructing a very male ruling class.
However, no hegemony is ever complete, able to rest at peace in its power. In order to examine the way the scribal act of masculine production runs into trouble, I focus upon the anomalies of this constructed coterie of ruling males, the way the scribes themselves threaten to disappear too readily into the stories they created, and idealist fallacy of scribal fantasy. In this case, there really are too many dicks at the writing desk. If the paradigmatic text for the first section of this paper is the challenge to power embodied in Jeremiah 36, the text for the second part is Ezekiel’s eating of the scroll in Ezekiel 2-3.
|
Economic Theory
Program Unit:
Roland Boer, University of Newcastle
Economic Theory
|
Subjectivity and Class in Ezra-Nehemiah
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible and Political Theory
Roland Boer, University of Newcastle - Australia
A key feature of postcolonial analyses of colonial identity is the issue of subjectivity. How is a person constituted as a subject? What are the specific processes that produce subjects? Barely recognised in the ongoing debates concerning subjectivity (from Althusser to Butler) is that the problem itself arose in response to colonialism and anti-colonial struggles from the nineteenth century onwards. The urgent issue was how colonial powers should view colonised peoples, whether they had the full status of citizen-subjects or were, in another use of the term, ‘subjected’ peoples. In light of this background, I argue three points. First, that subjectivity is a conservative question, for it postulates a universality of exclusion (not inclusion), a universal subject based on the exclusion of certain criteria and people. Second, that these patterns of exclusion and identity are codes for class, which slips out of the picture too quickly. Third, that in the case of Ezra-Nehemiah we find not only an effort at producing distinct subjects in a colonial matrix, but also a vicious pattern of subject-class formation that, while giving the impression of an inclusive universal, actually operates via an exclusive universal.
|
Why Was 2 Maccabees Read in the Ancient World?
Program Unit: Function of Apocryphal and Pseudepigraphal Writings in Early Judaism and Early Christianity
Francis Borchardt, University of Helsinki
2 Maccabees presents biblical scholars with a conundrum. It is a very late text that makes no claims to authority, and was eventually kept out of the Hebrew canon. Further, in an appended epistle, it specifically states that it is an epitome (redaction?) of a longer work by Jason of Cyrene. However, despite this less-than-glorious textual history, a significant portion of the diaspora community seems to have accepted this text as authoritative. This paper investigates particularly the evidence of the appended epistle and searches for suggestions of how the sender intended the text to be read and received. Using rhetorical and historical-critical models, we hope to show that unaffected by the recommendations of the epistle's author, the 2 Maccabees gained status that was never imagined for it. This raises questions not only concerning the function of Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha in antiquity, but also about all books eventually accepted into canons.
|
The Book of Judges and Decentralization
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible and Political Theory
Francis Borchardt, University of Helsinki
Though Judges is traditionally read as a work showing the necessity for centralized power under a monarchy, this paper seeks to show that at various points in the text (e.g. Judges 9, 17-18) the narrative is not only hostile to centralization, but gives evidence for solutions that arise outside of central planning. This study will read the pertinent passages in Judges through the lens of Nobel Prize winning economist Friedrich Hayek, particularly paying close attention to his belief in the value of local knowledge and emergent order. It is the aim of this work to show that (perhaps unwittingly) the ancient compiler of Judges proved the validity of such theories.
|
God’s Agent in the Fourth Gospel: Son, Prophet (like Moses?), Messiah, Son of Man, Logos? How Does the Judicial Agency Motif, as Developed in the Fourth Gospel, Cast Light upon the Mission of Jesus?
Program Unit: John, Jesus, and History
Peder Borgen, University of Trondheim
In the Fourth Gospel God is referred to as “He who sent me,” etc. Jesus is seen as being this emissary, but also John the Baptist refers to “the one who sent me.” Another phrase includes those who receive the emissary: “he who does not honor the Son does not honor the Father who sent him,” etc. There may be a chain of agency: “he who receives any one whom I send receives me; and he who receives me receives him who sent me.” Similar and corresponding phraseology and ideas are to some extent found in the Old Testament (LXX), Philo, Josephus, Rabbinic writings as well as in the Synoptic Gospels.
In the Fourth Gospel the authorization may refer to Jesus as Son, Prophet (like Moses), Messiah, the Son of Man, Logos, etc. The perspective ranges from the divine level when Jesus says “I and he who sent me” to the situation when the people were about to force Jesus to make him king, and he withdrew from them.
How can this judicial agency motif in the Fourth Gospel cast light upon the mission of Jesus of Nazareth, as he may have been seen by various people, and even as Jesus may have seen himself?
|
Sennacherib in Judah: The Devastating Consequences of an Assyrian Military Campaign
Program Unit: Warfare in Ancient Israel
Oded Borowski, Emory University
In 701 BCE, in response to a revolt against his throne, King Sennacherib of Assyria paid a hostile visit to the Levant that was recorded in several biblical references, in his annals, and in artistic representations commissioned by him. This paper will examine the consequences of the event as they manifest themselves in the archaeological and textual records concentrating on the devastation brought to the settlements and their population.
|
About Whom Does the Prophet Say This? A Contemporary Model for Preaching the Old Testament
Program Unit: Homiletics and Biblical Studies
Rein Bos, Protestant University of the Netherlands
In this lecture, I focus this question on the songs of the servant of the LORD in Second Isaiah (Isa. 42:1-4; 49:1-6; 50:4-9; 52:13-53:12). The question is: How do we preach on these four poems in a Christian context? First, I set the general stage of the hermeneutical issues involved in the practice of preaching the Old Testament in a Christian context (§ 2-3). Second, I take a look at the way apostles and evangelists apply the four songs of the servant of the LORD in the New Testament. Even though we cannot copy the practice of their hermeneutical and homiletical methods, I still think that their theological attitude and hermeneutical strategies can inspire present day preaching. I will therefore take a closer look at how apostles and evangelists apply these four songs (§ 4-6). And thirdly, I will give some hermeneutical elaborations and some suggestions of how this can work out in the practice of preaching (§ 7-8).
|
Willful Sin or Arrogant Men? The Ethics of Psalm 19:14 in Context
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Travis Bott, Emory University
Psalm 19 extols the glory of God’s creation (vv. 1-7) and praises the moral grandeur of God’s tôrâ (vv. 8-13). It concludes, however, with an urgent prayer in v. 14: “Keep your servant also from zedîm; do not let them rule over me. Then I shall be blameless, and innocent of great transgression.” This verse is crucial for interpretation because it introduces the central moral threat of the psalm: What or who are these zedîm? Both the NIV and the NJPS translate zedîm as “willful sins,” and commentators agree that the rendering “arrogant men” does not fit the context. Therefore, the majority view holds that the primary moral challenge to the psalmist comes from within himself. His own sinful thoughts or inclinations threaten to rule him, but he asks God for correction by means of tôrâ.
In this paper, I argue that the common translation of zedîm and its concomitant ethical understanding are incorrect, maintaining instead that zedîm should be translated as “arrogant men” on the basis of three overlooked contexts—literary, generic, and editorial. First, the following divine epithets in v. 15 (“my rock and my redeemer”) occur in settings of salvation, not instruction. Second, the other tôrâ psalms in the Psalter warn of the moral influence of wicked people, and Psalm 119 in particular uses the term zedîm. Third, the Davidic superscription of Psalm 19 suggests an early construal of v. 14 by linking it with Psalm 18, in which God saves David from his enemies. Thus, while Psalm 19 commends reflection on creation and instruction in tôrâ for individual character formation, its closing prayer also reckons with the moral influence of communities and God’s involvement in the social sphere.
|
Who is the Borrower and Who is the Lender? A Reappraisal of Methodological Considerations and the Legal Formulary at Elephantine
Program Unit: Literature and History of the Persian Period
Alejandro Botta, Boston University
In 1992 Bezalel Porten noted thirty-five legal expressions in the Aramaic documents from Elephantine, to which I was able to add a few more, which have Demotic equivalents. He offered four possible explanations for these equivalents: 1) the Aramaic borrowed from the Demotic, 2) the Demotic borrowed from the Aramaic; 3) both borrowed from a third source; or 4) each evolved independently, if coincidentally. In this paper I offer a wider comparative approach to the complex history of legal terms, legal formulae, and legal clauses that lie behind those Demotic-Aramaic equivalents. Focusing on methodological criteria developed during my own research on Aramaic-Demotic legal interactions, and data from Mesopotamian, West Semitic, and Egyptian legal traditions a very complex picture emerges that precludes uni-directional or simplistic understandings of the dissemination of legal terminology in the ancient Near East.
|
Narrative Christology and the Interpretation of Scripture: The Hermeneutical Gravity of The Lordship of Christ in the Speeches of Acts
Program Unit: Christian Theology and the Bible
Mark Bowald, Redeemer University College
The emerging character of the Church in Acts reflects the character of her risen and exalted Lord. This logic is grounded in Luke’s narrative Christology and his theological interpretation of scripture. Building on recent work on narrative Christology in Luke this paper begins by examining the repetitions and emphases in the transition between Luke and Acts where a hermeneutic intentionality is signaled by Luke and goes on to flesh out how this is manifested materially in the summative narrative Christology found in repetitive aspects of the Speeches in Acts. The Church’s self-definition is thus presented by Luke as reciprocally related to her hermeneutical practices: practices defined by the Christological and inchoate Trinitarian dimensions expressed in the proto-rule of faith of the Speeches. Insofar as this line holds, it is instructive for us in charting a course for our own hermeneutical application of the rule of faith: and from too quickly abstracting or prioritizing either ecclesial practices or dogmatic construction.
|
What Does God Have to do with It? The Problem(s) of Theologically Interpreting Trauma
Program Unit: Warfare in Ancient Israel
Nancy R. Bowen, Earlham School of Religion
The experience of trauma raises the theological question: Where is God in this? The book of Ezekiel is an effort to answer this theological question in regard to Jerusalem’s destruction and exile. However, sometimes the answer may do further harm. This paper explores some of the ethical and theological difficulties of Ezekiel's answer in light of current theories of trauma and PTSD. Among these are blaming the victim and God as abuser and war criminal.
|
Do Translators Always Mean What They Say?
Program Unit: Greek Bible
Cameron Boyd-Taylor, University of Cambridge
Do translators always mean what they say?
A key principle of the Society of Biblical Literature Commentary on the Septuagint (SBLCS) is “translator’s intent.” But to what extent is the meaning of a translation to be attributed to the translator? I shall explore the hermeneutics of translation literature with special reference to Greek Isaiah.
|
Online Biblical Studies: Past, Present, Promise, and Peril
Program Unit: Blogger and Online Publication
Christian Brady, Pennsylvania State University University Park
In this paper I will give a brief (and perforce incomplete) survey of the online biblical studies community including resources for biblical studies, but primarily focused upon the community itself. We will look at the "biblioblogs" and chat rooms, online journals and iTunesU. Finally, we will discuss how online productivity may and may not be considered for promotion and tenure.
|
Visits from Jesus, Angels, and Demons to the White Monastery: The Theory, Practice, and Politics of Discernment of Spirits
Program Unit: Religious World of Late Antiquity
David Brakke, Indiana University at Bloomington
Despite its reputation as a regimented space of sober and austere discipline, the White Monastery in late ancient Egypt was the site for startling and sometimes conflicting claims of divine and/or demonic visitations. Its most famous leader, Shenoute (ca. 348-465), delivered a short address now called "In the Night," in which he recounted his physical combat with a demon. One of very few certainly first-person accounts of such an experience to survive from antiquity, Shenoute’s report legitimated his disciplinary authority within the monastery, even as its details conflicted with and drew from monastic teachings (including his own) about evaluating the appearances of supramundane beings. In a separate incident, another White Monastery monk, whose name has been lost, challenged Shenoute’s leadership and claimed to have seen and spoken with Jesus and to have gazed upon Jesus and his angels. Such experiences legitimated the monk’s criticisms of the severity of Shenoute’s ascetic regime. Shenoute’s response to this challenge, found in the oration "So Listen," countered this compelling message with appeals to monastic tradition, to inherited norms, and to Shenoute’s suffering with an illness.
These two incidents provide an opportunity to investigate the ambiguity of actual experience in spite of extensive theoretical monastic discussion of claims to visionary occurrences. Principles of discernment derived from Athanasius’s "Life of Antony," Shenoute’s "Because of You Too, O Prince of Evil" and "A Beloved Asked Me Years Ago," and the works of Evagrius will form the background to Shenoute’s assessments of his experience and that of the unnamed monk. We can also explore how claims to divine, demonic, or angelic visitations functioned as claims to authority among other norms, such as rules, conventions, and scriptural texts.
|
Cerquiglini's Variance: An Alternate Ontology of Biblical Texts
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
Brennan Breed, Emory University
An examination of methodological introductions to recent text-critical projects reveals that the stemmatic concept of the Urtext still frames scholarly work. In these examples, text critics tend to classify variant readings according to an ethico-ontological hierarchy even in light of the textual pluriformity attested in the Dead Sea scrolls. Since it is clear that biblical texts are the layered products of many centuries of tradition and the result of many creative hands, biblical scholars must jettison their theoretical preference for locating a "pristine" Urtext at one specific point along the complex genealogy of production. Scholars who admit the shortcomings of the Urtext theory, however, continue to find it difficult to conceive of the text as something other than a singular ideal "work." On the other hand, too much reliance on the materialist shift to codicology and bibliography can unwittingly isolate specific manuscripts from their larger traditions of textual production and reproduction. In sum: manuscripts of a given biblical text may exhibit clear differences originating from an early, pre-"final" stage, but these differences between manuscripts do not necessarily sever the relationships between them. How can biblical scholars conceive of the ontology of biblical texts in a way that admits both differences and shared identity without privileging one supposedly "pristine" version? Cerquiglini's work provides a helpful concept for this very problem: variance. Cerquiglini asserts that variance is a part of the identity of any traditional text; rather than positing one particular (or ideal) form as the "correct" text, scholars should note the elements of the text that change over time, and take these changes into account when formulating its identity. Thus, text critics can study the genealogical relationships between manuscripts without creating a reductive axiology.
|
Learning Biblical Hebrew through Images
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Iconography and the Bible
Brennan Breed, Emory University
This presentation describes the procedures and outcomes of a recent pedagogical initiative at Emory University, one which utilizes images from the ancient Near East and the history of biblical interpretation to assist students in memorizing biblical Hebrew vocabulary. Since the 1950s, educational and psychological research has shown that associating images with vocabulary greatly assists in the acquisition of that new vocabulary. The simplest mode of associating word and image is by introducing a picture of an object—-an image of a hand, for example-—alongside the foreign word, here, the Hebrew "yad." As this basic method has proven to be effective, more complex variations of this basic model have also been profitably deployed in foreign language courses as well as in elementary English education. As students use ancient iconography and biblical art as a means to an end (namely, learning vocabulary), they begin to apprehend the historical and cultural context of the Bible as well as the divergent ways that the text has been interpreted in different places and times.
|
“De-Limiting” Midrash
Program Unit: SBL Forum
Marc Bregman, University of North Carolina at Greensboro
Despite various scholarly attempts to define midrash, there seems to be no consensus about precisely what should and what should not correctly be included in the category midrash. In order to address this issue, this presentation begins with a brief discussion of the etymology and evolution of the term midrash, followed by a short survey of what some scholars regard as inner-biblical midrash and midrash in writings of the Second Temple period. In order to clarify what the rabbinic sages period regarded as midrash, various attempts to limit interpretive creativity in the Talmudic period are analyzed. The classical rabbinic view of what constitutes midrash is compared and contrasted to later medieval views. The presentation concludes with a brief discussion of the linguistic status of the loanword midrash beyond Hebrew.
|
Territory and Identity: The Beginnings and Beyond
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Athalya Brenner, Tel Aviv University and University of Amsterdam
*
|
Gesture Mapping the New Testament: Lectorial Performance, Body Language, and the Interpretation of Texts
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Jeffrey E. Brickle, Urshan Graduate School of Theology
In the ancient world, documents were characteristically enacted orally by trained lectors. As with those engaged in oratory, lectors relied upon a variety of conventional gestures to ensure a rhetorically effective delivery. The employment of non-verbal signals by the lector during a performance communicated a visual “text” coterminous with the recited text. This visual text (1) served to evoke particular emotional responses from the audience; (2) underscored and clarified the spoken text, functioning as a quasi-independent interpretive commentary; and (3) in some cases completed the sense of the inscribed text when a lacuna was apparent. Drawing on the works of Roman rhetoricians as well as modern research on gesturing, this presentation will examine a critical aspect of ancient reading which is often overlooked in our silent reading culture: the visual dimension of lectorial performance. It will feature brief prerecorded videos of reenacted performance scenarios of selected, representative passages that present interpretive challenges. By applying the emerging methodology of gesture mapping to specific texts, including Mark’s ending, the account of the Jewish exorcists in Ephesus (Acts 19:13–17), Paul’s apostolic defense (Galatians 1), the disputed seam occurring at 2 Corinthians 10, and John’s response to the exalted Christ vision (Revelation 1:17), we will not only attempt to reconstruct plausible first-century performance scenarios but consider how “restored” visual discourses dynamically interface with corresponding recited texts. For each New Testament passage treated we will offer at least one alternative gesture map in an effort to show how the perceived meaning of the written text may be dramatically altered when accompanied by a different set of non-verbal signals. This exploratory study, which highlights the power and significance of non-verbal language vis-à-vis written texts, is intended to contribute to and further encourage the investigation of lectorial reading in antiquity.
|
"Why Should It Be Thought Impossible, Heterodox, or Improper for a Woman to Preach?” Jarena Lee's Scriptural Interpretive Lens against Paul and Culture
Program Unit: Recovering Female Interpreters of the Bible
Valerie J. Bridgeman, Lancaster Theological Seminary
Jarena Lee, born 1783 to free parents, was arguably the best-known eighteenth century-born female preacher. A Christian convert at 21, she joined the historic Bethel African Methodist Episcopal Church in Philadelphia where Richard Allen served as pastor. Though she announced her call to preach in 1809, it took eight years before she actually began. Her preaching required her to interpret scripture in the face of what appeared as insurmountable scriptural evidence against women preachers. Her two autobiographies give us a glimpse into her “canon within the canon” and her appeal to direct inspiration as source for understanding scripture. In this essay, I examine her apologetics for the call to preach as she describes it in her 1836 biography, The Life and Religious Experience of Jarena Lee. I argue that her appeal to Jesus’ gospel versus Paul’s interpretation is the core of her canon, along with the importance of experience. She is paradigmatic of how women reject dominant interpretation and with authority carve out a spiritual space of their own.
|
Who Can Read Wisdom? The Implied Virtues of the Readers of Wisdom's Narratives
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Richard Briggs, Durham University
Wisdom literature develops a range of portraits of the wise or virtuous
character. One way of assessing such wisdom is to look at the portrait
thereby constructed. But another is to ask after what is being supposed
with regard to the reader who is to be able to read their way towards
such a portrait. This approach to virtuous character in the Old
Testament is particularly suited to the case of OT narratives - and is
the subject of my own book The Virtuous Reader: Interpretive Virtue and
Old Testament Narrative (Baker 2010), as well as being found in the work
of such scholars as John Barton and Gordon Wenham. In this paper I
propose that such an approach might shed light on one of the striking
features of OT wisdom literature, viz its narrative setting, or the way
in which the vast majority of OT wisdom literature is presented in
narrative terms. Rather than ask 'how should one read it?', a
virtue-ethic approach asks 'Who must one be in order to see what it
wants to say?'. The narratives of Job, Proverbs and Ecclesiastes offer
three different portraits of such an implied reader: they range over
such virtues as the willingness to entertain a variety of questions and
perspectives; the desire to grow toward maturity; and the ability to
laugh at the difficulty of holding it all together in one coherent
vision. These virtues are not the subject matter of these wisdom texts -
rather they are implicit in the manner of presentation of the texts. As
such they are 'implied virtues', and perhaps allow us to get closer to
the estimation of what the books commend in practice, rather than what
they wish to be seen to commend.
|
Does Obligation Corrupt the ‘Purity’ of the Gift? Comparing Seneca’s De Beneficiis with Paul’s Letter to the Philippians
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
David Briones, Durham University
Seneca’s De Beneficiis, the major gift-giving treatise of Paul’s day, manifests intriguing — yet to us culturally unnerving — ideals on gift exchange. Particularly discomforting, for a 21st century readership, is the nature and role of obligation. Like most Greek and Roman philosophers, Seneca affirms the presence of obligation as intrinsic to bestowing and returning gifts (e.g., 1.4.3; 2.11.5; 5.11.5). But does obligation play the same role in Paul’s vision of gift giving, specifically in his financial dealings with the Philippian community (Phil. 2:25-30; 4:10-20)? Two opposing views have emerged on the matter. One aligns Paul with Seneca, maintaining that his two-way friendship with the Philippians certainly entailed ‘mutual obligations’ (Peter Marshall). The other envisages a parting of ways with Seneca, insisting that Paul sought to eradicate the Greco-Roman conventions that had skewed their perception of Christian giving (G.W. Peterman). These polarized positions, however, are found lacking. The first view neglects the fact that Paul incorporates God into his monetary relationship with the Philippians, a three-way bond which, by necessity, reshapes the form of their mutual obligation. The second view, on the other hand, suffers from an anachronistic, post-Enlightenment mentality, which deems any kind of obligation a corruption of the inherent virtue within the gift. Therefore, by placing Seneca and Paul in conversation, this paper will attempt to develop a middle-ground position, one that factors God into the relational equation and recalculates the role of Christian obligation. This endeavour will not only draw out the striking similarities between these erudite thinkers but will also uncover the crucial point where they part ways — the essential role of the third party.
|
Tracing Mark’s Origin: Why a Decisive Step Forward Is Possible
Program Unit: Markan Literary Sources
Thomas L. Brodie, Dominican Biblical Institute, Cecil St Upper, Limerick
For several decades the sense of Mark’s text has been moving from clumsy or unliterary (unliterarisch) to literary. This paper presents reasons indicating that a corresponding shift is imminent regarding Mark’s origin: it is largely literary—based on verifiable writings. These reasons come from the recent emergence of greater clarity on several factors: (1) orality, meaning oral rhythm—essentially a feature of all ancient writing, not an indicator of dependence on oral tradition; (2) ancient writers’ methods of composition; (3) Old Testament writers’ methods of composition; (4) New Testament use of the Old Testament; (5) the diversity of methods used in rewriting or transforming texts—unlike most gospel synopses; (6) criteria for judging literary dependence; (7) specific instances of Markan dependence on verifiable writings.
|
Overturning the Divine Decree: Interceding against Foretold Doom in Mesopotamia and the Bible
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Marian Broida, Emory University
Both the Hebrew Bible and Mesopotamian literature contain reflections of human intercessory attempts to overturn portended doom. In this paper I compare the rhetorical strategies in two groups of texts aimed at altering the divine decree: Neo-Assyrian ritual texts called namburbis, and pleas by biblical intercessors to defer, annul, or mitigate divinely-foretold punishment. Many of the namburbis' central prayers share with the biblical material the motifs of divine-human intimacy, the deity as judge, and the doomed party’s vulnerability. But whereas the namburbis laud divine attributes and vow more praise, the biblical prayers tend to stress God’s prior saving acts and promises as well as his current injustice. Besides reflecting generic differences, these distinctions accord with Westermann’s findings regarding Mesopotamian and biblical psalms. The distinction Westermann finds between biblical lament psalms’ declarative praise and Mesopotamian psalms’ descriptive praise appears to hold true as well for intercessory prayers.
|
Reading, Searching, and Blessing: A Functional Approach to the Genres of Authoritative Texts in the Yahad
Program Unit: Qumran
George J. Brooke, University of Manchester
This paper will begin with the three categories of reading, searching and blessing (qr', drsh, brk) as listed in 1QS to suggest that each term reflects an etic approach to authoritative texts that assists in the modern understanding of what the yahad members thought of genre. It will be argued that 'reading' was appropriation rather than verbal repetition, 'searching' was a reflection of hellenistic analogical thinking for ethical purposes, and 'blessing' was a particular performative speech-act in which pastiche permitted a corresponding functional identity formation. In paying primary attention to function, rather than form or content, this paper will open up some alternative possibilities for genre construal for the compositions from the Qumran caves.
|
What is a Variant Edition? Perspectives from the Qumran Scrolls
Program Unit: Transmission of Traditions in the Second Temple Period
George Brooke, University of Manchester
The numerous scriptural manuscripts from the eleven caves at and near Qumran have provided modern readers with evidence of variant readings for most of the books that eventually came to form the Hebrew Bible. In the context of this new SBL group on Variant Editions, the aim of this paper is to ask more precisely how a "variant edition" should be defined. What is any such text supposed to be varying from? Attention will be given to scribal activity, deliberate or otherwise, texts themselves, and the readers and receivers of texts. There will be some consideration of processes of textual formation and transmission, asking about assumptions that may be made about variance by modern scholars. Non-scriptural variant texts will also be mentioned.
|
Rhetoric and Philosophy in the First Century: Their Relation in Relation to 1 Corinthians 1–4
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
Tim Brookins, Baylor University
From the classical era to the present, rhetoric and philosophy have been in conflict. Their opposition has typically been expressed in terms of “words” (form) versus “things” (content), respectively. Since, in antiquity, both of these “arts” laid claim to wisdom (s?f?a), commentators have often understood Paul’s discourse on “wisdom” in 1 Corinthians 1-4 in the context of the Greco-Roman philosophical and rhetorical traditions. The question has been, does the divisive “wisdom” of the Corinthians pertain to form, content, or both? Recently, several important studies have argued that Paul opposed, not philosophy (“content”), or philosophy and rhetoric more generally, but simply Greco-Roman rhetoric (“form”). Challenging some of the assumptions of these studies, the present paper looks anew at the primary sources, seeking to provide a more nuanced “philosophical-rhetorical” framework for interpreting these chapters. From a fresh look at the primary sources, a certain tension arises. It is shown that, on the one hand, rhetoricians and philosophers tended to disassociate from each other, but that, on the other hand, the separation was far from absolute. The basic thesis of the paper, as regards 1 Corinthians 1-4, is that the tendency of certain studies to polarize rhetoric and philosophy, and an inclination towards the rhetorical side, has resulted in a questionable preference for a rhetorical explanation even in places where the evidence may strongly suggest otherwise. The conclusion regarding the relation of rhetoric and philosophy is two-pronged: (1) one must respect the first-century categories (i.e., “rhetoric/rhetorician/sophist” versus “philosophy/philosopher”); and (2) the categories, in turn, must be qualified by the evidence. That is, the categories should be employed, but with the realization that they are artificial, theoretical constructs reinforced in a polemical situation by the most stalwart proponents of each. It cannot be assumed that “eloquent words of wisdom” (2:4) didn’t involve the philosopher.
|
Elements of Stoic-Oriented Declamation in the Parable of the Rich Man and Lazarus (Lk 16,19–31)
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Tim Brookins, Baylor University
Past scholarship has often treated the parable of the Rich Man and Lazarus (Luke 16:19-31) comparatively, seeking to answer questions of origin, composition, and meaning by juxtaposing it with other ancient literature. With a departure from this approach, this paper asks, not questions of derivation and integrity, but rather, how the rhetorical conventions of the day might help illuminate the parable’s meaning in its final form. It is argued that the parable reflects elements of “declamation,” both topically (rich versus poor) and at the level of rhetorical content, and that the parable reflects elements of Stoic (and not precisely Cynic [so, Hock 1987]) philosophy. First, the paper traces a tradition of declamation thoroughly characterized by Stoic philosophy, as represented in the works of the two Senecas. Then, it is shown that the parable shares features of such Stoic-oriented declamation. Specifically, the case is made that the parable refers to the technical Stoic concepts of “good” (??a???), “evil” (?a???), and “indifferents” (?d??f??a) (usually summarized along the lines of “life, health, and wealth, and their opposites, death, disease, and poverty”; Diogenes 7.102), but that Luke dissents from the Stoic definitions of these terms and from the Stoic understanding of what they comprise. Examining the parable along these lines serves to underscore Luke’s teaching on the nature of rich and poor.
|
Jews and Christians in the First Century: Threads of Insight from the Minor Midrashim
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Buzz Brookman, North Central University
The minor midrashim abound with anti-Christian polemics. While the dating of most of these texts is precarious and difficult, there is widespread agreement that these texts may very well carry threads of traditions which go back to the 1st century and earlier. This paper will address examples of early Jewish-Christian relations within the minor midrashim, and particular focus will be brought upon an unusual text entitled Aggadat deShimon Keyfa. This minor midrash presents some unexpected details concerning Jewish-Christian relationships which seem to be set in a context of the first century. This text is one of many minor midrashim included in Micha Joseph bin Gorion’s landmark work, Mimekor Yisrael. Bin Gorion culled together many minor midrashim from popular literature that had circulated in Jewish communities for over a thousand years, and the Aggadat deShimon Keyfa is included in a section of stories which focuses upon persecution in the land of Israel during the Roman period.
|
The Secret History of the Twelve
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
E. Bruce Brooks, University of Massachusetts at Amherst
It is not clear whether the Twelve as we meet them in Mark are a condensed report of something that happened during the lifetime of Jesus, or are emblematic of a later development. I here argue that both are true in a sense, but that neither statement is strictly speaking historical.
What can be said at the outset, with some confidence, is that the mentions of the Twelve in Mark are interpolated; that is, they do not belong to the original Markan narrative. Collation of the canonical and other lists of the Twelve, no two of which are identical, and the evidence from Rabbinic and apocryphal Christian sources, suggests that the Twelve were not appointed at once, but grew by replacement over several years. The list of the Twelve is then indeed emblematic: it is a cumulative summary of a group which at no time consisted of twelve persons; the standard number during the early years of the Jesus movement (and also during the life of Jesus, as reported in the earliest stratum of Mark) appears to have been not twelve, but five.
I conclude that their function was to preach the Gospel of God as formulated by Jesus, beyond the geographical range of Jesus's own preaching. The Twelve fade from view as the center of organization of the Jesus movement shifts from Galilee to Jerusalem (only Peter, James, and John seem to have made that transfer), and as its missionary focus shifts from small towns to major cities; in short, as Christianity goes big time. By the end of the period during which the Gospel of Mark was formed, that is, the middle 40's, it seems that the Twelve were merely a symbolic memory, a memory which was then freely developed by the later Gospel writers.
|
The Position of Jude
Program Unit: Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
E. Bruce Brooks, University of Massachusetts at Amherst
Theologically, Jude belongs to what I have elsewhere called Alpha Christianity: it relies on repentance and good works for salvation, and knows nothing of the Atonement or Resurrection doctrines. Its authorities are orthodox Jewish tradition plus more recent Jewish texts such as Enoch and the Testament of Moses. This doctrinal stance links it with the Epistle of James, which has the same view of salvation, and which only cites Jewish tradition. Jude indeed links itself explicitly to James in its introduction. Its view of salvation is also compatible with that of the Two Ways document which now forms part of the Didache.
Chronologically, Jude refers to James in its author statement, and thus comes after James. The same kind of explicit reference links 2 Peter vertically to the earlier 1 Peter. Besides these two vertical relationships, there are clear lateral relationships. Jude has been absorbed, and in the process somewhat rewritten, in 2 Peter. Another lateral relationship, pointed out by Harnack, is that the evil doctrine denounced in Jude is denounced in similar terms by the author of Revelation. Jude is thus probably contemporary with Revelation, and its area of geographical concern is the same as that of Revelation.
Like the Two Ways, which was absorbed (in rearranged form) into the Resurrection-based Epistle of Barnabas, Jude was incorporated (in revised form) into the Resurrection-based 2 Peter. In both cases, the useful teaching of the original was brought into the context of emerging orthodoxy. In the case of Jude, references to extracanonical works were largely reduced, in 2 Peter, to canonical Old Testament allusions. Separately, the Two Ways tract was extended by baptismal and other catechetical material to make the present Didache. The history of both texts thus ends with one or more absorption phases. This seems to be part of the process by which the eclectic orthodoxy of later ages was achieved, and salvageable parts of heterodox teaching were brought under the orthodox umbrella.
|
Construing Connections: How Contemporary Scholarship Establishes Connections between Didache 9–10 and the New Testament
Program Unit: Didache in Context
Johana Broselid, Lund University
This paper sets out to examine three studies on the meal prayers of Didache 9-10 in order to elucidate and discuss what triggers the interpreter’s specific activity of comparison. “It is indisputable that human beings think (also) in terms of identity and similarity. In everyday life, however, it is a fact that we generally know how to distinguish between relevant, significant similarities on the one hand and fortuitous, illusory similarities on the other.” Umberto Eco, whom is cited, contrasts this everyday comparison with the comparison made by an interpreter of a specific text, suggesting that comparing texts (and/or words) is a practice that allows both significant as well as accidental relationships to be found.
The studies I examine are produced within the last decade, by both biblical and liturgical scholars, J. Schröter, Das Abendmahl; B. Witherington, Making a Meal of It; P. Bradshaw, Eucharistic Origins. My focus will lie on how the scholars compare the Didache 9-10 and the New Testament and how they argue for these specific comparisons. A small sample of connections that have been proposed by the authors may serve to illustrate how Didache 9-10 invites scholars to detect several different relationships: references to Matthew and 1 Corinthians are generally mentioned, but connections to John, James and Jude are also suggested. An examination of how the three scholars establish these connections is intended to illuminate new avenues in the practice of comparison of early Christian texts.
|
The Devil and Disease in the Ancient Judaism
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Derek R. Brown, University of Edinburgh
Among the many malevolent activities charged to the figure of the devil (or Satan) in ancient Judaism was the giving of diseases, illnesses, and other sicknesses to people. At times this is accomplished using demons as agents and at other points no agency involved. This paper will consider this motif in ancient Judaism and, to a lesser degree, in early Christianity. In particular we will be concerned with the following questions: why was the devil associated with the giving of sicknesses and diseases in Judaism? What sort of diseases were given by the devil and to whom did he give them? And what are theological implications for the belief that the devil causes illnesses (e.g., theodicy)?
|
“The Present Evil Age”: Paul’s Hope for the Redemption of all Creation in the Face of Futility of the Creation
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Derek Brown, University of Edinburgh
Paul’s declaration that creation awaits its redemption in Romans 8:19–23 have become something a slogan for NT and biblical ecological and environmental studies, and rightly so given the apostle’s positive affirmation about the goodness of creation and the lasting place of it in the cosmos. At the same time Paul also stresses the inherent evil of the present age (Gal 1:4; cf. 2 Cor 4:4) and the subjection of creation (Rom 8:20). This paper will consider Paul’s negative language on the evilness of “this age” and its implications for understanding the tension of living in an evil age and a world subjected to futility while maintaining hope for the transformation of creation into a “new creation.”
|
Matthew’s “Little Ones” Theology and Subversion of “Us/Other” Categories
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Jeannine Brown, Bethel University
*
|
The Digitization of the Collection in the Department of Manuscripts and Archives of the Institute of Ethiopian Studies, Addis Ababa
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Jeremy R. Brown, Trinity Western University
The Institute of Ethiopian Studies is home to one of the largest and finest collection of Ethiopian materials in the world, combining important Ethiopic manuscripts with an extensive collection of 20th century archives previously unavailable to scholars. Through partnerships with the Hill Museum and Manuscripts Library and the British Library Endangered Archives Programme, the Ethiopic Manuscript Imaging Project has undertaken the project of digitizing, so that the materials can be preserved and made available for research.
|
2 Kings 24–25: A Theological Reflection on Theological Reflection
Program Unit: Exile (Forced Migrations) in Biblical Literature
Walter Brueggemann, Columbia Theological Seminary
This paper, as per assignment, will offer a theological exposition of the narrative of Jerusalem’s “final days.” Attention will be given to the felt inadequacy of the dominant explanatory strategy of “Deeds-Consequences” (Disobedience-Curse). The result of such an analysis is the notice of the shrewd and sustained way in which theological claim and Realpolitik are inextricably interwoven. The “displacement,” per the narrative, requires both theological claim and Realpolitik, and cannot do without either.
|
The Table and Early Judaism I
Program Unit: Meals in the Greco-Roman World
Jonathan Brumberg-Kraus, Wheaton College (Massachusetts)
This paper will propose a set of theses defining the table as a generative locus for social formation in early Judaism.
|
At Babylon’s Table: Reading Jeremiah in the Context of Ongoing Exile
Program Unit: Exile (Forced Migrations) in Biblical Literature
Mark Brummitt, Colgate Rochester Divinity School
The refrain, ‘to pluck up, to plant’ runs through Jeremiah like a double helix of textual DNA encoding the book’s proclamation of exile and return. But while the book may attest to the reality of exile in the present, it can only proclaim return as a reality yet to come. The fulfillment of hope lies beyond the book’s conclusion; the conclusion itself (Jer 52), detailing the destruction of Jerusalem and the patronage of King Jehoiachin in Babylon, however, lies beyond the book proper since it is composed of material from 2 Kings 24-25. Thus Jeremiah is both structurally and textually open-ended: exile is never really brought to a close since the words of planting must give way—for the time being, at least—to replanting elsewhere; the book itself, although held together by the headings words of Jeremiah, and word of Yhwh, contains texts from non-Jeremianic sources. In effect, Jeremiah’s centripetally oriented vision of hope—centered on Jerusalem and in the prophetically mediated word—is challenged by the centrifugal forces of an apparently ongoing dispersal. This paper will consider the deconstructive effects that depictions of life in exile have on the proclamations of a Jerusalem-based restoration. In doing so, it will engage with writers who have studied the relationship between periphery and center (often in terms of the West and the Rest) such as Frederic Jameson, Homi K. Bhabha, and Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak.
|
Which Tabernacle Account? Re-assessing the Text-Critical and Literary-Historical Relationship between OG and MT Exodus 35–40
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
B E Bruning, University of Notre Dame
Throughout the latter section of the Tabernacle Account in Exodus (chs. 35–40), the Old Greek (OG) provides a more concise account of the construction of the Mishkan than the corresponding Masoretic passages present. Developments in recent decades suggest that the translator worked from a shorter Hebrew text; this shorter text also appears to represent an earlier edition of Exodus 35–40 than the edition represented in extant Hebrew manuscripts. The implications for the history of the Tabernacle material in the Pentateuch tend in two directions: (1) the sources and methods of redaction employed to create the Tabernacle Account, as evidenced by this earlier, less “reworked” version of Exodus; and (2) the methods by which subsequent editors produced texts such as MT, SP, and 4QpaleoExodm. The first is often regarded as the province of source- and redaction-criticism, the second as that of text-criticism; but the shorter text attested in OG Exodus 35–40 stands somewhere in the middle of a “transmission-and-reception history” that spans both. Taking Exodus 40 as an example, the paper thus briefly sketches a history from (1) a source recounting only the erection of the Mishkan to (2) its incorporation into the Priestly Tabernacle Account, i.e. as the basis of Exod 40:1-33 (+ Lev 8:6-13) and best preserved in OG, through (3) subsequent processes of editorial harmonization and expansion that result in MT-SP Exodus 40 as the fitting culmination of the Tabernacle Account in the book of Exodus. This “transmission-and-reception-historical” account also highlights methodological implications for text-critical, translation-technical, and source-redactional approaches—especially in relation to one another. Most importantly, perhaps, it recommends the merits of OG Exodus 35–40 as an invaluable resource for recovering and reassessing not only the Priestly contributions to the formation of the Pentateuch but also the literary and textual history of the Pentateuch.
|
Eyewitness Testimony and the Jesus Tradition in Paul: The Sermon on the Mount as the Background to Philippians
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Christopher R. Bruno, Wheaton College
All too often, Pauline and Synoptic scholars seem to live in different worlds, all the while forgetting that their subjects of study did not. Moreover, because of the lack of verbal agreements between Paul and the Synoptics, many dismiss a direct relationship between the two. However, many students of Paul, myself included, comb his letters looking for allusions to the OT based not only on shared language, but also on shared themes and the availability of texts, among other criteria.
Since it is unlikely that Paul knew the Synoptics in their final form, a fundamental difference lies between identifying allusions to the OT and identifying allusions to the Jesus tradition in the Pauline epistles. However, nearly all Gospel scholars would argue for the active transmission of the Jesus tradition during the lifetime of Paul. Some scholars, such as Michael Thompson, have suggested methods for finding this tradition in Paul (Clothed with Christ: The Example and Teaching of Jesus in Romans 12:1-15:3 [JSNTSup 59; Sheffield: JSOT Press, 1991]). However, Thompson and others have not fully reckoned with the possible influence of eyewitnesses to Jesus' career. Whether or not one accepts all of the arguments recently offered by Richard Bauckham, it is likely that eyewitnesses to the historical Jesus were members of the Christian communities throughout the Mediterranean during Paul’s life. Moreover, it is also likely that Paul would’ve heard and interacted with such eyewitnesses.
Therefore, in this paper, using a modified version Richard Hays’ method introduced in Echoes of Scripture in the Letters of Paul, combined with Bauckham’s recent work on eyewitness testimony, I will introduce a new method for finding possible allusions to the Jesus tradition in the Pauline epistles. I will test this method by examining the possible relationship between Philippians and Matt 5, based on the shared themes of joy, suffering, and Christian maturity. Using the criteria of recurrence, thematic coherence, and historical plausibility from Hays, along with the added criterion of eyewitness availability, I will argue that it is possible that the Sermon on the Mount lies in the near background of Philippians.
|
Carrying in the Body the Death of Jesus: The Passion Narratives as Paul’s Model for His Apostolic Self-Understanding in 2 Corinthians
Program Unit: Second Corinthians: Pauline Theology in the Making
Christopher R. Bruno, Wheaton College
All too often, Pauline and Synoptic scholars seem to live in different worlds, all the while forgetting that their subjects of study did not. Moreover, because of the lack of verbal agreements between Paul and the Synoptics, many dismiss a direct relationship between the two. However, many students of Paul, myself included, comb his letters looking for allusions to the OT based not only on shared language, but also on shared themes and the availability of texts, among other criteria.
Since it is unlikely that Paul knew the Synoptics in their final form, a fundamental difference lies between identifying allusions to the OT and identifying allusions to the Jesus tradition in the Pauline epistles. However, nearly all Gospel scholars would argue for the active transmission of the Jesus tradition during the lifetime of Paul. Some scholars, such as Michael Thompson, have suggested methods for finding this tradition in Paul (Clothed with Christ: The Example and Teaching of Jesus in Romans 12:1-15:3 [JSNTSup 59; Sheffield: JSOT Press, 1991]). However, Thompson and others have not fully reckoned with the possible influence of eyewitnesses to Jesus’ ministry. Whether or not one accepts all of the arguments recently offered by Richard Bauckham, it is likely that eyewitnesses to the historical Jesus were members of the Christian communities throughout the Mediterranean during Paul’s life. Moreover, it is also likely that Paul would’ve heard and interacted with such eyewitnesses.
Therefore, in this paper, using a modified version Richard Hays’ method introduced in Echoes of Scripture in the Letters of Paul, combined with Bauckham’s recent work on eyewitness testimony, I will introduce a new method for finding possible allusions to the Jesus tradition in the Pauline epistles. Using the criteria of recurrence, thematic coherence, and historical plausibility from Hays, along with the added criterion of eyewitness availability, I will test this method by examining how the Passion narrative may have shaped his apostolic self understandings, focusing on key parallels in 2 Cor 1:5-7; 4:7-12; and 5:16-21.
|
The Archaeology of the Alabaster Jar: An Intersectional Approach to Mary Magdalene
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Gitte Buch-Hansen, University in Oslo
Some years ago National Gallery in London curated an exhibition called the ”Stuff of Life”. Instead of focusing on the person’s history or the painter’s style and technique, attention was paid to the objects that surrounded the person in the composition. The “Stuff of Life” referred to the narratives that the various objects represented and by which the person wanted to be recognized. In fact, the person could be absent and his-or-her narrative still present. One painting from 1520 illustrated an introverted woman absorbed in a book with an alabaster jar adjacent to her. The painting is just one in a series of paintings from a workshop in Bourges in which the women had themselves represented by Mary Magdalene’s symbol. Decently dressed, they differ from Tizian’s contemporary painting of Mary Magdalene with her hair let down, exposed breast and heavenly upturned eyes.
The two traditions refer to an exegetical conflict about whether Mary Magdalene should be identified with the repenting woman of Luke 7 as claimed by Gregory the Great in his dogmatic narrative of "Unica Magdalena" or with Martha’s contemplative sister. During the 16. century, Mary Magdalene’s figure became the battlefield on which the Church Schism was played out: was Mary Magdalene to represent the Reformation’s ‘Sola Scriptura’ or the pope’s Sacrament of Penitence? Whereas the Counter-Reformation’s Mary represented bodily desire, the Mary of the Reformation became a liberating figure that legitimized women’s intellectual capacities.
Although rejected by modern feminist scholarship as historically incorrect and a literary misreading, Gregory’s "Unica Magdalena" represents an empowering figure to other women. This is the case of the Alabaster Girls, a church based reach-out project working among the sex-workers in Las Vegas. The paper argues that in order to understand the ‘truth’ about Mary Magdalene, an intersectional approach to feminist scholarship is needed.
|
Gender Ambiguity and the Johannine Signs
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Gitte Buch-Hansen, University in Oslo
The Samaritan woman suggests that Jesus is “the anointed” and her testimony causes her fellow-citizens to believe. Yet, having spent some days with Jesus, the Samaritans reject her testimony; their belief in Jesus as the Savior of World is caused by his words. Although Martha believes that Jesus is the “Son of God”, Jesus rebukes her for failing to understand how God’s glory manifests itself. Mary Magdalene recognizes the risen Christ as her teacher. Nevertheless, Jesus warns her not to touch him and sends her to his brothers with the message about his immediate ascent. Apparently, Mary isn’t among the disciples receiving the spirit.
Since John’s women are the first to break Mark’s secret about the Messiah and also to be appointed apostles, feminist exegetes evaluated this Gospel positively. Yet, this valuation fails to grasps the ambiguity of John’s female characters; seemingly, they never enter into the intimate circle of understanding disciples. The paper takes issue with this ambiguity.
John’s secret differs from Mark’s suffering Messiah; instead, the Johannine puzzle concerns the “uplifting and glorification”. All Jesus’ signs and sayings represent this enigmatic event, which I argue refers to Jesus’ translation into the divine spirit. Jesus leaves and unites with the pneumatic Father; and he returns and begets the disciples from above. Cf.20:31, the decoding of the Johannine signs takes place in two steps. Initially, the signs must engender faith in “the Messiah, the Son of God”(31a). This the women grasp. Yet, in order to have “life in his name”(31b), one must also be able to decode Jesus’ signs and sayings ‘spiritually’ as a reference to Jesus’ translation and their own renewal by the spirit. Consequently, the Johannine surplus is ‘impregnated’ with Aristotelian epigenesis: The women provide the ‘synoptic’ matter which the Johannine spirit transforms into the new (male) life.
|
A Marriage of Convenience: Apocalyptic Texts and Cohabitation in the (Pseudo) Epistle of Titus
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Debra J. Bucher, Vassar College
What does a tour of hell from Elijah, copious references to the book of Revelation, and an imminent appearance of the Antichrist have to do with a group of ascetics? Quite a bit, if you read the (Pseudo) Epistle of Titus, a late antique Christian Latin text written to encourage its audience to maintain their solitary ascetic practice. In this paper, I propose that this apocalyptic material, combined with language opposing the cohabitation between ascetic men and women, functions to identify holy and unholy relationships and works to establish the proper social boundaries between the male audience members and women. In the Epistle, all scripture, including material now considered “apocryphal” or “non-canonical,” is written for the ascetic audience who “have ears to hear.” Therefore, the Epistle text should be read as a commentary on how scripture is the instruction and guide for right-living. The Epistle text reveals an additional rhetorical move—through their practice, the ascetics themselves are the sign and the interpretation of the true meaning of the scriptures. By maintaining proper boundaries, the ascetics live a life of purity, which is the correct interpretation of the scriptures. Integrally entwined with the scriptures, they are living symbols of God’s presence and holiness, like the Sabbath and holy tabernacles, required to remain pure, free from Satan and desire. Apocalyptic texts function to reinforce that symbiotic relationship between the ascetic and the scripture by presenting a vivid juxtaposition between two options: the carnal unions with each other or a spiritual union with God. This is the contrast between life in heaven and life in hell, which the Epistle author so vividly outlines in promises of an angelic life in heaven based on John’s Revelation and references to Elijah’s punishments in the underworld. .
|
Writing a Commentary on Septuagint Leviticus
Program Unit: Greek Bible
Dirk Büchner, Trinity Western University
This paper will present some of the methodological choices facing a commentator of the Septuagint. Attention will be given to questions of exactly how one should bring to bear the various facets of classical historical-philological method upon a work that is not compositional. I shall limit my discussion to matters of lexicology, syntax and cultural aspects.
|
"I Am the Image of Your Glory": Exegesis and Intertextuality in a Byzantine Funeral Hymn
Program Unit: Bible in Eastern and Oriental Orthodox Traditions
Bogdan G. Bucur, Duquesne University
At first sight, this line in the Byzantine funeral service invites a connection with Genesis 1:26. However, even though the allusion to the story of creation, Eden, and the Fall is undeniable (and underscored by various other hymns in the same service), this hymn does not speak of the human being as kat’eikôna, but straightforwardly as the eikôn of God's glory. The first step in interpreting this line should therefore be the consideration of another set of biblical references, dealing not with "image" but with "glory." The second step is, necessarily, to make sense of the resulting interpretation within the context of the service's numerous references to creation kat’ eikôna, and within the larger theological context of Byzantine Christomorphic anthropology.
|
The Convergence of Adamic and Merkabah Traditions in the Christology of Hebrews
Program Unit: Mysticism, Esotericism, and Gnosticism in Antiquity
Silviu Bunta, University of Dayton
This paper explores the Christology of Hebrews, particularly of the first two chapters of the epistle, and argues that many features of Jesus reflect an intriguing mixed use of Jewish Merkabah speculations and traditions about the first human, Adam.
|
The Archaeology of Refugees: Case Studies from the Levant in the Iron Age
Program Unit: Warfare in Ancient Israel
Aaron A. Burke, University of California-Los Angeles
The devastation wrought across the ancient Near East by the Assyrian and
Babylonian empires during the Iron Age has received considerable schrift
in Near Eastern studies. Yet, no systematic effort has been made to
assess the archaeological and historical data for what must have been a
tidal wave of refugees that fled opposite these approaching threats, as
is amply documented for modern conflicts. Attention has been focused
instead on the victims rather than the survivors of imperial aggression,
a fact largely due to the historical sources preserved and the ensuing
archaeological inquiry based on these narratives. From the ninth century
BC it is, however, possible to identify examples of likely refugee
communities in the archaeological record and to correlate them with
specific historical campaigns by the Assyrians and Babylonians as they
sought to expand their territories in the Levant. Archaeological data
from sites in Judah, Philistia, and Egypt, for example, taken in
combination with historical-geographical evidence and textual sources
serve as case studies permitting the creation of a set of criteria for
the identification of refugees in the archaeological record that can be
applied to different periods and regions.
|
More New Testament Apocrypha
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Tony Burke, York University
Standard collections of Christian apocryphal texts (CA) limit themselves generally to material believed to have been written within the first to fourth centuries CE. As a result a large amount of non-canonical Christian texts important for the study of ancient and medieval Christianity have been neglected. The More New Testament Apocrypha Project is intended to address this neglect by providing a collection of new editions (some for the first time) of these texts for English readers. The project is inspired by the More Old Testament Pseudepigrapha Project headed by Richard Bauckham and Jim Davila from the University of Edinburgh. Like the MOTP, the MNTA is envisioned as a supplement to an earlier collection of texts—in this case J. K. Elliott’s The Apocryphal New Testament (Oxford 1991), the most recent English-language CA collection (but now almost two decades old). The texts to be included are either absent in Elliott or require significant revision. Many of the texts have scarcely been examined in over a century and are in dire need of new examination. One of the goals of the project is to spotlight the abilities and achievements of English (i.e., British and North American) scholars of the CA, so that English readers have access to material that has achieved some exposure in French, German, and Italian collections. The presentation will discuss the aims of the project, the justification for which texts to include and exclude, the plans for publication, and will solicit suggestions and contributions from fellow SBL scholars.
|
The Excavation and Interpretation of the Late Antique Synagogue at Priene, Turkey
Program Unit: Archaeology of Religion in the Roman World
Nadin Burkhardt, University of Frankfurt am Main
A structure in the west residential area of Priene, Turkey, was identified initially as a church by Wiegand and Schrader in their initial excavation report of 1904. A menorah plaque found at the site led Sukenik subsequently to identify the structure as a synagogue. No further excavation of the synagogue occurred in the century following. The first half of this presentation will summarize briefly the two seasons of excavation work done at the synagogue in 2009–10 by the University of Frankfurt am Main. Initial investigation has shown that the Hellenistic prostas House 24 was radically transformed in the late Roman period with part of it comprising the courtyard of the synagogue building. Two phases of the synagogue have been clearly distinguished: 1) a large east/west-oriented basilica probably without a narthex, and 2) a slightly smaller hall with a narthex to the west and a walled bench along the north wall. The second half of the presentation will reassess the Priene synagogue in light of the fresh archaeological data. There will also be a discussion of published works on the Priene synagogue and what reconsiderations must be made to scholarly understanding of its form and function in light of the new discoveries.
|
Greatness and Excesses in Oracles against the Nations of Prophet Isaiah
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Micaël Bürki, Collège de France
The Oracles against the Nations (ON) describe or forecast the decline and fall of powerful nations. They put forward many causes for this collapse: idolatry, violence, cupidity, or even excesses. This last reason, also described by the Greek word “hybris”, appears in Isaiah in the oracles against Assur (10), Babylon (13-14), Moab (16) and Tyr (23). It consists in elevating oneself beyond one's own rank, in the case of a monarch taking the place of God (himself). By the examination of the vocabulary and the way this theme is introduced in the oracles, this presentation will argue that the theme of hybris is due to a unified redaction including also the final redaction of Isaiah 2. Contrary to the other chapters, the theme of hybris in this chapter is well developed and structures the whole text, interpreting idolatry as a form of hybris. Verses 12-17 enumerate the heights called to come down in the world: cedars, mountains, towers and ships. Those fours entities are not only abstract symbols of greatness. We find them again associated with the four nations taxed with hybris. In those chapters, Assur is like a forest, Babylon is associated with the top of a mountain where she want to dress her throne, Moab is depicted as a tower in ruins, and logically Tyr is symbolized by his ships. Acknowledgment of the close link between chapter 2 and the “hubris redaction” of the ON conducts to reconsider the early dating generally admitted for chapter 2. ON offer very few reference points for dating but there are some other texts where hubris concerns Israelites. Those texts reflect the post-exilic opposition between the community of righteous men opposed to an unfaithful population. Therefore, we should date the “hubris redaction”, and also chapter 2, to this relatively late period.
|
What Is an Elohim? Reflections on Chronicles' Use of the Term
Program Unit: Unity and Diversity in Early Jewish Monotheisms
Joel Burnett, Baylor University
No abstract
|
Zostrianos and Iolaos: A Platonic Reminiscience of the Heracleidae at NHC VIII,1.4?
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Dylan Michael Burns, Yale University
This paper will address the question of puzzling references, on pages one and four of Nag Hammadi Codex VIII, to a certain "Iolaos." What import could the nephew of Hercules have here, in the apocalyptic frame narrative of one of the "Neoplatonizing" Sethian treatises, Zostrianos? The first passage, probably part of the title, is mutilated; the second passage has correctly been translated as a question ("do you think that Iolaos is your father?"), implying that the text's eponymous seer is in the line of Iolaos, and hence the Heracleidae. The paper will contest this implication, arguing that the passage ought to be read as sarcastic, contrasting the Heracleidae with Zostrianos' true spiritual paternity - the seed of Seth. Such a reading is supported by internal literary coherence, extra-Gnostic evidence (Arnobius and Proclus) concerning the personage of Zostrianos, and thematic parallels in Jewish apocalyptic literature. The reading in turn calls into question the purported audience and provenance of the treatise: while Zostrianos has been championed as "Pagan" Gnosis, an "accomodation" of Neoplatonism, and/or an "ecumenical" approach to revelation, the paper will argue that the text's frame narrative is polemical. Deeply Neoplatonic as Zostrianos might be, it also subverts Platonism.
However, this does not explain the choice of Iolaos as the target of the text's polemic. The paper will suggest that the pericope is a reference to Plato, Euthydemus 297b7-d2, in which Iolaos symbolizes capitulation to eristic argumentation. The Gnostic author would hold, then, that Platonizing, without the revelatory aid of an emissary of the Barbelo, amounts to nothing more than sophistry. If this hypothesis stands, NHC VIII,1.4 demonstrates Sethian interest in one of the least metaphysical "middle" dialogues, and is an example of how Sethians related philosophy to revelation.
|
The Christian Schism in Jewish History and Jewish Memory, or: The Parting of the Ways Revisited
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Joshua Ezra Burns, Marquette University
The aim of this paper is to outline a new approach toward assessing the documentary qualities of the earliest surviving Jewish witnesses to Christianity. Since the early nineteenth century, scholars have generally treated the classical rabbinic reference to Christianity as witnesses to the same basic narrative of Christian origins thought to be attested in the early Christian literary tradition. The tendency of Jewish and Christian scholars to weave the rabbinic evidence into the dominant critical discourse on the Jewish-Christian schism culminated in the so-called “parting of the ways” model introduced by Parkes in his 1934 monograph The Conflict of the Church and Synagogue. Although still the dominant historical model, recent challenges to some of the analytical presuppositions supporting Parkes’ theory have cast doubt over its continued viability. Of particular interest to the present study, several scholars (e.g., Kalmin, Boyarin, Schremer) have persuasively demonstrated the anachronism of imposing Parkes’ model upon rabbinic texts evincing no clear distinction between the ideas of Jewish and Christian identity. Consequently, the critical value of these texts as witnesses to the schism between Judaism and Christianity is no longer self-evident. It is with this observation in mind that I would like to revisit the question of how the authors of the early rabbinic tradition perceived the developments that would ultimately contribute to the schism. Where most surviving Christian media of the period construe the emerging divide between Jew and Christian as a confrontation between competing theologies, the early rabbinic sages, I argue, knew or cared about Christian belief only insofar as it affected the ability of its adherents to identify as Jews. As such, the earliest surviving Jewish witnesses to Christianity can be said to speak to different concerns than those underlying the conventional narrative of Christian origins without surrendering their intrinsic documentary qualities by comparison. While not a functional alternative to the Parkes’ model, I believe that the proposed historiographical approach offers a means of recovering the classical Jewish epistemology of Christianity and therefore represents a vital contribution to current discussion of the Jewish-Christian schism.
|
The Gospel of Jesus: Stanton, Biography, and the Genre of Matthew
Program Unit: Matthew
Richard Burridge, King's College London
This paper, offered in tribute to Graham Stanton, traces the theme of the biographical genre of Matthew’s gospel as a constant concern throughout his life’s work.
Stanton’s 1969 doctoral thesis, published as Jesus of Nazareth in New Testament Preaching (SNTS MS 27, CUP 1974) was the first voice of protest against the critical consensus since Bultmann that the gospels were not biographies. Early Christian interest in Jesus’ earthly life for their preaching meant that the gospels would have been considered ‘biographical’. This interest in the literary genre of the gospels continued through his 1978 Inaugural Lecture as Professor of New Testament at King's College London, and on into his particular interest in Matthew. The first edition of his The Gospels and Jesus (OUP 1989) drew attention to some features of the gospels, especially Mark, which would have puzzled readers familiar with ancient biography. However, in his later writing on Matthew and in the second edition of The Gospels and Jesus (OUP 2002), Stanton admitted that he had been ‘too cautious’ about this assessment. In A Gospel for a New People (T & T Clark, 1992), he devoted an entire section to ‘Genre’, discussing Matthew as an ancient biography, providing a social legitimation for a wider audience than just Matthew’s community. His other interests in the codex as a vehicle for ‘The Fourfold Gospel’ (NTS 1997) and in early Christian papyri led him to conclude the final chapter of his last major work, Jesus and Gospel (CUP 2004) with a study of ‘what are the gospels?’ to demonstrate the literary qualities of these texts.
I will conclude that Graham Stanton’s own devotion to ‘the gospel of Jesus’ led him to dedicate his life to demonstrating how the gospels portray this biographical account of Jesus’ life to bring life to others.
|
Ethical Readings of Romans 8: Compassionate Attention or Liberative Action in a Groaning World
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Presian Burroughs, Duke University
After a preliminary explanation of terms employed, this paper evaluates four interpretations of Romans 8:18-23 and their ethical implications for human life in an ecologically-fragile world. The attempt is made to understand the factors at work in the interpreters’ exegetical and theological decision-making. Attention is given to the interpreters’ definitions of Paul’s terms, the interpreters’ arguments about what “symbolic worlds” or interpretive contexts are supposedly at play in Paul’s reasoning, and the interpreters’ depictions of the wider literary and theological contexts that give shape to this passage. By drawing on the methodological strengths and exegetical insights of the four interpretations, the paper will conclude with an eco-ethical interpretive proposal and a few recommendations for future study.
|
Genre Transformations in the Nehemiah Memorial
Program Unit: Chronicles-Ezra-Nehemiah
Sean Burt, North Dakota State University
The site of a once-lively debate, research on the question of the genre of the Nehemiah Memorial (NM) has in recent years come to a quiet halt. This line of investigation has died out in large part due to a solidifying consensus that NM is a composite text and therefore cannot belong to any single genre. Recent developments in genre theory, however, help to point a way forward beyond treating genre as a primarily classificatory exercise, and this paper accordingly begins from the standpoint that a mixture of genres presents a starting point, not a dead end, for the study of genre. Specifically, this paper argues that NM makes primary use of two literary genres. At its outset, the narrative unfolds as a novelistic court tale (such as Daniel, Esther, and Ahiqar). NM resonates with the court tale genre even when Nehemiah departs Susa for Jerusalem. Through the course of the story, however, the reader can discern a slow, even deliberate, transition to a biographical or memorial genre, characterized by NM's distinctive refrain of "Remember me". Further, this paper argues that this change is signaled by a subtle, yet decisive, shift in the ideological underpinnings of the keywords tob and ra', whereby Nehemiah's drive to seek the welfare of the people and reduce evil perpetrated against the city becomes a set of appeals to credit his account for combatting his own people. This transformation builds upon some important similarities between the two genres but ultimately creates a text that frustrates the generic expectations established in the first half of the narrative. In NM, the courtier who promises to be the intercessor for Judah and manipulator of foreign power transforms into the governor who represents the source of power as the face of Persian Judah.
|
Why Am I Speaking to You in Greek? How Is It Not Only Helpful but Also Important (Delivered in Greek and English)
Program Unit: Applied Linguistics for Biblical Languages
Randall Buth, Biblical Language Center, Israel
[[The SBL program software does not yet accept unicode. The Greek part of the presentation will be available online before SBL, at http:SBLALBL.wordpress.com]]
After a 5 minute introduction delivered in Koine Greek, I will discuss how having to present my thoughts orally in Koine Greek has enhanced my Greek reading skills and has helped me to gain a better grasp of certain aspects of the language. This may be anecdotal evidence that cultivating an oral fluency in Koine Greek may be an important component for making advances in our knowledge of Koine Greek. More studies on this are justified.
|
Audiovisual Report from Hebrew Teacher’s Immersion Pedagogy and Fluency Workshop at Fresno Pacific University
Program Unit: Applied Linguistics for Biblical Languages
Randall Buth, Biblical Language Center, Israel
In Fresno, 4 June to 13 June, 2010, a workshop was held for Hebrew
teachers with a focus on developing oral fluency and oral pedagogy for
Biblical Hebrew classrooms. The audiovisual report will cover the
sessions, illustrating some of the gap that must be addressed by
teachers who may wish to use oral-aural pedagogies in a classroom.
Some of the questions are similar to those about Greek, as to the
usefulness, efficiency, and desirability of oral-aural pedagogy for
Biblical Hebrew. Other questions are specific to Biblical Hebrew
because of its closed corpus, relative paucity of extra-canonical
materials and relatively tight connections with other dialects of
Hebrew.
|
By the Waters of Colossae: Honoring the Repair of the Baths
Program Unit: Archaeology of Religion in the Roman World
Alan H. Cadwallader, Australian Catholic University
The ancient site of Colossae is not overburdened with discoveries of material evidence that might help us to understand the fortunes of the city in any historical period. The site has never been excavated. To date, twenty-six inscriptions have been published. These might be expanded beyond thirty if one adds Byzantine lead seals belonging to ecclesiastical and civic officials of Chonai. Accordingly the discovery of a new inscription of some length is to be prized, especially for what it might tell us of the Roman Imperial period and earlier. The paper offers a full transcription and critical analysis of a 37 line inscription which honors Korumbos for the repair of the baths at Colossae. The inscription is important for its disclosure of valued architecture, the pattern of public honors and the revelations that come from 66 names that are inscribed on the columnar bomos. Most significant, though open to potential contestation, is the ornamentation and possible dating that have been included on the white marble stone. Not only does this have the potential to deliver a precise time for analyzing the significance of the inscription but it also provides further clues to the religious and cultural landscape of the city and its surrounding environment.
|
Reception History: Theory and Practice in the Blackwell Bible Commentary Series
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Mary Chilton Callaway, Fordham University
A common thread in some reviews of the Blackwell Bible Commentaries is the question, as one recent reviewer put it, “of the ultimate purpose of the sort of reception history that one finds here.” As part of the panel on the Blackwell Series, this presentation will engage the question raised by some reviewers as a way to explore the broader implications of reception history. The presentation begins by offering an overview of the assumptions of critical theory and theological method that generally undergird the project of reception history of the Bible. It then offers for discussion some observations on unspoken tensions in the methods being developed and used. Finally, two specific ways in which awareness of theory can inform practice will be proposed.
|
The Recognition Formula and Ezekiel’s Conception of God
Program Unit: Book of Ezekiel
Dexter E. Callender Jr., University of Miami
The ‘recognition formula’ and related expressions present one way by which the prophet constructs his understanding of God. The puzzling nature of these texts has been construed as “portray[ing] YHWH as a deity with an ego problem” (Habel 2004). Joyce more soberly assesses such texts as signifying a ‘radical theocentricity’ (Joyce 1989, 2007). Proceeding from Joyce’s concept of radical theocentricity, this paper will explore the Ezekiel’s sensibilities regarding the nature language and symbol in establishing his conception of God. I will explore how emphasis on the name of God is expressive of concern with the linguistic dimension of the problem. I will also discuss how the frequent evaluation of the name as “holy” or “profane” further engages the name as linguistic symbol. Finally, I will investigate the significance of how Ezekiel frames his construct within the context of destruction and deliverance through an analysis of other relevant biblical traditions – particularly the Divine Warrior tradition, name theology, and kabod theology – to demonstrate Ezekiel’s ultimate interest in creating a God who is no mere abstraction—a potentially lifeless linguistic construct—but a matter of vital, orienting experience.
|
Secondary Characters Furthering Characterization: The Depiction of Slaves in the Acts of Peter
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
Callie Callon, University of Toronto
The portrayal of slaves within the Acts of Peter has to date gone almost completely uncommented upon. Rather than evincing any interest to undermine or contest the assumptions of the Roman elite pertaining to status in general and slavery in particular, the Acts of Peter appears to share this perspective. As such, re-contextualizing the depiction of these characters within the ideology of slave-owning antiquity reveals significant implications for how other characters in the work would have been perceived by its early audience. Examination of legal, literary, and documentary evidence pertaining to slaves in antiquity suggests that these secondary characters contribute more to the narrative than is perhaps immediately clear in a contemporary reading of it. In this paper I argue that the portrayal of slaves in their interaction with more predominant figures in the narrative is crafted by the author to enhance the characterization, both negatively and positively, of the work’s two central figures: to bolster the positive depiction of Peter, and to sharply underscore the negative characterization of Simon Magnus.
|
“The Lord Opened Her Heart”: The Adoption of the Outsider in Acts 16:13–15
Program Unit: Construction of Christian Identities
Teresa J. Calpino, Loyola University of Chicago
An important component of the study of The Acts of the Apostles is the construction of a religious and social identity for Christianity over against other groups through the use of insider/outsider language. Through the course of the narratives, ambiguous groups are either pushed into the category of “other” or adopted into the “we” of insider group. This type of language has mainly been used with reference to “the Jews” as the group most directly and vehemently opposed to the growth and spread of Christianity. However, there is one group within Judaism that does not get painted with this same negative brushstroke, the God-worshippers/fearers—those Gentiles who are not fully converted to Judaism but still adhere to at least some of its tenets and practices. Although this group lay on the fringes of Judaism, according to six stories in Acts it is this very group that is found to be most fruitfully converted to Christianity. In the story of Lydia (16:13—15) Paul does not approach the leading citizens of Philippi, nor even the Jews in the established synagogue, but he instead goes outside the gates of the city and finds a foreign woman who as a sebome,nh to.n qeo,n represents the boundary line between Gentile and Jew. While Lydia may begin the narrative represented as an outsider, through the direct intervention of the risen Christ who “opens her heart (a unique phrase within the biblical text),” she ends the narrative as a baptized member of the Philippian Christian community. Then, when Paul accepts Lydia’s hospitality, the division between the two dissolves and they become a “we” within the cult of the risen Christ.
|
“People of Athens”: Paul’s “Tragic Way of Thinking” in Acts
Program Unit: Formation of Luke and Acts
Teresa J. Calpino, Loyola University of Chicago
The study of the relationship between the speeches of classical orators and the speeches of Peter and Paul in The Acts of the Apostles is well trodden ground, but in most cases this has led to an analysis of the formal rhetorical features in the text in order to make claims about the relative skill of the author or the historical reliability of the contents. On another front, recent trajectories in the study of Demosthenes’ most famous speech De Corona eschew such discussions and instead attempt to explain the successful reception of the speech through a technique labeled as a “tragic way of thinking,” borrowed loosely from epic poetry. This method offers a possible alternative to understanding the speeches in Acts. The “tragic way of thinking” does not seek to employ the techniques of classical tragedy, but instead calls upon the commonly held and beloved traditions of the community/audience in order to demonstrate the necessity of actions that may on the surface appear to be failures. So too in Acts, Paul is a missionary who meets with uneven success and whose life ends in arrest and imprisonment—an apparent failure—but his speeches both call upon Christian traditions and defend his actions on behalf of the gospel as noble and necessary. This paper will use literary-rhetorical techniques to explore the points of contact between de Corona and Paul’s speeches and how this affects his characterization in the latter portion of Acts. This particular lens suggests that the Paul of Acts is not being portrayed as a martyr or suffering figure, but heroically, and his noble actions and cause are commissioned by God but misunderstood by the world.
|
Defective Deponency? A Review of the Discussion so far
Program Unit: Biblical Greek Language and Linguistics
Constantine Campbell, Moore Theological College
TBD
|
Future Directions for Greek Verbal Aspect
Program Unit:
Constantine Campbell, Moore Theological College
Future Directions for Greek Verbal Aspect
|
The Psalmic Lament in the Synoptic Gospels: Beyond Thematic to Theological Understanding
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
D. Keith Campbell, Southeastern Baptist Theological Seminary
Since Herman Gunkel’s delineation of the lament in 1933, exploration into the OT psalmic lament has broadened significantly, practically forming a field of study in and of itself. As lament studies gained steam, NT scholars began noting and investigating the references to this genre in the Synoptic Gospels. These scholars (such as C. H. Dodd, Barnabas Lindars, Joel Marcus, and others) primarily emphasize thematic trends shared between the psalmic laments and the Synoptics and/or investigate the histories “behind” the Synoptic texts. That the Synoptic writers parallel Jesus’ Passion with themes found in the lament literature is practically unquestionable. What has only been recently explored by Stephen P. Ahearne-Kroll, however, is the degree to which Mark understood the core theological function of the lament genre.
Ahearne-Kroll’s insightful monograph ("The Psalms of Lament in Mark’s Passion," SNTSMS 142, 2007) argues that Mark, aware of how the psalmic lament functioned, appropriated it in his narrative by portraying Jesus as, among other things, the Davidic lamenter par excellence. In this paper, I substantiate Ahearne-Kroll’s demonstration that Mark recognized the core theological function of the psalmic lament by more narrowly focusing on this issue and by more specifically defining/applying a methodology for the task. I then build upon Ahearne-Kroll by exploring the degree to which Matthew and Luke recognized Mark’s appropriation of the core function of the psalmic lament. In essence, I conclude that Matthew recognized and appropriated Mark’s understanding of the psalmic lament while Luke did not. This conclusion validates an extension of Ahearne-Kroll’s work on the theological role of the psalmic lament in Mark's gospel to an investigation of the theological role of the psalmic lament in Matthew's gospel.
|
Participation in the Covenant or Participation in Christ? - The Rationale for Gentile Identity in Paul
Program Unit:
William S. Campbell, University of Wales Trinity St. David
*
|
"My Horses Are Your Horses. . ."
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Deborah Cantrell, Vanderbilt University
Jehoshaphat, King of Judah, ruling in the ninth century b.c.e., is credited with offering to share his army, particularly his chariotry, with the King of Israel to further his expansionist goals in areas east of the Jordan River. His slogan, “My horses are your horses. . .” is roughly contemporaneous with the prophet Elisha’s visions, real and imagined, of the “chariots and horsemen of Israel,” always portrayed as a serious threat to enemy armies. What do the archaeological and architectural records of ancient Israel and Judah reveal about the strength of their equestrian forces during the Iron Age? How large was the chariotry of the combined armies of Judah and Israel? Where were the horses stationed and trained? Does the archaeological record support the textual evidence for the existence of “chariot cities” in Israel and Judah? How did chambered gates and tri-partite pillared buildings enhance the horse processing capabilities of Iron Age fortresses? This presentation will address these questions and explore the archaeological and textual evidence for horse compounds at various sites, such as Megiddo, Jezreel, Hazor, Beersheba, Gezer, and Lachish.
|
Sacramentality and Anti-Judaism in Twelfth and Thirteenth Century Interpretations of Galatians 3:28
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Aaron Canty, Saint Xavier University
Galatians 3:28 is not a profoundly formative verse in early or medieval Christianity, and yet a variety of interpretations of this verse exists. At times all three binary opposites (Jew/Greek, servant/free, and male/female) are treated equally; at other times one set of opposites receives greater attention. In twelfth-century Latin exegesis, the one set of opposites that receives the greatest attention is the Jew/Greek opposition, and in several places an explicit or implicit anti-Judaism emerges. The Glossa Ordinaria and Peter Lombard, for example, express concerns about “judaizing.” In the thirteenth century, however, commentators seem more irenic and tend to situate the content of verse 28 within the larger sacramental context in which these binary oppositions are situated. This sacramental context equalizes the opposites on account of their assimilation to Christ’s death in baptism. This paper will explore the exegetical emphases elicited by this verse as articulated by such sources as the Gloss Ordinaria, Peter Lombard, Baldwin of Ford, Robert Grosseteste, Hugh of St. Cher, and Thomas Aquinas.
|
Parallels Between Elephantine and Leontopolis: Some Preliminary Observations
Program Unit: Literature and History of the Persian Period
Livia Capponi, Newcastle University (UK)
This paper will analyse the parallelism between the life of the temple of Elephantine and the foundation, or re-foundation, of the Jewish temple of Onias at Leontopolis in the Maccabaean period.
|
Appeals to Sensory Experience in Apocalyptic Vision Reports
Program Unit: Senses, Cultures, and Biblical Worlds
Greg Carey, Lancaster Theological Seminary
By definition, the ancient Jewish and Christian apocalypses relate the narrative of a mystical experience. To their visionaries the apocalypses attribute experiences related to vision, audition, tactile sensation, taste and smell. Some report preparatory experiences such as journeys, fasting, and prayer. Scholars debate whether these reports relate authentic mystical experiences or simply represent a literary convention. Setting aside that question, this paper investigates the sensory dimension of vision reports in rhetorical terms, assessing such appeals to sensory experience as strategies to move or persuade their audiences. The present author has already investigate how the experiences of apocalyptic visionaries contribute to their ethos, or rhetorical authority; meanwhile, the visual and auditory dimensions of apocalypses represent their core content. Therefore, this paper emphasizes the role of tactile sensation, taste, and smell in the vision reports.
|
Instruction, Research, and the Future of Online Educational Technologies
Program Unit: Blogger and Online Publication
Robert R. Cargill, University of California-Los Angeles
Social media, blogging, and online collaboration technologies are changing the way the world communicates. Likewise, the rise of for-profit and online university instruction is drastically changing the way information is disseminated. Unfortunately, the academy has fallen woefully behind in adopting these technologies for the benefit of educational instruction and research. This paper surveys new technologies available to educators and makes recommendations about how the academy can benefit from innovations in peer-review, collaboration, crowd sourcing, student research, and public education. Recommendations are also offered to universities seeking to balance online and distance education with their traditional university classroom offerings and the overall university experience.
|
Paul’s Areopagus Address in Sophistic-Literary Perspective
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
Ryan Carhart, Claremont Graduate University
When Paul’s apologia before the Areopagus in Acts 17 is considered within the rhetorical textures of literary self-presentation within sophistic literature, the pericope offers a strategic staging of Paul in a highly symbolic location that serves to construct the cultural capital for this pivotal character within Acts’ narrative. Lucian, for example, uses the Areopagus in The Double Accusation and Athenian philosophy in The Dead Come to Life, or the Fisherman as strategic settings to compose literary apologiai that rhetorically and symbolically construct his paideia, parrhesia, and authoritative positioning in relation to his detractors. The author of Acts likewise uses this strategic location as an opportunity to mimetically develop the paideia, parrhesia, and symbolic authority of Paul, and present him as the idealized representation of Christianity in Acts. This sophistic portrayal of Paul, however, can be seen as subversive towards Hellenocentric constructions of authority and paideia (as is the case with Lucian). As the author of Acts trades off the authority of an inscribed notion of “Greekness” associated with classical Athens, he at the same time deconstructs and subverts the authority of this construction by citing an alternative locus of authority, cultural capital, and knowledge of the divine, namely the Hebrew Bible. Through a Socratic staging of Paul in Acts 17, the author of Acts both reifies and subverts normative classical narratives of Greek superiority by imitating and inserting the narratives from the Hebrews Bible into the conversation of proper religiosity. In this capacity, this pericope displays Acts’ imbrications with the cultural discourses surrounding authority, identity, and canonical notions of the past characteristic of Second Sophistic discourse.
|
Eschatological Viticulture in 1 Enoch, 2 Baruch, and Papias
Program Unit: Function of Apocryphal and Pseudepigraphal Writings in Early Judaism and Early Christianity
Stephen C. Carlson, Duke University
In the words of the psalmist, “wine gladdens the heart of people” (104:15), and viticulture—the art and practice of growing grape vines—was of central importance in the ancient Near East. It should then come to no surprise that viticulture in the eschaton would also be important. This study looks at three of the most prominent instances of eschatological viticulture in early Judaism and Christianity, namely 1 Enoch 10.19, 2 Baruch 29.5, and Papias in Irenaeus, Adv. haer. 5.33.3, paying particular attention to their tradition histories and intertextual relationships. All three of these texts imagine that the grape vine will be fantastically productive in God’s renewed creation, but they develop this image in different ways based on different biblical texts. First Enoch uses the trope in conjunction with its use of the account of Noah’s renewal of the earth after the Flood in Gen 9. Second Baruch uses it to present an eschatological banquet feasting upon the primordial beasts of Leviathan and Behemoth in a return to the paradise of Gen 2. Papias, in contrast, applies the trope to the Blessing of Isaac in Gen 27. Though these accounts are all different in their application, they all feature the same sensibility: what gladdens the heart in this world will also gladden the heart in the age to come.
|
Deuteronomy as Orientation Point for the Formation of the First Books of the Bible
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
David M. Carr, Union Theological Seminary
From the time of De Wette onward, Deuteronomy has served as an orientation point for study of the formation of the narrative books of the Bible. Recent years have seen that role complicated, as scholars have disagreed about the development of Deuteronomy itself and its relationship to the books that precede and follow it. This paper responds to some of these perspectives, offering a renewed defense of Deuteronomy (in its various layers) as an orientation point not only for study of the formation of the first books of the Bible, but also as an orientation point for the scribes themselves responsible for that formation. In the process it will present reasons for supposing that many of the oft-discussed proto-Deuteronomic/post-Deuteronomic elements of the non-Priestly Tetrateuch largely post-date corresponding layers of Deuteronomy and represent ways in which narratives now found in the non-P Tetrateuch were coordinated with Deuteronomy and (at least) Joshua.
|
Religion, Religiosity, and Paul's Letter to the Galatians
Program Unit: Psychology and Biblical Studies
Marion Carson, International Christian College
J.L. Martyn has suggested that Paul, in his letter to the Galatians, is arguing against religious tradition rather than Judaism. At first sight, this may seem to be an answer to the problems of disunity which the letter seems to foster. However, psychological studies have suggested that religion and religiosity are important components of what it is to be human. In this paper we will look again at Martyn's understanding of Paul's dualistic language and, using ideas from Allport's psychology of religion as a hermeneutical lens, suggest that this letter, rather than polemicising against religion in general, is arguing for a more mature religiosity in which flexibility and tolerance are acceptable, and unity easier to maintain.
|
Acts 8:26–40 and the Secret Tradition of African American Biblical Interpretation: (Re)viewing the Ethiopian as Intellectual
Program Unit: African-American Biblical Hermeneutics
Arthur Carter, Vanderbilt University
This paper uses Acts 8:26-40 as a mental springboard to reflect on the historical role
of the scholar in African American Biblical interpretation. While the brush arbor
and non-Academic Biblical interpretation is a vital part of the history of AABH, there
is a danger of erasing the scholar and social elite from the tradition of AABH. While
African Americans were long excluded from the Academy of Biblical Studies, there is
also a rich tradition of intellectual and scholastic Biblical engagement. One need
only consider the Biblical imagery in David Walker’s nineteenth century, “Appeal” or
W. E. B. DuBois’ early twentieth century Souls of Black Folk to recognize the
importance Biblical interpretation played among Black intellectuals. As one of the
first Black classicists, William Sanders Scarborough (1852-1926) was the first
African American to join the Modern Language Association, and the third member o
to join the American Philological Association. On various occasions Scarborough
discussed the role of Biblical history and interpretation for Black people. These
three African Americans occupied privileged social positions compared to African
American masses, and yet, their scholarship critically engaged their respective
audiences and articulated a particular social and liberative dimension of Biblical
imagery and Christian responsibility.
|
About Oxen and Asses: Variations on a Common Theme in Early Christian Art
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
David R. Cartlidge, Maryville College
It is common knowledge among scholars who come to early Christian art by way of the text that the ox and ass at scenes of the Nativity of Christ are reflections Pseudo-Matthew 14 (or vice-versa) and that Isaiah 1:3 underlies the presence of the animals in text and visual art. On the other hand, many art historians argue that it was common that images on children's sarcophagi contained animals and that this was the leading cause of such images in the nativity scenes in early Christian art. We will discuss this. What is more important, however, is that we try to discern what the early artists did with the animal's images--there is theology in images.
|
Prophecy and the Single Man: Marital Status and Gender in Jeremiah and Ezekiel
Program Unit: Prophetic Texts and Their Ancient Contexts
Corrine Carvalho, University of Saint Thomas
While great attention has been paid to the use of gendered metaphors for God and the city in both Jeremiah and Ezekiel, there has been less discussion of the fact that both books use the prophet’s marital status as an essential element in their presentation of the personae of these two prophets. For both of them, “wifelessness” is a prophetic sign. In light of recent work on the construction of masculinity in the ancient near east, this paper will explore the function of the prophet’s marital status as a rhetorical device within their prophetic texts. It will be shown that this characterization of both prophets extends each book’s gendered rhetoric in distinctive ways.
|
Martyrs and Memory in Late Antiquity
Program Unit: Memory Perspectives on Early Christianity and Its Greco-Roman Context
Elizabeth Castelli, Barnard College
Abstract to be made available by date of meeting.
|
“You Shall Not Abhor an Egyptian”: The Rabbis and Origen on Pharaoh’s Nation
Program Unit: Social History of Formative Christianity and Judaism
Michael T. T. Castori S.J., Santa Clara University
This paper addresses what constitutes an anomaly for the received tradition of “universalism” as a basis for distinguishing early Christianity from Rabbinic Judaism. Comparison of Origen’s Homilies on Genesis and Exodus with two broadly contemporaneous midrashic commentaries on the same biblical texts, Genesis Rabbah and the Mekhilta of Rabbi Ishmael, finds the Church Father conveying a more negative portrayal of Egyptian identity and moral character than his Rabbinic counterparts. The contrast is particularly noteworthy in the texts’ characterizations of the Exodus, the very narrative of the people of Israel’s separation from Egypt, for here Origen’s Egypt becomes the moral and spiritual antithesis of Israel, while the Rabbis repeatedly problematize such an opposition. The contrast, it will be argued, rests not simply in Origen’s application of allegory and typology to narrative, but also in the immediacy of pagan Egyptian belief and practice, from which he sought to distance his audience. The Rabbinic commentators, not sharing Origen’s concerns, but rather that of calling their community to close observance of Torah, apprehended and expanded on the dialogue over Israel’s election and distinction from the nations implicit in the biblical text itself. In the end, the Alexandrian Origen, born of Greek and Egyptian parentage, fails to allow Pharaoh the smallest measure of decency that even his fellow allegorist Philo had granted (“a tender love for his daughter”), while the Sages set about humanizing the very King of Egypt held to have enslaved their ancestors.
|
Apollinaris of Laodicea in the Catenae on the Pauline Epistles: Unknown Hexaplaric Readings of Isaiah and Psalms
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Reinhart Ceulemans, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
The catenae on Paul’s epistle to the Romans (ed. Staab 1933), contain several fragments that are ascribed to Apollinaris of Laodicea (ca. 315-391). Although appearing in catenae on the New Testament, these scholia are quite useful for textual critics of the Greek versions of the Hebrew Bible. They contain Hexaplaric readings of Psalms and Isaiah that have escaped the attention of previous editors (Field 1875 and Ziegler 1939).
The present paper aims to discuss the Hexaplaric readings in question in order to pass judgment on their authenticity. In addition, it will address the question what these (rather lengthy) readings of Aquila and Symmachus can tell us about Apollinaris’ access to Hexaplaric data. In conclusion, it wishes to formulate some thoughts on the circulation of the Hexapla in the Antiochean school, to which Apollinaris belonged.
|
The Old Latin Tradition of the Song of Hannah in Relation to the Greek Text
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Historical Books
Reinhart Ceulemans, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
The present paper aims to investigate how one should approach the Old Latin text of I Samuel when using it as a witness to the Greek text. To this end it will focus on Hannah’s Song. It wishes to present the state of previous research on the Old Latin text of this passage, its manuscript witnesses and its patristic quotations. It will also confront the various Latin fragments with each other and with the LXX texts that are transmitted through Greek manuscripts and other daughter translations. In conclusion, it will formulate some suggestions on how textual critics of the Greek text of I Samuel should deal with the Old Latin tradition.
|
Reading (Hebrew Bible) Texts Sociologically: Methodological Considerations
Program Unit: Social Sciences and the Interpretation of the Hebrew Scriptures
David Chalcraft, University of Derby, UK
Respondent to papers in session.
|
Metaphors of “Body” in John’s Apocalypse in Light of Social Semiotics
Program Unit: Semiotics and Exegesis
Lung Pun Common Chan, Chinese University of Hong Kong
Without social semiotics, the Apocalypse of John is unrelated to any research on metaphors of “body”. Somaton (Rev 18:13) provides an entry point for interpreting John's semiosis. Apart from this sole genitive plural form of “bodies”, “soma” has 141 NT occurrences. But only here, “body” is understood as commercial goods. The paper explores the “meaning potential” of John’s “somaton” from three aspects: sociolinguistics, social history and socio-rhetorical criticism. From the perspective of sociolinguistics, the translation of “somaton” as “slaves” (e.g. NRS, NKJ), which is probably influenced by 2Macc 8:10-11, should be reconsidered. In fact, within the network of options, John chooses another Greek word, i.e. “doulos” (14 times), for signifying “slaves” as a specific social status. In other words, John’s “somaton” may denote more than simply male forced labor. Does the diction also reflect human trafficking for prostituting women and children into the sex trade (e.g. Justin Martyr, First Apology 27)? The paper tries to explore, both in synchronic and diachronic approaches, why John opts for this dehumanized “somaton”. Social-historically, the diction is investigated in a political-economic context of the Roman Empire. In Rev 18, somaton are depicted as luxuries demanded by “Babylon”, the enormous and strong city (Rev 18:10). John's entire discourse about Roman urban living is clustered with sexual wording. The prostitution presupposes sexual intercourses with naked bodies (e.g. Petronius, Satires 7). To a certain extent, bodies have market values because of “sexual” desires – an illegitimate relationship between Rome and other parts of the world order. Furthermore, John's socio-rhetorical critique on the Roman ideology of somaton is particularly illustrated with his Jewish-Christian sexuality of body as “virgins” (Rev 14:4). In the same verse, the economic term (agoracho) can be found. In short, John’s “somaton” signify not only slavery, but also economic imperialism on human bodies caused by “sexuality”.
|
'Swifter than Eagles' (Jer 4:13): A Jeremianic Image Examined in Light of ANE Descriptions of Military Violence
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Michael Chan, Emory University
In Jer 4:13, an unidentified enemy is described as having horses that are “swifter than eagles” (qallû minnešarîm). This description, in turn, is part of a larger unit (vv. 11-13) that pairs avian and meteorological imagery in announcement concerning Jerusalem’s imminent destruction. These dramatic images, all of which describe threats from the air, elicit a cry of despair from the Jerusalemite audience (4:13b-14). How could these images evoke such terror? Answering this question requires considering how such imagery would have been perceived by inhabitants of the ANE, who were familiar with its various symbol systems. Unfortunately, little attention has been given to the ANE background of the military bird of prey image in general and to the bird of prey imagery in Jer 4:13 in particular. As a result, interpreters tend to understand the avian reference in v. 13 naturalistically, that is, as simply a comparison with the natural activity of a bird of prey (i.e., birds of prey are fast, just as horses are fast). This interpretation leaves unconsidered the bird of prey’s use in the larger symbolic, mythological, and propagandistic discourse of the ANE. In this paper, I will examine the ways in which birds of prey are used in the ANE to describe the realities of military engagement, paying particular attention to ANE parallels found in literary and visual forms of royal propaganda. I will argue that the bird of prey imagery in Jer 4:13 draws upon a common cache of royal, military symbols with which Jeremiah’s audience would have been familiar. Further, the fact that Jeremiah utilized imagery and literary motifs common to ANE royal propaganda may have contributed to the disdain among some Jerusalemites for his apparently “pro-Babylonian” position.
|
Symbols of Strength, Masculinity, and Apotropaism: An Examination of Wing-Like Fringes Worn by Human and Divine Characters on Neo-Assyrian Monumental Art
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Iconography and the Bible
Michael Chan, Emory University
A variety of characters – soldiers, genii, foreigners, and sometimes even kings – are depicted on Neo-Assyrian monumental art wearing wing-like fringes that hang between the legs of these characters as they stand and walk. At times, the fringe faces the viewer, showing that it was fastened to the waist. Elsewhere it is depicted on the opposite side, leaving only the tip of the “wing” visible between the legs of the wearer. Aside from occasional references to these attachments as decorative “fringes,” scholars have assigned them little to no symbolic significance. Based on similar practices in surrounding cultures (e.g., pharaoh’s wearing of a bull’s tail), I will argue that the wing-like fringes are meant to represent bird wings; they therefore participate in an ancient practice in which humans attach animal components to their bodies for various culturally-determined reasons. The wing-like fringes are also rich in meaning and have three overlapping shades of significance: (1) The fringes evoke notions of strength and are, therefore, related to a common ANE metaphor that describes soldiers as birds of prey. (2) The fringes seem to be related to constructions of masculinity, since, with only one exception found on a drawing from Dur-Sharrukin, only bearded males wear them; eunuchs (i.e., beardless males) never wear them. (3)The fringes function apotropaically, testifying to the protection of the deity associated with the winged-disc. The fringes, therefore, represent the kind of protection afforded the king, who is often accompanied by the winged disc, which overshadows him with wings and fights beside him as an ally. Avian imagery is also associated with notions of strength, power, military prowess, and protection in biblical texts (e.g. 1 Sam 1:23; Jer 4:13; Hab 1:8; Ps 91:4). The ANE context for this imagery, therefore, provides a more textured background against which to interpret these biblical passages.
|
If Memory Serves Me: Eve's Recollection of Eden in the Greek Life of Adam and Eve
Program Unit: Midrash
Cynthia R. Chapman, Oberlin College
This paper examines the expansive retelling of the Eden narrative attributed to the memory of the elderly Eve in the Greek Life of Adam and Eve (GLAE). Specifically focusing on the transgression narrative of Genesis 3:1-6, which becomes a six-chapter, thirty-verse tale remembered by Eve (GLAE 16-21), the paper argues that the author(s) of GLAE seeks to correct real and perceived speech-related problems in the Massoretic Text (MT) version. The key speech-related problem that elicits midrashic, gap-filling dialogue is the MT’s pronouncement of the divine punishment of the man for “listening to the voice of his wife” (Gen 3:17). Because the woman never uttered anything to the man in the temptation scene or in any part of Genesis 2-4, the author of GLAE clearly felt compelled to “retrieve” the missing speech of the woman to the man. The insertion of a speech of Eve to Adam at the time of transgression, therefore, can be understood as clarifying a genuine ambiguity in the MT. The author of GLAE, however, crafted the content of Eve’s speech such that it also corrected a perceived inappropriate association of Eve with speech, wisdom, and the power of discernment. The cumulative result of the expanded version of the transgression narrative in GLAE gives the prerogative for authoritative, god-like speech to Adam and the proclivity for dangerous, devil-inspired speech to Eve. Moreover, the woman’s pursuit of wisdom and her desire to be “like gods” is removed from Eve’s remembered tale and becomes instead Adam’s possession of wisdom and the knowledge of good and evil such that he can label his wife and her thoughts evil. By attributing this expanded and corrected version of the transgression event to the memory of the elderly Eve, the first transgressor, the author of GLAE lends authenticity and authority to his retelling.
|
Paul, Blindness, and the Servant of the Lord
Program Unit: Society for Pentecostal Studies
Blaine Charette, Northwest University
In Luke-Acts Jesus’ role is defined, in part, in terms of Isaiah’s servant of the Lord, whose task is to restore Israel and to take salvation to the Gentiles. Yet the description of Jesus’ ministry in the Gospel of Luke relates only the beginning of the servant’s work. The Book of Acts describes the continuation of the servant’s task in the work of the Church. Paul in particular is portrayed as one who will perform the role of the anointed servant. There is a particular irony in this identification of Paul with the servant inasmuch as the book of Isaiah depicts two contrasting servants: the servant who brings light and heals the blind and the servant who is blind. Paul in Acts comes to represent the two servants of Isaiah. When the reader is first introduced to Paul he is a ‘blind’ Israelite who is literally struck blind when Jesus appears to him on the Damascus road. Yet his eyes are opened so that he can now open the eyes of others to the light. Paul had represented blind Israel, but comes to represent the servant community.
|
Deconstructing John’s Apocalypse in the Apocalypse of Haiti
Program Unit: Islands, Islanders, and Scriptures
Ronald Charles, University of Toronto
John’s apocalyptic work is an ambiguous de-colonizing text that has been oppressively interpreted in order to oppress others. In the context of Haiti, John’s Apocalypse has been used as a (Re-)colonizing text by many missionaries and Christian leaders to pacify a population that is otherwise known for its resistance to hegemonic forces. The oppresive interpretation of this text can be observed in the ways in which the combat myth mentality and horizontal violence, as portrayed in the Johannine text, is usually not far from the mentality and actions of many Christians in Haiti. John’s language of “synagogue of Satan,” with its particular ideology of silencing the religious realities of others perceived as diabolical, has inspired many pastors and preachers in Haiti to use violent language against those perceived as belonging to the “synagogue of Satan.” The horrific anti superstitious campaign of 1942-1944, the horrible acts of stoning or burning alive those perceived as belonging to the “synagogue of Satan” shortly after the departure of the dictator baby Doc in 1986, and the unleashing animosity against some practitioners of the Vodou religion after the January 12th earthquake, testify to the point where education, tolerance, love and dialogue is necessary and urgent in Haiti today. My paper presents a deconstructing reading of John’s Apocalypse in order to liberate the text, not only from the traditional debilitating readings that have been so prevalent for most Haitian Christians, but also to liberate John's apocalyptic message from its own ambivalence.
|
Using the Witness of John in Jesus Research
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
James H. Charlesworth, Princeton Theological Seminary
Mark mostly and also Q intermittently have been the major sources utilized for recreating the life and teachings of Jesus of Nazareth. Acknowledging the significance of these two sources and recognizing the paradigmatic importance of archaeology and sociology, I shall explore the best ways ahead to include the Gospel of John in Jesus Research. Many scholars now admit that they should have used John is writing a book on Jesus and there is a growing awareness that archaeologists have found the Fourth Evangelist [or at least the author of the First Edition of John] to be astoundingly well informed about pre-70 Jerusalem. Alone among the Gospels, John claims to be based on an eyewitness. Is that claim only a typos or a clever rhetorical ploy?
|
Greek Literacy in First Century Palestine in Light of Papyrus Finds in the Judaean Desert
Program Unit: Papyrology and Early Christian Backgrounds
Scott Charlesworth, Pacific Adventist University
More than one-third of texts found in the Judaean desert were written in Greek, and of these documentary texts outweigh literary by just under 4 to 1. This encourages the conclusion that Greek was actively used by those who deposited the texts. However, the archives of Babatha (110-132) and Salome Komaïse (125-131) confirm that in many cases Greek documents were produced by professional scribes. Therefore, the comparative percentage of Greek papyri cannot provide an accurate indication of written literacy. Instead, the papyrological evidence must be: (1) closely examined for indications of individual (non-scribal) written literacy; and (2) supplemented by the inscriptional evidence. The combined evidence shows that Aramaic and Greek were in much wider use than Hebrew. One of the letters of Bar Kokhba suggests that he found Greek easier than the Hebrew he promoted for nationalistic reasons. But all of his preserved letters were also written by scribes. Most people with ability in Greek would have had a kind of oral/aural bilingualism; i.e., Greek could be spoken, understood, and perhaps read, but not written. By way of conclusion, the relevance of Greek literacy for the transmission of early Christian oral and written tradition will be discussed.
|
Persuading God to Take Sides: The Rhetoric of Denunciation in the Individual Psalms
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Davida Charney, University of Texas at Austin
Biblical scholars over the past 40 years have made great use of the techniques of rhetorical criticism in interpreting the Psalms. However, from the point of view of a scholar in rhetoric, the array of concepts and methods that biblicists have generally drawn on is fairly narrow. Much is to be gained from viewing the individual psalms as persuasive arguments between Israelites and God over the continuation of the covenant.
My overall project is to show that the individual psalms can be grouped into a small number of recurring stances that ancient speakers might have taken vis-á-vis God and the rest of the community. These stances include: maintaining the status quo of a trusting relationship between God and the speaker, establishing the right of innocent Israelites to redress from trouble, denouncing others with competing claims for God's favor, appealing to God's self-interest in saving faithful Israelites, modeling the appropriate stance towards God for other Israelites, and convincing one's self to remain faithful.
In this talk, I focus on eight psalms in which the speaker's main goal is to denounce rivals. In three psalms (Ps 10, Ps 28, and Ps 59), the opponents are treated as outright villains who have no authentic claim to God's favor. In three (Ps 35, Ps 41, and Ps 55), the opponents are those who may once have been worthy, but who have betrayed the speaker. The most interesting cases are two psalms (Ps 109 and Ps 140) in which the psalmist treats the opponent as a rival for God's favor.
In all these cases, the opponents are portrayed as much like the speaker—capable of calling to God. As such, the psalms indicate an appreciation of the power of speech and a belief that God is open to persuasion.
|
Tradition and Innovation in Sectarian Religious Poetry
Program Unit: Qumran
Esther G. Chazon, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
The religious poetry composed by members of the Yahad community exhibits distinctively sectarian terms, ideas, and motifs while, at the same time, drawing upon biblical tradition and a common extra-biblical Jewish heritage. This paper will explore the adoption and adaptation of traditional liturgical elements in sectarian religious poetry composed by the Yahad. Key examples include the use and deployment of blessings and penitential formulae (e.g., the proclamation of divine justice and the list of divine attributes) in hodayot hymns. The examples will be studied in their own right and for the light they shed on larger issues of literary composition, rhetorical strategy, formation of sectarian identity, liturgical tradition, and the network of connections between the Yahad and the world outside of Qumran.
|
Mythological Prologues in Mesopotamian and Biblical Literature
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Y. S. Chen, University of Oxford
Recent Assyriological research on mythological prologues to Sumerian and Babylonian narrative compositions has advanced our understanding of how the primeval time of origin was conceived and represented in ancient Mesopotamian literary traditions. Important observations have been made with regard to the content and style of narration of the primeval time of origins, the selection and ordering of the narrated primeval events, and the social and intellectual functions of these mythological narratives in ancient Mesopotamia. Synchronically and diachronically, commonality and diversity, continuity and discontinuity, and conventions and innovations in the course of development of these Mesopotamian literary traditions have been explored. Based on some of the relevant research findings in Assyriology, the current paper intends to re-evaluate the mythological prologues in the biblical traditions embedded in the opening chapters of the Book of Genesis. It seeks to investigate the extent to which the biblical traditions share and diverge from some of the literary conventions as observed in Mesopotamian mythological prologues.
|
Comparative Studies of the Mesopotamian and Biblical Flood Stories and the Comparative Method
Program Unit: Bible, Myth, and Myth Theory
Y. S. Chen, Oriental Institute, University of Oxford
The current study uses comparative studies of the Mesopotamian and biblical flood stories as a case to examine how comparative studies should be done, and to explore the roles of the comparative method for the study of the composition and transmission history of Mesopotamian and biblical traditions. Upon reviewing some of the conclusions reached by previous comparative studies of the Mesopotamian and biblical flood stories, it is observed that some of these conclusions are tenuous due to the lack of a fuller access to or usage of cuneiform sources and because of the lack of due attention to the diverse and composite character of both Mesopotamian and biblical sources. Similarities and differences can be relative depending on the texts involved in comparison. By analyzing the methodologies of Lambert & Millard’s study of Atra-hasis (1969) and Tigay’s study of the Gilgamesh tradition (1982), this study points out that it is important for comparative studies to go as far as possible to include all relevant and available sources for comparison, to analyze data in a historical framework, and to employ a combination of criteria (e.g., stylistic, formal, structural, conceptual, and ideological) for establishing intertextual and historical relationships between traditions and for identifying and classifying continuities and changes in transmission history. It is clear especially in Tigay’s study that the role of the comparative method is more than just comparing or contrasting several texts of related motifs or themes in order to observe their similarities and differences, or commonalities and distinctiveness. The method is seen as a crucial part of the procedure through which complex mechanisms and particularities of the composition and transmission of ancient texts may be revealed, and the traditions behind the texts may be recovered.
|
The Social-Religious Implications of the Leading Role of Women in Funeral Ritual as It Relates to Jesus’ Death and Burial in the Gospels (Mt 26:6–13 par.)
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
InHee Cho, Concordia University College of Alberta
The public role of women in ancient funeral practice has been discussed among classicists and New Testament scholars. As an exception to the many social restrictions imposed on women in Greco-Roman society, the leading role of women in preparing the body for the funeral draws our attention to the evangelists’ portrait of the death and burial of Jesus Christ.
All the Gospels with the exception of Luke record the incident of Jesus being anointed either on his head or his feet with costly perfume by a certain woman at Bethany (Mt 6:1-13; Mk 14:3-9; cf. Lk 7:36-50) at the dawn of his passion. John names her as Mary the sister of Lazarus (Jn 12:1-8). In reaction to the woman’s act the disciples of Jesus become enraged because they consider her behavior an extravagant and pointless waste, which reminds the reader of ancient Athenian Solon’s law for monitoring the excessive performance of women in funerals. Nevertheless, at odds with the disciples, Jesus interprets her act as a “good service” of preparing for his burial and also openly commends her as worthy of being remembered wherever the Gospel is proclaimed (Mt 26:10 par.). Further vignettes in the Gospels denote the leading role of women in funerals in relation to Jesus’ passion: women lamenting the deceased (Lk 23:27f), attending the dying (Mk 15:41ff; Mt 27:55f; Lk 23:49, 55; Jn 19:25), keeping vigil (Matt. 27:61), and visiting sepulcher (Mk 16:1f, 9ff; Mt 28:1; Lk 23:56–24:1ff; Jn 20:1).
The paper aims to (1) survey the essential role of women in funeral ritual from the Hellenistic, Jewish and early Christian traditions as it is relevant to the practice of the first century C.E.; (2) examine the evangelists’ redactions on the involvements of women in Jesus’ death and burial from the preparation of the body to visiting the tomb; (3) demonstrate that the burial of Jesus falls within the proper practices of burial on account of the characteristic and timely role of the women (4) show that the kinsmen role of women, which seems to be missing in Jesus’ passion narratives, is subtly demonstrated by the evangelists.
|
Paul’s Opponent in 1 and 2 Corinthians in Light of Gnostic Ideas
Program Unit: Korean Biblical Colloquium
Jae Hyung Cho, Claremont Graduate University
This paper proposes to investigate Paul’s opponents in 1& 2 Corinthians in light of Gnostic features of Paul and his Epistles. When scholars study Paul and his opponents, they often regard Paul as the anti-Gnostic due to church tradition. However, the Gnostic characteristics present in Paul indicate that he may have been influenced by Gnostic ideas, and his opponents are anti-Gnostics. This paper will provide coherent identification of Paul’s opponents in both 1 and 2 Corinthians and present a method for understanding the situation of 1 and 2 Corinthians as well as the “historical reconstructions” of Paul’s life.
Walter Schmithals and Gunter Bornkamm argue that Paul wrote his letters to refute the Gnostic Christians. If they are right, Paul is fighting not against an attack from right-wing conservative super-apostles, but against left-wing radical Gnostics. Interestingly, instead of repudiating Paul, the most famous Gnostic groups, the Naassenes and Valentinians, revered Paul as a Gnostic master. The Valentinians even alleged that their secret tradition came from Paul’s own teaching. The reason that Paul seems to be anti-Gnostic is based on the descriptions of Irenaeus, Tertullian, and Hyppolytus, who consider the Valentinian view an insult to Paul. Elaine Pagels argues that the Gnostic interpretation of Paul’s writings is not the false doctrine that Irenaeus harshly insisted it was, but that the Valentinians distorted Paul’s views. As G. Strecker argues, some ecclesiastical sources that refer to Paul often express hostility, indicating that Paul is associated with Gnosticism.
I, along with other scholars, argue that Paul was influenced by Gnostic ideas. Gnostic terminology, such as “knowledge,” “wisdom,” “pneuma,” “pleroma,” and “the elect” are apparent in the Pauline corpus. A better reading of the Pauline conflict is to read a Gnostic Paul against the pillar apostles. Therefore, the opponents of 1 & 2 Corinthians are anti-Gnostic Jewish Christians whom the pillar apostles influence.
|
The Linguistic Dimensions of Speech for Analyzing Q
Program Unit: Biblical Greek Language and Linguistics
Byung Pill Choi, McMaster Divinity College
Recently, many biblical scholars have presented the orality of Q as speech. Most of their arguments are based on hypothetical presuppositions derived from contextual presumptions. Although they in part draw textual attention, the results from the text relatively seem to be insufficient in explaining the linguistic features of speech, which can be discriminated from writing. If it is likely to agree that Q was a kind of speech form circulated amongst the early Christian communities when Matthew and Luke used it as one of their primary sources, we need a proper method to take a closer look at Q as speech.
In this paper, first of all, I expect to define the various linguistic-dimensional features of speech for Hellenistic Greek based on the Systemic Functional Linguistic perspectives, by which many modern linguists have paid particular attention to the situational and functional differences between speech and writing in English. Secondly, with both well defined dimensional features and the textual analysis of Q, I will try to classify Q according to its register such as teaching, conversation and prayer, and apply the Greek linguistic dimensions to each of them. The most significant point of this study will be to determine the dimensional functions in speech and to interpret the content of speech. It is true that this study should require a sort of statistic result. Therefore, to examine other examples of the ancient Greek speeches would be helpful to figure out how the dimensional features of Greek speech function to understand its content. So I will take some more examples from Luke-Acts in order to look at Lukan tendency on speech
I expect, from this study, to confirm that Q probably existed in speech, and this fact would be supported by our linguistic model as an applicable model for the ancient Greek speech.
|
A Formation of Post-Pauline Christian Identity in the Roman Empire: The Metaphor of Body and the Language of Unity, Maturity, and Fullness in Ephesians
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Jin Young Choi, Vanderbilt University
The theme of unity in Ephesians has been considered in terms of a “summary of Paul’s gospel.” The reconciliation of Jews and Gentiles presented in Paul’s letters as a future hope had become a present reality by the time Ephesians was written. Then why does the author of Ephesians still stress the unity of the church? I would argue that the author of Ephesians presents a construction of the unifying body in relation to the formation of a new identity, which is different from the construction of the Christian body and identity that Paul sought. The author’s claim for this new emerging Christian identity, particularly his stress of a status shift from ksenoi and paroikoi into sympolitai and oikeioi, displays how Christians’ earlier universalizing discourse embodying a sense of displacement or otherness was transformed into another type of discourse signifying trans-imperial identity, a new type of theo-political entity. I will examine this imperial configuration of the communal identity with regards to three aspects of power dynamics: the relationship with the empire; construction of Self and Other; and inner group dynamics. I will investigate these aspects from an imperial-critical and gender-critical perspective, focusing on the metaphor of body and the rhetoric of unity, maturity and fullness presented by Ephesians. Such a critical approach will reveal that Ephesians is not merely an abstract interpretation of Pauline tradition but seeks to reinscribe and even extend the dominating imperial ideology regarding body and identity in domestic, political, and universal levels.
|
Eve's Problem (Gen 3:16): Pain, Productivity, or Paucity of Birth?
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Maggie Low, Trinity Theological College-Singapore
The usual understanding of Gen 3:16 is that as a result of the Fall, the woman suffers pains in childbirth and is under the control of her husband. Carol Meyers, Discovering Eve (New York: Oxford University Press, 1988), 95-121, challenges this traditional understanding. Based on a semantic study, she proposes that it is not the pains of childbirth that God is multiplying but rather the woman’s agricultural labor and her number of pregnancies. Since the woman is reluctant to give birth, this is overcome by her erotic desire for her husband, who also imposes his will sexually upon her.
In this paper, I will build on Meyers’ observations, but I will conclude with a position that is diametrically opposed to hers. On further word study, I agree that !wrh and the transitive use of dly refer to pregnancy and parenthood respectively rather than to the birth process itself, and that !wbc[ and bc[denote agricultural labour and physical and/or emotional stress respectively rather than birth pangs. However, unlike Meyers, I read $nrhw $nwbc[ as a hendiadys and propose that what is imposed on women is the difficulty of conceiving and bearing children.
The notion that Eve’s problem is multiple pregnancies goes against the cultural norm of women desiring many children, as illustrated by examples in the Hebrew Bible and especially by Hannah’s song in 1 Sam 2:5. On the other hand, the reading that Eve’s problem is difficulties in having children is supported by the rest of Genesis where having a child, especially by the barren matriarchs, is possible only with God’s help. Such texts offer another perspective to the Priestly promise of fruitfulness. It is a theme that is also found in the Babylonian myth of Atrahasis. Finally, I interpret hqwvt and lvm in the light of Gen 4:7 and submit that Gen 3:16b describes a struggle for power rather than a mutual sexual desire in the marital relationship.
|
A Postcolonial Reading of Matthew 28:16–20 in the Light of a Korean Myth
Program Unit: Asian and Asian-American Hermeneutics
YongHan Chung, Graduate Theological Union
This paper seeks to reconsider Matthew 28:16-20 in order to overcome the imperial and colonial interpretation of the Great Commission from a perspective of an Asian reader. Additionally, it has become increasingly necessary to decolonize the scriptures for Christians in Korea and elsewhere in Asia. Asians have inherited not only from Christian traditions, but also from their own culture and literature—in this paper, the Korean myth of Tangun. First of all, this study will conduct an exegesis of the above passage, while acknowledging the manner in which Biblical scholarship has emphasized the inclusive (universal) and exclusive (particular) attitude of the Gospel of Matthew toward the gentile mission. Yet this focus of Matthean scholarship has not fully explained why and how the text has influenced the aggressive and at times even violent method of mission in the history of Christian church. Next, with the help of an intertextual reading between Mt 28:16-20 and the myth of Tangun, a post-colonial reading will be proposed as a more relevant interpretation of the text for readers with flesh and blood ties to the Korean church who have been missionized and colonized for the past century by the western missionaries. The post-colonial perspective will enable Korean readers to recognize the horizontal, humanitarian, theo-centric aspects of the Great Commission, rather than follow the hierarchical, doctrinal and Christ-centric interpretation imposed by the missionaries. After making it possible to reconstruct ‘another meaning’ for the Great Commission in a Korean context, a postcolonial reading will help the colonized to reform the church and society by abolishing the social class system, enhancing the status of the oppressed, reducing hierarchical inequality, and encouraging egalitarian relationships.
|
The Merkabah Tradition in Matthew’s Gospel
Program Unit: Mysticism, Esotericism, and Gnosticism in Antiquity
YongHan Chung, Graduate Theological Union
Despite the past several decades’ continuous emphasis on apocalyptic aspects in Matthew’s Gospel, the mystic interest of this Gospel in the Merkabah has not drawn much attention from Matthean scholars. This study will locate Matthew’s Gospel within the orbit of the early development of the Jewish mysticism in the Second Temple Judaism. Even though no reference is made in this Gospel to the chariot of God, Matthew is the only writer in the NT who speaks of the throne of His glory that the Son of Man will occupy at the parousia. By showing Matthew’s interest in the eschatological temple in general and the throne and the glory in particular, the current effort will explicate how a trajectory from early apocalyptic and mystic traditions to traditions attested in late Merkabah mysticism would be redrawn by a late first century Jewish sect, the Matthean community in this case. On the basis of the implication of verses (19:28, 24:30, 25:31, and 26:64), Matthew offers some support for the possibility of reconstructing the historical milieu of the Merkabah tradition and its relation to the subsequent development of Merkabah mysticism. This study will eventually shed new light on the mystic tradition embedded in the early Jewish-Christian traditions as well as the interrelation between apocalyptic and mystic traditions.
|
A Postcolonial Reading of Matthew 28:16–20 in the Light of a Korean Myth
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
YongHan Chung, Graduate Theological Union
This paper seeks to reconsider Matthew 28:16-20 in order to overcome the imperial and colonial interpretation of the Great Commission from a perspective of an Asian reader. Additionally, it has become increasingly necessary to decolonize the scriptures for Christians in Korea and elsewhere in Asia. Asians have inherited not only from Christian traditions, but also from their own culture and literature—in this paper, the Korean myth of Tangun. First of all, this study will conduct an exegesis of the above passage, while acknowledging the manner in which Biblical scholarship has emphasized the inclusive (universal) and exclusive (particular) attitude of the Gospel of Matthew toward the gentile mission. Yet this focus of Matthean scholarship has not fully explained why and how the text has influenced the aggressive and at times even violent method of mission in the history of Christian church. Next, with the help of an intertextual reading between Mt 28:16-20 and the myth of Tangun, a post-colonial reading will be proposed as a more relevant interpretation of the text for readers with flesh and blood ties to the Korean church who have been missionized and colonized for the past century by the western missionaries. The post-colonial perspective will enable Korean readers to recognize the horizontal, humanitarian, theo-centric aspects of the Great Commission, rather than follow the hierarchical, doctrinal and Christ-centric interpretation imposed by the missionaries. After making it possible to reconstruct ‘another meaning’ for the Great Commission in a Korean context, a postcolonial reading will help the colonized to reform the church and society by abolishing the social class system, enhancing the status of the oppressed, reducing hierarchical inequality, and encouraging egalitarian relationships.
|
Preaching as Proclamation of the Word of God
Program Unit: Homiletics and Biblical Studies
Yun Lak Chung, Anyang University
Unlike the forms and content of preaching, the nature of preaching has rarely been discussed especially from the perspective of biblical theology. This study attempts to clarify exegetically in what sense preaching is understood as proclamation of the Word of God.
Luke-Acts is particularly significant in studying the understanding of preaching in the New Testament. It demonstrates both Jesus' own preaching and his teaching of preaching and his apostles' and disciples' preachings in continuity with Jesus' preaching and his teaching of preaching. This paper is not concerned about the preachings of the historical Jesus and apostles. Instead, it deals with what the text of Luke-Acts presents about the understanding of preaching in the cases of Jesus, his apostles and the early church leaders.
This paper argues that the apostolic preaching of Luke-Acts is understood as proclamation of the Word of God, because the preachers preach what the Spirit of God gives them to preach. For this purpose, Jesus commanded his disciples to wait for the promise of the Father, that is, the Holy Spirit. Just as Jesus was anointed with the Spirit and sent to preach, the apostles and disciples were also sent to preach the Word of God by the Lord Jesus and the Spirit of God. The understanding of their preaching as proclamation of the Word of God claims the apostolic preaching's continuity with Jesus' preaching and also with the Old Testament prophets' proclamation of the Word of God.
|
Approaching Paul's Use of Scripture in Light of Translation Studies
Program Unit: Paul and Scripture
Roy E. Ciampa, Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary
This essay will explore some of the potential of the growing field of Translation Studies for the study of Paul’s use of Scripture, including elements of descriptive translation studies (e.g., polysystem theory), functionalist approaches (Skopostheorie), postcolonial approaches to translation, and the understanding of translation as cultural mediation. Particular approaches will be considered that may broaden the scope of issues that inform our understanding of Paul’s use of Scripture including seeing that usage as part of his role as one of the key translators of the message of early Christianity for the Gentile communities to which he ministered.
|
Resisting Dehumanization: Ruth, Tamar, and the Quest for Human Dignity
Program Unit: Feminist Hermeneutics of the Bible
Juliana Claassens, University of Stellenbosch
Feminist scholars have compellingly argued for intertextual connections between the stories of Tamar (Gen 38) and Ruth (cf. e.g. Ellen von Wolde). This paper seeks to add to this conversation by arguing that a common theme in both these stories regards the dehumanization of the most vulnerable members of society (women, foreigners, and widows) that is resisted by exactly the subjects whose human dignity is violated.
This common theme reveals to us some profound perspectives with regard to what it means to be human. As Beverly Mitchell has argued in her recent book, Plantations and Death Camps: Religion, Ideology and Human Dignity, ultimately to be human means to resist those forces that seek to assault, violate or obscure one’s human dignity.
A further connecting feature between these two stories that are worth exploring with regard to the theme of human dignity is the theme of seeing and not seeing/ concealing and revealing. Employing the Jewish philosopher Emmanuel Levinas’ notion of seeing the “face” of the other who calls upon me to take up my responsibility to act for good, I argue that it is when both Boaz and Judah truly see the face of the young woman in all of her vulnerability that they respectively act for good. In both narratives it is significant that it is the foreigner or the outsider who is the one who functions as the revealer, so transforming the male leader of the community (perhaps paradigmatically serving as representative of the society at large), to a position where the dignity of those who are desolate (females, aliens and widows) are respected.
|
Human Dignity in the Prophetic Traditions: Upholding Human Worth in a Context of Dehumanization
Program Unit: Ethics and Biblical Interpretation
Juliana Claassens, University of Stellenbosch
Within the conversation regarding “The Bible and Rights,” I argue that the notion of human dignity offers a fruitful avenue to explore the interrelated themes of justice, vocation and human responsibility in the biblical traditions. Human dignity is most evident in the image of the Imago Dei, i.e., the claim in Gen 1:26-27 that humans, both male and female, are created in the image of God. This powerful theological claim has led to some rich theological reflection by Christian and Jewish interpreters who have argued for the inherent worth of every human being whose dignity is a gracious gift bestowed by the Creator God. Nevertheless, in the Hebrew Bible there are numerous instances where this dignity of individuals and groups are threatened, obscured and violated. And yet, it is exactly in the midst of these situations of dehumanization that the conversation on what it means to be human becomes most urgent. For instance, in prophets like Amos and Isaiah, it is within the depths of the social justice violations that threaten the wellbeing of the society’s most vulnerable members that one encounters the prophet’s persistent critique that upholds the dignity of each member of the society (cf e.g. Amos 5; 8; Isaiah 5).
In conversation with recent works by Nicholas Wolterstorff (Justice: Rights and Wrongs), and Beverly Mitchell (Plantations and Death Camps: Religion, Ideology and Human Dignity), I argue in this paper that the theme of human dignity may help ground the discourse on justice and human rights within the narrative framework of the biblical traditions. Focusing on a few selected examples from Amos and Isaiah, I will show how despite the appalling portrayal of dehumanization we find in the prophetic traditions, one finds a counter narrative that resists this dehumanization, rooted in the belief that humans as created in the image of God are to be valued and respected.
|
Antanapleroo in Col. 1.24: Discovering a Semantic ‘Storyline’
Program Unit: Biblical Lexicography
Bruce Clark, University of Cambridge
Among interpreters ancient and modern, the verb antanapleroo in Col. 1.24 (a NT/LXX hapax legomenon) has remained a disputed word within an already disputed verse. To my knowledge, all modern interpreters have been aware of only six extra-biblical occurrences of the word; however, TLG lists 12 (from 4th cent. BCE to 3rd cent. CE). A detailed investigation of each occurrence (esp. the verb’s syntagmatic relations) reveals that it is highly probable that the following rather sophisticated semantic ‘storyline’ is evident in the use of Col. 1.24: the verb’s action assumes that an original/prior contribution has been made (either logically or temporally), one that genuinely adds to but, for whatever reason, is unable to achieve the desired or required fullness/completion; then in the action of the verb antanapleroo itself, a second/subsequent contribution is made in addition to the original contribution, one that actually realizes in toto the desired or requisite fullness. The paper will consist of a concise, accessible, logically sequential presentation of my results (with handout), followed by a summary of its very real/pertinent impact on the exegesis of Col. 1.24. Note: all the analysis is completed, and an initial draft of the paper is complete.
|
The KJV Translation of the Old Testament: the Case of Job
Program Unit:
David J. A. Clines, University of Sheffield
*
|
The Hype about Skype: Using Videoconferencing to Enhance Our Teaching
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Kelley Coblentz Bautch, St. Edward's University
One might suggest that Biblical Studies in a post-modern world is a discipline cognizant of multiple perspectives and appreciative of pluralism. The desire to explore our discipline from various vantage points and to offer students a range of approaches to the study of Scripture enriches our academic conversation. Yet, how do instructors with limited time and means bring other voices and views to their students? “Sky-Peer-to-Peer” (Skype) technology has the potential to be a cost-effective way to transform classrooms into a multi-vocal space so that students and faculty may be enriched by the expertise and perspectives of colleagues even those at some geographical remove. In this contribution to the Workshop on Interactive Teaching and Learning Technologies, I will share examples as to how instructors might use Skype in the classroom, in both large introductory courses and in seminars. From facilitating guest lecturers to conducting brief interviews, Skype assists instructors in sharing with students the wealth of knowledge and insights of colleagues. Additionally, Skype allows us to model for our students how we participate in ongoing academic discussions with others and it can make our classrooms reflective of a global environment where students may gain international perspectives with incredible celerity. As students bring technological savvy to the enterprise of learning and have similar expectations of their instructors, Skype is a tool for the Biblicist qua educator that expands our teaching repertoire and is relatively easy to access.
|
Diachrony in BH Lexicography and Its Ramifications for Textual Analysis
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Harold R. (Chaim) Cohen, Ben Gurion University
The purpose of this paper is to demonstrate how the diachronic method goes hand in hand with proper textual analysis including occasionally, when absolutely justified, the textual emendation of the Masoretic text (even when no alternative Hebrew version is extant). Four individual cases (each illustrating a different principle of proper diachronic textual analysis) will be briefly discussed and some general methodological conclusions will then be drawn.
These four cases include two individual words in ABH. one for which a new textual emendation will be proposed (Gen 49:15—MT twb w't is emended to twbh z't),the other, a hapax legomenon, for which an accepted textual emendation, knws, will be rejected in favor of the attested kms(Deut 32:34; see BHS). The third case involves the linguistic variation of a common root ts-c-q which occurs in its original form in more than one third of its occurrences in the Torah (27 times out of 76 occurrences), while the clearly later form, z-c-q occurs only twice in the Torah (out of 91 occurrences). This exemplifies diachrony in BH lexicography. The fourth case involves a common morphological form which is considered almost universally as an identifying feature of LBH (because it is so common in Aramaic), but is almost as common in ABH and SBH (and is just as common throughout Akkadian beginning with the Old Akkadian period): the -wt (ut) suffix for abstract nouns in BH. It should not be considered as an identifying feature of LBH.
|
Christian Authors on Jewish Observance of Shabbat
Program Unit: Sabbath in Text and Tradition
Shaye J.D. Cohen, Harvard University
Did Jews of the Roman diaspora observe Shabbat? If they did, did they observe it rabbinically, that is, did they follow the rulings propounded by the sages in the land of Israel and Babylonia? Rabbinic literature is overwhelmingly prescriptive, not descriptive, so it is of limited value in answering these questions. Still, it is striking that in at least two passages rabbinic literature assumes that the Jews of the Roman diaspora do in fact observe Shabbat, and do so rabbinically. In this paper I examine the evidence bearing on this question in the writings of the early church. The evidence that they provide as to the observance of Shabbat by Christians has been collected and discussed by scholars many times, but in this paper I collect and discuss the evidence that they provide as to the observance of Shabbat by Jews. There are the usual problems in the interpretation of this evidence: are the Fathers bona fide eyewitnesses to what Jews are really saying and doing, or are they presenting “type” Jews spun out of the Christian imagination? Sometimes the one, sometimes the other. In this paper after surveying the evidence as a whole I will concentrate on an enigmatic passage from ps.-Ignatius (fourth century Syria).
|
Dancing with the Devil: The Serpent as Eve in Fashion Magazine Advertising
Program Unit: Bible and Popular Culture
Shelly Colette, Mount Allison University
Garden of Eden imagery is ubiquitous in fashion magazine advertising in North America, particularly in advertisements directed at women. These popular biblical reconstructions commonly conflate a sexually seductive Eve with the Serpent. The highly eroticized Eve-Serpent figures in these ads also commonly suffer further conflation with the Garden of Eden itself, resulting in a composite Eve-Serpent-Eden character. As we read the narrative of this composite character, the voyeurism of the camera lens lures us, as readers, to adopt the position of Adam, to be seduced by the charms of Eve. At the same time, the advertisement’s message invites us to become Eve ourselves, and to seduce in turn.
In this paper, I trace the conflation of these characters in the Genesis/Fall reconstructions found in fashion magazine advertising. Through a feminist narrative analysis of the process of characterization, I examine the role of the reader in the construction of this new Edenic narrative, and the ways in which the reader becomes a second implicit character in the story.
|
The Garden, the Serpent, and Eve: The Biblical Eroticization of Environmentalism
Program Unit: Biblical Criticism and Literary Criticism
Shelly Colette, Mount Allison University
The biblical Genesis/Fall myth has been long used as a narrative through which we understand human-environment relationships, most commonly by fostering a stewardship model of human superiority to and dominion over the Earth. More recently, there has been a rise in a popular environmentalist ethic in the West, the Green Movement, questioning the unrestricted use of environmental resources that has emerged from this stewardship model. In biblical scholarship, the Green Movement has resulted in myriad ecological and ecofeminist interpretations of the Genesis/Fall myth. In Western consumer culture, by contrast, the Green Movement has given rise to yet another item to be sold and consumed: the environmentally friendly product, their advertising campaigns often featuring reconstructions of the biblical Genesis/Fall myth. This is especially true of print advertisements directed at women. The images in these ads conflate a sexually seductive Eve figure with the Garden of Eden itself, creating a composite Eve-Eden character. Such highly sexualized reconstructions of the biblical Genesis/Fall myth are often used to “green” consumer products.Drawing from specific examples of Garden of Eden imagery in women’s fashion magazines, in this paper I examine the narratological features that contribute to the conflation of characters in these popular biblical reconstructions. Through ecofeminist narrative analysis, I trace the environmental implications that attend such sexualized and eroticized “greenings” of the Creation/Fall myth.
|
“Violated by the Violence of the Enemy”: Augustine and Pope Leo I on the Changing Bodies and Identities of Raped Virgins
Program Unit: Violence and Representations of Violence in Antiquity
Jennifer Collins-Elliott, Florida State University
In the 5th century CE, barbarian invasions into North Africa resulted in the rape of a number of virginal nuns. In light of these attacks, women and their communities did not know who they were now or where they belonged: Were these women still virgins because they were not complicit in their attacks? Since these women’s bodies no longer reflected virginity, should they (how could they?) continue to be called “virgins”? Why were some virgins attacked and not others? Both Augustine, in De Civitate Dei book one, and Pope Leo I, in a letter to the bishops of Caeserea Mauritania, grapple with the questions proposed above, in an attempt to reestablish personal and social identities that have been dismantled and blurred by rape. Augustine, in De Civitate Dei I, assures these women that as long as they did not consent to the rape in their animi, they were blameless in their animi and thus remained virgins even if their bodies bore witness to their loss of virginity (i.e. their hymens were torn). And while Pope Leo I, like Augustine, does not necessarily blame the women for what happened to them, he tells the virginal victims of barbarian rape that they should not dare to compare themselves to virgins who were not raped. Instead, victims are now categorized, personally and socially, between undefiled virgins and chaste widows; these women now occupy an entirely new, liminal space as a result of their attack.
In this paper, I will explore why Augustine and Leo I have similar reactions to these violent and unsolicited attacks but come to very different conclusions concerning how these attacks have changed the identity of the victims. This will entail a discussion of the roles and the relationship between the animus and the body in personal and social identity formation in this period, as well as a discussion of Augustine and Leo I’s doctrines of free will and grace.
|
Jewish 'Fools' and Their Gentile Foil: Reading Comedy in Mark 15:34–39
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Jason Robert Combs, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
Many scholars have noted ambiguity in the phrase, "when the centurion … saw that he died in this way" (Mark 15:39). In what way? Matthew resolves the ambiguity, claiming that the centurion and others saw an earthquake and the tearing of the temple veil that succeeded Jesus' second cry and his death (27:50-54). In Mark, however, it is unclear what it is about Jesus' second cry from the cross that caused the Centurion to make his proclamation. Yet, if we do not follow Matthew in presuming that Mark's Jesus uttered a second cry then the ambiguity is resolved. I argue that Mark 15:37 is not a second cry, as it is in Matthew 27:50, rather it is the introduction of how another figure responded to Jesus' initial cry, "My God, my God…" (Mark 15:34). Not only does this reading make more sense of the grammatical construction in Mark 15:37, an aorist participle followed by an aorist indicative, but it also reveals a parallel to other ancient texts that interpret Psalm 22 with reference to divine sonship (see Wisdom 2:17-18, and other parallels in Joseph and Aseneth and 1QHodayot). Mark 15:34-39, therefore, presents a continuation of the Messianic secret motif by contrasting the response of those who should understand Jesus' Aramaic cry with the response of one who should not. While those who 'understand' Aramaic scramble to find wine in anticipation of Elijah – a misunderstanding with parallels in the Roman Comedies of Plautus and Terence – meanwhile, the presumably Latin speaking Roman Centurion truly understands. That this Centurion understood the Aramaic cry fits within the immediate context of miraculous events: i.e., the darkness covering the land (15:33) and the veil of the temple being torn (15:38).
|
Correcting the Commandment: The Effect of Early Christian Sabbath Polemic on the Text of Luke’s Gospel
Program Unit: Sabbath in Text and Tradition
Jason Robert Combs, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
The Gospel of Luke contains some of the most positive affirmations of early Christian Sabbath observance. Jesus attends synagogue on the Sabbath “as was his custom” (Luke 4:16), and some of his closest disciples “rested on the Sabbath according to the commandment” (Luke 23:56). Yet, as the text of the Gospel of Luke was copied, passages such as these were reworked in order to distance Jesus and his disciples from Jewish Sabbath observance. Bart Ehrman has demonstrated that early Christian controversy affected the transmission of the text of the New Testament, in particular with regard to the impassioned Christological debates in the earliest centuries of Christianity. Controversy surrounding Sabbath observance was no less impassioned in this early period, and I would argue no less influential on the transmission of the New Testament text. For instance, in two manuscripts, Luke 4:16 is altered so that Sabbath Synagogue attendance becomes the custom of the townspeople rather than of Jesus (see 2643, 2766, and l211). The changes to Luke 23:56 are even more dramatic. One manuscript in particular (MS. 579) moves the particle de backward by three words, from 24:1 to 23:56. With this small alteration, it is the women’s visit to the tomb on Sunday morning that becomes “the commandment,” instead of the Sabbath rest. These and other variants (e.g., Bezae-Luke 6:5) reveal a dynamic relation between contemporary Sabbath controversy evident Justin Martyr, Irenaeus and Tertullian and the transmission of the New Testament text. Reading Lukan variants in light of early Christian Sabbath polemic contributes to our understanding of the debate, and evinces openness toward altering the text to correct the commandment.
|
Ethnicity, Economics, and Diplomacy in Dionysios of Corinth
Program Unit: Early Christianity and the Ancient Economy
Cavan Concannon, Harvard University
In the latter half of the second century CE, Bishop Dionysios of Corinth wrote a letter to the bishop of Rome to thank his community for a financial gift to the Corinthian church. The letter itself only comes down to us in a few fragments in Eusebius’ Ecclesiastical History, along with a description of other letters written by Dionysios to early Christian communities throughout the eastern Mediterranean. In these fragments, we learn that Dionysios thanked the Roman church for their financial gift by deploying themes common in the rhetoric of ethnicity: appeals to common genealogy, history, and religious practice. In so doing, Dionysios justifies the economic interdependence of the Corinthian and Roman churches on ethnic grounds, participating in a broader discourse in early Christianity that drew on the rhetoric of ethnicity in the creation of Christian identity. Alongside analysis of the rhetoric of the fragments of Dionysios’ letter, this paper draws on archaeological evidence for the economic conditions in which the Roman gift of money was received by Dionysios. Economic indicators, like levels of imported pottery, allow us to situate the formation of cultic, ethnic, and financial ties between the Roman and Corinthian communities within the local context of Corinth. As such, this paper shows how, in the case of a single Christian community, the material conditions of trade and travel shaped the spread of early Christianity, the social networks and institutional linkages that emerged between Christian communities, and the flow of letters, oral traditions, and ideas.
This paper is intended for the third group focusing on the 2nd to 5th centuries.
|
The Politics of Malleable Bodies in Corinth
Program Unit: Paul and Politics
Cavan Concannon, Harvard University
This paper examines the politics of ethnically malleable bodies in Corinth. I compare Favorinus’ “Corinthian Oration” with Paul’s claim in 1 Corinthians 9:19-23 to “be all things to all people.” Paul and Favorinus sought to influence Corinthians in the first and second centuries CE by prominently displaying their own bodies as able to negotiate multiple ethnic and cultural identities. In presenting himself as one who, though a Roman from Gaul, has become Greek, the orator Favorinus challenges Corinth’s ability to claim Greek identity. Favorinus presents his Corinthian audience as Roman rubes, unable to appreciate his own role as the embodiment of a Greek identity open to all through training and education. In 1 Cor 9:19-23, Paul claims to be able to “become (as)” others for the sake of the gospel. Paul’s interest in this characterization serves both to underscore his authoritative position in the Corinthian ekklesia and to encourage his audience to imitate his example by changing their social, religious, and dietary practices. In so doing, Paul presents his body as both malleable and authoritative under the contradictions of a free slave, an honorable flatterer, and an athlete who seeks a prize for others. Both authors present their boundary-crossing selves to Corinthian audiences as arguments for their authority. By moving between ethnic identities, and the cultural and religious practices that constitute them, Paul and Favorinus show how deployments of the adaptable body could be used rhetorically in Corinth to defend their authority and honor before an audience of Corinthians.
|
Lamentations for the Lord: Preserving a Pagan Past in a Modern Mourning Ritual for Jesus
Program Unit: Lament in Sacred Texts and Cultures
Eugenia Scarvelis Constantinou, University of San Diego
The best attended service of the liturgical year for Greek Orthodox Christians is the evening of Great and Holy Friday, (“Good Friday” in the West). This service is known simply as “The Lamentations,” (Ta Engomia) and many of its elements are clearly a continuation of ancient Greek pagan rituals. Despite the length of the service, (at least three and a half hours), the Lamentations Service draws huge crowds which are especially attracted by the cherished singing of traditional lamentations to Christ and participation in the “funeral procession” for Christ. Drawing their inspiration from the biblical narrative and piety, the words of the lamentations themselves sometimes voice the sentiments of Mary, sometimes Joseph of Arimathea, and sometimes the followers of Christ. The clergy lead the faithful outside the church building into the streets with an embroidered icon depicting the dead body of Christ laid out and surrounded by his mourners. This icon, known as the “epitaphios,” (the term used in pagan antiquity for the funeral oration over a tomb) is placed in an elaborately decorated flower-bedecked “tomb”. The image on the tomb is carried through the streets by honored pallbearers while the faithful follow behind the procession carrying lit candles and singing the lamentations. Not mere re-enactment, as though recalling an event in the distant past, Orthodox Lamentations Service of Great Friday speaks of the events in the present tense in a case of lived-liturgy thousands of years old yet ever-new.
|
“One in Christ” but Multivalent in Meaning: The Creative Use of Gal. 3:27–28 in the Theological Controversies of the Early Church
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Eugenia Scarvelis Constantinou, University of San Diego
The meaning of being “clothed with Christ” and the corresponding creation of a corporate “oneness with Christ” in Gal. 3:27-28 was most commonly expressed and interpreted in the ancient Christian East through the association of this verse with New Testament baptismal texts and imagery, especially Romans 6. But could the idea in v. 27 of being “clothed with Christ” and the related concept in v. 28 of “oneness” with Christ be extended far beyond the sphere of sacramentology and Christian ethics to support a variety theological conclusions, even about the nature of God? In fact, these verses were utilized in surprising and unexpected ways in many early theological debates and controversies. At times they were employed in opposition to certain theological constructs and arguments, for example against Monotheletism (John of Damascus), Priscillianism (Leo the Great), and Manicheanism (Augustine). And in other instances these verses were applied in support of key theological positions, such as Trinitarian theology (Basil the Great), the divinity of the Holy Spirit (Ambrose), and for communicating conclusions regarding certain qualities of the afterlife (Leo the Great, Gregory the Great and Chrysostom). Multiple uses for these verses indicate not only the valuable elasticity of the concept of oneness through corporate clothing in Christ, but also the ingenious application of an authoritative Christian text by numerous interpreters for variety of purposes.
|
Postcolonial Studies and Historical Studies: Benefits and Limitations
Program Unit:
Colleen Conway, Seton Hall University
This paper will explore what postcolonial theory has to offer to the study of Christian origins. The answer to this question is particularly complex. At one level, there is issue of the usefulness and appropriateness of drawing analogies between modern imperialist agendas (the focus of most postcolonial theory and literature) and ancient Rome. This is a point that has been debated among historians and archeologists of Rome, and their contributions on this topic can be useful to those working from the angle of Judaism and early Christianity in the Roman empire. At another level, there is the issue of the multiple manifestations of Christian belief and practice among differing groups and regions of the empire, as well as the wide range of social status of adherents. Such differences would argue against any homogeneous application of postcolonial theory to all of early Christian experience and expression. Finally, there is the more general issue of studying a religious phenomenon through the lens of a theory that has been largely disinterested in the question of religion, except insofar as it has been seen as a tool of the colonizer. What might it look like to examine the emergence of Christianity (and its internal debates with Judaism) as a complex and multifaceted response to colonial contact? This paper draws on the work of the Roman historians mentioned above, as well as recent scholarship that is already at work redefining Christian origins, in an effort to begin answering this question.
|
Sin and Salvation, Aramaic Style: Reflections on the Aramaic Vocabulary of Sin in the Light of Gary Anderson's "Sin: A History"
Program Unit: Aramaic Studies
Ed Cook, Catholic University of America
Gary Anderson has recently proposed that the Judaism's adoption of Aramaic after the Exile as a vernacular was a key moment in the history of Israel's thought about sin. Sin passed from being regarded as a weight (in Hebrew) to a debt (in Aramaic). This thesis is examined in the light of the development of Aramaic vocabulary for sin and salvation up to the Second Temple period and beyond.
|
Egypt, Tyre, and Ezekiel: Strands in the Development of Isaiah
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Paul M. Cook, University of Oxford
This paper aims primarily to identify several contributions to the development of the book of Isaiah from the perspective of the period following Nebuchadnezzar's failed siege against Tyre, around 571 B.C.E. These circumstances are widely recognized as the background for some of the oracles concerning Tyre and Egypt in the book of Ezekiel. In particular, Ezek 29:17-20 anticipates a Babylonian invasion of Egypt as divine compensation for the failed effort against Tyre. This paper argues that the same perspective can be detected in certain passages in Isaiah that share close linguistic ties especially with the Egypt material in Ezek 30:1-19. With regard to Isaiah, it may come as no surprise to discover such influence within the oracles concerning Egypt (Isa 19) and Tyre (Isa 23), but the same perspective can also be detected in the boasts of Sennacherib in Isa 37:22-29 (// 2 Kgs 19:21-28).
|
Gilgamesh, The Book of Giants, and Antediluvian Knowledge
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Jeffrey L. Cooley, Boston College
The inclusion of Gilgamesh and, apparently, Humbaba in The Book of Giants (BG) known from Qumran has intrigued and puzzled scholars since the names were noted by J. Milik in his publication of the Aramaic Enoch fragments. Since then, several theories have been suggested to explain the king’s survival and the reason for his inclusion in that text. Scholars such as J. Reeves, D. Jackson and M. Goff have maintained that Gilgamesh is featured polemically in this late text as a deliberate representative of foreign traditions. Further, they argue that the way in which Gilgamesh is utilized in the BG demonstrates that the author had some knowledge, either direct or indirect, of the contents of the Epic of Gilgamesh. A. George, on the other hand, claims that Gilgamesh’s survival and inclusion is based solely on the king’s legacy in Babylonian mantic and exorcistic traditions which were widely circulated outside of Mesopotamia.
As Jackson has discussed, in Enoch and Jubilees, forbidden antediluvian knowledge is one of the reasons for the Flood. Further, he argues that Gilgamesh is used in the BG primarily as an agent of foreign knowledge. Thus, for Jackson Gilgamesh serves as a representative of a demonic culture. In this paper I assert that Gilgamesh is employed in the BG because of his identity as a tradent of secret knowledge from the time before the Flood (e.g. Tablet I 1-8 of the SB epic), rather than merely as a symbolic agent of such knowledge. Furthermore, this adds to the case that the author of the BG had specific knowledge of the Gilgamesh tradition outside of his mantic and exorcistic associations, as George contends.
|
Crossing over Jodan: The Telling and Retelling of the Exodus Narrative in African-American Communities
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Matthew J.M. Coomber, Concordia College-Moorhead
Biblical narratives rarely enjoy a static existence, but are frequently reshaped by the communities that receive them in order to suit their own experiences, either past or present. From its reception into the cultural fabric of African slaves in the United States, the Exodus story has been interpreted and reinterpreted in ways that fit the needs and understandings of African-American communities. A closer examination of this evolutionary process in the abolitionist and civil rights movements can offer valuable insights into how the malleability of biblical narratives allow communities to use these texts to renew their relevance, facilitate societal change, and allow communities to reinterpret their stories.
The central characters of the Exodus narrative did not change drastically from the abolitionist struggle to the Civil Rights movement; leaders of these movements, from Harriet Tubman to Martin Luther King, Jr., were often portrayed as “Moses,” while slave owners and agents of segregation were referred to as Pharaohs. However, the role of the oppressed and their relationship with the God of the Exodus underwent an important transformation. As opposed to the distant warrior-God who would send the Union Army to bring freedom, continued oppression led to revised interpretations of both the Exodus and the African American story. Rather than wait for a deity to act entirely on their behalf, Civil Rights leaders proclaimed that the God of the Exodus worked through his followers’ activities, beckoning them to lead themselves into the “Promised Land” that they sought.
In this paper I argue that the evolution of African-American receptions of the Exodus story, as found through literature, sermon, and song, not only reveal how biblical texts are able to help communities to define and redefine their relationships with the divine and the world around them, but can inspire followers to actively alter their social circumstances.
|
Yet Again the Kid in Its Mother's Milk
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Alan Cooper, Jewish Theological Seminary of America
It is well known that the strange biblical law prohibiting the seething of a kid in its mother's milk is the basis for the general Jewish prohibition of combining meat and dairy. Despite two millennia of commentary, however,there still is no general consensus about the meaning of the proscription in
its biblical context. Most ancient and modern commentators have explained it on the basis of humanitarian and/or cultic concerns. In the first part of this paper, I will examine those lines of interpretation systematically, with special attention to the traditional hermeneutics that inform them. In the remainder of the paper, I will focus on interpretations that classify milk and meat among the "forbidden mixtures," from an extraordinary seventeenth-century Jewish commentary to Nicole Ruane's recent work on the role of gender in biblical law. I will argue in favor of this line of interpretation, while acknowledging the difficulty inherent in deciding which of the possible antinomies are most salient (life/death,nurture/destruction, licit/illicit sex, male/female, etc.).
|
A Double Transgression: Film Theory, Writing, and the Moving Image
Program Unit: Bible and Film
Laura Copier, University of Amsterdam
In this paper I delineate the challenges of writing about film. The inevitable paradox of film analysis is that one has to momentarily halt the flow of the moving image in order to grasp the image, an image that derives its meaning from its forward motion in time. In this sense, the filmic text is in French film theorist Raymond Bellour’s words, “unattainable” (Bellour, The Analysis of Film, 2000).
I demonstrate the heuristic tool of the shot list as the valuable way to analyze the filmic image. A shot list is a detailed description of the succession of shots that, taken together, constitute a scene or sequence in a film. This approach merits some explanation. As Bellour argues, the written analysis of film is “the product of a double transgression”, since the analyst has to resort to the use of words to describe a moving image. The literary analyst, in contrast, does not encounter this problem. As Bellour’s own work demonstrates, the written analysis of film can be excruciatingly detailed, however, “the written text can never capture anything but a kind of elementary skeleton” (2000: 16). Despite the inadequacy of the word to describe the image, let alone a moving image, it seems to be the only tool available.
In this paper I demonstrate the combination of a written analysis, the shot list, with a screen capturing of the shot that is described. This combination of (descriptive) words and the paused image is the closest one can get to a rendering of the moving image within a written medium.
|
Violent Prayer and the Psalms in the Age of Barack Obama
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
Amy Cottrill, Birmingham-Southern College
“Pray for Obama: Psalm 109:8.” In the fall of 2009, this seemingly kind-spirited slogan was printed on bumper stickers and t-shirts in what seemed to be an expression of goodwill for the new president. Of course, when one reads Psalm 109:8, one can no longer assume that this encouragement of prayer was an offer of goodwill for President Obama; Psalm 109:8 says, “May his days be few in number, may another take his office.” What seemed to be an expression of support was in fact a violent prayer for, at the least, the end of President Obama’s presidency, and at the most, the end of President Obama’s life. Though the bumper sticker does not explicitly call our attention to the rest of Psalm 109, the verses immediately following are the psalmist’s prayer to God for further violence to fall upon the psalmist’s enemy. In fact, this particular psalm is one of the most infamous in the Psalter because of its extended fifteen-verse curse against the enemy. This particular use of Psalm 109 in public political discourse raises important questions for students of the Psalms interested in ideological criticism. Though we may reject the use of this psalm in this way as undemocratic hate speech, this bumper sticker isolates a particularly violent voice within the Psalms that scholars have not adequately discussed. Recent ideological criticism recognizes that texts do not speak with one unified voice, but are sites of ideological struggle and contention. Psalms scholars have treated violent psalmic language as a whispered voice in the text, but the bumper sticker demands that we examine the violent wishes of the psalms as a loud voice, one capable of overwhelming other voices. This paper analyzes the psalms as sites of ideological contest, a rhetorical location of struggle between voices of violent rage and resistance to violent theology.
|
Isaiah 2:1–4 and 11:1–10: Twin Visions of the Future
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
J. Blake Couey, Gustavus Adolphus College
In a recent essay on Isaiah 2:1-4, J. J. M. Roberts argues that this celebrated text presents a picture of Judean hegemony in which YHWH rules the earth from Jerusalem through the agency of the Davidic monarch, to whom other nations come for arbitration of disputes that would previously have led to war. Building upon Roberts’s reading, I argue in this paper that Isaiah 2:1-4 forms a pair with the royal oracle in Isaiah 11:1-10. The two poems respectively emphasize the divine choice of Zion as capital and the Davidic heir as regent but otherwise share practically identical pictures of the future. A considerable amount of shared vocabulary and themes join the two poems, including natural imagery, legal terminology, the motif of the nations’ pilgrimage to Jerusalem, and the portrayal of an end to military conflict. Understood in this way, these poems are not simply idealistic visions of an idyllic future; rather, they are grounded in the political realia of the ancient world, as interpreted prophetically through the lenses of ancient Judah’s royal-Zion theology.
|
Evoking and Evading: The Poetic Presentation of the Moabite Catastrophe in Isaiah 15–16
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
J. Blake Couey, Gustavus Adolphus College
The oracle against Moab in Isaiah 15-16 poses many challenges to the interpreter, including textual and philological difficulties, historical uncertainties, and the reuse of portions of the text in Jeremiah 48. In their preoccupation with these admittedly important issues, scholars have not often paid sufficient attention to the literary features of these chapters, with a few notable exceptions. The oracle is a striking and powerful composition, however, and many of the apparent difficulties may in fact be integral features of the poetry. The poem evokes a palpable sense of disaster but withholds key pieces of information from the reader or hearer, thereby evading a complete description of what has befallen the Moabites. In this paper, I will examine some of the stylistic features of the text that help to achieve this effect, most notably ambiguity, wordplay, and imagery. With these factors kept in mind, a richer and more coherent reading of the poem and a better understanding of its place in Isaiah's oracles against the nations are possible.
|
“I ‘Witnessed’ the Raising of the Dead”: Resurrection in Social-Scientific Perspective
Program Unit: Social Scientific Criticism of the New Testament
Pieter F. Craffert, University of South Africa
A social-scientific reading of the resurrection data does not attempt to explain the resurrection away but offers a historical and cultural sensitive interpretation of the data by means of anthropological and neuroscientific models. The data on Jesus' resurrection contain information about at least three sets of phenomena that requires consideration: the notion of a resurrected body, afterlife beliefs and visual perception as the basis for the resurrection experiences. Neuroscientific research offers insights into these phenomena as normal and common human phenomena while anthropological research provides comparative material about the interconnectedness of such phenomena within cultural systems.
|
Rethinking the Relationship between Temple and Tabernacle
Program Unit: Cultic Personnel in the Biblical World
Cory Crawford, Brigham Young University
This paper examines the foundation for current approaches to and conclusions about the relationship between the Wilderness Tabernacle and the Jerusalem Temple. After a brief summary of the history of scholarship on the question from Wellhausen to the present, a reanalysis of the comparative data is proposed, with special attention to questions of structure and iconography. Tentative conclusions as to the nature of the relationship between Tabernacle and Temple, whether experiential or textual, are put forth on the basis of the analysis. It is suggested that this view not only agrees with Haran’s dating of P, but that one might also suggest a narrowing of the pre-exilic date of the current Tabernacle texts. Finally, implications of these hypotheses for the understanding of the sociopolitical context of the Priestly School are discussed.
|
Illumination and Interpretation: The Nature of Exegesis according to Cyril of Alexandria
Program Unit: Christianity in Egypt: Scripture, Tradition, and Reception
Matthew R. Crawford, Durham University
In this paper I examine the theory of illumination according to Cyril of Alexandria, and explore what implications this idea has for exegesis. Cyril developed his theory of illumination most fully in his Commentary on the Gospel of John, and this development takes place in three stages corresponding to his exegesis of the prologue of John 1, the healing of the blind man in John 9, and the upper room encounter with the risen Christ in John 20. His conception of illumination is twofold, operating according to the levels of creation and redemption, the latter being most important for exegesis. Illumination according to redemption occurs by the indwelling of the Holy Spirit and grants to the believer an accurate understanding of the nature of Christ, of the fulfillment of the Mosaic law, and of the Trinity. Since, in Cyril's estimation, the scriptures are a book about Christ, this illumination according to redemption and by the Holy Spirit is necessary to see accurately Christ in the scriptures and so to interpret them correctly. Moreover, the process of writing a commentary or teaching others can also be described as illumination, but only insofar as it is a sharing with other creatures of the divine illumination that ultimately always comes from Christ by the Spirit. Finally, failure of interpretation results from the attempts by those lacking the Spirit and thus lacking illumination to understand the scriptures, be they by Jews, heretics, or pagans.
|
The Pentateuch as Found in the Proto-Samaritan Texts and 4QReworked Pentateuch
Program Unit: Transmission of Traditions in the Second Temple Period
Sidnie White Crawford, University of Nebraska - Lincoln
This paper will look at evidence for the scribal transmission of the Pentateuch (Torah) in the Qumran scrolls. In particular I will discuss the proto-Samaritan texts and the Reworked Pentateuch texts as a window into scribal activity and culture in the Second Temple period.
|
Space, Place, and Exile: The Land as “Third-Space” in Joshua 1–12
Program Unit: Space, Place, and Lived Experience in Antiquity
Ovidiu Creanga, King's College London
In the Conquest Narrative (Josh. 1-12) the ‘Land’ is a multifaceted narrative construct, configured at once as a physical territory and as a cultural site of memory and identity. Drawing insights from landscape and urban criticism, as well as social memory theory, this paper discusses how territorial summaries in Joshua 10-12, read alongside the rest of the Conquest Narrative and with an eye to division of the Land among the Israelite tribes (Josh. 13-21), transform the geography of the Land into a mnemonic landscape commemorating and anchoring the identity of a Yahwistic Israel. This reading assumes a period of loss of homelands, such as the Babylonian exile, but not necessarily or exclusively this period, and ongoing debates about the significance of living in the Land during and after the Babylonian exile.
|
The Codicology of the Bruce Codex
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Eric Crégheur, Universite Laval
Purchased in Egypt in the eighteenth century by the Scottish traveler James Bruce, the "Books of Jeû" are, with the "Pistis Sophia" and the "Untitled Text" of the same Bruce Codex, among the first direct Gnostic texts known to European scholars. However, the "Books of Jeû" are also among the least studied text of "Gnostic literature". The only critical edition of the text goes back to 1892, there is no literary, philological or historical commentary of the text, and no serious and detailed codicological analysis of the Bruce Codex has been done so far, despite sixty years of studies on the Coptic Gnostic Nag Hammadi Codices. By giving us a precious insight on the provenance and making of a codex, codicology is today an intricate part of any scholarly work on a text, particularly when it is preserved in only one manuscript.
As a way to contribute to the study of this text, this paper will examine in detail the various codicological elements relevant for the study of the Bruce Codex. With the help of the two oldest descriptions of the codex, and on the basis of a close new examination of the manuscript, we will seek to retrace the primitive state of the codex. The study of the material aspects of the manuscript will allow us to address the following points: the arrangement of the three different sequences of pages of the "Books of Jeû"; the place of the three fragments ascribed to the "Books of Jeû"; the relationship between the so-called two "Books of Jeû"; the relationship between these two "Books of Jeû" and the "Untitled Text" of the Bruce Codex; an estimate of the number of missing pages; and finally an approximate and preliminary dating of the codex.
|
The KJV in Orthodox/Byzantine Perspective
Program Unit:
Simon Crisp, United Bible Societies
*
|
A Course in Miracles, or a Secular Introduction to the New Testament?
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
Zeba Crook, Carleton University
Miracles -- from insignificant ones such as walking on water to significant ones such as Jesus raising and being raised from the dead -- are such a key feature of Christianity's self-understanding, it is perhaps not surprising to find that their treatment in introductions to the New Testament is complicated. In this paper, I shall compare how several such text books, ranging from the explicitly evangelical to the allegedly secular, deal with the question of miracles. In order to draw broader conclusions, I shall compare these to introductory textbooks on other religions.
|
"Not Great Men"? Studying Christian Origins with Heroes and Villians from the Nineteenth Century Onward
Program Unit: Redescribing Christian Origins
James Crossley, University of Sheffield
This paper will investigate 19th century takes on the ‘Great Man’ view of history and the ‘Jewish Question’, looking at how this combination, tied in with questions of nationalism and nation state, has continued to have a profound influence on the historical study of Christian origins into the 21st century. This will involve questions of how such concepts vigorously developed in the 19th century continue to be negotiated in different historical and cultural contexts and how the basic scholarly narrative of Christian origins is, rhetoric and cultural particularities aside, little different from its 19th century counterpart: a great leader is ‘needed’ and the issue of Jews, Judaism and/or the ‘Oriental’ needs to be ‘solved’.
|
A Talionic Approach to Warfare in Deutero-Isaiah
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
C.L. Crouch, University of Cambridge
This paper is an examination of how Deutero-Isaiah uses the principle of lex talionis to persuade his audience that Yahweh still has control over the military activities of the nations, despite the defeat of Judah's king in 587. Deutero-Isaiah does this principally in Isa. 47, the oracle against Babylon, by characterising the forthcoming fate of Babylon in language connected to the description of the fate of Judah at the hands of the Babylonians in Isa. 3:24-4.1. By so doing, Deutero-Isaiah connects the fate of Babylon to the Babylonians' own actions: what the Babylonians did to Jerusalem, so will Babylon now suffer. The recognition of Deutero-Isaiah's use of lex talionis in turn enables the reconsideration of the well-known connections between Isa. 47 and the descriptions of Zion's restoration.
|
Constructing Jesus with the Biblezines
Program Unit: Bible and Popular Culture
Bradley Crowell, Drake University
A recent phenomenon in the dissemination of the Bible is to package biblical books in a magazine format called Biblezines (produced by Thomas Nelson publishers). By juxtaposing biblical texts with images, explanations, and tips for modern life, this format constructs biblical characters and messages for various subcultures within a primarily American context. Constructing Jesus with the Biblezines analyzes how the Biblezines interpret the character of Jesus for various audiences.
|
Popular Reading among U.S. Latinos/as: Mexican American Cultural Productions
Program Unit: Latino/a/e and Latin American Biblical Interpretation
Gregory Cuellar, Texas Christian University
Popular Reading among U.S. Latinos/as: Mexican American Cultural Productions
|
Jesus Sayings in the Johannine Discourses
Program Unit: John, Jesus, and History
R. Alan Culpepper, McAfee School of Theology, Mercer University
This paper proposes a compositional approach to identifying traditional sayings, “maxims of the Johannine community,” in the Gospel of John. Traditional approaches have focused on either the content of the sayings (dissimilarity, embarrassment, Semitic elements) or parallels in other sources (multiple attestation). Neither works well for the Gospel of John because of its differences from the synoptic gospels and the distinctive content and style of its discourses. Relying on work by Peder Borgen, John W. Bowker, E. Earle Ellis, and Charles A. Kimball on early Jewish exegetical and homiletical patterns, we will draw observations regarding the placement and interpretation of traditional material in John’s discourses, and then identify sayings that by placement, function, and interpretation may derive from early or pre-Johannine tradition.
|
Modeling the Success of Religious Innovations
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
Istvan Czachesz, Helsinki Collegium for Advanced Studies and University of Heidelberg
In this paper I will discuss how insights from cognitive science and network theory can explain the migration of ancient cults. In the first part of the paper, I will outline four channels of inheritance that underlie the evolution of religious traditions. In the second part, I will describe two, complementary aspects of the success or failure of religious innovations: the cognitive structure of religious beliefs and narratives, on the one hand, and the nature of social networks, on the other hand. The cognitive structure of religious beliefs predicts their potential to become widely accepted. Ideas that are better remembered in the long run have a better chance to be transmitted. Relevant cognitive factors include counterintuitiveness, emotionally laden details, and magical reasoning. The success of religious innovations also depends on the social networks in which they try to spread. I will especially consider the effect of weak links in social networks on the spread of innovations. Weak social ties are ones that connect individuals who spend very little time together and/or invest very little, both in material and emotional terms, into their relationship. I will use the success of Early Christianity as a test case to illustrate the explanatory power of these concepts. In the final part of my paper I will discuss computational models of these theoretical propositions.
|
Memory, Cognition, and Theology
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Istvan Czachesz, Helsinki Collegium for Advanced Studies and University of Heidelberg
This paper will consider the implications of the science of memory for biblical studies.
|
Resurrection in Early Christianity from a Cognitive Perspective
Program Unit: Social Scientific Criticism of the New Testament
Istvan Czachesz, Helsinki Collegium for Advanced Studies and University of Heidelberg
This paper examines the cognitive capacities of the human mind that underlie the early Christian concept of resurrection. We will start our discussion with the review of empirical data about human expectations regarding the continuation of life beyond death, focusing especially on Jesse Bering’s psychological experiments and Rita Astuti’s fieldwork on Madagascar. In the second part of the paper, we will have a closer look at early Christian afterlife imagery and the cognitive mechanisms that explain such images. We will pay special attention to the representation of the human body after death and connect it to a particular moral tradition, expressed in Synoptic tradition. In the third part of the paper, we will examine the phenomenon of metamorphosis, which is well-attested in different cultures in the world, introducing the notion of cross-culturally shared, or maturationally natural, ontological categories. We will suggest that regular patterns of crossing boundaries between ontological categories provide better explanations for various features of metamorphoses than previous hypotheses. From the cognitive point of view, resurrection will be considered as a special case of metamorphosis traditions. In the final part of the paper, we will examine how different types of violations of ontological categories influence the memorability and transmission of ideas. We will use empirical results about the propagation of counterintuitive ideas to characterize the differences between various types of Christological concepts, and propose a cognitive explanation of the emergence of the proto-orthodox view of Jesus’ death and resurrection in early Christian thought.
|
Revisiting Eusebius' Use of the Figure of Moses in the "Vita Constantini"
Program Unit: Eusebius and the Construction of a Christian Culture
Finn Damgaard, University of Copenhagen
As several scholars have pointed out, Eusebius' comparison of Constantine with Moses seems to be a Leitmotif in the "Vita Constantini". By patterning the life of Constantine after the model of Moses Eusebius at the same time presents Constantine as a model for his sons on account of his Christianity and addresses his fellow Christians by weaving Biblical and Roman history into a single narrative that claims that Constantine in reality re-established the values and behaviours known from the Bible. Following Francis Dvornik's suggestion long ago in his "Early Christian and Byzantine Political Philosophy: Origins and Background" (Washington D.C. 1966), scholars seemingly agree that in writing the "Vita Constantini" Eusebius was influenced by Philo's "De Vita Mosis". However, no one has yet demonstrated the hypothesis. In this paper I shall show in detail the various ways Eusebius' use of the figure of Moses in the "Vita Constantini" is dependent on not only Philo's "De Vita Mosis" but also on Josephus' "Jewish Antiquities" and thus how the remarkable Caesarean library of Pamphilus with among others the Jewish writings of Philo and Josephus contributed to Eusebius' construction of Constantine as a Christian emperor.
|
Gossiping Jesus: The Oral Processing of a Social Personage in John’s Gospel
Program Unit: Social Scientific Criticism of the New Testament
John W. Daniels, Jr., Flagler College
Readers of the New Testament’s gospels are understandably attuned to the words and deeds of Jesus and relatively less concerned with how other characters in the narrative talk about him. Yet, the amount of talk about Jesus in the Gospels is striking, and when considered from the perspective of gossip, even more so. Indeed, many of the reports in John’s gospel describing gossip reflect this social phenomenon intricately operative along with a number of other social-cultural processes in constituting a person’s identity in the first-century Mediterranean world. The aim of this work is to suggest how gossip is operative in the process of constructing Jesus as a social personage in the Fourth Gospel. To do this, a viable framework for identifying gossip texts is constructed from modern socio-linguistics and ethnographies of both ancient and extant traditional Mediterranean cultures. Utilizing the method of abduction, the cross-cultural social type of a shaman is used against which a selection of gossip texts from John is read in order to see more clearly gossip’s part in the social construction of Jesus. Springing from inquiry into the sort of man who was the generative cause of the emergence of oral and eventually written stories about Jesus that come to us in John, this project involves linking literary features about oral phenomena in the text to a social personage thoroughly embedded in his social, cultural, and historical world, thus, underscoring gossip’s vital role in the construction of a culturally plausible historical Jesus.
|
A Comparison of the Usages of di/dwmi and di/dwmi Compounds in the Septuagint and New Testament
Program Unit: Biblical Greek Language and Linguistics
Paul Danove, Villanova University
This paper resolves the occurrences of di/dwmi and its thirteen compounds in the Septuagint and New Testament into eight usages and compares the distribution and frequency of these usages. The introductory discussion develops the semantic and syntactic criteria for identifying verbal usages and the distinguishing grammatical characteristics of di/dwmi and its compounds. The discussion then investigates each usage sequentially. These investigations identify the semantic, syntactic, and lexical properties of all occurrences of each verb with the usage, clarify potential interpretive difficulties, propose procedures for developing "working" translations that accommodate the interpretive constraints of the verbs with the usage, and compare the relative frequency of each usage and distribution of verbal complements in the LXX and NT. The concluding discussion identifies patterns in the distribution of usages and highlights the interpretation and translation of two realizations of complements that occur with multiple usages.
|
Icons in Context: Judean Pillar Figurines from the Top Down or the Bottom Up?
Program Unit: Art and Religions of Antiquity
Erin Darby, Duke University
Ancient religious representations challenge modern viewers who do not share the same temporal or cultural context. Archaeological location and artifact assemblage can help, but the challenge is even more pronounced when a piece of “religious art” is found in mundane contexts—contexts often associated with “popular religion.” For Judean Pillar Figurines, their contexts are often ignored or simplified. Moreover, archaeological contexts may be labeled “religious” for no other reason than the figurines, themselves.
At the same time, Judean Pillar Figurines partake in a long standing “religious” iconography. Unfortunately, few interpreters investigate the entirety of the female image. Instead, many interpretations depend solely upon the figurines’ breasts or pillar body, forgetting the importance of other figurine elements, like the varying head styles or the technological properties of clay molding and firing. As a result, much of the iconographic tradition is ignored, as are the significant design variations from one style of figurine to another.
By evaluating the archaeological context of figurines in Judah’s Central Hill Country, in combination with a thorough investigation of figurine iconography, this paper analyzes the most common female image from southern Israel/Palestine in the Iron II. Only when these two types of data are combined can interpretations be informed by the complexities of context and design, including possible contradictions as well as correspondences. Finally, by grounding these results in the dominant figurine traditions of the Near East, the female “religious” images of Iron II Judah are revealed as the complex nexus of ritual and social interactions that comprise them.
|
"Some Folks Is Born wid They Feet on the Sun and They Can Seek out de Inside Meanin’ of Words": An African American Scripturalization of the Book of Revelation Signified through the Middle Passage
Program Unit: African-American Biblical Hermeneutics
Lynne Darden, Drew University
African American biblical interpretation on the Book of Revelation traditionally engages in a hermeneutical key that is contrapuntal to the dominant ideological framework and is committed to exposing and challenging an ethos that promotes social inequality. However, in the performance of this noble enterprise scholars have neglected to present the complex dimensions of African American identity construction, seemingly locked into a discourse of marginalization and oppression, and have not fully represented the African American community of the 21st century that is evolving and will continue to evolve in many different social directions. Therefore, African American biblical interpretation must be re-framed to caution and challenge a community to resist reinscribing the behavior of the oppressor as the community moves steadily into the center of major institutions of American society. With this contemporary African American context informing the interpretation of the Book of Revelation, this paper proposes that while John the Seer's signifying on empire demonstrates that he is well aware of the oppressive nature of Roman imperialism as is evident by his fierce, non-accommodating stance towards participation in the imperial cult he, ironically, reinscribes imperial processes and practices. No matter how determined he is to disconnect from the oppressive religio-political mechanisms of provincial Asia Minor, his hybrid construction disallows him. Ironically, John's colonized construction as “almost the same but not quite” has resulted in the production of a resistance strategy that is a “blurred copy” of the hegemonic tactics of the Roman Empire which entail violent disruption and displacement. These multifaceted cultural, religious and political aspects are grounded in the cultural memory of the colonized Asia Minor Christian. It is this entanglement in the presentation of power that constructs John’s hybridity. The paper questions whether the Seer's re-presentation of images of empire is due, to a certain degree, to his being a colonized member of a society that demands participation in the rituals of religio-political power and suggests might the Seer’s virulent rhetoric be a result of his denial of his own ambivalent, hybrid construction, his unconscious realization of his contradictory double consciousness?
|
“Be Not Anxious for Your Psuche” (Luke 12:22): Psychagogical Rhetoric and Audience Formation in New Testament Narrative
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
John A. Darr, Boston College
In a recent book titled Augustine and the Cure of Souls: Revising a Classical Ideal (Notre Dame, 2009), Paul Kolbet argues cogently that Augustine drew heavily upon the classical rhetorical tradition called psychagogy. This ancient philosophical theory espoused the use of words to “order the emotions” (and so to “cure the soul”) of one’s audience. Augustine skillfully adapted this philosophical rhetoric to a wide array of theological tasks. Taking a cue from Kolbet’s work, I propose here that aspects of Luke’s discourse can profitably be understood as narrative psychagogy, that is, as an endeavor to shape audiences’ attitudes, emotions, and values through a variety of rhetorical strategies. My case in point will be the issue of anxiety, references to which appear repeatedly in the Third Gospel (most prominently in chapters 8, 10, and 12). Utilizing psychagogical and audience-critical insights, I will trace how, in the sequential actualization of Luke’s text, hearers are led to adopt certain understandings of and attitudes toward anxiety. Finally, I will raise the issue of the applicability of this new approach to other New Testament narratives.
|
God, with a Vengeance
Program Unit: Book of Ezekiel
Katheryn Pfisterer Darr, Boston University
Contemporary biblical scholars have turned to trauma and disaster studies for insights about the physical and psychological effects of forced migration on Ezekiel and his exilic community. Did the trauma Ezekiel experienced cause him to “create” Israel's God in the image of a traumatized and vulnerable deity? Against this view, I maintain that every Ezekielian characterization of God is an argument--specifically, part of an unremitting argument--that insists upon God's unrivalled sovereignty and power, even in the face of displacement and national collapse.
|
Biblical Canon(s) and Genre(s) in a Postcolonial World
Program Unit:
Steed Davidson, Pacific Lutheran Theological Seminary
Most postcolonial approaches to the Bible simple interrogate individual texts that may deal with constructions of empire. However, a full interrogation of the Bible itself as a canon and its growth as a book has yet to take place. This paper seeks to ask definitional questions of what constitutes the Bible in a postcolonial world and if “Bible” is a suitable placeholder for the texts that have been traditionally read, taught, and enforced in postcolonial contexts. Similarly, the paper engages the typical genre and section classifications of the Bible, probing whether a postcolonial approach can accept these classifications and how a postcolonial reading might reframe texts that have been labeled as historical, wisdom or prophetic, for instance. Ultimately, the paper offers a reconsideration of what a postcolonial engagement of the texts called “Bible” would look like from different starting points.
|
What Just Happened: The Rise of "Biblioblogging" in the First Decade of the Twenty-First Century
Program Unit: Blogger and Online Publication
James Davila, University of St. Andrews-Scotland
This paper recalls the rise of "biblioblogging" early in this decade, surveys its expansion and development since that time, and explores the ways in which it has affected the field of academic biblical studies. Biblioblogging has made possible rapid dissemination of information on new discoveries and other matters of interest – as well as dissemination of accessible specialist commentary on such matters – to a vastly enlarged audience, an effect increasingly amplified by the new "new media" such as podcasts, Facebook, and Twitter. It has helped to put a personal face on biblical scholarship by allowing scholars to speak with an informal public voice different from the voice of academic publication; it has encouraged biblical scholars to interact publicly with popular culture, including not only dubious television documentaries, but also the cinema and television series such as Lost; it has helped scholars to mobilize in support of their colleagues in an era of job cuts and financially threatened departments; and it has contributed at least a little to the accelerating erosion of the authority of the mainstream media. Blogging is likely to be with us for a long time to come and to be increasingly incorporated into our field as a fruitful contribution to biblical scholarship.
|
Cursing Jesus: Maledictory Memories in the Infancy Gospel of Thomas and Its History of Interpretation
Program Unit: Memory Perspectives on Early Christianity and Its Greco-Roman Context
Stephen Davis, Yale University
This paper will explore how ancient “pagans,” Jews, and Christians interpreted and contextualized the cursing prowess of Jesus in the Infancy Gospel of Thomas. Drawing on sociologies of memory—and examining sources including Celsus, the Talmud, and the manuscript tradition of the infancy gospel itself—I will show how such early readers made sense of such stories of a young Jesus via their own cultural memories connected with cursing as a ritual practice in late antiquity.
|
Systemic Violence in Job 1–2
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Kirsten Dawson, University of Otago
Drawing on Slavoj Žižek’s book Violence, this paper uses his threefold schema of subjective, systemic, and symbolic violence as a framework for an examination of the explicit and implicit violence in the prose prologue of the book of Job. Taken at face value, Job 1-2 narrates events of great violence directed at a single human being, portraying Job as the ultimate victim. While the subjective violence that befalls Job is well-recognised, in this paper I will focus on the systemic violence in which the prosperous Job is enmeshed, with particular reference to the institution of slavery. This approach reveals a different angle on the figure of Job. I will also touch on the symbolic violence which underlies systemic and subjective violence. Some implications that these observations might have for interpreting violence in the book of Job as a whole will be suggested.
|
The Cross and the Cosmos in Galatians
Program Unit: Pauline Theology
Martin de Boer, Vrije Universiteit-Amsterdam
Invited Paper
|
YHWH's Weather God Characteristics
Program Unit: Unity and Diversity in Early Jewish Monotheisms
Izaak J. de Hulster, Georg-August Universitaet-Goettingen
No abstract
|
Tools for Iconography: An Introduction to Image Sources and Practical Issues of Processing Pictorial Material
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Iconography and the Bible
Izaak J. de Hulster, Georg-August-Universitaet Goettingen
Iconography and iconographic exegesis is a growing field. Simultaneously, more and more pictorial material is made accessible through internet collections and databases. Despite these developments hard copy collections are still indispensable. In order to facilitate “Communicating and Educating through Ancient Near Eastern Images", I provide a guided tour through the landscape of image resources.
Important hard copy sources will be surveyed and internet resources will be introduced (especially Bibel+Orient Museum Database Online, BODO, with an online presentation). Practical issues of how to employ images in the classroom and in publications will be addressed, ranging from the choice of images and the information which needs to be provided about images to the quality of the images and publishing houses’ policies regarding copyright on images.
|
Psychologist in Private Practice: God as Bipolar or Paranoid Schizophrenic
Program Unit:
Anthony De Orio, Alpha Psychological Services
*
|
The Contrasting Polysemous Meaning of Herem in Biblical Hebrew: A Cognitive-Linguistic Approach
Program Unit: Biblical Lexicography
J.A. de Prenter, Catholic University of Leuven
As many scholars have noticed, the noun herem is related to entirely different semantic fields. On the one hand, it is strongly connected with the root qadaš in Priestly texts where it denotes a ‘holy thing’, while the cognate verb hrm means ‘to consecrate’ (Lev 27,21.29-29; Num 18,14; Ezek 44,29). On the other hand, herem is situated in the semantic field of destruction in Deuteronomy (Deut 7,2.4.25-26; 13,14-15; 20,16-18) and is combined with roots like nahah.
Brekelmans (1959) and Lohfink (1982) developed a diachronic semantic model to explain this double nature of the term: originally related to the domain of war in which herem has religious overtones, the term underwent a diachronic change to a ‘profane annihilation’ due to important historical and social changes in society. Not satisfied by this account, Stern (1991), Schäfer-Lichtenberger (1995) and Nelson (1997) devoted attention to the conceptions of the world underlying the concept, but did not come to an adequate description of its semantic structure which accounts for the double nature of the term.
In this paper I will offer a new perspective on the meaning of the concept herem informed by the semantic models of ‘Prototype theory’ (Rosch:1975) and the ‘Radial Network Model’ (Lakoff:1987). Prototypically, the term herem could best be labeled as ‘taboo’. The term is used to describe what is separated from the ordinary sphere of life, either because it belongs to the sphere of the sacred (qodeš) or because it is defiled (halal). The two meanings of holiness and defilement – which seem mutually exclusive to our conceptual understanding, thus form the polysemous core of the term’s semantic structure. Once this is established, I will develop a ‘radial network’ of the concept, showing that in particular the meaning of ‘defilement’ gave rise to new meanings by means of metonymy and generalization.
|
Society of Biblical Literature – Is the Name Appropriate
Program Unit:
Kristin De Troyer, University of St. Andrews-Scotland
*
|
The Different Books of Joshua
Program Unit: Joshua-Judges
Kristin De Troyer, University of St Andrews
The Book of Joshua is often studied in relation to the Deuteronomistic Literature. Most of the studies use the Masoretic Text of the Book of Joshua for their analyses. The Old Greek text of the Book of Joshua, however, is at times different from the Massoretic Text: it sometimes is shorter, sometimes longer and even having some difference in sequence of episodes. The question now arises whether the Old Greek translation is older than the Masoretic text, and then, it certainly must be used when studying Deuteronomistic theories, or younger, or whether the two versions are parallel to each other. Moreover, the important witness from Qumran, 4QJosh a and b need also be taken into consideration. This paper aims at reconstructing the history of the Book of Joshua using especially the Septuagint and Qumran witnesses.
|
Popular Reading: Method and Theory
Program Unit: Latino/a/e and Latin American Biblical Interpretation
Hans de Wit, Vrije Universiteit
"Popular Reading: Method and Theory"
|
The Role of Repetition in Understanding the Ritual Process of Acts 9:1–19
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Rebecca Dean, University of Oxford
The Acts account of Saul’s Damascus road experience can be interpreted as a ritual process of boundary breaking and “recruitment”/“conversion”. This paper will analyse the events described in Acts 9:1-19, developing existing studies of this subject by taking the two later repetitions of this experience (22:1-21 and 26:12-23) into account. It will be suggested that consideration of the later reports alongside the first causes a shift in our understanding of the ritual process as it is presented in Acts.
When we take these later reports into account, we find that the process of ritual transformation and boundary crossing is perhaps not as complete and irreversible as has previously been implied. In the second report, for instance, boundaries are re-crossed as part of S/Paul’s attempt to affiliate himself with the Jewish pilgrims. For example, the negative implications of S/Paul’s blindness as part of the liminal phase of his transformation are re-interpreted as a mark of special access to the divine (22:11). Furthermore, his claims to status and authority are those that originate from the old group (22:3); they have not been discarded in the ritual process.
This paper will also suggest that the process of transformation of status and boundary crossing continues as S/Paul re-tells his experience. While his reports fail to convince his immediate audience, it is through these rejections that his solidarity with the Christian believers is fully established. He embodies within himself the group as a whole, and his personal defence becomes an apologetic on behalf of the wider Christian community. We find that the idea of evocation of memory within ritual is turned on its head as it is through a process of recalling the memory of the ritual itself that Luke’s Paul finally finds his place as a representative of the Christian community.
|
A Voice of Their Own: Catholic Preaching, 1919–1941
Program Unit: Academy of Homiletics
Guerric DeBona, St. Meinrad School of Theology
*
|
The Bible as Transformational Object: The Psychoanalytic Theories of Christopher Bollas and Their Relevance for Religious Educators, Pastors, and Scholars
Program Unit: Psychology and Biblical Studies
Elizabeth Berne DeGear, Union Theological Seminary
This paper introduces some of the psychoanalytic theories of Christopher Bollas to the SBL community, and offers practical applications to our work with the bible.
Bollas argues that 'to be' and 'to appropriate' are the same thing. The idiomatic way we experience and live out our true self is synonymous with the way we appropriate ‘objects’ (both the human and cultural kinds). Each person’s object relations are quite idiomatic and constitute no less than the expression of the true self.
Bollas coins a term: destiny drive. He says the destiny drive is the inherent instinct we have to live out our idiom. And since our use of objects IS the way we live, it is vitally important that our idiomatic ways of relating to objects are nurtured from the earliest age. We need this proper handling for our destiny drive to 'kick in'.
With a knowledge of how important it is to help a child discover his own idiom of relating to the world, religious educators can make learning what each child’s idiom is the first step in their work. And *then* they can offer each child the bible *in such a way* that each can relate with the bible as the child’s inner nature guides them to do. In this way the bible is ‘unlocked’ to be what we know it can be and what Bollas speaks of: a transformational object. In idiomatic relationship with the bible, a child can grow into an adult, discovering and living out her or his destiny.
Bollas points us to the dialectic nature of our relationship with objects. As we choose and use them, both they and we are transformed. This paper also explores the significance of this dialectic for the way pastors ‘preach’ the bible and the way we as scholars approach it.
|
Community Ideology and the Goal of Textual Criticism
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
Steve Delamarter, George Fox University
This paper will describe the relationship between the ideology of believing communities and the nature of the text-critical enterprise that they set for themselves. In particular we will show the correlation between the master story of the community and its understanding of the text that needs to be recovered, preserved or replicated in its bible. In our presentation, we will give special attention to the Ethiopic tradition, but the patterns of relationship exist for all communities that produce their own biblical texts. Having constructed the typology we will include a discussion of the “master story” of the modern, Western church with its commitment to the likely original as reconstructed by scholars of textual criticism. While the modern Western church tends to think of its approach as sui generis in comparison to what they call the ecclesiastical text of other traditions, we will demonstrate the essential unity of their approach with the approach carried out by the other traditions.
|
Two Agenda Items for Ethiopian Studies in the Coming Three Years: 1) A Comprehensive Database of Ethiopic Manuscript Images and Metadata; and 2) A Study of Scribal Practice in the Ethiopic Tradition
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Steve Delamarter, George Fox University
This presentation will discuss two projects that should flow out of the Ethiopic Manuscript Imaging Project (EMIP). The first considers the need for a comprehensive digital database of Ethiopic manuscript images, including images from collections beyond those of the EMIP. The second describes work that we are already doing to analyze typologies and historical developments in Ethiopic scribal practices.
|
The Old Testament in the European Choral Tradition
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Katharine Dell, University of Cambridge
European choral music is rich in its use of Old Testament texts. This paper is interested in how key biblical stories are conveyed through this medium, how biblical texts are often placed alongside other salient texts from other parts of the bible, from both Old and New Testaments, often in the service of a Christianized interpretation, and how the text is translated by librettists in relation to the new context. It will also look at the effect of the musical techniques employed in the choral music upon the audience and how such techniques convey a particular interpretation of the message of the text. The key examples will be Mendelssohn’s Elijah (based on I Kgs 18 – 2 Kgs 2) and Walton’s Belshazzar’s Feast (based on Dan 5).
|
The Question of God and the Rhetoric of Metaphor
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Carol J. Dempsey, University of Portland
The central character within the Hebrew Bible is God. Who was this "God" for the ancient Israelite community, and how are communities of faith today to make sense of Israel's God? This paper explores the writings of the prophets in relation to God and the rhetoric of metaphor. The paper considers the theological implications of how God is portrayed in various prophetic texts and brings into conversation the recent work of Julia O'Brien (Challenging Prophetic Metaphor: Theology and Ideology in the Prophets, 2008), Carleen Mandolofo (Daughter Zion Talks Back to the Prophets, 2007), and Eric Seibert (Disturbing Divine Behavior: Troubling Old Testament Images of God, 2009).
|
Arslan Tash
Program Unit: Paleographical Studies in the Ancient Near East
Aaron Demsky, Bar Ilan University
The Assyrian conquest of the ANE forcibly brought together different peoples to create the first great syncretistic world culture. Illuminating this syncretism is the first incantation tablet from Arslan Tash, published in the 1930's. It was found at a site identified as Haddattu, i.e., “new town", established by Tiglath Pileser III. The text is written in an Aramaic script, paleographically dated to the mid-seventh century BCE, while the words are in a Tyrian dialect of Phoenician, with some Aramaisms, The illustrated text is a remnant of Phoenician literature and gives voice to the otherwise silent exiles caught up in the social and religious upheaval of the time.
For some scholars this fascinating document has been judged a scholarly forgery, for others its unique features have yet to be properly explained. A case in point is the meaning of the word HNQT.
In this paper I argue for the authenticity of the incantation by noting for the first time that this singular term is the Phoenician cognate and perhaps the source of “sphinx”, from the Greek root meaning “to strangle”. Supporting this observation is the sphinx like feminine demon depicted on the obverse side of the tablet.
|
Constructing Righteousness: The 'Better Righteousness' of Matthew as Part of the Development of Christian Identity
Program Unit: Construction of Christian Identities
Brian Dennert, Loyola University of Chicago
Since the issue of righteousness is essential for group identification, the long-noted emphasis of Matthew on a new form of righteousness, one that exceeds that of the Pharisees and scribes, may play a fundamental role in forming a new group identity for the community and constitute an element in "the birth of Christianity," as it differentiates the group from Jewish communities with particular attention to its practice of Torah in line with cultural situation. While often noted as a polemic directed towards rising Formative Judaism, the use of the Pharisees as the advocates of another righteousness also seems to oppose the influence of Jews among the Jesus following-Christ-worshippers in Matthew's community, countering their interpretation of the Law and the Prophets. This occurs through critiquing the Pharisees on issues involved in the Matthean community, as well as his presentation of them furthering their teaching, potentially within the community. Matthew responds to their endeavors through this polemic by showing the destructiveness of their teaching, as they prevent entrance into the kingdom and lead people to judgment. Furthermore, he associates them with the Jewish leaders who helped cause the death of Jesus, as they too distort the truth and elevate themselves; thus, their ideas correspond to Jewish groups and not Jesus, making his community a non-Jewish one. In contraposition, Matthew constructs a "new" form of righteousness based on the person of Jesus, as the Matthean Jesus teaches the true meaning of the Law and the Prophets. Therefore, Matthew lays claim to the Old Testament, demonstrating that the community has an ancient standard of righteousness, while also dissociating them from "mainstream Judaism" and grounding their identity in Jesus Christ and his teaching of righteousness. Thus, this gospel may help provide the "how" and the "why" of ideas that would later become characteristic of "mainstream Christianity."
|
"The Rejection of Wisdom's Call": Matthew's Use of Proverbs 1:20–33 in the Parable of Children in the Marketplace
Program Unit: Intertextuality in the New Testament
Brian C. Dennert, Loyola University of Chicago
A redactional examination of the parable of the Children in the Marketplace (Matt 11:16-19//Luke [Q] 7:31-35) utilizing recent advances in Q studies discloses an echo to Prov 1:20-33 in the Matthean form of the parable. This intertextual connection occurs through Matthew's heightening of already existing associations between the imagery of the Q parable and the rejection of Wisdom's call in Prov 1:20-33, as well as Matthew's integration of Q material with Markan traditions and his Sondergut. Since the identification of Jesus as Wisdom can rest on this intertexual link in addition to the parallelism between the works of the Messiah (Matt 11:2) and the works of Wisdom (Matt 11:19), this echo strengthens the Wisdom Christology of Matthew advanced by M. Jack Suggs. Furthermore, its placement issues a commentary on the ministry of Jesus and the Matthean community. In locating the parable and reference to Wisdom after the ministry of Jesus in chapters 8 and 9, Matthew allegorizes Jesus' ministry, presenting him as Wisdom rejected by the "simple" to whom he calls (Israel). By acting like the "childish" judges of the parable in rejecting John and Jesus, Israel opposes the last messenger of Wisdom in the era of promise (John) and now faces judgment for rejecting Wisdom herself (Jesus). In addition, the mission discourse (chapter 10) preceding this parable reveals the Matthean community to be the new messengers of Wisdom, as they speak the same message, perform the same works, and face the same hostility as Jesus/Wisdom. Since their missionary activity is part of Wisdom's work and the justification of Wisdom comes through the messianic works performed by Jesus, they are the new locus for blessing or judgment. Therefore, this echo to Prov 1:20-33 has Christological and ecclesiological significance for Matthew and his community.
|
James and the Testament of Job: The Evidence for Intertextuality
Program Unit: Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
David A. deSilva, Ashland Theological Seminary
The prominence of the language of “patient endurance” (makrothymia, hypomone) in James 5:7-11, thematic also throughout T. Job 1-27, together with the explicit mention of Job as exemplary in this regard, typically invite some comparison between the two texts. The connections between the passages, however, are more intricate than scholars usually discern.
The passage from James is a well-constructed argument promoting the virtue of endurance, specifically with an eye to God’s future intervention, as in the Testament. Job’s example serves directly to support the call to “patiently endure” (Jas 5:7), as it does in Job’s commendation of this virtue to his children (T. Job 27:7). James adds a rationale to explain the cause of the happy outcome of Job’s endurance: “because the Lord is very sympathetic and compassionate” (Jas 5:11), qualities of God that also promote endurance in T. Job. 26.4-6. Both – and, as far as I can tell, only – James and the Testament invoke these qualities of God specifically as a rationale for endurance and an assurance of the better consequences that attend endurance in connection with Job’s story.
James and Testament of Job, unlike canonical Job, do not raise the problem of suffering without knowing why. Both texts prepare readers to interpret sufferings and challenges as “trials” by means of which virtue can be tested, proven, and eventually rewarded, even crowned with victory (Jas 1:12; T. Job 4:10). This fundamental orientation runs throughout both texts.
While the difficulties arriving at consensus regarding the date of Testament of Job give one pause in arguing for direct literary dependency, the linguistic, rhetorical, and thematic connections between James and the Testament suggest some kind of close relationship between the two documents, with the former presupposing the traditions expressed – and the formulations in which they are expressed – of the latter.
|
Justification According to Faith and Its Reception in the Greek Orthodox Liturgical Tradition
Program Unit: Bible in Eastern and Oriental Orthodox Traditions
Athanasios Despotis, University of Bonn
The understanding of the Pauline theology of justification according to faith has been a matter of dispute between different Christian confessions for many centuries. However, no attempt has yet been made to describe the way the Orthodox Church understands this Pauline teaching as reflected in its liturgy. In this paper, therefore, many significant expressions found in Greek Orthodox hymns and liturgical texts concerning justification according to faith will be presented and a description of how this Pauline theme is understood within the Orthodox rite will be given. Lastly, the paper shall offer an optimistic answer to important ecumenical questions arising from the different understandings of this Pauline teaching between Orthodox, Protestant, and Roman Catholic commentators on Paul.
|
From Jesus Movement to Christianity: A Model for the Interpretation
Program Unit: Construction of Christian Identities
Adriana Destro, University of Bologna
When, where and on which grounds can Early Christianity be considered to be autonomous from Judaism, or from one of the various Judaic tendencies of their time? Two or more religious systems can be considered autonomous if they are rooted in different social groups, and experience separate religious practices and worldviews. A Christian community should be considered distinct from Judaism when it consciously differentiates itself in all these three fundamental elements.
|
In Memoriam: The Invention of the Death of Jesus
Program Unit: Memory Perspectives on Early Christianity and Its Greco-Roman Context
Arthur Dewey, Xavier University
Abstract to be made available by meeting.
|
A Ugaritic Incantation against Gonorrhea
Program Unit: Ugaritic Studies and Northwest Semitic Epigraphy
Heath Dewrell, The Johns Hopkins University
Since the discovery of RIH 78/20 (=KTU 1.169) at Ras Ibn Hani in 1978, many have worked on the text. Indeed, at least a dozen scholars have published translations of it, many of these differing in their understanding of precisely what the text describes. Despite this diversity in opinion, the current general consensus is that it is a Ugaritic incantation designed to treat an individual who has been afflicted by a demon (or demons) resulting in an “affliction of the penis.” Most scholars understand this “affliction” as sexual impotence. A cultic officiant presided over the ceremony to treat the malady, speaking the effective words of the incantation and probably performing ritual actions described in the text. Although it has a clear utilitarian function, the incantation is composed in a poetic style, making heavy use of parallelism and figurative language. Building on the work of previous scholars, this study suggests a new understanding of several key portions of the text. Most significantly, this paper argues that the victim was not suffering from sexual impotence but rather from a sexually transmitted disease. Further, it demonstrates that the incantation explicitly describes the symptoms of the disease, including fever, chills, and penile discharge. In addition to presenting a new edition of the text to support this argument, this study turns to other ancient texts, especially Greek and Egyptian medical texts, in order to demonstrate the existence of such a disease in the ancient world. Finally, in order to justify labeling the disease “gonorrhea” this paper compares the symptoms described in the text to those of the modern disease bearing same name.
|
Beyond 612 BCE: The Afterlife of Nineveh
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Michael Dick, Siena College
The Israelite prophet Nahum had presided over her funeral: “Nineveh would not arise again (Nahum 1:9).” However, the month of Abu (July/August) 612 BCE, would not be absolute and final. In this presentation, I shall trace Nineveh’s perdurance on two distinct levels.
First, archaeological evidence mounts that Nineveh survived into later periods; the American archaeologist D. Stronach found four levels of post-Assyrian occupation before the Hellenistic period. The city also played an important role in the Greco-Parthian and Sassanid periods, when settlement gradually passed to the west bank of the Tigris (Mosul). It is possible that we even have cuneiform tablets from post-612 Nineveh. Cult for some of Nineveh’s deities (e.g. Ishtar of Nineveh, Nabû, and Aššur) may have survived even into the Common Era.
Second, I trace the survival of Nineveh in literature as a paradigm (see LXX Nahum 3:6). Here we find in Seleucid cuneiform, Aramaic, Demotic, Hebrew, Greek and Latin texts—of different genres—Nineveh as a symbol of fallen arrogance; in this vein, she was the first of the riparian whores—to be followed by Babylon and Rome. She and her legendary founder Ninos also symbolized the first imperial power; in early Roman historiographers, the age of great empires began with Assyria and then passed west to Rome. The Roman poet Q. Ennius seems to have synchronized the founding of Rome with the fall of Nineveh.
|
The Canaanite Woman (Matt. 15:22–28): Discharging the Stigma of Single Moms in the African-American Church
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Febbie Dickerson, Vanderbilt University
*
|
Did Paul Expect His Converts to Further the Gospel?
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
John Paul Dickson, Macquarie University
This paper seeks to answer the question of its title with both a yes and a no. Many commentators, especially those with contemporary ecclesiastical concerns, have argued that Paul did indeed require converts to engage in deliberate proclamation of the gospel. While sympathetic to this widely held view, this paper argues that, in fact, Paul's concept of congregational commitment to the cause of the gospel was carefully distinguished from his own calling and from that of his co-workers.
|
My Father Is King: Examining the Legitimacy of Authority in the Abimelech Narrative
Program Unit: Social Sciences and the Interpretation of the Hebrew Scriptures
Linda A. Dietch, Drew University
Judges 9 recounts a brutal tale of fratricide, demagoguery, and retribution. When Gideon dies, a power struggle ensues as his concubine’s son Abimelech garners the support of his maternal kin and the Shechemite elite and kills his 70 half-brothers to become the sole leader of Shechem. Wholesale slaughter results as his right to rule is later contested, apparently also on the basis of lineage. Ultimately, the challenge to his authority, and the subsequent deaths of Abimelech and his supporters, is described as being incited by the deity as retribution for their evil actions. Based upon a reading of the final form of the Abimelech narrative, this paper explores the bases for establishing the legitimacy of political authority by considering the relationship between kingship and kinship, the effect of violence directed both outside and within the social group, and the role of religious belief and practice. Utilizing narrative analysis and a sociological methodology that draws on understandings of kinship-based social organization and concepts drawn from the work of Pierre Bourdieu, the text will be interrogated in the follow ways: What conditions or actions establish or undermine the legitimacy of authority? How does rhetoric advance or denigrate each character’s authority? What might consideration of the political and religious fields and their concomitant forms of capital reveal about the social realities behind the story? How does Bourdieu’s concept of doxa influence appraisal of the text’s messages?
|
Interacting Metaphors: Metaphoric Complexity in Biblical Poetry and Prose
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible and Cognate Literature
Sarah Dille, College of Wooster
Metaphoric expressions vary greatly in complexity and in conventionality/innovation. Lakoff and Turner have argued that metaphor is integral to all human thought and language, but that poetry utilizes metaphor differently than "ordinary language" (More than Cool Reason, 53-55). This paper will explore whether degrees of metaphoric complexity are related to literary genre in biblical literature (broadly prose and poetry but more specific genre designations as well). Is
poetry more likely to mix or juxtapose metaphors? Does juxtaposition of metaphor function the same way as a mixed metaphor?
|
The Fate and Power of Heroic Bones and the Politics of Bone Transferal in Ancient Greece and Israel
Program Unit: Society for Ancient Mediterranean Religions
Brian R. Doak, Harvard University
This paper is an attempt to read the narratives recounting the fate of Saul’s bones in 1Sam 31:1-13 and 2Sam 21:1-14 in light of what is known about heroic relics—specifically the bones of the hero—and the politics of hero cults in the western Iron Age Mediterranean. Specifically, I attempt to draw together several lines of thought regarding the existence of an Israelite “heroic culture” and “heroic age” that parallel similar developments in ancient Greece and elsewhere, and I argue that Saul’s status as an Israelite “hero” is an appropriate and hitherto underexplored lens through which to explore the meaning and power of Saul’s dead body. First, I review Greek concepts regarding the battle for the body of the hero and briefly demonstrate the notion that divine favor is bestowed upon the possessor of the heroic body as an important part of Greek hero cult, evident in the movement of Theseus’ bones from Skyros to Athens (recorded in Plutarch’s Life of Theseus) and the transfer of Orestes’ bones from Tegea to Sparta (in Herodotus’ Histories), as well as the religious dynamics evident in Oedipus at Colonus, among many other examples. Second, I explore the biblical passages regarding Saul’s death and bone transferal with specific attention to the religio-political drama culminating in the burial of Saul’s body in his home territory of Benjamin, only after which a deadly conflict is settled and a famine ended. The attention given to the power of the bones and the dead body in this biblical account is, I argue, analogous to certain Greek accounts in important and revealing ways, as both contexts reveal situations in which the location of a hero’s body has significant implications for either blessing or disaster for the possessors of that body.
|
Ezekiel’s Topography of the (Un-)Heroic Dead in Ezek. 32:17–32
Program Unit: Book of Ezekiel
Brian R. Doak, Harvard University
This essay is an attempt to address several interpretive problems in Ezek. 32:17-32 in light of religious ideas prominent in ancient Mediterranean expressions of hero cult. Previous studies have not adequately dealt with the richness of Ezekiel’s striking and unusual imagery in this passage, and I contend that a reading which more fully develops the meaning of Ezekiel’s presentation vis-à-vis the history of religious ideas regarding the power of the heroic dead is the most appropriate one in terms of Ezekiel’s overarching theological message in this chapter. First, I argue that Ezekiel’s invocation of ancient Israelite heroic traditions involving the Gibborim and Nephilim are more pronounced than previous interpreters have been willing to acknowledge, and that a more complete exposition of the passage in light of Ezekiel’s (re)interpretive motif involving the roll of the “heroes of old” (v. 27, with the LXX) yields nuances that have not received adequate exploration. Second, I demonstrate the manner in which a fuller integration of the exegesis of this passage with cognate traditions regarding the afterlife of heroes in ancient Greece and elsewhere in the Mediterranean reveals hitherto un-noticed nuances behind several enigmatic phrases in this passage (e.g., in vv. 23, 25, and 27). This demonstration provides a more detailed and forceful context supporting the claim already made by several commentators that the theological importance of Ezek. 32:17-32 rests specifically with its rejection of heroic ideals. Finally, my analysis shows that this passage exhibits a more striking authorial and theological unity than has typically been assumed, viz. that Ezekiel’s pervasive heroic imagery and reference to the underworld form a unified, coherent, and provocative description of an impotent and (un-)heroic foreign horde inhabiting their own ignominious places in the afterlife.
|
A ‘Corpus Permixtum’: The Cultural Significance of Letters in Second Temple Literature
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Lutz Doering, Durham University
Jewish letters have often been studied within the boundaries of individual language corpora: Hebrew, Aramaic, and Greek. However, as the Bar Kokhba letters show, this linguistic separation is not useful, since here all three languages were employed, and some of the addressees even received letters in any of these. Another problem with the corpus approach is the gap in documentary letter finds in Hebrew between the 6th century BCE and the Bar Kokhba revolt and in Aramaic between the 3rd century BCE and the first Jewish revolt. Have Hebrew and Aramaic letter writing had to be re-invented? This paper argues (1) that letters in the literary tradition of Second Temple Judaism (particularly in Ezra and Daniel MT, the Dead Sea Scrolls, and the ‘Septuagint’ as well as other Greek versions) are important witnesses for an epistolary praxis in Aramaic and perhaps in Hebrew; (2) that some of the evidence for this comes from letters preserved only in Greek translation; and (3) that some features of literary letters benefitted either from crossing language boundaries proper or from linguistic cross-fertilisation. Among these are the deployment of the letter as a literary macro-form (see Epistle of Jeremiah, later: Second Baruch) and the shape and semantic potential of epistolary formulae. What is required, thus, is an ‘inter-corpus’, cultural approach to ancient Jewish letter writing. Such an approach will also pay attention to the frequent use of letters to address communities rather than individuals.
|
Good, but not Good Enough—On the Exclusion of Persons with Disabilities in the Qumran Scrolls
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Anke Dorman, University of Zurich
The social and religious position of disabled community members in the Qumran Scrolls can be investigated by taking a closer look at the context and addressees of each regulation that applies to disability. Five Qumran texts relate to the topic: The Rule of the Congregation (1QSa), the Damascus Document (D), the War Scroll (1QM), MMT, and the Temple Scroll (11QT). The very existence of disability regulations implies that disabled persons were present in the communities behind these texts. Although the exclusion of disabled persons is obvious, the contexts to which these exclusions apply are very diverse and have different addressees. What is the rationale to disqualify or exclude persons with disabilities? Is there a link to ritual uncleanness? Is there a common denominator, or must we conclude that the reason for the exclusion is just as diverse as the contexts and addressees of each text under consideration?
|
Reading Galatians in Tanzania in Light of Male Circumcision as an HIV/AIDS Intervention
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
David J. Downs, Fuller Theological Seminary
Approximately 2.7 million people were infected with HIV in 2008, with 1.9 million of them living in sub-Saharan Africa. Among the available or potential preventative interventions-- including microbicides, postexposure prophylaxis, condom distribution, and vaccines -- one of the most effective is male circumcision (MC). Three large randomized controlled trials have shown that MC reduces the risk of HIV transmission among heterosexual males by about 60%. Yet in many parts of sub-Saharan Africa, where the burden of the HIV/AIDS crisis is greatest, the level of acceptability and rates of practice of MC are quite low. In the Mwanza region of NW Tanzania, for example, less than 20% of Christian adolescent males are circumcised. Many factors contribute to the low rates of MC among Christian males in this region, including tribal practices (i.e., the Sukuma people, the dominant tribe in the region, are traditionally non-circumcising), religious identities (i.e., Muslim males in the region are circumcised at much higher rates), and the fact that the medical procedure is not readily available in the area’s hospitals and health care centers. Moreover, claims that the Bible— particularly the Apostle Paul— prohibits circumcision for Christian males also figure prominently in the low rates of MC in NW Tanzania. Drawing on recent work on the Pauline writings that has emphasized the apocalyptic dimensions of the new eschatological community created in Christ (e.g., J. Louis Martyn, Theological Issues in the Letters of Paul [Abingdon, 1997]; Love Sechrest, A Former Jew: Paul and the Dialectics of Race [T&T Clark, 2009]), this paper will explore the possibility of a contextual and theological reading of Galatians in light of MC as a public health issue.
|
The Relationship of Joshua and Judges in the Late Stages of Redaction History
Program Unit: Joshua-Judges
Thomas Dozeman, United Theological Seminary
The repetitions, textual breaks, and interrelationships between Joshua 24 and Judges 1-2 raise a series of questions about the composition of the individual books and how they may have been combined to form a larger literary corpus. The problems have attracted a rich history of research (e.g., Amit, Auld, Becker, Blum, Brekelmans, Brettler, Jericke, Noort, Rake, Römer, Rösel, Weinfeld, Younger) as the basis for any future work on the topic. The potential breakdown in the influential literary hypotheses of the Hexateuch and the Deuteronomistic History provides the context to raise new questions about the composition of Joshua as an independent book and the forging of the literary relationship between Joshua and Judges at a late stage of editorial composition.
|
Jesus' Ancestors and African Ancestors: A Contextual Reading of Matthew 1:1–18
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Jonathan A. Draper, University of KwaZulu-Natal
For most Western scholars working in the historical critical tradition, and indeed for most Western Christians, the genealogy in Matthew 1:1-18 is of little interest. The main point of contestation is whether it has any historical credibility and whether it can be reconciled with the genealogy in Luke 3:23-38. However, for African readers, for whom the role of the ancestors is of crucial theological significance, this passage can play a key role in the interpretation of the Gospel. Matthew seems to affirm the importance of biological ancestors for a theological understanding of Jesus, and yet subtle yet significant signals in the genealogy simultaneously challenges it. This ambivalence recurs in the passage in Matthew 22:23-46. On the one hand, Jesus makes the “living dead” ancestors of Israel the pivot point of his argument for the resurrection of the dead (22:31-33). On the other hand, the Davidic ancestry of Jesus, which is the guiding principle of the genealogy, is problematized in 22:41-46. This simultaneous affirmation of the importance of the ancestors and the problematization of their importance for understanding who Jesus is, signals that ancestors are important for understanding Matthew’s Christology and opens up a fruitful narrative gap for an African contextual reading of the text.
|
Exegeting the Darkness: The Botswana Colonial Bible
Program Unit: African Association for the Study of Religions
Musa W. Dube, University of Botswana
*
|
Did Shalmaneser Conquer Samaria?
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Peter Dubovsky, Pontifical Biblical Institute
The only piece of extra-biblical evidence regarding Shalmaneser’s conquest of Samaria is preserved in Neo-Babylonian Chronicle 1 (BM 92502). This tablet reports that Shalmaneser destroyed the city URU.šá-ma/ba-ra-‘-in. Some Assyrologists, however, have hesitated to identify this city with Samaria. The reasons proposed are twofold: first, the handwriting of the scribe is unclear and therefore the third sign can be either ma or ba; second, the spelling of Samaria in this tablet is different from the spelling used in other Akkadian sources. Despite these problems, many modern historians use Chronicle 1 for the reconstruction of the fall of the Northern Kingdom. In this paper I will present a detailed analysis of the cuneiform signs based on enhanced digital photography of tablet BM 92502, which can help us to resolve the question of whether the city mentioned in this tablet can be identified with the city of Samaria.
|
What’s in a Title? Rethinking Women's Leadership in the Ancient Synagogue
Program Unit: Archaeological Excavations and Discoveries: Illuminating the Biblical World
Carrie Duncan, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
Twenty three inscriptions found around the Roman world link individual Jewish women with specific titles, including head of the synagogue, mother of the synagogue, leader, elder, and priest. These titles seem to associate the bearers with synagogue activity and have been cited in numerous studies to support the assertion that women held positions of leadership and authority in ancient synagogues. This paper focuses on theoretical assumptions, typically made by scholars in studies of women leaders in the synagogue, which are related to the study of gender in the ancient world. These assumptions include the dichotomy between honor and function, action ‘in her own right’ and the naturalization of ideals of personal freedom and autonomy. Challenging these assumptions is a first step towards reevaluating the meaning and significance of women’s synagogue titles, which will contribute in turn to more nuanced interpretations of gender and power relationships within the ancient synagogue setting.
|
How Far Can You Go? Jesus, John, the Synoptics, and Other Texts
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
Ismo Dunderberg, University of Helsinki
The paper pinpoints three questions related to the use of the Gospel of John as a potential source for the historical Jesus, and reviews how these questions have been addressed in the John, Jesus, and History Project (JJH) thus far: 1) The figure of "the beloved disciple," not mentioned in the synoptic gospels, appears in John in passages that have clear synoptic parallels. It has even been suggested that these passages in John are dependent on the synoptic gospels (Neirynck, Thyen, Kügler etc.). How does the alternative perspective emerging from the JJH respond to this view? How does it explain the absence of the beloved disciple in the synoptic parallels? And what does this perspective make of the fact that we find similar figures of authentication in other early Christian gospels and revelation dialogues? 2) How does the new perspective explain Jesus' secret dialogue with Nicodemus in John 3, where scholars have previously detected strong affinities with Hermetic traditions? 3) If the new perspective allows for the possibility that the Gospel of John, in spite of all the differences to the Synoptics, can be a reliable source of the historical Jesus, what should we make of the other "different" gospels (of Thomas, Judas, Mary etc.)? It would seem a natural consequence of the new perspective that the potential value of (some of) these other early Christian texts as witnesses to the historical Jesus should be taken more seriously than before. Is JJH willing to go into that direction, or does it play a role that the Gospel of John is in the canon, while the other "different" gospels are not?
|
Exile and Ambivalence
Program Unit:
Ben Dunning, Fordham University
This paper examines the work that the rhetoric of exile and displacement performs in the thought of two roughly contemporary early Christian writers of the late second and early third centuries: Clement of Alexandria and Tertullian of Carthage. As is increasingly well documented, the theme of the valorized exile was frequently invoked in the early imperial period as a strategy for articulating identity amidst the cultural complexities of the expanding Roman Empire. Here Tim Whitmarsh has drawn a contrast between early Christian narratives of persecution and displacement (i.e., martyrologies) that work “to create a sense both of united values and of the potency of the message” and Greek narratives of exile in the Roman period whose projects of identity formation he characterizes as more complex than Christian narratives (Whitmarsh 2001, 135). Building on Whitmarsh’s work—while also questioning the starkness of the above contrast—I will examine the complexities and ambivalences that attend the trope of displacement in selected writings of Clement and Tertullian. Clement figures his ideal Christian as a displaced stranger and sojourner who “lives in the city as in a desert, so that the place may not compel him” (Strom. 7.12). Here he attempts to draw a firm boundary that separates his Christian “exile” from the supposed dangers and delights of the paradigmatic Roman city. On a similar (if somewhat more aggravated) note, Tertullian deploys the common Pauline opposition between earthly and heavenly citizenships to represent Christian identity in terms of a sharply-defined reversal in which, through the categorical rejection of the Roman city, “those who mourn are happy” (Cor. 13). My analysis will explore the ways in which these disavowals of “the city” by means of the rhetoric of exile attempt to render invisible a pervasive ambivalence that characterizes both thinkers’ projects—that is, a complex interplay of derision and desire that, even while disavowed, proves nonetheless constitutive for these two visions of early Christian identity.
|
Mysticism, Femininity, and Difference in Badiou’s Theory of Pauline Discourses
Program Unit: Gender, Sexuality, and the Bible
Ben Dunning, Fordham University
The proposed paper examines the placement and significance of sexual difference in Alain Badiou’s philosophical reappraisal of Paul (Saint Paul: The Foundation of Universalism). Feminist scholars (McNulty 2005; Hollywood 2009) have noted the attempt to neutralize/eliminate “the feminine as such” that is at work in Badiou’s reading of Paul. Building on this scholarship, I argue that this aspect of Badiou’s project—while undeniably operative and deeply problematic—is not nearly so stable or successful as the streamlined conclusions of Saint Paul would initially suggest. To this end, my analysis explores how Badiou situates his putatively universal Pauline subject in relation to four epistemological configurations (or “discourses”): the Greek, the Jewish, the Christian, and the mystical. Here Badiou is most explicitly interested in the first three discourses—and the way in which the radicality of the Christian discourse, born out of the event, refuses the terms of both the Greek and the Jewish discourses to make way for (what is claimed to be) an absolutely new form of subjectivity. But Badiou also acknowledges that a fourth discourse (mysticism) is necessary, if only to mark the margin of the valorized third discourse. However, he consistently rejects any further endorsement of the fourth discourse. What then is at stake in this thoroughgoing dismissal of the mystical? My analysis highlights the unacknowledged/disavowed gendering of the mystical at work in Badiou’s treatment of the fourth discourse—a discourse that is both always necessary and always refused in relation to the Christian discourse. In this way, I argue, the coherence, fixity, and finality of Badiou’s “universal” (and ostensibly non-gendered) Pauline subject are called into question, insofar as the specter of the feminine irresolvably and ineluctably haunts it very conditions of possibility.
|
"Bowling Alone" or "I and Thou"? Individual and Community in Epictetus and Paul
Program Unit: Hellenistic Moral Philosophy and Early Christianity
Ben C. Dunson, Durham University
Due to a widespread reaction against Bultmannian existentialism, scholars have become increasingly suspicious of claims that the individual functions significantly in the letters of Paul. Even Troels Engberg-Pedersen, who has recently re-opened the question of aspects of individual experience in Paul, tends quite strongly to downplay the individual in Paul’s teaching on the post-conversion life. Scholars of Hellenistic philosophy such as Christopher Gill have also expressed doubts as to the existence of anything approaching modern conceptions of the individual in the first century CE. Combined with recent anti-individualist social-scientific scholarship, as well as classic polemics from scholars like Krister Stendahl against individualistic Pauline interpretations, there is often little room in Pauline studies for talk of the individual functioning in any noteworthy way in Paul’s thought, especially in his soteriology or ethics. However, recent scholarship on Stoicism, while readily granting there is no “Cartesian” individual in the first century, has nonetheless recognized the central place the individual and individuality play in Stoic ethics. Placing this kind of individuality firmly in the context of Stoic social thought, these scholars have made it clear that a dismissal of the importance of the individual in the Stoicism roughly contemporary with Paul must be re-evaluated. This paper contends that in both Epictetus and Paul there is a very lively and important understanding of the individual, but in neither case is this at the expense of communal aspects of their thought. Through a careful examination of selected passages in Epictetus’ Discourses and Paul’s letter to the Romans, this paper aims to contribute toward re-opening the question of the place of the individual in Paul. As with Epictetus, the Pauline individual is embedded in community, while in fundamentally important ways remaining an individual. I contend that interpretations that treat the individual and community as mutually exclusive categories are thereby greatly impoverished.
|
Peter, Paul, and Married: The Wives of the Apostles in the Syriac Tradition
Program Unit: Syriac Literature and Interpretations of Sacred Texts
David L. Eastman, Yale University
In 1 Corinthians 9:5, Paul claims that he would have the right to take a wife, as some other apostles had done – including Peter (Cephas). However, he had not done so (1 Cor 7:8), in order to keep himself free to pursue his mission. Paul’s statements about Peter and himself on the issue of marriage may seem fairly clear, but they were not so for many commentators of the patristic period. The marital status of both apostles was up for debate. In the case of Paul, was the "true yokefellow" of Philippians 4:3 his wife, or was she merely a companion in ministry? And for Peter, did the mention of his "penthera" in Mark 1:30 and parallels necessarily mean that he was married? A Syriac fragment ascribed to Epiphanius not only claims that both were married, but even gives the names of their wives. In this paper I will examine this fragment within the context of patristic debates about the apostolic biographies. I will then place this text, which I take as pseudepigraphical, within the broader context of Syriac commentary and historiography in the late antique and early medieval periods.
|
"The Evil I Do Not Want Is What I Do": Sin and Evil in Romans
Program Unit: Ethics and Biblical Interpretation
Susan Eastman, Duke University
This paper will explore the relationship between suppression of the truth, the deceptive reign of sin, and the evil people do, in Paul's letter to the Romans, with attention to the ethical implications of this relationship in the reception history of the text.
|
Yahweh’s Kabod and the Mesopotamian Muluhhu
Program Unit: Unity and Diversity in Early Jewish Monotheisms
Diana Edelman, University of Sheffield
No abstract
|
Court Prophets during the Monarchy and Literary Prophets in the So-Called Deuteronomistic History
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Diana Edelman, University of Sheffield
The kings of Judah had various cultic specialists at their disposal to determine the divine will. The ecstatic was only one alongside the interpreter of dreams, the omen priest, and practitioners of other forms of divination. Yet, the Deuteronomistic History tended to collapse retrospectively all of these practitioners into a single category, the ecstatic, and to insist that kings were never without someone who could convey Yhwh’s will to them directly. This paper will explore the implications of this literary construct.
|
Joshua 9 and Deuteronomy; An Intertextual Conundrum: The Chicken or the Egg?
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Cynthia Edenburg, Open University of Israel
The intertextual relations between Joshua 9 and the book of Deuteronomy raises methodological issues when examining how the book of Deuteronomy was shaped and redactionally expanded in order to fit into larger literary contexts. The story of the Gibeonite treaty shares various expressions and themes with sections in Deuteronomy that are generally assigned to late redaction (e.g., Deut 7:1-6, 20:15-18, 29: 4-5, 10, 21). At the same time, it is clear that the Gibeonite story too has undergone revision and overwriting. This paper will explore the directions of interaction between Deuteronomy and Joshua 9 in their different stages of growth, and examine how this intertextuality acted to integrate Deuteronomy within differing narrative frameworks, namely the Deuteronomistic History on the one side, and the Hexateuch on the other.
|
What Has Ambleside to Do with Jerusalem? A Consideration of Charlotte Mason’s Philosophy of Education as a Model for Teaching Biblical Studies
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Patrick Egan, University of St. Andrews-Scotland
This paper will briefly outline the pedagogy of Charlotte Mason, a British educator who wrote extensively about childhood education in the context of Victorian England. Her views on how to engage the ideas in texts through reading, narrating and Socratic dialogue provides a method that may be applied effectively in the academic teaching of biblical studies; both the texts of scripture and the writings within the history of interpretation. Suggestions will be made regarding how this philosophy may be employed in the classroom and will chronicle results that have been observed.
|
An Epistle for All Christians: Considering the Ethnic Identity of the Audience of 1 Peter
Program Unit: Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
Patrick Egan, University of St. Andrews-Scotland
The present scholarly consensus considers the audience of 1 Peter to be composed of Gentile Christians. This paper will briefly examine the loci classici which support this consensus: 1 Pet 1:14, 18; 2:10, 25; 4:3-4. I propose that we cannot actually learn the ethnic identity of the audience by “mirror reading” this epistle since we begin by providing our own interpretive framework rather than deriving evidence from these texts. Taking up an interpretive strategy outlined by Richard Bauckham, it is proposed that the best way to understand the audience of 1 Peter is as Christians from all walks of life.
|
“Open Your Eyes, LORD”: The Divine Reader in the HB
Program Unit: Orality, Textuality, and the Formation of the Hebrew Bible
Chadwick Eggleston, Huntingdon College
Drawing from ANE resources that depict epistolary exchanges between humans and the divine, this paper considers YHWH’s role as a reader and this portrait’s importance to an incipient concept of scripture in the Hebrew Bible. There, YHWH not only reads documents available in the divine realm (e.g., the Book of Life), but also texts produced and transmitted by humans. Examples of the latter appear in 2 Kings 19/Isaiah 37 (the Rabshakeh’s letter) and Jeremiah 29 (Shemaiah’s letter). These examples are the exceptions that prove the general rule of oral communication between heaven and earth, but they are significant with respect to the history of the production of biblical literature. The portrayal of YHWH as a reader of human texts represents a relative democratization of reading distinct from the portrayal of the divine as a reader of heavenly texts alone. This theological portrait of divine interaction with human writing shows a god deeply engaged with human texts, a god capable not only of reading texts but also of producing them for human readers. Before YHWH wrote in the history of Israelite religion, he first had to read, and to do so with and for humans. Special attention will be given to Hezekiah’s role as a royal reader alongside YHWH in 2 Kings 19 and the assertion in biblical scholarship that his reign represented a decisive moment in the process of scripturalization.
|
Lost in Translation - Paul a Broker (diakonos) in Inter-Cultural Communication?
Program Unit:
Kathy Ehrensperger, University of Wales Trinity St. David
*
|
Discerning Diachronic Change in the Biblical Hebrew Verbal System
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Martin Ehrensvärd, University of Aarhus
The paper will investigate the attempts of Jan Joosten and Mats Eskhult to show diachronic change in the biblical Hebrew verbal system. They argue that later biblical authors tried to write early biblical Hebrew but failed, and this failure shows in their use of verbs. While Joosten and Eskhult’s syntactic analyses are inspiring and to the point, the differences they point to are slight, the constructions are infrequent, and in addition, they acknowledge that what they regard as late traits are also found in undisputed early biblical Hebrew texts, even though less frequently. Now, it is obvious that linguistic change did occur in Hebrew, but it is equally obvious that later authors/ scribes could produce texts in what we call early biblical Hebrew. The paper will argue that the few instances of the analyzed constructions in late biblical Hebrew texts cannot meaningfully be used to show that late biblical Hebrew authors were not capable of writing good early biblical Hebrew – especially since the so-called late constructions are also found in undisputed early biblical Hebrew texts.
|
The Theological Tendency of Codex Bezae at Age Forty-Four
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Bart Ehrman, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
*
|
No Sacrifice? A Motif in the Prophetic Literature and Its Rhetorical Functions
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Göran Eidevall, University of Uppsala
References to a time without sacrificial worship are found in a number of passages in the prophetic writings in the Hebrew Bible: Isa 43:23-24; Jer 7:21-22; Hos 9:4; Amos 5:25; Joel 1:9, 13; 2:14. These texts reflect and address different historical situations. Moreover, the period without sacrifices is variously described as belonging to the past, the present, or the future. Nevertheless, it might be possible to speak of a shared motif, envisioning life without performing sacrificial rites. Drawing on both rhetorical criticism and argumentation analysis, the present study focuses on the rhetorical function of this motif, addressing the following questions: How does the vision of an existence without sacrifices contribute to the argumentation in each of these prophetic passages? How does it interact with other motifs in the literary context? Which aspects of sacrificial worship are highlighted in the text? Which are downplayed? From whose perspective is the absence of sacrifices described? To what extent can extra-biblical texts throw light on the use of this motif and its rhetorical function(s)? Moving beyond the debate whether some prophets rejected the sacrificial cult altogether, this study aims at a more nuanced and refined understanding of the role(s) of sacrifice in the prophetic literature.
|
Commensality in Metaphor and Reality: Prophetic Visions of YHWH's Sacrificial Feast
Program Unit: Sacrifice, Cult, and Atonement
Göran Eidevall, University of Uppsala
The image of a sacrificial meal has been reworked in a creative way in several passages in the prophetic books of the Hebrew Bible. This study focuses especially on two such texts: Ezek 39:17-20 and Zeph 1:7-8. Despite differences in details, these two passages have one thing in common: they announce, or send out invitations to, a feast of an extraordinary kind, arranged by YHWH himself. The depictions are, quite obviously, non-literal. However, based on the assumption that metaphor always relates to some kind of familiar reality, this paper represents an attempt to answer the following questions: To what extent do these imaginative, metaphorical depictions reflect real commensality, that is: notions and practices associated with real sacrificial meals in ancient Israel and Judah? In which way, and for what purpose, have traditional ingredients in such feasts been re-used, reworked or even reversed by the biblical writers? In a first step, I will examine biblical and extrabiblical texts, as well as iconographic material from the Ancient Near East, in order to trace the background of various features of these prophetic visions. Next, I will present an analysis of the metaphorical re-shaping of the motif of YHWH’s sacrificial feast. Finally, I will address the question of the rhetorical function of these texts. How did they relate to the reality experienced by their contemporary audience?
|
The Role of Metaphor in Biblical Interpretation: Possibilities and Pitfalls
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible and Cognate Literature
Göran Eidevall, University of Uppsala
Modern metaphor theory has taught us that metaphor, far from merely being an optional rhetorical ornament, is a phenomenon at the very center of human language and cognition, and hence of importance for the understanding of all communication (oral or written). Over the last decades the study of metaphors in the Hebrew Bible has gradually been established as a field of its own. However, it remains to be demonstrated that this is of importance for all interpretation of biblical texts (prose as well as poetry), and not just an ornament, or something on the side of “ordinary” exegesis for those who happen to be particularly interested. The aim of this paper is to contribute to a discussion about the future role of metaphor studies within biblical exegesis. On the basis of a retrospective overview, potential pitfalls as well as possibilities are identified and briefly outlined. Among the pitfalls discussed one can mention overinterpretation, decontextualization, and ostracism. Some of the more promising possibilities, it will be argued, seem to lie in the integration of metaphor analysis within such areas as rhetorical criticism, redaction history, narratology, iconography, and the history of reception of the biblical texts.
|
The Identity of the Crowds in the Passion Narrative
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Rebekah Eklund, Duke University
This paper seeks to clarify the identity of the crowds in the passion narrative in three scenes: 1) the triumphal entry preceding the passion narrative; 2) the arrest in the Garden of Gethsemane; and 3) the scene immediately following Jesus’ trial before Pilate, in which the crowd cries for the release of Barabbas and the crucifixion of Jesus. The three synoptic gospels are examined along with John’s gospel to determine if each gospel portrays the identity of the crowd in similar or significantly different ways, and if the identity of the crowd remains constant in the three scenes throughout each gospel. If the same crowd shouts "Hosanna" at the triumphal entry and then "Crucify" at the trial scene, do the gospels try to explain what has caused the shift? Also, who precisely are the crowds who cry for Jesus’ crucifixion? The identity of the crowds in the gospels can be read at several different levels: in terms of historical identity (who was “really” historically present in the various scenes); at the narrative level (in the world of the text itself); or at a symbolic level (who are the crowds meant to represent for the composer or reader of the gospel). This paper concentrates on the narrative level of the crowd’s identity. This exploration of the identity of the crowds seeks to clarify how the gospels portray the role that the crowds (and by implication, the Jewish people and/or Jewish authorities) played in the final days of Jesus’ life and his eventual crucifixion.
|
The Biblical Wayward Wife Looks in a Mirror: Marguerite de Navarre, Elizabeth of England, and the "Miroir de l’âme pécheresse"
Program Unit: Recovering Female Interpreters of the Bible
Hilary Elder, Durham University
Marguerite de Navarre’s "Miroir de l’âme pécheresse" (1531) is a devotional work, highly personal in its style, describing the relationship between a sinful soul, graced by faith, and its God. The political significance of this controversial work, both in France and in England, where a translation made by Princess Elizabeth for her stepmother, Katherine Parr, was published shortly after the accession of Edward VI, is still being assessed; as is its influence on later devotional writing by early modern women. Like much early modern writing by women, the work is rich in biblical allusion, such allusions providing a source of authority for the sinful, ‘unlearned’ – female - writer. This paper examines the use the work makes of biblical ‘bad women’, such as the two ‘harlots’ judged by Solomon, but most strongly the prophetic metaphor of God’s chosen as a wayward wife. The work’s focus on the personal relationship between God and the soul is handled in terms of a variety of gendered family relationships (the soul is mother, daughter, sister and wife); and the interaction between this gendered understanding and the more universal language of ‘man’ as representing the human condition is complex, and stands in complex relationship to devotional works by men, which often exploit gender in similar ways, since the soul is always gendered feminine in the metaphor. The paper will also consider the possible influence of this work on later women writers of devotional texts; and it will place Marguerite’s and Elizabeth’s reading alongside modern feminist biblical criticism of the prophetic metaphor of the wayward wife.
|
The Fragrance of Incense and the Struggling Priestly Memory on Holy Time, Holy Place, and Holy Ritual
Program Unit: Senses, Cultures, and Biblical Worlds
Rachel Elior, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
The Dead Sea Scrolls as well as The Book of Adam and Eve and the Books of Enoch preserved many mythical and mystical traditions about the atoning incense. The lecture will discuss the priestly nature of these traditions that associated incense with divine fragrance originated in the Garden of Eden, as well as with angels, sacred altars and with eternal cycles of holy time. I will argue that these mythic-mystical priestly traditions demonstrate an alternative memory and represent a struggle on ritual authority that took place in the wake of the biblical world, in the Hasmonean period, on holy time holy, place and holy ritual .
|
The Jews as “Children of the Devil” (John 8:44) Post-Shoah
Program Unit: Children in the Biblical World
Kathleen Gallagher Elkins, Drew University
In John 8, there is an infamous debate between Jesus and “the Jews.” In the course of the discussion about paternity, essence, and destiny, Jesus associates the Jews with the devil, emphasizing the devil’s violence and deceit. Gail O’Day rightly admonishes readers to “look the language of this chapter and the image of Jesus squarely in the face,” an especially important admonition for post-Holocaust interpreters, who must also acknowledge the faces of children killed in the wake of this text. How can the interpreter deal with (and not explain away) references to the Jews as murderers, liars, and children of the devil? By examining the use of this text in children’s literature, including propaganda from Nazi Germany, I will explore the horrifying afterlife of this biblical text, especially as it relates to the instruction of some children and the demonization of other children. Indeed, it is children who are the key victims of genocide in many cases; children are implicated in guilt that is not their own, because of their ability to perpetuate a “people.” The disassociation of Jesus (and, by implication, Christianity) from Judaism and the simultaneous association of the Jews with lying, murder, and the devil was accomplished at various levels of German society: academia, children’s literature, propaganda and news. But this message seems most odious when directed at children: John 8 itself is vitriolic and harsh, but when it presented to children it constitutes, in Gary Phillips words, “a figurative and literal killing field” because of its potential to indoctrinate children with racial hatred.
|
Memory, Psychology, and Biblical Studies
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
J. Harold Ellens, University of Michigan-Ann Arbor
This paper will consider the implications of the science of memory for biblical studies.
|
On Sick Gods and Sick People
Program Unit:
J. Harold Ellens, University of Michigan-Ann Arbor
*
|
Eldon Jay Epp's Exegesis
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
J. Keith Elliott, University of Leeds
A paper honoring the exegetical work of Eldon Jay Epp.
|
Aspects of the Exodus Narrative as Parody of Egyptian Mythology
Program Unit: Egyptology and Ancient Israel
Neil Elliott, Fortress Press
Scholars have long observed comparisons between aspects of the Exodus story and Egyptian mythology, e.g. concerning the birth and finding of Moses. These observations can be enlarged by careful attention to (a) aspects of the myth cycle concerning Osiris, Isis, and Horus, as these can be reconstructed; (b) awareness of the role this myth cycle played in Egyptian imperial ideology; and (c) a more elaborate network of negative correspondences between Exodus and this myth cycle. These negative correspondences suggest the possibility that one effect of an earlier form of the Exodus narrative was the parodying of Egyptian imperial claims.
|
Diagnosing an Allergic Reaction: The Avoidance of Marx in Paul Scholarship
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
Neil Elliott, Fortress Press
Diagnosing an Allergic Reaction:
Marxist Criticism in the Interpretation of Paul
Marxist criticism of the Bible has been rare. From the start, Marxist interpretation was hindered by theological and ecclesiastical interests. But more recently, within social-scientific and cultural interpretations, scholars have proposed models that appear studiously to ignore economic class in their analyses. It is therefore possible to describe what Steven Friesen has called a "capitalist criticism" of the New Testament; to name areas in the study of Paul where this criticism has hindered progress; and to outline an alternative approach to Paul in terms of ideology and ideological constraint.
|
The Relative Sequencing of Psalms 134–136
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
David Emanuel, Nyack College
Psalms 134-136 share a significant number of words and phraseology, and although they have found themselves in this sequence in the Psalter, it is unlikely that they were written at the same point in history. The proposed paper seeks to determine the approximate dates of the psalms, relative to each other, and whether the common material results from direct borrowing between them. To accomplish this, linguistic dating methodologies are employed to provide approximate dates for the psalms, and the shared words and phrases are examined for signs of diachronic developments. In addition to linguistic evidence, other evidence—such as the historical places mentioned within the compositions—is considered in the analysis. The results show that Psalm 135 is the latest of the compositions and that its author borrowed material from the neighbouring works. Both linguistic and internal evidence attest to this conclusion. Though limited in its application, the diachronic analysis of duplicate material in psalms still presents itself as a useful tool for determining their relative dates. The importance of determining a psalm’s date—relative to the common material it may share with another biblical text—is important for those engaging in diachronic inter-textual studies in the Psalter.
|
Logos and Pneuma in the Fourth Gospel
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Troels Engberg-Pedersen, Copenhagen University
The paper argues – following Francis Watson (1987) and Gitte Buch-Hansen (Copenhagen Ph.D. diss. 2007, soon to be published by de Gruyter) – for a very close connection between John 1:14 and 1:32-33: “the union of the Logos … with Jesus of Nazareth took place in the descent of the Spirit at his Baptism” (Watson). This union should be understood in the light of the Stoic cosmology of the Pneuma (Buch-Hansen). In particular, Logos and Pneuma are two sides (a cognitive and a physical one) of the very same thing, just as Pneuma is understood in Stoicism. When this entity comes to “remain on” the earthly Jesus (= when the Logos “becomes” flesh), Jesus becomes the Christ. Only as such will he have been with God in the beginning. The paper explains this conception by analysing the ties between the Prologue and the Baptist’s witness to Jesus’ baptism later in chapter 1 and then goes on to analyse chapters 3 and 6 in order to show that a Stoic-like understanding of the Johannine Pneuma will solve issues of epistemology in chapter 3 and ontology in chapter 6. This result is taken to support the same understanding of Logos and Pneuma in chapter 1. The paper argues more broadly for three methodological approaches to be adopted in Johannine interpretation: (a) John has a cosmology which is concrete and immediately intelligible. (It is not all “symbolism”, “imagery”, “metaphor”, “poetry” and “myth”.) (b) John must be read over longer stretches (e.g. complete chapters) as aiming to dissolve philosophical puzzles that are presented to begin with. (c) John must be torn away from the usual, Platonizing perspective within which he is normally read (if he is at all read from a philosophical perspective). A Stoicizing perspective is better able to account for the incarnation.
|
Which Cosmology? And How Important?
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Troels Engberg-Pedersen, Copenhagen University
This is an invited paper for a session on ancient cosmology and the Pauline epistles. It will be presented for discussion along with papers by Stanley Stowers and Edward Adams.
|
Paratextual Material and the Justification of Ideology in Children's Bibles
Program Unit: Children in the Biblical World
Emma England, University of Amsterdam
Printed Bibles often present explicitly stated purposes and ideologies in the paratextual material, i.e. the introduction, preface, and explanatory notes. In Children's Bibles this is even more common. Focussing on English Children's Bibles and retellings, this paper will present an analysis of the types of paratextual material in the books. Items discussed will include confessional letters of approval, educational guidelines for parents and teachers, and material aimed at the children themselves. Such elements include glossaries, maps, and questions like: "What things do people do which you think are wicked and evil?" (Mary Auld, Noah's Ark, 1999, 31). The paper will present patterns in the types of material, including how they have changed, for example, the decrease in explicitly Christian introductions and the increase in culturally sensitive ones, such as "A Child's First Bible was written with respect for Protestant, Catholic, and Jewish biblical and religious traditions." (Sandol Stoddard, 1991, 5r). Questions will be raised as to the (explicit and implied) ideologies of the material and how they may affect the manner in which the (Children's-)Bibles are read, understood, and used.
|
In the Beginning Was the New Testament Text, but Which Text? Consideration of the Terms Ausgangstext and 'Initial Text'
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Eldon Epp, Case Western Reserve University
The introduction of new terminology to describe the nature of the text being produced for the Editio critica maior by the Muenster Institute for New Testament Textual Research and the International Greek New Testament project raises questions about the sense these terms intend to convey and about how they will be understood.
|
“Sick with Love”: The Musical Symptoms of a Shtetl-Bound Shulammite in Waszinski’s Dybbuk
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
Heidi Epstein, University of Saskatchewan
S. An-ski’s Yiddish play The Dybbuk and Waszinski’s film adaptation thereof (1937) have been described as Jewish versions of Romeo and Juliet, Wuthering Heights, or Tristan and Isolde. Given that a musical rendition of the Song of Songs figures prominently in both play and film, why does Khonen and Leah’s unconsummated (albeit lethal) game of lovers’ hide-and-seek not prompt comparisons with the Song’s tale of love? Readers’ utopic pigeonholing of the biblical love ‘story’ may explain this myopia. But Fiona Black’s depiction of grotesque bodies in the Song (2008) and their evocation of love’s darker dynamics (eg. “death of the [pre-amatory] self ... the quest for possession, envy, perhaps even repulsion” [236]) provides a heuristic that allows:
1) the construction of untapped structural homologies between the film and the biblical text; the discomfiting transposition of the lovers’ quest to a shtetl cemetery, flanked by a rabbinical court full of watchmen, and funneled through proto-horror-film special effects translates the Song’s grotesque content and stylistic devices into popular Yiddish film/theatre conventions of the 1930s;
2) a new, intertextual reading of the film’s “Hasidic grotesque” elements (cf. Hoberman), especially the demonic possession of Leah by Khonen; Leah’s bartered, possessed, exorcised, excommunicated, and ultimately dead body--musically framed by the Song itself—somatically extends Black’s (and the Song’s) exploration of love’s thanato-erotic conflicts in extremis;
3) a resistant reading of the film’s beautifully lyrical Shir hashirim as a grotesque musical body, charged with positive and negative identificatory valences at several intertextual levels. This more dissonant configuration is produced with help from theories of film spectatorship, and a recontextualisation of the film’s music within the broader, semiotically fraught and gendered politics of representation in which Jewish self-definition constantly negotiated anti-Semitic caricatures of Jewish actors as doubly “dissembling and gender dysfunctional” (cf. Solomon, Re-Dressing the Canon, ch.4, 98).
|
“Sick with Love”: The Musical Symptoms of a Shtetl-Bound Shulammite in Waszinski’s Dybbuk
Program Unit: Bible and Film
Heidi Epstein, University of Saskatchewan
S. An-ski’s Yiddish play The Dybbuk and Waszinski’s film adaptation thereof (1937) have been described as Jewish versions of Romeo and Juliet, Wuthering Heights, or Tristan and Isolde. Given that a musical rendition of the Song of Songs figures prominently in both play and film, why does Khonen and Leah’s unconsummated (albeit lethal) game of lovers’ hide-and-seek not prompt comparisons with the Song’s tale of love? Readers’ utopic pigeonholing of the biblical love ‘story’ may explain this myopia. But Fiona Black’s depiction of grotesque bodies in the Song (2008) and their evocation of love’s darker dynamics (eg. “death of the [pre-amatory] self ... the quest for possession, envy, perhaps even repulsion” [236]) provides a heuristic that allows:
1) the construction of untapped structural homologies between the film and the biblical text; the discomfiting transposition of the lovers’ quest to a shtetl cemetery, flanked by a rabbinical court full of watchmen, and funneled through proto-horror-film special effects translates the Song’s grotesque content and stylistic devices into popular Yiddish film/theatre conventions of the 1930s;
2) a new, intertextual reading of the film’s “Hasidic grotesque” elements (cf. Hoberman), especially the demonic possession of Leah by Khonen; Leah’s bartered, possessed, exorcised, excommunicated, and ultimately dead body--musically framed by the Song itself—somatically extends Black’s (and the Song’s) exploration of love’s thanato-erotic conflicts in extremis;
3) a resistant reading of the film’s beautifully lyrical Shir hashirim as a grotesque musical body, charged with positive and negative identificatory valences at several intertextual levels. This more dissonant configuration is produced with help from theories of film spectatorship, and a recontextualisation of the film’s music within the broader, semiotically fraught and gendered politics of representation in which Jewish self-definition constantly negotiated anti-Semitic caricatures of Jewish actors as doubly “dissembling and gender dysfunctional” (cf. Solomon, Re-Dressing the Canon, ch.4, 98).
|
Commensality and Sacrifice: Gender Revisited
Program Unit: Sacrifice, Cult, and Atonement
Dorothea Erbele-Kuester, Protestant Theological University Kampen
According to Lev 6:11 (6:18ET), the female offspring of the Aaronite family is not allowed to eat from the priestly portions of the grain offering. However, the phrase “every male among the sons of Aaron” is intriguing and necessitates scrutinizing all occurrences of Hebrew banim in genitive constructions. Where is female offspring included, where is it excluded? A closer look at the sacrificial instructions in Leviticus 1 – 7 reveals gaps and ambiguities in the descriptions. It is often unclear who has to perform specific actions. Thus this paper aims at investigating the identity of those involved in performing sacrifices and eating sacrificial portions and the role gender plays in it.
|
Hebrew Dictionaries: Gender Revisited
Program Unit: Bible Translation
Dorothea Erbele Kuester, Protestant Theological University
Often the way in which the translations and explanations of words in Hebrew dictionaries construct gender is not questioned, although their renderings carry many implications. This is despite the fact that already in 1810, long before the rise of gender studies, Wilhelm Gesenius, the founder of modern Hebrew lexicography, was aware of gender implications when he discussed the inclusive and exclusive use of words such as ben/banim. Under that entry he states: “The plural is sometimes used for both sexes among the children.” It is explained that the communal/gender-inclusive use of the plural influenced the singular, as the expression “male son” shows. However, in the recent 18th edition this argument becomes cloudy, because ben zakar “männliches Kind” (male child) in Jer 20,15 is listed under “to express having a certain characteristic”.
As Hebrew dictionaries are influential points of reference, the aim of this paper is to unfold with the help of some examples how/if gender awareness plays a role in their translation practices. It will be shown that gender-specific translations reveal rather the gender perceptions of the editors and their contexts, but give only narrow insight into the reality of wo/men’s lives and the biblical writers’ perceptions of them.
|
Ascertaining the Place of the Western ‘Deuterocanonical’ Works in the Ethiopic Canon: The Cases of 1 Enoch and Jubilees
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Ted Erho, Durham University
This paper analyzes the placement of 1 Enoch and Jubilees in Ethiopic manuscripts and canon lists on the basis of various chronological and corpus-based considerations, both with a view towards its location relative to other documents as well as, at a more fundamental level, its existential ratio in the literature.
|
Renegotiating Identity in Job 19:6–12
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Amy Erickson, Iliff School of Theology
Scholars who work on the book of Job typically read the book as separate and distinctive from other literature in the Hebrew Bible. While this has resulted in many excellent studies, the question as to how Job interacts with and functions within the Hebrew Bible as a whole has not been addressed sufficiently.
In this paper, I argue that numerous allusions to Lamentations 3 in Job 19:6-12 function to provide the Israelite community in Yehud with an alternative identity to those informed by Deuteronomistic traditions which portray Israel as a perpetually guilty people that forsakes God again and again.
While Lamentations basically accepts the Deuteronomistic premise that the city’s suffering is the result of its guilt, the book’s overall emphasis on Zion’s suffering, as opposed to its sin, raises questions about the appropriateness of God’s punishment of Zion. Job effectively applies Lamentations’ portrayal of God’s extreme and merciless actions against a sinful, feminine city to himself, a male individual declared blameless and upright by God himself (Job 1:8).
Job’s speech in 19:6-12 challenges the community in Yehud, crippled by shame and guilt, to re-imagine itself as a people capable of righteousness and justice rather than as one condemned to a never-ending cycle of guilt and punishment. Job’s re-appropriation of Lamentations offers his readers a new vision of themselves as a people.
|
To Fulfill All Righteousness: Kenotic Glory in Matthew
Program Unit: Matthew
Nathan Eubank, Duke University
In the Gospel of Matthew Jesus convinces John to baptize him with the famously elusive words: "Let it be so now; for it is proper for us in this way to fulfill all righteousness.” This paper draws on the echo of Isaiah 42 in Matthew 3:17 to argue that Jesus' baptism is a metonymic presaging of the whole of his identity and mission, and that this is the sense in which it fulfills all righteousness. The theophany following the baptism glorifies the self-effacement of the Christ using the words of Isaiah 42:1-4 which describe the humble child of God who will bring krisis to victory through meekness. Matthew continues to develop this theme in the context surrounding the explicit citation of Isaiah 42 in chapter 12, as well as in the transfiguration, and the passion narrative.
|
Luke’s Good Samaritan and the Chronicler’s Good Samaritans
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
Craig A. Evans, Acadia Divinity College
.
|
Achieving Purity: Baptismal Rituals in the Second Book of Jeu
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Erin Evans, University of Edinburgh
The Books of Jeu of the Bruce Codex contain a plethora of examples of formulae for an initiate to pass through different areas of the divine realm. One of the most interesting features, however, is the set of detailed instructions found in the 'Second Book of Jeu' for three baptisms a soul must receive before embarking on this heavenly journey. This paper will examine the various elements comprising these three baptismal rituals of water, fire, and Holy Spirit, as well as the immediately following, related ritual to remove the “evil of the archons.” It will explore the nature and use of the variety of plants used in the offerings, and discuss the purpose of the seals used before and after the rituals and the number-ciphers held in the hands of those being baptized. Furthermore an analysis of the prayers spoken by the officiant of the rituals will be undertaken, as well as the use of glossolalia, mystery names and divine intermediaries.
The author of the text in question is clearly influenced by a strong magical ritual tradition, utilizing a wide assortment of elements in a repeated, but varied, ritual context. The aim is to achieve the intangible result of purification of the initiate’s soul. Although later texts belonging to the same milieu of thought reduce the complexity and importance of baptismal rituals, the detailed record of the complex rituals preserved in the 'Second Book of Jeu' is an invaluable resource in the study of Egyptian Christian-Gnostic mystery ritual tradition.
|
Polarizing Rituals and Civil Strife in Athens
Program Unit: Society for Ancient Mediterranean Religions
Nancy Evans, Wheaton College
The political lives of dead bodies can engage the passions of the living. Indeed, as Katherine Verdery discussed in her monograph (The Political Lives of Dead Bodies, Columbia Univ. Press, 2000), political upheaval is often accompanied by struggles over the bodies of lost leaders and cultural heroes. This paper will explore the relationship between dead bodies, civil strife, and traditional Greek religion as it played out in fifth-century Athens. A fresh analysis of three key historical episodes (recorded by Herodotus, Thucydides and Xenophon) can uncover how Athenians experienced the relationship between religion and civil strife. Drawing on insights from anthropological theory, I will explore how times of civil unrest deepened the Athenians’ reliance on dead bodies to simultaneously enact their religious and political identities.
The human body can serve as a symbol for both the political community and the larger cosmos. Traditional Athenian religion regularly conveyed this, with its tomb cult, public epitaphios rites, and festivals like the Apatouria. During times of civil strife in Athens these rites could assume an additional, politicized meaning. The Greek historians all describe how bones became powerful symbols: Control of corpses meant control of memory – not just the private memories of individuals, but the corporate memory of the citizenry. Dead bodies are symbolic capital, and as such they become a valuable resource during times of domestic unrest. The foiled plot to steal Abraham Lincoln’s body in 1876 illustrates how Americans continued to struggle over the meaning of the Civil War; likewise the Athenians struggled over the bones of Theseus, oligarchic leaders, and common soldiers. These examples illustrate not simply the central role of religious expression for Athenians, but the potential for political polarization that is inherent in civic rituals celebrated during times of civil conflict.
|
Pseudo-Jonathan's Nun Problem
Program Unit: Aramaic Studies
David L. Everson, Xavier University
One dialectical peculiarity of Targum Pseudo-Jonathan is the gemination of nun. This may be seen in such nouns as ’yntt’ and in such pronouns as ’nt. Additionally, imperfect verbs may also succumb to gemination in PsJ (e.g. ’ynd‘, thn‘yl). The specific inquiry of this paper concerns the non-assimilation of PSJ’s pe-nun verbs. Though one does find a number of non-assimilating form ins other Aramaic dialects (e.g. biblical Aramaic or the Bavli), the number of exclusively non-assimilating pe-nun forms is far greater. Within PsJ, most pe-nun verbs assimilate (some invariably), a few assimilate inconsistently, and others never assimilate. Is there a rhyme and reason to such variation? This paper seeks to present an analysis of the relevant pe-nun forms and attempt to explain this dialectal peculiarity.
|
What Has Mel Gibson to Do with the Book of Job? M. Night Shyamalan’s Signs and the God Who Tests
Program Unit: Bible and Film
J. Cheryl Exum, University of Sheffield
In M. Night Shyamalan’s Signs, Mel Gibson plays a Pennsylvania farmer who discovers crop circles in his corn field, signs left by aliens to aid their invasion of the earth. According to Shyamalan, who both wrote and directed the film, it is also about faith and signs from above, and viewers have also drawn attention to the film’s religious dimension. Gibson’s character is a former minister who lost his faith when his wife died, and who regains it when his children—and the world—are spared and the invaders depart. His crisis of faith could be compared to Job’s challenge to traditional piety when he accuses God of perverting justice and insists on his integrity. Both the Gibson character and Job suffer losses that disrupt their initial harmonious relationship with God, both wrestle with God in their own ways, and both are restored at the end. The first part of the paper will discuss these and other points of comparison between Signs and the book of Job. It will conclude with the argument that, quite apart from such superficial similarities, Signs calls into question conventional readings of the book of Job and brings into stark relief the cosmic terror that the resolution offered by the epilogue cannot adequately account for or explain away or reduce to something else.
|
Filling in the Semantic Voids and New Testament Translation
Program Unit: North American Association for the Study of Religion
Jennifer Eyl, Brown University
This is an exploration of conflicting positions of translation as a religious practice and translation as a practice of historical scholarship. In the act of translation, discourses are imported (immigration) or exported (emigration) from/to other non-identical discourses. However, translators and scholars of the New Testament are frequently confronted with the fact that concepts and categories in the source language (Greek) simply do not exist in the target language (English). The opposite is true as often: concepts and words in the target language (English) do not exist in the source (Greek). To compensate, these semantic voids are often “filled in” by translators with target-language ideas in order to render the New Testament more amenable to modern devotional audiences. While devotional appeal may be desired in some arenas, such “filling in” often entails ideological and theological choices that effect academic inquiry. The goal for the scholar of early Christianity or New Testament studies is not to generate followers of Jesus; nor is it to project onto the ancient texts proof of moral or religious truth claims which developed long after the source texts were written. Yet, scholars of early Christianity frequently utilize theologically-inflected translations—a practice which inevitably insinuates anachronistic ideas into theologically disinterested scholarship. Thus, this paper aims to unite the theoretical and practical implications of (mis)translating key concepts in the New Testament, and seeks to redress the dilemma of one practice (theology) determining the conclusions of another practice (historical scholarship).
|
Introduction: A History of LXX Lexicography
Program Unit: Biblical Lexicography
Erik Eynikel, Radboud Universiteit Nijmegen
Muraoka's lexicon in the light of a history of LXX lexicography
|
The Challenge of Teaching Scripture in African Seminaries
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Ernest M. Ezeogu, Spiritan International School of Theology
Most Bible teaching in Africa takes place within the context of seminaries and confessional colleges of theology where the Bible is regarded as Scripture and normative for doctrine and life. Paradoxically, most of this teaching is done by scholars who have been educated in Western universities where the Bible is regarded mostly as ancient literature without much reference to its normative use by groups of believers. This paradox creates an epistemological gap between the teaching goals of teachers and the learning expectations of students. This paper is an attempt to highlight the problematic and bring it to the attention of stakeholders in African biblical scholarship. The aim is to set in motion a dialogue with a view to a possible amelioration of the situation.
|
The Aqedah in the Sahidic Testament of Isaac
Program Unit: Christianity in Egypt: Scripture, Tradition, and Reception
John W. Fadden, Iliff School of Theology
Scholars have written numerous pieces on the Jewish and Christian interpretations of the Aqedah. However, scholars have failed to pay attention to the role of the Aqedah for the Sahidic Testament of Isaac. The Testament of Isaac offers an interpretation of Genesis 22 and its benefit for the Testament’s Coptic audience with two explicit references to Isaac’s binding. Yet, the Testament of Isaac is in conversation throughout its narrative with the Jewish and Christian interpretations of the Aqedah. This paper will examine the intertextual connections with the larger early Jewish and Christian interpretative tradition to suggest that the Testament of Isaac is doing something different from most Jewish and Christian interpretations when it comes to who benefited from the sacrifice of Isaac. The Testament of Isaac interprets the Aqedah in such a way as to extend the merit of Isaac beyond his genealogical descendants to encompass all who perform rituals in the memory of Isaac. At the same time the Testament does not resort to identifying the Aqedah as a type of the crucifixion of Jesus and thus does not minimize the efficacy of Isaac’s sacrifice. In this way, the Testament of Isaac continues the dialogue between Christian and Jewish interpretative traditions of the Aqedah.
|
The Gothic New Testament and the Byzantine Text
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Carla Falluomini, Università degli Studi di Sassari
My paper describes the text-critical relationship between the Gothic New Testament - translated by Wulfila in the mid-fourth century, in Moesia Inferior (modern North Bulgaria) - and the Byzantine text.
The Gothic version is very close to the Byzantine text. This is not surprising, because Wulfila’s relationships with the Church of Constantinople are well known and his Vorlage probably came from there.
But it is surprising that the Gothic and the Byzantine text are more closely related in the Gospels than in the Epistles, where numerous non-Byzantine variants are transmitted. The reason for such divergence has been a long-standing puzzle: some scholars of the previous century considered the non-Byzantine readings to be post-Wulfilian, introduced into the Gothic version through the influence of the Vetus Latina, after the Gothic settlement in Italy (486). This thesis agreed with a consensus in the New Testament criticism of the period, that the Byzantine text was already formed at the end of the third century/start of the fourth century.
However, the theoretical framework has now changed: the most recent theories concerning the formation of the Byzantine text view it as the result of a progressive textual development. This framework provides a new perspective on how to evaluate both the high percentage of Byzantine readings in the Gothic Gospels and the lower percentage of Byzantine readings in the Gothic Pauline Epistles. My paper argues that the Gothic text would reflect the stage of development of the Koine in the mid-fourth century, which was more advanced in the Gospels than in the Epistles. Many non-Byzantine readings (among them many shared with ,Western‘ witnesses) were probably pre-Byzantine variants, already present in Wulfila’s Vorlage.
|
A Dialogue between The Africana Bible (Fortress, 2009) and the Africa Bible Commentary (Zondervan, 2006) on Ezra-Nehemiah
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Elelwani B Farisani, University of South Africa
This paper critically engages with the articles/chapters on Ezra-Nehemiah in both The Africana Bible (Fortress, 2010), and the Africa Bible Commentary (Zondervan, 2006). First, the paper looks at the rationale, structure, content, contributors and methodology of each commentary. Second, the paper critically engages with each commentary’s article on Ezra-Nehemiah, namely Nupanga Weanzana (Africa Bible Commentary) and Herbert Marbury (The Africana Bible). And, finally, the paper spells out the significance of such a discussion/dialogue for African Biblical Hermeneutics.
|
On the Maturation of Evil
Program Unit: Paul and Politics
Douglas Farrow, McGill University
The Thessalonian epistles deserve more attention in the rendering of Pauline theo-politics. 2 Thessalonians, in particular, has been marginalized not only because of uncertainty about its date and authorship, but because of its blunt statements about retributive justice in the form of divine vengeance upon those who oppress Christians. What appears in that letter, however, is the foundation for a highly nuanced theology of history that takes into account the dialectical relation between the gospel’s restraining and enabling of evil, the maturing of which is otherwise impossible. This process of maturation is presented as the condition of possibility for the exercise of divine justice at the parousia, but also as a warning to Christians respecting premature judgments of their political and historical situation. An exegetical sketch of the salient parts of this letter will be offered in support of a broadly Pauline political theology that at once incorporates and transcends later Irenaean and Augustinian elements. Some attempt will also be made to broach related issues in a theology of law and lawlessness.
|
The Stoic Ethic of Perfect Manhood in Ephesians 4:13
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
April Favara, Iliff School of Theology/University of Denver
The author of Ephesians employs a similar, gender specific ethic as that of the Stoics in the use of the phrase “to a perfect man” (Eph 4:13). When carefully compared with the writing of Galen, the awareness and incorporation of this male-only Stoic pursuit, which is employed with the very same Greek terminology as that used in Eph 4:13, becomes illumined. Galen integrates much of the philosophical and Stoic beliefs and teachings of the time period into his work, 'The Diagnosis and Cure of the Soul's Passions,' which dates roughly to the middle of the 2nd Century C.E.. The achievement of this high ethic of perfect manhood is presented to a community of males that, like Ephesians, also identifies the utilization of others, and the mind, in this pursuit. Through a close reading of Eph 4:11-24 and Galen's work, this paper challenges the usual gender inclusive reading of Eph 4:13, which is reflected in numerous commentaries and the majority of English translations. The absence of inclusive language in Eph 4:13 has unsettling implications. Women, to a Hellenistic audience and in accordance with the examination of Galen’s treatise, would not be expected to pursue or achieve the high ethical standard that the phrase “perfect manhood” represented.
|
Blood Expiation in Hittite and Biblical Ritual
Program Unit: Hebrew Scriptures and Cognate Literature
Yitzhaq Feder, Bar Ilan University
Hurrian and Hittite inhabitants of southern Anatolia in the 14th- 13th centuries B.C.E. practiced a blood rite called the zurki, which closely resembles the Biblical sin offering. In both Anatolia and Israel, the rite consists of smearing blood on an object, frequently cultic, as a means of removing metaphysical threats, such as sin and impurity, which may otherwise evoke divine retribution. The Hurro-Hittite zurki rite was regularly accompanied by an offering of cooked fat, often from the same animal, called the uzi rite. This practice is strikingly similar to the sin offering which involved the burning of its fat on the altar as a “pleasing aroma to YHWH” (Lev. 4, 31). Moreover, the underlying dynamic of both the Hittite and Israelite rituals is a form of metonymy, where the ritual patron is absolved by association with the object. Finally, the rituals are performed in nearly identical circumstances, including expiation for unintentional sin, purification of a defiled temple and the consecration of a new cult structure.
These striking parallels among the Hittites and Israelites raise the possibility of a historical link, direct or indirect, between the two cultures. In order to establish the uniqueness of the Hittite and Biblical rites, they are compared to rituals from other ancient Near Eastern and Mediterranean cultures, where blood is used differently, namely as an offering to chthonic deities. A notable exception is the zukru festival from Emar which also features a very similar blood rite and thus may pertain to the same tradition as the Hittite and Biblical rite. In conclusion, I explore possible historical contexts for the transmission of this ritual tradition, paying particular attention to the exchange of rituals between Hurrians and Semites as reflected in the ritual corpus from Ugarit.
|
Aniconism, Otherness, and Cult in Deuteronomy 4
Program Unit: Sacrifice, Cult, and Atonement
Yitzhaq Feder, Bar Ilan University
According to the dominant cultic conception in the ancient Near East, divine support and protection was dependent upon the god’s localized presence within the community. Recent studies of the Mesopotamian mouth-washing ritual (mis pî) and other first-hand accounts of image worship have revealed a more sophisticated set of beliefs than the Biblical polemics against idolatry were willing to acknowledge. In particular, the belief in the divine presence dwelling within the idol was not viewed as limiting the deity to a particular location. If so, one must ask: even if the Israelite cult was as aniconic as the Biblical evidence claims, what differentiates the belief in images from the “legitimate” belief that YHWH dwells in the temple? In this paper, I will argue that Deuteronomy 4 addresses this question and responds with a radical redefinition of the notion of closeness between man and God.
In order to understand Deuteronomy 4’s polemic against image worship, it is necessary to recognize that this chapter makes extended intertextual allusions to the Second Commandment and the altar law of Ex. 20, 18--22. We will analyze the rhetoric of each so as to reveal the underlying sociological assumptions and attitudes towards iconic worship implied in each. Despite the abundance of recent studies dealing with the controversial question of the sociohistorical realities underlying Israel’s aniconic polemics, the value of analyzing the rhetoric of these passages has yet to be fully exploited.
We will then examine how Deuteronomy 4 subtly reinterprets these sources as it integrates them into a new literary and ideological context. Through an intricate weaving of diverse themes, including the uniqueness of God, the distinctiveness of Israel and the primacy of Torah, this chapter hints at the new view of cult expressed in the formulas of the Name Theology.
|
Philoxenus of Mabbug, Translation of the New Testament a Necessity for Theology
Program Unit: Syriac Literature and Interpretations of Sacred Texts
Paul Féghali, Ghazir, Lebanon
Despite the existence of the Old Syriac and Peshita Versions of the New Testament, Philoxenus asked Polycarp for a new Syriac translation. In 508 A.D., they produced what is known today as the Philoxenian. A more faithful translation of the Greek New Testament was necessary in order for Philoxenus to enter into dialogue with the Chalcedonian Church. The objectives of this paper are to present the reasons behind Philoxenus' request for the new translation and the outcome of this attempt.
|
What Can the Mesha Stele Teach Us about the Religion of Israel?
Program Unit: Israelite Religion in Its Ancient Context
Peter Feinman, Institute of History, Archaeology, and Education
The Mesha Stele is an underutilized key to understanding Israelite history and religion and to the writing of the Bible. Given its inclusion of the name Israel, the individual name of a king of Israel, a tribe of Israel, a sanctuary to the wilderness deity Yahweh of Israel outside the land of Canaan, and to a location which according to the biblical text is where the founder of the Israelite was buried, the Mesha Stele is an invaluable resource for understanding the history and religion of Israel and the writing of what became the Bible. This archaeologically asserted destruction of the Mount Nebo sanctuary is entitled to the same consideration to understanding the history, religion, and writings of the people that the future destructions of the temple would have.
The question to be raised here is: what was the reaction of the Israelite people to this event? I assert that 9th-century BCE Israel worshiped non-Canaanite Yahweh and believed that the founder of the people was buried at Mount Nebo. I further assert that the destruction of the sacred site was as traumatic to them as the later Jerusalem temple destructions were to the priests. Finally, I assert that the result of Mesha's actions was a call to arms expressed through a scroll written by a northern prophet in the Moses paradigm based on the values of the Yahwistic religion of Israel, a scroll that subsequently became part of the Bible.
|
The Violation of Dinah: Narrative Composition and Conceptual Foundations
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Eve Levavi Feinstein, Harvard University
The composition of the story of Dinah and Shechem (Gen 34) has been a subject of debate since the time of Wellhausen. The story has also naturally attracted the attention of feminist critics, who have noted that the narrative portrays conflicts between groups of men in terms of concerns about female sexual purity. Scholars interested in the portrayal of sex and gender in the story, however, have rarely seriously engaged with the question of the story’s composition. This paper will examine some of the major hypotheses on the composition of Genesis 34 and their implications for understanding the character of Dinah and her role in the narrative. I will argue that the literary problems in the narrative are best resolved by means of text criticism rather than source criticism, and I will discuss the implications of this view for understanding the ideas of sexual violation and pollution in biblical Israel.
|
The Sacrifice of Firstborn Sons: A New Approach to an Old Problem
Program Unit: Sacrifice, Cult, and Atonement
Eve Levavi Feinstein, Harvard University
The interpretation of Exod 22:28-29 is a subject of intense debate among critical scholars. While some maintain that the passage mandates the ritual slaughter of first-born male children, others argue that human sacrifice was never a mainstream element of the service of YHWH. In this paper, I approach the problem from the broader perspective of the language and phenomenology of sacrifice in the Hebrew Bible. Based in part on the polythetic approach to sacrifice recently proposed by Kathryn McClymond, I argue that the concept of sacrifice in biblical Israel is broader than sometimes thought, and did not inherently involve killing. While human sacrifice could involve ritual slaughter, it could also consist in the dedication of a person for service in the sanctuary. Exod 22:28-29 belongs to this latter category.
|
Joseph, Preserver of Life: Revisiting Ancient Near Eastern Mythologies in the Joseph Narrative
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Stewart Felker, University of Memphis
In early 20th century biblical scholarship—exemplified by William F. Albright and others—it was common to see, in Joseph's rescue from "symbolic 'death'" at the pit at Dotham and subsequent rise to rescue Egypt from famine, parallels to Ancient Near Eastern "dying-and-rising" gods, whose stories functioned as aetiologies for seasonal fluctuation, and cycles of famine and fecundity. Although many of the more questionable aspects of these theories have been abandoned, there remain scholars who still see hints of such "high mythology" in the Joseph story. Despite this, however, there has not been a study of the continued influence of older theories on modern scholarship, or of newer proposals. In this paper, I will review the status quaestionis in this respect, and suggest that we can detect a connected "cycle" that runs throughout Gen. 41-50, relating to Joseph's "rescue" or "preservation" of the Egyptian produce before the years of famine. This narrative is typologically similar to certain ANE cycles and, specifically, displays similarities with some prominent motifs from Egyptian literature. Significantly, this paper will reopen the currently "dormant" investigation of the enigmatic title bestowed upon Joseph by Pharaoh in Gen. 41.45.
|
Training for Hebrew Immersion Programs of Teachers without Prior Modern Hebrew
Program Unit: Applied Linguistics for Biblical Languages
Lee Fields, Mid-Atlantic Christian University
This paper explores the viability of teachers converting from traditional methods of instruction to immersion methods when they have no background in Modern Hebrew. The main topics covered will include: challenges, options, and payoff.
|
Assessing the Galilean Economy in the Post Finley Era
Program Unit: Early Christianity and the Ancient Economy
David A. Fiensy, Kentucky Christian University
EARLY CHRISTIAN ECONOMY SECTION: Scholars of classical history are going through a revolution in their thinking about the ancient economy. In particular, they are debating the usefulness of Moses Finley’s assumptions and methods for understanding and researching the Greco-Roman world. Those studying the economy of Galilee in the late second temple period are also involved in this debate but often not aware of its counterpart among classical scholarship. This paper will highlight three areas of disagreement in the study of the economy of the Roman Empire which also play a role in the current debate over the historical Galilee: 1) How useful are (socio-)economic models? Do they tend to ignore hard evidence, working deductively or can one use them alongside the data? 2) Should we discard Finley’s “primitivist” (non-market) understanding of the ancient economy in favor of the “modernist” understanding which teaches that modern capitalistic economies differ from the ancient ones only in quantity? 3) Should we discard Finley’s “substantivist” view of the role of status and civic ideology in the economy and accept the “formalist” view which holds that economic decisions were separate from social ones? I hope to present a more balanced approach to this study which avoids polarities and listens to multiple voices and one which still finds a place for Finley in the investigation.
|
The Jewish Helios: A Crux in the History of Late Antique Judaism
Program Unit: History and Literature of Early Rabbinic Judaism
Steven Fine, Yeshiva University
The image of Helios at the center of a zodiac wheel appears in a number of Palestinian synagogue mosaics from late antiquity. While the first of these mosaic pavements was discovered in 1929 (Beth Alpha), it was not until the post-World War II period that this image drew broad attention among historians of Religion. This interest is unabated, as a spate of recent articles attests.
The image of Helios has served as a crux for the a wider latter twentieth century assessment of "rabbinic authority" and as evidence for "non-Rabbinic Judaism." This lecture will trace the history of the interpretation of the Jewish Helios, setting this scholarship within the broader sociology of knowledge in which it developed. I will then suggest my own interpretation of the Helios image within ancient synagogues, contextualizing the literary evidence adduced by scholars to interpret this image and comparing the Jewish Helios to the use of "pagan" imagery within Christian contexts during late antiquity.
|
“See, I Have Called the Renowned Name of Bezalel, Son of Uri…”: Josephus’ Portrayal of the Biblical “Architect”
Program Unit: Josephus
Steven Fine, Yeshiva University
Josephus describes Bezalel, the builder of the biblical tabernacle, as a master arkhitektôn, as a nephew of Moses, as a peer of Oholiab, and as a respected figure (Antiquities 3.104-6). Whiston and Thackeray translate arkhitektôn as "architect" throughout Josephus' oeuvre, where pairs of arkhitéktonas appear on four separate occasions.
In this paper I will trace Josephus' usage of the term arkhitektôn to describe Bezalel back to LXX Ex. 31:3-4, 21, where the verb arkhitektoneô is applied to the biblical “architects.” I will then set Josephus’ Bezalel and Oholiab within the contexts of the other Josephan arkhitéktonas. Finally, I will interpret the Josephan "architects" within the larger contexts of “architects” in Roman and Jewish literature, epigraphy and visual culture.
I will suggest that Josephus construed Bezalel and Oholiab as upper tier Roman “architects,” taking his cue from the Septuagint usage and from the fact that Bezalel is called “by name” in Scripture.In the process of regularizing Bezalel and Oholiab to this Roman profession, Josephus relieves Bezalel of his Scripturally-ordained gifts of “wisdom”,” “understanding” and “knowledge.” Thus he both protects the uniqueness of Moses, and avoids any comparison of Bezalel with Greco-Roman craftsmen gods such as Daedalus and the Punic Kothar wa-Hassis.
|
Sleeping among Tombs for the Sake of Dream Visions: A Discourse of Incubation among Jews in Emperor Julian’s Works
Program Unit: History and Literature of Early Rabbinic Judaism
Ari Finkelstein, Harvard University
There are a couple of instances Emperor Julian comments on a Jewish practice of incubation: In Against the Galileans 339E, Julian castigates a Christian practice of incubation, which he claims stems from an Israelite tradition; and, possibly in his Letter to the Alexandrians 443B.This paper seeks to understand: Julian’s sources for a Jewish practice of incubation; his purpose in raising this practice; and, whether such a practice continued to exist among Jews in Late Antiquity. To date, no one has considered Julian’s comments about Jewish incubation.
Julian’s attack on a Christian practice of incubation and his linkage of it with an Ancient Israelite practice in Against the Galileans is not surprising as he regularly attacked Jewish practice to undermine Christian practice. Also, the Old Testament is replete with examples of Israelites having dream visions. Moreover, Hellenistic authors such as Strabo (Geographica XVI, 2:35) and Agatharchides (Contra Apion 1:211) attacked Jewish practices of seeking dreams and incubation. Thus Julian could easily have used the Old Testament and/or Hellenistic authors as a source for a Jewish practice of incubation.
Despite the antiquity of these comments, some Jews may have continued to practice incubation in Julian’s own day. The later evidence – the synagogue built on the site of Maccabean martyrs in Antioch and other archaeological and rabbinic evidence(Megillah 20b; Berachot 17b; and, T. Ohalot 4,2) - does not specifically mention a practice of incubation but rather reflects discourse of Jewish worship at tombs of their holy dead. This is surprising. Traditional Judaism looked at graves as polluted and stayed away from them. Given this evidence, most of it datable to after Julian’s time, it is possible that a cult of the dead existed in Antioch, where Julian wrote Contra Galileos, and that Jews practiced incubation in Julian’s time. If true, Julian may be a source for Jewish practice in his day.
|
Sleeping among Tombs for the Sake of Dream Visions: A Discourse of Incubation among Jews in Emperor Julian’s Works
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Ari Finkelstein, Harvard University
There are a couple of instances Emperor Julian comments on a Jewish practice of incubation: In Against the Galileans 339E, Julian castigates a Christian practice of incubation, which he claims stems from an Israelite tradition; and, possibly in his Letter to the Alexandrians 443B.This paper seeks to understand: Julian’s sources for a Jewish practice of incubation; his purpose in raising this practice; whether such a practice continued to exist among Jews in Late Antiquity, and, the possible influence of Christian discourse on this Jewish practice. To date, no one has considered Julian’s comments about Jewish incubation.
Julian’s attack on a Christian practice of incubation and his linkage of it with an Ancient Israelite practice in Against the Galileans is not surprising as he regularly attacked Jewish practice to undermine Christian practice. Also, the Old Testament is replete with examples of Israelites having dream visions. Moreover, Hellenistic authors such as Strabo (Geographica XVI, 2:35) and Agatharchides (Contra Apion 1:211) attacked Jewish practices of seeking dreams and incubation. Thus Julian could easily have used the Old Testament and/or Hellenistic authors as a source for a Jewish practice of incubation.
Despite the antiquity of these comments, some Jews may have continued to practice incubation in Julian’s own day. The later evidence – the synagogue built on the site of Maccabean martyrs in Antioch stemming from patristic sources and other archaeological and rabbinic evidence - does not specifically mention a practice of incubation but rather reflects discourse of Jewish worship at tombs of their holy dead similar to such discourse in Christianity of the fourth century. This is surprising. Traditional Judaism looked at graves as polluted and stayed away from them. Given this evidence, most of it datable to after Julian’s time, it is possible that a cult of the dead existed in Antioch where Julian wrote Contra Galileos and that Jews practiced incubation in Julian’s time. If true, Julian may be a source for Jewish practice in his day.
|
Jewish Private Sacrifice of the Right Shoulder in Emperor Julian’s Contra Galileos: A Case of Biblical Exegesis
Program Unit: Sacrifice, Cult, and Atonement
Ari Finkelstein, Harvard University
This paper examines Emperor Julian’s comment in Contra Galileos 306A that Jews give the dexios omos (right shoulder with the upper arm) to the priests as a priestly gift. I am interested in determining what Julian’s sources were and ultimately if he is a reliable source for Jewish practice in his era, a task that has never been done before.
Outside of biblical exegesis, there are no attested instances of this practice in Jewish or other sources. Deuteronomy 18:3 designates the zeroah (arm) along with the cheeks and stomach to the priests from a private slaughtering. Therefore, either Julian had a biblical source that added the right zeroah, or, had a Hellenistic practice in mind. However, neither the MT nor the LXX, which translates zeroah as brakiona, identifies this arm as the right arm.
After I establish the vorlage of the Septuagint, I will argue that Julian draws on a tradition of interpretations that harmonizes Deuteronomy 18:3 with Leviticus 7:32-34. Both of these verses focus on items that were given to the priests from sacrifices except that Leviticus 7:32 mentions the right brakiona (shok ha’yamin). Both verses were read together in Qumran (Temple Scroll cols. XX:14=16; XXI:1-4) and probably by Josephus (AJ 4:74) and in a fourth century Boharic manuscript of the Septuagint.
Julian’s choice of omos rather than brakion reflects Julian’s own expression of the tradition he found in Deuteronomy 18:3. That he departs from the language of the LXX makes sense since he would have thought in classical Hellenistic terms for sacrifice – a key part of his pagan program for the Empire. Given Julian’s classical education, and the common practice of imitatio among Hellenistic rhetors, I will examine the Progymnasmata of Libanius, his teacher, for common usages of the term omos as well as Mithraic and Neoplatonic uses of the term. I will also consider why Julian left out Deuteronomy 18:3’s cheeks and stomach from his paraphrase of that verse in CG 306A.
|
Khirbet Qeiyafa: A Cool-Headed Interpretation
Program Unit:
Israel Finkelstein, Tel Aviv University
The paper will deal with the site of Khirbet Qeiyafa in the Shephelah. It will show that the site dates to the late Iron I and that the radiocarbon determinations of samples from the site have no bearing on the Iron Age chronology debate. The paper will also deal with the fortification system, the ethnic affiliation of the inhabitants and the identification of the site. It will show the gap between the interpretation of the finds by the excavators and the archaeological reality.
|
The Hercule Poirot of Archaeology?
Program Unit:
Israel Finkelstein, Tel Aviv University
*
|
10th-9th Centuries: Megiddo and Beyond
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Israel Finkelstein, Tel Aviv University
The paper will deal with Megiddo and the north in the 10th and 9th centuries BCE -- the late Iron I and the Iron IIA. It will use the archaeological finds for historical reconstruction. It will also reflect on broader issues related to the reconstruction of the history of Ancient Israel: from Jerusalem to smaller sites in Judah and beyond.
|
Links between Sacrifice and God's Favor in the Psalms
Program Unit: Sacrifice, Cult, and Atonement
Stephen Finlan, Manhattan College
In many psalms, sacrifice secures God’s favor. A plea for God’s favor may be followed in quick succession by a promise to offer sacrifice and a report of rescue (Ps 54:5-7; 43:3-5). Sacrifice qualifies one for help (Ps 26:6, 9). Other psalmists call for sacrifice after God has demonstrated his faithfulness (4:3-8). A few psalms reject or even ridicule sacrifice (40, 50, 51), and others speak of prayer as amounting to sacrifice (141:2) or as being better than sacrifice (69:30-31).
|
Riddles of Reference: “I” and “We” in Isaiah and Jeremiah
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
George Fischer, University of Innsbruck, Austria
The use of the first person in these two prophetic books shows a wide spectrum. Sometimes the “I” in Isaiah can be identified, e.g. as standing for the prophet (Is 6:5), for king Hezekiah (Is 38:3), or for Zion (Is 49:14), but quite a number of passages remains open with regard to their references (starting with Is 3:7); this is also true for the first person plural. There are only two passages where an “I” or “we” in Isaiah is directly connected with the figure of the servant(s), namely Is 49:3f and 61:6. This leads us to look more precisely at the texts in Is 49-50 and 61 which also focus on suffering.
Jeremiah differs significantly from Isaiah with regard to the use of the first person. The prophet Jeremiah speaks a lot about himself in the first person, yet seems to avoid the designation “servant” for himself; it is even absent in the so-called ‘confessions’. The combination of “servant” with a first person occurs only in the singular (“my ...”), and solely with God as speaker, with four clear references: prophets (e.g. Jer 7:25; see also the contrast in Jer 29:15, 19), Jacob (denoting the people, in Jer 30:10 // 46:27f), David (33:21f, 26) and Nebuchadnezzar (three times, beginning with 25:9 MT, missing in the LXX). Especially the last identification of “my servant” with the king of Babylon in God’s speech is provocative and marks a noteworthy difference between the two prophetic books in question.
On the basis of these and other observations we will compare further texts dealing with a suffering “I” or “We” in Isaiah and Jeremiah and argue for a literary dependence of the latter from the former.
|
A Mesopotamian Framework for Understanding Ancient Faith: Religious Attitudes in Literary Perspective
Program Unit: Hebrew Scriptures and Cognate Literature
Daniel E. Fleming, New York University
This title is my contribution to a collaboration with Beate Pongratz-Leisten on "A Mesopotamian Framework for Understanding Ancient Faith: Individual Religious Experience in Communal Context." For all the evidence for the worship of deities in communities and households, by individuals from kings to scribes to those unnamed, in settings from palaces to remote shrines, ancient "faith" is difficult to define and investigate. The Bible is read as a book of faith, though here also, the category may be too easily forced into a conception from later religious worlds. For this project, we approach faith as the experience of the religious bond, a state of mind that finds expression in both individual and group dimensions that are best understood to overlap and blend. With this joine presentation, we will explore aspects of religious experience reflected in writing from Mesopotamia and Syria. Our contributions will play off one another, and we hope to provoke a wider conversation among participants.
|
The Mosaic Conquest in the Transjordan according to Deuteronomy 2–3
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Daniel E. Fleming, New York University
In the framework of early J and E documents, the prologue to Deuteronomy in chapters 1-3 seemed derivative, part of the last phase of expanding the book. John Van Seters was among the first to challenge the priority of the accounts in Exodus and Numbers, and he is correct to see Deuteronomy 1-3 as not based on other Torah narrative. Equally, he does not distinguish the Deuteronomistic voice in these chapters from an older narrative base that is only adapted to Deuteronomy by its first-person attribution to Moses. In particular, the account of Israel’s defeat of Sihon and Og, while bypassing the sons of Esau and the sons of Lot, depicts an eastern conquest that has no intrinsic relationship to a western Promised Land. This material was incorporated into the narrative prologue to Deuteronomy at a late stage in the book’s development from a source independent of and parallel to the sources for Exodus 18 and Numbers 20-21. With its focus on Israel’s domination of eastern territory north of Moab, and its association of military conquest with Moses, who never sets foot west of the Jordan River, the core account in Deuteronomy 2-3 appears to have its roots in the “northern” realm of Israel, not Judah. By this analysis, the eastern conquest would belong to what Marc Vervenne calls “pre-Deuteronomic” material, and this may be as old or older than the parallels elsewhere in the Torah.
|
Gods and Philosophers: Perceptions of Early Christianity and Paradigms in Its Intellectual Environment
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
Christopher Forbes, Macquarie University
This paper examines a range of responses to early Christianity by first and second century Greco-Roman observers. They categorize Christianity as either a superstitio (the “wrong kind of religion”), or as a misguided form of philosophy related to Cynicism. This set of perceptions raises fundamental questions about the nature of philosophy and religion as categories in the Early Christian environment. For centuries “philosophy” had been the dominant discourse for Greco-Roman intellectuals, and issues we would think of as “religious” were regularly subsumed under “philosophy”. A number of Jewish intellectuals in the centuries before Christianity set out to present Judaism, not as the “true religion”, but rather, as the “true philosophy”. In the mid-second century A.D. Justin Martyr pioneered this paradigm for Christians, but the precedents on which he drew were much older. I propose that a “cultural niche” existed in the Greco-Roman cultural world for a cross-fertilization between what we would consider “religion” and “philosophy”, and that some sectors within early Christianity, particularly in the Pauline tradition, made use of this paradigm in their self-presentation.
|
Toward a Hierarchical Lexicon for Biblical Hebrew
Program Unit: Biblical Lexicography
A. Dean Forbes, Andersen-Forbes.org
The notion of the hierarchical lexicon will be presented, emphasizing and exemplifying the representational amenities that make it such an elegant and powerful repository of lexical information. Illustrative of possible structures in such a lexicon, a preliminary hierarchy will be introduced for the twenty most frequent Qal active verbs of movement in the Hebrew Bible.
|
Five Approaches to Discourse Analysis
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
A. Dean Forbes, Andersen-Forbes.org
In this paper, I present analyses of a single diabolically complex verse (Judges 4:20) to illustrate five approaches to discourse analysis: (1) “Longacrian” analysis (Longacre), (2) rhetorical structure theory (Mann and Thompson), (3) relational discourse analysis (Grosz and Sidner, Moser and Moore), (4) the linguistic discourse model (Polanyi et al.), and (5) segmented discourse representation theory (Asher and Lascarides). I assess the strengths and weaknesses of each approach, arriving at my preferred synthesis.
|
The Extent of the Recoverable Q Material
Program Unit: Q
Paul Foster, University of Edinburgh
As is well known, Q is a reconstructed source based on the double tradition material shared by Matthew and Luke. Various attempts to reconstruct Q have been undertaken throughout the stages of scholarship on this source. This paper surveys the different approaches and principles that have guided those reconstructions of Q, and seeks to evaluate the validity of such methods. The paper concludes by offering some guiding reflections on how reconstructions of Q could most robustly be undertaken.
|
Led in Paths of Justice: Shaped by the Shaping of the Psalter
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Robert L. Foster, Southern Methodist University
The rhetorical trajectory of the Psalter, indicated in the seem psalms (1/41; 42/72; 73/89; 90/106; 107/150), intends to form just people. Psalm 1 opens this vista of justice by discussing two ways, one way in the practice of justice and the other in the practice of wickedness. The former path is known to God but the latter comes to an end. This former path is called, “blessed,” an affirmation reiterated in Psalm 41, which defines justice in terms of care for the poor (41:1). Caring for the poor marks the life of integrity (41:12), in spite of sin (41:4). Psalms 72 focuses justice specifically in the request that God grant the king the ability to enact justice, attending especially to the poor, weak, needy, and oppressed (72:12-14). The king’s just activity will lead to the whole land flourishing.
Yet, the psalms also ask whether it is worth maintaining one’s integrity, i.e. pursuing justice, in the face of life’s troubles. This is a question of the justice of God. The psalmist in Ps 73 nearly abandons integrity because of the prosperity of the wicked, until the writer recognizes that these violent and oppressive people (vv. 6-8) will find their just end. Psalm 89 directly questions God's justice (v.14) because YHWH rejected the Davidic line, which led to the desolation of Israel (89:38-51), rather than to the flourishing envisioned in Psalm 72.
As the psalter comes to an end, Psalm 106 affirms that blessing attends those pursuing justice (106:3), as it did for Moses (v.23), Phinehas (v.30), and the captors who pitied captive Israel (v.46). God proves just, especially by reversing the fortunes of the richly wicked and the sorrowfully afflicted (107:39-42). This renders God worthy of praise (Psalm 150) and invites the participant to reengage the psalms with greater commitment to persist in the path of justice.
|
The Remains of the Nations: The Role of Babylon in the Book of Isaiah
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Robert L. Foster, Southern Methodist University
Given the importance of Assyria for our apprehension of First Isaiah it comes as a bit of s surprise that Babylon is addressed first in the oracles against the nations in 13-23. It seems to me that the remnant language beginning in chapters 10 and 11 hold the key to understanding why the nation oracles begin with Babylon. By the time the book of Isaiah emerges in a more final form in the late Babylonian or early Persian period, it is clear that the real threat to the remnant of Israel is Babylon, not Assyria. The narrative material in 36-39 demonstrates this as the threat against the remnant of Israel (37:4, 31, 32) by the Assyrians is averted through a divine act of deliverance (ch. 38). The real threat against the remnant of Israel comes with the arrival to Jerusalem of the entourage from Babylon,, though Hezekiah feels relief that this threat will not come to fruition during his reign (ch. 39). Later, in the last reference to the remnant in the book of Isaiah, it is the remnant in Babylon who should not compare YHWH to the gods of Babylon (ch. 46) but realize that YHWH will take vengeance on Babylon for showing no mercy to the people of Israel (ch. 47). Returning to the oracles against the nations in 13-23, we then find an ironic use of remnant language in the charges against Babylon and the vassal nations that pose as threats to Israel. The grandiose language in chapter 13 expresses an exaggerated vision of Babylon encompassing the interests of heaven and earth, envisioning the time of Babylon’s demise. This demise will not only wipe out the remnant of Babylon (14:22), but will threaten the remnant of Babylonians vassals Moab (15:9; 16:14), Syria (17:3), and Arabia (21:17).
|
The Function of the Tale of Job
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Michael V. Fox, University of Wisconsin-Madison
The Tale of Job—that is to say, the Prologue+Epilogue—is almost universally felt to run counter to the message of the book as this is currently understood: that the world lacks a moral order and divine justice is simply not a factor in its operation. To allow for this understanding, the Tale is almost always dismissed in whole or part by an ironic reading. The author supposedly winks to the sophisticated reader that the Tale and its premises are too incredible and too simplistic to be believed.
This paper (based on a talk delivered at S.O.T.S. in July 2010) examines the function and truth-claims of the Tale, arguing that it is meant in full seriousness and lays down the premises by which the book develops its meaning. The Tale of Job may indeed be a folk tale, but the world of folk tales, naïve or not, is filled with dangerous forces and incessant uncertainty. This is also the world presumed and explored in the Dialogue and the speeches of the Theophany.
|
Biblical Sanctification of Dress: Why Wear Tassels on Garments (Num 15:38–40; Deut 22:12)?
Program Unit: Israelite Religion in Its Ancient Context
Nili S. Fox, Hebrew Union College - Jewish Institute of Religion
“Dress” is defined by social scientists as an unambiguous, gender-neutral collective noun designating an assemblage of modifications of the body and supplements to it. In and of itself dress does not carry inherent meaning but rather that ascribed culturally. As a visible extension of the body, its social message is understood by both the wearer and viewer and can mark social and ethnic identity as well as gender roles and boundaries. It is through dress that adults of a society reinforce and transmit cultural norms, instructing the younger generation not simply how to appear but how to act. In short, dress is a means by which society defines its ideology. The present study explores aspects of dress that relate to how ancient Near Eastern societies defined ethnic, social, and religious identity and how dress norms served to label members of different groups and instruct their behavior. My main focus, biblical Israel, concentrates on the Torah laws prescribing garment fringes or tassels. I review commonly held interpretations of these laws and offer additional perspectives based on comparative material and inner biblical exegesis. My thesis is that these biblical prescriptions derive from actual marital rituals involving hem ornaments and are meant to symbolize the covenantal-marital bond between Israel and God.
|
Memory and Rabbinics
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Steven Fraade, Yale University
This paper will consider how social memory theory can contribute to the study of Rabbinics.
|
Matthew’s Questions: Talmudic Rhetoric and Argumentation in the New Testament Jewish Gospel
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
David Frank, University of Oregon
Julie Galambush in her Reluctant Parting argues “Matthew’s extravagant assertions of Jesus’ authority are placed in the context of confrontations with the Pharisees” and that he is “equipping his community to go head-to-head against Pharisaic teachings" (68). In this paper, I draw from the work of Chaïm Perelman and Lucie Olbrechts-Tyteca’s New Rhetoric: A Treatise on Argumentation and Michel Meyer’s Questionnement et Historicité to illuminate the model of argumentation Matthew sought to teach his community. Perelman, Olbrechts-Tyteca, and Meyer help us to understand how the arguments between Jesus and the Pharisees enact a theology rooted in Talmudic rhetoric and argumentation, which is reflected in their theories. The influence of Talmudic thinking on the argumentative exchanges in Matthew is evident in two key notions: epideictic discourse and questioning. Epidictic discourse, the keystone of Perelman and Olbrechts-Tyteca’s work, identifies the need for those who argue to agree on a set of values that will guide action. The preface to the arguments between Jesus and the Pharisees establishes the values they should share, allowing them to critique interpretations of sacred texts and actions provoked by them. When Jesus and the Pharisees argue, they do so primarily through a question and answer process, reflecting an essential characteristic of the Torah and Talmud. Questioning, Meyer suggest, shifts the focus from propositional reasoning to an embedded reason allowing for multiple interpretations of texts and values. Accordingly, the use of epidictic and questioning in Matthew suggests it is a distinctly Jewish rhetoric.
|
The Relationship between Priestly Source of Genesis and of the Other Books of the Pentateuch
Program Unit: Pentateuch
David Frankel, Schechter Institue of Jewish Studies
A recent scholarly trend sees Genesis as a distinct source that was first brought into contact with the narrative of the Exodus at a late stage. It is usually assumed by scholars of this trend that the unification of the materials came about with the priestly layer, and that this layer is therefore related to the redaction of the Pentateuch. It is the thesis of this paper that a close examination of the priestly material in Geneis proves that, to a great extent, the priestly material of Genesis, like the non-priestly material, must be seen as standing independent of the Exodus tradition and of the Pentateuch as a whole. We will explore the distinguishing features of the P of Genesis in relation to the P of the remaining books, and show how they point to significant theological tensions.
|
The Quest for Solomonic Megiddo
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Norma Franklin, Tel Aviv University
This paper will follow the quest for Solomonic Megiddo conducted by three expeditions during seventy years of excavation. The first expedition conducted by the German Society for Oriental Research (1903-1905) proposed that the Solomonic period city was represented by the great burnt city of Stratum VI. The second expedition, the Oriental Institute of the University of Chicago (1925-1939), proposed that it was the great chariot city of Stratum IV. The third expedition, the Hebrew University of Jerusalem (1967, 1970-72) preferred the palatial city of Stratum VA-IVB. The personality, background, and ideology of the senior staff of each of the expeditions played an important role, leading each one to form very different conclusions regarding which stratum represents the 10th century BCE Solomonic city. Only after the earlier stand points are understood can the position of the current, Tel Aviv University expedition (since 1992), be evaluated.
|
A Way Forward for Research and Discussion of “Paul and Judaism”
Program Unit:
Paula Fredriksen, Boston University
*
|
Memory and the Study of the Historical Jesus
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Paula Fredricksen, Boston University
Consideration of how studies in social memory impact studies of the historical Jesus.
|
Voices from Below: The Role of Women’s Opinion in the Birth of Israel’s Monarchy
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Blaire French, University of Virginia
This paper argues that the opinion of women in 1 and 2 Samuel exerts a powerful influence over the reputation and political fortune of Israel’s first kings. My methods are literary. For evidence, I draw on the description of the singing women who greet Saul as he and David return from battle (1 Sam 18.6), the subsequent reports of the event (1 Sam 21.11 and 29.5), and David’s defense of his exuberant dancing before the ark (2 Sam 6.14-22).
The women’s song of 1 Sam 18.6 (“Saul has slain his thousands, but David his ten thousands”) demonstrates the potentially corrosive effect of public opinion on a leader’s reputation. Irreverent speech, if it finds sufficient traction, can take on a life of its own. We see this phenomenon at work as the incident becomes a twice-told tale. In both retellings, it is no longer a band of women who dance and sing, but rather the masculine “they”: “…did they not respond to this one with dancing, saying, ‘Saul has slain…’” (21.11). Over the course of time, the song has assumed the status of common currency among the general populace. As for David, he willingly exposes himself in dance to “the female slaves of his servants” to win their esteem (6.20), an act that shows the breadth of his populist stratagem.
My analysis stands in contrast to biblical scholars who marginalize nameless characters (Adele Reinhartz), as well as those who maintain that the “rank-and-file” are poorly represented (Norman Gottwald). In 1 and 2 Samuel, public opinion exercises influence over leaders in unsettled times, and the inconstancy of public opinion contributes to that political instability. It is within such an environment that the views of anonymous women help shape the opinions of the whole community.
|
Hugh Nibley and German Biblical Exegesis
Program Unit: Latter-day Saints and the Bible
Marco Frenschkowski, Johannes Gutenberg University of Mainz
As is well-known, Hugh Nibley had been in Germany (and Switzerland) 1927-1928 and again in 1945, could read and speak German fluently and in his scholarly work much used sources from Germany. How do his books read today in a context of German Biblical scholarship? As approaches to Biblical Studies become increasingly diverse, it can be useful to seriously analyze the work of a scholar deeply rooted in a non-mainstream church. His dedicated scholarship invites a close look both at the greatness and the limitations of an essentially apologetic life work. The paper discusses inter alia Nibley´s studies on the Henoch figure. Special attention will be given to Nibley´s apolegetic use of religious parallels, compared to apologetic literature from other churches, especially from mainstream Protestantism. What contributions to Biblical and apocryphal subjects in the works of Nibley recent scholarship might be well advised not to overlook? What can reading Hugh Nibley contribute to a dialogue between LDS and non-LDS Biblical scholarship?
The speaker is a German protestant theologian teaching New Testament.
|
The Angel of the Lord and the Hand of God: From the Bible to the Rabbis
Program Unit: Art and Religions of Antiquity
Richard A. Freund, University of Hartford
There are depictions of a hand reaching out of heaven that appear in Jewish amulets, synagogue floor mosaic and wall designs from the Greco-Roman through the Byzantine period that are associated with biblical and Rabbinic interpretations of biblical verses. These biblical verses are either directly associated with God or with an angel of God in the biblical verse or in the Rabbinic interpretation of the verse. In this paper we will explore some Iron Age and Persian period Israelite and Judean material culture that reflect images of God's hand(that may be precedents for the Greco-Roman “Hand of God” images) and compare and contrast the later Jewish depictions of the “Hand of God” with the Greco-Roman “Manus Dei” images.
|
The Rabbinic Economy of Palestine after 70 CE: The Origins of Jewish Milk, Cheese, Oil, Bread, Pickled Vegetables, Wine, Glass, Metal, Pottery, Stone, and Professions
Program Unit: Early Christianity and the Ancient Economy
Richard A. Freund, University of Hartford
The Rabbinic economy of Palestine was created following the two disastrous rebellions against the Romans in 70 CE and 135 CE and represents how ancient “protectionism” can be used to bolster a lagging part of the economy. This protectionist economy of the Rabbis can be tracked by the creation of new categories of restrictions that have little basis in Scripture but serve only to “protect” and differentiate what was left of Jewish life in Palestine from Christian and Roman populations in Palestine. It is well known that the standards of the rabbinic age are not always a continuation of the standards of the biblical period. While the Jews re-interpreted time-honored standards to meet the needs of the people in each age and these reinterpretations were affected by the historical circumstances, the events of 70 and 135 CE represent watershed events that totally changed the relationship between the different populations of Palestine. Many of the changes that were made in Rabbinic literature from the biblical period to the Roman period resulted from changing social and economic conditions of the Jewish people in Israel but some changes were based upon conditions extant in the far flung diasporas of Babylonia and the Mediterranean and therefore are not really relevant to the understanding of the Rabbinic economy of Palestine. This paper will be divided into three different parts: Part I will examine the biblical and Iron Age-Persian period evidence from archaeology for the economy of ancient Israel and will present a summary of what is known about this period.
Part II will examine the innovations of the Judean economy (especially Hasmonean) in light of the changes resulting from Greco-Roman trade and influence. Part III will examine the Rabbinic pronouncements that reflect the change after 70 CE and especially 135 CE and compare them with the evidence from excavations in Roman Palestine through the Byzantine period.
|
Eschatology and the Kingdom in the Fourth Gospel
Program Unit: John, Jesus, and History
Joerg Frey, University of Zurich (Switzerland)
The issue of eschatology has always been one of the most debated issues in Jesus research and in Johannine scholarship as well. The eschatology of Jesus (as reported in the Synoptics) seems to be far away from the eschatology of the Fourth Gospel, with its stress on the presence of life and judgment and its apparent radical reduction (or even negation) of apocalyptic and future-oriented elements. For the liberal theologians in the 19th century, the Johannine view seemed to be more acceptable than the Synoptic expectation of the Son of Man; the earlier Jesus research (before Weiss and Schweitzer) was strongly inclined to accept a more “Johannine” reconstruction of Jesus’ eschatology. Only after Weiss and Schweitzer was there a clear alternative between “Synoptic” and “Johannine” views, and the Johannine texts were totally dismissed from the range of sources for the views of the Jesus of history. In view of the recent questioning of that “critical consensus,” the issue of eschatology may be an interesting paradigm for considering afresh the relationship between the Synoptic views and the Johannine views. The present paper will focus on the notion of the Kingdom. The basileia tou theou is the central eschatological idea in the Synoptics and there can hardly be any doubt that it belongs to the authentic preaching of Jesus. In John, the notion is also presented, but only twice in John 3:3, 5 in a traditional saying, which is presented in two slightly different versions. Further on, the notion of the kingdom is strictly related to Jesus himself, who is finally presented as a king whose kingdom is not from this world (John 18:36). Thus, in Jesus’ kingdom the kingdom of God is realized. The notion of the kingdom is, thus, strongly influenced by Johannine Christology. The differences between the Johannine view and the earlier tradition are obvious, and it is necessary to account for the reason for the differences. Are they only due to the development Johannine theology, or is there a continuity with the eschatological views of Jesus himself?
|
The 'Spirit of Truth' in Qumran and in John: Influence, Analogy, or What?
Program Unit: Qumran
Joerg Frey, Universität München
Among the terminological links between the Qumran texts and the NT one of the most striking parallels is the common mention of a “spirit of truth” in the Doctrine of the Two Spirits (1QS 3:18-19; 4:21, 23) and in the Gospel of John (14:17; 15:26; cf. also 1 John 4:6). The expression can also be found in the Testaments of the Twelve Patriarchs (TestJuda20:1-2) and in Hermas (Mand 3:4), not to mention later (Gnostic) texts, but since the influential comparisons between Qumran and John by R.E. Brown and J.H. Charlesworth, this terminological parallel has often been mentioned as an argument for an indirect or even direct influence of Qumran thought on the Fourth Gospel.
In recent research the dualism in (part of) the Qumran texts and the dualistic elements in the language of the Fourth Gospel have been discussed in a more sophisticated manner, and central elements of the Johannine language such as the opposition of light and darkness can now better be explained from various Scriptural backgrounds without assuming any direct influence from Qumran or the Essenes. In such a more cautious manner, the paper analyzes the different instances of the expression “spirit of truth” and their precise meaning in the different contexts. Even in the Doctrine of the Two Spirits, the expression is not used in a unified manner, and the precise notion and motivations of ‘spirit’ and ‘truth’ are quite different in the various passages. Thus, apparent terminological parallels cannot prove any kind of ‘influence’ but rather show how different authors could use and combine the same terms in very different contexts.
|
Mark 7:15: Jesus' Teaching Is Consistent with Biblical Purity Laws
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
David Friedman, University of Oxford
§§ Jesus' teaching in Mk 7:15 and its explanation in 7:18ff. is usually taken to be a rejection of the biblical dietary laws (Taylor, Raisanen, Sanders, Hooker), ritual laws (Cranfield) or purity law (Gundry). Scholars who attempt to reconcile Jesus' apparently radical teaching with his Jewishness argue either that the teaching is inauthentic (Raisanen, Sanders), that it is a comparative (Booth, Dunn, Kazen, Klawans) or that Jesus did not understand its implications (Lambrecht). All of these readings, however, share the common assumption that Mk 7:15 and 18ff are a rejection of the Law. In contrast, this paper argues that each aspect of Jesus' teaching is consistent with biblical purity/dietary law.
§§ The teaching in Mk 7:15 and its elaboration in vv. 18-23 argue implicitly against hand impurity/ hand washing and explicitly that ordinary food can not defile a man because it passes into the sewer, but that actions can defile. A close reading of the relevant passages in the Pentateuch and Rabbinic literature shows that Jesus' argument is consistent with biblical purity law.
§§ There is no evidence in the Pentateuch that hands could become impure apart from the rest of the body or that hand washing was a required practice. Similarly, there is no biblical evidence that ordinary permitted food could either become impure or could defile by ingestion. Although each of these concepts are found in early Rabbinic literature, they were understood to be extra-biblical strictures. Interestingly, Jesus' teaching that what goes in can not defile because it goes out into the sewer is consistent with Rabbinic teachings that excrement is not defiling. Lastly, nearly all of the sins Jesus identifies as defiling are associated with impurity in the Tanach and Second Temple literature.
|
The Song at the Sea in Comparative Cultural Perspective
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Deborah Gordon Friedrich, Independent Scholar
The proposed presentation will have both diachronic depth and cross-cultural breadth. The time dimension will begin with the ancient context for victory chants praising the Divine Warrior Hero and include perspectives drawing on rabbinic interpretation and liturgical practice en route to an evolving interdisciplinary understanding of what Northrop Frye has called "words of power", with which one may address a dialogic unfolding in hopes that empowerment can become a vehicle for building peace.
Comparative Literature and Cultural Anthroplogy are two realms of discourse that I plan to combine in this exploration of The Song at the Sea as a multi-channel performance piece with divinely-inspired power to heal.
|
Meaning out of Chaos: Biblical Interpretation as a Dissipative System
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Serge Frolov, Southern Methodist University
In the last three decades, biblical scholarship has been increasingly split into two increasingly insular groups: the practitioners of more traditional diachronic (or historical-critical) methodologies and those who prefer newer, synchronic (or literary-critical) approaches. Little opportunity is currently seen for a fruitful, mutually enriching dialogue between these groups, as each of them explicitly or implicitly views its own hermeneutics as exclusively valid and thus denies legitimacy to the interpretive frameworks used by the other side. A promising way to overcome this deplorable and ultimately detrimental dichotomy is to approach it in terms of chaos theory as applied to dissipative (dynamically unstable) systems. Treating biblical interpretation as such a system may be instrumental in not only establishing the parameters under which synchronic or diachronic approach becomes valid but also in demonstrating that in many cases these approaches, routinely viewed as mutually exclusive, can in fact be mutually complementary.
|
Christian Bias in Feminist Introductions to the Bible
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
Esther Fuchs, University of Arizona
In this paper I explore a postcolonial Jewish perspective on feminist biblical studies.
There are several feminist 'textbooks' on biblical literature, as well as several introductions, anthologies, commentaries, and companions. In the 1990s these publications began to include so called “postcolonial” voices, and interpretations that sought to globalize feminist biblical studies. Feminist biblical theory did not define the meanings and diverse agendas of postcolonial criticism. The prevalent understanding is essentialist. What is missing from these new frames is an awareness of discourse as colonial practice. While feminist introductions to the Hebrew Bible are oblivious to the concept of nation, feminist introductions to the Greek Bible are oblivious to the discursive colonizing of the Jewish Bible. The paper will focus specifically on Elisabeth Schussler Fiorenza's “introduction” to a feminist study of the Bible, her hermeneutic theory, her Christian bias, and her limited definition of the postcolonial.
|
Textual Development and the Settlement of Judah: Divergent Traditions in MT and LXX Nehemiah 11–12
Program Unit: Transmission of Traditions in the Second Temple Period
Deirdre N. Fulton, Pennsylvania State University
Among the biblical accounts of the Persian period settlement and occupation of Judah, Nehemiah 11-12 contains a number of lists that recount the people who settled in Jerusalem, a record of settlements around the region of Judah, lists of temple personnel in Jerusalem, and catalogs of people associated with the dedication of the walls of Jerusalem. In reconstructing the post-exilic period in Judah, biblical scholars have used these lists as a means of understanding the scope and magnitude of the period of return to Judah. The MT and LXX, however, preserve variant editions of these texts, which affect the overall picture of the resettlement of Judah during the Persian period. This paper will examine the MT and LXX differences, specifically for the purpose of understanding scribal changes to the MT in light of the differences in the LXX.
|
Disaster Management: Paul's Use of the Book of Numbers
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
Julie Galambush, College of William and Mary
Paul's references to Moses as a model and source of his own authority reflect a rhetorical strategy that (as Hindy Najman has shown) goes back at least to Ezra-Nehemiah and that continues in later Second Temple and rabbinic writings. In his allusions to the book of Numbers, however, Paul makes a different use of Moses. In Numbers, Moses' repeated failures of authority are invariably followed by God's severe punishment of the people. The overarching message of Numbers is a clear mandate to respect the authority of God's representatives, no matter how questionable that authority may appear. Paul, facing challenges to his own authority, incorporates the failed Moses of Numbers with the tradition in which Moses' authority is absolute, thus buttressing his role as the heir to Moses as authoritative teacher with the threat of divine retribution against those who would take advantage of his failures.
|
Solomon's Temple: Fiction or Reality
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Gershon Galil, University of Haifa
The paper reexamines the description of Solomon's temple in 1 Kings 5:6 - 9:9 in light of ancient Near Eastern building stories, and points out that it is a realistic description, composed in Solomon's reign and enlarged mainly by the Dtr.
|
The Status of the Lower Stratum Families in the Neo-Assyrian Period
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Gershon Galil, University of Haifa
This paper reexamines the status of the lower stratum families in the Neo-Assyrian period. About 25% of the 450 families known to date, are clearly true slaves, attested mainly in sales of people, and about 5% are temporarily in that status, namely pledged people. The status of the other families is unclear. Scholars have adopted a variety of terms to define the status of these people, among them pseudo-sklaven, serfs, helots, tied cultivators, dependent persons, semi-free population, unfree workmen, servile labor force, and more. In my opinion, most of these persons were employed as errešu on land owned by the members of the middle and upper strata, and the great majority of the population of the Neo-Assyrian Empire should be defined by the term tenants. The main part of the paper considers other socio-economic and demographic issues, including family types, family size, marriage patterns, childless families, single-parents families, children's ages, infertility, infant mortality, longevity and more.
|
Connections between Judges, Samuel, Kings, and the Qeiyafa Inscription
Program Unit: Joshua-Judges
Gershon Galil, University of Haifa
In the first part of my lecture I present the four main editions of the book of Judges (in my opinion): a. "The book of Saviors"; b. The Judean edition of Judges: an updated edition of "the book of Saviors"; c. The Deuteronomistic edition of Judges (composed by the Deuteronomist in the sixth century BCE); and d. The Priestly edition of Judges (composed in the Persian Period).
In the second part of my lecture, I claim that "the book of Saviors" was actually re-written by "the author of the Book of Samuel", namely that this Judean "Pre-Deuteronomistic" edition of Judges was the work of the same person who composed the Book of Samuel. Moreover I maintain that both texts should be dated to the 10th century BCE, and that this must be the date of two other compositions, a Biblical one and an extra-Biblical inscription. The Biblical text is "the Book of the Acts of Solomon" which was written in the second half of Solomon's reign, and the other is the Qeiyafa inscription, a prophetical text which I have deciphered only recently. The connections between these four sophisticated compositions are reexamined in my paper, in light of other Ancient Near Eastern data (mainly building inscriptions), indicating that we should look for extra-Biblical criteria for dating Biblical texts.
|
The “Apocrypha” in Jerome’s Canonical Theory
Program Unit: Function of Apocryphal and Pseudepigraphal Writings in Early Judaism and Early Christianity
Edmon Gallagher, Heritage Christian University
In his Preface to Samuel and Kings (the Prologus Galeatus), Jerome sets forth a theory of the Old Testament canon that allows for no room between the canonical books and the apocrypha. Jerome’s use of the term “apocrypha” in this context should be interpreted in the light of such terminology in contemporary canonical discussions, which indicates that Jerome countenanced no “ecclesiastical” books outside the canon but still useful to the church, a category we find in Rufinus and, earlier, in Athanasius. However, Jerome elsewhere maintained a more neutral or even positive view of some of the non-canonical books, even accepting their use within the ecclesiastical liturgy. Jerome’s seemingly inconsistent attitude toward some books he classifies as “apocrypha” has led scholars either to posit a development in Jerome’s canonical theory, or to suppose that the theory found in the Prologus Galeatus does not represent even Jerome’s mature views, which were instead much more accepting of the deuterocanonicals than his famous preface would imply. This paper seeks clarification of Jerome’s canonical theory by investigating his remarks on the canon in several of his writings, and placing them in the context of fourth-century discussions of the Old Testament canon. The confusion arising from Jerome’s comments may be explained as a consequence of a multi-faceted plan to realign the Church’s Old Testament with the Hebrew Bible, a plan that Jerome articulates only partially on any given occasion.
|
The Jews and the Old Testament according to Julius Africanus and Origen
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Edmon Gallagher, Heritage Christian University
The famous correspondence between Julius Africanus and Origen discloses some of the conflicting ways in which early Christians conceived of the relationship between their OT (the LXX) and the Bible in circulation among Jews. In attacking the authenticity of the Story of Susanna, Africanus relies in part on its absence from the Jewish version of Daniel. Origen, however, developed an elaborate argument designed to instill doubt among Christians with regard to Jewish testimony on the contents of the Bible. These two positions—Africanus’ trust in the reliability of the Jewish Bible versus Origen’s suspicious stance—echo the uneasy attitudes toward Jews in the wider Christian world. On the other hand, both Africanus and Origen make it clear that a document had to be composed in Hebrew to be considered a part of the Christian OT. Indeed, both Fathers considered as distinct criteria of canonicity the Jewish acceptance of a document and its composition in Hebrew, and both explicitly endorsed what might be called the “Hebrew criterion”. Certain lines of evidence also indicate that this Hebrew criterion enjoyed general approval in the early Church. The probable reason for patristic acceptance of this principle was to bind the Christian OT to the Bible produced by the ancient Hebrews. That is, even as some Christians explicitly rejected the authority of “modern” Jews in regard to the Christian Bible, still these same Christians sought to authenticate their own scriptures by linking them to the “ancient” Jews.
|
The Understanding of Egypt as a Place of Refuge in the Book of Jeremiah
Program Unit: Exile (Forced Migrations) in Biblical Literature
Garrett Galvin, Franciscan School of Theology
The purpose of this paper is to examine the Book of Jeremiah’s portrayal of Egypt as a place of refuge. Although we have seen an ambivalent attitude towards Egypt as a place of refuge in 1 Kings 11-12, Jeremiah displays a more negative attitude overall towards Egypt as such a place. The relation of MT and LXX Jeremiah has led to much scholarly debate. I first address this general question and then examine the degree to which the LXX’s references to Egypt differ from those of the MT. In this connection, I will briefly note all the mentions of the word “Egypt” in both the MT and LXX and divide these into three categories: references to the past event of the Exodus, references to contemporary Egypt outside the Baruch Scroll (36-45), and the Baruch Scroll. After exploring these three categories, I will examine Jeremiah 46 in detail because of the concentration of references to Egypt, its history, and its cult found there and because it has a perspective quite different from the book’s other references to contemporary Egypt outside the Baruch Scroll. Jeremiah 46 also merits special attention because both prose and poetry from a number of time periods and perspectives appear there. I evaluate all this material from a synchronic perspective. Finally, I will explore how historians have treated the Egyptian material in the Book of Jeremiah and offer some concluding remarks.
|
Reading Exodus by Way of the Passover Haggadah
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Zev Garber, Los Angeles Valley College
Rabbinic tradition teaches that HaShem seperates,categorizes, and makes distinctions. Tradition interweaves the epic narrative of Exodus with ongoing historical experience and memory.Yet how to explain this article of belief, revelation and theology in terms of enlightenment, modernism, and post-modernism? An exercise in Torahtology.
|
Greeks, Rabbis, and the Origins of Jewish Charity in the Third Century
Program Unit: Religious Competition in Late Antiquity
Gregg Gardner, University of British Columbia
One of the central concepts of Jewish law and ethics is tsedaqah, which means “righteousness” in the Hebrew Bible, but in later texts also indicates “almsgiving” or “charity.” This paper is part of a larger study on the origins of Jewish charity, including how and why it came to be called tsedaqah. It traces the concept to the earliest stratum of rabbinic literature, legal and exegetical texts redacted in third-century Roman Palestine. These corpora, including the Mishnah and Tosefta serve as the foundations of the Talmud and, in turn, all subsequent works of rabbinic Judaism. This paper focuses on a narrative in which a king gives away his fortunes to relieve a famine (Tosefta Peah 4:18). A close reading of the text illuminates its approaches to supporting the poor, which are then placed into their Greco-Roman cultural contexts. This study finds that the rabbis display knowledge of Greek forms of giving, particularly Hellenistic civic benefaction (euergetism), which they adapt for their own purposes. Through their selection of biblical prooftexts, the rabbinic redactors also identify the benefactor as a righteous individual and his benefactions as acts of righteousness. This paper contributes to our understanding of Judaism in the third century by illuminating the role of – and the rabbis’ creative engagement with – Greco-Roman culture.
|
We`atta "Now"
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
W. Randall Garr, University of California-Santa Barbara
In dialogue with philological literature (Land 1949; Brongers 1964; Jenni 1972/1997) and discourse studies (Schiffrin 1987; Fraser 2009), this paper will trace the use of we`atta from a deictic of temporal immediacy to a marker of present-immediate discourse relevance appearing at significant turning points in reported speech.
|
Drought and Deceit: The Structure and Intertextuality of Jer 14:7–9, 19–22
Program Unit: Writing/Reading Jeremiah
R. E. Garton, Baylor University
Scholars have long been pressed to explain Yahweh’s callous rejection of Judah’s impassioned plea in Jeremiah 14. There, in the face of severe drought, Judah gathers together, confesses their apostasies, and attempts to spur Yahweh to action. Earlier Yahweh had complained about Jerusalem’s lack of contrition (Jer 8:5-6), yet here after having acknowledged their failures the deity curiously rejects Judah (Jer 14:10, 15:1). In an attempt to understand Yahweh’s rejection, this paper explores the two communal complaint speeches offered by the Judah in Jer 14:7-9 and 14:19-22. I begin by proposing a heretofore unrecognized intertextual relationship within these two speeches. In Jer 14:7-9, the confluence of situational context and intertextual allusions could have evoked the story of God’s miraculous provision of water at Massah (Exod 17:1-7). The plausibility of this intertext increases, however, when one reads Jer 14:7-9 in conjunction with 14:19-22. Scholars have so far failed to recognize the structural cohesion between these two so-called speeches. When read together, 14:7-9, 19-22 structurally form a single lament with a pattern of inverted concepts similar to that of a chiasm. Moreover, it is within the second half of this lament that further intertextual allusions emerge, making the proposed intertextual relationship that much more plausible. This intertext alone, however, cannot explain Yahweh’s acute reaction. Rather, one further needs to understand the characteristic portrayal of this intertext’s creator, Judah. Consequently, a brief survey of the characterization of Judah in the literary context prior to Jer 14:7-9, 19-22 is necessary. Combined, intertext and characterization converge, revealing that Judah’s intentions are not all that they first appear to be. Rather than genuine repentance, Jeremiah 14 portrays Judah as having formulated a ruse, one by which they had hoped to manipulate Yahweh.
|
A New Moabite Dedicatory Inscription and the Problem of Literacy in Moab
Program Unit: Hebrew Scriptures and Cognate Literature
Erasmus Gass, University of Tubingen
A few years ago a new Moabite dedicatory inscription on a basalt pestle was found during excavations at el-Balu. This new inscription lacks word dividers, so the demarcation of single words is difficult to find out. According to this text a group of workers - perhaps responsible for the water resources - dedicates the pestle to their leader. It is questionable whether a cultic context for this pestle can be expected - like for the one on the incense altar found at Khirbet el-Mudeyine - since the archaeological record does not present evidence for a cultic provenance. This new inscription can be distinguished from the Moabite royal inscriptions like the famous Mesha Inscription and represents the official language of standard Moabite not necessarily. However, up to date the amount of epigraphic data found in Moab exceeds all other transjordanian
polities. Maybe one has to reckon with broad literacy in Moab in the Iron Age. Therefore it is also possible that there was the capability of writing in Iron Age Israel like in Moab with implications for the literary history of the Bible.
|
Neither Height nor Depth: Discerning the Cosmology of Romans
Program Unit: Pauline Theology
Beverly Roberts Gaventa, Princeton Theological Seminary
Invited Paper
|
History of the Book of the Dead I
Program Unit: Egyptology and Ancient Israel
John Gee, Brigham Young University
The compilation of the Book of the Dead as a religious text provides an interesting parallel to the compilation of biblical texts, but has an advantage over the biblical text in that we have an ancient manuscript tradition that allows one to see how the text was compiled over time. This paper will examine the early stages of the compilation of the Book of the Dead and cover the early portion of the Eighteenth Dynasty.
|
Egyptian Interpretations of Abraham
Program Unit: Christianity in Egypt: Scripture, Tradition, and Reception
John Gee, Brigham Young University
Egyptian traditions about Abraham first appear in the reign of Ptolemy I and have a long history before Christianity comes to Egypt. This paper will survey the various traditions about Abraham ending with Coptic homilies about Abraham. The interaction between Coptic and Egyptian interpretations of this seminal biblical figure provide a backdrop for understanding how Egypt was prepared for Christianity.
|
Nomen est Omen: The Practice of Naming in Mark's Gospel as an Instrument (of Power) in Service of Identity Construction(s)
Program Unit: Construction of Christian Identities
Gabriella Gelardini, University of Basel
A look into Mark’s practice of naming perplexes: How come a passer-by, a narrative side actor by the name Simon of Cyrene is acknowledged a proper name by the author (Mk 15:21), and even his children—that play no part at all in the narrative—are, yet the central figures of high priest(s), scribes, elders, and Pharisees are not one single time granted one? Naming, as is generally known, is an important tool but also instrument of power to construct identity and identities, individual as well as collective ones. Power is exhibited in such a manner that the giver ascribes and inscribes social value via a name or the absence of it to individuals and groups. In that the author of Mark does not differ, as the example above—and only one amongst others—illustrates, this paper therefore seeks on the basis of apt identity theories to trace the author’s literal identity strategies as far as it applies to his practice of naming. The onomastic revenues are thereafter incorporated into a more general theory of literary identity construction(s).
|
Egyptian Perspective on Pharaoh as a Character in the Exodus Narrative: Exodus 1–15
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Magdi S. Gendi, Evangelical Theological Seminary, Cairo, Egypt
Pharaoh is a major character in the present form of the narrative of Exodus 1-15. He speaks, acts, and makes decisions (especially in relation to God) that contribute to the tension and development of the narrative and engage the reader, either positively or negatively. An investigation of the narrator’s portrayal of Pharaoh, considered within the literary structure of the narrative, produces significant insights into the literary artistry and the theological depth of this material.
No one, especially, the contemporary Egyptians can read the exodus narrative in Exod 1—15 without encountering Pharaoh, who stands firmly within its literary world. The flow of the narrative depends on the nature of the characters and their various interactions, which generate the sequence of the events. Each character helps to develop the character of Pharaoh. Pharaoh speaks, acts, reacts to other characters and events, and makes decisions. At the same time what the other characters say about Pharaoh, how they treat Pharaoh, and how they react to his decisions play an import important role in portrayal of Pharaoh himself. Thus Pharaoh plays a crucial role in the developing the tension and the plot of the narrative. The textual indicators for Pharaoh as a character in the narrative include appellation, character actions, character speech, inner life, and narrator commentary or point of view.
Pharaoh appears as a character from the beginning of the story to the end. The narrative’s presentation of the relationship between Pharaoh and other characters serves to provide a structure for a sequential reading of Exodus in an investigation concerned with Pharaoh as a character.
This relationship is most forcefully shaped by four episodes:
Pharaoh encountering the Israelites (1:1—2: 25), Pharaoh encountering Moses (5:1-23), Pharaoh in confrontation with Yahweh (7:7-11:8), Yahweh’s ultimate victory and Pharaoh’s final defeat (14:1-15:21).
|
Pharaoh as a Character in the Exodus Narrative: Exodus 1–15; Egyptian Perspective
Program Unit: Egyptology and Ancient Israel
Magdi Gendi, Evangelical Theological Seminary in Cairo
Pharaoh is a major character in the present form of the narrative of Exodus 1-15. He speaks, acts, and makes decisions (especially in relation to God) that contribute to the tension and development of the narrative and engage the reader, either positively or negatively. An investigation of the narrator’s portrayal of Pharaoh, considered within the literary structure of the narrative, produces significant insights into the literary artistry and the theological depth of this material.
No one, especially, the contemporary Egyptians can read the exodus narrative in Exod 1—15 without encountering Pharaoh, who stands firmly within its literary world. The flow of the narrative depends on the nature of the characters and their various interactions, which generate the sequence of the events. Each character helps to develop the character of Pharaoh. Pharaoh speaks, acts, reacts to other characters and events, and makes decisions. At the same time what the other characters say about Pharaoh, how they treat Pharaoh, and how they react to his decisions play an import important role in portrayal of Pharaoh himself. Thus Pharaoh plays a crucial role in the developing the tension and the plot of the narrative. The textual indicators for Pharaoh as a character in the narrative include appellation, character actions, character speech, inner life, and narrator commentary or point of view.
Pharaoh appears as a character from the beginning of the story to the end. The narrative’s presentation of the relationship between Pharaoh and other characters serves to provide a structure for a sequential reading of Exodus in an investigation concerned with Pharaoh as a character.
This relationship is most forcefully shaped by four episodes:
Pharaoh encountering the Israelites (1:1—2: 25), Pharaoh encountering Moses (5:1-23), Pharaoh in confrontation with Yahweh (7:7-11:8), Yahweh’s ultimate victory and Pharaoh’s final defeat (14:1-15:21)
|
Examining the Claim of the Midrashic Nature of the Matthean Parables through Understanding the Functions of the Rabbinic Parables
Program Unit: Matthew
Atef Gendy, The Evangelical Theological Seminary in Cairo
Several NT scholars claim that the Matthean parables are much closer to the rabbinic tradition than to the rest of the synoptic parables. The Matthean parables are frequently described as "midrashic" in their nature and function. It was argued that Matthew has often used his parables to provide a commentary to some Markan sayings or teachings (cf. Goulder, Midrash and Lection in Matthew, p. 64; Drury, The Parables in the Gospels, pp. 91-92; Kingsbury, The Parables of Jesus in Matthew 13, p. 136). The term "Midrashic" is used in a general sense by several scholars to signify the exegetical role of the Matthean parables. Although this usage could be acceptable linguistically, and though there is a fairly wide consensus among scholars regarding the general exegetical role of the rabbinic parables, the use of the term midrashic in the sense of exegetical can be misleading. This is because the usage is so general that it ignores the many technical and religious connotations the word has acquired over time, which makes the simple linguistic meaning-"exegetical"- no longer legitimate. In addition, nearly every parable, in a sense, interprets or explains something, but this does not qualify all or most of the parables to be called midrashic
Are the Matthean parables midrashic? The only way to answer this question is to define the "midrashic role/function" of the rabbinic parables and then to see if the Matthean parables play this role or not. In other words, we need to know first what are the different sub-roles and sub-functions, which are involved under the overall midrashic function. Then one can say that a midrashic parable is that which does such and such. Only then can we decide whether the Matthean parables are midrashic or not.
Six sub-function of the rabbinic parables will be presented here through studying many rabbinic parables which return to the early tannitic period of the rabbis (up to year 80 AD). Then, a reflection on the Matthean parables will be made in order to examine the claim of their midrashic function.
|
The Dynamics of Praise in the Ancient Near East
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Erhard Gerstenberger, Philipps Universität-Marburg
Praise language and articulations of supplication and complaint intertwine in the Ancient Near East since Sumerian times. What are the particularities of praise poetry? It is extremely rich in descriptive, aesthetic affirmations, thus portraying or even enacting the power and glory of the deities. We should note, however, also the performative qualities of exultation and jubilation: By using “beautiful” vocabulary and intricate stylistic and literary schemes as well as embedding them into ceremonial ritual the authors of eulogies are creatively constructing the very authority they are singing to. Praise is implementing and conferring power to the praised one. In contrast to the compulsive word of complaint and supplication or the educational language of instruction eulogies employ a subtly exalting poetry, which in itself is powerful and, in fact, produces power. Thus Patrick Miller’s contention that Biblical poetry “is figural and non-literal; it is indirect and open.” “… rooted in the imagination”, “figurative” and “mysterious” should be augmented by the dimension of power: Poetic language, responding to divine benevolent presence, is in itself a creative force.
|
Origen of Alexandria on Perceiving Ourselves and Others in Light of the Apocatastasis
Program Unit: Hellenistic Moral Philosophy and Early Christianity
Kathleen Gibbons, University of Toronto
In his work engaging contemporary discussions of how Western concepts of subjectivity emerged, Christopher Gill has argued for making a distinction between “subjective participant” and “objective observer” theories of the self, claiming that in ancient discussions of ethics the latter view dominated. While a number of issues are at stake in this distinction, presently I would like to consider the issue of self-reflexivity (the emphasis found in subjective-participant models) versus self-reflectivity (that found in objective observer models). Self-reflexive concepts of the self tend to be concerned with a distinctively first-person point of view, while self-reflective concepts emphasize the way in which our relationships with ourselves are of the same kind as our relationships with other people. Gill argues that, when it comes to self-perception, ancient theories of self-perception frequently emphasized self-reflection.
I will here consider how this distinction helps to illuminate early Christian theories of moral psychology. In developing his moral psychology, the third-century author Origen of Alexandria borrowed a great deal from Epictetus, including a concern with the idea that examining the behavior of other people helps us to examine our own. Origen inserts this strategy, however, into his broader cosmological picture, in which God pairs human beings against particular adversaries in order to facilitate the moral progress of rational beings with a view to their salvation in the apocatastasis. In this current study, I will consider how the parallels between self- and other-examination operative in Origen’s picture of moral progress informs, and is informed by, his apocalyptic orientation.
|
“This Is My World!” Son of Man and the Cross-Cultural Convergence of Bible and World
Program Unit: Bible and Film
Samuel Giere, Wartburg Theological Seminary
“This is my world!” is a refrain reiterated by the character of Jesus throughout Son of Man (2006), a telling of the story of Jesus set in a modern South African township called “Judea.” With dialogue and music primarily in the South African language of Xhosa, for people in the West and perhaps everywhere outside South Africa and Xhosa culture the film is a cross-cultural experience. The world of the film is unashamedly bathed in Xhosa culture and the story wrought with danger, violence, disappearance, and death. The telling of Jesus’ story in this cultural setting paints a convergence of the biblical horizon of Jesus stories and the contemporary horizon of the world’s deep brokenness particularized in modern South Africa. This paper addresses the relation of this film to the text of the Bible within two categories: quotation and allusion. Second, the paper explores the cross-cultural nature of two critical points in the film wherein Jesus’ story intersects with traditional Xhosa culture and modern South African (and by extension – global) political reality – baptism/temptation and crucifixion respectively. Finally, the paper explores how Son of Man, an artistic and cross-cultural interpretation of Jesus’ story, interprets the meaning of Jesus’ story in ways that send the viewer/reader back to biblical texts with otherwise unavailable insight.
|
“He Is Not Here”: Being There and the Gospel of Mark
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Grant Gieseke, Drew University
Many remember the 1979 movie Being There starring Peter Sellers for its audacious final scene in which Chance the Gardner walks on water. This is only one way in which the film echoes the Gospels, however, and the Gospel of Mark in particular. Chance’s mysterious parentage, his propensity to speak in parables (particularly of the horticultural variety) and the consistency of Sellers’ performance of the simple yet enigmatic character join the miraculous walk by inviting parallels with Mark’s portrayal of the character of Jesus. Indeed, Chance’s character is the quintessential example of a character type delineated by film theorists as a “holy innocent,” suggesting yet another point of convergence between these two protagonists.
The paper I propose will examine these connections by pairing analysis of the parable theory of Mark 4, Jesus walking on water and the longer ending of Mark with three scenes from Being There: Chance’s meeting with the President in which he provides a parable (1:01:48; 3 minutes), Chance walking on water (2:02:43; 3.5 minutes) and the outtakes that run over the closing credits in which Sellers breaks character (2:06:07; 3.5 minutes). The larger issues in play in the presentation are how the character of Chance serves as a surrogate for the character of Jesus in analyzing the process whereby characters or historical figures are constructed and/or interpreted by means of the projection of others’ expectations, both within and beyond the narrative in which they appear. Also, this essay will draw attention to the pedagogical strategy of studying these texts in tandem and how doing so creates a critical distance that invites students first to do this work with Chance and then apply a similar approach to the character of Jesus in Mark.
Note: I have submitted this proposal to the Bible and Film program unit, as well.
|
The Postcolonial Prologue: John 1:1–18 and Cosmic Colonization
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Grant Gieseke, Drew University
As suggested by Frank Kermode, the critical theorist and occasional interloper into New Testament studies, many endings in narrative texts are irresolute because they reflect a sense of the incompleteness of life with which artists are acutely familiar. But what of the sense of a beginning? The prologue to the Fourth Gospel has been understood by many as the construction of the work’s hermeneutical framework; thus, in a Gospel in which Rome plays such a significant role in Jesus’ climactic passion, we would expect a prologue similarly occupied with the Roman colonial elephant in the room. I suggest in this paper that the prologue to the Fourth Gospel (John 1:1-18) is constrained by colonial hybridity, as understood by the postcolonial theorist Homi Bhabha.
Hybridity is the product of a network of overlapping projects and ideologies under the auspices of the colonizer’s culture that seek to establish the identity of the colonized as inferior and hopelessly fractured. John’s conception of Jesus as the logos is audaciously universal, extended immediately and infinitely across time and space and for all people. And yet, this fracturing of identities is evident in the prologue insofar as John’s perception of the timeless logos is immediately problematized by the intruding present (as references to John the Baptist uneasily interrupt the prologue). Similarly, to read the prologue as a meditation on “logos theology” (to refer to Daniel Boyarin’s framing) demonstrates the multivalence of a signifier that would resonate both in Jewish and Hellenistic milieus, thus strategically appealing to hybridity to make claims that transcend cultures and ideologies. Finally, the sectarianism posited by J. Louis Martyn, though sublimated in this passage, punctures the prologue (in allusions to Moses and to the rejection by the logos’ own) and its bold, universal claims by exhibiting a parochial hybridity among Jewish communities. The prologue is thus irrevocably hybridized, reflecting a sense of fracture and incompleteness that lurks in the Johannine prologue and perhaps even across the hybrid whole of the Fourth Gospel.
|
"We Know That Everything That Law Says... ": Rom 3:9–20 as a Narrative Utilization of Intertextuality That Develops Its Own Theory of Intertextuality
Program Unit: Intertextuality in the New Testament
Alain Gignac, Université de Montréal
Rom 3:9-20 seems so clear (an indictment which proves or illustrates the universality of sin) that few studies are dedicated to these verses (e.g. Keck 1977, Hays 1980, Moyise 1995, Watson 2004). From a rhetorical perspective, it is an argument based on the authority of Scriptures. Nonetheless, the mechanisms of this text are more sophisticated. The intertextual assembly of vv. 10-18 (Ps 13:1-3 = Ps 54:2-4; Ps 5:10; Ps 139:4; Ps 9:28; Is 59:7-8; Ps 35:2) has a narrative function and develops its own theory of intertextuality via a complex enunciative device (cf. Benveniste). 1/ On the narrative level, some monstrous traits of deformity slowly appear: a humanity without a face, deprived of sight, with a wide open mouth ready to bite and howl, even incapable to look at God with fear. Is it the representation of humanity itself, or of a humanity which has lost its own humanness and has taken the very traits of its despotic master named Sin? 2/ The text’s enunciation is complex, since the monster’s description is assumed by two instances but in a different manner: as in a court of law setting, the prosecutor (we) first speaks and then his witness takes the stand (the Law). ‘We’ speaks to the letter’s receivers concerning humanity as a whole and quotes a written witness (3:10), while ‘Law’ talks to ‘those within the Law’ concerning the ungodly (3:19). Ultimately, it is the prosecutor who confirms the scope of the Law’s witness: “We know that everything that Law says, it says so that every mouth may be silenced” (3:19). In other words, Rom 3 suggests its own theory of intertextuality, through the confrontation of two voices (“we” and Law) and the double function of Law as interpreted Scripture and as interpreting speaker.
|
Singing Women and Promised Seed: Isaiah 54:1–3 as Christian Scripture
Program Unit: Theological Interpretation of Scripture
Mark S. Gignilliat, Beeson Divinity School, Samford University
By making use of a multi-layered hermeneutical approach to reading the Old Testament Christianly, this paper will engage the figural potentiality of Isaiah 54:1-3 as a Christian witness. Firstly, the text’s literary fixity will be examined. How does Isa 54:1-3 function within the canonical shape of the book as we now have it? It will be argued that in Isaiah’s own discrete voice and shape, Isaiah 54:1-3 functions as a hinge text that looks back to the work of the servant and anticipates the work of the servant’s progeny, namely, the servants (Isa 54:17). Isaiah 54:1-3 reorients the promises given to Zion (cf. Isa 51:1-3) as promises now inextricably bound to the servant and his heirs. Zion’s promises are for those who have identified with the servant and have extended the work of the servant in their own faithful actions. The paper will argue that the move made in Isaiah 54:1-3 (and the chapter in toto) anticipates the major themes developed throughout the rest of the book on the far side of the servant’s final scene (Isaiah 53). Once the literary fixity is examined, then the figural dimension will be explored as the text is naturally extended in light of the divine economy and our two testament canon. The following are examples: the person and work of Christ; more specifically, his gracious and sacrificial actions as providing the possibility for a righteous offspring; righteousness as firstly gift then covenant obligation; and the followers of Christ as heralds of his person and work as they wait in eschatological tension. Indeed, Jerome was correct in the preface of his Isaiah commentary to call Isaiah an evangelist (non solum prophetam, sed euangelistam et apostolum doceam) and to say, “[I]gnoratio scripturarum, ingoratio Christi est.” This paper will share the tenor of Jerome’s comments.
|
Trivocal Preaching in African America: Recovering the Preacher's Voice
Program Unit: Academy of Homiletics
Kenyatta R. Gilbert, Howard University
*
|
Capital of Solomon's Fourth District (?): Israelite Dor
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Ayelet Gilboa, University of Haifa
The Iron Age sequence at Tel Dor, on Israel's northern coast has provided a wealth of information regarding the early Iron Age - a time when its material culture, and the identity of its inhabitants may be characterized as Phoenician. For the last two decades this sequence indeed has been the focus of research. We are now turning our attention to the later part of the Iron Age, the period when Dor became part of the Israelite Monarchy, one of its main outlets to the Mediterranean, and according to the bible – the capital of Solomon's 4th district. Architectural and other finds at Dor in this time span are indeed very different than the previous, Phoenician ones, and provide first insights as to what the political transformation might have meant for Dor, its inhabitants - and on the chronology of the process.
|
Tel Dor from Phoenicians to Israelites (and Back?)
Program Unit:
Ayelet Gilboa, University of Haifa
Iron Age stratigraphical sequence at Dor can roughly be divided into three consecutive cultural units, which differ from each other in many aspects of their material culture. They span the time span from the 11th to the 7th century BCE. This lecture will explore the possibility that these different units reflect political and even ethnic transformations, reflecting the changing fortunes of Dor—form a Canaanite/Phoenician settlement to an Israelite administrative center in the 9th century BCE, and its affiliation under Assyrian rule.
|
Qoheleth's Pessimistic Response to Death
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Jason Gile, Wheaton College
This paper presents the thesis that Qoheleth’s reaction to the inevitability of death is unique in the Hebrew Bible and contrary to the norm of the Near Eastern wisdom tradition. Faced with the reality that he will die and have nothing lasting to show for his life, Qoheleth chooses pessimism, opting to emphasize the senselessness (hebel) of this “great evil” that will befall him (2:21). A comparison with other responses to death in wisdom literature shows that Qoheleth stands out in significant ways. Thus, for example, in stark contrast to the widespread emphasis on intergenerational instruction, Qoheleth is so consumed with the injustice caused by the finality of death that he overlooks the satisfaction and benefits of investing in the next generation. In particular, unlike other royal sages (e.g., Pharaoh Khety), the “king in Jerusalem” neglects instructing his son, the prince, in the ways of wisdom and instead bemoans the fact that his son will inherit his fortune. Qoheleth also laments that after his death he will not have a remembrance among posterity. While other sages (e.g., Ptahhotep) discovered that the wisdom they taught would serve as a remembrance of them in the mouths of the living, Qoheleth found no such solace. Finally, citing the influential developmental theory of psychologist Erik Erikson, I will show that Qoheleth contradicts not only the wisdom tradition but also the general human desire to leave something of value to the next generation. To conclude, I offer implications of these observations for understanding Qoheleth in relation to the narrative epilogue of the book and the place of Ecclesiastes among the wisdom literature of the Bible and Near East.
|
The Pharaoh Sety II and Egyptian Political Relations with Canaan at the End of the Late Bronze Age
Program Unit: Egyptology and Ancient Israel
Garth Gilmour, University of Oxford
The discovery of a jar handle with an stamp seal of the pharaoh Sety II at Gezer offers the opportunity for a look at the reign of this minor king who ruled in Egypt at the critical period right at the end of the Late Bronze Age, and his dealings with Canaan. This paper presents the context of the handle in the Gezer excavations, and reviews its significance within the small corpus of objects assigned to this king. This serves as an introduction to a review of the reign of Sety II and a reassessment of some of the controversies that surround the period following the death of Ramesses II. The paper looks at Sety’s career before ascending the throne (including his relationships with Ramesses II and Merneptah, role as Chief of the Egyptian army and the campaigns in Canaan and Libya), the controversies pertaining to his accession and reign, with special emphasis on his relations with and activities in Canaan, and the intrigue that followed his death.
|
Beware the ‘Strange Woman’: Lady Wisdom Calls out from Anne Brontë’s The Tenant of Wildfell Hall
Program Unit: Recovering Female Interpreters of the Bible
Michael Gilmour, Providence College (Canada)
Charlotte Brontë describes her sister Anne as “a very sincere and practical Christian [with] the tinge of religious melancholy [that] communicated a sad shade to her brief, blameless life.” We find something of this serious and pragmatic religious worldview reflected in Anne’s second and final novel, The Tenant of Wildfell Hall (1848), which relates the story of a young woman’s disastrous marriage to an uncaring, brutish drunkard. The novel is replete with biblical content and conversations about morality and duty among its characters, all of which serve pedagogical ends. Brontë makes this clear in a later preface, writing, “if I had warned one rash youth from following in [vicious characters’] steps, or prevented one thoughtless girl from falling into the very natural error of my heroine, the book has not been written in vain.” To achieve this, I argue, Brontë subtly introduces the warnings and enticements of Proverbs’ Lady Wisdom and Lady Folly (the “strange woman”). Through the interaction of her characters, Brontë creatively re-presents Proverbs 1-9, thus in her own way “[warning] rash youth” against perils lying in wait. Villainous individuals embody the dangerous “strange woman” who “lieth in wait at every corner” (Prov 7:12), while careless and foolish ones endure the tragic consequences of ignoring Wisdom. We also find imagined versions of Lady Folly, a Victorian ‘fallen woman,’ in the realm of suspicion, gossip, and innuendo, as neighbours speculate about the mysterious, secretive tenant of Wildfell Hall herself. Though she is ethically above reproach, biblically literate, and genuinely pious, Helen Graham endures the accusations of those who assume the worst of this single mother. Brontë deftly weaves biblical literature throughout this dark story of real and suspected ‘fallenness,’ and like her artist-protagonist, manages to create a compelling portrait, one of that problematic female, “the strange woman” of Proverbs.
|
Saved in the House of the Lord: Liturgical Soteriology from Psalms to Early Paschal Materials
Program Unit: Bible in Eastern and Oriental Orthodox Traditions
Dragos Giulea, Marquette University
One of the most representative soteriological doctrines is that which claims that participation in the liturgy is essential for human salvation. This paper will investigate the presence of liturgical soteriology in the Eastern Orthodox liturgy, especially connected with the Triodion, and further find the roots of this idea in early Paschal materials and their origins in the Psalms and Temple service. Such elements as the assembly in the Temple, the righteousness and holiness of the assembly, the co-celebration with the angels in the presence of the divine glory, and the salvation through the divine glory will be investigated in a comparative analysis in both the Bible and Eastern Paschal tradition. While liturgical celebration represents a veritable machinery of salvation, it is not the real soteriological agent, but rather a mechanism intended to prompt God’s gracious condescension and salvific agency.
|
Internalizing the Watchers’ Deeds: Athenagoras and Tatian on the Psychological Influences of the Fallen Angels
Program Unit: Function of Apocryphal and Pseudepigraphal Writings in Early Judaism and Early Christianity
Dragos Giulea, Marquette University
Various passages in Athenagoras’s Plea for the Christians and Tatian’s Address to the Greeks—two writings replete with Greek philosophical and mythological materials—represent a retelling of the Enochic myth of the Watchers. The two authors not only present their versions of the myth, but first and foremost insert Greek philosophical terminologies and topics within their retelling of the story. One of the most significant is their use of Greek psychological concepts, especially of Stoic origin, in the investigation of the way the fallen angels act within the human souls. Demons are not only the agents of evil in the world, but also masters of the material world. They inspire human thoughts to love matter and to fashion art which induces material thoughts. Athenagoras and Tatian, therefore, re-create the myth of the watchers, internalize it, and confer on it a psychological analysis.
|
The “Call” of Isaiah and the Baptism of Jesus in Mark: A Hermeneutical Reassessment
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Mark D. Given, Missouri State University
The thesis of this paper is that Isaiah 6:1-8, the narrative of the so-called “call” of Isaiah, is an influence on the narrative of the baptism of Jesus in Mark. The failure of previous scholarship to realize this is a failure of hermeneutics. In this case, even scholars deeply committed to interpreting Mark in light of the book of Isaiah have been hampered by a questionable application of form criticism and an overreliance on exact verbal parallels when determining intertextual relationships. A rereading of these texts informed by a more fully postmodern concept of intertextuality allows an interpreter to see the shaping of one text’s meaning by the other. Influences are not merely verbal, on the level of quotation, allusion, and echo, but structural as well. Once this shaping pattern is observed, the influence of Isaiah 6:1-8 on the baptism of Jesus becomes readily apparent, an influence that has important exegetical implications. Furthermore, recognition of this influence will allow us to add yet another explanation to the sixteen set forth by Davies and Allison for the surprising way in which the Spirit’s descent is described in Mark.
|
Ordination of Antoinette Brown: The Transformation of ‘Decency and Order’ from Barrier Bridge
Program Unit: Academy of Homiletics
Donna Giver Johnston, Vanderbilt University
*
|
Transforming Venom into Bread by Blood in John 6 and 13
Program Unit: Sacrifice, Cult, and Atonement
Gregory Yuri Glazov, Seton Hall University
Assuming that the “hard-saying” of a Jewish Jesus calling his Jewish disciples to eat his flesh and drink his blood (John 6:51-71) is mishandled both by those who interpret it only metaphorically and by those who interpret it literally but infer the teaching to be inherently non-Jewish and the narrative non-historical and non-unified (cf. Cahill), I wish to explore the alternative that the narrative is unified and connected with John 13:18 (via trogon; cf. Swancutt). This would identify the morsel given to Judas at John 13:27 as the Eucharist and explain Satan's entry into him (cf. 6:70) by the logic of 1 Cor 11:27-32 (cf. Hodges). Accordingly, “eating the flesh” and “drinking the blood” first betokens “portions-eating,” murmuring and betrayal (cf. Derrett). Why then would it then betoken forgiveness, atonement and life? While the Jesus-Joseph motif provides one avenue for explaining this, the immediate context of John 6 transfers Jesus’ audience to the days of Israel’s desert murmuring against God and its judgment and atonement by the venomous bite of burning serpents and by their gazing on Nehushtan, respectively. In this setting, the judgment and atonement that Jesus promises to his murmuring audience must be no less comprehensive. The eating and drinking must then signify both the “murmuring” (represented by giving the morsel to Judas) and the "gazing" that brings the healing (cf. John 3:14; 19:37). If Judas does not partake of this healing, it must be for failure to discern the latter dimension in this “bread.” It remains to explore the application of Pss 41:9, 69:21-28, and 109:6-14 to his venomous deed in John 13:18-26 (cf. 6:70-71) and Acts 1:20.
|
“Knowledge” in LXX Hosea
Program Unit: Greek Bible
W. Edward Glenny, Northwestern College
This paper is a discussion of some of the hermeneutical issues involved in interpreting references to “knowledge” and “knowledge of God” in LXX Hosea. Words referring to various aspects of knowledge occur at least seventeen times in LXX Hosea, and three times in LXX-Hosea [2:15; 4:15; 10:12] the translator apparently introduces the idea of knowledge into the Greek text where it is not in the MT. Modern interpreters face several problems in trying to interpret consistently the references to this theme in LXX Hosea. This study of the references to knowledge in LXX Hosea will engage several hermeneutical principles that have been suggested for interpreting the text of the LXX. They include the principle of the original text, the principle of the parent text as arbiter of meaning, the principle of translator’s intent, and the principle of linguistic parsimony.
|
Attentive Ears and Forward-Looking Eyes: Ritualization of the Senses in the Jewish Wisdom Tradition
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Greg Schmidt Goering, University of Virginia
Jewish sages of the Second Temple period esteemed eyes and ears as mediating organs through which students could encounter divine wisdom. These sages also understood that humans use eyes and ears to make moral judgments, whether sound or poor. Mindful of the subjective nature of sensory percepts, sages deemed it necessary to devise strategies for the regulation of the senses. Drawing on anthropology of the senses and Catherine Bell's theory about ritualization of the body, I interpret Second Temple Jewish wisdom instruction as a process of ritualization that aimed to regiment the senses. Sages sought to ritualize the senses by promoting an interaction of eyes and ears with the pedagogical environment and by impressing upon the senses schemes of privileged oppositions. In their attempt to manage the senses, Jewish sages simultaneously honed eyes and ears in certain ways and dulled them in others. Sages aimed to discipline visual perception, for example, by inculcating a forward gaze and vigilance, by prescribing certain visual practices and proscribing others, and by role modeling. Through such ritualization strategies, sages sought to reform and remake eyes and ears and, thereby, effect a status change in their students from "inexperienced" to "wise." The results of this process of sensory disciplining, however, were not limited to the instructional environment. As Bell argues, persons who become ritualized learn to behave in nonritualized spaces in ritualized ways. Hence, the ritualization of the eyes and ears through sapiential instruction increased the likelihood that students would practice good management of the senses and exercise proper habits of mind away from the watchful eye of the sage.
|
The Conceptual Blending of Light and Word in Ben Sira’s Wisdom Instruction
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Greg Schmidt Goering, University of Virginia
On three separate occasions, Ben Sira describes his teaching activity as a confluence of light and word. Combining a cognitive theory of metaphor and a theory of conceptual blending, this paper interprets Ben Sira's description of his wisdom instruction in light of local cultural assumptions regarding the operation of the perceptual organs. The different modalities assumed to be operative in vision and audition, respectively, are also implied in the sage's metaphorical uses of seeing and hearing. Throughout his work, Ben Sira deploys visual metaphors to indicate first-hand experience, apprehension of meaningful patterns in nature, continuity between the wisdom teacher (the seer) and the sacred realm, and the presentation of divine truths. The sage employs aural metaphors to suggest that the verbal medium of wisdom instruction stands at some remove from the original sagely insight based on visual perception, that wisdom instruction cannot immediately present meaningful patterns but only represent them, and that the student (the hearer) who experiences the sequential unfolding of the wisdom instruction in time stands in discontinuity with the sacred realm. When the sage combines visual and aural metaphors to describe his own teaching activity, the resulting conceptual blend not only points to the pivotal role of the sage in merging the visual and the verbal in the process of wisdom transmission, but it also expresses the sage's experience of the teaching event as extraordinary. By depicting his instruction as a blend of word and light, the sage describes a "perceptual paradox" (to use David Chidester's phrase), in which his experience of instruction is grounded in sensory perception and yet transcends normal sensory perception. Through this conceptual blend, the sage positions himself as an intermediary who is both continuous and discontinuous with the sacred realm and, thus, able to communicate divine wisdom to his students.
|
The Figure of Belos-Kronos in Pseudo-Eupolemus
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Matthew Goff, Florida State University
This paper analyzes the figure of Belos in the two fragments in Eusebius’ Praeparatio Evangelica that are commonly ascribed to Pseudo-Eupolemus (9.17.2-9; 18.2). Fragment 1 includes a genealogy that reconfigures information regarding the line of Ham in Genesis 9-10. The text places Belos at the head of its genealogy, who is also identified as Kronos. Fragment 2 claims that this person built the Tower of Babylon. In terms of understanding Belos, scholarship has focused on the question of whether he should be understood as signifying Nimrod or Noah. In this paper I argue that the Nimrod association is more plausible than identification with Noah, but that the name Belos should be taken seriously in its own right. “Belos” is a Greek form of Bel (“Lord”), a common epithet for Marduk. This god is referred to in Greek literature as Zeus-Belos. Belos is also regarded euhemeristically as an early king and founder of Babylon. With the name “Belos” Pseudo-Eupolemus does not simply apply a Greek name to an important Jewish figure; the author incorporates Hellenistic conceptions of the early history of the east into his reformulation of the line of Ham.
|
John as Elijah's Second Coming? A Malaysian Inculturation Interpretation of Luke 1:5–25
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Meng Hun Goh, Vanderbilt University
*
|
Poetics and Theology in Isaiah 56–66
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
John Goldingay, Fuller Theological Seminary
The paper considers how Isaiah 56 - 66 makes theological statements by means of their overall chiastic shape, by using parallelism, by using words whose ambiguity suggests complex theological ideas, by using paronomasia, and by using the rhetoric of persuasion.
|
The Exodus of the Rabbis
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Edward Goldman, Hebrew Union College - Jewish Institute of Religion
The Exodus constitutes a central theme in the literature and memories of the Rabbis. Because the topic is so huge, the available materials to be discussed could fill endless books. The goal of this paper is modest: to present a few key passages which reflect important rabbinic attitudes towards and understandings of the Exodus.
|
Isaiah 1–39 in the Light of Akkadian Sources: New Insights
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Ronnie Goldstein, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
While the study of the book of Isaiah has advanced immeasurably in the last decade, there is still a need to explore the
effect of extra-biblical material, especially Akkadian material from neo-Assyrian and Neo-Babylonian times, on the
interpretation and analysis of Isaiah 1-39. The comparative perspective on the book of Isaiah has advanced significantly in the last decades, especially relating to Assyrian prophecy and Royal inscriptions. However, other extra-biblical sources were not sufficiently explored in relation to Isaiah 1-39. Furthermore, Lexicography of Akkadian has advanced greatly in the last decades, and it is now the time to reevaluate many of the old lexicographical problems within the book. In contrast to comparative works which have ignored the diachronic analysis of the book, and distinct from the claim that the comparative
perspective must be done only after the diachronic analysis, it is proposed to combine the exegetical and historical analysis of
the book with the comparative perspective. This way it is proposed to reincorporate the book of Isaiah as an important source for the study of the history of the Ancient Near East from the eighth century B.C.E to the end of the Persian era. The present paper will deal with several new interpretations of problematic passages in Isaiah 1-39 in the light of lexicographical new suggestions based on Akkadian, some possible new parallels between passages in Isaiah 1-39 and Assyrian and Babylonian literature will be reevaluated, and new parallels in genre and in content, not yet investigated, will be undertaken.
|
Perpetua's Ascent: Popular Christianity in North Africa
Program Unit: Function of Apocryphal and Pseudepigraphal Writings in Early Judaism and Early Christianity
Eliezer Gonzalez, Macquarie University-Sydney
The Passion of Perpetua attests to popular Christian beliefs in North Africa that have more affinity with the Jewish/Christian apocalyptic literature than with the teachings of the church fathers. Saturus' vision of the martyrs' ascent to heaven in the Passion of Perpetua is remarkable in that it is one of the earliest Christian texts describing immediate post-mortem ascent. This paper will specifically explore the affinities between Saturus’ vision and other Jewish/Christian apocalyptic works, as well as its differences with the teachings of the early church fathers. Consequently, how did this text function within the lives of North African Christian communities, and how may this have been a factor in the eventual adoption of the idea of the immediate post-mortem ascent of believers by the Christian church?
|
Linguistic Archaeology: What the Translation of Chronicles Tells Us about Hebrew Verbs in the Second Century BCE
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Roger Good, University of California-Los Angeles
The Septuagint’s translation of the verbs of Chronicles, made sometime in the middle of the second century BCE, slices through the diachronic development of the Hebrew verbal system from classical biblical Hebrew to Mishnaic Hebrew. The translation gives insight into the spoken Hebrew of the time of the translator, which was the primary influence on his understanding of the Hebrew verbs and was probably similar to the Mishnaic Hebrew three tense system of past qatal forms, present qotel forms, and future (or modal) yiqtol forms. It seems the use of past, present, and future or modal Greek forms in the translation of these Hebrew forms reflects this. In addition to this, the translator recognized, through the reading tradition and through his study, archaic meanings to certain verb forms (such as consecutive yiqtol and qatal) and commonly translated them by the appropriate Greek equivalent. However, sometimes he translated these archaic consecutive forms with a Greek future or past form respectively (producing an awkward or different resulting text), perhaps influenced by his contemporary Hebrew. Sometimes the introductory wayhi and/or infinitive construct with a preposition are translated by particles introducing temporal clauses with indicative verb forms. This also may reflect Hebrew use contemporary to the translator. The translation of Chronicles contains a number of clues like these for us to view the Hebrew of the Hellenistic period in its transition from classical to rabbinic Hebrew.
|
Compelled to Preach: Retaining Paul's Apostolic Right in 1 Corinthians 9:17
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
John Goodrich, Moody Bible Institute
1 Corinthians 9.15-18 provides a unique, though rather complicated, insight into Paul’s apostolic profile. In this passage, Paul exposes the nature of his monetary policy, the chief tension lying between him and the Corinthians, and the role Paul occupied in the church as God’s agent. As one commentator explains, ‘Although one has the feeling that the argument got away from him a bit, nonetheless the explanations of vv. 16-17 probably help us as much as anything in his letters to understand what made Paul tick’. But despite the huge importance of this passage for Corinthian studies as well as the great attention it has received in recent decades, the logic of the unit remains intensely disputed among NT interpreters and is in still further need of revisiting. Chief among the problems is to be found in verse 17. There Paul presents two conditional sentences to help explain the volitional nature of his preaching: either he preaches willingly and is therefore entitled to a wage, or he preaches unwillingly, and has thus been entrusted a stewardship. But which alternative is actual, which is hypothetical, and what does the actual condition suggest about his right to receive pay? Although this is the very matter which Paul aims to illumine in verses 15-18, interpreters remain divided over Paul’s actual condition, largely because they fail to understand how the smaller units correlate. In this paper, therefore, I will carefully scrutinize the two major existing views and offer a new explanation (that Paul presented himself as preaching involuntarily, yet was still deserving of compensation), and show how familiarity with ancient stewardship (commercial agency) provides the remaining key for unlocking this exegetical crux.
|
Honest yet Shrewd: Pliny and the Unjust Steward (Luke 16:1–8) in the Ancient Economy
Program Unit: Early Christianity and the Ancient Economy
John Goodrich, Moody Bible Institute
Luke’s Parable of the Unjust Steward (Luke 16.1-8) is widely considered the most puzzling of Jesus’ teachings. Although a seemingly endless string of interpretations continue to appear in print, no single reading looks to have yet won the day. The trickiest feature of the parable in need of resolution is how the steward can be commended for reducing the debts owed to his master. Some interpreters suggest that the story simply ends in irony, with the steward cheating the master, but still receiving applause on account of his successful acquisition of a new home. The primary weakness of this approach is that it portrays Jesus condoning unethical behavior, which for many is significant enough cause to consider additional interpretations. Others propose that the steward genuinely earned his master’s favor by subtracting from the debts either unlawful penalties or his own commission. This approach, however, presupposes familiarity with localized legal customs of which Luke’s audience may not have been aware.
In this paper, therefore, I will offer a new reading based on the general practices of lease adjustment in the early empire. I will demonstrate, firstly, that proprietors often had relatively modest financial goals for their large estates, preferring moderate, consistent returns to maximum, high-risk investments. Secondly, utilizing Pliny’s letters as the primary source of evidence (esp. 9.37), I will show that these modest goals enabled, and at times required, proprietors to adjust their leasing arrangements in order to secure the repayment of debts and the longevity of their tenants. Thirdly, and in the light of these earlier insights, I will argue that, by reducing the debts of his master’s tenants, the steward in Luke’s parable successfully secured the repayment of those debts, and consequently the long-term profitability of his master. The steward’s actions, then, were both honest and shrewd, being deserving of both praise and perhaps exoneration.
|
Creating Meaning in the Present by Reviewing the Past: Social Memory in the Psalms of Solomon
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Matthew E. Gordley, Regent University
Psalms and prayers are found in a wide range of Second Temple writings including wisdom literature (Sirach), narratives (Tobit), apocalyptic writings (4 Ezra), and psalm collections (Psalms of Solomon). In these varied contexts psalms often play a significant didactic role in instructing the reader on key themes and ideas of the larger writing as they paint a portrait of reality which the reader is invited to embrace. A common feature in many of these is the allusion to events of the biblical past as a way of providing meaning to the experiences of the present community. In some cases the reminder of the way God has worked in the past provides hope for the community for the present and the future. In other cases, events of the community's day are described in ways that show these events are a reflection of the events of the earlier biblical era. Accordingly, recent events are invested with "biblical" significance and the present community is urged to see itself as a participant in the larger plan of God which has been unfolding throughout history and into the present. By reviewing historical allusions within several of the Psalms of Solomon (8, 9, 17, and 18) and attending to the temporal register of these allusions this paper argues that Jewish hymns of the Second Temple period that draw on events of the past function as what Assmann referred to as "social memory." That is, they are exercises in communal memory, mediating and processing cultural history in light of present challenges. This paper highlights ways that Psalms of Solomon uses multiple temporal registers to rehearse the past as an exercise in communal memory with implications for the present. It will also suggest that attention to these dynamics in other Second Temple psalms and prayers is needed.
|
Reading the Household Code of Colossians in Its Contexts: A Critique and Proposal
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
Matthew E. Gordley, Regent University
The earliest of the NT household codes continues to be interpreted in diametrically opposed ways. Some view the code as embodying an unambiguously oppressive ethic which is a departure from the earliest Christian emphasis on equality. Others see in the code a subtle move toward mutual respect, love, and fairness as a distinctly Christian way of living in a household community. Recently there has emerged a mediating position that acknowledges the patriarchal values embodied in the code, but also attempts to salvage the reputation of the letter as a whole by proposing a new way of reading the code. This view suggests that the code conflicts directly with Col 3:11, and that this fact, together with other clues, lets the recipients know that they should read the code “against the grain.” Read this way the code embodies a hidden transcript—a message that would have been imperceptible to outsiders but would have had special meaning to insiders. To outsiders it functioned to certify that the Christian household members were not a threat to a peaceful, orderly society. To insiders it contained a message that was potentially liberating and empowering when read in line with the teaching of the whole epistle. This latest view is appealing for a number of reasons, not least of which that it draws on the insights of post-colonial analysis to provide a more nuanced reading of this passage than previously possible. Nevertheless, this paper will outline several considerations which suggest that this view is ultimately unsatisfactory. Further, this paper will argue that recent research on the literary, social, and especially the imperial contexts of the code supports a reading in which the code supplies a way for Christians to live their daily lives under the lordship of Christ as opposed to the lordship of Caesar.
|
What Did the Author of Acts Know of Pre-70 Judaism?
Program Unit: Book of Acts
Lester L. Grabbe, University of Hull
The historicity of Acts has been debated for the past two centuries. Much of the discussion has centered around the question of what the author of Acts knew about the history of the early church. One way of testing his knowledge, at least in part, is by examining what he knew about another area of history, pre-70 Judaism, which is referred to here and there in the book. This paper will address the question with a variety of examples and also ask about the source of any knowledge of Judaism that the author of Acts had.
|
Miriam and Me
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Naomi Graetz, Ben Gurion University of the Negev
Miriam’s significance as a biblical figure is “proved” by the fact that God, portrayed as a concerned doctor, intervenes in her case and personally treats her illness. Her well according to rabbinical midrash is said to have been one of the ten things created during the twilight before the first Sabbath of the creation (B. Pesahim 54a). Rabbinic midrash describes her as a prophet, interpreting the passage “and his sister stood afar off” (Ex. 2:4), to mean that she stood afar to know what would be the outcome of her prophecy that her mother was destined to give birth to a son who would save Israel. Miriam was a singer, a woman of spirit. Miriam can serve as an inspiration for contemporary “Miriams” world-wide, whose message influences the downtrodden. A notable example is the South African singer and civil rights activist, Miriam Makeba, who died in 2008.
I too have been inspired by Miriam. I am a feminist Conservative Jew living in Israel who has been writing midrash since the mid 1980’s. One of my favorite subjects has been Miriam, to whom I have returned many times for inspiration. She sometimes served as my alter ego, sometimes as “the enemy”. As a young mother, I envied her single-minded pursuit of a “career” and the fact that she didn’t have children to slow her down. Inspired by the feminist Kate Millet, I wrote a free flowing midrash about Yocheved’s relationship with her daughters in law (Elisheva and Tzipora) and her free spirited daughter. At certain low points in my life I identified with her bitterness at her mistreatment by God and life, yet now, with the perspective of age, I see her as a redemptive figure, one who has had children and has made her peace with God.
|
“You Have Become Dull of Hearing”: Hebrews 5:11 and the Rhetoric of Conversion
Program Unit: Hebrews
Fritz Graf, Ohio State University
The long reprimand at the end of Hebrews 5 is set into the context of Greek religious treatises (starting with the 5th century BCE treatise contained in the Derveni Papyrus) that set out to convince their audience of a new and often surprising interpretation of known facts (such as the Theogony of Orpheus in the Derveni Papyrus). Setting Hebrews into this context, I try to understand better the personality of the speaker and the position of his teaching; I will also enter in a discussion with recent scholarship on sacrificial ideology and superstition in Hebrews and on its context in the Graeco-roman world.
|
Semitic Language and Syntax within the Speech of the Johannine Jesus
Program Unit: John, Jesus, and History
Steven A. Graham, George Fox University
Despite the fact that the Fourth Gospel was finalized in a Hellenistic setting, its cultural background and thought forms remain thoroughly Jewish. Recognizing Semitic terms and syntax in some of Jesus’ language in the Gospel of John may also provide a distinctive window into the teachings of Jesus. Therefore, this paper will explore John’s use of Aramaic terms and language, as well as Hebraic ideas and thought forms, in its presentation of Jesus speech. While such an inquiry cannot claim to identify particular teachings of Jesus, it may at least suggest primitivity within the Johannine tradition as well as further implications.
|
Mount Sion and the Christian Construction of a Sacred Space
Program Unit: Space, Place, and Lived Experience in Antiquity
Susan L. Graham, Saint Peter's College
A number of historical and archaeological puzzles surround Jerusalem's Southwest Hill (Mount Sion) during the Late Roman and Byzantine periods. It was not included in Emperor Constantine’s building program. Nevertheless, by the end of the fourth century a sizable Christian church is attested there, although Christian associations for Mount Sion continue to be in flux into the sixth century and beyond. Some reports record a memory of synagogues on the hill, one reputed to have survived into the fourth century. The overlapping (and fourth-century expansion) of Jewish and Christian claims regarding Mount Sion raise several subtle questions concerning these traditions (see the work of Fredricksen and Irshai).
An analysis of the accounts and the archaeology using the methodologies for the study of sacred space, and especially the social, geographical, and sociological frameworks offered in the work of Henri Lefebvre, Edward Soja, Pierre Nora, and Maurice Halbwachs, suggests that these traditions may plausibly all be Christian. This paper analyzes the potential for deliberate Christian building up of existing traditions, or the construction of a mythology, surrounding the Southwest Hill that would support their claims to the place, as to other parts of the city. It argues that they did so.
The fourth-century literary evidence and archaeological remains, taken from the perspective of constructions of sacred space, makes this assessment plausible. The synagogue traditions lend themselves to a supersessionistic argument. Christian associations of the place with the narratives of the Gospels and Acts, which build through the sixth century, strengthen their claims to it. Methodologies of sacred space thus illumine the potential of the evidence to draw a picture of Christian construction of a sacred place on the Southwest Hill that clearly articulated a Christian supersessionistic argument, and supported Christian claims to the city.
|
Mount Sion and the Christian Construction of a Sacred Space
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Susan L. Graham, Saint Peter's College
A number of historical and archaeological puzzles surround Jerusalem's Southwest Hill (Mount Sion) during the Late Roman and Byzantine periods. It was not included in Emperor Constantine’s building program. Nevertheless, by the end of the fourth century a sizable Christian church is attested there, although Christian associations for Mount Sion continue to be in flux into the sixth century and beyond. Some reports record a memory of synagogues on the hill, one reputed to have survived into the fourth century. The overlapping (and fourth-century expansion) of Jewish and Christian claims regarding Mount Sion raise several subtle questions concerning these traditions (see the work of Fredricksen and Irshai).
An analysis of the accounts and the archaeology using the methodologies for the study of sacred space, and especially the social, geographical, and sociological frameworks offered in the work of Henri Lefebvre, Edward Soja, Pierre Nora, and Maurice Halbwachs, suggests that these traditions may plausibly all be Christian. This paper analyzes the potential for deliberate Christian building up of existing traditions, or the construction of a mythology, surrounding the Southwest Hill that would support their claims to the place, as to other parts of the city. It argues that they did so.
The fourth-century literary evidence and archaeological remains, taken from the perspective of constructions of sacred space, makes this assessment plausible. The synagogue traditions lend themselves to a supersessionistic argument. Christian associations of the place with the narratives of the Gospels and Acts, which build through the sixth century, strengthen their claims to it. Methodologies of sacred space thus illumine the potential of the evidence to draw a picture of Christian construction of a sacred place on the Southwest Hill that clearly articulated a Christian supersessionistic argument, and supported Christian claims to the city.
|
“Apocryphal” Elements in the Qur’an and the New Testament as Portrayed in Muslim and Christian Scholarship
Program Unit: Qur'an and Biblical Literature
Michael Graves, Wheaton College
The historical critical study of religious texts that took place in the nineteenth century placed significant emphasis on the possible sources underlying the texts in question. Critical scholarship on the NT investigated the ways in which (mostly) post-Hebrew Bible Jewish traditions (e.g., the “apocrypha and pseudepigrapha of the OT”) found expression in the NT, e.g., Michael the Archangel and Enoch in Jude. At the same time, Jewish and Christian scholars were identifying “apocryphal” (or later rabbinic) materials that could be seen as sources for accounts in the Qur’an that diverged from the related story in the Bible (e.g., Abraham Geiger, C. C. Torrey, and numerous more recent works). This paper will identify some of the examples cited for the NT and the Qur’an, and will show how these phenomena have been explained by Muslim and Christian scholars working within their respective faith traditions. In view of the critical discussions surrounding the Christian Bible, some Christian scholars have accepted the idea of non-historical “apocryphal” elements in the NT, some have defended the historicity of the traditions, and some have argued that the NT writers did not intend the traditions to be taken as historical. In view of the critical discussions surrounding the Qur’an, Muslim scholars (and other sympathetic voices) have attempted to problematize the idea of “sources” for the Qur’an, and some have employed arguments similar to those used for the NT. From my own vantage point, I will try to show how problematic it has been for Christians who have wanted to use Quranic scholarship to criticize Islam to handle the theological problems created by the NT appropriation of extra-biblical Jewish traditions.
|
The Diverse Forms of Suffering: The Book of Job and Today
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Emily O. Gravett, University of Virginia
It is no remarkable observation to note that Job suffers. Neither is it particularly innovative to suggest that Job has become a paradigm for suffering for us today. What this paper will do, however, is use these (by now banal) ideas as a starting point and, looking at both the prose inclusio and the poetic ‘interlude’ (for lack of a better term) from a literary perspective, typify the diverse aspects of suffering in the book of Job.
I will argue that eight elements characterize this suffering. First, it can take a physical form (e.g. Job’s boils). Job also experiences mental anguish. Third, his suffering affects those around him (his wife, for instance, becomes so exasperated with the situation that she says, “Curse God, and die”). Despite the ripple effect of suffering, Job nonetheless epitomizes the isolation suffering causes (he, for instance, can find no solace in his so-called “friends”). In this state of loneliness, it is often difficult to fully or adequately express suffering; Job’s lamentations never receive validation from the human or the divine realm. The lack of a heavenly response especially (to Job’s suffering, and our own) can lead to serious questions and doubts regarding the meaning of life and, for some, the existence of God. Unfortunately, for Job and for us, no response from heaven regarding suffering or its explanation ever comes (in Job’s case, God’s thundering reply is as good as none). Finally, and most subtly, Job reveals the reward that we all (deep down) expect for our suffering: the restoration of health, of wealth, of children lost, of faith in God.
Ultimately, I suggest that the way Job suffered is the way that suffering is characterized, articulated, and understood today. Given that the Bible undergirds much of Western culture, this should come as no surprise.
|
Jeremiah’s Confessions and the Gender of Prophetic Sound
Program Unit: Gender, Sexuality, and the Bible
Rhiannon Graybill, University of California-Berkeley
This paper explores the gendering of sound and its destabilizing effects on identity in the prophet Jeremiah. In an essay entitled “The Gender of Sound,” classicist Ann Carson argues that the male economy of language fears female speech as a subversive and dangerous influence that refuses reason and materializes meaning. Though Carson’s concern is with classical Greece, her distinction has much to offer an analysis of the biblical world as well. I will argue that Carson’s analysis of non-rational, materialized language offers a useful framework to understand gender and language in biblical prophecy, and in Jeremiah in particular.
After sketching out the threat represented by female sound in Jeremiah, I turn from the feminine to the male speaker, the prophet himself. In Jeremiah’s “confessions,” the normative relationship of gender and sound is subverted. Here, pain, lament, and disordered noise overwhelm the ordered strictures of normal prophetic discourse—discourse that is nearly always male. The prophet’s body, too, is drawn into the subversion of gendered order, as Jeremiah’s pain suggests a blurring of the linguistic and somatic registers, much like the “somatic compliance” that Freud identifies in his female patients. What does it mean to locate the utterances of the prophet not in the space of rational male speech, but in the same field as the cries of Cassandra and the nervous complaints of Dora and Anna O.?
The bulk of my paper explores the challenge and possibility of this transformed understanding of gender and sound. I will also take up the question of what it means to delocate Carson’s model from the question of sex—that is, to apply her category of hysterical female speech to men—and the openings this move offers. As a radical challenge to gender and language, Jeremiah’s confessions have much to teach us.
|
Voluptuous, Tortured, and Unmanned: Prophetic Bodies at the Boundaries of the Human
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
Rhiannon Graybill, University of California-Berkeley
Daniel Paul Schreber’s Memoirs of My Nervous Illness presents a body at the limits of the human. Schreber was a noted German jurist until he suffered a series of mental breakdowns. He eventually published his memoirs, which inspired one of Freud’s most famous case studies. The memoirs present an elaborate world system, with Schreber’s body at the center of a cosmic battle. A passive but sexualized Messiah, he must “become feminine” through constant sexual intercourse with the divine to save the world.
Schreber’s body, I argue, is a prophetic body, radically implicated in mediating between the divine and human realms. At once marginal and central, over-invested with meaning and denied autonomy, Schreber’s body resembles in particular the body of Ezekiel, particularly in the “action prophecies” of Ezekiel 3-5. The Hebrew prophet’s bizarre performances foreground the anguished, affective body and resist resolution into communicative meaning. The body, forcibly transformed under divine command, transgresses the normative categories of subjectivity.
I am not suggesting that prophecy is pathology, or that Ezekiel suffers from a “nervous illness.” Instead, I use Schreber’s insights into the self-understood prophetic body as entry points into Ezekiel. Both men share a complicated relation to the human, at once exemplary and exceptional. And for Ezekiel as for Schreber, the body is at once a medium of divine communication and a means of a radical critique of the existing world order. Schreber’s memoirs also make clear that sex and sexuality are at once contested and central in this prophetic body—a body that moves outside rationality and into polymorphous perversity. Ezekiel likewise refuses the biologically determined body, turning instead to a fluid, tactile corporeal economy that blends outrageous suffering with autoeroticism. Reading Ezekiel together with Schreber opens a new hermeneutic space to think about embodiment, extremity, and the boundaries of the human.
|
What If, As If: Implications of Genre for Jeremiah 11–20
Program Unit: Bakhtin and the Biblical Imagination
Barbara Green, Dominican School of Philosophy and Theology
Can a persuasive case be made for the genre ‘divine soliloquy’ in Jeremiah 11-20 once the generally recognized prophetic laments and the prose teaching sections are identified and set aside? What helpful contributions are made by contemporary critical collaborators: form-criticism, Hebrew rhetorical criticism, general genre studies, and Bakhtin’s work on genre? I will argue that there are grounds for such a construction where God’s speaks with rhetorical and thematic consistency, constellating a stable though not inevitable set of small formal elements, and I will demonstrate the fruits of my work, sampling from the eight soliloquies to be discerned.
|
Rhetoric of Responsibility: Constructing and Performing a Genre of Divine Soliloquy in Jeremiah 11–20
Program Unit: Writing/Reading Jeremiah
Barbara Green, Dominican School of Philosophy and Theology
It seems possible to identify within Jeremiah 11-20 the genre prophetic lament (or confession) and prose pedagogic units where deity and prophet instruct people. When those two rough piles are swept together, what remains? Commentators, generally disagreeing among themselves, see a welter of diverse small forms that seem to obscure rather than to aid understanding. Is it possible and responsible to construe a genre for the ‘leftovers,’ nameable as divine soliloquy? If so, how does it function effectively as a genre, both for (presumably) intended audiences and for our contemporaries as well? I will demonstrate the possibilities, reading Jeremiah 14:1-10 and 17:1-13 as divine soliloquies.
|
Becoming Multicultural: An Inter(con)textual Analysis of the Growing Multiculturalism in US Protestant Churches and the Early Church of Acts
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Bridgett Green, Vanderbilt University
*
|
Rethinking "History" for Theological Interpretation
Program Unit: Theological Interpretation of Scripture
Joel B. Green, Fuller Theological Seminary
Faced with a series of challenges at the hands of critical theorists, the historical-critical paradigm has changed little while continuing to reassert its dominance in the field of biblical studies. Thus, e.g., for John Barton, “...the preferred description of biblical criticism [is] the ‘historical-critical method’” (2007). For many in NT studies, the alternative has been narrative criticism — or, as James Dunn labels it, a “flight from history” (2003). Unfortunately, though, this interest in narrative has generally proceeded with the same history-theology dichotomy characteristic of the historical-critical paradigm. I urge that historical inquiry grounded in the suppositions and principles of the historical-critical paradigm is no friend to theological interpretation of Scripture, and that Heikki Räisänen is correct when he insists that historical criticism cannot be correlated with any theological concerns apart from the historical attempt to describe early Christian religion. I argue that recent work in the philosophy of history redirects the way we think about “history” and NT “texts” in ways that are integral to the work of theological interpretation of Scripture.
|
Up, down, in, and out: Case Studies on Status and Belonging in the Gospel of Luke
Program Unit: Ethics, Love, and the Other in Early Christianity
Joel B. Green, Fuller Theological Seminary
n/a
|
Augustine and the Role of Scripture in Christian Formation: Genesis 1–3
Program Unit: Christian Theology and the Bible
Kathryn Greene-McCreight, St John's Episcopal Church
Augustine apparently never held a single-volume Bible in his hands. His Bible was a collection of many different books, or collections of books and letters. After all, Augustine's conversion experience at hearing the children's sing-song "Take and Read; Take and Read" led him to open his collection of Paul's letters to the scale-tipping Romans 13:13. And Augustine's now-famous request, upon his ordination to the priesthood, that Bishop Valerius allow him some time to read and study Scripture, is just as striking. Certainly it was Ambrose' preaching that opened up particularly the Old Testament to Augustine. What does this tell us about the role of Scripture not only in Augustine's conversion, but also in his understanding of the ongoing nurture of the soul before God? Why does Augustine focus on certain parts of Scripture more than others, returning as he does throughout his life in particular to Genesis 1-3? What is it about these first three chapters of the Bible which fascinate and vex him so, apart from trying to correct and win over his theological adversaries?
|
If I Forget Thee: Remembering, and Forgetting, in Scriptural Citations by Writers of the New Testament
Program Unit: Paul and Scripture
Leonard Greenspoon, Creighton University
Interest in Scriptural citations by the writers of the New Testament is a perennial issue that shows no signs of abating. If anything, closer contacts between scholars of the Septuagint and those of the New Testament, among others, have cast new light on this intriguing phenomenon. In this paper, I will explore this issue primarily through the extra-textual phenomenon of citation from memory, using modern examples, which can be clearly documented, as a starting point for further examination of the ancient world.
|
Proverbs of Ashes, Defenses of Clay: Isolating the Proverbs in Job
Program Unit: Hebrew Scriptures and Cognate Literature
Kyle R. Greenwood, Colorado Christian University
In Job 13:12 the book’s namesake retorts to his three friends, “Your maxims are proverbs of ashes; your defenses are defenses of clay.” Job’s statement suggests that Eliphaz, Bildad, Zophar (and later, Elihu) were citing common platitudes as evidence for the explanation of Job’s condition. In reality, these aphorisms, which were intended to comfort, served only to heap insults on the righteous sufferer. Due to the fact that the proverb is a recognizable and identifiable genre in both the Hebrew Bible and cognate literature, it is the position of this paper that the proverbs within Job may also be identified. This study will examine known proverbs from Mesopotamia, Syria-Palestine, and Anatolia to formalize a diagnostic by which the sayings from the book of Job may be scrutinized with the goal of detecting where they occur within the book.
|
"Epigraphical Rabbis" and Epigraphical Priests: Using Inscriptions to Evaluate the Relationship between Priests and Rabbis in Late Antiquity
Program Unit: History and Literature of Early Rabbinic Judaism
Matthew J. Grey, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
In recent years, scholars of Late Antique Judaism have debated the societal role of Jewish priests in the centuries following the destruction of the Jerusalem temple. An important aspect of this debate is the relationship between priests and rabbis in the Talmudic period. Did priests and rabbis comprise distinct social groups that competed for influence over post-70 Jewish society? Or, did priests assimilate into the rabbinic movement and merely maintain an honorary social status? Scholars have tried to answer these questions by drawing upon Jewish art, archaeology, and literature. However, the ways in which priestly inscriptions might inform this debate have not been considered fully. In this paper I will reevaluate the epigraphic evidence for Jewish priests in Late Antiquity by noting where priests are attested and by examining what light these inscriptions shed on the various social roles that priests may have had in the post-70 era. Evidence will include coins minted during the Bar Kokhba revolt in the second century, inscriptions from the Beth Shearim catacombs from the third and fourth centuries, and synagogue inscriptions from the fourth through sixth centuries, all of which inform our understanding of priestly activity in this period. To more fully assess these priestly inscriptions, I will also compare them to the portrayal of priests in contemporaneous rabbinic literature and note how they relate to rabbinic inscriptions from this period. By examining the inscriptional evidence we are better able to articulate the complex relationship that existed between priests and rabbis in the second through seventh centuries C.E. This evidence indicates that some priests may have interacted with rabbinic social circles, while others engaged in activities that were outside of the interests and wishes of rabbinic sages, thus adding to our understanding of the rich diversity that existed within Late Antique Judaism.
|
The New Temple’s New Liturgy: The Performance of John’s Gospel, Its Setting, and Effect
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Robin Griffith-Jones, King's College London / Temple Church
Several (generally familiar) observations need to be brought together to form an unfamiliar and revealing series. John 1.1-5, 9-14 are in tone (and perhaps in origin) a hymn to God’s power active in creation and tented on earth in the person of Jesus. The prologue thus sets the tone of the whole gospel: a story to be performed and heard in or as if in a liturgy. Jesus is declared at 1.51 to be, as was any temple, the mediating point between heaven and earth, and at 2.14-22 to be the new sanctuary. At 7.2-8.12 Jesus is the water and light of the new Tabernacles, at 19.14 the lamb of the new Passover. At 19.30 the new creation is completed (cf. Gen. 2.1-2), and at 20.11-18 the new Adam and Eve meet in the new Eden. The Jerusalem Temple, point of union between heaven and earth, evoked in its decoration the garden of Eden; at the heart of John’s new Eden is the new Holy of Holies in which angels flank the mercy-seat (20.12), and the new tent of God’s presence – and the new tree of knowledge – must still not be touched (Num. 3.10, Gen. 3.3). The risen Jesus comes to the disciples in a richly liturgical scene (recalling the Temple’s Tamid), and in a final act of creation breathes life into them (cf. Gen. 2.7). The prologue and John 20, framing the gospel, evoke the liturgies within which the gospel itself will first have been performed. The new creation is realised in the gathered community of Jesus’ followers, gathered in the new Temple that the body of Jesus is. This is the paradisiac setting, uniting heaven and earth, in which the gospel’s catechetical performance was designed to bring about the catechumens’ re-creation, their new birth from above.
|
Treasures in Earthenware Vessels: Unveiling the Son in the Person of Paul
Program Unit: Construction of Christian Identities
Robin Griffith-Jones, Temple Church
It has long been recognised (Ashton, etc) that some early churches saw in Jesus an ‘upside down apocalypse’: the revelation on earth of a glory that could otherwise have been glimpsed only by a privileged seer on a journey to heaven. Paul was such a seer (2 Cor. 12.2-4); he believed himself to have been transformed (as seers were) by the experience, and sought to transform his converts in their turn. How? ‘It pleased God to unveil his son in me’ (Gal. 1.15-16; en emoi has its natural meaning, and is not synonymous with emoi). Paul is not claiming a revelation within him (an understanding to which exegetes rightly object), but through him. The disclosure of the son – of his nekrosis and his life – was in Paul’s own person. The presence of Paul should effect in Paul’s converts what his visit to the third heaven had effected in him. At 2 Cor 4.4-5 Paul fends off the consequent danger of a reverence for himself (Gal. 4.14) approaching idolatry.
|
‘We’, ‘You’, ‘All’: Respecting Paul’s Distinctions in 2 Corinthians 1–5
Program Unit: Second Corinthians: Pauline Theology in the Making
Robin Griffith-Jones, King's College London / Temple Church
For large parts of 2 Cor. 1-5 Paul distinguishes clearly between the Corinthians on one hand and Paul himself (with Silvanus and Timothy) on the other. Most commentators assume, however, that at a few (climactic) moments Paul’s ‘we’ embraces his addressees: 1.22, 4.16-5.9, 5.21. But we do better to abandon this assumption, to respect the consistency of Paul’s usage, and to hear in the letter what the audience of its first performance would have been likely to hear in it. In 2 Cor 1-5 Paul claimed of himself and his co-workers alone that they had been sealed and given the down-payment of the spirit, knew of and longed for their heavenly home, and were in a position to become the righteousness of God in Christ. (The reference in Rom. 8.23 and 1 Cor. 1.30b is just as narrow.) Was Paul saying, then, that the Corinthians did not have these qualities or blessings? No; he was just not saying that the Corinthians did. How clear and wide a gulf, then, divided Paul’s own standing, as Paul presented it, from the standing of the Corinthians? This can be decided only passage by passage, with an ear open to the – encouraging or admonitory – tone of Paul’s rhetoric. The letter would have succeeded if, by its end, the Corinthians had come to share at least some of Paul’s privileges. But which? This needs careful inquiry; for Paul and his co-workers, who made the dying of Jesus visible in their own person, would remain far more than simply examples for the Corinthians to follow.
|
Reading Matthew’s Healing Narratives from the Perspectives of Caregiver and the Disabled
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Jim Grimshaw, Carroll University
The co-presenters propose contextual analyses of five healing narratives in the Gospel of Matthew (4:23-25, 8:5-13; 9:2-8; 15:29-31, 17:14-20) that deploy a hermeneutic of disability informed by literature from Disability, Cultural, and Postcolonial Studies as well as by personal experience with rheumatologic illness. One presenter is the spouse of a person with Rheumatoid Arthritis (RA); the other has Ankylosing Spondylitis (AS). Neither disease is curable, and both minimally involve chronic pain, loss of mobility, and fatigue.
We have selected these five passages because all include:
(1) a silenced ill or disabled character whose impairment(s) bear some similarity to those associated with RA or AS (e.g., the lame, paralytics, epileptics, the maimed, persons enduring chronic pain,);
(2) family or community members (e.g., a Roman centurion, a parent, other companions or friends) who are (a) acknowledged over against a disparaged group (e.g., Israelites, scribes, disciples) and (b) awarded agency simultaneously withheld from the disabled character they are supporting; and
(3) an ideology of similitude in which all differently-abled bodies are re-formed in accordance with a Matthean ideal of wholeness/health (i.e. an ideology rooted in Levitical health care and prophetic and apocalyptic eschatology).
Foregrounding life-contexts informed by rheumatologic illness, the co-presenters will address representations of the disabled, Jesus, and family/community members as well as implications for an understanding of disability today. Equal time will be given to an analysis of the text and the context. Each presenter will respond to the other presenter’s reading.
|
Chronicles in Medieval Jewish Exegesis: Response to Kalimi
Program Unit: Midrash
Mayer Gruber, Ben Gurion University of the Negev
I am interested in in both forming and participating in the panel devoted to a critical discussion of Isaac Kalimi, The Retelling of Chronicles in Jewish Tradition and Literature: A Historical Journey [Winona Lake, IN: Eisenbrauns, 2009]. I bring to this discussion my knowledge gained from discussing in my Rashi's Commentary on Psalms (Brill 2004) three medieval commentaries on Chronicles, one of which is commonly attributed to Rashi.
|
The Hebrew Lament in Early Modern England
Program Unit: Lament in Sacred Texts and Cultures
Mayer Gruber, Ben Gurion University of the Negev
In the 17th and 18th centuries the university presses of Oxford and Cambridge published a series of large folio volumes that contained both odes on the accession of English monarchs and dirges on the occasion of their demise. Most of these poems were written in English or Latin. However, the published volumes included also poems written by English academicians in Classical Greek, Syriac, Arabic, Persian, Turkish, Phoenician, Palmyrene, and even Etruscan. Especially interesting are the Hebrew dirges composed by various Hebraists including Benjamin Kennicot (1718-1783) and Thomas Bennett (1673-1728). The presenters will analyze the Hebrew text of several of the longer and shorter Hebrew lamentations, will offer their own English translations of these previously untranslated dirges, and will discuss the background of the various authors. Finally, the presenters will show how these poems are a previously untapped resource for biblical exegesis and its history. In fact, these now obscure dirges embody important exegetical insights into the biblical lamentations, which inspired our early modern Hebraist poets.
|
Caligula, the Imperial Cult, and Philo's Legatio ad Gaium
Program Unit: Philo of Alexandria
Erich Gruen, University of California-Berkeley
This paper wil look at the notorious effort of the emperor Gaius Caligula to install his statue in the Temple in Jerusalem in 39/40 CE. It will approach this controversial topic from several angles: the personality of the emperor, the significance of the imperial cult, struggles between Jews and gentiles in Palestine, and the character and reliability of Philo's narrative.
|
Proselytization, Serpents, and Poison in Ancient Christianity: A Reappraisal of the Longer Ending of Mark
Program Unit: Redescribing Christian Origins
William "Chip" Gruen, Muhlenberg College
In the "Longer Ending of Mark" (Mark 16 9-20) Jesus sends his disciples to proselytize. Aiding them in their ability to gain new converts, the disciples are told that "signs" will follow belief, including the casting out of demons, speaking in tongues, snake handling, and the drinking of poison. Of course, this section of Mark is not in the oldest manuscripts of Mark and is summarily disregarded by most scholars as unauthentic. However, regardless of its relative inantiquity, these passages are evidence for an ancient Christian community from a slightly later date. Further, it is clear that this text is not a rhetorical flourish, but evidence that suggests that some ancient Christian groups practice snake handling and the drinking of poison. While these are certainly nontraditional practices vis a vis normative (locative) Christianity of antiquity, they are less remarkable when viewed against a broader context of utopian traditions, like Dionysiac ritual. This paper will seek to redescribe the significance of this longer ending of Mark in the context of a 2nd century Christianity that eventually lost out to the hegemony of proto-orthodox beliefs and practices. Additionally, it will enlist the work of Pierre Bourdieu to notice the alternative construction of a habitus for the purposes of proselytization and as a means for theological differentiation. Finally, the study will comment on the ability or inability of this type of marginalized community to leave its mark on the sources that are extant, affecting both the perception of "religion" in antiquity and what it means to study "religion" in contemporary scholarship.
|
Popular Reading: The People's Bible Project
Program Unit: Latino/a/e and Latin American Biblical Interpretation
Leticia Guardiola-Sáenz, Seattle University
"Popular Reading: The People's Bible Project"
|
The Diatessaron in Early Manichaean Art and Text
Program Unit: Syriac Literature and Interpretations of Sacred Texts
Zsuzsanna Gulacsi, Northern Arizona University
The Manichaean use of Tatian’s Diatessaron has been detected first in 1968 by Werner Sundermann. At that time, Sundermann identified two passages in a Parthian language text discovered among the Manichaean finds of Kocho in East Central Asia that corresponded with two sections of the Diatessaron, as seen in the Arabic version, generally considered as reliably preserving the sequence of Tatian’s original. This paper focuses on the identification a diatessaronic Manichaean painting from ca. 10th century Kocho. More specifically, I argue that two adjacent vignettes, remaining from within a larger set of small scenes (now lost) that narrated the life of Jesus on a Manichaean illuminated folio (MIK III 4967a recto, housed today in the collection of the Museum of Asian Art, Berlin), depict two subsequent events as discussed in the Arabic Diatessaron. One of the vignettes shows “Judas Paid by Caiaphas.” The other is a scene of “Jesus Washing Peter’s Feet.” In addition to certain iconographic details, the unique sequence of the two events (which are not discussed together in any of the canonical gospels) corresponds with Tatian’s account. The diatessaronic pictorial narration conveyed in the archaic “West Asian style” of Manichaean art from Kocho together with the archaic Parthian language on Sundermann’s diatessaronic text point to a late ancient Syro-Mesopotamian context of origin. They suggest that already the first Manichaean communities during the late 3rd century began to use Tatian’s work as their source for teaching the life of Jesus through text and art.
|
Pictorial Diatesserons in Early Manichaean and Early Christian Art of Syro-Mesopotamia
Program Unit: Art and Religions of Antiquity
Zsuzsanna Gulacsi, Northern Arizona University
The Syriac gospel harmony from the late 2nd century, known today after its Greek title Diatessaron and its attribution to Tatian, was used in place of the four canonical gospels in Syro-Mesopotamia between the 3rd and 6th centuries. It has been long thought that this text must have had an impact on the arts of the region. This paper identifies two partially surviving pictorial cycles depicting Jesus’ life, whose narrations, vignette-by-vignette, correlate with the events discussed in two sections of the Diatessaron as documented by the most accurate witnesses to the sequence of Tatian’s prose. One of the two paintings is preserved on a folio fragment of a Manichaean illuminated manuscript from ca. 10th century East Central Asia. The other is found in the famous illuminated St. Augustine Gospels, dating from 6th century Italy. It has been previously pointed out that neither painting is a literal “illustration” to the text of its manuscript. At the same time, they both show iconographic ties to West Asia. Based on their newly discovered diatessaronic contents, I argue that they were copied into their respective codices from earlier prototypes, which were solely pictorial renditions of the life of Christ. I suggest that these paintings originated in a relatively little documented pictorial medium present in Syro-Mesopotamia during late ancient and early medieval times. Textual sources confirm that didactic paintings were used there as visual displays in a religious version of the practice that Victor Mair in his monograph from 1988 calls “picture recitation” or “story telling with pictures.”
|
“It Is a Shame for a Woman to Speak [in Her Own Words] in the Assembly”: A Non-Pauline Total Ban on Women’s Uninspired Public Speech (1 Cor 14:34–35)
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Judith M. Gundry, Yale University Divinity School
Is 1Cor 11:34-35 an interpolation: “Let the women be silent in the assemblies! For it is not permitted for them to speak, but let them be subject!...”? Interpreters disagree. One of the key issues is what kind of public speech is prohibited here. Advocates of authenticity argue for a narrow type: e.g., disruptive speech, evaluation of men’s prophecies. Women are not totally silenced, so the text is not inconsistent with 11:5, 13 (cf. 14:26-32). Interpolation advocates argue that the injunctions are absolute and prohibit all public speech by women. In support, there is no specialized use of lalein for particular prohibited speech in 1Corinthians (lalein denotes speech from the Spirit, 2:13 passim, and rational speech, 3:1 passim). W Schrage concludes: “there can hardly be any doubt that every type of charismatic and noncharismatic speech in communal worship is meant by lalein”—and prohibited!
I will argue (using primary sources) that Schrage’s conclusion has no compelling historical basis, since there was wide cultural acceptance of women’s public inspired speech in the ancient Mediterranean. A prohibition of women’s public speech including inspired speech may thus be attributed neither to Paul, nor a contemporary, nor a 2nd century author.
There is, however, a compelling historical basis for a prohibition of women’s uninspired speech in public as shameful (to be shown using primary sources). I will contend that 1Cor 11:34-35 is an absolute prohibition of women’s speech in assemblies where inspired speech was not practiced or characteristic. The author could issue an absolute prohibition because no exception for women’s public inspired speech needed mentioning. This disqualifies Paul as the author. These verses could have been added by someone like the author of 1Timothy, for whom inspired speech was not typical of communal worship and who demanded the woman’s public silence, submission and not teaching men (2:9-12), i.e., not speaking in her own words—thus closing a loophole left by references to pneumatic women’s public speech in 1 Corinthians.
|
Real Men Don't Speak in Tongues and Prophesy
Program Unit: Ethics, Love, and the Other in Early Christianity
Judith Gundry, Yale University
In 1 Cor 3:1-2; 14:20 “child” (paidion, nepios) stands for the cognitively immature: “Do not be children in your thinking!”; “I could not address you as spiritual people, but as children in Christ,” not “ready” for “solid food.” In the Graeco-Roman world, where rationality was prized, the irrational and uneducated child could serve as a negative example of cognitive maturity. The positive counterpart was the educated adult male.
In 1 Cor 13:10-12 Paul uses both as examples: “When I was a child (nepios), I spoke like a child (nepios), I thought like a child (nepios), I reasoned like a child (nepios); when I became a man (aner), I gave up childish ways (ta tou nepiou).” The child represents the Corinthian “spiritual person” whose Spirit-inspired knowledge was partial and imperfect: “we know in part…” (13:9). The man represents the eschatologically transformed person of the future who “shall understand fully, even as I have been fully understood” (13:12). Paul thus relegates perfect knowledge to the future, and implies that the Corinthian women and men, despite their impressive spiritual gifts of prophecy and tongues, are mere “children” in comparison to what they shall be.
I will propose and argue that Paul is here opposing the Corinthians’ “male” model of spirituality that defines it in terms of knowledge (expressed in inspired speech), corresponding to the Greco-Roman ideal of the educated adult male. There are no real “men” in the Corinthian church, implies Paul, for real “men” don’t speak in tongues and prophesy. They are completely “in the know”! Still, the Corinthians should attempt to grow up in understanding—“pursue spiritual [empowerments], especially that you might prophesy!” (14:1). But even more importantly, they are to “pursue love” (14:1), the “more excellent way” (12:31), which “abides” and “never ends” (13:8, 13).
In my reconstruction, the Corinthians are portrayed as adopting a “male” model of spirituality, which Paul deconstructs as “childish” because it is based on partial knowledge and thus necessarily characterized by cognitive immaturity this side of the eschaton. The truly “spiritual” are characterized by love.
|
Reception History in Practice: The Cases of Judges and Samuel
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
David Gunn, Texas Christian University
Five years after the publication of my commentary on Judges in the Blackwell Commentaries series, I am nearing completion of another volume, on 1& 2 Samuel. While both Judges and Samuel, as narrative books, might seem very similar, they are also very different in the structure and extent of the component stories. Here I review some of the challenges and pitfalls in the research and writing of the Judges commentary and compare that project with my present work on Samuel. I look, for example, at the range and availability of resources in each case, the factors weighed in making choices for breadth or depth, as well as the challenges in presenting findings in a logical and coherent fashion, given the commentary format. Among the challenges: how to show adequately the use of the biblical material in visual art and illustration. I also consider how publishing in the commentary format affects the research and (in light of feedback on the Judges volume) what advantages and disadvantages the format presents for readers (including students). Finally, I offer some suggestions arising from these projects for fruitful avenues of research in biblical reception history.
|
What Will Be the City's Name? On LXX Ezekiel 48:35
Program Unit: Greek Bible
Hacham Noah, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
The nonliteral translation of LXX Ezek. 48:35 - "and the city's name after whatever day it comes to be it shall be its name" - has troubled scholars seeking to reconstruct the Hebrew vorlage, or to identify the translator's error. It seems, however, that the translation stems neither from a different Hebrew vorlage nor from a mistake but rather reflects a deliberate change undertaken to reinforce ideological and theological views of the Diasporan translator. A parallel Diasporan view is found elsewhere in Jewish Hellenistic sources, defining Diasporan identity separately from the homeland Jewish identity.
|
Celebrating "A Basic Introduction to Biblical Hebrew"
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Jo Ann Hackett, University of Texas at Austin
I will be present for a panel discussion and question-and-answer period of my new Biblical Hebrew textbook.
|
The Transformational Rhetoric of Defeat in Nahum
Program Unit: LGBTI/Queer Hermeneutics
Susan E. Haddox, University of Mount Union
The book of Nahum describes the coming destruction of Nineveh in graphic and compelling language. It draws upon a number of images and themes employed by other prophets, many of which cross boundaries of gender and species. These boundaries are particularly permeable in the descriptions of defeat. Transgendering the defeated party is a frequent rhetorical technique in the prophets. In Nahum the king of Assyria is addressed in some places as a man, ordered to gird his loins, but in defeat, his warriors are transformed into women. The defeat of the capital city is, as is typical, portrayed as the humiliation of a prostitute, who is publically shamed before the nations. It is the fate of the female slaves which is used to personalize the devastation, while male victims are ignored. A second rhetorical transformation turns the defeated king and warriors into animals. The prophet mocks the Assyrian lion iconography and develops different aspects of locust imagery to suggest the total defeat of the king’s forces. One of the effects of the transgender and interspecies imagery is to preserve the ideology of hegemonic masculinity. Men, as men, are not defeated in battle, but their defeat is rhetorically transferred to those of lower status. The descriptions of YHWH in the oracle invite inter-religious analysis through their incorporation of Canaanite mythic images, in particular in showing YHWH’s interaction with nature.
|
Aspects of the Decalogue Tradition in Luke 18:20
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
Diane Hakala, University of Cambridge
The story of Jesus conversation with the ‘Rich (Young) Ruler’ appears in the three synoptic gospels (Matt 19:16-30; Mark 10:17-31; Luke 18:18-30) and contains one of the few references to Decalogue commandments grouped as a literary unit in the New Testament. Commentators have long been aware of the unusual ordering of the Decalogue in these texts, which positions the fifth commandment, honouring parents, after the rest of those in the second table. Some commentators have concluded that the commandment to honour parents was an addition. D. Flusser, in particular, has argued for the existence of a Second Temple Jewish homily based on the second table of the Decalogue. However, it was proposed over a century ago by A. Seeberg and G. Klein that there may well have been an underlying text or tradition, which placed the fifth commandment after the second table. Evidence from Jewish literature from the late Second Temple period seems to support this view. In addition, the parallel question and response in Luke 10:25-27 concerning the inheritance of eternal life, may hint at some echoes to the first table of the Decalogue being present in Luke 18:20. This paper will argue that the order of commandments in Luke 18 and parallel texts may reflect an underlying tradition and that in Luke 18 both tables of the Decalogue are in view.
|
The Gospel of the Poor in African Villages
Program Unit: Q
Sakari Häkkinen, Diocese of Kuopio, Finland
The Sayings Gospel Q was probably composed and used by Galilean villagers from several villages that formed a network consisting of two categories of Jesus followers: itinerant missionaries and settled disciples of Jesus. Itinerant missionaries were most likely landless peasants who had lost ownership of their ancestral Galilean fields through an inability to pay their taxes and loans, most likely having used their property as collateral. Poverty is clearly the underlying context for most of the Q texts, and, as such, seems likely to me to be the key to understanding their meaning.
In order to get to better understand the problem of poverty, I travelled to southern Tanzania and visited several villages where poverty is pervasive. I interviewed the villagers and tried to get to know the social structure of a village as well as how networking works between villages. I am especially interested in questions like: Who owns the land? What do people think about taxes? Do they feel taxation is necessary for their own lives or do they believe that paying taxes privileges others over them? What are the reasons for contact with neighboring villages, and who is responsible for maintaining relations?
The paper is a part of my forthcoming monograph that aims to come to new understandings and fresh interpretations of the texts in the synoptic Gospels that deal with poverty and the poor. In addition to the exegetical research to be undertaken, these same texts will also be investigated from a contextual standpoint – that is – from the perspectives of the materially poor. Findings from my field research among the poor living in villages in Tanzania (spring 2010) will be studied and then compared to current biblical hermeneutical scholarly investigations concerning the poverty texts. In this paper the texts under examination will be limited to a few examples.
|
When the Lights Went Out: Hugh Nibley on the Passing of the Primitive Church
Program Unit: Latter-day Saints and the Bible
John F. Hall, Brigham Young University
In the 1961 volume of the journal Church History, Professor Hugh Nibley published a seminal article contrasting LDS views of early Christian history with both the traditional view of churchmen and revisionist views belonging to contemporary scholarship.
While Nibley accepted the notion that the second century witnessed the differentiation of Christian groups, he would not have agreed that they or their doctrines arose independently. Rather he concluded that all had sprung from an original primitive Christianity, initially uniform in doctrine and practice, and which had by the second century fractionated into multiple Christianities. In advancing the theory of fractionation, Nibley preceded by half a century current scholarship demonstrating the second century fractionation process, such as Lampe’s recent From Paul to Valentinus.
Nibley’s work also adapted to academic discourse the fundamental LDS doctrine known as the apostasy of early Christianity. In the LDS community apostasy had often been interpreted per the King James text, as “falling away” to suggest a gradual departure from pristine doctrines. However, Nibley, was careful to apply secular uses of apostasia, such as revolt or rebellion, to assert a clear rejection of both first century teachings as well as the apostolic authority behind such doctrine.
Nibley depicts a late first century Christianity in disarray, and the resultant second century Christianity as having abandoned essential features of Christianity. These losses led ultimately to a changed religion that, after bitter disputation among various Christian factions, emerged from Nicaea with the triumph of the most popular of those factions. In this manner Nibley’s work prefigures current assessments of proto-orthodox Christianity and its triumph over other Christianities.
The present paper proposes to assess the work of Professor Nibley in light of contemporary scholarship and evidences produced in the fifty years since Nibley’s work was done. Nibley’s adaptations of LDS doctrines about early Christianity will thus be seen to accord with many elements of current scholarship concerning this same period.
|
David Behind the Shephelah: What Lachish Tells Us about Hinterland Life
Program Unit:
Baruch Halpern, Pennsylvania State University
The correlation between settlement at Lachish and state formation in Judah or Israel on the one hand, and trade on the other, has been
considerably complicated by the new discoveries at Kh. Qeiyafa. The exploration of the relation between settlements in the Negev and in the
Shephelah deserves fresh examination.
|
NAPH: Hebrew Grammars (Hackett, A Basic Introduction to Biblical Hebrew)
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Martien Halvorson-Taylor, University of Virginia
Panel member
|
The Conceptual Unity of Psalm 19 in the Light of Egyptian Solar Imagery
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Iconography and the Bible
Joel Hamme, Fuller Theological Seminary
This paper examines the conceptual unity of Psalm 19 in the light of Egyptian Solar Imagery as preserved in hymns found on funeral stelae, using the two hymns to the sun god on the funeral stele of Suti and Hor from the 18th Dynasty as an exemplar of the solar theology that emerged at that time. One difficulty that must be overcome in this comparison is the fact that the 18th Dynasty, and the entire New Kingdom, passed away centuries before the Kingdom of Israel came into existence. This paper traces the continuance of the New Kingdom Solar Theology into the Saite period by the examination of the inscriptions on various stelae and an Oracle Papyrus. Egypt held sway over Syria-Palestine for centuries, from the New Kingdom through the Saite Period, with brief breaks during the period of the United Monarchy and during Assyrian Hegemony. This has left its imprint on Hebrew scribal practices and cultural expression. Most significance for us are two sets of Stamp Seals found in Israel and Judah that date from the 9th-8th centuries that use Egyptian solar imagery that depict protective powers such as the, sungod on lotus, uraeus and sphinx and the royal cartouche. Starting in the seventh centuries, the stamp seals in Judah overwhelmingly are merely epigraphic, without any iconography. The combination of royal and protective themes in the iconography of Israel and Judah’s stamp seals suggest the Egyptian solar imagery being used as representative of the Deity’s protection and blessing of the king democratized, the ureaus and sphinx being hypostases of the Deity’s blessing. This is set in proper Yahwist perspective in Psalm 19:1-7, with the Sun being one of the LORD’s creations. This protection and blessing is viewed as being derived from Torah in the second section of the Psalm (19:8-15).
|
Women and Divination in Biblical Narrative
Program Unit: Prophetic Texts and Their Ancient Contexts
Esther Hamori, Union Theological Seminary
This paper is a study of the literary presentation of women in biblical narrative who engage in some form of divination. This includes women who are given the title neviah, such as Miriam and Deborah, women with other titles or descriptions, such as the medium of Endor, and women with no titles, such as Rebekah. The so-called “prophetesses” have generally been treated independently; however, prophecy in its ancient Near Eastern context should be understood as one subcategory of divination. This paper addresses issues in the portrayal of all kinds of female diviners, including their social location and family life, how their actions were understood by their communities, on whose authority they speak and act, and how their actions fit into the larger traditions built up around each character. Attention is given to the literary presentation of these roles and actions in light of ancient Near Eastern divinatory roles defined by men and generally related to the scribal profession.
|
The Peril of Precarious Performativity in Genesis 27
Program Unit: Cognitive Linguistics in Biblical Interpretation
Jin H. Han, New York Theological Seminary
With all its comic twists, the story of Jacob’s acquisition of Esau’s blessing in Genesis 27 constructs an edifice of tragedy, whose entanglement cannot be easily overcome due to the performative nature of Isaac’s words. On the one hand, the passage underscores the patriarch’s discursive authority. It prefaces his blessing with hnh-n’ zknty (v. 2), introducing it as a death bed pronouncement. The special occasion concludes with a ritual meal (w’klh b‘bwr tbrkk npšy, v. 4), marking a duly constituted space that permits neither modification nor cancellation. Jacob himself acknowledges the risk in the ruse, saying whb’ty ‘ly qllh wl’ brkh (v. 12). On the other hand, in spite of the presumably unassailable reality of Isaac’s blessing (brkh for Jacob, v. 41), a number of features threaten to undermine the efficacy of his declaration. The whole process is tainted by the scheme of deception. Rebekah’s epexegetical lfny yhwh (v. 7) suggests that words are not self-sufficient. Esau mounts a passionate protest (brkty, v. 36; cf. brktk, v. 35) concerning the illegitimacy of the stolen blessing. He exposes Jacob’s repeated offences pithily with a play on word (bkrty and brkty in v. 36). By interrogating the nature of the performative, the story hauntingly explores the erratic nature of human life somehow linked with divine design, as well as the checkered history of enmity between Israelites and Edomites.
|
A Performance-Critical Study of the Disrupted Word Order
Program Unit: Performance Criticism of the Bible and Other Ancient Texts
Jin H. Han, New York Theological Seminary
Biblical Hebrew is normatively classified as a VSO language, in which the main verb heads the sentence. Historical linguistics ascribes the relatively fixed nature of biblical Hebrew word order to the loss of early case endings, which increased the importance of word order. The so-called normal word order is occasionally disrupted for various reasons including emphasis (e.g., Gen 37;4; 1 Kgs 5:1), chiasm (e.g., Gen 18:6; 1 Sam 13:3), iteration (e.g., Deut 9:7, 22, 24; 31:27; cf. Hos 5:1), aesthetics (e.g., Joel 2:13), and certain contextual constraints (e.g., in Gen 42:7, Joseph’s brothers answer a question in the anticipated word order, while in Judg 17:9, Micah the Levite deviates from the norm to volunteer to say more than he was asked). The breach of word order may well be analyzed in terms of grammatical conventions, and the normal predicate-subject sequence seems to be less strictly observed in the subordinate or nominal clause than in the main verbal clause. A variety of other factors can affect word order, as well, ranging from genre and setting to the speaker’s social location or sentiment. While serving a variety of linguistic functions, irregular word order contributes to the richness of the discourse. Surprisingly, versions and translations largely disregard the disrupted word order, presumably in the interest of clarity, particularly when the target language has its own syntactical inflexibility (as is the case with English, whose loss of archaic endings has resulted in rigorous word order along with the preponderance of prepositions). The diluted renditions threaten to consign to obscurity the performative possibilities embedded in the extraordinary word order. The paper examines selected examples of the disrupted word order in the MT in view of searching for meaningful ways to bring their special nuance to life.
|
“Severing the Joints and the Marrow": The Double-Edged Sword of Comparison
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
James Constantine Hanges, Miami University
In the wake of a recent flood of publications of Greek and Roman inscriptions, Edwin Hatch dared to argue for the comparability of early Christianity, especially in terms of its ecclesiastical structure—parallels in this structure with Greek and Roman models were there, he argued, right from the beginning of the Pauline churches. He based his argument on the ubiquity of what he believed were similar, pre-existing Greco-Roman social formations, thiasoi, koinoi, and collegia. Despite his appeal to parallels, the specifics of his comparison were criticized for lack of terminological precision—his comparanda were not sharp enough or sufficiently rigorous to be compelling and the uniqueness of Christian forms was preserved. This paper explores the process of comparison, especially the complexities of deciding what constitutes comparability in specific cases. This paper argues that the process of identifying the comparanda of a particular comparison is political and strategic. Comparison is used both as a tool and a weapon, and too often in the study of religion—as in the case of Hatch’s critics—comparison is wielded in the service of incomparability, a strategic move that can be called comparatio iniquitatis causa (comparison for the sake of difference). In theorizing the process, this paper argues that to be effective, comparative study must first develop a solution to its political problem. One step toward this solution would be to establish usable criteria for defining the categories of comparison.
|
Job 28, from Metonymy to Metaphor
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Davis Hankins, Emory University
This paper proposes a new reading of the wisdom poem in Job 28 according to a twofold movement. I argue that the logic operative up to v.19 can be characterized via reference to the rhetorical figure of metonymy, at which point the poem's governing logic transitions to something more like that which characterizes metaphor. Verses 1-19 evoke a sense of wisdom as that which is displaced in a seemingly endless, metonymic process of deferral from the representative materials available to human beings. Verse 20 then speaks of wisdom as something that has come, that is present. But this presence, which appears to God in the creative acts recounted in vv.25-26, is no less displaced. Wisdom is neither on the side of God---as a divine attribute or as that which guides God's creative activity---nor on the side of creation---wisdom is something other than those things which God's creative activity creates. The different sense of wisdom's displacement in vv.20-27 is similar to that which characterizes certain kinds of metaphor. If this alternative proposal accurately accounts for the poem's structure and movement, it poses a number of consequences for several important interpretive issues. The paper explores at least two of these in some detail, namely, the significance of the poem's controversial final verse and the uncertain identity of the voice that speaks the poem.
|
The Meaning of Q 17:37: Problems, Opinions, and Perspectives
Program Unit: Q
Gertraud Harb, University Graz
Luke 17:37 with its parallel in Matt 24:28 is not easy to understand, and so it is no surprise that many different interpretations have been suggested over the years, especially for the Lukan context of the saying.
My aim in this presentation is to look critically at Q 17:37 and its recent interpretations, in order to find the most plausible meaning of this verse in Q. First, the role the "eagles" in the saying should be explained. After looking in the Hebrew OT, the LXX and some examples of eagles and vultures in the Hellenistic culture, it will become clear that the term aetos is used for the Hebrew nsr: This bird cannot be identified easily with the Greek aetos or gups, but in Jewish contexts it is connected with fastness and destruction (Deut 28:49; 2 Sam 1:23; Prov 23:5; Jer 4:13, 49:22; Lam 4:19; Hos 8:1). Instead of over-emphasizing the motif of visibility in Q (cf. Beasley-Murray, Schulz, Zeller, Günther, Bridge and McCane), I would like to stress the temporal and brutal imagery of the saying (the eagles as a picture of swiftness and devastation), the certainty of the coming of the son of man and the connecting function of the verse between vv. 23-24 and 26-27, 30, 34-35. Considering this connection, the eagle-saying describes on the one hand the certainty of the coming of the son of man and the unimportance of the question of location, but it stresses on the other hand the speed and brutality of his coming and judgment.
|
Listener Surveys and Theological Questions (or Lack Thereof)
Program Unit: Academy of Homiletics
Charles B. Hardwick, Princeton Theological Seminary
*
|
Reading with an ‘Eye’ (I) to the Heavens: Reading as Ritual Transformation in the Qumran Teacher Hymns (TH)
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Angela Kim Harkins, Fairfield University
The hodayot scroll from Cave 1 is a collection of prayer texts. The name of this scroll itself is taken from the formulaic phrase “I give thanks to you O God” that appears consistently among the collection known popularly as the Teacher Hymns (TH) that are clustered in 1QH cols. 10-17. While the texts in the scroll present themselves as a collection of prayer texts, extremely little attention has been paid to how these TH would have been experienced in a ritual context. This paper will explore the possibility that these texts were used in a ritual way for the purpose of achieving a religious experience, an ascent into the heavens and communion with angels. The important elements that will be considered in this paper are the use of first person speech and the strategic arousal of emotions. The TH laments are descriptions of terror and suffering (both physical and psychological) and they generate intense affective responses in the reader. These powerful laments, along with the first person “I,” are two literary elements that would have well-served a reader who seeks to create a religious experience from reading. Through the rhetorical “I” the reader would be able to enter into the text and assume the persona of the text, allowing the reader to emulate the experiences which are described in the text. The experiences of suffering would be emulated by the reader, but more importantly, the experiences of exaltation and communion with the angels. In this understanding the laments, terrifying experiences recounted in the first person, serve a key function because they assist the reader in achieving an altered psychic state, one that is thought to be a necessary precursor for a visionary experience. This study relies upon the work of Moshe Idel and others who have proposed that weeping was an important technique for a mystical experience.
|
Ethical Dimensions of Oral Strategies in Bible Translation
Program Unit: Bible Translation
Bryan Harmelink, SIL International
Is the trend toward orality in the global Bible translation movement evidence of a paradigm shift? Or is the current pendulum swing in favor of oral strategies merely a reaction to the long-term emphasis on literacy and print strategies? Are there specific contextual factors that call for the implementation of oral strategies or should they be considered wherever translation is being done?
These questions will be considered in the first section of the paper together with an overview of currently proposed oral strategies. Assessment will also be made of pilot projects implementing oral strategies by the Mapuche translation team in southern Chile.
These considerations are important, but there are also fundamental ethical issues that must be considered in decisions about appropriate strategies. These ethical considerations have come into particular focus with increased awareness of postcolonial concerns, globalization, and the oft-mentioned shift of the “center of gravity” in the Church. The final section of this paper will explore pertinent literature in these fields that needs to be considered in the formulation of principles to guide the ethical implementation of oral strategies in Bible translation.
|
The Trajectory of the Greek Theophany in Hab 3:3–7
Program Unit: Greek Bible
Joshua Harper, University of Cambridge
The Old Greek translation presents the theophany in Habakkuk 3 with a distinctly different spin from that of the Masoretic Text. For instance, although in MT YHWH appears to be retracing the route followed in the exodus, some changes in detail in OG (such as "the shady, bushy mountain" in place of MT "Mt. Paran") remove the specific Sinai connections. Such differences between the texts are primarily due to translation technique, especially the strategies employed by the translator for approximating the meaning of difficult or obscure Hebrew, but in certain instances intertextual allusions seem also to have influenced the final shape of the Greek text. Not only is it helpful to probe the circumstances that shaped the original translation, but it is also instructive to trace the interpretive tendencies of the text into the exegetical writings of the Church Fathers to observe the links they find in the Greek text that allow them to reinterpret the passage in their own context. This paper, then, will attempt to explain representative differences between MT and OG and examine the subsequent life of the Greek text in early patristic writings.
|
Jesus and Roman Imperialism: The Problem of "Hidden Transcripts"
Program Unit: Jesus Traditions, Gospels, and Negotiating the Roman Imperial World
J. Albert Harrill, Indiana University, Bloomington
An increasing number of biblical scholars assert that Jesus in the Gospels challenged, to the point of "subverting," the imperialism of ancient Rome. One argument is, for example, that the Gospels deploy particular terminology parallel to that of Rome's "imperial cult," with the specific intention of turning the emperor's "propaganda" upon its head. Another is stronger: Jesus' entire preaching, rather than just specific terminology, fully challenged the domination of Rome with clear, if "coded" (hidden), speech of resistance. I find much of this scholarship highly problematic. My paper will critique in particular the "Jesus and Empire" argument that detects language in the Gospels that corresponds to what the political theorist James Scott has called "the hidden transcript," which is a rebellion of words that subordinate groups use behind the back of the dominant in contrast with "the public transcript" of words used in open interaction (James C. Scott, Domination and the Arts of Resistance: Hidden Transcripts [New Haven: Yale University Press, 1992]). James Scott's thesis of the presence of a "hidden transcript" in the public actions of subordinates is based upon his study of the oral testimonies of African American slaves in the antebellum American South. Scott can identify certain words and actions to be "coded" as subversive to the dominant ideology, precisely because he has testimonies from the slaves themselves that say so. Without this "insider" testimony from the subordinate informer, who is speaking freely beyond the eyes and ears of the dominant, the identification of any speech as "coded" is total speculation.
|
How Does Intermarriage Defile the Sanctuary?
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Hannah K Harrington, Patten University
The law that intermarriage defiles the Sanctuary is promoted in the book of Jubilees and in certain Dead Sea Scrolls, although nowhere in Scripture is this statement explicitly made. What are the Scriptural antecedents of this phrase and what is its significance in the Scrolls? Do other sins defile the sanctuary in the same way? This paper examines the intertwining of sexual defilement and the defilement of the sanctuary in several Second Temple texts, most notably, Jubilees, Aramaic Levi, the Temple Scroll, MMT, and D. Scholars have largely assumed that the pollution caused by intermarriage to the sanctuary was caused by the physical entry of foreign spouses into holy space. However, this rationale is nowhere explicitly stated in the texts listed above. It seems more likely that these authors are concerned not only about possible defilement of the temple but for the desecration of the human sanctuary of Israel. This paper examines the usage of biblical priestly terminology in the Scrolls and concludes that for many of these authors the bodies of Israel were a cultic sanctum, i.e. “sanctuary,” which could be defiled by illicit sexual activity even when no one was entering the temple. This thesis is supported not only from Pentateuchal traditions where the impurity of sex, both licit (Lev 15) and illicit (Lev 18 and 20) can defile the sanctuary without contact, but also by early Second Temple biblical texts, e.g. Ezra 9 (desecration of “holy seed”) and Mal 2 where intermarriage desecrates “the holiness of YHWH.”
|
Why Did Ezra Force Divorce?
Program Unit: Chronicles-Ezra-Nehemiah
Hannah K. Harrington, Patten University
This paper looks beyond socio-economic explanations (e.g. Smith-Christopher) for the forced divorce Ezra tries to implement (Ez 10) and, rather, to a new theological paradigm caused by the exile (cf. Blenkinsopp 2009). During this period there is a change in the locus of holiness. Without the Temple, the only available sanctuary for God’s holiness was the bodies of Israelites. Thus, the legitimacy to be physical containers of holiness becomes the issue. While the notion that Israel is holy predates the Exile, it takes on a cultic, technical dimension in Ezra-Nehemiah. Although the temple is rebuilt by this time, the notion had already gained strength during its absence that the bodies of Jews were also sancta. Thus, intermarriage becomes for the writer of EN a sacrilege which desecrates Israel and her offspring and requires an asham and divorce (Ez 9-10), and foreigners inherently cause ritual pollution (Neh 13). These stricter purity attitudes form not only because of external sociological factors (e.g. purity barriers as a defense for a threatened community, cf. Douglas), but as a way of dealing with the absence of the temple during the period of the exile. This case is made by 1) examining EN’s cultic language and reshaping of pre-exilic traditions which do not present a technical, impermeable view of lay Israel’s holiness and 2) investigating similar attitudes toward the sanctity of Jewish seed in other temple-less Jewish communities (e.g. Qumran, the Rabbis, early church).
|
Still Water, Rushing Water: A Comparison of the River Descriptions in Genesis with Parallel Portrayals in Old Norse Eddic Literature
Program Unit: Bible, Myth, and Myth Theory
Tod R Harris, The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints
Much has been written about the four rivers described in Genesis 2:10-14. Most commentaries tend to center around attempts to identify those rivers with modern-day equivalents, with varying degrees of success. Rather than treat them as literal rivers, however, it is perhaps more useful to consider them as features of a “mythic” geography. Considering the rivers in Genesis in this way allows a comparison to similar occurrences in other mythic traditions, which in turn yields some valuable insights into the purpose of the river descriptions in this passage, beyond merely fixing physical location. Though the cultures are quite disparate, it is fascinating to note that a similar set of rivers features prominently in Norse myth. The purpose of this paper is to compare the descriptions of the primordial rivers in Genesis with their counterparts in Old Norse mythic literature (both Elder and Younger Eddas); to contrast the functions these descriptions seem to serve; and by using some of the tools of modern myth theory, to proffer some suggestions for using the ideas generated to increase understanding of the figurative role rivers play, not just in this particular passage but in the biblical text in general.
|
Augustan Rome and the Body of Christ: A Comparison of the Social Vision of the Res Gestae and Paul’s Letter to the Romans
Program Unit: Pauline Theology
Jim Harrison, Wesley Institute
A major study remains to be written comparing Augustus’ conception of rule in the Res Gestae with Paul’s eschatological gospel of grace in the letter to the Romans. Even though each document was foundational in the history of Western civilisation, a comparison of their vastly different social outcomes has not been undertaken. Undoubtedly, the considerable differences in the genre and aims of each document makes such a comparison daunting for New Testament scholars, without having also to master the controversy that each document continues to generate in its own discipline. It is possible that Paul saw a Greek version of the text of the Res Gestae at Pisidian Antioch along with the Latin text that still survives there during his first missionary journey (Acts 13:14-50), even though there are no archaeological remains of the Greek text at Antioch today. Presumably Paul would have been aware that the original Latin copy of the Res Gestae was inscribed in bronze at Augustus’ mausoleum at Rome. In writing to the Romans, the apostle decided to highlight the eschatological triumph of Christ’s grace over sin and death in a manner that intersected with traditional Roman boasting culture and the iconic Augustan age of grace, while unfolding for his Gentile auditors the extraordinary privilege of their incorporation as a ‘wild olive shoot’ into the ‘olive root’ of covenantal Israel (Rom 11:24; 15:7-11). The paper will investigate the social and theological significance of themes common to the Res Gestae and Romans: the necessity of self-advertisement, the conquest of the nations, the extension of beneficence, the centrality of ancestral tradition, the accumulation of honour, the achievement of virtue and the authority of the leader. Paul’s gospel of Christ crucified posed a radical social alternative to Roman culture that would transform the Western intellectual tradition.
|
Wholeness in James and the Q Source
Program Unit: Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
Patrick J. Hartin, Gonzaga University
The sayings traditions of Jesus of Nazareth lie at the foundation of the moral exhortations in both the Letter of James are the Q Source. An examination of both James and Q reveals that they hold some moral exhortations in common. The purpose of this paper will be to examine these common links with the Jesus tradition by focusing on their vision of God and its consequence for action.
This study demonstrates that faith in action captures the vision of James and the Q source. James’s vision embraced an understanding of works that occurred in the context of one’s whole life of faith (Jas 1:14) as does the Q Source (Q 6:46-49).
A social-scientific examination of the Israelite value of ‘wholeness’ demonstrates that this value is reflected equally in James and Q. Patterns of all-or-nothing (characteristic of the Israelite value of wholeness) are common to James and Q. Some examples that are examined: God demands total allegiance; people cannot serve both God and mammon (Q 16:13). Friendship with the world is enmity with God (Jas 4:4); the need to keep the whole Law (Q 16:17 and Jas 2:10), etc.
Through this analysis of the moral exhortations in James and Q, this paper illustrates that the Q tradition as it developed further in the Sermon on the Mount is also reflected in the Jesus tradition at the heart of James’s ethical teaching. The common links in the traditions between James and Q are explained from the fact that James is aware of the Jesus tradition as it is being handed on within the Q community and its developing tradition as seen in the Q Sermon on the Mount.
|
“You Spoke and It Came into Being”
Program Unit: Cognitive Linguistics in Biblical Interpretation
Kirsten Marie Hartvigsen, University of Oslo
In Joseph and Aseneth 15-16 Aseneth invites her heavenly visitor for a meal. During the preparations for this meal, the supernatural being asks Aseneth to bring him a honeycomb. Aseneth knows that she does not have a honeycomb in her storeroom, but the heavenly visitor says: “Go into your storeroom and you will find a honeycomb lying on the table. Pick it up and bring it here.” When Aseneth enters the storeroom, she finds a honeycomb on the table. In order to understand this phenomenon, Aseneth creates a conceptual blend which relates the appearance of the honeycomb to the breath of his mouth. Later Aseneth returns to him with the honeycomb and she interprets its existence in the following manner: “Lord, I never had a honeycomb in my storeroom, but you spoke and it came into being.” Aseneth first understands the utterances of the supernatural being as false assertions. Later, she reinterprets them as performative speech acts which caused the appearance of the honeycomb in her storeroom. In this paper, I employ speech act theory and blending theory in order to shed light on this dialogue and the conceptual blend which Aseneth creates to understand the miraculous event. Furthermore, I utilize blending theory to illuminate the manner in which this conceptual blend is developed when the heavenly being uses the honeycomb in a ritual context.
|
Ta Biblia: A Hermeneutic of Diversity
Program Unit: Semiotics and Exegesis
Matthew R. Hauge, Claremont Graduate University
Chrysostom, the fourth century bishop of Constantinople, is credited with being the first person to refer to the two testaments as ta biblia, “the books.” These books represented 66 texts written over a span of hundreds of years in three different languages from across the ancient Mediterranean world – a collection defined by diverse confessions of the salvific work of God. The shift from the Greek plural to the Latin singular, Biblia, “the Bible,” has had a profound impact upon the popular imagination of American evangelicalism, which more than any other form of Christian expression in the world, emphasizes the final, ultimate authority of “the Bible.” This moniker, coupled with the post-canonical concept of inspiration and the transmission of “the books” in a single volume, has misled many to assume the biblical witness represents a single voice, unified in clarity of vision in all matters. This is simply not the case. In fact, the beauty of the Christian canon lay in its kaleidoscopic witness to the divine – not a single voice, but a chorus of voices singing from every corner of the human experience. In Divided by Faith, Michael O. Emerson and Christian Smith examine the problem of race relations in American evangelicalism. At the heart of their discussion is the problem of diversity within this community and the impact of social location upon perceptions of reality – among the approximately 85 million Americans who identify themselves as evangelical nearly 90 percent are middle class and white. The history of biblical interpretation includes morally reprehensible acts carried out in the name of Jesus within culturally hegemonic communities armed with a misperception of the singular truth of scripture. This history stands as a prophetic witness, unveiling the darkest contours of the misappropriation of scripture. American evangelicalism must first recognize the diversity of voices within “the books” and the diversity of perspectives that they represent, and then it must embrace the “other” as a hermeneutical strategy; if it does not, it is destined to repeat the tragic past, wielding “the Bible” as a weapon of divinely ordained violence and oppression.
|
The Wandering Bee: Ancient Education and Markan Composition
Program Unit: Markan Literary Sources
Matthew Hauge, Claremont Graduate University
Greek and Roman education was largely a private enterprise, and yet there was remarkable consistency among educational practices from the fourth century B.C.E. to the fifth century C.E. Even a cursory examination of the educationalists and educational papyri reveals that at each stage, primary, secondary, and tertiary students learned to read and write based on the imitation of literary models. Seneca the Younger described this literary process beautifully in his famous Epistulae 84, in which he imagined the ancient author as a bee who wandered from flower to flower, gathering and blending honey, creating a delicious new compound that betrayed its origin yet was clearly different. The author of the second gospel was groomed within these literary hallways, a wandering bee gathering material from multiple models creating something clearly different – ???? t?? e?a??e???? ??s?? ???st??.
|
The Gilgal Traditions in Joshua and Recent Archaeology in the Jordan Valley
Program Unit: Joshua-Judges
Ralph K. Hawkins, Kentucky Christian University
Dtr was was not the first to gather together traditions about ancient Israel. Evidence within the book of Joshua suggests that a cult centered at Gilgal played a key part in both the early worship and the gathering together of the traditions about earliest Israel. The traditions about Gilgal and its role in early Israel are complex. The Israelites are said to have reconnoitered the region of Jericho (Josh 2:1), crossed "near Jericho" (3:16), and camped "in Gilgal on the east border of Jericho" (4:19). Yet the instructions for carrying out religious rites at Mts. Ebal and Gerizim contained geographic references which located it "opposite Gilgal, beside the oak of Moreh" (Deut 11:29-30), which suggests that this may be a reference to a northern Gilgal; in addition, "the oak of Moreh" was located near Shechem (cf. Gen 12:6). The biblical tradition claims that "Gilgal" served as the Israelites' base of operations throughout the early phases of the Israelite settlement (6:14; 9:6; 10:15, 43; 14:6), but is this a reference to a southern or a northern Gilgal? In all, the MT refers to at least three, and possibly five, different locations identified as "Gilgal" in both the north and south, and multiple sites identified as Gilgalim have been discovered in surveys of the central hill-country. This paper will sift through both the biblical and archaeological data in an effort to elucidate the role of Gilgal and the gilgalim in early Israel.
|
Martyrdom and the First Apocalypse of James
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Mikael Haxby, Harvard University
This paper presents a reading of the First Apocalypse of James which incorporates evidence from both the Nag Hammadi and Tchacos Codex versions of the text. In particular, I take as the key to interpretation James’ martyrdom at the conclusion of the text. This paper shows that 1ApocJas works as a didactic text, exhorting its readers and hearers to undertake a practice of preparation that will enable them to endure martyrdom with equanimity, just as James does. This paper considers preparation for martyrdom as a practice or set of practices, drawing in particular on Michel Foucault’s notion of practices of the self. 1ApocJas calls for several identifiable practices from its readers and hearers. To aid in the attainment of knowledge, which leads to triumph over fear, 1ApocJas calls for practices of ritual recitation of theological formulae. For the Christian to learn to act properly in a situation of persecution, the text exhorts a practice of discernment, by which everyday events may be interpreted in terms of their cosmic or theological significance. Previous scholarship on 1ApocJas has focused heavily on the importance of revelation in the text. I suggest that the revelation dialogue form, by depicting in narrative the acquisition of knowledge, serves the purpose not only of disseminating teaching, but more specifically of exhorting practical transformation of readers and hearers through the incorporation of this teaching. It is the reception of knowledge which enables James to triumph over his fear and face persecution and death with equanimity. Through the inculcation of true understanding, the text implicitly claims, a person may alter his or her emotional response to even situations of extreme danger. I locate this cognitive understanding of emotions among a broader discourse in antiquity reflected in moral philosophy and a variety of martyrdom texts.
|
Female Martyrs and Theologies of Violence in the First Apocalypse of James
Program Unit: Violence and Representations of Violence in Antiquity
Mikael Haxby, Harvard University
Through a reading of the second-century C.E. Christian text, the First Apocalypse of James, this paper investigates dilemmas that arise when a community’s remembrance of its martyrs exists in tension with its theological commitments. The tensions involve the remembrance of female martyrs and the gendered nature of these theological commitments, and so I consider also the question of the gendering of violence in antiquity. 1ApocJas uses the form of a dialogue between Jesus and James, the brother of Jesus, to discuss theology and martyrdom. According to the text’s theological exposition, the true God is perfectly male, and femaleness is not only secondary, but also responsible for evil and violence in the world. After laying out this theology, the text proceeds to memorialize and honor a group of women “whom all the generations bless,” among whom are three martyrs. By setting these two discussions in succession, 1ApocJas asks implicitly how it might be that women should be honored as foundational martyrs when femaleness is so devalued theologically.
Violence was commonly understood in the ancient world in inextricably gendered terms, as the victim of violence would be seen as feminized. The text makes use of this connection between suffering violence and femininity in order to authorize the three women as paradigmatic martyrs. At the same time, the text instrumentalizes its theology to feminize the persecutors of Christians. 1ApocJas explains the violence of worldly persecutors by saying that these authorities are the followers of a figure named “femaleness” and as such they are not children of the true God. The persecutors are the ones who have qualities of femaleness. I suggest that 1ApocJas makes use of the complex, overlapping nature of the discourses of gender and violence in order to navigate the tensions between its theology and memorialization of martyrs.
|
Methods of Exile
Program Unit:
Leslie Hayes, University of Toronto
The second-century Christian text of the Acts of Thecla presents a number of interpretive possibilities that have been explored to greater and lesser degrees in the last thirty years. This paper re-positions the Acts of Thecla inside an alternative interpretive framework constructed from ancient legal practices, literary and philosophical traditions, and potential social subjectivities related to exilium. By probing the possible presence of exile as a narrative device in the Acts of Thecla, this paper essays distances and proximities between one potential instance of an early Christian narrative use of a rhetoric of exile and corresponding “fictions” and “facts” of exilium in the context of empire.
|
The Egyptian Goddess Mut in West Semitic Seals: Re-evaluating the Evidence
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Iconography and the Bible
Christopher B. Hays, Fuller Theological Seminary
A number of stamp seals bearing the theophoric element m(w)t have been interpreted as referring to Mot, the god of death and the underworld in West Semitic tradition. It is more likely that these refer to Mut, the Egyptian national goddess who was prominent in Egypt throughout the biblical period. Unlike Mot, who was a demonic figure, Mut's cult and benevolent aspects are well known.
|
Intimations of Divine Identity Christology in Luke's Reading of Scripture
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
Richard B. Hays, Duke University
.
|
Graham Stanton and the Four Gospel Codex: Reconsidering the Manuscript Evidence
Program Unit: Matthew
Peter M. Head, Tyndale House
An important part of Prof. Stanton's later work is the attention he gave to issues relating to the four gospel canon in early Christianity. In his presidential address to the Studiorum Novi Testamenti Societas - published as 'The Fourfold Gospel'in NTS 43 (1997), 317-46 - Stanton proposed that the fourfold gospel canon was intrinsically linked with the development of the fourfold gospel codex, which he argued was a well established artifact by the end of the second century. This paper offers an illustrated reconsideration of the manuscript evidence appealed to by Stanton, alongside a general survey of second and third century gospel manuscripts on papyrus. I argue on the basis of the surviving manuscript evidence that the gospels mostly circulated individually up until the fourth century, and that four-gospel codices were the exception rather than the rule.
|
The Irresistible Joseph: Continuity and Discontinuity between Syriac Sources and the Quran
Program Unit: Syriac Literature and Interpretations of Sacred Texts
Kristian Heal, Brigham Young University
Potiphar and his wife return to the Joseph narrative after their appointed scene in Genesis 39 only in the Syriac and Islamic sources (e.g. Surah 12.50-52). In the earliest Syriac example of this extra-biblical episode Potiphar’s wife excuses herself by claiming that Joseph was simply irresistible, a theme we find elsewhere in Jewish and Islamic sources. In the Quran, the mention of Potiphar’s wife is only oblique, which is what one would expect given the trajectory of this motif in later Syriac sources. This paper will consider whether these extra-biblical episodes can be used to trace continuity between the Syriac tradition and the Quran? My purpose is to show that it is essential to consider the narrative integrity of each source as well the trajectory of the respective traditions in the process of asserting any measure of dependence.
|
Babel-ing On: Reflections on Writing the Reception History of Genesis 1–11
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Christopher Heard, Pepperdine University
Writing a large-scale reception-historical commentary presents a variety of challenges, including the question of organization. The commentary form imposes a sequential structure mirroring the textual units, but how ought one to organize material within each unit? As part of the "Reception History: Theory and Practice in the Blackwell Bible Commentary Series" panel, this presentation will use the Primeval Narrative of Genesis 1-11 as a case study in writing and structuring a reception-historical commentary.
|
Sadducees—Jewish Disciples of Jesus?
Program Unit: History and Literature of Early Rabbinic Judaism
Karin Hedner-Zetterholm, Lund University
A number of recent studies have suggested that the bold assertions and hyperbolic praise of the Oral Torah in some Bavli passages as well as an increased emphasis on rabbinic tradition in general indicate that the rabbis perceived a challenge to their authority during the amoraic period (Hayes, Elman, Schremer). Other indications of a perceived challenge to rabbinic tradition and authority is the idea that the entire Oral Torah with all its details was given at Sinai that developed during the amoraic period, and the hostility towards Sadducees portrayed as a group that accepts only Scripture and rejects rabbinic tradition expressed in Bavli passages from the mid-fourth century (Kalmin).
This paper explores the possibility that the increased emphasis on rabbinic oral tradition in the Bavli is a reaction to the rejection of rabbinic authority and tradition by groups in Babylonia that accepted Scripture but who were constructing an alternative authority in distinction from rabbinic Judaism, such as the community of the Didascalia Apostolorum. It has been increasingly recognized that the Didascalia community represents a variety of Jewish identities and accordingly this community and rabbinic Judaism could be seen as two competing Jewish groups who both claimed to have the correct interpretation of the Bible. The Didascalia’s rejection of the “second legislation,” understood as rabbinic tradition (Fonrobert), could have made them look Sadducee-like in the eyes of the rabbis and led to an increased emphasis on the power and divine origin of the Oral Torah as well as hostility towards “Sadducees” on the part of the rabbis. This paper explores the possibility of establishing a link between the Babylonian rabbinic construction of Sadducees and groups like the Didascalia community.
|
Jewish Christians in the Light of Nerva’s Reform of the Fiscus Judaicus
Program Unit: Jewish Christianity / Christian Judaism
Marius Heemstra, University of Groningen
When considering the issues involved in conceptualizing Jewish Christians or Jesus-believing Jews as a distinct category or categories of religion in antiquity, it is remarkable that the Roman legal perspective is rarely taken. “Jew” was a specific legal category in the Roman Empire, especially after the year 70 CE when Jews were supposed to pay the Jewish tax to the Fiscus Judaicus. “Christian” was another legal or rather illegal category as early as the reign of Trajan judging from Pliny’s letter to his emperor (c. 112 CE).
At that moment in time being a Jew was acceptable to the Roman authorities and being a Christian was not. In this paper it is argued that the reform of the Fiscus Judaicus by the emperor Nerva in 96 CE was of the highest importance in this context. This reform very probably led to a new, religious, definition of “Jew” in contrast to the initially ethnic definition as used by Vespasian when he introduced the tax. It is argued that the term “Jewish Christian” quickly loses its relevance when used for the historical situation after 96 CE. As a consequence of Nerva’s reform of the Fiscus Judaicus, some or many Jewish Christians lost their “Jewishness” and “became” Christians, sharing the same (il)legal status as their non-Jewish Christian brothers and sisters. Examples of this category are, e.g., the writers and Jewish Christian audiences of the Letter to the Hebrews, the Book of Revelation and the Fourth Gospel.
There were others, better referred to as Jesus-believing Jews, who remained fully faithful to the “customs of their forefathers” and who were considered to be Jews by the Romans. Examples of this category are very likely the Ebionites and the Nazoraeans. The term “Christian” should probably not be used in relation to them.
|
A Word Returning: The Word of God in Isaiah 55
Program Unit: Theological Interpretation of Scripture
Katie M. Heffelfinger, Church of Ireland Theological Institute
As many have noted, Second Isaiah makes reference to the word of God in its opening and closing chapters. But Second Isaiah's focus on the divine word goes beyond these occurrences and appears in the very fabric of the poetry. In many ways Second Isaiah presents its hearer with an encounter with the speaking voice of the LORD through the dominance of the divine voice. For the Christian reader this encounter with the divine speaking voice, particularly as articulated in Isaiah 55, finds resonance with John's Gospel's metaphor of Jesus as the Word made flesh. This paper will investigate the ways in which the imagistic poetry of Isaiah 55, read in conversation with John's Gospel, might spark Christian imagination about the nature of the encounter with God offered by the Word, and how that encounter might shape human response.
|
The Divorce Saying in Q 16:18: What Does It Tell Us about Q’s View of the Torah?
Program Unit: Q
Christoph Heil, Universität Graz, Austria
According to a large consensus today, Q is a Jewish-Christian document which presupposes and affirms the Torah (Q 4:1-13; 11:42; 16:17). All debates in Q are inner-Jewish and "intra muros"; the opponents are characterized as those "who do lawlessness" (Q 13:27). However, Q demands its addressees to do what Jesus says (Q 6:46); his sayings must be heard and acted on in order to survive the coming judgment (Q 6:47-49). This definitive teaching of Jesus does not repeat usual contemporary interpretations of the Torah, but is highly original and even offensive for other Jewish Torah interpreters like the Pharisees. Therefore, although the general Jewishness of Q must be acknowledged, it must be asked which kind of Judaism is represented in the Sayings Gospel. As a test case, this paper investigates the saying on divorce in Q 16:18. It will be argued that this saying is a new prophetic instruction on the basis of the original marital unity at the beginning of creation (compare Mal 2:14-16). Thus, Q 16:18 fits well into Jesus' preaching of the kingdom of God which means a renewal of the original order of creation. As an eschatological, Moses-like prophet Jesus interprets the will of the universal, fatherly and merciful creator and judge of the world. Such a hermeneutic of the Torah is hardly paralleled in the Jewish contexts of Q and puts the Sayings Gospel at the margins of ancient Judaism which certainly had no lack of marginal groups.
|
The Call to Right Relationship with ‘Beatrice’ in Men’s Life and Catholic Preaching
Program Unit: Academy of Homiletics
Gregory J. Heille, Aquinas Institute of Theology
*
|
Solving the Riddle of 'Amon: Wordplay in Proverbs 8:30
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Knut M. Heim, The Queen's Foundation; The Methodist Church
The enigmatic word ’amon in Proverbs 8:30, which in English translation reads: “then I was beside him, ’amon; and I was daily his delight, rejoicing before him always,” has received three interpretations, from earliest times to the present: (1) artisan; (2) constant(ly), faithful(ly); (3) little child. Three of the most recent articles dedicated to the puzzle—by Hurowitz (1999), Weeks (2006), and Lenzi (2006)—continue this trend. Weeks argues convincingly that the most plausible meaning for ’amon is “faithfully.” Hurowitz and Lenzi argue that wordplay is involved, suggesting several meanings. Despite their methodological agreement, however, they still come to different conclusions. Hurowitz convincingly opts for the meaning “nursling” as the only valid primary meaning, allowing for the “slight” possibility of “legitimate secondary meanings, on the level of intentional word plays and double entendres.” By contrast, Lenzi argues convincingly that the word is an Akkadian loanword with a secondary meaning “growing up” and a primary meaning “master, craftsman, scholar, mediator of knowledge.” – In this paper I will present some new insights into the value and purpose of ambiguity in Hebrew poetry and outline some new perspectives on the phenomenon of wordplays. I hope to demonstrate that all three scholars are partly correct. All three meanings are intended primary readings of ’amon. But none of the three meanings is the only primary meaning. Rather, the combination of polysemous and multi-lingual wordplay creates a kaleidoscope of meanings, all of which together enhance Wisdom’s uniquely powerful role in, at, and beyond creation.
|
Bible—Just Asking Questions
Program Unit:
Christine Helmer, Northwestern University
*
|
A Word to the Whites: The Implications of Racial Identity Development Theory for Preaching about Racism in White Congregations
Program Unit: Academy of Homiletics
Carolyn Browning Helsel, Emory University
*
|
Hugh Nibley and Attestations of Missing Traditions: The Lost 40 Days
Program Unit: Latter-day Saints and the Bible
Laurence Hemming, Lancaster University
In 1966 Hugh Nibley published an article enquiring into the meaning of the tradition of the forty day period between the Resurrecton and Ascension of the Lord, whose meaning he identifies as having been lost in mainstream Christianity.
The article vibrates with the depth and breadth of scholarship that are the hallmark of his work. The argument is buttressed with cast-iron scholarship, however much many contemporary scholar may wish to pull it apart. What matters in the 40 days was both what was taught and what was done, and the meaning of it, because it belonged to the most secret of the unwritten record of Christ, was subsequently lost.
There are several cycles of forty days in Catholic practice, all based on scriptural events, which seem unknown to Nibley, but reinforce his observations. Lent was the (late) devotional parallel rather than the origin for these cycles: all of them have as their focus the Temple, as Nibley might have predicted.
Nibley brings to the fore in a magisterial way an important aspect of biblical interpretation that is nevertheless foundational to the way Latter Day Saints interpret scripture, and so available to him because of the tradition in which he stands: scripture does not contain the key to its own interpretation. A theology of continual revelation is required to understand it. Catholics may differ from Latter Day Saints in some of the particulars of that theology, but Nibley indicates in important ways how that difference is perhaps less great than is commonly supposed.
|
The Social Matrix that Gave Rise to the Hebrew Bible and the Scrolls
Program Unit: Orality, Textuality, and the Formation of the Hebrew Bible
Charlotte Hempel, University of Birmingham
A fruitful area of investigation in recent scholarship is the light the Scrolls can shed on the processes of ancient Jewish literary activity. A fascinating next step in tracing the significance of the Qumran Scrolls more broadly is the much discussed issue of the social background of the material. The Scrolls testify to a learned group of Jews engaged in composing, shaping and collecting a very large amount of literature. We know that there were similarly learned Jews engaged in shaping and collecting and editing another very large amount of literature: the emerging Hebrew Bible. Since both social spheres share a considerable amount of overlapping material the connections between both become even more tangible. Bearing in mind that literacy, and especially learning at the level required to deal with the material at issue here, was the preserve of a small elite in the Second Temple Period, it is likely that the same limited stratum of highly educated scribes is the pool responsible for the Hebrew Bible and the corpus of the Scrolls. This paper will probe the relationship between the circles behind the emerging Hebrew Scriptures further by means of a comparative discussion of Joshua 1:8, Psalm 1:2 and 1QS 6:6-7.
|
What is Old? What is New? A Reconsideration of Garments and Wineskins
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Suzanne Watts Henderson, Queens University
Interpreters often read Mark 2:21-22 as an eschatological pronouncement that emphasizes the incompatibility of the “new” messianic age Jesus inaugurates with the “old” structures of Judaism, including Jewish law, which it supplants. But the broader context of Mark 2:1-3:6 is more nuanced. There, religious authorities challenge Jesus’ Torah observance on such central matters as the oneness of God, eating habits, and Sabbath observance; rather than setting the law aside, though, Jesus reinterprets Torah in light of God’s impinging reign upon the earth.
In this paper, I wish to explore Jesus’ reinterpretation of the law throughout Mark 2:1-3:6, a collection of Markan and pre-Markan stories that depict Jesus’ authority against the backdrop of escalating conflict with other interpreters of Torah. Of particular interest will be the two “Son of Humanity” pronouncements (Mark 2:10, 28), which may imply that Jesus as “new Adam” wields prototypical authority available, by extension, to those aligned with his kingdom purposes. At a minimum, he assesses Torah observance according to its impact on others, thus emphasizing the scriptures’ own ethical contours. Read in this light, the “old” of Mark 2:21-22 pertains not so much to Jewish law itself as to its use by others. When it functions as restrictive religious code, Torah cannot contain God’s life-giving redemption unleashed on the world. But when it functions “for humankind” (Mark 2:27), Torah serves as staging ground for the “new thing” at work through Jesus and those whom he has called.
|
In Sickness and in Health: Ancient ‘Rituals of Truth’ in the Greco-Roman World and Early Christianity
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Meghan R Henning, Emory University
On the one hand, the New Testament is filled with dramatic scenes of healing in which the sick are rescued from demonic forces (Jesus’ healing miracles in the Gospels), aligning sickness and disability with evil. On the other hand, the violent death of Jesus becomes a rallying point for early Christians, elevating the weak body as a source of identity and power (the passion narrative in the Gospels, Pauline Christianity, 1Peter). This paper examines ancient attitudes towards illness and disability as a means of understanding the opposing attitudes represented in early Christian literature.
As a point of departure, this work will begin with Michel Foucault’s concept of “rituals of truth,” that are constructed through specific discursive practices. Next, this paper will look at two bodies of evidence in order to sketch the discursive practice of illness in antiquity: 1) the testimonies of the “sick” and 2) the observations of ancient physicians. The primary sources available for reconstructing the experiences of the “sick” are two catalogues of inscriptions from the Asklepion at Epidauros and the Asklepion at Athens (ancient sites of healing dedicated to the god Asclepius), photos from the Asklepion at Pergamon and the Pergamon museum (which I have visited in modern day Bergama, Turkey), and the personal tale of the healings of Aulius Aristides preserved in his Sacred Tales. The sources for reconstructing the ancient perspectives of the “well” toward healing include Hippolytus and Galen. Finally, I will consider the manner in which New Testament attitudes toward illness/disability participate in these ancient “rituals of truth” surrounding sickness and healing. In particular this paper will focus on 1Peter as a test case.
|
Buried Dead or Alive: Were Children in Ancient Israel Considered People?
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Kristine Henriksen Garroway, Hebrew Union College - Jewish Institute of Religion
Recently, scholars of ancient Israel have started to look for children in the historical record. This paper follows that lead and examines the archaeological evidence from 100 Middle Bronze Age II (1900-1550 BCE) child burials located in 36 sites throughout ancient Israel. The data both identifies children in the historical record, and then interprets the data to further the process of illuminating how children fit into the history of ancient Israel. I begin the paper by discussing how to define a child in burial contexts through the use of social-age versus chronological age categories. Then I focus on what the burial method, burial location, and burial goods can tell us about the gender and social persona of children in ancient Israel. As will be seen, the burial data suggests a divide in child burials: those buried like an adult, and those buried differently from an adult. I conclude the paper by suggesting that a correlation exists between age, burial style, and perceived membership in MB II ancient Israelite society.
|
Bound and Free: Patterns of Conversion and Conduct in the Theology of the Syriac Text of the Acts of Thomas
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Jonathan K. Henry, University of Pennsylvania
As A.F.J. Klijn and Han J.W. Drijvers argued, the Acts of Thomas is to be located within Syriac Christian theology. The current study supports this argument, and offers greater refinement to understandings about the theology of the Acts of Thomas in its Syrian setting. This is primarily done by compiling and describing repeated or clustered terms in the Syriac text (with reference to other text bases). The essay studies contrasting images of bondage and freedom, which are used to describe the volitional capacities of God, demonic beings, and humans. Freedom of will is an inherent quality of humanity imparted by the freedom of God. Bondage explains the problem of evil in the cosmos, including the troubling behavior of other humans. Subjection can be due to a creature’s nature; but in the case of humanity, bondage of the will is due to deception by Satan and blind slavery to base behavior. The highest goal for the human will is to perform the will of God. These themes are found both in small units of narrative and discourse, as well as in the overarching framework of the story (e.g. Thomas’ paradoxical status as a free slave whose goal is to accomplish the will of God). With due caution against anachronism, attention is paid to a sampling of major Syriac theologians of Late Antiquity, who serve as a sounding board for the findings synthesized from the Acts of Thomas (some materials are presented in English for the first time). Secondary attention is paid to ways in which the Acts of Thomas, seen in the light of the findings of this study, might interface or conflict with Manichaean teachings.
|
Qumran Wisdom, Post-Qumran Apocalyptic: The Book of Mysteries, 4 Ezra, and 2 Baruch
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Matthias Henze, Rice University
While the twin sister apocalypses, 4 Ezra and 2 Baruch, were written after the Qumran community was destroyed, there are still numerous points of connections between them and the Qumran material. One of these connections concerns the nature and function of Wisdom in an apocalyptic context. This paper has two aims: first, it compares the complex interrelationship of Wisdom and Apocalypticism in three texts, the Book of Mysteries, 4 Ezra and 2 Baruch; and second, it argues that, instead of assuming a linear development from Wisdom to Apocalypticism, these three texts suggest a reciprocal influence of sapiential and eschatological thought at Qumran and beyond.
|
Invoking the Spirit and Narrative Intent in John's Apocalypse
Program Unit: Society for Pentecostal Studies
Ronald Herms, Northwest University (Washington)
*
|
Andrew of Caesarea and His Reading of the Apocalypse
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
Juan Hernandez Jr., Bethel University
Andrew of Caesarea’s seventh century commentary on the Apocalypse offers an unparalleled opportunity for the exploration of early Byzantine interpretive practices. Historians of early Christianity, textual critics and biblical exegetes stand to gain considerable knowledge and insight about their own discipline from an examination of Andrew’s commentary, as his work traverses a variety of scholarly terrains. This paper will examine Andrew’s reading of the book of Revelation, paying particular attention to the texts Andrew has at his disposal, as well as to the reading strategies deployed in his appropriation of those texts. At bottom, Andrew’s reading of Revelation performs catechetic and paranetic functions for his seventh century readers, offering a "Chalcedonian alternative" to Oecumenius’ sixth century commentary and encouragement to the faithful. Andrew’s reading also challenges popular notions about what the Apocalypse may or may not mean.
|
Language and Thoughts of the Pastoral Epistles in Light of the Papyri
Program Unit: Papyrology and Early Christian Backgrounds
Jens Herzer, University of Leipzig
Both the language and the theological ideas of the Pastorals are considered to be different from the genuine Pauline Letters to his congregations. As letters to individuals, the Pastorals’ genres have parallels in Greek papyri. Moreover, as documents of the common all-day culture of Jews and Gentiles the papyri allow interesting and sometimes surprising insights in many aspects of letters like the Pastorals. The paper will compare the Pastorals with Greek papyri by particularly focusing on issues of economy and administration, but also on characteristic key terms such as pistis/pistos, hygies and others.
|
The Role of the Shephelah and the Beer-sheba Valley in the Formation of State in Judah
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Ze'ev Herzog, Tel Aviv University
The large-scale regional research of the Beer-sheba Valley provides rich archaeological evidence that inform us on the cultural and political processes during the 10th and 9th centuries BCE. Comparative data from excavated and well stratified sites presents a distinctive archaeological picture of the two IAIIA sub-phases. Early IAIIA is characterized by unfortified civilian settlements, mainly of the ‘enclosed settlement’ type (Arad XII, Beer-sheba VII, Tel Masos II-I, Lachish V, and the Negev Highland settlements). In contrast, the Late IAIIA saw the erection of fortified cities and fortresses (Arad XI, Beer-sheba V-IV, Lachish IV). Despite the evident continuity in ceramic shapes we observed specific typological features of each sub-phase. We dated the Early IAIIA to the second half of the 10th century BCE, and the Late IAIIA to the 9th (and possibly early 8th) century BCE.
In contrast to prevailing common opinion, the process of state formation in Judah was not centered in the Highlands of southern Palestine, in the Hebron and Jerusalem area, as portrayed in the biblical tradition. While the sites of the hilly region present very poor evidence of occupation and social complexity in the IAIIA, the archaeological manifestations of centralized authority is uncovered in the low hills of the Shephelah and in the Beer-sheba Valley. The administrative centers exposed in Late Iron Age IIA at Lachish, Tel Beer-sheba and Arad provide sound testimony for the emergence of a managerial elite that was capable of undertaking such large-scale projects as erecting planned cities and fortresses, constructing fortification systems and hewing water reservoirs. The heart of the emerging monarchy in Judah should be relocated from the hill country to the lower land regions. The central role of Jrusalem was achieved only in the 8th century BCE.
|
Bezalel in Context
Program Unit: Hebrew Scriptures and Cognate Literature
Richard S. Hess, Denver Seminary
Bezalel has been compared with Kothar in the Baal Cycle as one who was appointed by the deity to build his temple. The purpose of this paper will be to investigate this comparison and to observe possible reasons for the similarities as well as differences. In doing so, consideration will be given to the temple building accounts of Bronze and Iron Age West Semitic literature, the priestly traditions and purposes of the biblical literature, the immediate literary contexts of the Baal Cycle and Exodus, and the larger issues of comparisons within the West Semitic world of the Bronze and Iron Ages. It will be argued that the distinctive nature and purpose of the accounts in Exodus and in Ugaritic literature had refashioned any West Semitic literary tradition naming a builder/architect in the construction of the central holy place.
|
With Veiled Head: Sacrifice and Roman Power
Program Unit: Sacrifice, Cult, and Atonement
George Heyman, St. Bernard's School of Theology and Ministry
Wherever Roman sacrificial practices are depicted, the officiant is easily distinguished by the veil covering their head. This paper looks at the imagery of “veiling” in the Roman world and the iconography of a veiled Roman Emperor engaged in sacrifice as a mode of discursive social power. I propose that religious discourse is more than a collection of words or an extended soliloquy; it is a means that generates and constitutes social identity through the exercise of power. This paper understands “sacrifice,” not in the limited ritualistic manner of atonement or expiation, but as a social discourse used throughout the Graeco-Roman world to establish identity as well as political and social control. From numerous coins issued by imperial households to the ornate Ara Pacis, the altar to Augustan Peace, the veiled members of the Imperial family, as sacrificial overseers, position themselves and their family in a procession between heaven and earth. The Emperor, as pater patria and priestly officiant signaled a political resolve to maintain the fragile balance of power between the gods, the state, and the masses. The veil of sacrifice, so prominent in Roman iconography, was a symbol of power and control. It rhetorically and visually positioned the Emperor as the intermediary linking life and death between the gods and the people of the Roman world.
|
Breaking an Eternal Covenant: Isaiah 24 and Persian Period Discourse about the Covenant
Program Unit: Covenant in the Persian Period
J. Todd Hibbard, University of Tennessee at Chattanooga
The ???? ???? Isa 24:5 is one of 16 references to an “eternal covenant” in the Hebrew
Bible, and most scholars presume the Isaiah reference is one of the later texts to speak of
this covenant. Because the reference in Isa 24 is ambiguous and opaque, previous studies
have attempted to identify which of the earlier covenantal references is in view in the
Isaiah passage. Most scholars have focused on three primary possibilities: the Noachic
covenant of Gen 9; the P covenant; and the Mosaic covenant (or some combination of
these). What is generally not explored is the relationship of the Isa 24 reference to a ????
???? to the other two such references in the book of Isaiah, namely Isa 55:3 and 61:8.
This study seeks to clarify the association between these texts by asking two related
questions: 1) What is the relationship between these inner-Isaianic references to a ????
???? and 2) What contribution does Isa 24:5 make to the Isaianic and Persian period
discourse about covenant?
|
Rewritten Gentiles: Joseph and Aseneth and the Greek Bible
Program Unit: Greek Bible
Jill Hicks-Keeton, Duke University
As Susan Docherty has shown, the Hellenistic Jewish narrative Joseph and Aseneth is much more dependent on the Genesis story than many scholars have recognized, and moreover, it is widely acknowledged that Joseph and Aseneth shows great familiarity with the Septuagint. This paper argues that this imaginative retelling of Joseph’s story borrows, reinterprets, and transforms Septuagintal language and themes – particularly those concerning life and living – in order to promote a fundamentally optimistic outlook toward the conversion of Gentiles to the God of Israel. The paper demonstrates the significance of Joseph and Aseneth’s interpretation of the Septuagint in three related moves: (1) We shall see that narrative employs Greek vocabulary from Genesis (LXX) in order to characterize the God of Israel as the creator of all life and the re-creator of Aseneth; (2) Through a comparison of Joseph and Aseneth’s use of the epithet “the living God” with its usage in the Additions to Esther, Daniel (LXX), Bel and the Dragon, and 3 Maccabees, we shall see that Joseph and Aseneth transforms its Septuagintal context of idol polemic in order to re-imagine the possibilities for the relationship between the God of Israel and Gentiles; (3) Through a comparison of the zoe language in Joseph and Aseneth with that of Genesis (LXX), we shall see that the former takes up the Genesis Joseph cycle’s picture of Israel’s God facilitating life for Gentiles and develops it further by characterizing life as spiritual and eternal rather than merely physical. Thus, my claim is that Joseph and Aseneth’s (re)interpretation of the language of “life” and “living” in these Septuagintal intertexts is an essential part of the narrative’s portrayal of the God of Israel as the living God who created all and who can therefore give life to all, including Gentiles.
|
Of City Brides and ’aqi Wives: Gender Bending, Gendercide, and Revelation’s New Jerusalem in the Spanish Conquest of California
Program Unit: LGBTI/Queer Hermeneutics
Jacqueline M. Hidalgo, Williams College
In late eighteenth-century California, Spanish Franciscans built missions modeled on Revelation’s New Jerusalem, employing imagery from the text in the architectural structure of the missions while striving to create isolated, utopian communities of friars and Amerindians. The tragic consequences of these mission projects included near genocide of the indigenous populations, attempted cultural genocide, and attempted “gendercide.” Several indigenous Californian peoples held a third gender category, identified in Ventureno Chumash as ’aqi. The Franciscan writings about California frequently included a meditation on stories of these third gender peoples, especially when they were discovered to be wives of men, while also praying for their extermination. Third gender peoples were prohibited from the missions, brutalized if found in the missions, and only admitted to mission life if they were willing to change their gender identities.
This paper takes up a conversation between the Franciscan interest in, and fear of, third gender peoples, the Franciscans’ own gender bending performances that undergirded their religious authority, and the gender bending imagery that underlies Revelation’s representation of the New Jerusalem as a bride. Why were the Franciscans both fascinated and disturbed by the third gender peoples of California? How was gender play invoked in authorizing Franciscan power, and how did this play inform their interpretive attempts to enact the New Jerusalem in the space of California? How does Revelation’s own gender bending imagery inform and defy these Franciscan imaginations of peoples and place? What challenges to Franciscan normative interpretation and performance did third gender Californians pose, and what fissures in scripturalized performance did their existence in or near the missions reveal? How might studying these Franciscans’ gendered utopianizing help us rethink other readings and appropriations of Revelation’s New Jerusalem?
|
Sectarianism, Pluralism, and the Controversy over Marriage Laws between the Houses of Shammai and Hillel
Program Unit: History and Literature of Early Rabbinic Judaism
Richard Hidary, Yeshiva University
This paper will analyze Tannaitic and Amoraic sources relating to the law of the daughter’s cowife in a levirate marriage that was a source of great controversy between the Houses of Shammai and Hillel. This controversy, involving the interpretation of Deut 25:5-10 and how it interacts with the laws of incest, had the potential to split the two major schools of thought within the Pharisaic movement into two sects. Similar issues, which caused members of one group to be considered illegitimate for marriage according to the other, were in fact catalysts for Second Temple sectarianism. M. Yev. 1:4, however, makes the extraordinary statement that the Houses continued to marry each other despite their legal differences. While the House of Shammai was no longer operative during the Amoraic period, the rabbis continued to analyze this controversy as the prototype for how to deal with pluralism versus legal truth in general. By tracing the discussion about this issue from Tannaitic through Amoraic times in both Palestine and Babylonia, we can gain important insight into how the rabbinic movement managed internal dispute and what their vision was for an ideal rabbinic polity. While the Tannaitic sources reflect the greatest tolerance for halakhic diversity, the Palestinian Talmud takes a sharp turn towards monism. The Babylonian Talmud, in turn, returns to a more tolerant stance. The Tannaitic sources, which in their original context aimed to combat the threat of sectarian division, became the focal point for the Amoraic discussion about how to maintain a balance between tolerance and uniformity. The paper will end by offering explanations of the different attitudes reflected in the two Talmuds based on their geographic and cultural contexts.
|
The Rationale for the Society of Biblical Literature Commentary on the Septuagint
Program Unit: Greek Bible
Robert J. V. Hiebert, Trinity Western University / GSTS
Recent discussions in Septuagint scholarship have highlighted the distinction between the meaning of a text at its point of inception, or the text as produced, and its reception history, or the text as received. The forthcoming Society of Biblical Literature Commentary on the Septuagint (SBLCS) will seek to elucidate the meaning of the Old Greek version of the Jewish Scriptures at the original, constitutive phase of its existence. This paper will provide an overview of the principles upon which the SBLCS series is based.
|
NAPH: Hebrew Grammars
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Theodore Hiebert, McCormick Theological Seminary
Member of a Panel discussing A Basic Introduction to Biblical Hebrew by Jo Ann Hackett.
|
The KJV Apocrypha: When and How Lost?
Program Unit:
Andrew Hill, Wheaton College (Illinois)
*
|
Skeat’s Thesis, Not Dead Yet? On the Making of P4, P64, and P67
Program Unit: Papyrology and Early Christian Backgrounds
Charles E. Hill, Reformed Theological Seminary
This paper will offer a new proposal about the original codicological setting of the fragments P4, P64, and P67. It is generally agreed that all three sets of fragments come from the same scribe and that P64 and P67 are from the same codex of Matthew. Peter Head and Scott Charlesworth have each challenged Skeat’s 1999 thesis that these fragments came from a single-quire codex which originally contained all four Gospels. Head has shown that Skeat’s argument from the allegedly decreasing number of letters per column was flawed and invalid. Charlesworth has shown that the fibre orientation of the fragments rules out a single quire codex. This paper will challenge, however, Charlesworth’s further inference, that Matthew and Luke could not have been contained in the same codex. It will argue that P4 (Luke) almost certainly came from a multiple Gospel codex. It hopes to demonstrate, in a way consistent with Charlesworth’s argument that a regular page (fibre) orientation characterized this scribe’s careful work, how the scribe might have produced a multiple quire codex containing multiple Gospels.
|
Yes Context, But How? Responding to the Implications of Relevance Theory
Program Unit: Bible Translation
Harriet Hill, SIL International
Relevance theory has demonstrated the need to assure that audiences have access to the intended context as well as the translated text for effective communication of Scripture. It has also provided conceptual tools to help us see what is happening in what we formerly thought of as 'the black box of implicit information.' These developments open new horizons of uncharted waters for the Bible translation endeavor. In this paper, I look at the implications of the importance of context for current translation practice as I laid out in my 2006 book, "Bible at Cultural Crossroads: from Translation to Communication". I examine developments in this area over the past 5 years. I then identify areas needing further work to respond adequately to the implications of Relevance Theory.
|
Israel as the Church or Israel as Israel? Romans 9:1–5 in the Römerbrief and Church Dogmatics II/2
Program Unit: Karl Barth Society of North America
Wesley Hill, Durham University
*
|
The Bible in the Marriage Liturgical Form: A Legitimization of Violence and a Diminishment of the Human Dignity of the Wife?
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Cornelia Hoffman, University of Stellenbosch
It will be argued that the marriage liturgical form used by centuries by the Anglican church and other similar marriage liturgical forms has contributed to a legitimatization of violence in many marriages and consequently devalued the dignity of countless wives the past three centuries. Focus is given to the egalitarian roles for husbands and wives advocated by Paul in 1 Corinthians 7. Special mention is made of the context of South Africa, encompassing a bold and futuristic constitution which is founded on human dignity, the promotion of equality and the abhorrence of discrimination. South Africa has a particular high percentage of domestic abuse and it is argued that the hierarchal and patriarchal perspectives advocated by some religious leaders based on Biblical texts and endorsed in the marriage forms contributes to this abuse. In conclusion an earnest call is made for the review of most of the marriage liturgical forms still used by the mainline churches today.
|
"Like Summer's Gatherings, Like Vintage Gleanings" (Mi 7:1): Micah 7 and the Composition of the Book of Micah
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Yair Hoffman, Tel Aviv University
The paper aims at substantiating the following (rather odd, perhaps) dictum: 'The "summer's gatherings" metaphor is an interpretive clue to solving some literary, thematic and compositional riddles of Micah 7 and the entire Book.' Micah 7 is a problematic chapter. The logical sequence of its various motifs is loose and unclear; the speaker's and the addressee's interchange between singular and plural; they are referred to sometimes as male and sometimes as female, and the speaker refers to them as enemies, yet sometimes he favors them. The lack of correlation between these features disables delineating sensible homogeneous sub-units. And indeed scholars are disputed over nearly every issue within the chapter: Is it a prophecy or a psalm? Is it one literary unit? If not – how many units are there? Is Micah the author of the whole chapter or of some parts of it? How does the chapter fit into the overall structure of the book? In 1924, Gunkel suggested that vv. 1-6 is a prophecy while vv. 7-20 is an independent liturgical psalm, and since then many scholars adhere to this view. However, it doesn't solve the problems and raises further difficulties. I suggest that Chapter 7 has been intentionally designed to be an independent collage functioning as an epilogue to the Book of Micah. It is a psalm consisted of two elements: (a) Four pre-existed psalm and prophetic units and (b) Two psalm and prophetic sayings composed by the author/editor. This epilogue mirrors the literary character of the Book of Micah as a pannier of "gatherings." It also sheds light on some main topics in the book and thus becomes its first 'commentary'.
|
Teaching the Hebrew Prophets in a Service-Integrated Course
Program Unit: Teaching Biblical Studies in an Undergraduate Liberal Arts Context
Karina Martin Hogan, Fordham University
This paper describes the outcomes of a course on the Hebrew Prophets that I taught in the fall of 2009, incorporating reflection on direct experience of working with marginalized groups. Each student was required to spend two to three hours a week volunteering at one of three service agencies in the neighborhood: an afterschool tutoring program for economically disadvantaged children, a senior center offering activities and services to seniors living in a housing project, and an agency that provides meals and nutritional education to people living with HIV/AIDS. I chose these agencies with the prophetic emphasis on care for the marginalized in mind, but the students’ actual experiences of service enabled them to relate personally to the prophets in ways I hadn’t anticipated. Every writing assignment and class discussion included some form of reflection on the service experience, so the learning in this course was very student-directed.
In essays written near the beginning of the semester, some students identified with the reluctance and divided loyalties felt by many of the prophets. Many reported inner conflicts associated with a growing awareness of their own privileges and responsibilities relative to the people they were working with. In later essays, students demonstrated personal growth, observing that studying the prophets had helped them to put their objections to performing menial tasks in perspective and to focus on the human connections they were making. By the end of the semester, students were able to identify themes in the prophets that relate to current issues of social justice and to make connections between the history of ancient Israel and contemporary events. Many also demonstrated civic learning, by expressing a commitment to ongoing community service, and in some cases by continuing with their service placement after the course was over.
|
The Astronomical Diaries and Sennacherib’s Selective Demolition of Babylon
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Steven W. Holloway, American Theological Library Association
The data recorded in the astronomical diaries were highly stable across an attested seven centuries. From internal evidence as well as the statement in Ptolemy’s Almagest, the “institution” of the recording of celestial phenomena in this fashion was begun with the accession of the Babylonian king Nabû-na?ir in 746/745. During this tumultuous period, Babylonia was ruled by various native dynasties, Assyrians, Achaemenid Persians, Hellenized Macedonians, and Parthians. Apocalyptic images of Babylon’s destruction figure openly in Sennacherib’s inscriptions and are echoed by subsequent rulers, yet the transmission history of the astronomical diaries, issues of precise compositional provenance notwithstanding, force us to reevaluate the relationship of hostile military action to the preservation of major Mesopotamian city temple archives.
|
The Children in the Marketplace (Q 7:32): Tradition-Historical Aspects of Childhood in Ancient Hellenistic and Jewish Traditions
Program Unit: Q
Michael Hölscher, Institute of New Testament Studies
For a better understanding of the original parable of the children in the marketplace (Q 7:31-32), a look at ancient child culture can be helpful. Whereas in the history of research scholars often discussed actantial models (How many groups of children? Who calls to whom?), this paper analyzes a new aspect of the tradition-historical background especially of the verse Q 7:32. The paper elaborates on two different concepts of childhood: (1) a Hellenistic one on the one hand and (2) an ancient Jewish one on the other hand. (ad 1) The Hellenistic phenomenon, which will be examined, is the so called "discovery of childhood". In ancient Greek tradition, the specific childlike character of children was not acknowledged, but in early Hellenistic times there is literary and artistic evidence of a changing attitude: The body and the inner nature of children were associated with a new quality. (ad 2) The Jewish background, which will be presented, is described by Rüdiger Lux (Leipzig) in his article "The Children in the Lane. A Motif of Childhood in Prophetic Speeches of Judgment and Salvation". Especially its aspect of salvation can be regarded as the Jewish backdrop against which the verse Q 7:32 can be understood. Furthermore, in each of these two traditions texts can be found which bear a striking resemblance to the parable of the children in the marketplace (Q 7:32): On the one hand Callimachus' first epigram with its combination of children sitting in a public place, playing and giving advice and on the other hand Zechariah 8:4-5 that combines the aspects of children who reassemble in public places and play. We see: The parable is open to interpretation for two different target audiences. This implicates new facets of an interpretation of the parable Q 7:31-32 (31-35).
|
"Never Did Adam Escape the Hands of God": Irenaeus' Vision of Genesis 2:7
Program Unit: Christian Theology and the Bible
Thomas Holsinger-Friesen, Spring Arbor University
In Adversus Haereses, Irenaeus is renowned for formulating points of doctrine (e.g., “recapitulation” and the regula veritatis) that would be of great import in the development of early Christian thought. Yet his contribution to theological hermeneutics is no less significant. Given that Irenaeus and his “Gnostic” opponents shared a strong interest in origins, the Genesis creation texts served as a crucial battleground. In particular, Irenaeus found the Genesis 2:7 “breath of life” text to be conducive for exceptionally wide typological readings. In order to contradict a Valentinian anthropology appealing to 1 Corinthians 15:50, Irenaeus mines theological riches from Genesis 2.7. The images of God’s formation of the human body from dust and that of his inbreathing the breath of life enable Irenaeus (or so he claims) to interpret a broader range of texts: prophetic, apostolic, and gospel. In so doing, Irenaeus models an innovative hermeneutic of Scripture that is painstakingly christocentric, while showing remarkable flexibility and interpretative freedom. By means of focal texts like Genesis 2:7, he casts an expansive, unique vision of God and prepares the way for an anti-Platonist Christian anthropology. For Irenaeus, the purposeful work of the Father, through his two hands (Son and Spirit), will present the human creation as fully alive – in body no less than soul.
|
Hearing Cases and Establishing Facts: Comparative Perspectives on the Legal Nuances of Hebrew Words
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Shalom E. Holtz, Yeshiva University
Recent scholarship has demonstrated the importance of Akkadian documents of legal practice, especially from the Neo-Babylonian corpus, in reconstructing trial procedure in the Hebrew Bible. These extra-biblical texts shed important light on biblical lawsuits between humans, as well as
on litigation between God and people. This paper will demonstrate that the comparisons extend beyond procedure into the very terminology of the courtroom. The forensic interpretation of common Hebrew words, such as the verbal root š-m-' ("to hear") and the adjective nakôn ("established"), can be supported by comparison with equivalent legal terminology attested in Neo-Babylonian trial documents.
|
Four Righteous Gentiles—Not Four (Five) Women—in Matthew's Genealogy of Jesus
Program Unit: Matthew
Jason B. Hood, Christ United Methodist Church
This paper articulates an overlooked and underdeveloped approach to the anomalous characters in Matthew's genealogy of Jesus (1:3–6). Gender-centric interpretations have been popular throughout church history: the four characters, with Mary sometimes included, have been labeled sinners, “irregular” in reproduction or relationships, or Gentiles. A consensus has not been established, and a number of scholars now propose that a unified interpretation for the four (five) women is not possible (R. T. France [2007; 36-38]; Talvikki Mattila; John Nolland; J. P. Heil; Schnider and Stenger; Larry Lyke). Several scholars (including Amy-Jill Levine, Robert Gundry, and C. T. Davis) have proposed that Matthew intends for readers to take Uriah as a member of this group, rather than Bathsheba. The name of the former actually appears in Matthew 1, and the name of the latter does not. Moreover, like Tamar, Rahab and Ruth, Uriah is a moral rock star; and like those three women, he was not born a Jew. Thus, rather than four women, Matthew intends for readers to see four righteous, faithful non-Jews in the genealogy of Jesus. In picking up and advancing this interpretation, I point out weaknesses in the handful of previous studies where a similar approach has been taken. I conclude with comments on the significance of this interpretation for reading the whole of the Gospel. Other references to Gentiles in Matthew and the conclusion of the Gospel corroborate the present thesis. This paper constitutes a fresh approach to the study of the genealogy in Matthew 1, and also challenges the important work of David Sim, who sees Matthew as essentially Gentile-hostile.
|
Summaries of Israel's Story: Intertextual Pratice in an Overlooked Use of Scripture
Program Unit: Intertextuality in the New Testament
Jason B. Hood, Christ United Methodist Church
While other “uses of Scripture” such as citations, quotations, echoes and allusions have received a great deal of attention in recent decades, the discrete category of "story summaries" has been largely neglected. Although occasionally noted as a "use of Scripture" (as by Richard Hays and Joel Green in one recent overview), perhaps along the lines of a shorter version of Rewritten Bible (cf. Joachim Jeska, 2001), and on rare occasion noted as a form of intertextuality, methodological questions regarding this category of Scripture remain unasked and unanswered. This paper is an exploration of "summaries of Israel's story" (in the NT: Matthew 1:1-17, Mark 12:1-12 and parallels, Acts 7 and 13, Heb 11, Rev 12; cf. Neh 9, Jud 5, Pss 78, 105; etc.), a more focused category of story summary. Previous efforts to define and list such summaries will be canvassed, including the work of Ethelbert Stauffer, Howard Clark Kee, Joachim Jeska, and N. T. Wright. Methodological clarification for the identification of such summaries will be offered, followed by analysis of the intertextual practices most commonly associated with summaries. On the basis of this analysis, concluding reflections of the "test-case" variety will be offered on Matthew 1:1-17 as a "summary of Israel's story". A list of such summaries of Israel's story will be made available via handout.
|
Jesus' Disabled View of Cultic Rites of Affliction in an Ideal Community
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Renate Viveen Hood, University of Mary Hardin-Baylor
My paper will assess the cultic restrictions to worship, and the rites of afflictions associated with such prohibitions in the Law. These same rites of afflictions are the subject of my investigation in the New Testament. I posit that Jesus is portrayed as one who offers such rites, and proclaims a community, in which the disabled will realize an honorable status, based upon an altered spatial purity. Moreover, this ideal community would dispense with the social categorization of interpersonal and cultic relationships. With regard to methodology, disability, or “physical lack of wholeness” (Jerome Neyrey, Semeia, 1986), is principally studied within the context of biblical literature and ANE studies employing a functional perspective as in anthropology (e.g. Victor Turner’s approach in History of Religions, 1977). My research reflects a more Durkheimian approach, whilst considering the nature of societal organizations as espoused by Mary Douglas’s classic work, Purity and Danger. This paper will take the inquiry one step beyond Douglas’s basic categorization by proposing separate standards for interpersonal communal interactions and spatial purity in cultic rites as they pertain to the disabled. I will give examples from Mesopotamian texts with requirements for priests and diviners for physical perfection and from 1QSa2:3-10 listing various disabilities as conditions warranting exclusion from religious assembly. Hector Avalos (Healthcare and the Rise Christianity, 1999) was critiqued for considering the blind and the lame in Lev 21:18 impure. I deem this critique incorrect, siding with Saul Olyan (CBQ 1992) and viewing Lev 21:18 and Deut 23:2 as synecdoche.
|
Biblical Purity Laws in the Dead Sea Scrolls: Examining the Community Related to 4QMMT
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Jamal-Dominique Hopkins, Interdenominational Theological Center
The purpose of this paper is to examine purity regulations primarily in the sectarian Dead Sea text MiqSat Ma‘aWe Ha-Torah, also referred to as MMT, which correlates with and sheds some light on similar purity stipulations found among certain Hebrew Bible laws. Elisha Qimron and John Strugnell translate MiqSat Ma‘aWe Ha-Torah as ‘Some Works of the Law’ or ‘Some Precepts of the Law'. Lawrence Schiffman classifies the work as the ‘Halakhic Letter’. Regardless of the exact title, contention over certain legal stipulations is clearly outlined. In light of the correlations (with biblical material), this paper will also explore the variant ideological views concerning purification among late Second Temple period Jewish sectarian groups. MMT reflects some of the specific tensions that existed among the Jewish sects of the particular time; some of these tensions included: (1) The purity regulations for those dealing with the preparation of the heifer of the sin-offering ceremony (B 13-17), (2) Slaughtering animals outside the temple and the prohibition of bringing and using their bones and hides in Jerusalem (B 18-23), (3) The overall place where slaughtering animals was to take place (B 20-35), (4) The regulations concerning admission into the assembly and possibly the temple for the Ammonite, the Moabite, the bastard, and the one with mutilated genitalia (B 39-49), (5) The restriction of the blind and deaf from entering into the temple area (B 49-54), (6) The prohibition of dogs from entering Jerusalem (B 58-62), and (7) The prohibition of lepers from entering the holy place (B 64-72). Some of these stipulations will be examined here. Throughout this paper, MMT’s cultic matter will be examined not only alongside Hebrew Bible material, but also with other sectarian texts and rabbinic sources. Although rabbinic sources postdate MMT and the Qumran scrolls in general, seeming comparisons can be made concerning the variant views of late Second Temple period Jewish groups.
|
The Blessings of Ham in Biblical and Late Second Temple Literary Witnesses
Program Unit: African-American Biblical Hermeneutics
Jamal-Dominique Hopkins, Interdenominational Theological Center
In his 1987 Annual Charles B. Copher Lecture at the Interdenominational Theological Center, Copher, himself, explored the place of Black peoples in biblical and intertestamental literature. Investigating the ideology behind the curse of Canaan and the status of Ham, Copher suggested that both Pseudepigraphical and Qumran (Dead Sea Scrolls) writings lacked reference to Black people. In light of Copher's study, this paper will explore the transmission and recension history of Genesis 9:18-27, up to the early rabbinic period, with particular focus on the so-called curse of Ham. This curse, which is explicitly spelled out in early rabbinic literature beginning in the third century C.E. is unfounded. Considered by some to be linked to the Genesis 9 account, post-biblical Jewish accounts offer their interpretation as midrashic. This paper will explore pre-rabbinic traditions of the Genesis 9 account in order to determine the origins and agenda behind the rabbinic readings. Two such accounts that will be examined in particular are represented in Qumran and Pseudepigrapha literature in particular (i.e. 4Q252 - The Genesis Apocryphon and the book of Jubilees), which both reflect a late Second Temple Judaic tradition and witness and do, indeed, speak about the nature of Black people. Next this paper will map out the trajectory of whether/how rabbinic interpretations were appropriated by Christian apologists for the subjection or inferiority of dark-skinned peoples. With this in mind, this work is interested in re-writing mis-appropriated biblical readings that appear to be based on racial and ethnic hegemony.
|
Ephraem the Syrian on the Matriarch Sarah in the Light of Jewish and Christian Traditions
Program Unit: Syriac Literature and Interpretations of Sacred Texts
Cornelia B Horn, Saint Louis University
This paper offers a close study of Ephraem the Syrian’s interpretation of the figure of the biblical matriarch Sarah. Based on Ephraem’s poetry and prose commentaries on Scripture, one can show how the author was especially interested in casting Sarah into the roles of prophetess and caring mother. Very close is the relationship Ephraem discerned between Sarah and Mary, the mother of Jesus. For him, Sarah was a raza. She was a type of Mary, but she also functioned as a model for Mary. Ephraem’s Mariology was neither one-dimensional, nor one-directional, but dynamic.
This paper addresses the role of interpretative traditions of Sarah within Judaism in order to evaluate parallels to and contrasts with Ephraem’s interpretation of her character. The figure of the matriarch Sarah serves Ephraem as a model, both negative and positive, for every-day Jews and Christians. In Ephraem’s hand, Sarah’s character could advance the author’s anti-Jewish agenda. Yet perhaps more pronounced, one finds Ephraem highlighting Sarah’s exceptional prominence among biblical women, both from the Hebrew Bible and the New Testament.
|
Biblical and Apocryphal Intertexts in Greek and Syriac Shared btw. Early Arabic Poetry and the Qur'an
Program Unit: Syriac Literature and Interpretations of Sacred Texts
Cornelia B. Horn, Saint Louis University
This paper offers a discussion of selections from works of early Arabic poetry, concentrating primarily on the work of Umayya ibn Abi as-Salt. It identifies and evaluates the usage of potential intertexts from the realm of biblical (OT and NT) and apocryphal materials therein. Of particular relevance are Syriac and Greek versions of texts, for example the Protoevangelium of James, that either derive from Christian authors or that went through a distinct process of reception in the Christian realm. Some of the relevant texts also circulated in the milieu in which the Qur’an emerged, judging from the fact that the Qur’an displays familiarity with this material. This paper contributes to the discussion of the interrelationships between the Qur’an and Arabic literature that was contemporary to it. It suggests that instead of casting early Arabic poetry and the Qur’an into the straightjacket of direct mutual dependency, whichever direction that may have been, it is necessary at least to triangulate potential dependency relationships and consider the role of Jewish and/or Christian intertexts. Methodological considerations that are otherwise relevant for the discussion of Q and the Synoptic Problem in New Testament studies prove to be helpful in this regard.
|
Embodied Theology: Soma as Soteriological and Social Category in Paul
Program Unit: Pauline Theology
David Horrell, University of Exeter
Invited Paper
|
Rethinking How We Understand the Gospels as Historical Sources for Jesus-in-Context
Program Unit: John, Jesus, and History
Richard A. Horsley, University of Massachusetts Boston
A call for a serious change in the way we understand the Gospels as sources, one that includes John along with text-fragments from the Synoptics and non-canonical Gospels: For several years the John, Jesus, and History Group has been asking hard questions about the use and disuse of the Gospel of John for investigation/ construction of the historical Jesus, significantly broadening the continuing debates about what sources are to be used, how they are to and how. “Jesus-scholars” working from the different perspectives in these debates, however, have so far not taken into account recent research that is calling into question some of the most fundamental assumptions of the study of the Gospels and of Jesus. Literary criticism has shown that the Gospels are whole stories with plots and agendas, not mere containers of individual sayings and mini-stories. (Moreover, to have become a significant figure historically, Jesus must have communicated with people; but people do not communicate in individual sayings.) Leading text-critics are saying that because of the considerable diversity of Gospel MSS until the 4th-5th centuries, it is probably impossible to “construct” an early (much less original) text of any of the canonical Gospels. Extensive research has shown that, with literacy quite limited in the ancient world, communication was predominantly oral. Thus the Gospel stories were almost certainly orally performed, even after they existed in written form. Investigation of long orally performed texts has shown that particular lines and stanzas vary from performance to performance, while the overall story or plot of a given text remains basically stable. Recent research on all these interrelated matters indicates that individual sayings and stories isolated from literary context are unstable and unreliable as “data” for historical reconstruction, and that the Gospels are usable as historical sources only as whole stories. The first and ground-laying step in historical investigation of the historical Jesus, rather, would be careful investigation of the various Gospels’ portrayals of the key activities and aspects of his mission, which would start from the main plot and agenda of each Gospel. The implication of this conclusion, moreover, is that John and the Synoptic Gospels are on (more or less) the same footing as whole stories about Jesus’ mission. The plot/ agenda of Mark is Jesus leading a renewal of Israel over against the rulers of Israel. Matthew and Luke both expand on Jesus’ renewal of Israel (from the Q speeches) and sharpen the opposition to and by the Jerusalem and Roman rulers. The plot/agenda of John also happens to be Jesus’ renewal of Israel in opposition to and by the Judean and Roman rulers. John presents a Jesus with many of the same features as in the Synoptics, such as opposition to and by the Pharisees and a demonstrative entry into Jerusalem and a prophecy against the Temple in context of a forcible demonstration against Temple. But John has some different emphases from the Synoptics: e.g., Jesus active in all three districts of Israel; and frequent confrontations with Judean rulers at festivals in Jerusalem. In contrast to Mark, moreover, John (like Matt and Lk) views Jesus as the Messiah and even has the people want to make him king (similar to Josephus’ accounts of popularly acclaimed kings). Finally, by comparison of the somewhat different portrayals of Jesus’ interaction with followers and opponents in the Gospels, in further comparison with other literary and archaeological sources, it may be possible to reason our way historically to Jesus in relation to others in historical context.
|
Second Temple Period
Program Unit:
Richard A. Horsley, University of Massachusetts
Second Temple Period
|
Good God?!? Lamentations as a Model for Mourning the Loss of the Good God
Program Unit: Psychology and Biblical Studies
Tiffany Houck-Loomis, Union Theological Seminary
In this paper I will address the devastating psychological and social effects due to the loss of one’s primary love-object, namely God in the case of faith communities and religious individuals. By using Melanie Klein’s Object Relations Theory as a way to enter the text of Lamentations I will articulate an alternative reading that can serve as a model for pastors and educators to use when walking with individuals and communities through unspeakable losses. Lamentations, used as a tool for articulating the confounding depression and anxiety stemming from a damaged introjected object – one’s personal and communal relationship with the divine God – can allow individuals and communities a framework for placing anger and contempt upon God in order to re-assimilate the object that has been damaged in a way that is restorative to the self. In using Lamentations as a model for mourning the loss of a good God we can begin to reclaim the self that has been split off as a result of the inability to deal with the devastating loss of God, the introjected love-object. In reclaiming the self, acknowledging the damaged ego as a result of the loss of a good God we can enter into the community described in Lamentations and begin to make sense of the inconceivable horror one is faced with upon the loss of the good God and we can begin to help reconstruct the shattered worldviews of our students and parishioners.
|
Neglected Codicological Features of P91: A Third Century Indirect Gospel Witness?
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Rex J. Howe, Dallas Theological Seminary
The New Testament papyrus fragments customarily labeled P91 (P. Macquarie Inv. 360 + P. Mil. Vogl. Inv. 1224) contain Acts 2:30–37 and 2:46–3:2. The fragments are generally recognized as a third century witness. Other than the initial examinations of the fragments by Claudio Gallazzi in 1982 and by S. R. Pickering in 1986, the codicological aspects of the fragments have been given little to no attention. Features such as fiber orientation, quire identification and reconstructed leaf dimensions can offer insight concerning the original codex to which P91 belonged. Did the codex contain the book of Acts alone? Or do the physical aspects of P91 reveal a codex large enough to have possibly contained more of the New Testament? More specifically, could P91 be an indirect third century witness to at least one of the Gospels?
|
Using Technology Not to Manage but to Connect Course Teaching and Learning
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
David Howell, Ferrum College
The challenge to using technology in teaching is not simply to organize course material (e.g., we often talk about Course Management Systems at our schools), but to use teaching and learning technologies so that they fundamentally contribute and integrally connect to student learning outcomes in our classes. For this workshop, I propose to demonstrate a variety of Web 2.0 tools and how they contributed to specific learning outcomes in some of my classes: Wordle for students to construct word clouds while exploring the rhetoric of apocalyptic discourse; Google Earth and Google maps in a Biblical archeology class to document archeological sites and the material culture; Diigo for students to locate, tag, and annotate websites and thus learn critical reading and thinking of material on the web; and Flickr for students to share and annotate art work as they explore the reception history of biblical texts.
|
Blind and Disobedient: The Portrait of Jews and Jewish Leaders in Stories about Jesus’ Childhood in Selected Children Bibles
Program Unit: Children in the Biblical World
David Howell, Ferrum College
The boyhood of Jesus has frequently been used in hymns, children Bibles, and Sunday school lessons to teach virtues with Jesus’ own life providing an example of how children should behave. In some re-tellings of the biblical stories, however, the positive portrayal of Jesus’ actions and attitudes that people seek to inculcate in children are contrasted against a negative backdrop of first century Judaism. Since the holocaust many Christian theologians and biblical scholars have been become sensitive to what has been called the church’s “teaching of contempt.” In this tradition, first century Judaism is constructed as a corrupted and degenerate religion, Jesus is separated from his Jewish heritage, and Jews are blamed from the rejection and crucifixion of their Messiah. In this paper I look at art, illustrations, and text drawn primarily from children Bibles to explore how negative stereotypes of Jews are perpetuated even while positive virtues that Jesus possesses are extolled. This portrayal of Jesus within Judaism will be contrasted with other more recent Bibles which more sensitively reflect post-holocaust interfaith dialog and hermeneutics. Children’s bibles thus provide a unique window to the reception history of biblical texts.
|
Struggling with the Call
Program Unit: Academy of Homiletics
J. Dwayne Howell, Campbellsville University
*
|
“Coming into Wedding”: Reading Revelation’s Bridal Imagery through the Paintings of Myrtice West and Gertrude Morgan
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
Lynn R. Huber, Elon University
Christ and Bride Coming into Wedding is the title of the final work in a series of paintings on Revelation by self-taught artist and visionary Myrtice West. The central image is Christ and his Bride clasping hands surrounded by those inhabiting the New Jerusalem. While Christ’s appearance (e.g. white, bearded) is not surprising given West’s social location, her depiction of the bride is unusual. Rather than picturing a city or church, the Bride resembles West’s daughter, who died at the hands of an abusive husband. West’s use of her experience (or that of her daughter) to represent Revelation’s bridal imagery is paralleled in the paintings of another self-taught artist, Gertrude Morgan. Morgan, a self-proclaimed bride of Christ, visionary and New Orleans street-preacher, produced numerous depictions of the New Jerusalem in which she stands alongside of Christ the bridegroom. Christ’s pink skin and red hair are striking next to Morgan’s representations of the bride as an African-American woman. While the paintings of both suggest an individualistic interpretation of Revelation’s New Jerusalem, closer examination reveals that their interpretations are not so simple. Additionally, although the paintings of West and Morgan are distinct in terms of style and the ways in which their identities shape their textual interpretations, they illustrate how Revelation’s metaphorical language invites interpreters to extend the ideas undergirding Revelation’s bridal and New Jerusalem imagery. Likewise, the paintings of these two women, each with exceptional life stories, prompt us to think about the ways in which gender and race are negotiated within appropriations of Revelation’s imagery. Thus, this exploration of West and Morgan’s paintings shows the ways that Revelation’s imagery intersects with interpretive identities, helping us understand how Revelation’s rhetoric works on real readers, as well as documenting an exegetical tradition among visionary women in the Southeastern US.
|
Revealing/ Rejecting Roman Family Values: Revelation as a Queer Critique of Empire
Program Unit: LGBTI/Queer Hermeneutics
Lynn R. Huber, Elon University
Situated within first-century Asia Minor, John’s Apocalypse presents itself as revealing and rejecting the various discourses promulgated by the Roman Empire. One of these, which was expressed textually and visually, was a sort of Imperial “family values” that valorized the family or household, including the pious and inviolable head of the household, along with his dutiful, chaste wife, and children. Adopting this vision of the family was part of being a faithful and pious Roman citizen. In contrast to this, Revelation promotes an image of a faithful community that follows a slaughtered Lamb, whose gender appears ambiguous, and that is comprised of virginal (non-married and non-reproducing) males. Complicating the picture, these males eventually transform in toto into the feminine Bride of the Lamb. Utilizing Alexander Doty’s understanding of queer as a position that resists and challenges heterosexist norms, this paper will explore Revelation’s gender-bending images of the Lamb and Bride as a type of queer critique of Empire. This exploration is balanced, however, with the recognition that Revelation’s critique of Roman social discourse is complicated by John’s inability to challenge the feminine gender stereotypes of the dominant discourse. Thus, the paper addresses the issue of how queer interpretations of Revelation relate to feminist concerns over Revelation’s gendered imagery.
|
How the Lights Went Out: The Loss of the Temple in Both Testaments
Program Unit: Latter-day Saints and the Bible
Frederick M. Huchel, The Frithurex Athenaeum
It would not be an overstatement to say that the armature upon which the life’s work of Hugh Nibley was wound was the temple.
From the days of Adam, according to Hugh Nibley, there has been, among God’s covenant people, the equivalent of the temple. But, what is the temple? According to most Jews and Christians, “The Temple” is that built by Solomon: the First Temple. The sanctity of the Second Temple, built after the Babylonian Exile, and rebuilt again and again, was confirmed when Jesus referred to it as “my father’s house.” The Greek word translated “house,” oikos, also gives us the word oikonomia, “economy,” as in “the divine economy,” the care and providence of God towards earth and humanity: all creation. Oikonomia “implies the management of an environment or household, [oikos], which is also the root of the word ‘ecology’ [oikologia].”
Hugh Nibley held to a strict Biblical view of oikologia and man’s proper stewardship of the natural world (he used the term “Man’s dominion). He linked this with the temple, and what in Temple Theology is referred to as the Cosmic Covenant, actuated by a Great Oath, which binds all creation in harmony and stability, and by which mortals enter the Covenant. Dr. Nibley tied man’s proper stewardship of the world to the temple as “the place of creation . . . the source of life.”
It is in linking the temple with stewardship of the natural world — “all living things” — that Dr. Nibley gave his vision of man’s stewardship over the environment; and, in the breaking of the Cosmic Covenant we see how “the lights went out” and both the first and second temples, one in each Testament of the Bible, were lost.
|
Notes on Diachrony in Assyrian Akkadian
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
John Huehnergard, The University of Texas at Austin
Aspects of diachronic change in the Assyrian form of Akkadian between about 1500 and 600 BCE will be examined as representative of the types of developments that can be observed in a long-dead language. Features of phonology, morphology, syntax, and lexicon will be considered, as well as possible instances of dialect and register mixing.
|
Priestly Healing in Egypt and Israel
Program Unit: Egyptology and Ancient Israel
Herbert B. Huffmon, Drew University
It is sriking that so many of the Israelite priests, in the tradition of Moses, have Egyptian personal names. But the priestly associations of Israel with Egypt go deeper than that. There are also interesting similarities between the priestly role in Israel's health care and the health care role of the ancient Egyptian physician, who is often a priest as well as a physician and who at times employs religio-magical means.
Israel's priest did not effect healing--that was more the role of others, including prophets--but the priests had a central role in Israel's health care if only because of the importance of purity and the role of the sanctuary.
|
Sitting on the Waters: A Pastoral Position on Secure Connection with the Depths
Program Unit: Bible and Practical Theology
Mary Huie-Jolly, North Atlanta CPE Center
Pastoral theology sees painful and passionate depths of experience as formative of the soul. The biblical motif of YHWH enthroned (literally “sitting”) secure upon the waters invites reflection on God’s presence in relation to the depths. The waters (mayim) variously symbolize chaos, death, hostile threats and profound emotion generative of power for life (Ps.69.1-2,14-15;Ps.29.3-4,10;Gen.1.2;Is.55.1). The motif includes narratives of the formation of community in the likeness of God’s reign, as in Ps 89.25 where God sets David “upon the sea” reiterating the pattern associated with YHWH.
What does the image of “the waters” evoke in your experience?
What thoughts on human personality resonate with the biblical motif?
For example:
• The waters symbolize the unconscious compared to an “oceanic feeling” associated with infantile/maternal relationship. For D.W.Winnicott selfhood is formed out of a lifelong “going-on-being” in relationship with this source.
• For C.Jung the unconscious is collective. We can imagine its universality like a sea in which all swim, its water is a conduit carrying emotion. P.Cooper-White sees such transfer of emotional connection as the basis for resonance with shared experience.
As a biblical scholar and chaplain who supervises Clinical Pastoral Education (ACPE Candidate), a theology of “the waters” helps me:
• attune to the depths in peoples’ stories as potential for the mettle on which their character rests
• sit with my own emotions so I am neither overwhelmed nor out of touch with theirs.
The paradox of One who is the Ground of Being, sitting upon the floods points to a pastoral metaphor of a transcendent meaning.
What does it say to the relation between troubling human texts and the formation of the soul?
How does it express tension between the intuitive and the rational, surrender and self-control, depth of emotion and the growth toward maturity?
|
James and the Abusive Tongue
Program Unit: Speech and Talk in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Jeremy Hultin, Yale University
In terms of the content of its advice about speech, the Epistle of James is largely conventional. What is not so common is the way James sets the tongue at the heart of a cosmic and primeval struggle. True religion, says James, consists in keeping oneself "unstained by the world" (1:27), but the tongue — which is itself "the unrighteous world" — stains the body (3:6). The defiling world is present in the human body. The tongue sets "the wheel of creation aflame" and is itself "set on fire by hell." The tongue is not only a portal between Hell and Creation, but it, unlike the animals (!), has not been brought under human control (3:7-8). James has, in effect, configured "the world," "religion," and "the tongue" in such a way so that to use the tongue improperly is actually to grant "the world" access to one's mouth. Thus the male and female addressees are alike "adulteresses" (4:4). Whereas most Greeks and Romans viewed abusive language as the mark of a manly brio (cf. Catullus 16 or Priapic poetry), in James's apocalyptic discourse, verbal assaults constitute a sexual humiliation.
|
Reading, Community, and the Wilderness Road
Program Unit: Christian Theology and the Bible
Douglas A. Hume, Pfeiffer University
In recent years, narrative criticism has been used increasingly to interpret Acts of the Apostles theologically. Such interpretations presuppose that the text’s theology is inextricably bound to its narrative form, thus cautioning against separating out specific theological propositions from the text or considering such extrinsic factors like authorial intention. Narrative theological readings of Luke-Acts view the story as divinely purposed activity. Some interpreters see God’s purpose even extending beyond the narrative into the experience of contemporary readers. Is this supposition, however, enough to safeguard Acts as a special locus of divine revelation? If one’s reading of Acts uses methods developed for the criticism of contemporary novels and presupposes that theological meaning is inseparable from narrative form, how is one to know that Acts is any more a source for theological understanding than any given novel, poem, or story?
This paper considers such questions through a close reading of the story of Philip and the Ethiopian Eunuch (Acts 8:26?40). In this story, the Ethiopian Eunuch needs Philip to explain Is 53:7 by “starting from this scripture and proclaiming the good news to him about Jesus” (8:35). Given that Philip is sent by an angel (8:26) and the Spirit (8:29) to join the Eunuch, in this story God is composing a reading community that can unpack the Christological identity of the Isaiah 53 character. The paper explores how the intersection of multiple stories—the Eunuch’s, Philip’s, Jesus’, and that of the Isaiah 53 character—reveals God’s purpose, as God’s story is interwoven with those of the readers. The paper explores how the narrator uses perspective and the wilderness setting to focus the reader’s imagination on this web of characters and readers who are discovering God’s story. The paper concludes that theological purpose in Acts can best be uncovered by reading in community.
|
What is Divine Presence?
Program Unit: Unity and Diversity in Early Jewish Monotheisms
Michael Hundley, University of Cambridge
No abstract
|
Thrones in Scheol (Is 14:9–11)
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Iconography and the Bible
Regine Hunziker Rodewald, University of Strasbourg, France
The throne characterizes rulers’ authority. That kings also in the Netherworld are associated with this symbol of power causes astonishment. However, from the point of view of religious history, the idea that in the Ancient Near East dead rulers are privileged is well established, both literally as well as iconographically. This is attested by sculptures and funeral stelae of seated kings or officials and priests from the 2nd or 1st millennium BC respectively. Furthermore, KTU 1.161 shows that at the funeral ceremony the throne of the Ugaritic king was ritually transferred to the Netherworld. In the artistic satirical song about the king of Babylon, Is 14:4b-21, a refined game of up-down and high-low is visible. In this game the king of Babylon is given the lowest possible position: He („even you!“ Is 14:10) is imagined as being thrown down among the killed soldiers; in the setting of this image the idea that the kings in Scheol rise from their thrones when greeting the king of Babylon has the function of taking the game of high and low to extremes.
|
What Comprises 'Jewish Monotheism' in the Late Hellenistic and Early Roman Period?
Program Unit: Unity and Diversity in Early Jewish Monotheisms
Larry Hurtado, University of Edinburgh
No abstract
|
Striving for a Clearer View of the Big Picture: Eldon Epp as Textual Critic
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Larry Hurtado, University of Edinburgh
Striving for a clearer view of the big Picture: Eldon Epp as textual critic
|
The “Linguistic Dating of Biblical Texts”: Comments on Methodological Guidelines and Philological Procedures
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Avi Hurvitz, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
A series of publication in recent years attests to an insistent claim that no extant data support the notion that diachrony in BH can be described. Some of the arguments advanced are purely linguistic (for instance, that Persian loan-words cannot serve as a chronological marker indicative of the 2nd Temple period); others are of an extra-linguistic nature (for instance, that the text of the MT has suffered a great degree of fluidity in the course of its transmission, a fluidity that undermines any effort to delineate the linguistic profile of the original authors).
In this paper, I revisit six concrete examples whose linguistic lateness within BH is acknowledged by supporters of traditional diachronic research but denied by those who argue that such research is based on misguided assumptions. Using these examples, I will evaluate the sets of methodological guide-lines and philological procedures that result in such diametrically opposed conclusions in order to determine whether or not (1) linguistic distribution, (2) linguistic contrast, (3) consideration of extra-biblical data and (4) the principle of “accumulation” in dynamic combination suffice for generating valid diachronic statements.
|
The Meaning of the Expression 'ir Dawid in Samuel and Kings
Program Unit: Biblical Lexicography
Juerg Hutzli, Collège de France
The paper examines the significance(s) of the term 'ir dawid in the books of Samuel and the books of Kings. In scholarship the term is commonly understood as the name of a part of Jerusalem (south-eastern hill) and translated by “city of David”. Since in 2 S 5:7-9 'ir dawid designates the “stronghold of Zion” (metsudat tsiyyon) we should ask if the term 'ir dawid–at least in certain instances in Sam and Kings–rather refers to a single, fortified building than to a “city” as part of a town. The meaning “fortification, tower” for 'r is attested in Old South Arabic. In fact some occurrences of the term 'ir dawid in the book of Kings suggest the reference to a single (fortified) building as well.
In favour of this interpretation we may also point to several instances in Sam and Kgs where the noun 'ir probably relates to a fortification or a tower. J. Gray has proposed this understanding with regards to the expression 'ir hammayim in 2 S 12:27 (proposed translation “the water-tower” instead of the traditional rendering “the city of waters”).
|
Co-existence of Conditionality and Unconditionality of the Davidic Dynastic Promise in Chronicles
Program Unit: Korean Biblical Colloquium
Sunwoo Hwang, University of Edinburgh
The tension between the conditional and the unconditional aspects of the Davidic dynastic promise exists in both Chronicles and the Deuteronomistic history. The major explanation for the tension within the Deuteronomistic history is the redactional hand of the Deuteronomist. This approach views the unconditional covenant of 2 Sam 7 as the original promise and other conditional aspects of the promise in the Deuteronomistic history as the secondary development attributed to the Deuteronomist’s interest in accounting for the destruction of the Davidic kingdom by Babylon.
To explain the co-existence of the conditional and unconditional Davidic dynastic promise in Chronicles seems more difficult since the Chronicler’s reception of the Deuteronomistic history is in the post-exilic period. The question is why the Chronicler leaves both the unconditional and conditional Davidic covenants in the work of Chronicles. The Chronicler could have reduced the two dispositions of the covenant into either one that is unconditional or, more likely, one that is conditional given that no Davidic kingdom existed in that period. The more succinct question becomes: why does the Chronicler leave the unconditional Davidic covenant?
This paper attempts to find an answer in the organic relationship between the unconditional and conditional aspects of the dynastic promise. The Chronicler would see the two aspects of the promise not as contradictory but rather as complimentary forming two facets of one coin. The Davidic dynastic promise is conditional in the sense that the kingdom is punished, destroyed, and ceased to exist. At the same time, it is unconditional in the sense that Yahweh’s loving-kindness would not depart from it though the kingdom goes through the time of chastisement (1 Chr 17:13; cf., 1 Chr 10:13-14). In other words, the Chronicler believes and hopes the restoration of the Davidic dynasty after the period of God’s discipline ends.
|
The Paradox of Women in the Early Church: 1 Timothy and The Acts of Paul and Thecla
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Susan E. Hylen, Vanderbilt University
The story of women in the early church is most often told as one contrasting radical ascetic groups that encouraged women’s leadership with the proto-orthodox tendency to limit women’s participation in conformity with social norms. For example, the scholarly consensus is that 1 Timothy and The Acts of Paul and Thecla represent two divergent developments in Pauline thought, often understood to have been in direct conflict with one another. (Thecla affirms women’s leadership; 1 Timothy restricts it.) In this paper I argue instead that the contradictions modern interpreters see in these texts represent a paradox that existed within and cut across early Christian communities. On the one hand, women are understood to be inferior to men and are restricted from certain tasks; on the other hand, women exercise significant leadership, often including tasks that are expressly forbidden to them. The argument develops in three parts. The first part is exegetical: I argue that the differences between 1 Timothy and Thecla have been overstated. There are tensions in the conceptions of women in these documents, yet they are common to both texts. The second part of the argument makes sense of my interpretation of the texts in their larger social context. I point to evidence for similar tensions between the views of women in Greco-Roman culture and the roles women assumed. Finally, I argue that later evidence of the widespread acceptance of both of these texts reinforces the idea that the contradictory views of women in these texts did not define boundaries between Christian communities but existed within them.
|
Teaching Revelation to the Left Behind Generation
Program Unit: Teaching Biblical Studies in an Undergraduate Liberal Arts Context
Susan E. Hylen, Vanderbilt University
I teach the Book of Revelation in an introductory-level course in which one of my objectives is for students to learn that more than one good interpretation of a text is possible. Revelation is a useful text for this purpose because there exist a variety of very different interpretations, each of which deals with the complex language of this text in a unique way. The difficulty is that many students can only imagine this text in one way, often shaped by their prior encounters with the Left Behind series. In this context, meeting my goal requires me to address the role the text plays in students’ imaginations, and to give them an alternative way to imagine Revelation. In this paper I discuss three techniques I have developed that help students meet the goal, and the means by which I measure their progress. Through discussions of genre, theology, and artistic representations of selected passages, I ask students to develop a new way of “seeing” Revelation. I prepare students to articulate two interpretations of the same passage of Revelation, and to explain the choices each one makes regarding the language of the text. The goal is not to replace the student’s former understanding of the text, but to enable them to see multiple possibilities within one text.
|
YHWH, Humanity, and Non-human Creation: Rereading Micah 6:1–8 through the Lens of “Modified” Ecological Triangle
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Ma. Maricel S. Ibita, Catholic University of Leuven
“He has told you, O mortal, what is good; and what does the LORD require of you but to do justice, and to love kindness, and to walk humbly with your God?” Micah 6:8 (NRSV). As the Book of Micah’s “crowning verse”, it has been employed as a presidential inaugural address quotation, a guide to respond to international terrorism, a window into the psychology of the prophets, a national liturgical guide, and a global inspiration in achieving the United Nations Millennium Development Goals. The timelessness of this text and the pressing environmental crisis prompt our research to reread the pericope in its context (Micah 6:1-8) from the viewpoint of ecological hermeneutics. What roles do the human and non-human creations (Mic 6:1-2, 4-5, 6-7) play in the text? How do YHWH, humanity and non-human creation interrelate in the pericope? What fresh insights can we glean from reading Mic 6:8 with ecological eyes? This investigation answers these questions by presenting an overview and a critique of the two recent responses on the ecological crisis from the field of biblical scholarship: the Earth Bible Project’s ecojustice principles (2000-2002) and Hilary Marlow’s “ecological triangle” (2009). We shall look at (1) the understanding of the non-human creation in the text; (2) the discernible assumptions on the relationship between YHWH and the created world; and (3) the effects of the actions and choices of human beings concerning the non-human creation and vice versa. To further the scholarly discussion, we propose that the “ecological triangle” be modified by (4) discerning deeper and inner dimensions of the interrelationship between YHWH, humanity and non-human creation. Our research suggests that the most authentic answer to the many “whats” that unite the pericope is a “who”, a corrective and transformative reconsideration of humanity’s interrelationship with other humans, non-human creation and YHWH.
|
Reclaiming the Voice of the Earthy Witnesses in the So-Called ryb in Micah 6:1–8
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Ma. Maricel S. Ibita, Catholic University of Leuven
Since the publication of the Earth Bible Series, the interpretation of the ryb (Deut 32; Ps 50; Isa 1:1-20; Hos 2:4-17; 4:1-3; Jer 2:4-13; Mic 6:1-8) has taken a new direction. Traditionally understood, these texts present how YHWH confronts Israel’s infidelity to the covenant by way of “disputation” or “conduct of a legal case,” with usually the natural elements as witnesses. Recently, however, some interest has focused on the presence and role of Earth community in the covenant relation between YHWH and Israel. Our research looks into the ryb in Mic 6:1-8 and discerns not only what the role/s of the hrym, gb‘wt, and ’tnym msdy ’rts (Mic 6:1-2) are but also the presence and function/s of other members of Earth community in the pericope. Guided by the principle of voice that “Earth is a subject capable of raising its voice in celebration and against injustice,” our study investigates the various ways (gesture, sign, image or sound) in which Earth community communicates with humans, other members of Earth community, and YHWH. We endeavor to reclaim the voice of Earth community in Mic 6:1-8 in four steps. First, we consider the role of the hrym, gb‘wt, and ’tnym msdy ’rts as witnesses in the so-called ryb (Mic 6:1-2) in comparison with the role of the deities and natural elements in the ancient Near East treaties. Second, we attempt to listen to the voice of these witnesses by rereading the complaint of YHWH (Mic 6:3-5) from their perspective. Third, we allow these witnesses to raise their voice against objectification and exploitatively anthropocentric mindset which suggest covenant violation (Mic 6:6-7). Lastly, we show how hrym, gb‘wt, and ’tnym msdy ’rts witness anew the re-presentation of covenant relationship within the Earth community which allow for fullness of life for all life forms (Mic 6:8).
|
When Crops, Imperial City, and Church Fail: A Re-reading of 1 Cor. 11:30
Program Unit: Biblical Criticism and Literary Criticism
Ma. Marilou S. Ibita, Catholic University of Leuven-Belgium
Part of the UN Millennium Development Goal No. 1 is to halve the proportion of people experiencing hunger between 1990 and 2015. Hunger is a complex issue with a complex solution. It is significant to note how religious beliefs and rituals play a role in responding to this problem. This paper explores a hunger situation in Roman Corinth where crops, imperial city and the church seem to have failed with dire consequences and how Paul offers a possible response within the Christian community.This situation is reflected in the story of the Lord’s Supper (1 Cor 11:17-34) when Paul says dia touto en hymin polloi astheneis kai arrostoi kai koimontai hikanoi (v. 30). The identity of these people has been either regarded as anonymous or limited to those who perpetuated the abuses at the Lord’s Supper. In contrast, we argue that this text probably speaks of the most vulnerable members of the Corinthian community (cf. Friesen, 2004 & 2005 and Longenecker, 2009). Using narrative-criticism and socio-historical analysis we will consider textual clues in 1 Cor 11:17-34 that point to the identity of the characters mentioned in v. 30. They are plausibly victims of (1) an ecological crisis (probably a food crises) that affected Corinth at the time of the Corinthian correspondence; (2) an inadequate imperial city response through the limited recipients of the benefits from the curator annonae; and (3) the Christian community’s failure to let the poorest among them eat in their midst when they gather to eat together during the Lord’s Supper. We, then, explore Paul’s response to the issue of hunger at the Corinthian Lord’s Supper. At the end, we offer a short reflection on how this passage poses a challenge to our Christian response to the issue of hunger in view of Millennium Goal No. 1.
|
Episteusa dio elalesa (2 Cor 4:13): Paul and the Psalmist
Program Unit: Second Corinthians: Pauline Theology in the Making
Ma. Marilou S. Ibita, Catholic University of Leuven-Belgium
In describing his apostolic trials (2 Cor 4:7-18), Paul says episteusa, dio elalesa in 2 Cor 4:13 and expounds on it in vv.14-15. There are several issues here: (1) does Paul cite Ps 116:10 (MT) or Ps 115:1 (LXX)? (2) does Paul only refer to Ps 116:10/Ps 115:1 or does he allude to the whole Ps 116/115?; (3) who does Paul suppose the speaker to be in the psalm quote in 2 Cor 4:13? According to Stegman (2007), following Hays (2005), Paul understands the psalms Christologically and, therefore, Christ is the one who says episteusa, dio elalesa. In this paper, we shall critically evaluate this position and offer an alternative narrative-critical reading exploring the way Paul explicitly and implicitly uses Ps 116 (MT) and/or 114-115 (LXX) to create his own new psalm thus effectively characterizing himself as a psalmist in 4:7-18. We will also relate this to the use of psalms in the Corinthian liturgy (1 Cor 14:15, 26). Paul’s effectively acting like a psalmist is an expression of his theology-in-the-making in so far as the use of psalms in the Corinthian liturgy articulates a theologizing on suffering and deliverance as well as proclamation in 2 Corinthians by making use of an existing psalm to write a new psalm-like text in 4:7-18.
|
Through the Lens of Hegesippus: Eusebius on the Jews and Judeo-Christians
Program Unit: Eusebius and the Construction of a Christian Culture
Oded Irshai, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
In composing his celebrated Church History, Eusebius of Caesarea availed
himself of documents, literary and historical sources many of which it is
assumed he recovered from the Jerusalem and Caesarea archives and libraries.
One of his main sources for the post apostolic period was Hegesippus who
wrote his "memoires" ca. 180 CE in five volumes of which thanks to Eusebius
only eight excerpts survived.The aim of our discussion is to decipher the
essence of the Eusebian excerpts of the Hegesippian descriptions of
the fate of the Jews during and after the destruction of Jerusalem and its
Temple ca. 70 CE, portrayed through the lenses of his Judeo-Christian sources
or informants. Hegesippus' descriptions grant us with a unique and insightful
persepective on this most horrendous hour in Jewish history as it was being
told and more so engraved in the local collective memory of an important
segment of the early Palestinian Christian community. This overall picture
will be discussed in the light of the aims and achievements of the Eusebian
historical enterprise.
|
The Text Linguistics of the Suffering Servant: Subordinate Structures in Isaiah 52:13–53:12
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Bo Isaksson, University of Uppsala
Taking as a point of departure the results of the research project Circumstantial Qualifiers in Semitic (Harrassowitz 2009) the author analyses the textual structures in Isaiah 52-53 with a reconsideration of the linguistic concept of subordination in the Isaiah text. As a result new light is shed on the text and on the Hebrew "tenses" (the verbal grammatical morphemes), which stand out as quite regular in a Westsemitic setting. The language in the text turns out to be a normal human language with a structure that is well attested among modern spoken languages seen in a crosslinguistic perspective.
References:
Isaksson, Bo, Heléne Kammensjö, and Maria Persson. Circumstantial qualifiers in Semitic: The case of Arabic and Hebrew. Edited by Bo Isaksson. Abhandlungen für die Kunde des Morgenlandes 70. Wiesbaden: Otto Harrassowitz, 2009.
Isaksson, Bo. “Circumstantial qualifiers in Qumran Hebrew: Reflections on adjunct expressions in The Manual of Discipline (1QS)”. In Conservatism and innovation in the Hebrew language of the Hellenistic period. Proceedings of a fourth international symposium on the Hebrew of the Dead Sea Scrolls & Ben Sira, edited by Jan Joosten and Jean-Sébastien Rey, 79-91. Studies on the texts of the desert of Judah 73. Leiden - Boston: Brill, 2008.
Isaksson, Bo. “Semitic circumstantial qualifiers in the Book of Judges: A pilot study on the infinitive”. Orientalia Suecana 56 (2007): 163-172.
|
The Paradox of Secrecy in the Gospel of Mark: A Performance-Critical Perspective
Program Unit: Performance Criticism of the Bible and Other Ancient Texts
Kelly R. Iverson, University of St. Andrews
The so-called “messianic secret” has been a fixture in Markan studies for over a century. Despite the passage of time, however, William Wrede continues to exercise significant influence over scholarly discussions, and the questions that drove Wrede continue to dictate contemporary approaches to the messianic secret. The problem is that while questions pertaining to secrecy and the historical Jesus deserve careful attention and offer a profitable avenue for inquiry, scholarly conversation has stagnated in recent years. The aim of this essay is to demonstrate that performance criticism is an indispensible tool for shedding light on Mark’s secrecy theme. The hermeneutical trajectory it sets forth paves the way for a more complete understanding that pushes beyond the current discussion and fosters questions about the use of secrecy and the impact of Mark’s narrative that have been widely overlooked.
|
Input, Output, and Interactions: What SLA Research Can Contribute to Teaching Biblical Languages
Program Unit: Applied Linguistics for Biblical Languages
Ellen Jackson, SIL International
Second Language Acquisition research seeks to understand how adults learn second (or third or fourth) languages, and to identify and evaluate the factors that influence speed of learning, efficiency, and success in attaining a high level of proficiency. SLA theories on the social aspects of language have suggested major innovations for classroom activities. This paper will review some of the related research, including Paul Nation's Four Strands of input, output, grammar and fluency, and propose possible applications to teaching Biblical languages.
[This is an invited paper by the ALBL Group to survey how Second Language Acquistion Studies may contribute to Biblical language pedagogy. -- Group chairs]
|
Qoheleth's Lament
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
John R. Jackson, Milligan College
How would an Israelite lament if there was no one to whom to talk? Studies that highlight the limitations of form criticism and conceptual overlaps in the various genres of literature in the Hebrew Bible invite the reader to read across genres. The prominent place of lament in Job opens the possibility of reading Ecclesiastes in terms of Israel’s lament tradition. While Job’s complaints move generally from 2nd-person to 3rd-person when speaking of God, Qoheleth offers no address to God and thus has no place for 2nd-person lament. But Ecclesiastes is certainly a book of complaint, of protest. Qoheleth may voice lament of God in the 3rd-person, but he expresses complaint primarily without reference to person. Although Qoheleth needs to express lament, his theological framework has no place for 2nd-person lament – or even, really, 3rd-person lament. This paper will examine lament in the wisdom traditions of the ancient Near East and in the book of Job as a prelude to exploring ways that Qoheleth’s language of complaint is like and unlike the lament language of Job, the biblical psalms, and the wider wisdom tradition.
|
The ‘Call’ and the Community: Setting Boundaries for the Christian Rhetorical Use of Argument
Program Unit: Academy of Homiletics
Maury Jackson, La Sierra University
*
|
‘Jewish Christianity’ and ‘Christian Deism’ in Thomas Morgan’s The Moral Philosopher (1737)
Program Unit: Jewish Christianity / Christian Judaism
Matt Jackson-McCabe, Cleveland State University
Between John Toland’s invention of “Jewish Christianity” in his Nazarenus (1718) and F. C. Baur’s influential formulation of the concept more than a century later stands Thomas Morgan’s The Moral Philosopher (1737). Presented in the form of an extended dialogue between a “Christian Deist” and a “Christian Jew,” this work develops a notion of “Jewish Christianity” that, while not obviously dependent on Toland, prefigures Baur to a remarkable degree. This paper will examine Morgan’s construction of “Jewish Christianity” and his account of Christian origins more generally as a function of his religious ideology, in the process shedding more light on Baur’s subsequent reinvention.
|
"Singing the Lord’s Song in a Strange Land": Psalm 137 as a Reflection on Exile and Cultural Identity
Program Unit: Islands, Islanders, and Scriptures
Mignon R. Jacobs, Fuller Theological Seminary
In Psalm 137 we hear the haunting sound of a displaced people making sense of the reality of captivity. Their identity is fused with the land from which they came and “other” than their present location. Whatever the length and quality of their stay in Babylon (the foreign land), a longing to return to their home marks their presence in Babylon. Similarly, Psalm 137 holds a place in Caribbean culture giving voice to a generation and an experience of displacement and contending with an identity in colonial and post-colonial environment. Within the Caribbean interpretative frame of reference, the psalm also functions as a point of dissonance to the reality of captivity. This paper examines Psalm 137 along side the reggae song of Bob Marley—‘By the Rivers of Babylon’ as a case study in the fusion of biblical interpretation of the exile and cultural identity. This hermeneutical endeavor explores the assonance and dissonance of the psalm in relation to Caribbean existence—that is, the richness of that existence and the challenge to embrace the distinctiveness and multifaceted of Caribbean identity.
|
Homiletical Exegesis and Theologies of Revelation: Biblical Preaching from Text to Sermon in an Age of Methodological Pluralism
Program Unit: Academy of Homiletics
David Schnasa Jacobsen, Waterloo Lutheran Seminary and Toronto School of Theology
*
|
“And I Will Write It on Their Hearts”: The Word as Transformative in Popular Film
Program Unit: Bible and Film
Karl N. Jacobson, Augsburg College
Our paper will explore an often under-appreciated aspect of popular film, the effect that the biblical word is perceived and represented as having.
In Quentin Tarantino’s Pulp Fiction (1994), Jules Winnfield (Samuel L. Jackson) “quotes” Ezekiel 25:17 twice. The first serves as summary of Winnfield’s career-long use of scripture, which is largely unreflective. As he later says himself, “I never gave much thought to what it meant, I just thought it was some cold blooded sh** to say to a motherf***** before I popped a cap in his a**.” The second, coming at the end of the film, marks a shift in Winnfield, as he begins to think seriously about what the passage he has quoted means in his own life.
In The Book of Eli (2010), Eli (Denzel Washington) struggles to balance protecting the Bible with living and acting in a way consistent with its principals, at least as he understands them. Eli strives to “stay on the path,” both the literal path of his journey to a place where his Bible (the last known copy) will be protected and copied—a path to which he has been called by God—and the figurative path of righteous, faithful living—a path to which he is called by his burden.
In both films the biblical material, in concert with lived experience, works a change in the character in question. Each offers a thoughtful reflection on the impact of the biblical word and the likelihood that once encountered, once internalized, the biblical word will work as an agent of transformation. These uses of the biblical material are both integral to the messages of these films, and engaging interactions with biblical text.
|
“But These Words Are Drawn so That You May Come to Believe…,” : The Bible according to Siku
Program Unit: Bible and Popular Culture
Karl N. Jacobson, Augsburg College
In 2007 Doubleday Published The Manga Bible: From Genesis to Revelation, by Ajinbayo Akinsiku (Siku). Siku’s work received a good deal of critical attention from religious circles, but even more so from the art and comic book world. The majority of critical responses dealt either with questions of propriety—is it appropriate to commit biblical stories to a form of graphic art typically dedicated to the violent and erotic?, or of quality—is Siku’s work good artwork, is it really “manga,” is it “good manga”? Missing in the examination of Siku’s work is an appreciation of the rhetorical care and intentionality with which he crafts his re-presentation and re-interpretation of the biblical story.
Siku describes his work as an interpretation of the Bible which seeks to communicate its relevance to new generations via a new medium, a vernacular medium which both brings the biblical material into contemporary, vernacular expression, and at the same time recaptures and represents much of the oral nature of the biblical material in a visual form.
My paper will first explore the rhetorical moves/devices that drive The Manga Bible, before outlining some of the pedagogical potential in engaging Siku’s work both as an entree to the Bible itself, and as a conversation partner in reading and interpretation.
|
“Let The Redeemed of the Lord Say So”: Israel’s Storied Ethics in Their Thanksgiving Songs
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Joshua T. James, Fuller Theological Seminary
Within Old Testament studies, the methodological designation, narrative ethics, primarily refers to the scholarly attempt to extract Israel’s ethical principles from their stories, whether through an analysis of the virtues and vices of the literary characters or the ethical vision of the implied author. In contrast, the discipline of Christian ethics understands a narrative ethical approach, not as a methodology confined to a particular genre, but rather, as a systematic understanding of the storied form of all reality. Exemplified in the early writings of Stanley Hauerwas, narrative ethics emphasizes the importance of the communally-accepted framing narratives, which inform its audience of the nature of God, the self, and the world. Further, these stories invite the community to live within the “ongoing narrative” in such a way that their ethical commitments demonstrate the veracity of their underlying narrative to the world.
The goal of this paper, then, is to apply the methodological principles of Christian narrative ethics to the thanksgiving songs of the Psalms. As such, the thanksgiving songs will be viewed as evidence of the storied form of Israel’s ethical instruction, particularly in the psalmist’s personal confirmation of the validity of Israel’s communal narrative(s) and the consequent invitation to the community to live “rightly” within the ongoing narrative. Therefore, rather than merely providing a witness to the Lord’s deliverance, the thanksgiving songs are understood to be motivated by the ethical concern of character formation. This appeal to Israel’s character, however, is not made on the basis of isolated ethical principles or injunctions, but through the rehearsal of a story.
|
Greek Lexicography
Program Unit: Biblical Lexicography
Patrick James, University of Cambridge
Lexicography involves the collection of evidence relating to the meaning and usage of words, the identification and arrangement of the distinct senses of those words, and the
presentation in a lexicon or dictionary of a kind of biography for each word. Although such work draws on etymological studies and on research into word formation,
derivation, and compounding, since these are disciplines in their own right within linguistics and philology, they are not treated in this bibliography. Also, personal and
place names may contribute to our understanding of the semantics of Greek vocabulary,and words certainly should be studied in their cultural context. However, works that are
primarily onomastic in character rather than semantic or encyclopedic are not included here, although a few starting points for the former are listed under Onomastic Works.
|
2 Kings 25:27–30: An Ambiguous Ending to the Forced Migration and the Future of the Davidides
Program Unit: Exile (Forced Migrations) in Biblical Literature
David Janzen, North Central College
The author of the concluding verses of the Deuteronomistic History has written a deliberately ambiguous ending to that work. Scholars have variously interpreted this final scene of Jehoiachin’s release from captivity as signaling both hope for the displaced exiles and lack of it, but the passage itself avoids any specific reference to the future of the exilic community and the Davidides. This paper examines the reasons that 1 and 2 Kings as a whole presents for the punishment of dynasties, as well as the particular favor accorded to the Davidides in Dtr. While the author of the end of Kings had a variety of formulas available that he or she could have used in order to specify what future awaited the Davidic king and his fellow exiles in Babylon, 2 Kings 25:27-30 avoids all of them. The result is an ambiguous conclusion to the work that avoids looking to the past, and so that reflects the traumatic present of the displaced exiles.
|
Exegesis and Eschatology in Pesher Isaiah A (4Q161)
Program Unit: Qumran
Alex P. Jassen, University of Minnesota-Twin Cities
Pesher Isaiah A (4Q161) is the most often cited of the pesharim on Isaiah. It has gained this prominence in scholarly literature based on the appearance of the messianic interpretation of Isa 11:1-5 in the final lines of the extant text. If we subtract the treatments of the messianic interpretation of Isa 11:1-5, however, the rest of the pesher has received less attention than it deserves. Perhaps the largest lacuna in the scholarship on 4Q161 is the lack of attention to its exegetical technique, which is only episodically treated and rarely in a sophisticated way. The primary focus of the pesher is the eschatological war that will be waged against the Kittim under the leadership of the messianic Prince of the Congregation. This paper argues that a full understanding of the text—as in other Pesharim—cannot be apprehended without consideration of its exegetical technique. This paper examines the exegetical technique of the pesher in its interpretation of the remnant theme from Isa 10:22; the march of the Assyrian enemy toward Jerusalem from Isa 10:28-32; the encounter with the Assyrians in Isa 10:33-34; and the Davidic figure in Isa 11:1-5. The central themes of the pesher are all crafted through an exegetical reformulation and amplification of scriptural themes and content from Isaiah 10-11, other scriptural passages, and related sectarian literature. In addition to unpacking the exegetical technique of the pesher, this paper seeks to locate Pesher Isaiah in the wider context of the eschatology of the community of the Dead Sea Scrolls as well as broader trends in early Jewish and Christian exegesis and eschatology. Particular emphasis is placed on the relationship of the pesher to sectarian war texts (especially 1QM and 4Q185) and their related messianic speculation and representations of end-time violence.
|
Socio-rhetorical Commentary on Colossians
Program Unit: Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity
Roy A. Jeal, Booth College
This session is dedicated to examining the new contributions to the interpretation of particular texts facilitated by socio-rhetorical interpretation as this has been developed by the Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity Group under the leadership of Vernon Robbins. Three scholars engaged in writing commentaries for the Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity Series (Deo Press) will present what they believe to be the fresh perspectives or insights into particular passages from Colossians, Ephesians, and 1 John developed as a result of engaging the passage through socio-rhetorical interpretation. Respondents who have written commentaries from more traditional hermeneutical approaches will assess the relevant section of the presenter's commentary. The session as a whole seeks to nurture dialogue between practitioners of socio-rhetorical interpretation and scholars located in more traditional methodologies within the larger guild.
|
The Illusion of Political Benefaction in Luke 22:25
Program Unit: Jesus Traditions, Gospels, and Negotiating the Roman Imperial World
Robert Jewett, University of Heidelberg
This logion exposes the central contradiction of dominating others in an imperialistic manner while calling oneself a “benefactor,” as Greco-Roman, imperial apologists claimed. The logion provides a succinct evaluation of "benevolent imperialism," its moral appeal, its self delusion and its disguise of brutal domination. After weighing the historicity of this logion and its place in the theology of Luke, the paper lays out the background of euergetos ("benefactor) in the Greco-Roman world, taking account of visual depictions in ancient propaganda. The paper then examines the relevance of the logion in the debate over the interaction with imperialism in the New Testament.
|
Biblical Foundations for Human Rights in Jus Post Bellum Theory
Program Unit: Ethics and Biblical Interpretation
Robert Jewett, University of Heidelberg
The paper responds to the discussions about Afghanistan in the U. S. and NATO countries, which have concentrated on the classical criteria of initiating and conducting a “just war.” Those criteria were relevant in 2001-02 but seem inappropriate after a long and contested occupation. Although barely mentioned in past debates over just war, the principles of jus post bellum seem far more appropriate in considering policy options in current circumstances of occupations following wars. Studies by experts in international law such as Alexander Moseley, Brian Orend, Juan Diego Garzón, Christian Schaller, Carsten Stahn and Jann K. Kleffner lay out aspects of a just occupation, but so far as I can tell, no biblical scholars have entered this discussion. The proposed paper would aim in a preliminary manner to apply to the issue of just occupation various biblical passages that are (1)critical of domination, (2) supportive of universal human rights, and (3) providing encouragement to prudence.
|
God and Jesus as Kyrios in the Gospel of Mark: Unity and Distinction
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Daniel Johansson, University of Edinburgh
Many scholars have noticed that it often is difficult to determine in what sense Mark uses the term kyrios and whether it refers to Jesus or God. This paper argues that this ambiguity is intentional and serves the purpose of linking Jesus to the God of Israel so that they both share the identity as kyrios. Significantly, the first instance of kyrios, which appears in the citation of Isa 40:3 at the outset of the Gospel (1:3), refers to both God – in its original context – and Jesus – in the Markan narrative. The promised coming of God, the kyrios of the Jewish Scriptures, is fulfilled through the coming of Jesus. Starting in 1:3, this paper will first proceed through five other passages in which the referent of kyrios is ambiguous and an unity of act between God and Jesus can be identified (5:19; 11:3; 13:20; 12:9 and 13:35). Attention will then turn to two passages where kyrios unambiguously refers to Jesus (2:28, 7:28) but which at the same time closely associate Jesus with God. Further, Jesus’ coming in the name of the kyrios (11:9) presents him not merely as one authorized by God, but as one who possesses the name of God. Finally, the implications of the juxtaposition of the Shema and Ps 110:1 (12:28-37), the seeming contradiction between the confession of one kyrios and the presence of two kyrioi on the divine throne, will be highlighted. It will be concluded that there is an overlap of identity between God and Jesus realized through their shared identity as kyrios and their unity of act. At the same time, a clear distinction is maintained as two figures are linked to the kyrios title and Mark never calls Jesus “God.”
|
When Pseudepigrapha Become Canonical: Rethinking Canon and Textual Criticism
Program Unit: Function of Apocryphal and Pseudepigraphal Writings in Early Judaism and Early Christianity
Loren L. Johns, Associated Mennonite Biblical Seminary
The Historical, Theological, and Ecclesiological Contexts for the Question
Historically, the relationship between canonical criticism and textual criticism has been unclear. Is it the “Old Testament” or the “Hebrew Bible” that Christians hold as canonical? Or is it a Platonic theoretical ideal of the above? If the early church held some Septuagint-like Greek version of the Bible as canonical, why does the church today pay more attention to the Hebrew version? And is it the Masoretic version that is authoritative for the church, or the state of the text at some earlier point?
Mark 16:9-20 and John 7:53-8:11 as Case Studies in Pseudepigrapha and Canon
The textual-critical work on Mark 16:9-20 and John 7:53-8:11 has been extensive and conclusive. However, these passages continue to be included in the text of printed editions of the New Testament, unlike most variant readings deemed inauthentic by textual critics. When the New Testament in the Revised Standard Version appeared in 1946, Mark 16:9-20 and John 7:53-8:11 were relegated to the footnotes. However, when the second edition of the RSV New Testament appeared in 1971, they were both restored to the text, with brackets and explanatory footnotes. How and why did this happen? What kind of theological, ecclesiological, and political thinking went into that decision? And why should these two passages be treated differently from shorter passages, such as John 5:4 or 1 John 5:7b-8a?
Hans Frei, James Sanders, and others have emphasized that biblical scholarship ought to serve communities of faith. This paper explores how the Society of Biblical Literature might serve the church in sorting out its Scriptures.
|
The Height of Goliath and Other Significant Numerical Variants in the Septuagint of 1 Samuel
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Ben Johnson, Durham University
It is a recurring phenomenon that the LXX witnesses different numbers than the MT in many places. While these instances are very likely instances of intentional changes to the text (it is hard to imagine a translator mistaking ses for arba) it is often very difficult to ascertain a reason for the change or the directionality of the change. The present paper surveys the instances of numerical variants between the MT and LXX in 1 Samuel. The intention of this study is to shed light not only on the use of numerals in these textual traditions but also on the instances of intentional emendations.
|
Idea of the Messiah in the Hebrew Bible and Messianic Ideas among the Shudras (Low Castes) of India
Program Unit: Asian and Asian-American Hermeneutics
Rajkumar Boaz Johnson, North Park University Theological Seminary
Most Indian Christian Theology has focused on Christological Ideas developed by theologians who have come from High Caste Hindu families. The Christology of Brahamobandab Upadhyaya, e.g. develops Christology around the Upanishidic idea of sat-cit-ananda. Unfortunately, these Christologies do not make sense to Low Caste and Dalits people of the Indian Church. Almost no thought has been given to a Christology based on grass roots stories of the Shudras- the hundreds of low castes on Indian society. This paper will present some ideas of the Messiah in the Old Testament, and correlate these to ideas of the Messiah found in Shudra or Other Backward Caste (OBC) literature.
|
Historical and Archaeological Evidence for Crurifragium in John 19:31–37
Program Unit: John, Jesus, and History
Brian L. Johnson, Lincoln Christian University
The detail of the breaking of the leg bones in John 19:31-37 is frequently cited as an historical detail of the Fourth Gospel’s presentation that contributes to a sense of this Gospel’s historical reliability. This paper will assess the Fourth Gospel’s description in relation to the evidence of historical accounts of crurifragium and the archaeological evidence of the Giv’at ha-Mivtar ankle bone in order to determine how specifically the details of this ancient practice can be understood. This paper will suggest that the Gospel of John possibly provides the historian with the earliest detailed account of the practice of crurifragium, and therefore should be treated as a telling piece of the first-century historical evidence. The statement of eyewitness testimony that accompanies this account in John’s Gospel will also be considered in order to understand how this account serves the narrative purposes of the author. This will provide a way to approach the Fourth Gospel’s presentation of history and will suggest the need for a properly nuanced approach to questions of historicity in John’s Gospel.
|
NAPH: Hebrew Grammars Panel
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Vivian L. Johnson, United Theological Seminary
I will be on a panel discussing "A Basic Introduction to Biblical Hebrew."
|
The Promissory and Obligatory Features of God’s Covenant with Abraham in the Light of Abban’s Royal Grant to Yarimlim (Alalakh Text 1 and 456)
Program Unit: Hebrew Scriptures and Cognate Literature
Gordon H. Johnston, Dallas Theological Seminary
In the 1970s, Moshe Weinfeld distinguished two types of ANE covenants: suzerainty treaty (conditional obligatory) from royal grant (unconditional promissory). Weinfeld suggested Yahweh’s covenant promise with Abraham in Genesis 15 was modeled on the unconditional ANE royal grant. Nevertheless, he acknowledged that subsquent passages articulate stipulations upon which fulfillment of the covenant was conditioned (Gen. 17:1-2, 9-14; 18:18-19; 22:14-18; 26:5). Weinfeld suggested this tension could only be explained by the existence of two conflicting traditions—the Yahwistic tradition which viewed the covenant as unconditional and the Deuteronomistic tradition which viewed it as conditional.
This paper will reexamine the royal grant that Weinfeld suggested was the closest parallel to Yahweh’s covenant promise of land to Abraham: Abban’s royal land grant to his faithful servant Yarimlim (Alalakh Texts 1 and 456). According to Weinfeld, AT 1 and 456 are classic examples of an absolutely unconditional covenant. However, this paper will demonstrate that Weinfeld misunderstood the nature of this royal grant, since he ignored the clear obligations that Abban placed on Yarimlim and his descendants in lines 43-58 of AT 456. Whereas the original royal grant document (AT 1) highlighted the promissory element, the subsequent document (AT 456) made explicit what was implicit in the original grant: the obligation of Yarimlim and his descendants to remain loyal to Abban.
This paper also will suggest that the presence of both promissory and obligatory features in AT 1 and 456 provides an important paradigm for understanding the presence of promissory and obligatory features in God’s covenant promise with Abraham. Although the original covenant promise highlighted the promissory feature (Gen 15:13-21), the subsequent passages in the larger narrative made explicit what was apparently implicit in the original grant: the obligation of Abraham and his future descendants to obey God (Gen 17:1-2, 9-14; 18:18-19; 22:14-18; 26:5). This represents a classic example of how ancient Near Eastern literature—when properly handled/interpreted—may clarify imporant features—both individual passages as well as theological themes as a whole—in the Hebrew Scriptures.
|
A Critical Re-Evaluation of Moshe Weinfeld’s Traditio-Historical Analysis of the Promissory and Obligatory Passages Related to the Abrahamic Covenant
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Gordon H. Johnston, Dallas Theological Seminary
In the 1970s, Moshe Weinfeld distinguished two types of ancient Near Eastern covenants: suzerainty treaty (conditional obligatory covenant) and royal grant (unconditional promissory covenant). Weinfeld suggested Yahweh’s covenant promise in Genesis 15:13-21 was modeled on the ANE royal grant and therefore was unconditional. Nevertheless, he acknowledged that subsquent passages articulate explicit stipulations upon which fulfillment of the covenant was conditioned (Gen. 17:1-2, 9-14; 18:18-19; 22:14-18; 26:5). Weinfeld suggested this tension could only be explained by the existence of two conflicting traditions—the early Yahwistic tradition which viewed the covenant as unconditional and the later Deuteronomistic tradition which concluded from historical realities of the seventh century that the covenant was conditional.
This paper will reexamine the set of royal grant texts Weinfeld suggested was the closest parallel to Yahweh’s covenant promise of land to Abraham (Gen 15:13-21): Abban’s land grant to his faithful servant Yarimlim (AT 1 and 456). According to Weinfeld, AT 1 and 456 are classic examples of an absolutely unconditional covenant. This paper will show that Weinfeld misunderstood the nature of this royal grant, since he ignored the clear obligations that Abban placed on Yarimlim and his descendants (AT 456: lines 43-58). Whereas the original grant (AT 1) highlighted the promissory element, the subsequent document (AT 456) made explicit what was apparently implicit in the original grant: the obligation of Yarimlim and his future descendants to remain loyal to Abban. By mishandling AT 1 and 456, Weinfeld created a false dichotomy by viewing ANE royal grants as purely promissory and absolutely unconditional.
This paper suggest that the presence of both promissory and obligatory features in AT 1 and 456 provides an important paradigm for understanding the presence of both promissory and obligatory features in God’s covenant with Abraham. Although the original covenant promise highlighted the promise (and thus seemed unconditional), subsequent passages in the larger narrative made explicit what was apparently implicit in the original grant: the obligation of Abraham and his future descendants to obey God. Consequently, the larger narrative dealing with God’s covenant promise to Abraham may feature more literary unity than Weinfeld recognized.
|
The Sabbath as Metaphor in the Second Century C.E.
Program Unit: Sabbath in Text and Tradition
Robert Johnston, Andrews University
Already in Second Temple Judaism the Sabbath had begun to be used as a metaphor for an eschatological millennium and for the celestial repose of God. All this apparently did no damage to the literal seventh day Sabbath, as far as Judaism was concerned. A third metaphoric use took its inspiration from the remarkable dominical saying in Matthew 11:25-30 (called “a Johannine thunderbolt in the Synoptic sky”), signifying a spiritual state. These metaphoric understandings of the Sabbath were taken up by Christian writers, and the third in particular became a popular motif among Gnostics and Gnosticizers, especially Valentinians. It was picked up and used in a slightly less antinomian fashion by writers such as Justin. In the process the idea of a Sabbath experience became separated from the literal Sabbath day, and the latter was discarded. I propose to examine this development.
|
The Sociological Significance of Strangers in the Qumran Movement
Program Unit: Qumran
Jutta Jokiranta, University of Helsinki
Were the strangers (/gerim/) integrated in the Qumran movement or were they a category with utopian significance only, as argued by some (Donaldson 2007)? Were the strangers part of some factions or stages of the movement but not the others? The relevant passages are, for example, those about the covenant where CD includes /gerim /but 1QS does not (CD 14:3-6; 1QS 2:19-25; 6:8-9) as well as the exclusion of /gerim /in 4Q174 and their partial inclusion in 11QT. On what basis are /gerim /rendered as proselytes and does this category bring us any closer to understanding what the status of such persons was? This paper investigates the textual data about the/gerim /in the Dead Sea Scrolls and also addresses the sociological significance of interpreting the /gerim /either as insiders or outsiders or something in between. The classic work by Max Weber saw the changes in the attitudes towards the strangers in the Hebrew Bible as one reflection of the development into a separated confessional community.
|
Pedagogy of Preaching to Empower Ethnic Minority Students
Program Unit: Academy of Homiletics
Song Bok Jon, Boston University
*
|
John, Jesus, and the Kingdom: Re-examining the Meaning of One “Q” Saying
Program Unit: Q
Brice Jones, Yale University
This paper reconsiders the meaning and function of the comparison in Mt 11:11//Lk 7:28 (“Yet the one who is least in the kingdom of Heaven/God is greater than he”). From ancient times to the present, this “Q” saying has been nderstood in various ways. To demonstrate the real ambiguity of this verse, I re-examine the interpretations of three ancient exegetes and three modern exegetes, all of which provide distinctive approaches to the interpretation of the verse. One popular view, for example, is to understand “the one who is least” as an allusion to Jesus, in which he indirectly referred to himself as being less than John. In this view, Jesus is considered, in a real comparative sense, to be “less[er]” than John either in age or earthly status. Another popular view is that “the least” should be identified not with any one individual, but with a group
of persons associated with the kingdom of God. Naturally, the question of whether John is included in or excluded from the kingdom arises. I attempt to show that the comparison in this saying is explained via the idea in Lk 7:29-30, that an example of “the least” seems to be “the people and even the tax collectors” who responded to the call to repentance. I demonstrate further that the portrayal of John following Mt 11:11//Lk 7:28 is not only positive, but it is also likened to the role of Jesus. I argue that the comparison has nothing to do with John and should be seen as a rhetorical device to emphasize the greatness of the kingdom. The question of John’s personal status, then, is irrelevant.
|
From Toland to Baur: Tracks of the History of Research into Jewish Christianity
Program Unit: Jewish Christianity / Christian Judaism
F. Stanley Jones, California State University-Long Beach
The path of John Toland’s seminal insight that the Jewish Christians were the first Christians (and the first heretics) is traced through the reception of Toland in Germany to its establishment in the later writings of Baur. Stops along the way include Semler, Credner, and Gieseler.
|
A Greimassian Senmiotic Approach to the Theodotion Narrative of Susanna
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
Pierre Johan Jordaan, University of Johannesburg
The Theodotion Narrative of Susanna (and the elders) has been examined by various scholars in different ways. The methods used for examining this narrative vary greatly in style. Some are purely grammatical, others use semantics to arrive at meaning. However, only a few follow narrative analysis to determine meaning. The Greimassian semiotic approach has until now not been used as approach to scrutinize the Theodotion Narrative of Susanna. Reasons for this lack are many. One is that Greimas wrote in French thereby making it accessible to only a selected audience. A second reason might be the difficulty of applying this method to narratives. This paper applied the Greimas’ semiotic approach to the narrative with surprising results. The most prominent contribution is that the main question in the narrative seems to be “Who is a real Jew”. The answer is “Anyone who upholds and abides by the law, be it man or woman”. It shows that Susanna is indeed a gender equalizing narrative. Another result is that all the names in this narrative were not just randomly selected but indeed carry great significance in the Jewish tradition. Still another insight shows that there is a spatial tension between Babylon and heaven. Various other insights resulting from the Greimassian semiotic analysis are shown. This approach proved fertile for this popular narrative.
|
Theologizing the Black Atlantic, Black Liberation Theology in a Cosmopolitan Context: From Dutty Boukman to James Cone
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Celucien L. Joseph, University of Texas at Dallas
In this paper I point out the confluences and connections in four texts written by four individuals of African descent. These include my analysis of three poems, one text, and one religions prayer which represent a common black religious consciousness. I consider particularly the common themes of liberty, freedom, resistance, and vindication embedded in those passages, in the tradition of Black Liberation Theology. Consequently, I begin with Dutty Boukman’s prayer of liberty. In the night of August 22, 1791, which initiated the Haitian Revolution, Dutty Bookman, an ex-slave and a religious leader, gattered former slaves and uttered one of the most important prayers in the Slave religious tradition: “Coute la liberte li pale nan coeur nous tous…?” (“Listen to the voice of liberty which speaks in the hearts of all of us…”). Libète pwoklame (liberty proclaimed), libète chante (liberty sung) has then become a myth of the African Diasporic religious experiences. The phrase informs us about the historical tyranny of oppression and suffering, and the collective cry of people of African descent in the pursuit of freedom, universal emancipation, and human dignity. Accordingly, I situate the prayer of Boukman in the tradition of Black religious practices and Africana constructive theological heritage. I then read the four following pieces: Countee Cullen’s “Heritage,” Langston Hughes’s “Goodbye Christ,” and James Cone’s “God of the Oppressed” in the light of Boukamn’s historical invocation. My objective is to demonstrate the parallels between Boukman and Cullen, Hughes and James Cone, and the [inter-] connections and collective aims. I argue that Boukman’s prayer is probably the earliest attempt to articulate a Black Liberation Theology of freedom and therefore is perhaps the seedbed of Africana Liberation Theology. I insist that the prayer of Boukman envisioned a new theological conversation in forms of vindication and collective solidarity across the Black Atlantic.
|
Luke's Dependence on a Written Source for the Passage in Lk 5:33–39
Program Unit: Formation of Luke and Acts
Chang-Wook Jung, Chongshin University
Some scholars argue that the passage in Lk 5:33-39 depends on Mk 2:18-22. It is accepted that the basic structure of the event in Luke is identical to that in Mark. Nevertheless, the differences are too significant to be ignored as trivial matters. To list some of the differences, 1) Luke adds a reference to prayer of Jesus disciples, whereas the question in Mark as well as in Matthew is limited to their fasting. In addition, the Greek word for ‘prayer’ is non-Lukan; 2) Luke describes the final verses (vv.36-39) as parabolic; 3) a proverb in v.39 is unique to Luke’s Gospel. It is probable, therefore, that Luke relies on other written or oral Greek sources. Non-Lukan locutions and characteristics in Lk 5:33-39, which are not found in Mark 2:18-22, may suggest that Luke was dependent on written source(s). This study demonstrates that the passage in Lk 5:33-39 relies on a written Greek source or sources.
|
Stoicism, Social Stratification, and the Q Tradition in James: A Suggestion about James' Audience
Program Unit: Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
David A. Kaden, University of Toronto
James is addressed to “the twelve tribes in the Diaspora”. “Twelve tribes” has been interpreted as a metaphor for “Christians”. But if the greeting is taken at face value, then James’ audience would be Diaspora Judaeans, and the letter itself would be situated in the larger milieu of Hellenistic Judaism. There were several Diasporic centers in antiquity. This paper will argue that James’ audience was in Rome in the early second century CE. This assumes of course that “James” is a pseudonym.
Other scholars have argued for a Roman provenance based, for example, on connections between James and the Shepherd of Hermas. This paper is intended to substantially strengthen this hypothesis. First, by detailing linguistic similarities between James and the Stoic Epictetus, who began his teaching career in Rome. Second, by examining how James adapts the Jesus tradition from Q for an audience higher up the social register than the Q people. Finally, by analyzing James’ rhetorical usage of the categories “rich” and “poor” to situate the audience somewhere in between.
When these data are linked with the social situation in Rome in the early second century CE after the Dacian Wars led by Trajan, a remarkable picture emerges. Trajan’s wars precipitated an economic revival in the capital city, and the letter of James seems to reflect this. The writer’s affinity for Stoicism, the ideology of the Roman “bourgeois”, locks together nicely with the adaptation of the Q tradition for an audience higher up the social register. It also explains why the writer rhetorically locates the audience between the rich and poor, on the one hand urging them to care for the latter, and on the other warning them not to become greedy like the former.
|
"Did God Plant a Garden in the Manner of a Farmer?" Divine / Human Relationship in Origen
Program Unit: Christian Theology and the Bible
George Kalantzis, Wheaton College (Illinois)
This paper examines Origen's view of scriptural hermeneutics through his lens of the hexameron, as he presents it in De Principiis IV. I will argue that Origen's emphasis on the primacy of allegory and the s??p?? of Scripture over historicity allows Origen to work through the theological questions posed by human p??a??es?? (as a guiding principle) and divine foreknowledge and thus provide an alternative reading of divine sovereignty and human responsibility.
|
Antioch and the St. Julian Cult: Cultivating Holiness Across the Urban/Rural Divide
Program Unit: Archaeology of Religion in the Roman World
Dayna S. Kalleres, University of California, San Diego
The martyr site of St. Julian rested some three miles outside of Antioch. While we know that Julian had been bishop of a small town in Cilicia, the mystery remains as to how his bones came to be in this location. Nonetheless, multiple sources testify that this site grew in fame from the late fourth to the sixth centuries. John Chrysostom describes a very popular two-day martyr festival, which consisted of ritual processions tying the urban Christian population tightly to the rural site. Theodoret of Cyrrhus mentions Julian as the preferred site of depositio ad sanctus for the Syrian holy men Aphrahat, Theodosius and Macedonius. Likewise the St. Julian church provided the setting for a rather dramatic and memorable conversion of one of the city’s most notorious sinners in The Life of Pelagia/Pelagius. St. Julian’s enduring appeal to both the citizens of Antioch and the pilgrims traveling through the city is also attested by sixth century sources including Procopius and the Latin text Antonini placentini itinerarium.
In considering Antioch and the St. Julian shrine/church together, this paper seeks to contextualize a larger phenomenon in late antiquity: the deepening symbiotic relationship between the urban environment and the holy rural site. Finally this paper will attempt to explore how the ritual cultivation of holiness transformed both.
|
Depositio Ad Sanctos—Using the Dead to Condemn the Living
Program Unit: Religious World of Late Antiquity
Dayna S. Kalleres, University of California, San Diego
The practice of depositio or inhumatio ad sanctos—i.e., seeking burial next to a martyr—is attested prior to the fourth century. With Constantine, however, the practice dramatically increased, and scholars have recognized the ritual’s Christianizing effect upon the urban sphere. Constantine himself provides a clear example of the phenomenon. In 336ce, the emperor violated Roman law and offended religious sensibilities in his translation of the relics of Andrew and Luke to his own mausoleum within the walls of Constantinople. Constantine’s actions prefigured the larger transformation from pagan to Christian city as ad sanctos practices challenged the purity/impurity divide lending shape to the urban versus rural arrangement of the Graeco-Roman world. This paper attempts a closer examination of the dynamics of religious as well as urban transformation carried within this practice by comparing two famous examples: 1) Ambrose’s inclusion of the bones of Gervasius and Protasius in the Ambrosiana just outside Milan and 2) Meletius’ translation of the Babylas relics to his own martyrium within Antioch. By reading these incidents in the context of the Arian/Nicene battles plaguing both episcopacies, I hope to elucidate the manner in which the miracles associated with those relics assumed a theological edge inscribing the religious demographics within and around their respective cities. To that end, I propose that Ambrose and Meletius intended the arrangement and specific location of the (holy) dead to define not only the orthodoxy and heresy but also the legitimate residency of the (not so holy) living.
|
As She Did, Do to Her: Revenge Fantasies and Jeremiah's OAN
Program Unit: Writing/Reading Jeremiah
Amy Kalmanofsky, The Jewish Theological Seminary of America
Found throughout the prophetic literature, the oracles against the nations (OAN) raise critical rhetorical questions. To whom are these oracles addressed and for what purpose? Are they aimed at Israel in an effort to bolster confidence and to instill hope in Israel's future defeat of their enemies? Or, are they aimed at Israel's enemies proving God's (and Israel's and even the prophet's) triumphant place in the universe? Applying contemporary literary and film theory, I consider the OAN in the book of Jeremiah as examples of revenge fantasies, particularly rape revenge fantasies. In the first part of this paper, I identify Jeremiah's OAN as revenge fantasies. Like _Thelma and Louise_ or _The Accused_, Jeremiah's OAN are fantasies of retribution that provide valuable insight into Israel's experience of the Babylonian conquest. Seen as revenge fantasies, Jeremiah's OAN are about Israel and for Israel. They reveal Israel's self-perception and convey Israel's experience as a victim. Yet questions remain about the rhetorical purpose of these oracles. Do Jeremiah's OAN incite or provide cathartic comfort? Do they describe Israel's transformation or do they work to transform Israel? In the second part of this paper, I address the rhetorical function of Jeremiah's OAN as revenge fantasies.
|
The Origin Of The Samaritans
Program Unit:
Magnar Kartveit, School of Mission & Theology (Misjonshogskolen i Stavanger) (Norway)
This presentation will consist of a brief overview of the author's new book.
|
An Intersectional Approach to the Pastoral Epistles
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
Marianna Kartzow, University of Oslo
Intersectionality has become the primary analytic tool that feminist and anti-racist scholars deploy for theorizing identity and oppression. This paper aims at using an intersectional approach to the Pastoral Epistles in order to highlight issues of power and dominance. Instead of examining gender, race, class, age, and sexuality etc. as separate categories of difference, intersectionality explores how these categories mutually construct one another and modifying and reinforcing each other. In addition, intersectionality not only helps to reveal complexities and dilemmas in what we study, but also challenge interpreters and scholars to be critical to their own positions. For intersectional theorists, marginalized subjects have an epistemic advantage. I ask: How can the Pastoral Epistles various statements about wives, Jews or slaves be understood by help of intersectionalty? And how can we as interpreters deal with the intersecting power structures constructed by these epistles?
|
The Apocryphal Mary in the Cubiculum of the Velata in the Priscilla Catacomb
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Ally Kateusz, University of Missouri
This paper will build upon a paper titled "Using Later Iconographic Analogues to Identify Apocryphal Scenes in Early Art" which I presented at the 2009 SBL International Meeting. That paper reviewed sixth century images identified by art historians as Mary at the Test of Bitter Water -- a scene from the Protevangelion -- and then showed that these images have several points of contact with the unusual left hand scene in the main fresco in the Cubiculum of the Velata. In the current paper I will briefly review the methodology of using later iconographic analogues to identify scenes in earlier art, illustrated by the images of the 2009 paper. Then I will compare the center figures in the catacomb fresco -- an orante female beneath the Good Shepherd inside a circle -- with fifth century and later extracanonical scenes known as "The Ascension of Christ." These later scenes depict an orante Mary beneath Christ inside a circle. In some of these later scenes, apostles flank Mary and angels flank Christ, thus I propose that this iconography may depict a post-resurrection scene from the third century Gospel of Bartholomew where the apostles entreat Mary to lead them in prayer -- and then Mary stands before them, lifts her hands to heaven, and prays to her son above. I will show that the catacomb iconography has significant points of contact with the later iconography (examples of which are found in Rome). If correct, then the composition of the entire fresco can be seen as two smaller scenes about the miraculous birth of Jesus flanking a central scene about his Ascension. The identification of apocryphal scenes in the Cubiculum of the Velata would mean that apocryphal gospels were the source of some of the earliest gospel scenes in the catacombs.
|
The Lucianic Text of the Song of Hannah
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Historical Books
Tuukka Kauhanen, University of Helsinki
This paper offers an evaluation of the Lucianic text of the Song of Hannah (1 Sam 2:1-10) in the light of recent theories concerning the overall nature of the Lucianic text. Special consideration will be given to the readings of Tertullian from the viewpoint of the proto-Lucianic problem.
|
Methodological Assumptions in Historical Jesus Studies
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
Craig S. Keener, Palmer Theological Seminary of Eastern University
The Synoptics and their putative sources are our fullest helpful consensus sources for historical Jesus research. While many approaches have provided much insight, reading the Gospels as one would read other biographies of recent figures from their era may invite greater appreciation for the traditions they contain. Likewise, concrete information about oral memory and written sources from the period invite the same tendency. One's specific approach to the sources is determined partly by the nature of one's historical interest (finding a critical minimum, maximum, or what is most probable on historical grounds), but often also by one's focus.
|
Maintaining Order through Subversion: A Fresh Approach to the Structure and Thematic Development of Psalm 8
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
H J Keener, Baylor University
Despite the copious literature that Psalm 8 has generated, understanding the structure and thematic development of the psalm still proves difficult. On first blush, the various topics of Ps 8:2b-4 may not seem to relate with one another or with the rest of the psalm, and accounting for the meaning of Ps 8:3 is especially difficult. Furthermore, while three clear themes run throughout the psalm, readers may be less clear how, exactly, these three themes cohere together to form a thematic unity. This paper proposes a fresh approach to the thematic development of Psalm 8 that addresses all of these difficulties.
The study analyzes the body of the psalm (verses 2b-9) by considering the way in which the psalmist presents each of Psalm 8’s main topics. This analysis will demonstrate that the poet treats each topic in a similar programmatic way and interweaves the topics together artfully, creating what Alter calls “a single panorama with multiple elements held nicely together.” Three parallel reversals drive along the body of the psalm; in each case, the psalm introduces the reader to a relatively inferior thing, and then leads the reader into a contemplation of the exalted position that the inferior thing has in the created order. The LORD’s decision to give the most exalted place to the relatively insignificant human is the focal point of the body of the psalm, and all three of the psalm’s reversals illustrate the excellence of the name of the LORD (Ps 8:2a, 10). The overarching message of Psalm 8, therefore, is that the LORD makes His name excellent in all the earth by establishing and maintaining the created order through the exaltation of things that seem otherwise to be insignificant. In so doing, the LORD subverts human expectations and thwarts all of his enemies.
|
The Rulers of the Heavens and the Rulers of the Earth: Psalm 8 and the First Creation Account
Program Unit: Pentateuch
H. J. Keener, Baylor University
This study will read Psalm 8 in light of Gen 1:1-2:4, exploring how Psalm 8 picks up material from the creation account and reconfigures it in a new context. First, the study will re-examine the question of the historical relationship between the two passages, arguing that it is highly probable that Psalm 8 is reflecting upon either the creation account found in Genesis 1 or a very similar version of the creation account. Next, the paper will survey the points of contact between Psalm 8 and Genesis 1, identifying the themes from Genesis 1 that the psalmist gives her attention to; Psalm 8, it will be shown, contains two uneven reflections upon creation (a reflection upon elements from the fourth day of creation [Ps 8:2b, 4], and a reflection upon elements of the sixth day of creation [Ps 8:5-9]), while at the same time using language evocative of the entire creation account of Genesis 1 (Ps 8:2, 10).
From there, the study will reconsider the content and structure of the first creation account. The study will argue that, in focusing on the creation of the heavenly luminaries (Gen 1:14-20) and humanity (Gen 1:26-30), the psalm turns the reader’s attention to the two climactic moments in the creation account. By reflecting upon the created things that Genesis 1 describes as God’s representative rulers of their respective domains, the psalmist meditates upon the way in which YHWH maintains the created order. Furthermore, the two uneven meditations also serve to clarify the place of the human in creation by contrasting the human with the heavenly bodies. As a result, when read as a hymnic meditation upon the first creation account, Psalm 8 emphasizes God’s maintenance in the created order through the exaltation of the seemingly insignificant human to a position of honor.
|
Memory, Jesus, and Early Christian Media Culture
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Chris Keith, Lincoln Christian University
Consideration of how studies in social memory inform studies of Jesus in relation to early Christian media culture.
|
Forms of Contact with the Supernatural in the Construction of Christianity: Experiencing and Assigning Value to Persecution in the New Testament
Program Unit: Construction of Christian Identities
James A. Kelhoffer, University of Uppsala
This paper examines depictions of withstanding persecution in the NT as examples of forms of contact with the supernatural and their role in the formation of early Christian religious identity. Rom 8:17 exemplifies the thesis in stipulating that if one has suffered for, or with, Christ, there is assurance that the believer will also be glorified with Christ. Likewise, in the Synoptic tradition the believer must take up his or her cross (Mark 8:34 par.; “daily,” according to Luke 9:23), in order to be Christ’s follower.
Experiences of the supernatural by means of the persecution also play a role in Paul’s depictions of his experiences of Christ. E.g., in Phil 3:10–11, Paul wants to know not only “the power of [Christ’s] resurrection” but also “the sharing/fellowship [koinonia] of his sufferings,” to “attain the resurrection from the dead.” Experiences of hardship and persecution also come to the fore in Paul’s constructions of his apostolic authority. At Gal 6:17 Paul demands that “no one,” including his Christian opponents, “make trouble for me; for I carry the marks [stigmata] of Jesus branded on my body.” In this instance one could speak of a “privileged” contact with the supernatural, since Paul speaks of his particular authority as Christ’s apostle. Paul also accuses his Christian opponents that they proclaim a false gospel, in order to avoid persecution (Gal 6:12). One subtext of the construction of apostolic authority in Gal 6:12, 17 is that the Galatian agitators lack a privileged experience of, with, or for Christ that Paul can amply demonstrate through the stigmata of his previous persecutions.
These NT witnesses, to which numerous others could be added (e.g., 1 Thess 1:6; 2:14; 3:1–6; Heb 10:32–34; 13:13; 1 Pet 2:18–25; 3:1–2), merit testing the thesis to what extent depictions of withstanding persecution contributed to constructions of religious identity in early Christian literature.
|
What Would Moses Do? On Applying the Test of a False Prophet to the Current Climate Crisis
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Joseph Ryan Kelly, Harding University Graduate School of Religion
A test for identifying a false prophet is set forth at the conclusion of Deuteronomy 18: a prophecy that does not come true is "a word that YHWH did not speak." However, this test would prove problematic for the larger phenomenon of prophecy in the Hebrew Bible. Much of Israel's prophetic tradition is not predictive in character. Of the tradition that is predictive, most of the prophecies are contingent, allowing for the possibility of divine compassion in response to human repentance. Other prophecies that look forward speak of events that fall beyond the horizon of the experience of the human audience. The limited usefulness of this test for authenticating a prophetic message renders it insufficient for creating the paradigmatic response to prophetic messages. In our modern context, many within the scientific community are declaring oracles of doom regarding the current climate crisis. The response, much like in ancient Israel, reflects differing approaches to authenticating the prophetic message. Reading Israel's own matrix of responses, from the simplistic approach of Deuteronomy to the more radical approach embodied by the king of Nineveh, in light of modern day prophetic messages provides unique insights into how modern individuals might reflect upon and respond to the current climate change crisis.
|
Rachel and Leah: Migrations of the Matriarchs and Israel's Ethnic Myth
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Elisabeth Robertson Kennedy, Evangelical Theological Seminary in Cairo
A literary reading of Genesis 29-31 in comparison with Genesis 24 reveals a striking parallel structure in the decision of each ancestress to migrate to Canaan. Narrative emphasis on these moments of choice highlights personal autonomy and responsibility for the matriarchs in their response to a divine call. Each woman makes an individual commitment to a new kin group and a new land, just as Abraham and Sarah made in their initial migration (Genesis 12). The matriarch’s responses to narrative representations of a divine imperative stand alongside, and challenge, narrative portrayal of male initiative in the choice of marriage partners.
Results of the exegesis are interpreted using the sociological theory of Anthony D. Smith. Smith’s work on ethnic myth eschews a singular focus on boundary mechanisms in the construction of group identity, in favor of an emphasis on the cultural/symbolic content of origin myths and their power in identity formation. Current scholarly discussion regarding the endogamous structure of patriarchal marriages can benefit from the use of Smith’s thought to illuminate the importance of migration decisions made by Israel’s matriarchs, alongside the well-rehearsed significance of kinship structures as boundary markers.
A close reading of the migration decisions made by Rebekah, Rachel, and Leah sheds fresh light in several areas. (1) The centrality of the migration motif in the origin stories of Israel and its nuanced significance for both male and female members of Israelite society. (2) The addition of a focus on female choice to the ongoing debate regarding endogamy in Genesis. (3) The uncovering of a structural parallel in the Genesis narrative that can generate further fruitful literary analysis.
|
Angels and Angles: Courtroom Scenes, Ideology, and Angels as Messengers of Characters and Authors in Late Antique Literature
Program Unit: Art and Religions of Antiquity
Meira Z. Kensky, Coe College
This paper will examine the role that angels play in early Christian depictions of heavenly trials. While often angels bring messages to and from God, and present cases to God, in courtroom scenes, angels can also serve an additional narrative function, in that they carry messages and directions from the author to the reader. By close examination of texts such as the Visio Pauli and the Apocalypse of Peter and reference to emergence of Christian visual iconography, I will demonstrate the function of angels in the process of judgment, not only as they appear on the page and the frieze, but also as they mediate authorial ideology and exhortation, providing the angle and lens for the intended audience.
|
The Edict of Flaccus and the Violence in Alexandria in 38 CE
Program Unit: Philo of Alexandria
Allen Kerkeslager, Saint Joseph's University
In previous articles I argued that the central dynamic in the violence in Alexandria in 38 CE was Roman imperialism rather than disputes over Greek civic status or Egyptian religious practice (SPhA 17 [2005] 49-94; JSJ 37 [2006] 367-400; REJ 168 [2009] 1-49). Ethnic tensions only offered a staging ground for playing out immediate conflicts between Roman elites, including the imperial household and its Alexandrian supporters, Flaccus, and the Roman client Agrippa I. The manipulation of the public in their rivalries climaxed in the Judean violation of the Alexandrian funerary rites for Caligula's sister Drusilla and the subsequent Roman response. This included officially sanctioned attacks on the Judean community. In this approach, the edict of Flaccus was a punitive decree directed at a Judean crime.
The present study sets this edict more precisely within the context of Roman political and legal policies. These included unresolved internal inconsistencies that had been created within the Roman legal system by the new program of deifying emperors, which was redefining the crime of treason. This inadvertently brought Roman policies of respecting provincial religious sensitivities (in this case Judean) into conflict with policies for expressing loyalty to Rome. Flaccus was invested with full discretionary authority to articulate his own approach to such tensions when dealing with the Judean crime. The edict's language and consequences suggest that he chose to reduce Judeans to a status historically assigned to enemies recently defeated in war. While Flaccus may have exploited legal ambiguities in response to a personal insult from Agrippa, his edict and the violence that followed were in harmony with established Roman policies. Caligula's plans for the temple indicate he agreed with Flaccus's interpretation of Roman law.
|
Paul, the Didache, and the Two Ways
Program Unit: Didache in Context
Taras Khomych, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
During the past decade there has been a noticeable increase of interest in the Two Ways tradition in the Second Temple Judaism. In general, the Two Ways material sets out antitheses, such as life versus death, truth versus falsehood, flesh versus spirit, etc, presenting on the one hand, positive items as examples to follow, and, on the other, negative ones, to be avoided. This opposition scheme emerges preeminently, although not exclusively, in the Two Ways section of the Didache. There is a shortage of studies of the Two Ways in the Pauline Epistles and their comparison with the Didache. This paper seeks to fill in this gap. I will argue that the investigation of this Jewish motif in Pauline writings can shed new light particularly on Paul’s polemical passages (e.g. 2 Cor 5; Gal 5) addressing the question of whether they should be interpreted as polemics with or within Judaism.
|
Another Gospel: Exploring Early Christian Diversity with Paul and the Didache
Program Unit: Extent of Theological Diversity in Earliest Christianity
Taras Khomych, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
The issue of diversity in early Christianity has recently attracted a lively scholarly interest. In this field of research the Didache received a relatively limited attention. This contribution seeks to fill in this gap by juxtaposing the notion of "euangelion" from the Didache to that of the Pauline epistles.
It is generally recognized that the Pauline "gospel" was focused unambiguously on the Lord Jesus Christ, particularly emphasizing His death and resurrection. The evidence of the Didache, however, is remarkably different. As opposed to Paul, the Didache is notably not centered on Christology. Focusing instead on the expectation of the ultimate arrival of the Lord God, this document presents Jesus as God’s servant, who revealed the will of the Lord. Accordingly the term "euangelion", which reappears four times in this short document, can hardly be associated with the death and resurrection of Jesus Christ. As a matter of fact, these crucial for Paul topics, are not even mentioned in this text. The notion of "euangelion", however, is found there predominantly in the paraenetic context. The evidence of the Didache, radically different from that of the Pauline epistles, which is echoed in the rest of the New Testament, yields invaluable information about the origins of Christianity. This paper highlights the importance of the Didache, insisting that its investigation would advance the ongoing research on the diversity in early Christianity.
|
Acting as Midwives
Program Unit: African-American Biblical Hermeneutics
Erica Kierulf, Union Presbyterian Seminary
My thesis is that artistic images are theological and ethical texts waiting to be mined as liberative gems. Dr. Richard Viladesau’s Theology and the Arts: Encountering God through Music, Art and Rhetoric supports my hypothesis by suggesting that visual art is an extra-canonical source which can serve two functions; first as a historical narrative, second as a mode of reflection or an embodiment of ideas and values. This means that biblical texts about slave midwives, such as Exodus 1:15-21, are not the only form of witness to tumultuous attacks perpetrated by slave owners upon enslaved women’s bodies and psyches. Extra-biblical texts, like the black paper silhouettes created by Kara Walker, testify to similar heinous atrocities and inhumane cruelties that occurred in the southern region of the United States during the antebellum era. If mined for their interpretive possibilities, these visual narratives become liberative sources for the marginalized and oppressed.
Moreover, common in both Exodus 1:15-21 and Kara Walker’s black paper silhouettes is the theme of midwifery. In my ongoing excavation of enslaved women’s experiential realities in the Antebellum South, I find evidence documenting that many bondswomen functioned as midwives. Slave midwives integrated African-centered and Euro-centered traditions in order to create elaborate systems of care to aid women during childbirth. They transmitted gynecological information and secrets of root-work to the women and girls on the plantation enabling these individuals to survive with dignity in spite of their precarious conditions as commodities who bore the humiliation of being treated as stock for breeding. Midwives’ efforts forged the foundations of community welfare as they worked to meet the medical and spiritual needs of pregnant slave women. Thus, midwifery is an appropriate metaphor for critiquing racial justice and liberation ethics. Enslaved women’s lives in Exodus 1:15-21 read through Kara Walker's black paper silhouettes reveal midwives as prophetic moral agents in their struggle to hold onto human dignity while creating positive life affirmations.
|
Imitating Christ: Jesus as a Model in Cognitive Learning Theory
Program Unit: Psychology and Biblical Studies
D. Andrew Kille, Bible Workbench
Paul writes in 1 Cor. 11:1 "Be imitators of me, as I imitate Christ." Paul calls upon his hearers/readers to engage in mimesis, a concept familiar in the ancient world. Cognitive Learning Theory emphasizes the importance of models for shaping behavior. By observing the behavior of the model and internalizing it, an individual can create an internal reinforcement for desired behavior. Paul, however, is no longer with us in the flesh. What happens when a model is no longer an external phenomenon but is itself an imaginative construction? Who is the "me" of 1Cor 11:1, and who is the "Christ" that is to be emulated? Through the lens of cognitive learning theory we will explore the role of the imitation of Christ from Paul to the contemporary WWJD (What Would Jesus Do?) movement.
|
Easter Sermons from the Gospel of Mark
Program Unit: Homiletics and Biblical Studies
John Killinger, Vanderbilt, Samford (retired)
Many preachers planning Easter sermons shy away from Mark because they consider its ending disappointing ("they said nothing to anyone, for they were afraid"). But careful literary examination reveals at least two very preachable post-resurrection accounts earlier in the Gospel, in the stilling-of-the-storm stories of 4:35-41 and 6:47-52.
|
YHWH as Jealous Husband: Abusive Authoritarian or Passionate Protector? A Reexamination of a Prophetic Image
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Brittany Kim, Wheaton College
Given the shocking metaphorical depictions in the prophetic literature of Zion/Jerusalem as YHWH’s adulterous wife and of YHWH’s resultant rejection and humiliation of her (e.g., Hos 1–3; Jer 2–3; Ezek 16, 23), some contemporary scholars, such as Julia O’Brien and Linda Day, denounce these texts as promoting a picture of God as an abusive, authoritarian husband and thereby implicitly legitimizing such practices in human marriages. They accuse commentators who follow more traditional approaches to these texts of romanticizing the relationship between YHWH and Zion/Jerusalem and ignoring the more troubling, violent aspects of these texts. This paper seeks to reexamine this prophetic image (1) by focusing on the anthropopathic motif of divine jealousy through an analysis of the usage of the qn’ root in the Hebrew Bible, (2) by comparing these prophetic texts with pentateuchal legislation concerning adultery and spousal jealousy in order to consider whether the divine response to Zion/Jerusalem’s “adultery” may be seen to legitimize a similar human response, and (3) by determining how the marriage metaphor functions rhetorically in the prophets. The paper will argue that, while the violence in these texts should not be glossed over, in using the metaphor of marriage and adultery the prophetic authors draw on their experience of the harsher realities of their world in order to shock Israel into recognizing its betrayal of YHWH and to portray YHWH as Israel’s passionate protector, who will bring judgment if necessary in order to drive Israel away from idolatry and back to him. Within the context of the Hebrew Bible these texts do not legitimize abusive behavior in human relationships but operate on the premise that, unlike human husbands, YHWH alone, as the holy and transcendent God, is judge.
|
Noah’s Ark: Spatiality, Power, and the Memory of the Holocaust
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
Dong Sung Kim, Drew University
Reading the biblical story of the Flood after the Holocaust bears ethical difficulties. What if the Ark was made of transparent and limpid glass, through which those inside could clearly see what was happening outside? Could those inside the Ark still celebrate their salvation/survival while seeing the millions of bodies floating in front of their faces? In this essay, I would like to further the present scholarly and artistic discussion on ethical reading of the Deluge by using Edward Soja’s space theory as my hermeneutical approach.
This essay, thus, explores such questions as the following: What kind of spatiality is constructed in the Ark? What does such a construction do to the insiders of the Ark, as well as the outsiders? What is the divine intention in designing the Ark in such a way—salvation or discipline? How is such spatiality actually used/experienced by Noah, his crews, and animal passengers? Which is Noah’s ark reminiscent of, the ‘safe haven’ or the sealed prison cells of the Concentration Camp?
Such comparative reading between the space of the Ark and the Concentration Camp is to use the image of the Ark as a trope to understand the Death Camp, and vice versa. To borrow the words of Danna Nolan Fewell and Gary A. Phillips, such a reading would “usher us into broken worlds where lives were lived in affliction and uncertainty, where lives depended upon the text’s construction, and where lives today continue to depend upon the text’s interpretation.”
By this way of reading, I intend to deconstruct the insider (the saved)/outsider (the drowned) binary that is built in and around the Ark narrative, and invite biblical readers to re-think about our fixation with salvific reading of the biblical stories.
|
Preaching as an Act of Shared Leadership
Program Unit: Academy of Homiletics
Eunjoo Mary Kim, Iliff School of Theology
*
|
Isaiah 22: A Crux or a Clue in Isaiah 13–23?
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Hyun Chul Paul Kim, Methodist Theological School in Ohio
In the commonly called “Oracles against the Nations” of Isa 13-23 (OAN), there is one section which seems an anomaly. It is chapter 22, the so-called “valley of vision” oracle, in which Judah rather than other nations is accused and announced of her judgment. This study examines how this chapter functions in the OAN especially in comparison with the OAN in Amos, Jeremiah, Ezekiel, and possibly the Twelve. Special attention will be given as to the structural pattern of Amos 1-2, which may have been a template of Isaiah’s OAN, except with Isaiah’s shift of the climax from Israel/Judah to Babylon, which roughly envelopes the OAN (Isa 13-14 and 21). Likewise, unlike the OAN in Jeremiah (MT) and Ezekiel, which conclude with the targets of Babylon and Egypt respectively, the OAN in Isaiah do not conclude with Babylon but continues on, possibly until its recapitulation in the anti-Edom oracle (Isa 34). In light of these comparisons, a closer look at Isa 22 may provide further clues with regard to not only its place and function within Isa 13-23 (and 24-35) but also its theological implications of Zion’s fate in relation to the overall themes of the entire book of Isaiah.
|
The Conceptions of Death and the Netherworld in the Tablets of Ilimilku of Ugarit
Program Unit: Ugaritic Studies and Northwest Semitic Epigraphy
Jun Kim, Graduate Theological Union
Ilimilku was a scribe in the house of the high priest Attenu of Ugarit, which was located on the Mediterranean coast of Syria at its height from 14th to 12th century B.C.E. Ilimilku’s three major Ugaritic epics —the Baal Cycle (1.1-1.6), the Keret epic (1.14-1.16), and the Aqhat epic (1.17-1.19, cf. 1.21-1.22)—offer a unique opportunity to explore the concepts of death and the Netherworld because the tablets were the works of a scribe (or an editing author) in a limited period of time and place.
This study aims at exploring the concept of death and the Netherworld, focusing on Ilimilku’s three major works in conjunction with other Ugaritic texts. This paper is organized into three main parts. The first part will be an examination of certain patterns of death themes in Ilimilku’s three works, especially between the Baal Cycle and the Keret epic, showing several patterns of themes, such as death and drought, the reception of a report of death and the reaction of listeners, the search for corpses and burials, and revenge by sister/female figures. The second part will mainly focus on the concepts of death and the Netherworld in relation to each character of Illimilku’s works. The concepts of death and the Netherworld include descriptions of the Netherworld, human mortality, immortality, resurrection, chthonic deities, and funeral practices. In the third part, the natures of Mot and Raphaim (rpi, rpum) in Ilimilku’s works are explored in the light of the larger Ugaritic cultural context. Mot is regarded as a main deity of death and the Netherworld in the Baal Cycle; however, he is totally absent both from the Ugaritic god list and from the sacrificial and ritual texts. This raises the question whether Mot should be regarded as the god of death and the Netherworld. Another investigation explores the nature of Raphaim. In Ilimilku’s tablets, Keret and Aqhat are associated with Raphaim. Their association with Raphaim opens the interpretation possibility that they could become deified beings after their death.
|
Tradition, Memory, and Scribes: Critical Reflections on Some Recent Accounts of the Origins of the Double Tradition
Program Unit: Q
Alan Kirk, James Madison University
Past as well as a number of recent attempts to conceive the double tradition as primarily oral or to disperse it into indeterminate oral and/or written sources are predicated on faulty assumptions about the media realities of the ancient world—and more precisely, faulty assumptions about the relationships among oral tradition, written tradition, and memory, particularly as these intersect in scribal competencies and practices. Similar criticisms may be leveled, however, at literary conceptions of Q of the sort that fail to account for the effects of oral practices on Q’s constitution, utilization, and transmission and thus overestimate its literary isolation within early Christianity.
|
Memory and Jesus Traditions
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Alan Kirk, James Madison University
This paper will consider how social memory theory can contribute to the study of Jesus traditions.
|
Toward a Theory of Narrative Transformation: The Importance of First Context in Paul’s Scriptural Citations
Program Unit: Intertextuality in the New Testament
J. R. Daniel Kirk, Fuller Theological Seminary
A perennial question when adjudicating the significance of intertextuality in the NT is the extent to which the original context of the quoted passage should influence our understanding of its NT usage. This paper provides some preliminary building blocks for constructing a theory of “narrative transformation” in Paul’s citations of scripture.
This model suggests that a full understanding of Paul’s hermeneutical method requires the reader to take stock of the narrative dynamics within which the OT passage originally found its coherence. However, this attention to first context provides the reader not with a meaning that Paul imports into his text, but with a story that he transforms by bringing it to bear on his work as an apostle of a crucified and resurrected messiah.
This paper will make a preliminary case for a model of narrative transformation by examining Paul’s citations of Isa 59:20 in Rom 11:26 and of Ps 68:10 in Rom 15:3. In the former case, attention to the original narrative movement, in conjunction with Paul’s alteration of the text and his broader argument in Romans 11, will show the power of the theory to provide an interpretation that clarifies the meaning of a perennially challenging text. With this in place, the second investigation will highlight the potential for a theory of narrative transformation to open up possibilities for fresh, even provocative understandings of Paul’s theology by bringing the narrative of the psalm more fully into conversation with the situation in Rome.
By investigating the importance of “narrative dynamics” in two scriptural passages that are not narrative in genre, the paper hopes to underscore the broadly applicable nature of “narrative transformation,” and its importance even for interpreting passages that might not, at first glance, seem amenable to such an approach.
|
Precious Memories: Rule of Law in Deuteronomy as Catalyst and Contradiction of Domestic Violence
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Cheryl Kirk-Duggan, Shaw University Divinty School
*
|
Mapping Martyrs: Commemorating Violent Death to Claim Urban Topography
Program Unit: Social History of Formative Christianity and Judaism
Bradford Kirkegaard, San Diego State University
This paper maps a violent martyrdom account onto the preserved remains of the city of Aphrodisias to envision Christian claiming of a largely pagan landscape in the 5th and 6th centuries during a critical period of urban transformation. Known for its late survival of paganism and thriving Jewish community, Aphrodisias’ Christian community has proven more elusive, with little preserved evidence until the sudden transformation of the city’s temple into its new cathedral at the end of the fifth century. For roughly two centuries, Christianity, Judaism and paganism co-existed with overlapping and occasionally competing sacred landscapes within the city. Christian claims on the city of Aphrodisias, as in many cities throughout the empire, were gradual and problematic. In a city replete with monuments and art that depicted attachment to the goddess Aphrodite and the city’s rich religious history and identity, Christianity had its work cut out for it. The construction of the new cathedral in place of the goddess’s temple was a frontal assault on earlier religious identity, but it still only created an isolated monument within what remained a “pagan” topography.
At Aphrodisias, as in other cities, earlier martyrs provided a ready vehicle for remaking sacred space. Through commemoration and re-enactment of the martyrdom of two local martyrs, Aphrodisian Christians were able to re-envision their landscape and history into one of triumph, even as the older buildings continued to dominate the physical topography. Creating a fundamental reorientation, the new cathedral turned its back on the old religious axis and placed new emphasis on existing throroughfares. Mapping the Aphrodisian martyrdom account and festival of Rhodopianus and Diodoretus onto the preserved remains offers a unique vision into how Christians experienced and lived within their city during this nascent period of conflict and transformation.
|
The Rabbinic Art of Memory: Talmudic Spatial Practices and Roman Mnemonics
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Gil Klein, Franklin & Marshall College
The set of memorizing techniques in rabbinic learning and their Graeco-Roman background have been studies extensively in recent scholarship. However, the mnemonic aspect of rabbinic spatial practices such as the Shabbat Boundary (tehum shabbat) and the agricultural laws of charity (leket, pe’ah, shikheha) have so far received very little attention. Through a comparison between Roman manuals of land survey and rabbinic texts dealing with such practices, this paper will examine the similar procedures and understandings of memory employed in these two traditions of spatial organization. Roman manuals such as the Corpus Agrimensorum Romanorum were never explored in the context of rabbinic literature, in spite of the striking parallels they contain with Talmudic methods of defining space. As shown by scholars such as Frances Yates, the mental links established in the Graeco-Roman world between language and space for the purpose of memorizing, had significant cultural implications, which extended beyond the functionality of mnemotechnics. This paper will make a similar claim, drawing on architectural, visual and textual material pertaining to rabbinic spatial practices.
|
Panel Discussion: Isaac Kalimi, The Retelling of Chronicles in Jewish Tradition and Literature: A Historical Journal
Program Unit: Midrash
Ralph W. Klein, Lutheran School of Theology at Chicago
I am interested in forming and participating in the panel devoted to a critical discussion of this work (I am writing the Hermeneia Commentary on Chronicles)
There will be other panelists, but I do not know who they are.
|
Mirrors on Yesterday—Reflections for Today: A Cross-Disciplinary Exploration into the Contextualization of ANE Images and Material Culture within the Framework of Adult-Educational Theory
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Iconography and the Bible
Gerald Klingbeil, Andrews University
Biblical texts and ancient Near Eastern pictorial images and material culture are separated by thousands of years from people living in the twenty-first century. This is, however, not only a temporal divide, but also represents a significant ideological (or worldview) divide. Following a brief introduction to important principles of adult-educational theory, this paper describes an experiment of using ancient Near Eastern images and material culture to connect modern, often secular, people to the world of the Bible. It suggests that these images represent helpful means to initiate a truly cross-cultural conversation, linking twenty-first century people (outside of academia) to the concerns and issues of those living in the biblical world.
|
Rethinking Last Supper/Lord's Supper II
Program Unit: Meals in the Greco-Roman World
Matthias Klinghardt, Tu Dresden Germany
This paper will provide a set of theses proposing how we can rethink the origins and development of the Last Supper texts in the New Testament.
|
The Text of Marcion’s Gospel and the Western Text of Luke
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Matthias Klinghardt, TU Dresden Germany
In more than 250 instances the text that is attested for the Gospel used by Marcion and the Marcionites concurs with variant readings of the so-called “Western” text (D it sy) of Luke. These variants include minor differences of little semantic influence but also highly significant differences, among them some of the famous “Western Non-Interpolations”. Since the publication of P75, these “Western” readings vanished from the focus of textual criticism. The problem of the distinct Western text, however, has yet to be solved. In this respect the great number of concurring Marcionite-Western variants poses a particular problem, since it is hardly possible that the heavily criticised “heretic” text exerted such a massive influence on the catholic textual tradition. The paper proposes a new solution, assuming that the Western readings concurring with the Marcionite text are traces of an older pre-canonical Gospel which is basically identical with the Marcionite Gospel. Although it does not solve all the riddles posed by the “Western” text, this assumption closely connects the emergence of the canonical Gospels with the history of the NT textual tradition, thus bringing together research areas that once were closely linked to each other but increasingly drifted apart in the 20th century.
|
Memory, Performance, and the Sayings of Jesus
Program Unit: Memory Perspectives on Early Christianity and Its Greco-Roman Context
John Kloppenborg, University of Toronto
The discussion of memory and the production of the texts of the early Jesus movement is fraught with unhelpful dichotomizing of orality and literacy and remarkable assumptions made about the reliability of human memory to preserve faithfully formulations of the past. This paper, working comparatively with, examines the prevailing models of orality, memory and literacy, with special attention to the Jesus tradition.
|
Deuteronomy, Name Theology, and Divine Location
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Anne K. Knafl, University of Chicago
In the classic work of Gerhard von Rad, P reflects a Kavod-Moed (Glory-Meeting) Theology, in which YHWH’s presence is primarily located in heaven, but descends to earth through the Tent of Meeting. In contrast, Deuteronomy’s Shem (Name) Theology is an attempt to spiritualize earlier cultic traditions which conceptualized the tabernacle as the dwelling place of YHWH. Deuteronomy demythologizes the older view by asserting that it is YHWH’s name, not the deity himself, that resides at the tabernacle. Recently, Benjamin Sommer has argued that D and P, in contrast to J and E, reject the concept of a fluid divine body in favor of their respective Shem and Kavod-Moed theologies which locate God primarily in heaven and as indivisible. I will argue that the D source neither rejects the anthropomorphic deity of the J and E sources nor does it assert that God is only located in heaven, an assumption heavily influenced by Von Rad’s Name Theology. I submit that in D, while the cult site is legitimated by divine mandate and not divine presence, YHWH is still present at the cult site. At the same time, YHWH is located in heaven. Instead of rejecting one or the other concept, the D author embraces both.
|
David in the North
Program Unit:
Ernst Axel Knauf, University of Bern
As an archaeologist and nothing but an archaeologist, David Ussishkin has always sought the dialogue with biblical scholars and historians due to the conviction that our common grasp of history, insofar as it might stand the test of empirical and rational testing, must be the result of the combined efforts of "dirt people" and "text people". This presentation shall try to summarize the impact of David's work on our present knowledge of the Kingdom of Israel (10th century to 720 BCE).
|
The Spirit, the Sacraments, and Sanctification in Cyril of Alexandria's Commentary on Isaiah
Program Unit: Theological Interpretation of Scripture
David Kneip, University of Notre Dame and Abilene Christian University
Prior to the outbreak of the Nestorian controversy, Cyril of Alexandria wrote a monumental commentary on the book of Isaiah. The commentary appears to be tacitly familiar with other Christian interpretations of the great prophetic book, and it exemplifies much early Christian commentary on the Hebrew Bible in that it reveals a consistent focus on Christ as the "*telos* of the Law." Despite the fame of the author and the importance of the commentary, however, it has only recently begun to be published in translation. In this paper I will examine this important and representative work of early Christian exegesis; however, my focus will not be Christology but rather the intersection of pneumatology and soteriology, as it finds expression for Cyril in the sacrament of baptism. The paper will focus on a variety of non-traditional Isaianic texts; as the essay will reveal, Cyril rarely speaks of the Spirit, salvation, and baptism all together, but the many occasions on which he explicitly names two of them suggests that there is an entire conceptual complex at work in this regard. That this complex, constructed as it is of specifically Christian stages in the history of these ideas, can be birthed in Cyril's mind by texts from the *Hebrew* Bible provides for modern interpreters a rich field for understanding how the Hebrew Bible in general, and the book of Isaiah specifically, has been interpreted theologically. Further, the paper's focus on non-traditional lenses for Christian exegesis of the Hebrew Bible (pneumatology, sacramental thought) will add interest for those hearers accustomed to Christological interpretations. Finally, because the commentary is unfamiliar to most scholars, the paper will add to the growing understanding of the commentary itself and early Christian interpretation of Isaiah.
|
The Transformation of Merkabah Mysticism in Early Christianity
Program Unit: Mysticism, Esotericism, and Gnosticism in Antiquity
Jonathan Knight, Katie Wheeler Research Trust/York St John University, UK
This paper examines the transformation of Jewish throne-mysticism in the literature of early Christianity; specifically, the significance of early Christian binitarianism for that strand of thought, and the contribution of mysticism to the development of a New Testament theology
|
The Early Syrian Christology of the Ascension of Isaiah
Program Unit: Syriac Literature and Interpretations of Sacred Texts
Jonathan Knight, Katie Wheeler Research Trust/York St John University, UK
This paper sets out to examine the Christology of the early second century apocalypse known as The Ascension of Isaiah, whose provenance is almost certainly Syria. It collates the evidence and draws some conclusions about the development of Syrian Christianity at the end of the New Testament period.
|
“Cast Out of His Presence”: The Depopulation of Jerusalem and Judah in Kings
Program Unit: Exile (Forced Migrations) in Biblical Literature
Gary N. Knoppers, Pennsylvania State University University Park
In tracing the causes of the Babylonian exiles of 598 and 586 BCE, historians often discuss ill-timed foreign policy shifts and the geo-political changes connected to the disintegration of the Assyrian empire, the rise of the Neo-Babylonian empire, and the resurgent interests of Egypt in the southern Levant. The Deuteronomistic writers do not deny foreign policy mishaps, but their analysis is profoundly confessional. Tying domestic religious practice to the course of Judahite history, the writers of Kings probe Judahite royal and popular responsibility for the foreign invasions that ravage Judah and Jerusalem. The cumulative effect of this devastation is not "the destruction of the people" (contra Noth), but a series of mass deportations from the land. Given the tremendous carnage and death that attended Judah`s last years, why do the Deuteronomistic writers devote such great attention to corporate dislocation? This paper explores the relationship between the writing about Judah’s decline in 2 Kings 24-25 and earlier sections of Deuteronomy and Kings, which discuss the prospect of exile. If time permits, some comparisons will be made between the history of Judah’s demise in Kings and that in Chronicles.
|
Experiencing the Meal: The Role of Johannine Meal Narratives in the Formation of Community Identity
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Esther Kobel, University of Basel
In the narrative world of the Gospel of John the accounts of communal meals and the metaphorical use of food and drink language play an important role.
Communal meals are a central locus for the formation of community and group identity in antiquity. Historical investigations suggest that Christianity spread primarily through the practice of communal meals.
The present paper aims to link the Johannine narrative with the Fourth Gospel’s historical world. The Gospel reaches out beyond its narrative borders to directly address the implied reader. I take this implied reader as a bridge to an extratextual audience. If a real meal of a certain group of Christ-believers formed the “Sitz im Leben” of the Johannine meal accounts, the very accounts of meals would have given significance to these meals that surpassed the intake of calories and contributed to the formation and strengthening of the community’s identity. This will be illustrated with the motif of mutual indwelling that clusters in the meal scene and farewell discourses prior to Jesus’ death (Jn 13-17).
|
Reading the Jeremiah Codex (P.Bodmer XXII/ Mississippi Coptic Codex II) within a Pachomian Context
Program Unit: Christianity in Egypt: Scripture, Tradition, and Reception
Alex Kocar, Princeton University
The aim of this paper is to examine the underlying logic of the Jeremiah Codex (P. Bodmer XXII/ Mississippi Coptic Codex II) as a collection and develop a hypothesis as to its function based upon the deliberate codicological arrangement of the four texts, i.e., Jeremiah, Lamentations, Letter of Jeremiah, and Baruch. In my reading of the Jeremiah Codex, the codicological arrangement and use of nomina sacra indicate a Pachomian context in which the Jeremiah Codex encouraged an identification on behalf of its monastic audience with the destruction, repentance, and redemption of the Israelite community. To further support a Pachomian origin for the Jeremiah codex, I will examine similar Coptic translations of sections of Baruch contained in Horsiesios’ Third and Fourth Letters in light of the same passages as they appear in the Jeremiah Codex. It is my contention that the linguistic and hermeneutical similarities between Horsiesios’ Letters and the Jeremiah Codex demonstrate a shared milieu and lend additional support to James Robinson’s hypothesis of the Dishna collection constituting an example of a monastic library within a Pachomian community.
|
Orphans without a Father: The Protest of the Mother Goddess in Lamentations
Program Unit: Children in the Biblical World
Laurel W. Koepf, Union Theological Seminary
Bat Tsion presents a plaintive figure in the book of Lamentations. From the beginning, an anonymous narrator describes her shame and dishonor in graphic detail. Yet when she speaks, Bat Tsion herself does not dwell for long upon her own suffering. Rather, she continually interrupts the narrator on behalf of her children. This maternal protest is not uncommon in parallel literature; the weeping mother goddess is ubiquitous in the Sumerian Lament for the Destruction of Ur. This mother figure also takes the form of a female personified city in the Nippur Lament. In light of the divine paternal rejection threatened in the Prophets and apparent throughout the book of Lamentations, Bat Tsion is rightly concerned for her children, who are orphaned without a father, and upon whom it follows she herself is now dependent. Attention to Bat Tsion’s maternal role reveals a poetic arc throughout the book of Lamentations, peaking with her central protest to YHWH on behalf of her children, the people.
|
Pentateuchal Semiosis of Esoteric Logos, “Dual-Channel” Poesis, and Other Markers of a Noetic Signifier
Program Unit: Semiotics and Exegesis
Alex Shalom Kohav, Union Institute
The paper proposes three semiotic-discursive planes as a structure of the Pentateuch: (i) social semiotics, ranging from Foucaultian discursive power formations to Thibault’s (2004) notions of semiosis as an activity “guided and modulated along its trajectory by higher-scalar semiotic constraints”; (ii) discourse semiotics, involving the concept of “logos,” with the latter broadened to include an idiosyncratic—and conjectured to be a textually-embedded esoteric Sôd stratum—heretofore-unknown logos unrelated to either mythical or philosophical logoi; and (iii) what may be called literary semiotics and the concept of “poesis” that, in the Pentateuchal text, encompasses complex literary notions, from markedness and parabolic projection; a special, Sôd-linked code; a dedicated genre; to Pentateuch-specific, one-of-a-kind “Asymmetric Noetic Parallelism” which, this paper proposes, is among the principal methods employed by the Pentateuch to reify key abstract and esoteric principles and notions. The Pentateuchal text is proposed to be seen as a “dual-channel” (Baars 2003[1988]), two-prong narrative: one strand, the conjectured esoteric-noetic Sôd stratum seen as remaining deliberately-unconscious for the typical reader, the other the dominant “surface” or “ostensive” storyline. Husserl’s theory of the intentional act and its tripartite hyletic-noetic-noematic correlates (cf. Føllesdal 2003) are engaged for a noetic probing of the Pentateuchal text; the paper discusses such phenomenological framework in the context of its being superimposed over the Sôd stratum conceptualized as a semiotic “sign,” with its signifier-signified-referent aspects.
Baars, Bernard J.
2003[1988] The Fundamental Role of Context: Unconscious Shaping of Conscious Information. In Essential Sources in the Scientific Study of Consciousness. B.J. Baars, W.P. Banks, and J.B. Newman, eds. Pp. 761-775. Cambridge, MA and London, England: The MIT Press.
Føllesdal, Dagfinn
2003 The Thetic Role of Consciousness. In Husserl's Logical Investigations Reconsidered. D. Fisette, ed. Pp. 11-20. Dordrecht, Boston and London: Kluwer Academic Publishers.
Thibault, Paul J.
2004 Brain, Mind and the Signifying Body: An Ecosocial Semiotic Theory. London and New York: Continuum.
|
The Distribution and Function of the Direct Object Marker (iy)yat in Middle Aramaic
Program Unit: Aramaic Studies
Aaron Koller, Yeshiva University
The direct object marker yat/iyyat appears in Aramaic texts from Old Aramaic and on, but it has long been observed that it does not occur in all texts or all dialects. In this paper the distribution will be re-examined, taking into account the recent arguments of M. L. Folmer on this issue, as well. It will be argued that geographic and dialectal differences explain some of the data, but not all of it, and that a model other than a Stammbaum is needed to account for the Middle Aramaic data in particular. Epigraphic Judean Aramaic uses yat often, as does neighboring Nabatean; it is attested sporadically in Qumran Aramaic but never in the Genesis Apocryphon. Rather than positing a geographical explanation for this distribution, it will be suggested that documentary texts (such as the material from Nahal Hever, Wadi Murabba‘at, and the Bar Koseba letters) were written in a different dialect than literary – and possibly biblicizing – texts such as the Genesis Apocryphon.
|
Review of the Bible Illuminated
Program Unit: Ideology, Culture, and Translation
Jennifer Koosed, Albright College
Review of the Bible Illuminated
|
Making Room for Sacred Space in Jewish: Christian Reconciliation
Program Unit: Romans through History and Cultures
Ralph J. Korner, McMaster University
This paper will explore the use of the term ekklesia (“assembly”) as a socio-religious tool for reconciliation and peace between Christ-followers and Jews, particularly within the book of Romans. In the NT, ekklesia is appropriated as a distinctive term for voluntary associations of Christ-followers who met within, or separately from, Jewish synagogues and/or synagogal gatherings. William Campbell (2006) has incisively examined Paul’s project in Romans 9–11 from the perspective of “Christian” identity formation. Campbell’s work, however, could be expanded to incorporate the theological implications of ekklesia in its role as a creator of group identity for Christ-followers. Of particular import for his argument is the (deutero-) Pauline predilection for portraying those “Christian” voluntary associations (ekklesiai) as sacred space (e.g., living Temple, body of Christ).
This sacralisation of the universal and local body/bodies of Christ-followers (ekklesiai) makes even more persuasive Campbell’s claim that in Romans 9–11 Paul presents the Abrahamic covenant as the common theological thread that ties together Christ-followers and Jews in their shared status as the chosen people of God, but which, at the same time, still affirms ethnic diversity within that theological unity.
The present paper will argue that the (deutero-) Pauline appropriation of ekklesia can be said to serve a reconciliatory function in Romans 9–11 in that it: (1) differentiates Jewish Christ-followers from non-messianic Jews within the semi-public synagogue association, even while at the same time maintaining their sociological interconnectedness as covenantal ethnic Israel, and (2) provides theological continuity between the multi-ethnic communities of gentile Christ-followers and the socio-religious reality called “Israel,” while still upholding the ethnic discontinuity between gentiles and members of ethnic “Israel”, otherwise called Ioudaioi (“Jews”).
|
Toward a Pentecostal Understanding of the Restrainer of 2 Thess 2:6–7
Program Unit: Society for Pentecostal Studies
Waldemar Kowalski, Northwest University
The katechon/restrainer of 2 Thess 2:6-7 has been variously identified as human government (in particular the Roman empire and the Emperor), the Jewish state (James), the proclamation of the gospel (especially Paul), rebellion (Satan), the will of God or his plan, the Holy Spirit, the Church, along with suggestions such as the archangel Michael. This paper will argue for a particularly Pentecostal identification of the Restrainer: that the removal of the Restrainer is the reversal of the coming of the Holy Spirit on the day of Pentecost, without interpreting this as the rapture of the Church. The paper will give a brief synopsis of current opinion, followed by an investigation of textual and other arguments to be made for this identification of the Restrainer as the outpouring of the Spirit, initiated on the day of Pentecost. The conclusion is that the coming of the Holy Spirit on the day of Pentecost culminates eschatologically in a corresponding removal of the outpouring of the Holy Spirit (the removal of the Restrainer).
|
The Jewish Bible – A Christian Perspective
Program Unit:
Robert Kraft, University of Pennsylvania
*
|
Deuteronomy between Torah and Former Prophets: The Case of Deut 1–3
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Reinhard G. Kratz, Universitaet Goettingen
This paper will evaluate the question of the narrative and literary context of the Book of Deuteronomy. I will focus on Deut 1-3, i.e. those chapters that form the beginning of the book as well as containing several cross-references to the preceding and following (narrative and literary) context. Talking up insights first presented in my contribution to the Festschrift for Lothar Perlitt (FRLANT 190, 2000, 101-120) and engaging with some recent publications that explicitly or implicitly react to this proposal I will use Deut. 1–3 as an example in order to discuss the place of Deuteronomy in older and more recent theories of the formation of the Pentateuch and the Former Prophets (Documentary Hypothesis, Deuteronomistic History or Conquest-Narrative Deut–Josh respectively,Pentateuchal D- Composition, Hexateuch or Enneateuch).
|
From Elephantine to Alexandria: The Early Egyptian Diaspora
Program Unit: Literature and History of the Persian Period
Reinhard Kratz, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen
This paper will offer a comparison between the Jewish Diasporas of Elephantine and Alexandria. According to the sources preserved we find here two forms of Judaism: at Elephantine we encounter a lesser known non-biblical Aramaic-speaking form of Judaism while at Alexandria we find a known expression of biblical Judaism, though Greek-speaking. How to explain these different forms historically remains a vexing question. Here we have to take into account also the third Jewish Diaspora known to us, i.e. the temple in Leontopolis. Lastly we will look at the relationship between Egypt and the Jewish homeland (Judah and Samaria).
|
“For in Christ Is Neither Jew Nor Samaritan, But Christ Is One”: Jonathan Edwards’s Use of Galatians 3:28
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Glenn Kreider, Dallas Theological Seminary
In the spring of 1750, Jonathan Edwards (1703-1758) delivered a series of lectures defending his decision to change the practice of open admission to the Lord’s Supper. His predecessor, Solomon Stoddard, had allowed unconverted church members, believing that the sacrament might be a means of conversion. Since assuming the pastorate in 1726, Edwards had followed the same practice. By 1746 his conviction had changed, as he explained in the doctrine defended in this lecture series: “’Tis the mind and will of God that none should be admitted to full communion in the church of Christ but such as in profession, and in the eye of a reasonable judgment, are truly saints or godly persons” (Edwards, “Qualifications for Full Communion,” Works of Jonathan Edwards [New Haven: Yale University Press, 2006], 25:354). This decision contributed to his dismissal from the pastorate in Northampton.
One of the arguments Edwards musters in support of this doctrine is based upon Galatians 3:26-28. The plain meaning of this text, he asserts, is that Jew and Greek, bond and free, male and female are all one in Christ Jesus. What unites all in the church of Christ is saving faith, the faith of Abraham.
In the Redemption Discourse (1739) Edwards similarly defends the unity of all believers through conversion based upon this text, asserting that Jews and Samaritans are one in the church. In this case, he replaces “Greek” with “Samaritan” in quoting Galatians 3:28. Thus, the meaning of the text is plain, although the words themselves allow for emendation.
Edwards uses Galatians 3:28 to defend the unity of the body of Christ based upon conversion by grace through faith. He insists that this is the plain meaning of the text, “beyond all possibility of evasion” (Edwards, “Qualifications for Full Communion,” Works of Jonathan Edwards, 25:391).
|
“It Was Written in Hebrew, and in Latin, and in Greek”: Multilingualism in the Ancient World and the Papyri
Program Unit: Papyrology and Early Christian Backgrounds
Christina M. Kreinecker, Salzburg University
The Passion Narratives contain several occasions in which more than one language has been involved. John 19:20, for example, mentions a title on the cross of Jesus, written in three languages: Greek, Latin, and Hebrew in order to give the reason for his crucifixion. Although there is no papyrological evidence for such a “titlon” a lot can be said about official and private multilingual texts in the papyri and their purpose. One example are the so called “leukomata” of Ptolemaic times, but also bilingual hearings (III–IV CE) that offer a clear difference in the importance of the different languages. While Latin can be characterized as a “language of power” (J. N. Adams), Greek and also Aramaic (in certain parts of the East) have been administrative languages for pragmatic reasons. This arises also the question in what language Pilate and Jesus communicated. Next to an official correspondence with the people, also private examples of bilingualism are given in the papyri.
This paper will address the issue of multilingualism in the Ancient World as it shows itself in documentary papyri and ostraca, and will deal with the question how much Latin and Greek average Galilean or Judean people like Jesus and his disciples might have spoken and understood.
|
As He Who Called You Is Holy: Missional Holiness and the People of God in 1 Peter
Program Unit: GOCN Forum on Missional Hermeneutics
Aaron Kuecker, Trinity Christian College
Over the past three decades, a great deal of scholarly attention has been given to identity-formation strategies in 1 Peter. These lines of investigation (and their resulting social reconstructions) have reached an impasse with regard to whether Peter seeks a sectarian identity for his hearers or, alternatively, whether Peter encourages an identity open to social assimilation. Both of these interpretations understand identity formation primarily to be in service of group preservation. I will argue that a missional reading of 1 Peter reveals that Peter’s identity-forming strategy is concerned with group preservation/formation as well as cultural transformation. Stated as a thesis, identity-distinction within 1 Peter functions to form the social identity of the in-group in such a way as to leverage in-group identity-distinction simultaneously for the sake of those inside and outside the Jesus-group. To support this argument, this paper will examine Peter’s deployment of several clusters of identity-rich language drawn from images of Israel’s experience of exile and wilderness wanderings. Peter uses these images in order name and cultivate the sense of “otherness” and social displacement experienced by the community. This distinct identity is given meaning and direction primarily through Peter’s admonition to “be holy as God is holy” (1:16), which is informed by Peter’s claim that God’s holiness is an essential aspect of God’s own missional engagement with the world. Hence, for Peter, the theoform holiness of the community is ultimately “missional holiness.” In contrast to readings of the text that see in-group solidarity and cultural engagement as mutually exclusive, a missional reading of 1 Peter will show that Peter understands the theoform identity of the church, even (and perhaps especially) when it leads to suffering, as allowing no distinction between the community’s experience of salvation and the community’s participation in God’s mission.
|
Jezebels in East Africa
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Robert Kuloba Wabyanga, University of Glasgow
Almost all work on postcolonial biblical interpretation in Africa to date has been based in West Africa and South Africa. This paper comes from a different context—East Africa—where the use of the Bible is and has been complex. In the mid twentieth century, African nationalists such as the Mau Mau leader Jomo Kenyatta used texts from the Bible as the Ibuku ria Ngai (the book of God) to defend customs and values like polygamy, female circumcision, ancestral veneration, African names and other practices that missionary Christians were campaigning against. Later, biblical principles were used to criticise leaders such as Mwai Kibaki and Iddi Amin. The Bible widely circulates as a source of unquestioned moral authority. For example, Bible texts are inscribed on the sides of buses and other passenger service vehicles.
In this paper I will focus on the use of the figure of Jezebel to describe prominent female figures in Uganda and Kenya. In Uganda, Janet Museveni, the President’s wife, has been equated to the biblical Jezebel—specifically in the case of the murder of Aron Kagondoki, a young Makerere University undergraduate who protested against land seizure. In Kenya, Lucy Kibaki, the President’s wife has been described as the ‘dreadful First Jezebel of Kenya’ who ‘has become a law unto herself and literally out of the bounds of legal restraint and due process…’. Considering these and related cases from a feminist and postcolonial perspective, I will address questions such as: ‘How do such accusations relate to the rise of female influence in East African politics?’; ‘How can we interpret the unsettling combination of misogyny and campaigns for justice in relation to the Bible?’; and ‘How do these East African cases relate to the use of Jezebel in, for example, the southern United States (Pippin)?’
|
Olfactory Modes of Knowing God: The Interpretation of 2 Cor 2:14–16 in the Writings of Origen, Gregory of Nyssa, and John Chrysostom
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Dominika Kurek-Chomycz, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
The metaphor of fragrance in 2Cor 2:14-16 is remarkable in its concentration of olfactory terms. It has captivated the imagination of the readers throughout the centuries. In Christian antiquity the notion of Christ’s aroma became a common topos in the discourse of olfactory piety. In my paper I suggest that three authors in particular provide interesting insights. Origen adopted Paul’s metaphor as the key NT text to prove the existence of the spiritual sense of smell. Yet such an interpretation was primarily aimed at more advanced Christians; for the “simple” believers he deemed the ethical understanding more appropriate. Gregory of Nyssa took over from Origen the concept of spiritual senses, but was less interested in the detailed interpretation of 2:14-16, focusing rather on the person of the Apostle Paul. The authority of Paul plays a double role: 1)he guides others in striving for the knowledge of God; 2)as “the aroma of Christ,” he spreads the good news throughout the world. The figure of Paul is also of central significance in the way John Chrysostom employs 2:14-16. In this case the emphasis is on paraenesis. In all these various contexts the distinct qualities of olfaction play a role.
The approaches of the three authors differ in their emphases, but are not mutually exclusive. My examination of the manner in which they interpret 2:14-16 allows for a more nuanced understanding of early Christian attitudes towards sense perception and its role in theological discourse, especially with regard to attaining the knowledge of God. It also contributes to the ongoing discussion concerning the distinction between the Alexandrian and Antiochene modes of biblical interpretation. Finally, my discussion offers insight into the development of the concept of spiritual senses, very influential in the Christian East in the pre-modern era, but largely neglected in contemporary scholarship.
|
Re-interpreting Retribution: The Use of Psalms 1 and 73 in the Book of Job
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Will Kynes, University of Cambridge
Job’s “bitter parody” of Ps 8:5 in Job 7:17-18 has become a “scholarly commonplace,” but the question which naturally follows has rarely been pursued: if the author of Job interacted with this psalm in such a knowing and sophisticated way, what other allusions to the Psalms may likewise make significant contributions to the dialogue between Job, his friends, and God? This paper will attempt to address this question by tracing some other psalmic allusions as they weave through the speeches in Job 3–27. In particular, I will address connections between Job and two so-called “wisdom” or “didactic” psalms: Ps 1 and Ps 73. It is often suggested that the book of Job was written as a reaction to the type of retributive doctrine dictated in Ps 1, and that in his struggle with this doctrine, Job’s experience matches that of the author of Ps 73, sometimes referred to as the “Job psalm.” I will suggest that the correlation between Job and these two psalms is not mere coincidence, but that it instead results from an intentional intertextual interaction with them both signaled by several allusions over the course of the dialogue by both Job and his friends. This technique of dialogical reinterpretation of earlier texts contributes a further facet to the hermeneutical nature of the wisdom movement (cf. Sheppard 1980). Their use in Job also illuminates the tensions within these “wisdom” psalms.
|
Which Criteria for Family 13 Manuscripts?
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Didier Lafleur, Institut de recherche et d'histoire des textes
To date, Family 13 manuscripts are first order witnesses of the greek New Testament. Textual scholars generally accepted, as Nestle-Aland 27a, that Family 13 include thirteen witnesses and, as it is said : et alii. They all are minuscule manuscripts containing the Four Gospels. From 1670, date of the first mention of the Vienna codex (Gregory-Aland 124) up to now, new witnesses often have been declared as belonging to Family 13 on divergent features. My paper will focus on four possible criteria :
(A) The transfer of the Pericope of the Adulteress to a position after Luke 21:38. Unfortunately, that criterion, one of the most actually recognized characteristics of Family 13, is not valid for the recently rediscovered manuscript of Prague, Gregory-Aland 1689. (B) The transfer of the Pericope of the Angel and the Sweat like “Drops of Blood” (Lk 22:43-44) to a position after Mt 26:39. Only five members present the verses after Mt 26:39, three present them both in Luke and Matthew ; other manuscripts let the verses in Luke alone, some with asterisks, some not. (C) The omission of The Signs of the Times (Mt 16:2-3) and (D) the Hagiographical criteria. As most of the Family 13 witnesses include menologia and synaxaria, scholars hardly debated in the first decades of 20th century for establishing hagiographical lists of local saints from southern Italy representatives of Family 13 manuscripts. As no consensual list is actually admitted, I suggest as a common base Elias Spelaeotes (Bibliotheca Hagiographica Graeca 581).
I will conclude that Family 13’ main characteristics features cannot be summarized as a whole for the entire group. If the most important features of Family 13 manuscripts are the singular readings as above described, we have to pay attention to the others readings of the text. Generally speaking criteria have to be delineated as a stimulating debate.
|
The Language of the Gospel of John: The Antilanguage of an Antisociety?
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
David Lamb, University of Manchester
In their depiction of the Johannine Community as a sectarian group both within Judaism and early Christianity, a number of recent sociological commentators on the Gospel of John have drawn on a concept from the discipline of sociolinguistics. This concept, that of "antilanguage", denoting the sociolect of a distinct and subordinate group opposed to wider society (an "antisociety"), was first proposed by the British sociolinguist, Michael Halliday (the founder of systemic functional linguistics) in an essay published in 1976. The concept was applied to the language of the Gospel of John by Bruce J. Malina in a paper given in 1984 and it has since been adopted by a number of other commentators, including Norman J. Petersen, Jerome A. Neyrey, Richard L. Rohrbaugh, Philip F. Esler and Ronald A. Piper. I suggest that the use of the term "antilanguage" may be perceived as lending interdisciplinary weight to the arguments of those who support a sectarian view of the Community. However, I will argue that a close examination of the way the concept and related terms, such as "relexicalization" and "overlexicalization", have been used by these scholars reveals a number of key ways in which Halliday’s original proposal has been misrepresented and that there is, in fact, no sociolinguistic support for modelling the Johannine Community as an "antisociety".
|
Apocalypticism and the Construction of the Torah as Revelation
Program Unit: Orality, Textuality, and the Formation of the Hebrew Bible
David Lambert, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
A casual reader of the Pentateuch should conclude that, whereas God revealed law to Moses, he did no such thing with respect to the narratives that comprise a good portion of that collection. Indeed, there are few, if any, significant instances in ancient Near Eastern literature in which a deity reveals to an intermediary stories of the past, as opposed to information about the future or law. Nevertheless, both Jewish and Christian communities eventually came to believe, with some variation, that God revealed the entirety of the Pentateuch, in its present form, to Moses at Sinai.
The Book of Jubilees is, I believe, the earliest text that clearly ascribes Mosaic authorship and hence revelatory status to the narratives that comprise Genesis and early portions of Exodus. In point of fact, the author seems to suggest that Jubilees is the oral record transmitted by the angel of the presence to Moses from the Heavenly Tablets containing knowledge of all things past and all things future. Thus, according to the author of Jubilees, Moses would have combined the oral transmission he copied with law revealed separately to craft the book that came to be known as the Torah of Moses.
In this rendering, Moses becomes first and foremost an apocalyptic seer (the law, Jubilees says, is provided directly by the hand of God). Though law retains its superior, unmediated written status, knowledge of the past and future becomes the more dynamic concern in this worldview. It is no wonder then that many pseudepigraphic texts, with their apocalyptic tendencies, focus on heroes from Genesis. The apocalyptic appropriation of the Torah would have provided a compelling logic for narrative to take its place beside law as revelation and thus make a vital contribution to one aspect of the Hebrew Bible’s scripturalization.
|
Women and Ritual in Philippi: Images and Their Meaning on the Acropolis
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Jason Lamoreaux, Brite Divinity School
On the acropolis of Philippi, a plethora of images dot the landscape. These images date back to the time of Paul and give clues to women’s lives in ancient Philippi. Images of women and Artemis are by far the dominate reliefs carved from the stones on the hill but there are few inscriptions to explain why they are present. In this paper, I will propose possible meanings behind these images as well as examine the rituals they might represent. Lastly, I will suggest how women’s ritual background might inform their reception of Paul’s letter in the Jesus community in Philippi.
|
"We Have an Altar" (Hebrews 13:10): The Reclamation of Reinterpreted Liturgy for Ecological Responsibility
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Jeffrey S. Lamp, Oral Roberts University
The letter-sermon of Hebrews has reinterpreted many symbols of the old covenant in light of the new covenant introduced through and by the Son. Many of these symbols have liturgical significance: Sabbath, sacrifice, priesthood, sanctuary, to name the most prominent. In each case, the symbol has been relativized through christological reinterpretation. In the process of reinterpretation, implicit connections between many of the cultic rituals and God's creation are lost, eroding the potential for concern for creation performed in liturgical practice. This erosion in significance has also manifest in certain ecclesiastical traditions that are suspicious of and sometimes antagonistic to liturgical practice.
This paper will illustrate how the author of Hebrews has demonstrated a bias against Earth both through the choice of liturgical symbols for reinterpretation and through the reinterpretation itself. A point of identification with Earth will be identified in the author's depiction of the Son entering the heavenly sanctuary to offer his own blood. This point of identification will further provide a significant basis for the voice of Earth in reasserting the importance of liturgical practice for ecological responsibility. Two areas of practice, one explicit in Hebrews, baptism, and the other implied in the offering of the Son's blood in the heavenly sanctuary, the Eucharist, will be developed in terms of how they might foster a sense of responsibility toward Earth's well being.
|
The Celluloid Sermon: Portrayals of Matthew's Sermon on the Mount in Four Films
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
David Landry, University of Saint Thomas
A comparison of the treatment of the Sermon on the Mount (Matthew 5-7) in Terry Gilliam's Monty Python's Life of Brian (1979), Pier Paulo Pasolini's The Gospel according to St. Matthew (1964), Richard Attenborough's Gandhi (1982), and Martin Scorcese's The Last Temptation of Christ (1988) reveals a great deal about the message conveyed by each film. All four of these films incorporate the Sermon on the Mount in a key segment, and a close examination of the details of each scene exposes the filmmaker's distinctive interpretation of this portion of Matthew's gospel. But just as revealing as the details of the films themselves are the divergent reactions that each film garnered among critics, audiences, biblical scholars, and censors/watchdog groups. To the degree that these reactions were based on the portion of the film that represented the Sermon on the Mount, they reveal something important about the interpretive assumptions of the various audiences. "Readers" of these films—depending on their interpretive communities—approach them with some definite ideas about the "proper" use and treatment of this key biblical passage, ideas that can be challenged by biblical studies but to which biblical scholars should be attentive.
|
Respondent
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Francis Landy, University of Alberta
In my role as respondent to the four panel speakers on the reception history of the Hebrew Bible, I shall focus particularly on the handling of the Jewish sources.
|
YHWH's Gracious and Compassionate Reign: Exodus 34:6–7 and the Psalter
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Nathan C. Lane, Palm Beach Atlantic University
This paper will discuss the function of the Exo 34:6-7 credo within the macro and micro structures of the Psalter. Three major parallels of the credo appear in the Psalter,the most significant coming in Psalm 145. The covenantal name and attributes of the credo dominate this final psalm before the section of ‘hallelujah psalms’. From a macro-canonical vantage point, parallels also occur in Psalms 86 and 103. Both of these psalms also appear near the seams of Books III/IV and IV/V. All three of these “psalms of David” characterize YHWH’s reign over the cosmos as compassionate, gracious, and, in particular, marked by divine hesed. The Psalter excises the punishing/wrathful attributes of YHWH’s reign to stress God’s goodness. The covenantal attributes are used in these psalms to show the extension of the God’s goodness to the ‘poor and needy’ (86:1), the ‘oppressed’ (103:6) and the ‘humble’ (145:14).
The paper will also identify micro-level connections that are based upon the stock of images from the credo and affirmed in the aforementioned macro-canonical structures. This language appears at several of the seam psalms. For example, “iniquity” and/or “rebellion” figure prominently in 89:33; 90:8; 103:10,12; 106:43; and 107:17. Also, the lament of David calls into question the hesed of YHWH in 89:34,50, as opposed to Moses requesting YHWH’s compassion and hesed (90:13-14). The juxtaposition of the macro level emphasis on compassion, hesed, and the graciousness of YHWH with the micro level use of the iniquity and rebellion of the people assumes that an eschatological hope for the nation rests only in the graciousness of God’s reign over the cosmos. This character of YHWH's reign will ensure justice and righteousness in kingdom citizens.
|
Ezekiel in Eden: Recovering the Origins of Biblical Mythmaking
Program Unit: Book of Ezekiel
Peter T. Lanfer, University of California-Los Angeles
The Book of Ezekiel plays a prominent role in a comprehensive analysis of the biblical narrative of the Garden of Eden. In particular, the Edenic motifs in Ezekiel carry significant implications for the redaction history of the Genesis narrative. However, despite some excellent treatments of the subject such as James Barr's article “‘Thou Art the Cherub’: Ezekiel 28:14 and the Post-Ezekiel Understanding of Genesis 2-3” (1992); and Robert Wilson's “The Death of the King of Tyre: The Editorial History of Ezekiel 28” (1987) the relationship between the mythic material in Ezekiel and Genesis 2-3 requires fuller explication. This paper proposes a reevaluation of the Eden material in the book of Ezekiel in light of recent textual work on both Ezekiel and Genesis, and situates the mutual incorporation of the mythology of Eden in the social circumstances of the early Exilic period.
|
Luke’s ‘Little Apocalypse’ Is Not about the Parousia: Reconsidering the Subject and Setting of Luke 17:22–37
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
T.J. Lang, Duke University
The universal assumption among interpreters of Jesus’ discourse in Luke 17.22-37 is that the subject is the parousia. Setting aside the fact that parousia is a term Luke never uses, and perhaps deliberately avoids, this assumption that ‘the end’ is in view here generates several exegetical difficulties. These include, but are not limited to: 1) Jesus’ prediction that the disciples will long to see ‘one of the days’ and not ‘the day’; 2) the shifts in the entire discourse between the restrictive (‘one of the days’), the plural (‘days’), the singular (‘day’), and then the differently specific (‘in that night’); 3) the presence of a passion prediction (v.25); 4) the logic of the Noah and Lot parallels, which describe a departure and not an arrival (vv.26-29); 5) the warnings about returning for goods or turning back when the parousia should be sudden and decisive (vv.31; cf. vv.34-35); and finally 6) the disciples’s question about locality when they should be expected to ask about temporality (v.37a). In this essay I offer a reading of 17.22-37 as a discourse on the subject of the Son of Man’s impending passion in Jerusalem. I demonstrate that, if not approached from the perspective of a Synopsis, there is not a single image, term, or expression that necessarily signals that the topic of the discourse is the end-time return of the Son of Man. Though several of the images and terms are utilized by Matthew in his formal treatment of the parousia (Mt. 24), they are not repeated by Luke in his parallel treatment in ch. 21. The ch. 17 discourse is a Lucan creation, woven together with both unique and redacted material; the setting is the journey to Jerusalem, and the teaching, as in the surrounding context, concerns issues of direct relevance to those disciples in that narrative.
|
Critical Interaction with Paul’s Exodus Exegesis (1 Cor 10): Origen and Augustine
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
T.J. Lang, Duke University
In a recent essay, John Cavadini recommends that in place of the shopworn practice of labeling ancient exegesis as “precritical” (and therefore “uncritical”) we should begin to attend to the ways in which ancient styles of exegesis are “differently critical” from more modern methods. But just as important as it is to recognize with sympathy the differences between “us” and “them” in matters of criticism, it is also important that we seek to appreciate how ancient readers are “differently critical” when compared to each other. With this latter task, the goal is not to judge ancient readers in terms of modern canons of criticism but to judge their successes and failures as readers in terms of their own canons and objectives. To illustrate this point about the importance of attending to the differences that exist when various ancient readers critically interact with a text, I will examine the assorted ways in which two ancient exegetes—Origen and Augustine—interact exegetically with Paul’s own exegesis of the exodus narrative in 1 Cor 10. The 1 Cor 10 passage is helpful for putting into relief the variations in critical practice that exist among these readers in two primary ways. First, the significant gaps and aporias in this text invite its readers to pose questions and supply information which, in turn, illumine their individual concerns and presuppositions. Second, because this passage is itself an exegesis, it tends to provoke systematic hermeneutical reflection. And it is during such hermeneutical reflection that the “differently critical” approaches of these three readers are most clearly exhibited.
|
In-between Spaces: The Wilderness and Diaspora Jews
Program Unit: Space, Place, and Lived Experience in Antiquity
Tim Langille, University of Toronto
Memory and place are interrelated phenomena, as the latter represents continuity, forms a locus of memories, and invokes personal and collective nostalgia. The wilderness is a recurring spatial trope in ancient Israelite and Jewish collective memory. Wilderness narratives and imagery in the Pentateuch depict an oscillatory space that sits between the benign and the malign, an in-between space of possibilities and identity formation, where ethno-religious identities are negotiated. Likewise, a diasporic environment is a betwixt space, a dual ontology as the diasporic subject gazes in two directions: the historical identity and the society of relocation. Philo and the producers of 1QS and CD represent the dual ontology of a diasporic experience—the memorialization and rememorialization of the past of the former home and the present realities of the new home, the relocation outside of the former home, and the experience of an identity constructed simultaneously by similarity and continuity with the past and with difference and rupture in the present.
This paper examines ways in which the ancient Israelite memory of the wilderness, an ambiguous space of both punishment and revelation, was appropriated to represent a place of purification and revelation and used to construct identity in diasporic environments. More specifically, this paper analyzes ways in which Philo (De Decalogo and De Vita Contemplativa) and the producers of 1QS and CD deploy wilderness imagery to connect mnemonic communities to idealized pasts and exemplary figures such as Moses, a cultural hero who received revelation in the wilderness and lived and died outside of the homeland. Thus, the wilderness, which for Philo and the producers of 1QS and CD is juxtaposed with the city, is a natural locus for those in Diaspora to form mnemonic communities that create continuity between the present and the idealized past.
|
“And None Shall Make Them Afraid”: Atlanta’s Temple Bombing and Southern Jewish Uses of the Bible
Program Unit: SBL Forum
Scott M. Langston, Texas Christian University
During the early morning hours of Sunday, October 12, 1958, Atlanta’s Hebrew Benevolent Congregation, better known as the Temple, had one of its walls blown out after someone placed fifty sticks of dynamite against it and detonated them. Although in the bombing’s aftermath several individuals were arrested and tried, no one was ever convicted. With the country and especially the South caught up in the turmoil of the Civil Rights Movement, the Temple’s rabbi, Jacob M. Rothschild, had been outspoken in his support of African-American rights. This made him a target of segregationists who by the mid-1950s had been detonating bombs across the South on a regular basis.
As representative of the Reform congregation, Rothschild responded publicly in a number of ways, and at times employed the Bible to address not only his congregants, but also non-Jews. Perhaps his fullest use of the Bible came during the first Friday evening service after the bombing when he delivered a sermon entitled, “And None Shall Make Them Afraid.” My paper will take this sermon as the starting point to explore how Jews in the American South have used the Bible to engage Christians. While focusing on Rabbi Rothschild’s uses of the Bible, they will be examined and contextualized within the broader southern Jewish experience. Jews in the South have found the Bible to be an effective tool for building bridges with non-Jews, while also using it to confront and challenge Christian southerners when necessary. Rabbi Rothschild continued what had become a practice previously used by southern Jews such as Rabbis James K. Gutheim and Isaac Leucht, both of New Orleans, Rabbi Morris Newfield of Birmingham, and even during the trial of Leo Frank, a Jewish factory manager in Atlanta who a generation before had been lynched. Pictorial images will accompany the presentation.
|
Hugh Nibley and the New Year Festival
Program Unit: Latter-day Saints and the Bible
David J. Larsen, University of St Andrews
One of the key features of the late Hugh W. Nibley’s scholarship was his research on and use of the hypothetical annual enthronement festival suggested by scholars to have been celebrated in the ancient Near East annually at the New Year. Nibley built on the work of some of the major proponents of this theory in the early 20th century, including Sigmund Mowinckel, Aubrey Johnson, and S.H. Hooke. Nibley adopted the principles of cultic ritual outlined in the Ancient Near Eastern “patternism” of the time and applied them to many societies, including, ultimately, to cultural/religious gatherings attested in the Book of Mormon. He suggested at one time that, in his opinion, the rituals of the New Year were “the most convincing evidence yet brought forth for the authenticity of the Book of Mormon.”
Nibley’s work on the New Year Festival has greatly inspired succeeding generations of LDS students and scholars, leading many to do further research on the topic, both in its ancient settings in the Old World, and in relation to our understanding of the Book of Mormon. Their valuable contributions to LDS scholarship on this subject have been based on the assumption that arguments for the annual New Year Festival are valid.
I propose to address the status quaestionis of the suggested New Year Festival in ancient Israel. To what extent is it reasonable to use this theory as a basis for argumentation? In the last few decades, biblical scholarship has largely distanced itself from the conclusions of the “Myth and Ritual School” and condemned ideas of a universal pattern of ritual across ancient cultures. However, a number of scholars have recently argued in favor of the validity of the general theory. I will explore what is being said about the New Year Festival in today’s scholarship, and will present an evaluation of Nibley’s work on the subject in light of this analysis.
|
Seniors Speak, Juniors Listen: Gerontocracy and Youth Rebellion in Jewish and Christian Wisdom Literature
Program Unit: Speech and Talk in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Kasper Bro Larsen, University of Aarhus
According to the so-called positive wisdom literature in the Hebrew Bible, young people need something that the elders have: wisdom. Accordingly, wisdom literature is gerontocratic. The speaker is always a senior, whereas juniors are passive
listeners. Yet, in some forms of wisdom literature a metaphorical youth rebellion seems to take place. In Job and in apocalyptic texts, the notion that old age equals wisdom is called into question, and the Gospel of Thomas even teaches that the old
person needs to be taught by a child (log. 4). Juniors seem to gain voice in wisdom texts in two ways. Either they appear in the role of the puer senex (the premature child) or they represent a criticism of experience-based types of wisdom. The child
lacks experience and thus becomes a medium for alternative, revealed types of wisdom.
|
A Profile of Eucharistic Origins (II): Monks, Meals, and Meanings
Program Unit: Meals in the Greco-Roman World
Lillian Larsen, University of Redlands
This paper will outline a set of theses that will add to the development of a new profile of eucharistic origins.
|
Addressing the Elephant That’s Not in the Room: Comparing the Eucharist in the Didache with the New Testament
Program Unit: Didache in Context
Matthew D. Larsen, Church of the Incarnation (Episcopal)
This paper will seek to analyze the Didache’s Eucharistic prayers found in chapters 9–10. While interacting with Schwiebert’s recent monograph on the topic, it will move the discussion in a different direction by making use of heretofore underutilized literary tools. It will attempt to answer the questions: (1) what is their theological message, and (2) why do they lack the words normally associated with the Eucharist as found the Synoptic Gospels, Paul, and much of later early Christian literature? Most notably, they lack any reference to Jesus’ death whatsoever. The thesis of this paper is that these Eucharistic prayers were originally composed between the time of resurrection of Jesus and 40CE and are eschatologically focused, christologically undeveloped, and ecclesiologically polemical. Further, the Didachist chose these prayers instead of the Eucharistic prayers found in the Synoptic Gospels and Paul because they better suited his consistent polemical purposes, positing the Jesus movement as the legitimate continuation of Israel over and against the Judaism[s] of his day. The Didachist held that the Jesus Movement was not a false, rogue Jewish Messianic sect, but the true Israel—the true people of God. The prayers in the Didache 9-10 fit this rhetorical purpose better than the liturgy of the Synoptic Gospels and Paul.
|
The First Century Two Ways Catechesis as the Background of Hebrews 6.1–6
Program Unit: Hebrews
Matthew D. Larsen, Church of the Incarnation (Episcopal), Dallas, TX, USA
Hebrews 6.1–6 has proved to be a nettlesome passage throughout its interpretive history. The author of Hebrews has embedded three stubborn obstacles in the path of 6.4–6, which, taken together, have made it difficult to walk an exegetically straight course. First, the text seems to describe actual members of the Christian community, not pretenders (6.4–5). Second, it seems to speak of a true falling away (6.6). And third, it warns of the real impossibility of repentance after the apostasy (6.4, 6). These three obstacles have created a series of stumbling blocks for interpreters throughout history. Perhaps as early as the Shepherd of Hermas, the belief that Christians could not repent of certain sins—based partly on Heb 6.4–6—has vexed pilgrims traveling the Way. Understandably, modern scholarship has repeatedly attempted to steer a course around these difficulties by illuminating the path with a variety of historical backgrounds, none of which has achieved anything like a consensus. This paper argues that the first-century catechetical Two Ways didactic pattern, as exemplified in the Didache, proves to be an illuminating historical background to Hebrews 6.1–6. Though not evincing literary dependence, compelling conceptual parallels exist between the Didache and Hebrews 6.1–2. Further, the descriptors in Hebrews 6.4 correspond closely with the experience of catechumens at conversion in the Didache. In this light, parapiptõ in Heb 6.6 does not refer to irreversible apostasy, but to a failure to advance on the Way of Life.
|
What Did Roman Officials Know about Church Property during the Persecutions of the Late Third Century?
Program Unit: Religious Competition in Late Antiquity
Steve Larson, Ohio Wesleyan University
This paper will explore possible misunderstandings among Roman imperial officials about the contents of Christian assembly halls during the persecutions of the second half of the third century CE and beginning of the fourth. It is commonly assumed that officials confiscating Christian property were fully aware of the fact that Christian cultic practice centered around the use of texts and that, consequentially, they focused their repressive energies on gathering and destroying these texts. I will argue that, instead, it is more likely that Roman officials considered Christian churches to be similar to Greco-Roman temples, at least in terms of what they contained in the way of ritual objects. Temple inventories, in other words, would have been their reference point for what to expect inside Christian halls. In addition, while official Roman documentary evidence from the period tends to focus on the confiscation of property (in contradistinction to Christian martyr acts), there is often no mention of texts in those lists. Instead, there is an emphasis on such items as might be expected to be found among temple property (e.g., precious metal objects and human and animal property). Scholars have considered the absence of texts in some records to be an anomaly in need of explanation. The vast majority of religious practice during this period in the Roman Empire still did not center on the reading and interpretation of writings. I will explore the possibility, then, that the focus on texts in narratives of these persecutions reflects a distinctly Christian perspective (one that would of course erupt into controversy over those who had handed over manuscripts [the traditores]). Scholarly explanations that assume a text-centric understanding on the part of Roman officials may well instead reflect the perspectives of Christian insiders who were familiar with Christian practices – then and now.
|
Everything Belongs to Me: Holiness, Danger, and Divine Kingship in the Post-Genesis World
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Stuart Lasine, Wichita State University
The biblical concept of holiness continues to be a subject of debate among source critics and theologians, in several respects. These include the basic meaning and distribution of the term qodeš, the relationship between holiness and danger, and the morality or amorality of the holy. This paper offers a fresh examination of these issues. In addition, the paper assesses the significance of the fact that the root qadaš is almost totally absent from the book of Genesis, concluding that this is not merely a case of “vocabulary rather than substance.” While aspects of holiness are anticipated in Genesis and intimated by several characters, the lethal danger presented by the holy enters the biblical world only in Exodus, where it is intimately connected to Yahweh’s taking on the role of Israel’s exclusive divine suzerain. After this change is discussed in general terms, two specific events which illustrate this difference are examined, one which takes place before the initial mention of holy ground in Exodus 3 and one which occurs shortly after. In each instance God attacks the person to whom he appears. In the first case, the patriarch Jacob successfully wrestles a blessing out of God. In the second, Yahweh seeks to kill Moses (or one of his sons). The paper concludes with an analysis of the new character traits Yahweh displays after Genesis, including the relationship between his deadly wrath and his need to guard his prerogatives as the holy and jealous divine king to whom everything under heaven belongs.
|
Contested Space: Intra-Christian Competition and Disputed Episcopal Elections at Rome
Program Unit: Religious Competition in Late Antiquity
Jacob Latham, University of California-Santa Barbara
There were at least five disputed episcopal elections in the fourth through the sixth centuries. This intra-Christian competition did not, however, lead to the contestation of space in the form of processions as it did, for example, in Constantinople, where Arians and Niceans held competing processions. At Rome, intra-Christian competition took the form, at least rhetorically, of siege and occupation. Instead of conquering urban space through processions—impossible as the Roman aristocracy and their patronage of traditional public display still dominated and defined the public sphere—Roman Christians resorted to warfare.
Throughout all of these electoral disputes two elements consistently emerge: one, the use of martial language to describe the events and two, the concentration on a few contested sites. A strategy of militaristic occupation of centrally important churches clearly marked these schisms, as each side marched upon and occupied the principal churches of Rome, invading and expelling their enemies from other principal churches when they could. The martial language in the descriptions of these conflicts often veered close to the religious, indicating, hinting, that the origins of Christian processions lie in conflict and battle. From the literal soldiers of Christ, armed with clubs, rocks, and swords, emerged spiritual soldiers bearing crosses and singing hymns.
|
The Debt in the Hebrew Bible: The Silent Indebted Persons
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Kari Latvus, University of Helsinki
The paper gives an inter-contextual analysis (see Latvus, Reading Hagar in Contexts) of central Hebrew Bible debt texts (Ex 22: 24-26; Deut 15:1-11 and Lev 25) in relation to the letters of the indebted Finns.
The social context of the paper is rooted into the Finnish (and global) economical crises: the banks were supported and saved while the individuals may be trapped by non-ending debt payments and the lost of homes. The data analysed includes the letters written by 278 indebted persons. The letters were collected in open invitation by the Lutheran church.
The exegetical analysis of biblical debt texts illustrates the development of debt problem and changing attitudes concerning the interests and release of the debt from pre-exilic Covenant Code to Post-Exilic Jubilee text. This paper uses the scheme created by W.Domeris (in Touching the Hearth of God, 2007): distinction of power-powerlessness, shame-honour plays a central role both in modern and in ancient debt issues. The comparison with the current debt texts illuminates the attitudes of the Biblical writers. The debt texts in the Hebrew Bible leave the indebted as an object and structure of the society unchanged (exception: the utopian plan in Lev 25). The indebted may be named as “a brother” or “a next” but he is never seen as “you” (sg 2) but “he” (sg 3) or “the poor”. Questions of the inner world of the indebted person are seldom dealt with by the biblical writers because probably they were themselves not poor or indebted (cf. J. Unsok Ro). Analysis of the indebted poor Finns reminds about silent role of the poor behind the Bible.
|
The Delay of Restoration: The Interpretation of Deuteronomy 30 in the Book of Tobit
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Benjamin Laugelli, University of Virginia
The paper considers the interpretation of Deuteronomy 30 in the book of Tobit, with emphasis on the use of the LXX. Deut 30 details Israel's restoration from exile in four stages: (1) exile, (2) repentance, (3) return to the land, and (4) renewal of the heart and covenantal blessing. For the author of the book of Tobit, Deut 30 offers a paradigm for understanding the vicissitudes of life in the Diaspora. Although Tobit is putatively set in Assyria after the deportation of the northern Israelite tribes, the book was written sometime during the third or second century BCE to address the ongoing situation that resulted from the sixth century BCE deportations to Babylonia. The book frames Tobit's piety in Deuteronomic terms, which suggests that Tobit possesses the renewed heart of Deut 30.6. If so, why does he continue to suffer affliction outside the land? Why has Deut 30's promise gone unfulfilled? In Tobit's words, "Although still alive, I am among the dead" (5.10). In answer to this question, the book effectively re-scripts Deut 30 in order to account for the delay of restoration. It responds to the adversity of a protracted exilic experience by displacing Deut 30's promised restoration onto the eschaton. This enables the book to affirm Deuteronomy's retributive justice for the righteous even as it laments the ongoing conditions of exile. For the interim, Tobit's acts of piety function as a model for Diaspora Jews who await eschatological restoration.
|
Gender, Purity, and Power in Ezekiel’s Priestly Vision
Program Unit: Prophetic Texts and Their Ancient Contexts
Dale Launderville, Saint John's University
In Ezek 36:17, Ezekiel uses highly charged rhetoric to accent the potency of the defilement unleashed by Yahwistic community’s transgressions against Yhwh. He likens the community to a menstruant who disregards the purity regulations of the priestly legislation. The dynamics of this rhetoric raises questions of gender and power within the priestly cult. Issues to be examined include: purity and impurity in relation to gender and power; gender reversal for the men when the community-as-a-whole is addressed as a woman.
|
The Armenian Version of the Song of Hannah (1 Samuel 2)
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Historical Books
Timothy Michael Law, Oxford University
Recent studies by Pablo Torijano Morales, Andrés Piquer Otero, and Julio Trebolle Barrera have demonstrated the importance of the Versions of the Caucuses for the untangling of the textual history of the Septuagint in the historical books. The Armenian Version has often been used, and abused, as a witness to the Lucianic and Hexaplaric recensions, and even to the Old Greek. This paper will examine the nature of the Armenian Version of the Song of Hannah in 1 Samuel (1 Kingdoms) 2 and its place in the textual history.
|
Moses and Cosmogony: The Pedagogical Intent of the Creation Account from Philo to Didymus
Program Unit: Christianity in Egypt: Scripture, Tradition, and Reception
Richard A. Layton, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
The prologue to Philo's De Opificio Mundi frames the creation account as Mosaic pedagogy introducing the Torah as both "legislation" and "instruction" embedded in the natural order of the universe. While clearly apologetic, this narrative frame also positively links legislation integrally to the education of the "world citizen.” Philo blends together a Stoic theory of natural law, the narrative shape of the Pentateuch, and a conception of the lawgiver as pedagogue to interpret the cosmogony in a canonical context. At the same time it unites the particularity of Israel’s Torah to the universality of God’s sovereignty; legislation for Philo is not simply the code for an individual people but a device to school the world into an authentic understanding of reality.
This paper will focus on the hermeneutical dynamic between particularity and universality in Philo’s conception of Mosaic pedagogy and its reorientation by subsequent Alexandrian Christian exegetes, especially Didymus. At the outset of his Genesis commentary, Didymus turns the Philonic motif in an anti-Judaic direction. For Didymus, Moses’ educational aim is to separate Israel from the tendency toward idolatry it had developed during its sojourn in Egypt, and Moses is turned from being an educator of the "world citizen" into a restrainer of Jewish vice. It would seem that for Didymus the particularity of Israel plays at best a restricted, if not outright negative, role in the education to God’s universal sovereignty. It is possible, however, that the extant commentary omits valuable information that would allow us to see a fuller and more positive role Didymus provides for Mosaic pedagogy in Genesis 1. The possible evidence comes from Procopius of Gaza's commentary on the Octateuch, which borrows extensively from Didymus. This paper will consider this evidence and its possible effect on the assessment of Didymus' Genesis commentary.
|
The Historiographical Jesus
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Anthony Le Donne, Lincoln Christian University
Introduction to the book, "The Historiographical Jesus"
|
“The Law of Your God and the Law of the King” in the Political Structure of the Achaemenid Empire
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible and Political Theory
Kyong-Jin Lee, Spring Arbor University
A basic political paradigm of empires features the bilateral relationship between the central government and local subunits. The Achaemenid imperial power ruled over an unprecedented number of tribes and tongues stretching as far as the Indus Valley to the east, Anatolia to the north, and the Nile Valley in the south west. This paper proposes that “the law of your God and the law of the king” in Ezra 7:26 must be interpreted for its propagandistic yet pragmatic value that contributed toward an effective and symbiotic relationship between the central and local government. Based on the Achaemenid Foundation Charters, Judea only constituted a second-tier province among the company of imperial subjects. Based on insights garnered from Persian legislative interactions with other vassal states, this paper argues that this biblical phrase witnesses an instance of convergence between the central government and local subunit’s respective political interests. The imperial government’s desire to assert its authority and dominion on the westernmost front collided with the Jewish people’s desire to attain a higher political status from among the minor vassal societies.
|
The Bread and Its Symbolic Meaning: Beyond the Boundaries (Focused on Matthew 14 and 15)
Program Unit: Matthew
Minkyu Lee, Chicago Theological Seminary
The Gospel of Matthew exhibits group dynamics and various conflicts caused by many issues of boundaries in terms of religion, ethnicity, gender, class and the like. At the same time, the Gospel of Matthew symbolically transcends those conflicts and destructs all kind of boundaries through the bread (a;rtoj) that Jesus provides, when Jesus broke the bread (a;rtoj) to share with others in the two feeding narratives in Matthew 14 and 15. Interestingly, as a center of the Gospel of Matthew, the significant role of the Canaanite woman not only changes Jesus' mind of Jewish-centered mission but also intensifies the meaning of the bread (a;rtoj), which invites all people into God’s kingdom regardless any socio-religious barrier, gender, class, ethnicity, and the like, through the sandwich structure of the narrative within two feeding stories (Matthew 14 and 15). Here, the narrator uses the bread (a;rtoj) as metaphor, which signifies destruction and re-construction of boundaries. This paper firstly will examine metaphorical meaning of the bread in Hebrew traditions. Then I will investigate the symbolic meaning of the bread (a;rtoj) and its metaphoric usage in Matthew’s narrative, which shatters all human false prejudices and exclusivism.
|
Using Technology to Deconstruct Privileged Readings: Scholars & Activists Bring African Perspectives to Biblical Interpretation
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Nancy C. Lee, Elmhurst College
This paper shares the results of an effective, co-teaching methodology by an American biblical scholar and a South African activist of an undergraduate course entitled, The Prophets: Visions of Social Justice. The biblical study included readings of the biblical prophets with American and African students through the perspectives of African biblical scholars, consideration of traditional African practices related to seers (so-called shamans, or sangomas), liberationist and post-colonial approaches (to the Exodus narrative and the biblical colonizing problem of Mosaic and subsequent land claims). The teaching methodology led students to critically define ancient prophets, and social justice, in their contexts (including Muhammed for Islam) but also to compare them to ‘prophetic’ figures today, particularly in South Africa’s anti-apartheid and other global justice movements. This approach to reading the Bible was brought to a focus through an innovative use of live, online video technology in the classroom in which students from two cultures (South Africa and U.S.), in two places, discussed the above topics, and older ‘prophetic’ activists from anti-apartheid and U.S. civil rights movements—foremost concerned with injustice—shared their firsthand experiences, with one another and with students. Thus, cross-cultural and experiential study of biblical prophets and their influences on later movements were made real for teachers and students through hearing stories and interpretations that happened ‘on the ground’ from the African and African-American perspectives, and without students having to travel.
|
A Poetic Analysis of Qumran Text 4Q246
Program Unit: Aramaic Studies
Peter Y. Lee, Reformed Theological Seminary and Catholic University of America
4Q246 is a text that has stirred a great amount of interest, specifically due to its extraordinary pre-Christian reference to a “son of God, “son of the Most High,” epithets also found in the Gospel of Luke 1:32-35 in reference to Jesus of Nazareth. The bulk of the scholarly work on this text has been spent on identifying this significant figure. The literary background of this text has also been a point of debate. Due to both the scholarly fascination with the identity of this “son of God” figure and the discussion of the literary vorlage, the poetic character of the text has been largely overshadowed and ignored. The reference to the “son of God” figure is indeed worthy of attention, but the lack of consideration of the poetic nature of the text is still surprising since the work of Puech in the editio princeps in the DJD volume clearly outlines it as poetry. This presentation will examine this well known Qumran text and analyze the poetic features within it, specifically its articulation into pausally defined units, or cola, that show constraints on the number of clauses, phrasal constituents, and words. This type of analysis will demonstrate that column 2 of 4Q246 is in fact an example of Aramaic poetry.
|
Prophecies Never Fail: An Examination of a Theological Tendency in Reading Prophecies in the Old Greek Version of Second Zechariah
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Suk Yee Lee, McMaster Divinity College
Interest in the Greek Jewish Scriptures (OG) has grown considerably in the past few decades as is demonstrated through the increasing volume of publications. Besides using the OG in textual criticism, scholars have exerted much effort on the task of constructing a theology of the OG and its background in the Jewish community. The motivation behind this is the gradual recognition of the important contribution of the OG to the earliest reception history of the Hebrew Bible. This paper attempts to depict a theological tendency in reading prophecies in the Old Greek version of Second Zechariah (OG-Zech 9–14). It argues that the scribe-translator of OG-Zech 9–14 would have considered the corpus as a prediction of events in a period of history in which s/he lived and these chapters would have been read and interpreted by him/her as predictions about events in his/her time, as well as events hoped for in the new future. At the outset of the paper, the historical and cultural contexts which have affected the translation of OG-Zech 9–14 will be looked into by analyzing two important questions: (1) who was the translator(s) and (2) which mode of reading prophecies was prevailing at the time of translation? Then we will attempt to identify a theological tendency in reading prophecies in OG-Zech 9–14 by applying the findings discovered in the previous section to a selection of representative verses expressing theologically a different understanding than that expressed in the MT. Since OG-Zech 9–14 is part of the OG-Minor Prophets (OG-MP), which is to be treated as the work of one translator, some relevant verses in OG-MP will also be examined to support the argument.
|
Paul’s Creative Use of Authoritative Traditions
Program Unit: Korean Biblical Colloquium
Yongbom Lee, University of Bristol
Paul quotes the Old Testament and contemporary Jewish exegetical traditions and creatively applies them to the Sitz im Leben for his rhetorical purposes. Although Paul seldom quotes the Jesus traditions explicitly (1 Cor 9:14, 11:23-25, 15:3-6), he uses them as authoritative words in support of his instruction in 1 Cor 7:10-11 and 1 Thess 4:15-17. In this paper, I will investigate seven distinct cases (Gal 4:21-31; 1 Cor 9:3-14; 10:1-22; 2 Cor 3:7-18; Rom 10:5-13; 1 Thess 4:13-5:11; 1 Cor 7:8-16) of Paul’s creative use of various authoritative traditions (e.g. the Old Testament, contemporary Jewish exegetical traditions and the Jesus traditions) for his rhetorical purposes. My goal is to identify Paul’s typical ways of handling of various authoritative traditions for his rhetorical purposes. My investigation in this paper will focus on three specific aspects: authority, citation and creativity. Firstly, I will compare the level of the authority that Paul attributes to various authoritative traditions. Secondly, I will carefully observe Paul’s citation method of various authoritative traditions. Since the exact form of the contemporary Jewish exegetical traditions cannot be identified, I will focus on his citation method of the Old Testament in this paper. (Although the LXX is not the only Scripture that Paul cites in his letters, Paul evidently depends on the LXX in the five cases that I will investigate in this paper.) Thirdly, I will investigate Paul’s hermeneutical creativity in using various authoritative traditions and applying them to the Sitz im Leben of his readers for his rhetorical purposes. As I will conclude, Paul often uses various authoritative traditions creatively (and not rigidly) for his rhetorical purposes, applying them to the Sitz im Leben of his readers, which is not unique to Paul but common to other authors in late antiquity.
|
How Lonely Sits the City: Dismantling Solomon's Temple, 2 Kings 25:13–17
Program Unit: Exile (Forced Migrations) in Biblical Literature
Peter Leithart, New St. Andrews College
The list of temple vessels and description of the dismantled temple furnishings in 2 Kings 25:13-17 are unusually detailed. Vessels of which we have read little in 1-2 Kings are listed as the temple is dismantled, and the description of the bronze pillars repeats many of the details of the original description in 1 Kings 7:15-22. By comparing the initial description of the pillars with the description in 2 Kings 25, and by examining the place of this passage within the structure of 2 Kings 25, this paper will expound on the literary effects and theological significance of this description, especially highlighting the "bridal" features of temple architecture in 1-2 Kings.
|
Picturing Divine Violence in Psalms of Lament
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Iconography and the Bible
Joel LeMon, Emory University
Images of violence against enemies pervade the Psalms---particularly, images of divine violence. This study identifies the patterns and protocols by which ancient psalmists pictured divine violence within psalms of lament. After first establishing a typology of psalmic depictions of divine violence, I then turn to an analysis of ancient Near Eastern iconography in order to contextualize the images of violence that the Psalms present. Within the ancient Near East, different cultures exhibit unique artistic customs for depicting violence. Egyptian reliefs, for example, typically cast the king in a smiting posture, with one arm raised high in the air, ready to strike, and the other arm outstretched, grasping the hair of the subjugated enemy. This powerful image of potential violence stands in contrast with Neo-Assyrian reliefs, which often picture the king in the midst of dealing a deathblow and depict the concomitant gore. The study examines how the Psalms' literary imagery accords with these and other ancient Near Eastern iconographic traditions with respect to representing divine violence.
|
Biblical Operas by Jewish Composers
Program Unit: SBL Forum
Helen Leneman, University of Amsterdam
There are few known Jewish composers in any era, and still fewer that tried their hand at setting a story from the Bible. One 19th century example is German composer Ferdinand Hiller, who wrote oratorios based on Abraham and David. But for operas by Jewish composers, we have to wait until the 20th century.
Kurt Weill (1900-1950), one of the outstanding composers in the post-WWI generation, emigrated to New York in 1935 to collaborate on The Eternal Road with Franz Werfel and Max Reinhardt. In this vast spectacle, the history of the Jewish people is recounted by a rabbi to his community at a time of persecution. The original German version was never performed. The English-language version premiered on Broadway in 1936.
Joseph Rumshinsky’s (1881-1956) 1949 opera Ruth, written in Hebrew, is a powerful example of a biblical story’s transformation into a different medium. Most of Rumshinsky’s life was devoted to writing Yiddish music for the Second Avenue Theatre in New York. Ruth, his last work, was never published or performed.
Darius Milhaud (1892–1974), one of the 20th century's most prolific composers, dedicated his monumental opera David to the people of Israel, on the occasion of the 3000 year anniversary of the founding of Jerusalem. Written in 1952, its world premiere in concert form was in Jerusalem in 1954, and as a staged work at La Scala in 1955. The 1956 American premiere was at the Hollywood Bowl in Los Angeles.
Aminadav Aloni’s (1928-1999) short Ruth opera was commissioned in Sherman Oaks, California and has been performed twice, in 1989 and 2001. Aloni used a different traditional trope (biblical cantillation) for each movement.
Excerpts from these four rarely heard works will be both played and performed. The particularly ‘Jewish’ aspect of the music will be highlighted and explained.
|
A CBS Special: The David-Bathsheba-Uriah Triangle Re-visioned in a Televised Opera
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Helen Leneman, University of Amsterdam
The opera And David Wept by Ezra Laderman was first performed live on CBS television on April 8, 1971. The story is based on 2 Sam. 11 but is told entirely in flashback, from three different viewpoints: David’s, Bathsheba’s, and Uriah’s. The libretto, by Broadway lyricist Joe Darion, is entirely original text. The fact that CBS considered the broadcast of an opera based on a biblical narrative a good commercial venture is indicative of a different era and way of thinking. It is difficult to imagine such a production being funded and shown on television today, in the U.S. or elsewhere.
In this retelling, there is no doubt at all about Bathsheba’s role: she is a seductress from the first moment she enters. Throughout the opera, the characters are recalling events that occurred decades earlier. Uriah is actually speaking from the grave, a very unusual and effective device. We may not agree with this opera’s portrayals of a young and romantic David or a lusty and vulgar Bathsheba, but they must have truly come alive on television. Uriah’s portrayal is particularly interesting because he has been ignored by so much post-biblical interpretation and midrash, yet here he is a man of flesh and blood. He is conflicted and angry--very real and believable emotions considering his story.
The bawdy and scheming Bathsheba of this opera could have been dreamed up by any one of many sexist and biased commentators. The imagined David-Bathsheba ‘love story’ is more cinematic by far than biblical.
Excerpts from the original broadcast, featuring singers from the Metropolitan Opera, will be played.
|
Disability in Ancient Egypt
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Stephen J. Lennox, Indiana Wesleyan University
Although recent studies have explored disability in ancient Israel and Mesopotamia, less attention has been given to how this topic was understood in ancient Egypt. This paper surveys disability in the land of the Pharaohs from Old to New Kingdoms. Particular attention will be given to how physical disability relates to the Egyptian ideal of beauty and to Egyptian perspectives on the afterlife.
|
“One in Christ”: Galatians 3:28 and the Holiness Agenda
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Stephen J. Lennox, Indiana Wesleyan University
The 19th century American holiness movement employed Galatians 3:28 to argue for liberation, both spiritual and social. Luther Lee not only used it to argue for abolitionism, it was also his text for “A Woman’s Right to Preach the Gospel,” the sermon he preached in 1853 at the ordination service for Antoinette Brown, the first American woman ordained to ministry. B. T. Roberts, founder of the Free Methodist Church, also used this passage to explain his support for the ordination of women. This paper explores how Lee, Roberts, and others in the holiness tradition employed Galatians 3:28 to pursue their theological and social agenda.
|
The Textual Character of an Early Witness to Matthew's Gospel
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
James M. Leonard, University of Cambridge
Codex Schøyen is a substantial but fragmentary Coptic manuscript of Matthew’s Gospel which only became public in 1999. It dates perhaps to the early fourth century, and may be the earliest witness to Matthew in 13 entire chapters, and to many portions of other chapters. However, its textual character has not yet been adequately analysed. Analysis of its textual character has been hindered, in part, by the atypical translation method reflected in its text which often makes the Vorlage difficult to discern. This paper demonstrates how an understanding of the version’s translation technique can help discern its Vorlage. Analysis of important test passages will show its textual character and relationship with other manuscripts. Ultimately, the paper will address the issue of whether Codex Schøyen is the closest ally to Sinaiticus and Vaticanus in Matthew’s Gospel.
|
"To Those Far and Near": The Case for "Community" at a Distance
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Brooke Lester, Garrett-Evangelical Theological Seminary
Many educators believe that "community" cannot happen without face-to-face interaction. This proposal will argue that "community" can be developed at a distance and will demonstrate this via participatory on-line demonstration of community-building.
|
From Levite to Maskil in the Book of Daniel
Program Unit: Cultic Personnel in the Biblical World
Mark Leuchter, Temple University
Many scholars view the "maskilim" references in the book of Daniel as a key to identifying the scribal circle responsible for the book's authorship. A study of the hermeneutical methods standing behind several important literary hinges in Daniel suggest that these maskilim were strongly influenced by Levitical tradition, witnessed most significantly by the interest in the cult, legal exegesis, and especially the apocalyptic form. Set within the context of the increased emphasis on Levi in other 3rd-2nd century Jewish texts, the book of Daniel abstracts scribal and exegetical traditions fostered by Levites for centuries and establishes a literary conduit for their re-emergence as the intellectual curriculum of the maskilim as a non-sacerdotal caste. In this way, the authors of Daniel move beyond older sacral categories at a time when political and military conflict threatened their viability, paving the way for the rise of sectarianism in the wake of the Hasmonean revolt.
|
Engaging Bakhtin Tri-focally: The Meet/Melt-ing Point of Psychology, Literary Studies, and the Empirics of Reading (The Case of Isaiah 49)
Program Unit: Bakhtin and the Biblical Imagination
Barbara M. Leung Lai, Tyndale Seminary
Using Isaiah 49, a fascinating polyphonic text as a case-study, this paper explores the ways that an integrated tri-focal reading will further expand the horizon of reading and enhance the meaning-significance of readers. Employing a psychological lens, I shall explore the interplay of voice and interiority/emotionality (Landy and Leung Lai) and the Bakhtinian notion of unmerged voices and ideologies/consciousnesses. Analyzing polyphonic texts from the Bakhtinan perspective, the dialogic dynamics in presenting truths becomes the focal point. Engaging Bakhtin emotively, I seek to look into the element of “emotion” as it relates to the textual presentation of the multiplicity of speaking voices, as well as the highly sophisticated technique of the “third person projection of first person views” embedded in the text. Moreover, integrating theories on the empirics (emotive experiencing) of reading (Schuyler Brown and Kitzberger, reading between “text” and “self”) and the Bakhtinian concept of “dialogic self,” an elevated readers’ experiencing is anticipated. It is my high hope that at the meeting/melting point of these three perspectives, a more enriched Isaian emotionality/interiority may emerge.
|
Augustine’s Theology of History
Program Unit: Theological Interpretation of Scripture
Matthew Levering, University of Dayton
I will suggest that Augustine’s City of God offers a way forward for understanding the nature of history, and provides an example of what happens when we fail to understand the nature of history properly. I will briefly survey the five parts of City of God: (1) Books 1-5, (2) Books 6-10, (3) 11-14, (4) Books 15-18, (5) Books 19-22. Part One shows the nature of history when viewed from the perspective of paganism: history is basically inexplicable, the gods partake of “linear” history along with humans, the gods cannot truly act, and astrological fatalism becomes a privileged way of understanding the nature of history. Part Two shows the nature of history when viewed from the perspective of the best pagan philosophy. Platonism allows for not only a linear understanding of history, but also history as participation in God. Yet Platonism lacks a way of overcoming sin. A participatory understanding of history requires the sacrificial redemption of history accomplished by Christ Jesus. Part Three takes up history in its origin. History is a created participation in God; evil has no existence of its own, the world is not eternal, death is not the final word, and history has union with God as its goal. Part Four explores linear history as depicted by Scripture, and shows that this history is radically participatory, with earlier events participating in later ones and the City of God present at all times. Part Five explores history in its final goal. Perfect peace in God is the goal of history. Even eternal punishment does not negate the accomplishment of this goal. Miracles show that linear history has this participatory nature and goal. The goal of history is the vision of God, deification, or radical participation in the Trinitarian life. In conclusion, I will suggest that the shift toward a strictly linear understanding of the nature of history promotes a re-paganizing of culture of the kind that David Hart sketches in Atheist Delusions.
|
Literary Sources and Editorial Layers in 2 Kgs 24–25
Program Unit: Exile (Forced Migrations) in Biblical Literature
Christoph Levin, University of Munich
In the two last chapters of the Book of Kings, several pre-redactional sources and editorial expansions can be discerned: (1) The excerpt of the annals of the Judean kings provides the framework, as usual. (2) The Deuteronomistic Historian inserted some fragmentary notes from the Temple records, and (3) added his judgements about the religious behaviour of the kings. (4) Later the History was expanded from the records of the Babylonian branch of the Davidic house for to give the history of the kings a hopeful end. (5) There was also what may be called the "Jehoiachin edition" which stated that the Babylonian branch of the Davidic dynasty was the sole legitiate heir of the royal tradition of Judah. (5) Finally, the theory of the empty land was added by a series of golah-oriented revisions, claiming that the whole of the Judean tradition survived only by way of the exilic community.
|
The Inheritance of the Land According to Joshua, Judges, Samuel, and Kings
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Yigal Levin, Bar Ilan University and Ariel University Center
The four books of the Deuteronomistic History each draw a different “map” of the Land that was conquered. The basic theme of Joshua is that (almost) the entire Land was conquered, “From Mount Halak… to Mount Hermon” (Josh. 11:17). While admitting that there was a “land that remains to be conquered” (Josh. 13:1), the tribal territories described in chapters 15-21 basically assume that the entire land was possessed or would be possessed in the near future. The book of Judges, while part of the same Deuteronomistic History, assumes a very different reality: after the death of Joshua, the tribes lacked the will to continue to conquer the Land, and remained in possession of the central hill country alone – and not even all of that area. The “map” drawn here is “from Dan to Beer-sheba”, with several large enclaves of Canaanite territory nearby. This situation continues into Samuel, and even David’s conquests do not change the picture. Solomon’s empire in 1 Kings 5:1-5 ruled over all of “Across the River”, but Israel and Judah still only dwell “from Dan to Beer-Sheba”, and the land that David and Solomon conquered remained populated by Canaanites. The tribes’ failure of will leads them into direct contact with these Canaanites – which leads to sin, punishment and ultimately to exile. Even the death of the “Messiah” Josiah occurs near one of these “Canaanite” cities – Megiddo. The northern tribes, those with most contact with the Canaanites, sin more and are punished more harshly; Judah, who did conquer most of its allotment, sins less and survives to return. Thus the Deuteronomist builds upon a major theme of Deuteronomy itself in order to explain the actual history of Israel and Judah.
|
Reconciling 2 Kings 24–25 with Jeremiah: Preparing for the Judean Exile
Program Unit: Exile (Forced Migrations) in Biblical Literature
Baruch Levine, New York University
This paper will address issues and concerns germinating from 2 Kings 24-25 in light of the Book of Jeremiah.
|
Jonah’s Thought Experiment: Between True and False Prophet
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Ely Levine, Luther College
The line between true prophet and false prophet is very thin. In situations where multiple prophets claimed that their words came from the God of Israel, there was no independent verification. Prophets, such as Elisha, Micaiah, and Jeremiah, express concern about their audience trusting them amid prophetic competition; others certainly felt the same way. Deuteronomy clarifies the nature of true and false prophets, and establishes a test to distinguish between them, and a punishment for the false prophets.
Jonah, a book canonized among the prophets and that contains a prophetic story, otherwise does not fit in with the other prophetic books. Instead, we may take the literary clues in the text – from Jonah’s flight, to the renewed call that is different from the first, to the fact that Jonah is disheartened to the point of death – as indicating that Jonah is a false prophet.
The point of the book, however, is not to accuse Jonah in this way; there are too many other problems with the story. Rather, it stands as a thought experiment in prophetic self-doubt. Reading the book as describing this fine line between true and false gives us some insight into the prophetic mind. It also provides a way to explain the whole text without claiming some elements of the story as simply augmenting the narrative.
|
The Narrative Framing of the Decalogue in Deuteronomy
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Bernard Levinson, University of Minnesota-Twin Cities
Most scholarly discussion of the Decalogue in Deuteronomy has focused on its relation to its counterpart in Exodus 20: which is earlier, which later, and the literary sources to which their redaction should be attributed. More recently, attention has also been drawn to Deuteronomy 4: whether it belongs to a post-priestly redaction that seeks to harmonize the sources of the Pentateuch (Otto) or operates within the Bundestheologische Redaktion of late Deuteronomistic thought alone (Veijola). These debates have overlooked the narrative framing of the Decalogue, a question that entails probing the relation between law and narrative both within Deuteronomy and the Pentateuch more broadly. The way that the Decalogue is embedded in its narrative frame raises a series of issues about how Deuteronomy was shaped to fit within the Pentateuch as a whole. The redactional considerations at play cut through any individual conventional pentateuchal source; they also do not fit within the parameters of a D-Composition or P-Composition model. They point to a sophisticated meditation that redefines theophany in light of hermeneutics.
|
Bible – A Historical Perspective
Program Unit:
Bernard Levinson, University of Minnesota-Twin Cities
*
|
The Destruction of Texts in Ancient Israel, Assyria, and Babylonia
Program Unit: Hebrew Scriptures and Cognate Literature
Nathaniel Levtow, University of Montana
This paper will examine the phenomenon of textual destruction in ancient Israel, Assyria, and Babylonia. It will discuss the variety of ways in which scrolls and inscribed tablets were burned, smashed, buried, immersed, consumed, erased, and rewritten. Attention will be given to the social, ritual, and political contexts of textual destruction including covenant violations, military conquest, ideological usurpation, disposal rites, prophetic intermediation, and competition between religious specialists. The paper will focus on Israelite, Assyrian, and Babylonian examples of the destruction of law codes, treaty tablets, written oracles, and divine and royal statuary inscriptions. The destruction of texts will be compared to the destruction of cult images, human bodies, temples, palaces, and cities. The public dimensions of textual destruction will be linked to the promulgation of law codes, treaty tablets, and historiographic inscriptions; to the oral delivery of oracles and incantations; and to the public performance of mythic and ritual traditions. The paper will argue that the destruction of scrolls and inscribed tablets was a strategic deployment of violence aimed at scribal representations of social relations, ritual practice, and political power.
|
Martin Luther King, Jr. and the Hebrew Prophets
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Andrew Zack Lewis, University of St. Andrews
In the Yerba Buena Gardens in San Francisco stands a fountain inscribed with the following words: “No, No, we are not satisfied, and we will not be satisfied until ‘justice rolls down like water and righteousness like a mighty stream.’” Despite the quotation marks around the last phrase, the fountain attributes the entire sentence to Martin Luther King Jr. Of course King is quoting the words of Amos, a prophet he admires. However, Amos is hardly the only prophet to whom King alludes or refers in his speeches. In fact, the Bible inspires much of King’s works and had a great influence with many leaders in the Civil Rights movement.
Scholars have recently begun to pay more attention to the influence the church and theology had on the Civil Rights Movement of the 1950s and 1960s, but not much has been done on how the leaders exegeted the Bible for their sermons and speeches. This paper intends to begin this process by looking strictly at Martin Luther King’s sermons in his last three years and how they incorporate the Hebrew prophets specifically. I have chosen the last three years of his life because the sermons from those years are often overlooked. They tend to display more anger and calls for God’s judgment than one normally associates with King, but through that anger he distills a prophetic message calling for social and economic equality and an end to militarism. What also emerges in these sermons, sometimes through a flurry of allusions to the prophets, is a vision of the Day of the Lord and Kingdom of God that is universal and stretches well beyond the immediate problems in the United States.
|
When the Bible Hit the Headlines in Hong Kong
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Chun Li, Bethel Bible Seminary Hong Kong
In 2007, the Bible literally hit the headlines of Hong Kong newspaper when 1,400 complaints were made to the Television and Entertainment Licensing Authority of the Hong Kong government. It all began when a student newspaper was charged by the public as posting inappropriate pornographic articles. Spokesperson of the press refuted the charges by saying that the Christian Bible also had similar contents about rape, cannibalism, and coprophagia. Suddenly, there were over a thousand complaints about the “indecent content” of the Bible. These complaints were made by people unrelated to the student press. It is interesting to note how the Bible was quoted firstly as a Western classic to defend the position of the student press, and then complained as having obscene and indecent content. While the student press used the Bible to defend their reports as appropriate, the other complainers were targeting at “showing the Bible as merely a book written by human beings”.
The present paper analyses the discussions of this incident and explores how the Christian Bible was perceived and used by different parties. Some people saw the Christian Bible as a classical text from the West, while others identify the Bible as a symbol of the fundamentalists. Some people regarded the Bible as a benchmark for literary documents, while others saw it as a suppressing tool towards unbelievers. The responses of from the church and the public also showed that the Bible induced different emotions from different parties. These emotions are actually related to different understanding of the Bible in a Chinese culture that treated Christian Bible as a document of a Western religion called Christianity.
|
The Changing Role of Rhymed Translations of the Protestant Bible when China Moved from Oral-Based to Literacy
Program Unit: Bible Translation
Chun Li, Bethel Bible Seminary Hong Kong
The current paper introduces three attempts to translate the Protestant Bible into rhymed Chinese texts from 19th century to 20th century and discusses the role of these translations when Chinese society moved from oral-based to literacy stage. Rhyme was one of the dominating features of the texts used in oral-based stage. The three rhymed translations introduced in the present study will illustrate how the role of rhymed texts changed as China moved into a literacy society.
The first translation was done by Medhurst. He adopted the Bible into a small tract with three-character sentences that rhymed. This format was similar to the widely used Three Character Classic. The translation was used as a tool for missionaries to spread the message of the Bible to Chinese who were used to oral knowledge transmission. The second translation translated the Lamentation into a comparable genre from ancient Chinese poem Li Sao. This translation opened the way for inter-cultural conversations by matching a lament in Hebrew to an ancient Chinese lament with which Chinese scholars are familiar. The third translation was done by Wu Ching-Hsiung. He translated the Psalms into classical Chinese poems. The motivation was to create a “classic” way of presenting the Biblical messages so that the Protestant Bible could be appreciated by Chinese scholars.
It is hoped that by reviewing the history of rhymed translation of Protestant Bible into Chinese, we can explore the role of rhymed Chinese translation in the present second-orality society.
|
Identifying Heavily Damaged Manuscripts and Papyri Using the METIS Textual Identification System
Program Unit: Computer Assisted Research
James A. Libby, McMaster Divinity College
A multidisciplinary review has demonstrated that the de facto approach used to identify fragmentary texts of antiquity displays substantial limitations. These limitations produce two kinds of systemic error; the failure to find actual matches (false negatives) and the failure to reject false candidates (false positives.) An analysis of the causes that contribute to these errors has yielded a reengineered approach to fragmentary textual identification that has produced two enabling technologies: the Integrated Judeao-Christian Corpus (IJCC), a text-critical database of 205 Jewish and early Christian texts, and the development of specialized search software, the Manuscript and Epigraphal Textual Identification System (METIS). In this session we will interactively demonstrate METIS by exercising it upon the enigmatic 7Q5 fragment from Qumran. In brief, METIS allows unlimited search term depth, includes both combinatoric and permutation based searching (thus reducing false negatives), takes into account important textual characteristics such as spacing, and line skipping between terms, allows searching via wildcards or Boolean searching, implements a more accurate approach to calculating alignment by taking into account textual phenomena (such as varying character widths, etc.), produces “best fit” reconstructions of the text, implements a component-based approach to orthographic readings allowing each match or “hit” to be scored based on their summed correspondence to the contested letters in the fragment, eliminates matches that do not meet researcher determined alignment and orthographic criteria and includes a variety of automation and output options. Overall, the early evidence seems to suggest that these enabling technologies have both increased the sensitivity of textual detection, as well as improved the ability of practitioners to eliminate false candidates.
|
A Reworked Omnibus Protocol for Identifying Fragmentary Papyri Using 7Q5 as a Test Case
Program Unit: Papyrology and Early Christian Backgrounds
James A. Libby, McMaster Divinity College
A multidisciplinary review has demonstrated that the de facto approach used to identify fragmentary texts of antiquity displays substantial limitations. These limitations produce two kinds of systemic error; the failure to find actual matches (false negatives) and the failure to reject false candidates (false positives.) An analysis of the causes that contribute to these errors has yielded a reengineered approach to fragmentary textual identification. This reworked protocol consists of four elements; a redesigned component-based approach to scoring textual readings, a redesigned approach to measuring alignment (stichometry), the development of a text-critical database of 205 Jewish and early Christian texts, and the development of specialized search software. To test and validate its performance, the reworked protocol was exercised upon the enigmatic 7Q5 fragment from Qumran. The search results demonstrated that for the 26 highest likelihood readings, 2,773 matches for 7Q5 were found in the LXX, Pseudepigrapha and the New Testament. The intersection of the highest scoring stichometric and orthographic matches yielded ten final candidates; four within 2 Esdras 15:19-20, three from Deuteronomy 14:1-2, and one each from Isaiah 17:3ff, I Enoch 5:9, and Sirach 14:23. Of these, one of the 2 Esdras candidates consistently ranked first both stichometrically and orthographically, even as assumptions were varied. While it may be argued that the line length of this match does not correspond to other 7Q fragments, marked textual differences between 7Q5 and the other 7Q fragments obviate the need for any such correspondence. Finally, the 2 Esdras match fits not only the traditional Essenic context of de Vaux, it also does no violence to more recent proposals that posit a non-Essenic Qumran. Overall, the evidence seems to suggest that the reengineered protocol has both increased the sensitivity of textual detection, as well as improved its ability to eliminate false candidates.
|
Let’s Play Master and Servant: Acquiring an Assistant in the PGM
Program Unit: Religious World of Late Antiquity
Lynn LiDonnici, Vassar College
Many ritual texts of the PGM state “acquiring an assistant” as their goal. These assistants are divine visitors held under compulsion but also companions, who in at least one case will eat and sleep with the practitioner in an intimate if insubstantial daily relationship between two companions – one of whom happens to be a daimon of some sort. The assistant once acquired will be doing the actual work (whatever it is) and careful ritual practices are needed to make sure he doesn’t just go off on his own and start doing it as he wishes – perhaps even to the master practitioner himself. When the effort required for management approaches or exceeds the effort to perform the original task itself, then one may indeed ask at that point, who is the servant and who being served.
How to address the assistant, how to shape his energy to our will through names and titles is a perennial aspect of these spells… and how we describe them, the words we use for practices and categories has an effect on how we think about. For decades the scholarly categories we need to discuss these texts – things like magic, religion, tradition, ritual, authority, compulsion, mastery and dominance – these categories were the masters under whom a lot of scholarship labored. In our time these magic terms or categories have lost their power to charm and control the servants of knowledge – that is, ourselves – and we have become very unruly, rejecting categories and pointing out all their flaws. In this paper, I will address these larger issues of terminology and of our particular moment in scholarship against the backdrop of five spells for gaining an assistant in the PGM, using the methodological discussion to point out the current difficulties in understanding just what it is these spells are trying to do, and what form of intimate connection with divine realms they envision.
|
The Poetry of Creation: Amittai’s Yotzer le-Hatan
Program Unit: Midrash
Laura Lieber, Duke University
Amittai ben Shephatiah (9th century, Apulia) composed a wedding hymn on the occasion of his sister Cassia’s marriage to Hasadiah b. Hananeel in order “to crown her with charm and beauty” (Megillat Ahimaatz, Klar ed., 27). The first section of this lengthy epithalamium, a yotzer le-hatan that begins “The Lord who from the beginning tells the end,” reads the opening chapters of Genesis as the wedding of Adam and Eve. This paper will examine how this piyyut intersects with extant prose midrashic traditions; it will also explore how the liturgical-performative setting of the piyyut and its poetic structure generate uniquely payyetanic kinds of aggadic creativity.
|
Heresy and Scripture
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
Judith Lieu, University of Cambridge
Debate has long circled around the question whether Marcion stimulated and even instigated the formation of the Christian canon, or whether he responded to developments already in process. This paper will acknowledge the difficulties of historical reconstruction but will focus on how through polemics against Marcion the construction of the idea of (Christian) scripture is intertwined with the construction of heresy.
|
How to Use the Manuscript Finds from the Judean Desert to Shed Light on the Variant Literary Editions of Ezekiel
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
Ingrid E. Lilly, Western Kentucky University
Several scholars have argued that the Septuagint copy of p967 traces back to a Hebrew parent text that is different from MT. However, unlike other cases of variant literary editions, the book of Ezekiel enjoys little early Hebrew manuscript evidence that would shed light on its stages of textual development. Due to the lacuna of evidence from our Hebrew manuscripts, the fluid textual tradition behind the variant editions is harder to discern and describe.
This paper will examine the Hebrew texts from the Judean desert that shed light on Ezekiel’s textual history. Several types of manuscripts from the Judean desert bear on the textual history of Ezekiel, including: (1) fragments of Ezekiel’s text, such as those from the roll of Ezekiel (11Q4), (2) MasEzek, (3) the so-called excerpted text (4Q73), (4) Pseudo-Ezekiel, and (5) select quotations of Ezekiel in other types of texts, such as 37:23 in 4QTa. The current study will reflect on the nature of these various types of evidence and their utility to textual questions about the literary development of Ezekiel.
|
Trajectories of the Scribes in Ezekiel: MT and Targum Ezekiel in Light of Ezekiel’s Textual Tradition
Program Unit: Book of Ezekiel
Ingrid E. Lilly, Western Kentucky University
The last stages of the development of canonical Ezekiel are marked by significant textual fluidity. Following on my work with p967 and MT as variant literary editions, this paper explores the lines of interpretive continuity between MT’s edition of Ezekiel and Targum Ezekiel. Certain trends emphasized in MT’s more expansive edition, like false-prophecy, the nature of allegories, the fate of the dead, a focus on Egypt and Tyre, and Israel’s restoration characterize some of the interpretive interests in Targum Ezekiel as well. This paper will examine the strong cases for interpretive continuity in order to shed light on the dynamic scribal traditions that characterized the production of MT.
|
From Servant to Servants: Continuing the Legacy of the Exile in the Post-Exilic Era
Program Unit: GOCN Forum on Missional Hermeneutics
Bo H. Lim, Seattle Pacific University
Exile was the most formative event in Ancient Israel’s history and provided the context in which, and for which, the majority of the Old Testament was written and edited. Certainly one can speak of an exilic theology or exilic theologies. What is striking is how such influential literature arose from such a short period of time. Consequently this theology was largely lived out in a post-exilic/2nd Temple context. Not only does the Old Testament narrate how the Jews put into practice these texts, but it also demonstrates how they adapted theologically to a new situation.
This paper aims to describe how the theology of the Servant in Second Isaiah (SI) defined the identity and the mission of the community of Servants in Third Isaiah (TI), and how this community put into practice their theology as narrated in Ezra-Nehemiah. Isaiah’s Servant theology was born in exile, and TI and Ezra-Neh describes how this theology was transferred to a different context. This Servant theology provides a religious challenge to Israel by calling her to re-evaluate what it means to be the people of God. By observing how the post-exilic community continued the exilic legacy of the Servant into a new era, hermeneutical suggestions can be drawn regarding how the people of God ought to read Scripture afresh in new contexts. Since the theme of the Servant reappears in the New Testament, suggestions will be made as to how to this theology contributes to the missio Dei revealed in Jesus Christ, and announced through the apostles. Isaiah and Ezra-Neh, then, may provide a template by which the Church today may faithfully read and obey the Scriptures in light of great social-cultural shifts.
|
The Thymic Semantics of Asian Contexts: What Does Jesus’ Sorrow in Gethsemane (Matthew 26:36–46) Signify for a Korean Pastoral Kid?
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Sung Uk Lim, Vanderbilt University
This paper aims to reconstruct Jesus’ feeling of sorrow at Gethsemane (Matthew 26:36-46) from the thymic semiotic perspective. My assumption is that the Gospel of Matthew, as Timothy B. Cargal rightly claims, is founded upon the non-Western, Palestinian Jewish culture, which offers priority to the thymic category (euphoria v.s. dysphoria) rather than the veridictory category (being v.s. seeming). One cannot overemphasize the fact that meaning of a text is dynamically generated out of a plurality of contexts of the text in a diachronic sense. This offers a good reason to pinpoint the thymic category within the Jewish context in the exegesis of the Gospel of Matthew, which was clearly aligned with the first-century Palestinian Judaism.
By the same token, the contexts of the reader as well as the contexts of a text are of greatest importance to the generation of meanings of a text. In this respect, let me as a reader introduce my own specific context in which I personally read the given text of the Gethsemane scene. I as a pastoral kid feel sympathetic with what Jesus would feel at Gethsemane in the face of his imminent death. In the Korean Christian context, a pastoral kid, like a pastor, is supposed to sacrifice him/her in a way that may meet the needs of the congregation of the church. For this reason, many, although not all, pastoral kids would grow up, while being at least emotionally hurt by them. In this vein, I pay attention to Jesus’ pathos of grief at Gethsemane. With this in mind, the paper attempt to fathom why Jesus is transformed in such a way that he decides to submit to God’s will by forsaking his will, even though he was left alone by his Father as well as the disciples.
|
Political Economy of Symbolic Practice of Idol Meat Consumption in 1 Corinthians 8 through Pierre Bourdieu’s Sociology
Program Unit: Paul and Politics
Sung Uk Lim, Vanderbilt University
This paper aims to revisit the matter of political economy of idol meat consumption as symbolic practice in 1 Corinthians 8 through the lens of sociology of Pierre Bourdieu. I claim that Paul undertakes to subvert the dominant socioeconomic system of the Roman Empire by replacing the habitus of consumption with the habitus of abstention. In Bourdieu’s terms, Paul’s first letter to the Corinthians reveals the city of Corinth as a religious field, in which there exists a struggle over cultural, religious, and symbolic capitals between the strong and the weak. Via a rhetorical strategy of status reversal, imitation, and love, Paul empowers those weak of less capitals with their agency to refuse and resist the social structure as em-bodied in the habitus of eating idol meat, while persuading those strong of more capitals to surrender their authority to the social order. When all is said and done, Paul deconstructs an old, colonial habitus of consumption and thus reconstructs a new, postcolonial habitus of abstention.
To support this thesis, I have good reasons to take Pierre Bourdieu’s sociology as a method to explore 1 Corinthians 8: first, because Bourdieu pinpoints an economic and religious field where social powers in relation and religious discourse interact; and second, because Bourdieu’s work provides probably still more room for subversion of the dominant culture, in particular, related to the mode of consumption than he seems to envisage. To this end, I shall begin with a summary of Bourdieu’s main ideas such as cultural/religious/symbolic capitals, field, habitus, and strategy. Then I shall consider the benefit of Bourdieu’s method for approaching the specific case of 1 Corinthians 8, a case that demonstrates the advantage of Bourdieu’s model in a noticeable way.
|
Holy Beatings: Emmelia, Her Son Gregory of Nyssa, and the Forty Martyrs
Program Unit: Violence and Representations of Violence in Antiquity
Vasiliki Limberis, Temple University
In Encomium in xl martyres ii, Gregory of Nyssa relates a bit of biographical information that leaves his audiences, both now and then, intrigued and disturbed. It is intriguing because so succinctly Gregory invites the listener into the intimate confines of family dynamics; it is disturbing because it is so violent. Finally it is both because Gregory intended its palpable, rhetorical ramifications.
When Gregory was an adolescent, his mother, Emmelia, commissioned the building of a beautiful martyrium in Ibora, Pontus, in honor of the Forty Martyrs. Emmelia asked Gregory to accompany her to the inaugural festival, when the relics of the Forty Martyrs would be deposited. Gregory only grudgingly went with his mother. Once there his lax behavior and inattentiveness earned him a visit from the Forty Martyrs, during which they beat him.
This paper examines the violent episode from three perspectives. First, it is crucial to discuss what is ‘acceptable’ violence within the household of an elite Cappadocian family. What status and what gender can legitimately mete out corporeal punishment, and in turn receive it? Here the tension and resolution between Emmelia and Gregory, mother and son, will be explored. Next, it is important to turn to the valence Gregory gives this particular traumatic event in his life, and what it means in the larger context of his familial history. Both were extremely important to Gregory and inextricably bound to the Forty Martyrs. Is the violence legitimate because it is intra-familial, and if so what is his claim about the Forty Martyrs? The paper ends with the startling ways Gregory employs the beating in the sermon, both to reify his family as kin to the martyrs, and to assiduously promote imitation of the martyrs among the faithful. As such this has particular consequences for the meaning of family violence.
|
The Function of Poetry in the Book of Ruth
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Tod Linafelt, Georgetown University
Although the book of Ruth is in many respects a classic example of biblical Hebrew narrative, with its stripped-down prose style and the opaqueness of its character’s inner lives and motivations (à la Erich Auerbach), there are two examples of formal poetry in the book (1:16-17 and 1:20-21). Biblical poetry works with a very different set of literary conventions than narrative, and by taking note of those conventions we can see the distinctive contributions made by these poems to the book as a whole.
I suggest that the author of the book of Ruth shifts into the poetic mode here in order to give the reader access to the inner lives of Ruth and of Naomi – such access being typically denied in biblical prose narrative -- and to signal to the reader that he or she is doing so. Why? In the first place, the shift foregrounds the importance of Ruth and Naomi for the book, since they are the only two characters who get such treatment; Boaz, then, the other major character, is confirmed on this reading as secondary to these two women. But I think also that the specific content of their speeches is important to the formation of the book’s plot, introducing as it does two basic narrative tensions (personal and theological) between Ruth’s and Naomi’s view of their situation.
While many translations and commentaries recognize the verse form of these passages, virtually none has expended any energy on interpreting the significance of poetic form here. By paying attention to both the form and the function of the two speeches, we can gain insight both into their literary art and their crucial role in the plot of the book, a role that could not have been easily served by the resources of prose narration.
|
FC Baur's Place in the Study of Jewish Christianity
Program Unit: Jewish Christianity / Christian Judaism
David Lincicum, University of Oxford
While F.C. Baur has long been recognized as an important and influential scholar in the study of Jewish Christianity, recent work has rightly drawn attention to the formative work of Baur's predecessors in the study of Jewish Christianity during the 18th century. This paper seeks to contextualize Baur's investigation of Jewish Christianity in order to discern the sources and influences that shape his ideas and in this way to locate more precisely the original contribution Baur made to the discussion
|
King Og's Iron Bed
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Maria Lindquist, Harvard University
The reference to King Og's huge iron bed (eres barzel) in Deut 3:11 has long been a source of puzzlement for biblical scholars. Rather than referring to a literal “iron bed,” scholars have traditionally understood the phrase as denoting King Og's final resting place in the form of a basalt sarcophagus or dolmen. Proponents of this view have reasoned that some type of tomb would be better suited as a memorial of King Og's defeat than would a bed. I will argue, however, that a giant iron bed fits quite well within Deuteronomy’s conquest account, as the image can be shown to support Deuteronomy's broader ideological concerns and is also meaningful within the historical context of the Assyrian empire. In particular, King Og’s iron bed becomes significant when seen in light of the Neo-Assyrian custom of seizing royal beds as booty. As a war trophy, the size and substance of Og's bed take on greater import. Not only does Og's huge bed legitimate his identity as one of the Rephaim, but in citing the specific dimensions of Og's bed, the author also seems to allude to the bed of Marduk, a famous battle trophy and political status symbol in seventh-century Mesopotamian politics which is also said to have measured 9 by 4 cubits. By placing Og on the same level as Marduk, the author bolsters Og's status as a superhuman warrior. The description of Og's bed as iron further emphasizes the power of this formidable foe who is defeated by Yhwh. By recounting how Yhwh crushed the colossal King Og and captured a royal bed as grand as Marduk's, the author asserts that Yhwh is capable of competing with current international superpowers, thereby encouraging the nationalistic hope that Yhwh might again rise to battle on behalf of his beleaguered people.
|
Wild Beasts of Paradise: Royal Menageries in the Ancient Near East
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Iconography and the Bible
Maria Lindquist, Harvard University
This paper examines the venerable tradition among ancient Near Eastern kings of collecting exotic animals for display in their homeland. The royal acquisition of foreign animals through trade, hunting, or as tribute from distant kingdoms is well-documented; moreover, iconographic and textual sources from Egypt and Mesopotamia suggest that these animals may have been confined and displayed in royal game parks or menageries, which can be considered forerunners of the modern zoological garden. In this paper, I survey the evidence for the collection of wild animals and their upkeep in royal parks in the ancient Near East, focusing on the Egyptian and Neo-Assyrian empires. Extrapolating from iconography and textual sources, I also discuss the imperial ideology that underlies the royal practice of amassing exotic beasts. By subduing wild animals, the king demonstrates his ability to protect his people from forces of chaos; the domestication and display of exotic beasts shows that the king is capable of transforming threatening forces into objects of wonder and pleasure for his people. Thus, the king's collection of wild animals serves to legitimate his royal authority. Finally, the paper discusses how the political implications of the ancient Near Eastern menagerie may challenge traditional understandings of certain paradisaic scenes—in particular Isaiah 11—as presented in the Hebrew Bible.
|
Announcing the Human: Rethinking the Relationship Between Romans 1:18–32 and Wisdom of Solomon 13–15
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Jonathan A. Linebaugh, Durham University
Readers of Romans agree that there exist an unusually close correspondence between Romans 1.18-32 and Wisdom of Solomon 13-15, but when it comes to assessing why this is the case and what it means for an interpretation of Romans things are decidedly less clear. The standard (though by no means only) explanation reads Romans 1.18-32 as a strategic restatement of the Hellenistic Jewish polemic against false religion which functions within the argument of Romans 1-2 to elicit the initial agreement of Paul's Jewish interlocutor. This agreement, however, is a set up for the rhetorical turn of 2.1ff which effectively demonstrates the soteriological equality of the interlocutor and those whom he judges. Read this way, Romans 1.18-32, while contextualized within a subversive argument, is an essentially faithful representation of the Diaspora's anti-Gentile polemic, especially as it comes to expression in Wisdom 13-15 (cf. Douglas Campbell's recent radicalization of this trajectory). This paper intends to question this assumption, arguing instead that Paul's textual engagement with Wisdom is situated within a dramatic theological disagreement with Wisdom. The functional inclusion of the 'judge' of Romans 2.1ff within the scope of his own polemic invites a reconsideration of content and characters of Romans 1.18-32. Rereading this section in close conversation with Wisdom demonstrates that Wisdom 13-15 and Romans 1.18-32 articulate antithetical anthropologies. In Wisdom, the anti-Gentile polemic serves to reinforce an irreducible distinction between Jew and non-Jew. Romans 1.18-32, by contrast, consistently alters Wisdom's polemic so as to include Israel within the Verdammnisgeschichte it narrates. The result is an anthropology that presses behind the Jew-Gentile difference to identify a single category, the human.
|
Why Is This Mythology Different from All Other Mythologies?
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
James Linville, University of Lethbridge
One of the recurring themes in biblical studies is the issue of myth in the Hebrew Bible. Of course, the term itself is notoriously difficult to define, but its application to any of the materials in the Hebrew Bible is still often influenced by modern theological conceptions of the uniqueness of the Israelite world-view and not solely on academic principles and methods of comparison. This has led to unjustifiable claims that the Hebrew Bible only retains “fragments” of myths. Moreover, the predominance of the “historical” approaches to the Hebrew Bible has also served to marginalize mythic studies. Fortunately, this state of affairs has been changing in key areas but has it impacted the way the Hebrew Bible is presented in introductory texts? In many ways it has not and this raises further questions about the relationship between Biblical Research and confessional Biblical Studies on the one hand and, on the other, the secular field of Religious Studies. Introductions are generally pitched either towards overt confessional class room environments or the “grey” area between the confessional and the secular. The conclusion of the paper is a recognition of the need for a fully secular, critical introduction that is designed as a component in a comprehensive study of world and/or ancient religions and is built upon conceptions and methods taught in secular Religious Studies.
|
Reevaluating the lmlk Storage Jars
Program Unit:
Oded Lipschits, Tel Aviv University
The lecture proposes a new chronology for the lmlk and the the so-called 'private' Judahite stamp impressions. It suggests that the lmlk stamp impression system was introduced in the final quarter of the 8th century BCE when Judah became an Assyrian vassal kingdom, and that it should be interpreted in light of the new economic and administrative policies that became operative in Judah during this period. The paper maintains that the lmlk system persisted and developed after Sennacherib’s 701 BCE campaign, reusing old jars from sites not destroyed in the onslaught and also producing new jars with new types of stamp impressions. The lecture further suggests that the jars with the so-called 'private' stamp impressions were limited in number and restricted in distribution (primarily to the Shephelah of Judah), and were manufactured for only a short time (from 704–701 BCE) as part of Judah’s preparations against the impending Assyrian campaign (701 BCE).
|
Methodological Notes on the Archaeology of "The People that Remained in the Land"
Program Unit: Warfare in Ancient Israel
Oded Lipschits, Tel Aviv University
Destruction layers, abandonment, deportations and gaps in settlements are clear markers in archaeological research and relatively easy to identify. They are the clear markers of the end of archaeological periods and the bases for reconstructing changes in material culture. In reality, however, most areas were never totally destroyed, and never became totally empty and deserted. Also changes in material culture were much slower and gradual than archaeology can tell; usually there is no sudden change in material culture, and the clear-cut archaeological periods are the outcome of the archaeological methodology. In this lecture I will describe some outlines of the methodology of "the archaeology of the people that remained in the land". I will demonstrate this phenomenon with some examples, and will examine the importance and influence of this methodology on the history of Judah between the "pre-exilic and the "post-exilic" periods.
|
Transformation through a Mirror: Moses in 2 Cor 3:18
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
M. David Litwa, University of Virginia
The odd juxtaposition of beholding God in a mirror and transformation in 2 Cor 3:18 has incited many commentators to grasp for some parallel from Greek magic (R. Reitzenstein), catoptromantic ritual (H. Achelis), Dionysian mysteries (Chr. Wagner), “vision mysticism” (A. DeConick), Greco-Roman mythology (A. Weissenrieder), Wisdom traditions (M. Thrall), or Jewish hydromancy (J. Scott). All of these proposals, it is contended, fail to note the key importance of Moses in 2 Cor 3. Ancient Jewish exegetical traditions based on Num 12:6-8 portray Moses seeing God through a mirror on Mt. Sinai (Lev. Rabb 1:14; Philo, Leg. All. 3.99-101). Although most commentators note an allusion to Moses in another famous Pauline reference to a mirror (1 Cor 13:12), the allusion to the Mosaic mirror in 2 Cor 3:18 has not been explored. Using the Mosaic mirror traditions, this paper argues that Paul knew and used Mosaic mirror vision as the model for Christian catoptric seeing in 2 Cor 3:18. The Mosaic model indicates that the Christian vision through a mirror was thought of as both clear and involving a Mosaic-like metamorphosis into glory (Ex 34:29-35).
|
Shelly and Thad: Testimonies of Music, Vocation, and Faith
Program Unit: Academy of Homiletics
Gerald Liu, Vanderbilt University
*
|
Listening to the wife in Ezek 16 through the voice of Harriet Jacobs
Program Unit: African-American Biblical Hermeneutics
Stephen Llewelyn, Macquarie University
Ezek 16 presents problems for the reader and has prompted various responses. For example, Linda Day analyses the husband’s (i.e. YHWH’s) actions in terms of the behavioural patterns of wife bashing and postulates that much of the woman’s alleged activities were projections of her overly jealous and possessive husband. Van Dijk-Hemmes in her discussion of the parallel story in Ezek 23 argues that the prophet misnames the abuse and blames the victim. ‘Both are degraded and publicly humiliated in order to make clear that their sexuality is and has to be an object of male possession and control.’ But does the woman have to be the victim of either earlier abuse or male projection? As has often been noted, the woman is voiceless throughout Ezek 16. The speaker is YHWH, the allegorical husband of the oracle, and he presents the plea from his perspective and also utters the judgement against her. The conventions of speech predispose us to give him the benefit of the doubt, until such time as we hear the other side. But this never happens and so the reader is left with a one-sided account.
Attention must be given to the voice of the female character. To facilitate this, a comparison will be made with the autobiographical character of Brenda in Harriet Jacobs’ Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl. The women in both texts utilized their sexuality against the dominant male. The question is raised as to why? Ezek 16 recounts a one-sided reproach of the woman for her adulterous behaviour, and this impairs our ability to discern the motives behind her actions. Jacobs’ story, however, explains from the woman’s point of view the reasons behind her actions; we clearly understand her circumstances and how self-interest and revenge played a part in her defiance.
|
Sexuality from Jesus to Paul: Comparisons and Connections?
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
William Loader, Murdoch University
This paper addresses the question to what extent there is continuity (and possible influence) between the attitudes of the historical Jesus and Paul to sexuality. The issue arises in the context of the author’s five year research project on attitudes towards sexuality in Judaism and Christianity in the Hellenistic Greco-Roman era. To what extent did the historical Jesus shape the early Christian movement in this regard or were the attitudes which emerged primarily the reflection of common Jewish origins, of adaptations within Jewish communities to pagan influences and of appropriation of what they chose to affirm as compatible in the pagan world? To what extent did sexual issues function as identity markers, it at all, in the emerging Jesus movement? Within the broad scope of these questions the paper will examine the extent to which teaching attributed to Jesus on sexual issues finds some echo in Paul. The most obvious issue is divorce, but the paper will include attention to the less obvious: the role of Gen 2:24; assumptions about the effect of sexual intercourse on people; sexuality in holy space and time; sexuality and gender roles; and sexuality in the age to come.
|
What Happened to "Good News for the Poor" in the Johannine Tradition?
Program Unit: John, Jesus, and History
William Loader, Murdoch University
A central element of the preaching of Jesus was the proclamation of "good news to the poor," in which he announced radical change for his people, especially in their poverty and need. It informed both his eschatology and his action in ministry, as through healing and exorcism he addressed some of the drivers of poverty in the ancient world and looked to God's rule replacing the rule of his time. As the Jesus movement faced a world beyond Galilee and Judea and beyond Jesus' own Jewish people, it had to come to terms with what it might mean to proclaim good news for the poor in the wider world, whether through universalizing Jesus' message, or through retaining its promise to God's people into whom Gentiles now might be incorporated and so share its promise. The paper will argue that while this aspect of Jesus' preaching appears to have been lost in the Johannine tradition, a closer examination suggests that the Johannine community had appropriated it like most other branches of the movement at the time on the model of incorporation in Israel, and that beyond the mere solidarity of defensiveness its message of mutual love also had roots in this tradition - not least in the implications of such teaching for the poor and impoverished in both means and status. The first letter's challenge about poverty is not a one-off illustration but reflects what is mainstream in the Johannine tradition. In any such development there is both continuity and discontinuity, loss and gain, and the paper will seek to address this issue.
|
Stone Tablets: Torah Traditions in 2Cor 3
Program Unit: Second Corinthians: Pauline Theology in the Making
Hermut Loehr, University of Munster
The paper examines Paul’s reference to „stone tablets“ in 2Cor 3:3,7 within its epistolary context. It gives special attention to the intertextual relations (Hebrew Bible and Second Temple Literature) of the notion in particular and of chap. 3 in general, but turns also to text-pragmatic considerations. How can Paul’s usage of tradition and Scripture categorized? What can be concluded from 2Cor 3 with regard to Paul’s understanding of the Law? How, then, is 2Cor to be understood with regard to the making and development (if there is such) of Paul’s theology? The paper shows that Paul uses a current Jewish tradition of the time with regard to stone tablets and the Torah, but gives it a new accent. The investigation leads to the conclusion that Paul’s theological positions and use of Scripture and tradition in 2Cor are near to strategies used in Galatians.
|
“Why Did I Come Forth from the Womb?” “Geburtsverwünschung” as Part of the Hebrew Bible’s Death Wishes
Program Unit: Lament in Sacred Texts and Cultures
Hanne Loland, MF Norwegian School of Theology
While some characters in the Hebrew Bible express wishes to die (for example Elijah, Jonah, Moses) we find a few characters who not only wish to die, but wish they had died before they were born. As part of their laments Jeremiah and Job ask “Why did I come forth from the womb?”, “why was I not buried like a stillborn child?” This paper will look into the rhetorical function of wishing away one’s birth, the Geburtsverwünschung, in Job and Jeremiah. The texts in question are Jer 20:14-18 (and 15:10), and Job 3 and 10:18-19. Why is it not enough to wish to die in Job and Jeremiah? Why this wish for one’s whole life to be eradicated? Other death wishes in the Hebrew Bible function as negotiation, but Job and Jeremiah do not seem to be bargaining. The Job and Jeremiah texts construct a notion that it would be better never to have been born. This paper will study the Geburtsverwünschung in the broader context of death wishes in the Hebrew Bible and the function of death wishes in lament.
|
Barth and von Balthasar: Re-framing the Discussion
Program Unit: Karl Barth Society of North America
D. Stephen Long, Marquette University
*
|
Socio-rhetorical Commentary on Ephesians
Program Unit: Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity
Fredrick Long, Asbury Theological Seminary
This session is dedicated to examining the new contributions to the interpretation of particular texts facilitated by socio-rhetorical interpretation as this has been developed by the Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity Group under the leadership of Vernon Robbins. Three scholars engaged in writing commentaries for the Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity Series (Deo Press) will present what they believe to be the fresh perspectives or insights into particular passages from Colossians, Ephesians, and 1 John developed as a result of engaging the passage through socio-rhetorical interpretation. Respondents who have written commentaries from more traditional hermeneutical approaches will assess the relevant section of the presenter's commentary. The session as a whole seeks to nurture dialogue between practitioners of socio-rhetorical interpretation and scholars located in more traditional methodologies within the larger guild.
|
What Do Ugaritic Texts Tell Us about Greek Cosmogonies?
Program Unit: Ugaritic Studies and Northwest Semitic Epigraphy
Carolina Lopez-Ruiz, Ohio State University
Northwest Semitic texts, mainly Ugaritic and Phoenician, have been largely overlooked by classicists even though they are crucial for understanding the cultural exchange between Greeks and “orientals” in the Late Bronze Age and Iron Age. The Ugaritic Baal Cycle and the more recently published Ugaritic Deity Lists, complemented by the later Phoenician testimonies in Philon of Byblos, reveal that the divine hierarchies of the Northwest Semitic and Greek pantheons were closer than previously observed. For instance, we can see in Greek cosmogonies traces of Kronos’ role in the Succession Myth, which is paralleled by the figure of El (Ilu) in the Canaanite tradition. Briefly presenting this and other significant examples, this paper will highlight the relevance of Ugaritic studies in a new phase of exploration of Greek and Near Eastern contacts
|
The Word of God in Carnivalized Preaching: Reconsidering the Call to Preaching from Bakhtinian Perspective
Program Unit: Academy of Homiletics
Marlene Ringgaard Lorensen, Copenhagen University
*
|
Preaching 2.0
Program Unit: Academy of Homiletics
David J. Lose, Luther Seminary
*
|
Lamentable yet Laughable: The Book of Job and A Serious Man
Program Unit: SBL Forum
Katherine Low, Brite Divinity School, Texas Christian University
In the 2009 Coen brothers film, A Serious Man, featuring the unraveling life of Larry Gopnik, a junior Rabbi tells Larry that he should view his misfortunes “as expressions of God's will. You don't have to like it, of course.” Larry responds, “The boss isn't always right, but he's always the boss.” Due to Larry’s unforeseen, unfortunate, and seemingly undue problems in his life and quest to find religious meaning in the midst of it all, many viewers have described A Serious Man as a modern adaptation of the book of Job.
Hailed as the Coen brothers’ “most Jewish film” to date, this paper analyzes in what ways audiences have seen A Serious Man capture, with a particular Jewish lens, themes from the book of Job. The Coen brothers have stated that they did not consider Job at all when writing the movie. As a method of investigation, Reception History offers a unique perspective because I explore how the viewers of the film ascribe meaning to a particular Jewish take on Job in A Serious Man, regardless of the Coen brothers’ original intentions. In their assumptions about the film acting as a modern version of Job, audiences reveal significant perceptions and assumptions about the book of Job.
The paper will address several questions, including what makes viewers see Job in A Serious Man. Do variances across communities and groups affect the way people receive Joban themes in the film? What do audiences mean for the book of Job when they categorize A Serious Man as “dark Jewish comedy”? In discussing this last question, notions of Jewish humor, comedic suffering and the book of Job will surface. The paper will incorporate multi-media elements to draw attention to these questions.
|
A Contextual Reading of Matthew 6:9b–13
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Francisco Lozada Jr., Brite Divinity School
*
|
Unlocking the Cryptic Connection between the Inscription and the Icon in Pre-exilic Hebrew Seals
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Iconography and the Bible
Meir Lubetski, City University of New York Bernard M. Baruch College
Most of the writings on the iconography of Hebrew seals were published more than a half century ago and a fresh look at the connection between the engraved name and the icon has been a desideratum for some time now. The paper is designed to provide examples of how an integration of the meaning of the icon and the owner's name leads to a better and broader understanding of the message of the seal. In addition, it throws light on the cultural life of the biblical period.
|
Monotheism and Christology in Judaism, Christianity, and Islam
Program Unit: Qur'an and Biblical Literature
Alec J. Lucas, Loyola University Chicago
This paper utilizes the topics of monotheism and Christology in Judaism, Christianity, and Islam to explore the relationship between historical reconstruction and theology, with attention to the implications for interreligious dialogue. The claim of Hans Küng that the Qu’ran preserves and embraces an early Jewish low Christology before Gentile influence led to an “increasingly exaggerated” understanding of Jesus is called into question. This is done by relating the recent work of Richard Bauckham on the conception of “divine identity” (who God is) in Judaism and Christianity to the Qu’ranic understanding of Allah and Jesus. When the Qur’anic Jesus is viewed in light of Bauckham’s work, there is unity between Judaism, Christianity, and Islam in an understanding of divine identity centered upon Creation, Rule, and Worship, but disunity concerning the association of these characteristics with Jesus. Whereas early Christianity incorporated Jesus into its Jewish understanding of divine identity by depicting Jesus’ participation in Creation and Rule and his consequent reception of Worship (cf. e.g. 1 Cor 8:6; Mark 12:36; Phil 2:9–11), the Qur’an distances, if not disassociates, Jesus from these same divine identity markers (cf. e.g. surahs 3:49; 5:17; 19:35–36). Thus, employing Bauckham’s reconstruction, as opposed to Küng’s, suggests that the Qu’ran does, indeed, preserve an early Jewish Christology but it is high, not low; and it is rejected, not embraced. Two conclusions are then drawn from this study. First, the diametrically opposed outcomes of Küng and Bauckham’s work, as applied to the Qu’ran, highlight the importance of the historical reconstruction one brings to a text. Second, even if one adopts Bauckham’s particularistic understanding of Christology as applied to the Qur’an, the shared conception of divine identity in Judaism, Christianity, and Islam nonetheless provides a basis for mutual understanding and dialogue in the midst of difference.
|
Saeculum quod incipiet pertransire: 4 Ezra, Travel, and the New Age as Intellectual Space
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Timothy Luckritz Marquis, Moravian Theological Seminary
Based on a rhetorical analysis of the prevalent use of the terms _pertransire_ and _saeculum_ in the extant Latin of 4 Ezra, this paper argues that the theme of travel functions to delineate an intellectual space for reconstituting a Jewish scribal community after the destruction of the Temple in 70 C.E. According to Michael Stone, the use of _saeculum_ reflects a development within Hebrew usage in which the term _‘lm_ denotes not merely time but the space of the “world.” Similarly, the verb _pertransire_ in 4 Ezra denotes both physical travel as well as the passage of time, as it does in Latin more broadly. Travel indicates Ezra’s social location as a sage, one who has “traveled widely” (4 Ezra 3:33), a motif found elsewhere in wisdom literature. At the same time, the verb expresses the wandering existence of inhabitants of the present, evil age (e.g. 5:11). Travel evokes an ancient commonplace whereby itinerancy connotes both status and shame, life and death. As the visions and expositions develop through the text, Uriel introduces the theme of eschatological travel: attainment of a promised, heavenly kingdom requires a journey through a narrow and treacherous path (7:1-16). The “passing” of the _saeculum_ as “era” also features prominently, as do the events and tortures that visit the living and various fates of departing souls. The journey of time is ambivalent, in that the advent of the new age brings suffering and promises salvation. Read in conjunction with the anxiety 4 Ezra expresses concerning the human quest for divine knowledge, the ambivalent connotations of travel motifs function to create a social location for scribal wisdom despite affliction, as sages meditate on the revelatory nature of societal suffering.
|
Apostolic Travels as ‘Carrying around the Death of Jesus’ in 2 Corinthians 4:10
Program Unit: Second Corinthians: Pauline Theology in the Making
Timothy Luckritz Marquis, Moravian Theological Seminary
Scholars have seen Paul’s comment that he “always carries around the death of Jesus in his body” as a reference to the close union between apostolic experience and Christ’s suffering, some commentators even noting that Paul’s missionary travels may lie behind the figure. This paper more fully explores the connection between itinerancy and crucifixion in 2 Cor 4:10a and its context by reading the letter as largely comprised of travel metaphors. Such metaphors evoke ancient associations of travel or wandering with mendacity, social shame, and even death. Paul deploys travel metaphors to respond directly to suspicions and accusations concerning his apostolic authenticity. Pairing travel and death allows Paul to portray his voyages as a performative expression of Christ’s crucifixion. Contextualized within wider Greek usage (including renderings from the Septuagint), Paul’s choice of the verb _peripherein_ in 4:10a connotes notions of wandering, uncontrolled motion, error, and insanity. Simultaneously, the image builds upon the triumphal procession image introduced in 2:14-17, reveals the sufferings listed in 4:8-9 as aspects of his on-the-road affliction mentioned in 1:8, and also prepares for Paul’s discussion of his own death as a cosmic journey paling in comparison to the significance of his earthly voyages for the Gospel (4:16-5:10). Travel as an interpretive context solves many of the exegetical dilemmas surrounding the chapter by highlighting as its main focus the display of apostolic sincerity, the concurrence of inner glory and external devotion, as a model for cruciform life. The paper concludes by considering the generative nature of multivalent images for Paul’s self-presentation and how the success of travel motifs in rehabilitating Paul’s reputation in Corinth led Paul to reuse the theme of itinerancy in Romans in order to depict and defend his apostleship.
|
Eldon Epp and the Oxyrhynchus Papyri
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
AnneMarie Luijendijk, Princeton University
This paper honors Eldon Epp's work on papyrological sources, especially as it relates to the ancient Egyptian city of Oxyrhynchus and the Oxyrhynchus Papyri.
|
Jesus’ Appearance to James the Just
Program Unit: Jewish Christianity / Christian Judaism
Petri Luomanen, University of Helsinki
In Illustrious Men, Jerome describes how Jesus appeared to his brother, James the Just:
“But the Lord after he had given linen cloth to the servant of the priest, went to James
and appeared to him (for James had sworn that he would not eat bread from the hour in
which he drank the cup of the Lord until he had seen him rising again from those who
sleep), and again, a little later, it says: Bring the table and bread, said the Lord. And
immediately it is added: He brought bread and blessed and brake it and gave it to James
the Just and said to him: My brother, eat thy bread for the Son of Man is risen from
those who sleep.” (Jerome, Vir. Ill. 2; Trans. Klijn, Jewish-Christian Gospel Tradition,
1992).”
The Eucharistic allusions of the passage have often been noted but they have not been
paid much attention in the discussion about the passage, except that a meal is recognized
as one of the usual settings for Jesus’ appearance. Usually it is also assumed that one
of the basic motives behind the passage is to provide a story of James as a witness of
resurrection, mentioned in Cor 15:7 but not described in the canonical gospels. But why
does the story include James’ vow? The paper explores the possibility that the vow is
related to the so-called “Easter controversy” that arose towards the end of second
century between Asian and other dioceses (Eusebius, Hist. eccl. V 23-25). The controversy
concerned the timing of Easter and, consequently, the length of “Christian” Easter fast:
should it always end on "the day of Savior’s resurrection" or on the fourteenth of Nisan.
|
What Parting of Which Ways? The Gospel of Matthew as a Study Case
Program Unit: Construction of Christian Identities
Edmondo Lupieri, Loyola University of Chicago
In its final pages, the Gospel of Matthew accentuates its aspect of a “manifesto” defining the identity of the communities the members of which were accepting – or going to accept – Matthew’s teachings. Apparently, the counterposition against the Jewish authorities and, more in general, the non believing Jews, is at its apex.
This paper will try to identify first of all what the real object of confrontation is (the conversion and salvation of the Gentiles is at stake, given the competition of different proselytistic activities) and secondly how important the conflict with external adversaries was for the intramural contentions.
|
The Body as Social Sign in the Hebrew Bible: Analyzing the Intersection of Social and the Bodily Domains through “Shame” Terminology
Program Unit: Semiotics and Exegesis
Matthew J. Lynch, Emory University
Scholars have long studied the social processes expressed through “shame” terminology in the Hebrew Bible (e.g., bosh, klm, and ?pr). However, very little attention has been paid to ways that “shame” terminology can denote bodily representation of social “shame.” This paper argues that in a number of cases, “shame” terms presuppose a conceptual link between social shame (loss of status, sanctioning) and bodily manifestation through physical diminishment or debilitation. For example, some shamed individuals would publically display shame on their bodies by afflicting themselves. This “sociosomatic” impulse was so strong that several prophetic texts call attention to cases where bodily representation failed to occur. This paper will examine several such instances and also will also suggest ways that shame semantics shed light on larger questions about the intersection of social and bodily domains in the Hebrew Bible.
|
Sociosomatics of Shame: Exploring the Intersection of Social and Bodily Domains through “Shame” Terminology
Program Unit: Social Sciences and the Interpretation of the Hebrew Scriptures
Matthew J. Lynch, Emory University
Scholars have long studied the social processes expressed through “shame” terminology in the Hebrew Bible (e.g., bosh, klm, and ?pr). However, considerably less attention is paid to way that “shame” terminology involves bodily representation. This paper explores conceptual and behavioral links between social shame and bodily harm in the Hebrew Bible. It argues that physical diminishment or debilitation of the body is a common response to social shame (loss of status, sanctioning) in the Hebrew Bible. For example, some shamed individuals would publically display shame on their bodies by afflicting themselves. This “sociosomatic” impulse was so strong that several prophetic texts call attention to cases where bodily representation failed to occur. This paper will examine several such instances, and will also reflect on differences between biblical and modern ways of understanding the body’s response to social shame.
|
“Time to Cut Him down to Size?” A Critical Examination of Martin Gore's 'Alternative' John of Patmos
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
William John Lyons, University of Bristol
The Apocalypse of John has long been appropriated by musicians, both in sacred formats and in secular ones. Its concepts, its imagery, and its words have provided springboards for the development of extensive musical traditions through which it has continued to impact upon audiences. The vast majority of such compositions are positive appropriations, either in the sense that the Apocalypse's ideology is being broadly affirmed, or in the sense that the kinds of ideas that it contains are being positively developed to different ends. One well-known piece that fits both categories is 'John the Revelator', originally a gospel song recorded by such as Blind Willie Johnson, Son House, Beck, and Nick Cave, but later developed into a revelatory soundtrack/plot device in John Landis' film, 'Blues Brothers 2000' (1998). In 2005, however, Martin Gore, the lyrical driving force behind the British group, 'Depeche Mode', penned his own response to both Revelation and the positivist musical tradition dependent upon it. Following in the footsteps of earlier songs problematising popular Christian religion ("Personal Jesus", ''Blasphemous Rumours"), Gore subverted the tradition by characterising "John the Revelator", not as someone legitimately re-applying the visions of authors like Ezekiel and Daniel, but rather as a 'thief' who, by claiming the deity as "his holy right", stole the “God of the Israelites” (and of “the Muslims too”), and as a "smooth-operator" with a "book of lies" who needed to be cut down to size. In this paper, Gore's devastating attack on John of Patmos--"All he ever gives us is pain...., He should bow his head in shame"--is analysed as an acute critique of the Apocalypse by a hugely successful producer of populist culture and explicitly contrasted with the positivity of so much of the reception of Revelation by those within biblical scholarship.
|
The Pedagogic Importance of Emotional Appeals for Character Formation in the Book of Proverbs
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Sun Myung Lyu, Korean Presbyterian Church of Ann Arbor
Wisdom’s appeal to its reader in the book of Proverbs has a robust emotional component in that it urges the reader to desire certain values and loathe others, notably by describing characters both desirable and detestable characters (the righteous and wise, the gangs, the loose woman, Lady Wisdom and Lady Folly, to cite the most colorful ones). More than simply explaining why certain moral choices are better than others, the discourse utilizes emotional appeals to influence its readers and shape their characters according to its paradigms. The presumed target audience of the moral discourse appears to be not the wicked (deemed incorrigible and doomed) but the impressionable young people who struggle to define themselves through their actions. Proverbs recognizes that the character, namely the total makeup and disposition of a person, is the link between human actions and their consequences. Actions are bound to shape and alter the human character, and in the end the human character determines the course of the human lives. In fact, Proverbs teaches that wisdom and foolishness are dimensions of character rather than of individual actions. Given that character formation is a chief concern of the moral discourse of Proverbs, it is not surprising to find the emotional appeals playing such crucial roles. It is generally accepted as clinically proven that a person learns better when emotional aspect is incorporated into the learning process, and techniques like aversion therapy is found effective to alter behaviors. The use of emotional appeals in Proverbs therefore represents a key pedagogic strategy toward its goal of shaping the desirable character out of its readers.
|
The Pedagogic Importance of Emotional Appeals for Character Formation in the Book of Proverbs
Program Unit: Korean Biblical Colloquium
Sun Myung Lyu, Korean Presbyterian Church of Ann Arbor
Wisdom’s appeal to its reader in the book of Proverbs has a robust emotional component in that it urges the reader to desire certain values and loathe others, notably by describing characters both desirable and detestable characters (the righteous and wise, the gangs, the loose woman, Lady Wisdom and Lady Folly, to cite the most colorful ones). More than simply explaining why certain moral choices are better than others, the discourse utilizes emotional appeals to influence its readers and shape their characters according to its paradigms. The presumed target audience of the moral discourse appears to be not the wicked (deemed incorrigible and doomed) but the impressionable young people who struggle to define themselves through their actions. Proverbs recognizes that the character, namely the total makeup and disposition of a person, is the link between human actions and their consequences. Actions are bound to shape and alter the human character, and in the end the human character determines the course of the human lives. In fact, Proverbs teaches that wisdom and foolishness are dimensions of character rather than of individual actions. Given that character formation is a chief concern of the moral discourse of Proverbs, it is not surprising to find the emotional appeals playing such crucial roles. It is generally accepted as clinically proven that a person learns better when emotional aspect is incorporated into the learning process, and techniques like aversion therapy is found effective to alter behaviors. The use of emotional appeals in Proverbs therefore represents a key pedagogic strategy toward its goal of shaping the desirable character out of its readers.
|
Psalmody and a Theology of Place in the Scottish Western Isles
Program Unit: Islands, Islanders, and Scriptures
Grant Macaskill, University of St Andrews, Scotland
A distinctive form of Calvinism is observed in certain of the Western Isles of Scotland, with a spirituality that from the outside can appear cold and hard (as it is portrayed in, for example, Lars von Trier’s film, Breaking the Waves). In fact, the outward solemnity of worship can mask a warm and emotional appreciation of divine presence that is distinctively expressed through the medium of Gaelic psalmody, the exclusive form of sung worship in such traditions. While such “exclusive psalmody” is practiced elsewhere, it has a distinctive association with the Western Isles and the Gaelic language that survives in density only there.
The psalms furnish the key spiritual vocabulary of Island Presbyterians and, as the sole form of sung praise, require to be translated Christologically. They also, however, require to be translated geographically: the frequent naming of places in the psalms creates a profound sense that God is encountered in specific locality, but these named localities must be subconsciously transferred to the Island. Thus, the psalms furnish a powerful theology of place for those who sing those psalms exclusively. Combined with the celebrated “thinness” of the Western Isles—the felt immanence of the other world—this creates a potent local theology.
This paper will examine this theme, approaching it through contemporary island literature and, particularly, non-liturgical songs that embody such a spirituality. It will be suggested that the phenomenon highlights a dimension to the psalms that can easily be overlooked in other contemporary contexts and pinpoints one distinctive contribution that the psalms can make to contemporary worship.
|
Better to Rule in Hell? Lucifer and Hell in Neil Gaiman's "Sandman"
Program Unit: Bible and Popular Culture
Grant Macaskill, University of St Andrews, Scotland
Of all the great works published by America’s DC Comics, The Sandman series stands out for its intellectual depth and literary quality, receiving the kind of widespread critical acclaim that allow it to be regarded as a contemporary “classic” of the genre. While the work of a British author, Neil Gaiman, the work is rather more American in its orientation, engaging in particular with East Coast culture of the 80s and 90s. As with Gaiman’s other books, the series draws on great texts and ancient myths to construct an eclectic mythology that embraces contemporary society in its depictions of “The Endless,” a family of god-like beings that embody human identity: Dream, Despair, Desire, Destiny, Delirium (who was once Delight), Destruction and Death.
Jewish and Christian tradition contribute significantly to the text and provide many of the figures encountered by the key character, Dream. This paper will examine two major storylines in the series that revolve around the person of Lucifer and the location of Hell. I will argue that Gaiman uses these to reflect upon the nature of guilt and evil, understanding both as primarily self-destructive instincts. While he draws on both biblical and Miltonian imagery, Gaiman’s skillful storytelling, married to the visual potential of the graphic novel medium, allows this source material to achieve its full contemporary impact, speaking to the late-modern American condition. As always, Gaiman avoids naïvety in his reflections on human experience through his profound grasp of tragedy as a genre and by his sensitivity to the functions of myth. Essential to his success, though, is the subtlety with which he develops the conflicted character of Lucifer and the ambiguity with which he imbues his abdication of the throne of hell.
|
Mark Must Have Known Q, but Which Q?
Program Unit: Markan Literary Sources
Dennis MacDonald, Claremont School of Theology
Scholars typically reconstruct Q by comparing content common to Matthew and Luke and by eliminating Marcan influence; consequently, one would assume that hypothetical reconstructions of the lost Synoptic source would have little in common with Mark. On the contrary, text established by the editors of the Critical Edition of Q, for instance, shares with Mark more overlapping content than exists between any two ancient documents for which one would not require direct literary borrowing. Many interperpreters thus insist that Mark knew and used Q.
In this paper I will argue that Mark indeed knew Q but that the Q he used was nearly twice as long as appears in CEQ. I call this lost text the Logoi of Jesus or Q+ and reconstruct it primarily on the basis of inverted priority, that is, from evidence that Matthew and Luke preserved content in a more original form than in their surviving sources. Although some of these units may derive from oral tradition, it is more likely that they, and Mark, knew a document, now lost, with this more primitive material. This assessment permits far more precision in identifying Marcan redaction and precludes the need to posit any other missing source.
|
Education, Speech, and the Rhetoric of Parenting in 2 Timothy
Program Unit: Speech and Talk in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Margaret MacDonald, Saint Francis Xavier University
2 Timothy displays a remarkable degree of concern about speech, including speech at inopportune and opportune times, the destructive speech of opponents, and the power of speech to persuade (e.g., 2 Tim 4:1-5). Closely related to the interest in speech is the interest in the roles of true teachers and preachers with decidedly “public” orientations. This is in contrast to the false teachers who creep into households and capture “silly little women” (2 Tim 3:6). The purpose of this paper is to examine the focus on speech taking into consideration recent scholarship on early Christian families and the house-church setting. By drawing upon ancient educational discourse where even the nurse’s standard of speech was prized in the rearing of very young children, the paper will examine the concern for speech in light of the house church as a locus of education. The presentation of Timothy as absorbing faith and knowledge from infancy and through the agency of women (2 Tim 1:5; 2 Tim 3:15) is of particular interest.
|
Response to "The Future of Biblical Studies"
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Peter Machinist, Harvard University
This paper is a response to the four papers of the session on The Future of Biblical Studies.
|
A History of a History: Reflections on Isaac Kalimi's New Chronicles Book
Program Unit: Midrash
Peter Machinist, Harvard University
Kalimi's new history of the study of the books of Chronicles is valuable not only for its comprehensive coverage of its topic. It also raises questions about the nature and significance of history-writing in classical Jewish tradition. The present paper, with Kalimi's book as a base, seeks to grapple with these questions, and so to compare the post-Biblical Jewish with the Biblical ways of dealing with history.
|
Early Christian Eschatological Experience in the Warnings and Exhortations of Hebrews
Program Unit: Hebrews
Scott D. Mackie, Independent Scholar
The Epistle to the Hebrews is one of the most eschatologically oriented books in the NT. The author repeatedly expresses his conviction that the Christ event had inaugurated the eschaton (1:2; 9:26), thus signaling the imminent end of both the earthly realm and the present age (9:28; 10:12-13, 25, 37-39; 12:25-29; 13:14), and the present accessibility by faith of the heavenly realm and future age (4:14-16; 10:19-23). Perhaps the most conspicuous indication of the imminent “end of the ages” was the miracles and profound spiritual experiences that were apparently occurring in the community addressed by Hebrews. The author considers these manifestations of the “powers of the age to come” (6:5) to be divinely sent “testimonies” to the truth of the gospel (2:4). Though accounts of these eschatological experiences are found throughout Hebrews, they are particularly concentrated within the most rhetorically charged contexts: the warnings against apostasy (2:1-4; 6:4-6; 10:26-31), and the exhortations to persevere (3:6, 14; 4:1-11, 14-16; 10:19-23; 12:5-17), where they perform a similar testimonial function. This paper examines both the nature of the eschatological experiences as well as their rhetorical function in the warnings and exhortations of Hebrews. In these two contexts, warnings and exhortations, nearly every aspect of the community’s eschatological experiences is vitally connected to the author’s hortatory strategy. His warnings of the dire consequences of forsaking the community are almost entirely substantiated by appeals to the community’s eschatological experiences. The severity of the warnings may also have been conditioned by his perception of their import. Similarly, the author’s exhortations to persevere, offered in response to societal opposition the community was probably facing, are largely supported and empowered by both reminders of their past and present supernatural experiences and promises of future eschatological blessings. This analysis of the eschatological experiential elements and their rhetorical function in the warnings and exhortations of Hebrews therefore contends they be considered integral to the author’s hortatory effort.
|
The Role of Scriptural Interpretation in Philo of Alexandria’s Mystical Praxis
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
Scott D. Mackie, Independent Scholar
A good deal of attention has been paid to almost every aspect of Philo of Alexandria’s allegorical interpretations of scripture, including his methods and structure, his use of traditions and sources of influence, and even the socio-cultural function. However, the role allegorical exegesis plays in his mystical praxis has been relatively neglected. This paper contends that allegorical scriptural interpretation is at the heart of Philo of Alexandria’s mystical praxis, and it attempts to demonstrate the manner in which this allegorical text work inspires a contemplative ascent to the noetic realm, where one might see God. Though Platonic contemplative ascent undoubtedly informed Philo’s own practice of mystical ascent (Migr. 34-35; Spec. 3.1-6), he is careful to attribute the practice to Moses instead. In fact, Philo even contends Moses discovered the noetic realm (QE 2.52). Most relevant, however, is his depiction of Moses’ receipt of the Torah as involving a paradigmatic noetic ascent and contemplation of the Forms (Mos. 1.158-159). As with many other ancient Jewish and early Christian accounts of mystical practice, Philo’s portrayal of Moses’ revelatory experience describes and prescribes the means of heavenly ascent for others. Since the Torah reflects Moses’ noetic experience, those who correctly read that text may in turn experience the same heavenly, noetic vision (Plant. 18-27). In addition to his autobiographical accounts (Migr. 35; Spec. 3.1-6; Somn. 1.164–165), Philo locates this same pattern of textual mysticism in the praxis of the Therapeutae/Therapeutrides (Contempl. 11-12, 28–30, 78). These latter texts are also particularly instructive for understanding Philo’s own mysticism, since contrary to popular opinion, they explicitly demonstrate that the cognitive activity of text work is capable of inspiring emotionally rich mystical experiences that transcend rationality. Thus Philo’s mystical praxis is almost entirely dependent upon allegorical exegesis, as it is truly the “method dear to those whose eyes are opened” (Plant. 36).
|
A New Database and Online Environment for Patristic Citations
Program Unit: Novum Testamentum Graecum: Editio Critica Maior
Rosalind MacLachlan, University of Birmingham
This paper will discuss a new database and online tools for dealing with patristic citations, particularly in the production of a new critical edition of the Gospel of John.
|
The Nations in Zechariah: The Rise of a Revelatory Tradition
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Heather Macumber, St. Michael's College
The visionary material of Zechariah 1-6 has led to much speculation concerning the place of this book amongst the other prophetic books of the Hebrew Bible. As Zechariah carries forward older traditions, it also carves out new ways especially with regards to angelic mediation. While the first six chapters are focused on divine revelation, these visions are firmly rooted in the situation Israel faces in relation to other nations. Israel continues to suffer from its past experience of exile and its present situation under Persian control (Zech 1:15; 2:4, 12). Yet the book of Zechariah also contains the possibility of including the nations along with Israel in peace coexistence (Zech 2:15). Each of these episodes are revealed by the angelic mediator through symbolic visions or by angelic communication with God. This paper proposes that the innovative use of the angelic intermediary allows the prophet to access divine revelation concerning Israel’s past, present and future relationship with the nations. Thus, allowing the nation of Israel a fuller understanding of its place both as God’s people and as part of the larger world.
|
Tell es-Safi/Gath in the Late Iron Age I and Iron Age IIA
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Aren Maeir, Bar Ilan University
In this paper I will present an overview of the archaeological finds from Tell es-Safi/Gath dating to the late Iron Age I and Iron Age IIA (ca. late 11th/early 10th to mid/late 9th centuries BCE), as revealed in the last 15 years of excavation at the site. Based on these finds, I will try to assess the role, size and character of Philistine Gath during this period, and discuss the implications of these finds for understanding the processes and structures that existed in Philistia, the Judean Shephelah, and other regions of the Levant, during this time frame.
|
The Mundane Wisdom of Job 28: Reading the Poem within Its Tradition
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Sophia Ann Magallanes, University of Edinburgh
Job 28 compares two “down-to-earth” procedures: 1) digging into the earth in search for the hidden treasure (vv. 1-11), and 2) the process of finding wisdom on earth’s surface (vv. 12-28, especially v. 25, “[God] looks to the ends of the earth and sees everything under all heaven”). The one(s) mining for precious metals and stones in verses 1-11 are human, while the one who looks for and “finds” wisdom is a divine being (vv. 25-28). Because the world (mundus) is context for both the processes of mining and for finding wisdom, both procedures are equally mundane. Nowhere does the poem divert from the earthly and mundane.
A close reading of Job 28:1-1 and 12-28 within the context of the sapiential texts (Job, Proverbs, and Qoheleth), challenges the reader to redefine what the book of Job is saying about wisdom in ethical terms and, therefore, also provokes a redefinition of the divine gaze upon the earth in terms of divine justice. It is obvious that Job 28 speaks of a hidden wisdom, but it is not so obvious how this prescribed wisdom (fear of God and avoiding evil) is connected to divine justice until the poem is read within the of context of the biblical wisdom books (Job, Proverbs, and Qoheleth).
In this paper, we shall see how wisdom and divine justice are both rooted in earthly matters. It is only when the “down-to-earth” aspects of both topics are explored that we see that they are related to each other in sapiential literature. If ‘wisdom’ is understood as proper conduct on earth (avoiding evil action, Job 28:28b) prompted by an understanding that God gazes on this earth he created (fear of the Lord, Job 28:28a), then divine justice is to be understood as divine regulation of that proper conduct and attitude. Because this is the case, there is a need to explore these divine matters in earthly terms.
|
Food and Clothing in the Gospel of John
Program Unit: John, Jesus, and History
Jodi Magness, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
Scholars have noted that the Fourth Gospel provides historical and archaeological information including references to sites in Jerusalem which is not contained in the Synoptic Gospels. This suggests that John drew on or incorporated some different sources than the Synoptic
accounts. Is the additional information provided by John historically and archaeologically accurate, and does this information preserve authentic traditions relating to the historical Jesus? This paper examines selected details surrounding food and clothing in the Fourth Gospel which are not contained in the Synoptic Gospels, in an attempt to ascertain whether this information might be connected to the historical Jesus.
|
The Character of YHWH in Jeremiah in Postcolonial Perspective
Program Unit: Writing/Reading Jeremiah
Christl M. Maier, Philipps-Universität Marburg
The political message of Jeremiah in Jer 21:4-10 commands to surrender to the Babylonians, i.e. to an imperialist regime that imposes its rule on Judah by military force and economic coercion. While Jer 21 characterizes YHWH as active agent in colonizing the inhabitants of Jerusalem, there are other passages arguing that the deity had no other choice (Jer 5:7-9; 12:7-12a). From the perspective of the survivors of Jerusalem’s defeat who are colonized under Babylonian rule, this ‘ambivalence’ in the portrait of YHWH seems to be a means to cope with the loss of both their home and their faith in a strong national deity. The paper aims at reading these passages by using the concepts of ‘ambivalence’ and ‘agency of the subalterns’ introduced by the postcolonial thinkers Homi Bhabha and Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak.
|
Fourth-Century Images of the Healing of the Hemorrhaging Woman
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Art
Elizabeth Struthers Malbon, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University
The synoptic Gospel story of the healing of the hemorrhaging woman is portrayed in a number of Early Christian art works. My presentation will investigate the significance of the appearance of the scene—especially its significance in relation to other scenes on the same work—on about half a dozen well-preserved fourth-century sarcophagi (now mostly in the Museo Pio Cristiano of the Vatican Museums) and on the ivory carvings on the Brescia casket (box). In addition, I will be investigating references to this New Testament story in several fourth-century writers: church historian Eusebius, theologian and bishop Augustine, and poet Ephrem the Syrian. My focus will be how the story of the faith of the hemorrhaging woman is incorporated into the differing contexts of these writers and artists to serve their distinctive agendas.
|
‘That Tares It!’ and ‘Sow it goes:’ Us/Them/Inside/Outside/Over/Under: Re-inscribing Power in Matthew
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Robert D. Maldonado, California State University-Fresno
Not insignificant segments of the gospel tradition, some more than others, exhibit egalitarian or at least anti-hierarchical tendencies. As important as such impulses are, they bring a danger of re-inscribing exploitative power dynamics in spite of (or, perhaps, because of) resistance. While Matthew provides aspects of resistance to power-over, e.g., “call no one father” (Mt 23:9), the gospel also distinguishes between leadership in the community (symbolized by the character of the disciples, e.g., in the parable of the wheat and the tares) and the rank and file. This establishes a hierarchy which can work counter to the egalitarian impulses. A contextual reading highlights these dynamics via a dual focus on plural contexts, both ancient and modern. Modern awareness of the influence of context on reading, for example, Luther’s reading of the contemporary Catholic Church and comtemporary Anglo-American atomistic individualistic readings of Jesus, as well as negative imperialist and racist readings, has, hopefully, sensitized us somewhat to the dangers and fraughtness of interpretation and context. On the other hand, the gospel community’s apparent inability to escape similar traps provides a caution to any contextualist reading against impulses to universalize or totalize our readings, including alleged progressive ones. This paper offers an intercontextualist approach to modern and ancient readings (and writings) and explores the strategies of resistance in the community of Matthew reflected in the gospel (and in our readings).
|
Between Galatia and Johns Hopkins: Intersex(ed) Challenges to the ‘Management’ of Biblical Bodies (and Beyond)
Program Unit: LGBTI/Queer Hermeneutics
Joseph A. Marchal, Ball State University
Many of the current medical standards for the “management” of intersex(ed) populations rely upon and reinstall particular normalizing trajectories of gender, sexuality, and embodiment, trajectories that show surprising resonances and reflections from an ancient biblical domain. The challenges brought by intersex(ed) activists and scholars suggest a number of alternatives to these continuing trajectories, alternatives that should also transform ethically and politically accountable interpretations of texts like Paul’s letter to the Galatians. Galatians and its interpretation should prove particularly relevant since the persistent scholarly focus on a Paul focused on the circumcised penis itself focuses upon, obsesses over, and reinstalls the normative place of Paul’s perspective on embodied practice in the community. However, the correspondences between these two loci of debate and deliberation (ancient Galatia, hypermodern hospital) also indicate that any normalizing argument cannot finally foreclose its subversion or anticipate solidarity between unexpected allies. These attempts at initiating people into constrained forms of community, both biblical and beyond, can (and do) become sites for resistance. Thus, pursuing an analysis attentive and accountable to these sets of arguments can lead to rather idiosyncratic, or even queer potentialities for a critical present that reframes the meaning and meeting of baptisms, bodies, and belonging (religious or otherwise).
|
Paul as Socrates in Acts
Program Unit: Book of Acts
Daniel Marguerat, University of Lausanne
The presence of a Socratic model in the the Lukan picture of Paul has been long ago recognized. But the parallels have been limited to the similarity of appareance before court and condemnation between Paul and the Athenian philosopher (Acts 17,16-34), A close scrutiny of the argumentation of the discourse in Athens shows however an impressive number of internal similarities between both. Other passages (14,11-18; 19,8-10) make clear that Luke has consciously modelled his portrait of Paul in that direction. His intention is to show Paul endorsing the role of witness of the truth as the Greek culture uses to conceive him. The profile of Christianity as a school ("the Way") belongs to the some cultural model.
|
Sense and Soul in the Hebrew Bible and in the Septuagint
Program Unit: Senses, Cultures, and Biblical Worlds
Peter Marinkovic, Ludwig-Maximilians Universitaet
In the Hebrew Bible as well as in its Greek version, the Septuagint, we can find non-dualistic and non -naturalistic concepts of living beings and their senses. The most important keyword of these concepts is soul (Hebrew: nephesh; Greek: psyche). This observation corresponds to concepts of soul that are proposed by pre-Socratic philosophers and authors (e.g. Aischylos, Antiphon, Aristides, Euripides, Hesiod, Pindar, Sophokles) as well as by the post-Platonic philosopher Aristotle (384 BC – 322 BC), especially in his De anima.
It is helpful to explore non-naturalistic concepts of the human person and his senses which are at the same time non-dualistic. The background is the Aristotelian concept of the soul. In the Aristotelian context the soul was considered to be the particular “forma substantialis” of a living organism. “Forma” refers to the nature of an individual determining its identity -, continuity -, and existence - conditions and identifying its typical powers and capacities.
In the field of (neuro-) biological descriptions there are findings which seem to fit well into a Biblical and Aristotelian framework. These findings stress the importance of the organizational and functional structure of the human organism for an adequate conception of human identity.
Because of these scientific data we consider the Biblical and Aristotelian concept of the soul superior to the concept of self. The notion of the soul refers to functional organisation as well as to biological and cognitive capacities of the human person and their mutual interdependence. The notion of self, instead, is traditionally bound to cognitive processes alone.
We take the soul to be a useful concept for conceiving the human being as psycho-physical unity. There is just one subject – the animate organism – which in virtue of its nature is able to do the things a living being of this specific kind typically does (if circumstances permit).
|
The Table and Early Judaism II
Program Unit: Meals in the Greco-Roman World
Susan Marks, New College of Florida
This paper will propose a set of theses defining the table as a generative locus for social formation in early Judaism.
|
Between Law and Land: Physical, Social, and Religious Disjuncture in Hosea
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Hilary Marlow, Cambridge University
A number of the biblical prophets present a clear link between Israel’s relationship with her God, societal ethics and the wellbeing of the land. This is epitomised in Hos 4:1-3 which in just a few verses presents this relationship in terms of cause and effect: the people’s neglect of YHWH results first in social breakdown and then in desolation of the land. This paper will explore this interconnection in more detail in order to establish more clearly how the relationship is construed in Hosea as well as in other prophetic texts. It will also assess the extent to which similar themes may be found in other ANE writings, in particular those from the neo-Assyrian period and suggest that Hosea and his contemporaries develop more fully ideas that are embryonic and perhaps marginal in other literature of the region. This development is the product of the biblical prophets’ unique emphasis on the personal nature of Israel’s relationship with her God, as depicted in Hosea in terms of metaphors of marriage and family.
|
“What Am I in a Boundless Creation?” An Ecological Reading of Sirach 16 and 17
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Hilary Marlow, Cambridge University
This paper draws on insights from the field of ecocriticism within literary studies, as well as engaging with the methods of the Earth Bible Project, to examine the creation poem of Sirach 16:26-17:14 from an ecological perspective. The text is significant for such a purpose because of its reuse of the Genesis creation accounts, in particular the notion of human beings as the image of God and human dominion over creation, which has caused some critics to label the biblical accounts as exploitatively anthropocentric. The paper explores the tension in the poem between human finitude, and the unique and potentially exploitative nature of the divine image in human being. It suggests that the poem’s stress on the stability and order of the cosmos and on the ethical responsibilities of Torah provides a framework for resolving this tension as well as inviting recognition of the ambiguity of human place in the world and of the ethical challenges posed by growing environmental pressures.
|
Preaching through Our Troubles: How Preachers Use Their Sermons to Heal in Times of Intense Personal Challenges
Program Unit: Academy of Homiletics
Kay Palmer Marsh, Iliff School of Theology
*
|
Who Is My Flesh? Uncovering the Honorable Family in Lev 18:7–23
Program Unit: Social Sciences and the Interpretation of the Hebrew Scriptures
Noah M. Marsh, Iliff School of Theology
This paper argues Leviticus 18:7-23 extends the definition of family given in Lev 18:6 beyond a single family to incorporate all humans and YHWH by extending the familial concern for honor. Leviticus 18:7-23 extends the familial boundaries through three movements: blood (consanguine) relatives (18:7-13), conjugal relatives (18:14-19), and extra-familial relatives (18:20-23). The first movement (18:7-13) uses the term “flesh” (????) from Lev 18:6 to form an inclusio that ends with two prohibitions of blood aunts. The passage transitions easily to the second movement with a third prohibition concerning an aunt, but this aunt is a conjugal relative. The second movement (18:14-19) uses the verb “to approach” (???) from Lev 18:6 to form an inclusio. The third movement uses the phrase, “Do not have sex to become unclean from it” (?? ??? ?????? ????????) to form an inclusio. Unlike the preceding two movements, the third movement’s inclusio does not recall the initial prohibition in Lev 18:6. Instead the central clause (18:21b) repeats the phrase “I am YHWH,” otherwise only found in 18:6. The three movements’ prohibitions all protect the reader’s honor. The first movement prohibits the reader from shaming a blood relative and thereby dishonoring the household to which he belongs. The second movement extends prohibition against shaming to a conjugal relative since they too are a part of the reader’s household. The third and final movement extends the reader’s concern for honor to all Israel, YHWH, and any non-Israelite. This radical extension of the concern for honor beyond blood and conjugal relatives challenges the ancient (and modern) reader’s exclusive definition of whom is considered “flesh.”
|
Grace in Creation: Kierkegaard on James 1:18 and the Condition for Receiving Gods Gifts
Program Unit: Søren Kierkegaard Society
Paul Martens, Baylor University
Luke Timothy Johnson, following Richard Bauckham (1999), claims that Kierkegaard “does not so much try to figure out what James meant as to consider what his own life means in light of James” (2004, 243). The purpose of this paper is to challenge the either/or implicit in Johnson’s assessment by attending to Kierkegaard’s interpretation of James 1:18.
In the intense scholarly debates surrounding this passage, there are three basic options concerning who is brought forth by the “word of truth”: humanity, Jews, or Christians. In his idiosyncratic “upbuilding discourses” devoted to James 1:17-22, Kierkegaard seems oblivious to the minute details of this debate. Yet, this paper displays how a careful reading of Kierkegaard’s 1843 “Every Good Gift” discourse places him right in the middle of the debate. In short, this paper shows how Kierkegaard’s exegetical reflections on James 1:18 provide a sort of theological anthropology, an account of how God’s grace is the first word: God extends grace to all humanity in that God creates everyone with the absolute need for God, a good and perfect gift that (a) must be awakened and (b) can only be satisfied by the gift of the received Word (James 1:21).
The proposed paper begins by briefly summarizing the scholarly debates surrounding this verse. Second, in conversation with Timothy Polk (1997) and Bauckham, it carefully examines Kierkegaard’s cryptic comments in the second of “Four Upbuilding Discourses” published in 1843. Third, it explores related texts in Kierkegaard’s corpus—“To Need God is a Human Being’s Highest Perfection” (1844), Philosophical Fragments (1844), and Works of Love (1847)—to illuminate the depth of Kierkegaard’s interpretive insight. In conclusion, coming full circle, the paper argues that it is precisely through considering his own life in light of James that Kierkegaard passionately sought to interpret what James meant.
|
Origen's Doctrine of Pre-existence in Its Exegetical and Heresiological Contexts
Program Unit: Christian Theology and the Bible
Peter Martens, Saint Louis University
People often talk about Origen's doctrine of the pre-existence of souls or minds as "speculative," implying that this is a whimsical and largely conjectural theme. This teaching is also invariably framed as yet another sad episode in the Hellenistic take-over of Christian doctrine, and thus, that it was deservedly anathematized.
I will re-examine this doctrine. I will begin with an overview of the cardinal elements in Origen's understanding of the pre-existent state, including his account of the fall of minds (drawing primarily from On First Principles). Without denying his sources in Hellenistic philosophy, I will pursue two lines of thought. (1) How did Origen seek to integrate Scripture, and in particular, the opening chapters of Genesis, into his curious account of beginnings? Origen was undeniably an exegete, and so too sensed (as many of his readers have also often sensed) that there was some disconnect between his account of beginnings and the account we find in Genesis. (2) To what extent did Origen's doctrine of pre-existence serve as a calculated rebuttal of "Gnostic" theology? I will argue that there is a lot less idle speculation and a lot more pointed agenda in the contentious doctrine of preexistence than most scholars recognize. The key texts for my argument will be Origen's first Homily on Genesis, books 1-2 of his Commentary on John and his Commentary on Genesis.
|
Yahweh, Balaam, and the Ass That Speaks: A Pentecostal Hearing of Balaam’s Prophecy (Numbers 22–24)
Program Unit: Society for Pentecostal Studies
Lee Roy Martin, Pentecostal Theological Seminary
Utilizing a literary/theological approach, this paper attempts (1) to place Balaam’s oracles within context of the Torah and the book of Numbers and (2) to assess their significance for Pentecostal theology. In the Balaam story, God speaks both through an ass and through a stubborn diviner, while Israel is not active in the events. It is proposed that God's speaking through Balaam can contribute to our understanding of how God speaks in the world outside Israel and the Church. In light of the statement that “the Spirit of God came upon” Balaam (Num. 24:2), it is argued that the Holy Spirit plays an important role in the Balaam narrative.
|
Trade Networks, the Canaanite Jar, and the Dissemination of Alphabetic Script
Program Unit: Ugaritic Studies and Northwest Semitic Epigraphy
Robert J. Martin, University of Toronto
This paper explores the relationship between the robust trade networks of the Bronze and Iron Ages and the dissemination of alphabetic script. Beginning with Liverani’s suggestion that alphabetic writing had spread westward along trade routes from the Levant by the Iron II, I trace this process to the Bronze Age (BA). The Canaanite Jar is ideally suited to provide a useful index of MBII-LBA trade networks. Comparing the BA trade patterns implied by the distribution of the Canaanite Jar with early alphabetic inscriptional evidence discloses an apparent correlation. Moreover, the littoral distribution of this vessel highlights the importance of maritime trade and the dendritic networks associated with port centers during the BA. The evidence supports the role of the BA Canaanites and the IA Phoenicians in this process, but the spread of the alphabetic principle in the Near East and Mediterranean during the BA and IA was itself a consequence of long distance trade of a remarkably cosmopolitan and increasingly maritime nature.
|
Putting the Monster, Egypt, under Check: Geo-Political Minimization of Egypt (Ezekiel 29:12–16) and Pharaoh’s Descent into Sheol (Ezekiel 32:17–32)
Program Unit: Book of Ezekiel
Safwat Marzouk, Princeton Theological Seminary
The prophet Ezekiel portrays Egypt as a monster twice in his collection of oracles against Egypt (Ezek 29:3; 32:2). After YHWH’s spectacular defeat of Egypt/Pharaoh who is embodied as a monster of chaos (Ezekiel 29:3-5; 32:2-5), YHWH intends to restore Egypt to its southern origin (Ezekiel 32:12-16) and he commands the prophet to send Pharaoh/Egypt down into Sheol (Ezekiel 32:17-32). Many scholars have discussed how Ezekiel appropriates the Chaokampf tradition in order to proclaim the divine judgment over Egypt. One of the motifs that scholars have not dealt with in relation to Ezekiel’s appropriation of the Chaoskampf is the notion of putting the power of chaos under check. In this paper I will argue that by minimizing Egypt’s political power, pushing its borders to the south, and sending pharaoh down into Sheol YHWHH restrains the power of chaos embodied by Egypt. In this way YHWH will maintain the boundaries between Egypt, the monster that perpetuates chaos, and Israel. In other words, I believe that Ezekiel puts Egypt, the monster of chaos, under check in two different ways that correspond to both empirical and cosmological geographies: first YHWH minimizes Egypt geographically and politically by making her a lowly kingdom that occupies the southern region of the land of Egypt, therefore it will be at a greater distance from Israel (Ezekiel 29:14-16). Second, by sending pharaoh and Egypt's hordes into Sheol, YHWH positions Egypt at the periphery of the cosmos, where it occupies even the periphery of the nether world. There Egypt will be accompanied by the impure uncircumcised and the slain by the sword (Ezekiel 32:17-32; Cf. 31:18). This study will be illumined by the work of Mark Smith, who has provided a structural analysis of the relationship between the anthropomorphic gods and the monstrous gods in the Ugaritic religion. Whereas the anthropomorphic gods occupy the centre, the monsters inhabit the periphery, be it a steppe (mdbr) or the nether world. In the case of Ezekiel, whereas Israel occupies the centre, Egypt the monster occupies the periphery. The boundaries between chaos and the ordered world will be restored and tightly maintained.
|
The Monstrification of Egypt in Ezekiel: Why Is Egypt a Monster in Ezekiel?
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Safwat Marzouk, Princeton Theological Seminary
The prophet Ezekiel portrays Egypt as a monster twice in his collection of oracles against Egypt (Ezek 29:3; 32:2). Many scholars have discussed how Ezekiel appropriates the Chaokampf tradition in order to proclaim the divine judgment over Egypt. Scholars also have alluded to the political alliance between Judah and Egypt against Babylon as the motive behind Ezekiel’s severe judgment against Egypt. What scholars have not discussed, however, is why Ezekiel portrays Egypt as a monster— what function does the vivid monstrification of Egypt serve in the book of Ezekiel?
A monster, which embodies chaos, represents boundaries transgressed; it is an interstitial creature that does not fall into a natural category; it is what is in the house but does not belong to the house (unheimlich). I will argue in this paper that according to the prophet Ezekiel the boundaries between Egypt and Israel were transgressed at the time of the exile. I establish my argument based on Ezekiel’s revision of the history of Israel from its presence in Egypt prior to the Exodus until the time of the exile. According to Ezekiel the Israelites prior to the Exodus worshipped Egyptian idols (Ezek 20:7-8) and they whored with the Egyptians (Ezek 23:1-3). By depicting the relations between Judah and Egypt as idolatrous and adulterous, the prophet highlights the loss of boundaries and the fuzziness of borders between Israel and Egypt. Egypt then becomes the monster that embodies chaos and the unheimlich that is in the house but does not belong to the house. Worshipping the same idols and whoring with the Egyptians are markers of the loss of identity and the transgression of boundaries between Egypt and Israel. The chaos that Egypt represents is analogous to the ancient Near Eastern monsters of chaos in that it is primordial and in that it is resurgent. Egypt the monster always comes back, haunts and threatens the ordered world of the covenantal relation between Israel and its god YHWH.
|
Dripping Nails, Desire, and Polygynous Partnerships: Navigating Women's Stories in Genesis 29–30 through African Love Songs
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Madipoane Masenya, University of South Africa
Genesis 29-30 presents among others, the story of the origins of what would later be referred to as the “twelve tribes of Israel”. This paper will not focus on the traditional rendering of the story. It will instead use African love songs to engage the narrative of Leah (and women in her life) with a view to foregrounding the experiences and struggles of women in a polygynous partnership.
The lead singer of the main song is an African man with the main respondent being one of his co-wives. On account of her “dripping” nails, she refuses to engage in ordinary household chores. However, she cannot hide her excitement when invited to go to the hut. In the second song, a male lead singer openly chooses a girl (monyana) to a woman(mosadi). In present day South Africa whose head of state has more than one wife, the debate on polygyny is neither strange nor insignificant. This is also pertinent in a context which attempts to resuscitate the African culture among others. The present text seeks to use the preceding African songs to investigate women’s struggles with their desires within polygynous marriage settings. Read through the lenses of the two songs, which light can be thrown on women’s views about female sexuality as these are reflected in the story of Leah and her co-wives?
|
Hebrews and Second Temple Jewish Traditions on the Origins of Angels
Program Unit: Hebrews
Eric F. Mason, Judson University
Angels are mentioned at important points in the Epistle to the Hebrews. The author spends much time arguing for Jesus' superiority to the angels in 1:5-14, reflects the Jewish tradition that angels delivered the Sinai covenant in 2:1-4, and may have traditions of enmity between angels and humans in mind when quoting and building on Ps 8 in 2:5-18. Other explicit references to angels reflect descriptions of theophanies (12:22) and patriarchal hospitality (13:2). Also, his description of Melchizedek in 7:3 and subsequent elaboration in the chapter seems to demand that the author understands him as an angelic figure since both he and Jesus lack a Levitical genealogy and endure forever. An objection to this interpretation states that the language of 7:3 cannot imply that Melchizedek is understood as angelic because angels are created beings, thus not lacking origins as the verse implies. This paper considers traditions about the origins of angels in Second Temple Jewish thought and the significance of such ideas for interpreting Hebrews.
|
The Batman’s Use of Malchus’s Cave Summary
Program Unit: Bible and Popular Culture
Robert Mason, Claremont Graduate University
This paper explores the expanded understanding of asceticism and contemptus mundi as understood by G.G. Harpham and others, in terms of the way that these complexes have been embraced in contemporary pop culture, comparing hagiographic materials from the 4th century, specifically Jerome’s “Malchus the Prisoner” with the Batman saga.
Pop culture is a power medium in Western Culture—one that is constantly evolving and is in constant dialogue with other facets of life, including religion. The pervasiveness of pop culture in part has caused it to intersect in such a major way with religion so that, today, in a sense, pop culture is religion and religion is pop culture.
I focus on the two most recent offerings of the Batman series to show how ascetic ideals play a major role in the development of the superhero persona. These movies are cultural statements that bring together ascetic complexes including contemptus mundi, authority, and resistance, and because this complex of ideas was a part of the early church in the late Roman period, a comparison will be made that will highlight similarities and identify differences. By focusing primarily on the “Life of Malchus” and comparing it with Batman Begins and The Dark Knight, this paper highlights the way asceticism is used in pop culture. Other points of comparison involve the similar role that both media play in terms of entertainment and communication. Both of these media are involved with discourse. Since all discourse has an agenda, the parallels of genre are comparable.
As far as broad conclusions are concerned, this research points toward the fact that religion is not fading away as some recent sociologists and such had declared, but religion is evolving and a certain aspect of it is coalescing with different strands of pop culture.
|
Luke Backs into the Bacchae
Program Unit: Book of Acts
Robert Mason, Claremont Graduate University
Scholars have chronicled the uses that Christian writers have made of the Roman myths in the creation of their own mythic structures. In this paper I compare the way that other groups within the Roman Empire, including the Lukan communities, use the Dionysian myth. The specific points of contact will focus on the miraculous ‘prison-breaks’ and the purpose that these serve in the overall structure in the Lukan narrative.
Pervo, MacDonald and others, by emphasizing literary dependence, stress the novelistic character of Acts and the Lukan literary devices as portrayals of aretai for the gods. Weaver, among others, has contested this approach because past attempts do not address the ‘mythic pattern’ or its significance. I theorize on the comparison enterprise itself, the nature of myth as ideology and the way ideology is a source of power. Both approaches fail to adequately appreciate such intertextuality in terms of oppressed groups writing in resistance. By foregrounding these intertextual studies in a theoretical framework that accounts for power dynamics within ‘resistance-myth’ discourse that is navigated by non-elites, I suggest a way of understanding the significance of these connections.
Luke tells the story of the expansion of the Jesus movement throughout the dominant Roman Empire and seeks to respond to the ‘public transcript’ of acceptable Roman religio. When we turn to the ‘prison-break’ narratives, they show that past preoccupation with literary dependency of the ‘myth of Dionysus’ does not fully account for the way subordinate groups must deal with the power of ‘public transcript.’ It is rarely in direct confrontation, but rather through irony, and humor, re-interpretation of myth and metaphor that subordinate groups like the early Jesus movement sought to alter the Roman ‘public transcript’ and carve out a space that would allow them to transact their ‘good news.’
|
The Failure of Cestius Gallus: A Case Study in Historical Method
Program Unit: Josephus
Steve Mason, York University
Cestius Gallus, Nero's legate in Syria at the outbreak of the Judaean War, became one of history's losers. Josephus' comments on his failure seize Jerusalem while he had the chance (War 2.539–541), in late 66 CE, have largely shaped scholarly inquiry into that episode. Assuming that Jerusalem's reduction was Cestius' aim, scholars have debated the real reasons for his curious withdrawal, soon after arriving. Standard treatments of the incident reflect general tendencies in our study of Roman Judaea. This paper re-examines Cestius' campaign from a different perspective, using it to raise questions about the nature of history and, particularly, about our methods in studying ancient Judaea when Josephus is our main or only source.
|
Reading “Habakkuk” through the Lens of Performance Criticism
Program Unit: Performance Criticism of the Bible and Other Ancient Texts
Jeanette Mathews, Charles Sturt University
When Biblical Performance Theory is applied to the book of Habakkuk, integral performance themes of embodiment, process and re-enactment can be shown to have important expression. Furthermore, analysis of the performance features of script, actor, audience, setting and improvisation allow for a new appreciation of the inherently “dramatic” nature of prophetic books in general and the book of Habakkuk in particular.
What can be gained through reading this book through a performance lens that would not be noticed in a more traditional reading? This paper will analyse the book of Habakkuk via the performance features outlined above, reading the book as a unified script divided into acts and scenes based on a highly iconic translation which offers new insights into the book’s characterisation and message. This paper also shows how the innovative use of conventional forms and themes by the “author” of Habakkuk may serve as a model for later interpreters.
Like modern theatre, a performance reading of Scripture aims for audience transformation. The audience becomes actor, embodying the script and re-enacting it. Reading the text as a “script” helps draw out performative aspects already embedded in it. Variations in translation due to textual difficulties allow for a variety of faithful re-enactments. The open-endedness of Habakkuk with its final verb “to walk” and its colophon inviting re-performance ensures that it will continue to be relevant to new situations of crisis.
|
Reshaping the Prophets: The Influence of the Epistle of Enoch on John’s Critique of Wealth in the Seven Messages and Revelation 18
Program Unit: Function of Apocryphal and Pseudepigraphal Writings in Early Judaism and Early Christianity
Mark D. Mathews, Durham University
The language of Revelation 18 has been examined in detail for its many allusions to the Hebrew Bible, in particular the oracles against the nations of Tyre and Babylon in the prophetic tradition (Is 13, 23; Jer 50-51; Ezek 27). Yet a transformation of the language by the author is evident in his explicit denunciation of riches. Those who have dealt with this text in light of the biblical tradition have identified this transformation, though without an analysis or explanation that accounts for this shift. This raises the question: To what degree might more recent Jewish interpretive traditions related to wealth in the Second Temple period inform John’s portrayal of the faithful Christian community?
The proposed study will examine the author’s sharp denigration of the rich (3:17) and praise of the poor (2:9) in the seven messages in connection with the critique of wealth in Revelation 18 and the call for the faithful to ‘Come out’ of Babylon. In light of a tradition-historical reading the study will compare the author’s language of wealth in the seven messages and the reformulation of prophetic traditions in Rev 18 with similar themes found in the Epistle of Enoch. The essay hopes to demonstrate that the worldview presupposed in the Apocalypse that distinguishes between the righteous and the wicked in terms of economic status has been shaped by the Enochic tradition. This allows us to suggest that John’s concerns over economic involvement among the Christian communities was not an ad hoc response to the Roman Empire, but was influenced by traditions already circulating in the Second Temple period that associated faithfulness with poverty and the rich with the wicked.
|
The Tears of Marcellus; The Weeping of Jesus
Program Unit: Jesus Traditions, Gospels, and Negotiating the Roman Imperial World
Shelly Matthews, Furman University
A highly influential interpretation of the distinctively Lukan pericope in which Jesus weeps over the destruction of Jerusalem holds that the depiction of the weeping Jesus communicates "sympathetic pity" and proves that Luke has no anumis toward Judaism.
This paper juxtaposes Luke's depiction with Livy's depiction of the tears shed by the Roman general Marcellus over the city of Syracuse he has just conquered. Marcellus' tears do indeed indicate pathos, but still, also, signal awareness that a historical era has come to completion, and that the brutal conequest served the necessary aim of extending Roman territory.
This comparison of the tears of the military general with the weeping Lukan Jesus aims to clarify the power plays at work in displays of pity and other beneficient acts in literary accounts of military destruction. It will suggest in conclusion that the Lukan weeping Jesus, like Livy's Marcellus, figures in a complex rhetorical assertion of beneficence toward *and* power over the defeated city of Jerusalem.
|
The Second-Century Construction of the First Christian Martyr: Acts' Stephen and Hegessipus' James
Program Unit: Violence and Representations of Violence in Antiquity
Shelly Matthews, Furman University
This paper argues that Acts' narrative of the Stoning of Stephen and Hegessipus' narrative of the martyrdom of James are variations on the same trope. While Hegessipus is typically characterized as a "Jewish-Christian," and the author of Acts clearly privileges a more Hellenistic, "Pauline" Christianity, both authors employ nearly identical means to construct the first Christian martyr.
|
Respondent to Ernst Wendland's Paper
Program Unit: Bible Translation
James Maxey, Nida Institute for Biblical Scolarship
Response to Ernst Wendland's paper from a perspective of Performance Criticism.
|
Stories Unfinished: Rhetorical Function of the Audience and Open-Ended Characters
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
Kathy Maxwell, Palm Beach Atlantic University
The audience is a vital element for the communication of a story; without audience participation, the narrative fails. Ancient rhetors were quite concerned with engaging the audience—who at the very least should pay attention and in many cases helped the author create the story, making the audience more inclined toward moral formation. Strangely enough, one method used by the rhetoricians involved silence, or gaps, relying on the audience to complete their thoughts. Modern rhetoricians label this phenomenon literary gap theory, but long before the modern theories, ancient rhetors used gaps to encourage their audiences to become “fellow-workers” (Mor. 48:14) with the speaker.
In this paper, I will focus on the gaps left by open-ended gospel characters – characters whose decisions are left untold, whose stories remain unfinished. In particular, I plan to explore the fearful women who silently leave the empty tomb in Mark 16; the ruler who remains without action in Luke 18, and Nicodemus, a rather ambiguous character whose response to Jesus remains unresolved in the gospel of John. Should the gaps left by open-ended or unfinished characters be understood as prompts to the listening audience – invitations to participate in finishing the story? Ends left loose require the creative completion of the characters’ stories in the lives of the audience.
The rhetorical effect had on the audience is not unbounded, because the open-ended characters act within a literary context. An attentive audience would have heard clues in the earlier narrative that guide their response. This paper will also explore narrative information to which the audience has privileged access, details woven into the story that act as instructions for the attentive listener who would live out the unfinished gospel characters’ lives.
|
The Psalmist in the Psalm: A Persona-Critical Analysis of Psalm 101
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Nathan Maxwell, Palm Beach Atlantic University
This paper proposes a literary and theological reading of Psalm 101 that is primarily informed by the theory of the literary persona (though more generally situated within canonical approaches to the Book of Psalms). Following the persona theory, this paper argues that the speaker or speakers in a psalm are properly identified as literary personae, and should not be equated with the psalm’s historical author. This distinction is hermeneutically significant insofar as the psalm’s speaker is therefore oriented to the world of the poem rather than the reader’s knowledge of or access to the historical author.
The paper will offer an interpretation of Psalm 101 as an illustration of this approach. In short, the interpretation of Psalm 101 turns on the aspect of voice. In terms of the original historical setting and function of the psalm, as well as the editorial recasting of the psalm within Book IV of the Psalter, the idea of persona—the idea of a literary voice that is in some sense distinct from historical persons—is a necessary part of making sense of the psalm. In terms of its original setting, the persona forms the identity and attitude of the king at the enthronement ceremony; the focus is on the prevention of calamity. Recast in its final literary setting, the persona is a wholly fictional king of the lost Davidic monarchy who reasserts adherence to the “way of completeness” (v. 2); the focus is on restoration from calamity.
With a brief description and example-application of the persona-critical method in place, the paper will conclude by drawing out the key implications of this method regarding the formative capacity of psalms within normative contexts. Specifically, the paper will suggest that attention to the aspect of voice or literary persona within the Psalter is essential to understanding how the prayer, practice and liturgical use of the Psalter function to shape character.
|
The 10th Century B.C.E.: A View From Tel Rehov
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Amihai Mazar, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
Ten excavation seasons at Tel Rehov in the Jordan Valley since 1997 revealed parts of an unusually large Iron Age city (10 hectares in area) which, unlike most other Iron Age sites in Israel, was a dense urban settlement throughout the Iron I and Iron IIA periods (12-9th centuries BCE). The excavation enabled us to examine aspects of cultural continuity and change throughout this period, based on stratigraphic observations, large ceramic assemblages, numerous artifacts and radiocarbon dates. The lecture will concentrate on the definition and significance of the 10th century levels at Tel Rehov and their implication for broader issues. Topics to be addressed are: the urban sequence and planning, ceramic continuity and change, the meaning of selected objects, the identity of the population, and trade relations. Implications for the current debate relating to the archaeology of the 10th century BCE and related historical issues will be briefly mentioned, in particular the new radiocarbon dates from the massive destructions at the end of Iron Age I, which lead to the dismissal of basic tenets of the 'low chronology' for the Iron Age, particularly the dating of the end of the Iron Age I to the time of the Shoshenq invasion.
|
Sacred Marriage, Sacred Trees, and the Asherah: Tracking a Ritual through Time with Texts, Pictures, and Objects
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Kathleen McCaffrey, University of California-Berkeley
A solution is offered to the long-standing debate as to who impersonated the goddess in the Mesopotamian sacred marriage. This interpretation brings together 1) texts that allude to a marriage between kings and Inanna/Ishtar; 2) a curious tradition of depicting monarchs watering various types of palms; 3) suggestively shaped vases and other equipment, and 4) biblical references to the Asherah. It is proposed that Inanna/Ishtar was not represented by a flesh and blood woman in the performance of the sacred marriage but by various types of palm vegetation. In a mundane sense, the ritual union consisted of a libation performed with specialized vessels and a palm tree. The mechanics of the Sacred Marriage did not need to be spelled out in texts because the ceremony was performed in public and was prominently featured on many royal monuments. As the libation ceremony moved further north, into regions outside the natural habitat of the date palm, synthetic “potted plants” replaced real palm branches and clusters of dates arranged in twin vases. Over time, the single palm tree morphed into the imperial palm grove, the so-called Assyrian Sacred Tree. Placed in this larger context, biblical diatribes against the biblical Asherah would not have been aimed at the goddess herself but at the tree-like object used by Assyrian monarchs to channel the fecundity of the goddess for their own ends.
|
Decoding the S/he Lamashtu: Gender Identity and Transgression in the Ancient Near East
Program Unit: LGBTI/Queer Hermeneutics
Kathleen McCaffrey, University of California-Berkeley
At sites from Syria to Iran, protective amulets and associated incantations have been recovered from the second and first millennia B.C. that feature a ferocious, transgendered demoness. This paper decodes the sex/gender symbolism of the lamashtu iconography, looking in particular at how traditional portrayals of the lamashtu’s gender inversion shift abruptly in the Hellenistic period. The earlier tradition uses exaggerated musculature, nudity, and an aggressive posture to indicate that the female entity is masculine. In the period of extensive Greek contact, the demoness acquires a beard and a penis. Defining and decoding how different sectors of the ancient world understood transgenderance may provide a frame of reference for situating polemics about male and female gender variance in the Old Testament.
|
El Elyon, Begetter of Heaven and Earth
Program Unit: Hebrew Scriptures and Cognate Literature
Daniel O. McClellan, Trinity Western University
While the procreative nuance of the root qnh in contexts related to conception and childbirth is generally recognized, scholarship has been relatively reticent regarding such a reading in Gen 14:19, 22, where Melchizedek blesses Abram by ’el ‘elyôn qoneh šamayim wa’are?. This paper will trace the development of that epithet from its Syro-Palestinian predecessor, ’l qn ’r?, through to its biblical adaptations. Analogous Assyro-Babylonian appellatives, generally marginalized in this discussion, will be incorporated to provide a more comprehensive context within which the semantic range of the phrase may be more fully delineated. A Second Temple Period shift in the understanding of the phrase will be shown to have arisen as a result of theological sensitivities. Ultimately, a procreative reading of qoneh šamayim wa’are? (“Begetter of Heaven and Earth”) will be shown to be original and preferable in the case of Gen 14:19, 22.
|
What is Deity in LXX Deuteronomy?
Program Unit: Unity and Diversity in Early Jewish Monotheisms
Daniel McClellan, Trinity Western University
The book of Deuteronomy provides a number of valuable and unique insights into early Israelite perspectives on the nature of God, his relationship to other divine beings, and the diachronic development of both. For example, Deut 32:8–9, as found in 4QDeutj, attests to a likely early distinction between Yahweh and Elyon and presents the latter as the overseer of the gods of the several nations of the earth. Deut 4:19 represents a later recasting of the relationship of Elyon (now identified with Yahweh) with those deities (now represented astrally). Multiple historical layers and theologies are represented.
The Greek translation of Deuteronomy, however, redefines and harmonizes the nature of God and his relationship to the deities of the surrounding nations. Whether as the result of dynamic equivalence, translator exegesis, or a variant Vorlage, the perspective offered is one of the earliest of developing Hellenistic-Jewish monotheism. The unique nature of Deuteronomy’s references to other deities provides a rich backdrop against which to read the Greek translation. This paper will examine the view of divinity presented in LXX Deuteronomy and evaluate its relationship to that of the Hebrew text as it has been preserved to us.
|
A Comparison of the Peshitta of Ecclesiastes with the Lemma of the Syriac Translation of Theodore of Mopsuestia's Commentary and Catena on Ecclesiastes
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Andrew McClurg, Southern Baptist Theological Seminary
The Syriac translations of the Commentary and Catena of Theodore of Mopsuestia contain lemmas taken from the Peshitta. Two available manuscripts of Syriac translations of Theodore for the book of Qoheleth are as old as the earliest Peshitta manuscripts for Qoheleth. This paper will compare lemmas from the translations of Theodore with the earliest Peshitta manuscripts, and will present evidence of Septuagintal influence in Theodore's lemmas of P. Conversely, in at least one case, evidence will be presented that LXX influence is seen in the known manuscript tradition, and that Theodore's lemmas may contain a more original reading. Any future critical edition of the Peshitta of Ecclesiastes should take account of these manuscripts.
|
Why Cana of Galilee? The Impact of the Archaeology of Khirbet Qana on the Gospel of John’s Use of Cana of Galilee
Program Unit: John, Jesus, and History
C. Thomas McCollough, Centre College
While Cana of Galilee is given a prominent role in the Gospel of John, the village is never mentioned in the Synoptic Gospels. Why did the Gospel of John pick this village to initiate the ministry and cycle of miracles? This paper will present the evidence for identifying Khirbet Qana as Cana of Galilee and will go on to argue that the excavations of the first century village have revealed aspects of the village that bear on the question of its role in the Gospel of John. Our excavations disclose a village that grew substantially after 70 C.E., and that growth included the construction of a large public building that we have identified as a synagogue. This archaeological evidence sheds new light on the narrative strategy of the Gospel writer and in particular suggests that the wedding feast and attendant miracle may be part of the larger Johannine-Jewish rhetoric of the Gospel of John.
|
Jesus the Humble Victor: Jacob of Sarug on Jesus’ Combat with Satan
Program Unit: Syriac Literature and Interpretations of Sacred Texts
Adam McCollum, Hebrew Union College
In two homilies, nos. 82 and 126 in Bedjan’s edition, Jacob of Sarug considers Satan’s temptation of Jesus in the wilderness (Mt 4//Mk 1//Lk 4). In what is certainly one of the most extended meditations on this pericope, Jacob explores the biblical narrative with his customary depth and imagination and presents it squarely as combat between the two of them, combat which Jesus enters in humility and emerges victorious. Jacob is concerned with aligning this event of salvation history with Satan’s temptation of Adam, who was defeated by Satan but becomes a victor over him through Jesus’ own victory. In addition to linking Jesus with Adam, Jacob also connects him, especially in terms of his fast, with Moses and Elijah; Moses also comes into the discussion because he is a source for Jesus in his verbal sparring with Satan. While there were antecedents in the canon of biblical heroes for Jesus’ words and actions in this passage, Jesus is unique, for, paradoxically, he appears more human than them and less miraculous. Since these two homilies are based on a biblical text centered around a conversation, Jacob is even freer than usual to expand or invent the conversation, and in this way he fills out his understanding of the passage. This paper considers Jacob’s place in patristic exegesis (especially that of Cyril of Alexandria and Theodore of Mopsuestia) on this passage and highlights his unique contribution to its interpretation and preaching. Particular attention is paid to his use of language and imagery, chiefly with respect to the vocabulary of aggression, descriptions of Satan, and Jesus’ humility.
|
When Illness Calls: Insights from Julian of Norwich’s Call to Frailty
Program Unit: Academy of Homiletics
Donyelle McCray, Duke Divinity School
*
|
An Intratextual Examination of Ambiguities: Reading Isaiah’s Intertexts from Beginning and End
Program Unit: Intertextuality in the New Testament
Karl McDaniel, McGill University
Ambiguity in intertextuality is often stressed. Often unaddressed is the way in which the meaning of various intretexts obtained during a primary reading can change in light of a complete or subsequent re-reading. Matthew makes continued reference to the book of Isaiah throughout the Gospel. It has often been argued that these passages are pro-Gentile or anti-Gentile. This paper will argue that they are both, depending upon the way in which they are read within the overall context of the Gospel. To understand the nature of the ambiguities involved, one must discuss the nature of beginnings (primacy effect) and endings (recency effect) and their influence on literary intertexts. Literary theory has evidenced that beginnings and endings change one’s perception of the ways in which literature is understood. In this type of examination, one discovers hidden and implied meanings that may revise initial understanding to make the entire text a coherent macrostructure, making the text “postdictable”. In Matthew, each instance in which Isaiah is explicitly quoted with reference to Jesus’ salvation or Gentiles, an inception-oriented reading tends toward a “salvation of Israel” view with an implied negative evaluation of Gentiles. However, a retrospective reading of the same texts inverts this perspective, opening the entire Gospel to further reconsideration in terms of inclusion and positive evaluation of Gentiles. The relevant Isaiah formula quotations are found in Mt 1:23-24, 4:14-16; 8:17; 12:18-21. Discussion will encompass the use of ambiguous language, primary textual context and its relevance to the intertextual quotations, and finally, the primacy and recency effects on interpretation. In each instance in which Isaiah is quoted with ambiguity, there is a double meaning depending upon where one focuses his/her interpretive paradigm. This relationship between intertextuality and intratextuality has not been noted previously in Matthean studies.
|
Suspicion Regarding Peter’s Salvation: Suspense, Emotive Affect, and the Structure of Matthew’s Gospel
Program Unit: Psychology and Biblical Studies
Karl McDaniel, McGill University
The development of suspense in the Gospel of Matthew has never been examined. Using a structural-affect model, Brewer has studied the impact of narratives on human emotion, with particular emphasis on suspense. His definition of suspense has been verified by cognitive appraisal theory which views suspense as caused by an oscillation of the prospect-based emotions, viewing suspense as involving a hope emotion and a fear emotion coupled with the cognitive state of uncertainty. In relation to biblical literature, this paradigm was originally theorized by Meir Sternberg. Fear and hope, and their relation to suspense, have been examined in appraisal models and verified in studies of advertising and television news. This paper will apply suspense theory to Matthew as a whole, with specific attention granted to Peter. Jesus comes to save his people as revealed at the beginning of the Gospel (Mt 1:21). This initiating event allows for development of significant consequences for the narrative’s characters, including Peter. Throughout the Gospel, Jesus’ didactic proclamations and parables emphasize understanding of and dedication to himself. These criteria, when used to evaluate Peter’s words and actions, emphasize his failure and set up a tension with Jesus’ salvific mission. Throughout, readers hope for Peter’s salvation, and at times he is exemplary, but readers also continually encounter his shortfalls and return to a state of fear. The back and forth play of these emotional responses builds suspense as the narrative draws to its conclusion. Finally, it will be shown that the promised presence of Jesus at the Gospel’s conclusion leaves readers in a perpetual state of suspense regarding Peter’s outcome. This tension induces fear regarding their own failure along with hope for their own success as disciples resulting in an existential suspense.
|
Reading Mark 5 with Persons with Mental Illness
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Jenny McDevitt, Union Presbyterian Seminary
Mark 5:1-20, the story of the Gerasene demoniac, is often interpreted as demonstrative of Jesus’ substantial power and authority over all areas of life -- including any and all things that disfigure human life. Such an interpretation also addresses political overtones in the text, finding much reference to the Roman Empire and interpreting the story in light of those details. However, those interpretations draw largely upon the historical critical method; many additional viewpoints emerge from alternative approaches, including reader response criticism. Working explicitly within the framework of contextual biblical interpretation, this paper combines rhetorical analysis with reader response criticism. The particular lens for this study is that of severe mental illness (more specifically, reading in solidarity with individuals with severe mental illness -- I draw upon personal experience as the child of two mentally ill parents).
Working verse by verse (and at times, word by word), the text of this pericope is placed in dialogue with published accounts of individual experiences with severe mental illness. This conversation, and the insights drawn from analysis of the Greek paired with my own close encounters with mental illness, constitutes the bulk of the paper. It includes places in which the text’s details may prove hopeful for those living with mental illness, and places in which the text’s details may prove harmful -- in both cases, however, the paper argues that the language used in contemporary expressions of mental illness powerfully mirrors that of the Gerasene demoniac.
The paper also identifies, albeit briefly, some of the inherent difficulties of healing stories when viewed from the perspective of illness or disability (and thus, the importance of interpretations from this point of view).
The full text of this paper is available upon request.
|
Status Quo and Lukan Complicity: Restoring the "Dear Slave" of Luke 7:2–10
Program Unit: Jesus Traditions, Gospels, and Negotiating the Roman Imperial World
Joseph McDonald, Brite Divinity School
I argue here that the story of the healing of the centurion’s slave in Luke 7:2-10 is an act of empire-negotiation that reinscribes the blueprint of power dynamics of imperial Rome. First, I assemble data to show that Luke’s centurion is not a benign figure, but rather a highly valued retainer of the empire, and thus a powerful agent of an exploitative governing class with every interest in the maintenance of an unjust status quo. I also contend that his patronage of the synagogue is not a disinterested act, but a species of euergetism by which he gains honor and co-opts the local elite establishment, thus partially incorporating its members into the imperial hierarchy that he represents. Next, I demonstrate that despite these characteristics and actions—indeed, because of them—the centurion is unreservedly approved by the narrator, by secondary characters, and by the character Jesus. In a complementary argument, I further maintain that the centurion’s address of Jesus as “Lord” here does not, as some have claimed, “subvert” the nature of the centurion’s relationship to the imperial order in any meaningful way. Finally, I assert that in the outcome of the story the character of Jesus moves beyond complicity to outright imperial collaboration. In addition to voicing his abstract endorsement of the centurion, Luke’s Jesus here enables the restoration of an exploitative, possibly pederastic relationship—one that serves as a kind of personal microcosm of the abusive imperial proprietary model—by rejuvenating the centurion’s “dear slave” and returning him to his servitude.
|
Job Talks Back: Hearing Job’s Speech under Pressure with James C. Scott
Program Unit: Social Sciences and the Interpretation of the Hebrew Scriptures
Joseph McDonald, Brite Divinity School
I here address some of the enduring problems in the interpretation of the book of Job by applying the work of cultural anthropologist James C. Scott to the interactions of the Joban characters. Scott’s theories provide useful perspective for analysis of the communicative acts of the characters in Job, especially as these acts are influenced by disparate levels of power. Specifically, I attempt to explain the way Job speaks in his confrontation with Yhwh at the end of the book, where his tone differs so markedly from that of his speeches in the verse dialogue.
After detailing those of Scott’s theories that are useful to an interpretation of Job—concepts of “hidden transcript,” “public transcript,” and the “voice under domination”—I apply these ideas to relevant characters in Job, considering Job’s subordinate “hidden transcript,” Yhwh’s elite “hidden transcript,” and the clash between these and the “public transcript” that occurs in the theophany in chapters 38–42. The direct interaction of Yhwh and Job in this last scene offers a valuable opportunity to measure what they have said “offstage” against what they say in a public venue.
I argue that Job’s highly ambiguous replies to Yhwh’s speeches here constitute a disguised form of his subordinate hidden transcript that partially emerges on the public stage. Job’s production of this disguised transcript enables him to maintain his dignity, as he thus avoids retracting his candid feelings as expressed in his earlier arguments, while the fact of its disguise helps to convince Yhwh of Job’s deference and so clear the way for his restoration of Job’s fortunes.
|
Longing to Be at Home in the Universe: Rethinking the Religious and Ethical Aspects of the 'Elements of the Cosmos' in Paul's Epistle to the Galatians
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Kevin McGinnis, Claremont Graduate University
Interpretations of ‘the elements of the cosmos’ in Paul’s epistle to the Galatians have represented a variety of pejorative opinions of what has typically been described as an empty or even evil ‘pagan’ religious tradition. These ostensibly second-order interpretations have often been modern replications of ancient stereotypical representations of Hellenistic thought and practice – the Galatian recipients being charged of willfully worshipping demons, evil spirits, or inconsequential physical elements. Two discussions of the elements stand out as taking a more promising approach to understanding why the Galatians still worshipped, or were in some way devoted to, the elements: Eduard Schweizer, who considers the importance of the four elements of fire, earth, air, and water in terms of their effect on the weight of the soul as it strives to return to heaven, and Gail Armstrong, who is the first to recognize the ethical component that is implicit in Paul’s discussion of the elements. In this paper, I argue that the elements of the cosmos are still best translated as the four physical elements, but that this translation can be explained in terms that respect the integrity and dignity of Hellenistic thought and religious practice and that also connect the elements to ethics, time, space, and the gods. I outline the place of the elements in Greek cosmological thought and religious practice to show how the Greeks understood the interconnection between the heavens, the earth, and humanity through the elements and their effects on people and places. Such an understanding of the cosmos was common in antiquity and is still held to be true in many parts of the world. This interpretation thus clarifies the meaning of ta stoichea tou kosmou in Galatians and helps us to understand why the Galatians may have valued the place of the elements in their lives.
|
Sanctifying Interpretation: The Symbolic Labor of Origen’s Hermeneutical Practices and His Theories of Scripture and Salvation
Program Unit: Religious Competition in Late Antiquity
Kevin McGinnis, Claremont Graduate University
It is well known that Origen promoted an understanding of scripture as a significant locus of divine-human interaction with the teachings of the texts communicating the teachings of God through the power of the Holy Spirit. Daniel Shin has noted that Origen talks about the reading and interpretation of scripture as a sort of sacrament in so far as through engaging with the text one also engages with the Logos. Karen Torjesen has also shown how Origen’s theories of scripture and of interpretation are reflective of his notions of soteriology and of a tripartite anthropology in which people are ranked based on the progress of their souls toward salvation. In this paper, I interpret Origen’s assertions about the nature of scripture and interpretation through the lens of Pierre Bourdieu’s political economy of symbolic power in order to show how his claims may have functioned to structure the Christian community around certain textual practices with progress toward salvation (i.e., an increase of the community’s specific form of religious capital) dependent on the types of textual study at which Origen was so adept. Implicit (and sometimes explicit) in Origen’s conception of the church was a hierarchy in which Origen himself was at the most valued and honored position vis-à-vis his students, the lay members of his church, and even the bishops. I will show how these intellectual (and narratological) claims about the nature of scripture, salvation, and the church both reinforced and were reinforced by the everyday practices of study and interpretation that were central to Origen’s position in the church.
|
Patristic Rhetorical Analyses of Romans 3:1–8/9
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Tom McGlothlin, Duke University
What would a dramatic reading of Romans 1-4 sound like? Who would speak which lines, and with what tone? Recent “revisionist” readings of Romans have highlighted the significance of these questions. If one reassigns the voices or reinterprets the tone, a radically different theology can emerge. This presentation will look at several patristic commentators on Romans to see how they went about answering these questions, focusing on a passage for which these questions are particularly acute, Romans 3:1-8/9. As readers intimately familiar with ancient Greek and the beneficiaries of an education that placed a heavy emphasis on rhetoric, one would expect that they would note rhetorical markers in the text and interpret it accordingly. However, comparative explications of Origen’s, Chrysostom’s, and Pelagius’s interpretations of this passage will show that they assign voices and tone in the passage in radically different ways based on their expectations of what the passage should say. Origen reads it as reassurances for believing Jews reeling from 2:17-29; Chrysostom as a clever ploy to set up Jewish privilege only to undercut it; and Pelagius as an argument between Paul and a combative Jew trying to evade the argument of 2:17-3:1. These interpreters do appeal to rhetorical arguments, but they do so to overcome elements of the passage that are problematic for their expectations. This diversity suggests that, although the text clearly demands rhetorical analysis, it lacked clear rhetorical markers even for ancient readers. The value of these patristic readings for modern interpreters is the variety of plausible readings they suggest, not the narrowing of interpretative options.
|
A Profile of Eucharistic Origins (I): Symposia, Sustenance, and Sacrifice
Program Unit: Meals in the Greco-Roman World
Andrew McGowan, Trinity College, University of Melbourne/Melbourne College of Divinity
This paper will outline a set of theses that will lay out a new profile of eucharistic origins.
|
Intertextuality without an Intertext? Musings on Matthew and Method
Program Unit: Intertextuality in the New Testament
James F. McGrath, Butler University
There has been much discussion about the degree of importance of the original context of a Scripture which is quoted or alluded to in the New Testament. Matthew 2:23 provides an interesting test case, since what Scripture(s), if any, the author may have had in mind remains uncertain. This paper will consider similarities between this instance and other examples in the New Testament where the assertion that something happened “according to the Scriptures” appears to have been more important than clarifying which Scriptures were in view. It will also explore the possibility that the term Nazoraeans may have denoted an already-existing Jewish religious group with which Jesus and his followers were being associated (cf. Acts 24:5). Concluding considerations will be offered focused on methodology and intertextuality, noting that our inability to identify what Scripture was being referred to suggests that the specific text, much less its original context, was not always important in New Testament citations and allusions.
|
The Blogging Revolution: New Technologies and Their Impact on How We Do Scholarship
Program Unit: Blogger and Online Publication
James McGrath, Butler University
Not that long ago, in an academic galaxy not that far away, scholars steeped in traditional models, paradigms and technologies marveled that young academics would "fritter and waste the hours in an offhand way" by engaging in that rather frivolous activity referred to as "biblioblogging." But as blogging (and other new technologies and media) become increasingly mainstream, not only do the activities of blogging and online publication seem less frivolous, nor do they merely begin to appear to be highly appropriate topics for a session at the SBL annual meeting, but these technologies show themselves to have the potential to revolutionize the ways we do scholarship, every bit as much as the transportation and printing technologies that have made possible the types of interaction in person and in print that scholars in our time have come to take for granted. Two key examples will be discussed: the possibility of "blog conferences" to supplement if not replace conferences such as the one at which this paper is being read; and the possibility for harnessing interactive media to create textbooks which not only address readers but do so in response to readers' answers to questions the textbook has asked them. The key issue is no longer whether new media will impact the academy, but how to utilize them to their full potential, and not merely as yet another means of transmitting and viewing material which is otherwise presented in a traditional format.
|
Memory, Jesus, and Early Christian Tradition
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Rob McIver, Avondale College
This paper will consider the implications of the science of memory for biblical studies.
|
Oral Performance, Memory Capacity, and the Aphorisms of Jesus
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Robert K McIver, Avondale College
The qualities of human memory shape oral performance. This paper explores how memory capacity shaped the oral preservation and performance of the aphorisms of Jesus in the period before they were gathered into the Synoptic Gospels. While memory skills may develop differently in scribal cultures such was found in rural first-century Palestine than they develop in a modern chirographic culture, biological constraints require that there can have been little difference in the actual structures of the human brain used for short term memory of verbal information. The human brain is composed of many specialist functions, including areas devoted to short-term and long-term verbal memory. The exact memory of recent sounds held in the small capacity verbal loop is used to generate both verbatim and gist short term memories simultaneously. The small capacity of short-term memory means that without written or aural cues, only very short sequences of verbatim words are remembered. Furthermore, long term verbal memory tends to be formed as gist memory, and verbatim memory is either remembered entirely or not at all. Thus verbatim memories must be frequently rehearsed to before they become part of long-term memory. Based as they are on brain structures that are significantly alike in all humans, these observations will be true of humans in oral, scribal and chirographic cultures, and may provide significant clues as to the methods used by the earliest Christians to preserve and shape the aphoristic like materials found within the Jesus traditions preserved in the Synoptic Gospels.
|
Performing the Psalms of Lament: Placebo or Healing?
Program Unit: Psychology and Biblical Studies
Heather McKay, Edge Hill University
The effectiveness of placebos has remained a medical curiosity for many years and has often been set aside or ignored because there was no place to understand the effect within the dominant Cartesian medical understanding that was, and is, prevalent in Western cultures. There, ‘disease’ was a damage to, or malfunction of, the human body with—usually—an identifiable cause such that the damage could be repaired or the cause removed or inhibited and the ‘patient’ be ‘cured.’ (Pilch, 2008)
Recently, however, an understanding of the placebo as either activating the individual’s power of self-healing or as a way of decreasing whatever stress, or anxiety was currently inhibiting that power, has become more commonly accepted.
In other cultures, ‘disease’ has not been so understood; there persons suffered ‘illness’ which affected not only the individual, but also their family and social standing. It mattered to those communities that such ‘sick’ persons could be ‘healed’. (Pilch, 2008)
In all forms of healing intervention, however, whether by surgery, drugs, touch, application of lotions, incantations or psychodramas (Lewis, 1971), a definite input from ritual may be observed. This paper will explore whether the performance itself of a psalm of lament may produce such benefits by means of effects within the performer’s own mind and consciousness.
|
That’s Our Story and We’re Sticking to It’: Preaching John Wesley’s ‘Holy Living’ for Postmodern People
Program Unit: Academy of Homiletics
Alyce M. McKenzie, Perkins School of Theology/SMU
*
|
The Book of Jonah as a Historical Romance
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Cameron McKenzie, Providence College
Mikhail Bakhtin approached the novel, ancient and modern, in terms of its special sense of space (understood as social) and time (understood as historical). The spatial and temporal indicators of a given narrative fuse into one carefully thought out concrete whole which becomes a key indicator of genre. Bakhtin calls these genre marking entities “chronotopes”. Using Mikhail Bakhtin’s theory of the chronotope, this paper will argue that the book of Jonah, the lone, largely narrative chapter in the Book of the Twelve, should be understood as a kind of historical romance, where the action is spread across a global stage involving multiple countries and settings fused together with several “chance” happenings. Additionally, as Jonah progresses through the various episodes of the story he does not experience any change, neither biographical nor ideological. The spatial contexts of Joppa, Tarshish, the ship, the sea, and Nineveh tend to be mere background against which the character of Jonah is presented as following a predetermined character path that the context may obstruct but not essentially shape. This “historical romance chronotope” has the effect of giving substance and flesh to a whole realm of cultural assumptions and values underlying the book of Jonah.
|
Agrarian Aphorisms in the Fourth Gospel
Program Unit: John, Jesus, and History
Linda McKinnish Bridges, Wake Forest University
Logan Pearsall Smith, author of A Treasury of English Aphorisms, describes the literary genre of aphorism in this poetic manner: “We are startled by their novelty; we catch our breath and gaze for a moment blankly at them. Then, as we ponder their meaning and recall their past, their truth, as well as their lucid perfection, delights us. Like shooting stars, they seem to leave a track of gold behind them; like flashes of lightning they reveal the familiar world in a sudden, strange illumination; the accompanying din alarms us, till, from far ranges of experiences, echoes return in long reverberations to confirm them. This paper seeks to describe these “flashes of light” in the Johannine landscape, by providing an inventory of Jesus’ aphorisms in John, their peculiar identity and function. Special focus on the agrarian and nature-associated aphorisms of John 4:32-38, 12:23-28; 16:20-21 will be provided, highlighting the residual quality of orality inherent in the sayings as well as the transmissional process of the aphorism located within the synoptic traditions.
|
KJV Theology/Exegesis through the Lens of James
Program Unit:
Scot McKnight, North Park University
*
|
Eusebius on the Capture of Jerusalem and the Flight to Pella Story
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
James McLaren, Australian Catholic University
The historicity of the story that Christians fled from Jerusalem to Pella before the captial was captured by the Romans contiunes to be debated. Much of the discussion focuses on issues associated with the situation in Jerusalem in the late 60s CE and the origin of the story. As the earliest extant source Eusebius tends to be relegated to the role of a person simply transmitting an existing tradition. This paper foscues on Eusebius, exploring the function of the story in his narrative. It will be argued that the story plays a crucial role in his depiction of how God punished the Jews: it explains the timing of God's actions. It will be proposed that the story has far more to say about Eusebius' contribution to the emerging Christian anti-Jewish theological tradition than it does about what actually happened during the war of 66-70 CE.
|
Gideon the Judge in the Pitts Theology Library Digital Image Archive
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Art
Phillip McMillion, Harding University Graduate School of Religion
This paper will examine images of the Judge Gideon and the stories in Judges 6-8 as examples of the images available in the Digital Images Archive at Pitts Theology Library, Emory University. This collection represents a sampling of woodcuts and engravings from the 15th to 19th centuries and contains 63 images related to Gideon. The images typically reflect the common interpretation of scripture of that time period, but are significant for the details they highlight from the texts of the Book of Judges. Recent approaches such as reception history suggest that the interpretation of Biblical materials by later audiences and the influence of those materials are both interesting and significant. These artistic representations may, in fact, suggest readings that expand the possibilities within a given text. The primary stories illustrated are the call of Gideon, Gideon’s fleece, the selection of the soldiers, and the defeat of Midian. The stories that are not illustrated are also interesting, and those include, the execution of the Midianite leaders, the offer of Kingship, and Gideon’s Ephod that becomes a snare to the people. This collection of digital images is an important resource that deserves wider recognition for the rich illustrative material available for scholars and teachers of scripture.
|
Prophets Who Set Precedents in Luke
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
Jocelyn McWhirter, Albion College
It is widely recognized that the author of Luke portrays Jesus as a prophet. He accomplishes this in part by using various biblical prophets as models for Jesus. Scholars have paid particular attention to the extensive parallels with stories about Elijah and Moses. Luke’s Jesus, like Elijah, is filled with the Holy Spirit and ascends into heaven. Then, like Elisha, Peter and Paul receive the spirit of their mentor. Luke’s Jesus, like Moses, initiates two successive offers of salvation to Israel – one in his own ministry and one in the ministry of the apostles – that are both rejected. These parallels establish Elijah and Moses as important precedents for Jesus. They allow Luke to assure his readers that Peter and Paul are continuing Jesus’ prophetic ministry, and that Israel’s rejection of all three is consistent with the treatment given to Moses.
Scholars have also commented more briefly on parallels between episodes in Luke and other passages about prophets. The birth and infancy narratives of John and Jesus (Luke 1-2) resemble those of Samuel (1 Sam 1-3). Jesus’ pronouncements about sinners in Luke 15:4 and 19:10 seem to draw on a similar pronouncement by Ezekiel (34:16). His prophecies concerning the temple (Luke 19:41-44; 21:20-24; 23:29-30) echo phrases in Isa 29:3; Jer 16:15; 21:7; 26:10; Ezek 32:9; Hos 9:7; 10:4; and Zech 12:3; 14:2.
My paper will demonstrate how not only Elijah and Moses, but also Samuel, Isaiah, Jeremiah, Ezekiel, Hosea, and Zechariah – whose ministries include the marginalized and who announce the doom of faithless cities – set important precedents for Luke’s Jesus. By likening Jesus to appropriate prophets, Luke legitimates the Christian message of a crucified Messiah who offends the righteous and ministers to the impure. He also assures his audience that even the unexpected destruction of Jerusalem is part of God’s plan.
|
An Analysis of the Relationship of the Peshitta and the Septuagint of Ecclesiastes
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
John D. Meade, Southern Seminary
Forty years ago, the Syriac Peshitta (S) was called a “daughter version” of the Septuagint (G). Agreement between S and G was sometimes understood in terms of a dependent relationship on the part of S. Yet, scholars, such as Michael Weitzman, have established criteria to show that agreement may not always indicate dependence. Other factors (polygenesis, common exegetical tradition, and common Vorlage) can account for agreement besides direct dependence. When one is able to dismiss these factors as reasons for agreement between S and G, only then is one able to posit that S is dependent on G. Analysis of Ecclesiastes indicates that S is dependent upon G in this book in a non-systematic and sporadic fashion. Once one has discerned these places of dependence, S becomes an early witness to the text history of G.
|
Mourning Ezekiel's Wife: Funeral Sermons on Ezekiel 24
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Andrew Mein, Westcott House, Cambridge
In Ezekiel 24.15-27, the death of Ezekiel's wife is symbolic of the coming destruction of Jerusalem, and Yhwh commands Ezekiel not to perform the usual mourning rites. The prophet's response to his wife's death is symbolic of the people's appropriate response to the impending national calamity. For most modern commentators, Ezekiel’s message is ‘obviously inappropriate in personal situations of grief and loss’ (Odell 2005), but in fact it was quite regularly used in the past as a text for funeral sermons. Such sermons ranged well beyond the compass one might expect from this text: from national grief at the death of a princess, to catalogues of feminine virtue, to sober reflection on a public minister’s response to personal tragedy. Arising from work for the Blackwell Commentary on Ezekiel, my paper will explore some of the uses to which early modern sermon writers put this text, and reflect on the relationship between the commentary tradition and other more popular forms of reading/exposition.
|
A Tale of Two Eunuchs: Isaiah 56:1–8 and Acts 8:26–40
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
Sarah J. Melcher, Xavier University
*
|
Angels and Demons: The Development of Jewish Angelology in the Post-exilic Period
Program Unit: Israelite Religion in Its Ancient Context
David P. Melvin, Baylor University
(Ph.D. Student, Baylor University; faculty advisor Dr. Joel S. Burnett)
This paper examines the portrayal of angelic beings in the Hebrew Bible, focusing especially on the origins of Israelite angelology against its ancient Near Eastern background, the distribution and various functions of angelic beings throughout the various texts and layers of texts in the Hebrew Bible, and the rapid developments in Jewish angelology which occur beginning in the early Persian era. A systematic comparison of ANE textual and iconographic sources, biblical literature, and early post-biblical literature reveals that 1) the roots of biblical angelology are found in the mythological repertoire of ANE religions, as represented in both texts and iconography, that 2) the Hebrew Bible evidences a generally muted and simplified angelology in comparison with the ANE evidence, and that 3) the development of apocalypticism in the post-exilic period saw the re-emergence of ANE mythological motifs regarding angelic beings which are absent or suppressed in the Hebrew Bible. A number of new developments appear in apocalyptic literature pertaining to angelic beings, most notably increased autonomy and volition, personal names, intercession, interpretation, and dualism. A number of these changes first appear sporadically in post-exilic biblical texts (e.g., Zech 1–8; Ezekiel; Job), but become much more common and prominent in post-biblical apocalyptic literature. With regard to many of these same motifs post-exilic literature displays greater continuity with the ANE material than do pre-exilic texts. This is especially evident with regard to demonology: in both apocalyptic literature and ANE sources, demons are the cause of much, if not most of the evil and suffering in the world. Thus, with regard to its angelology apocalyptic literature may be seen as in large measure a return to an earlier mythological worldview, with its battling gods and demons and a vast heavenly realm filled with thousands upon thousands.
|
What Queer Hermeneutics Can Do for Us in Spain: The Case of 1 Cor 6:1–9 and Rom 1:26–27
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Luis Menendez, Vanderbilt University
*
|
Striking the Shepherd: Early Christian Versions and Interpretations of Zechariah 13:7
Program Unit: Greek Bible
Maarten J. J. Menken, Tilburg University
According to Mark, Jesus predicts after the last supper that all his disciples will soon defect, and he substantiates his prediction with words derived from Zech 13:7: “I will strike the shepherd, and the sheep will be scattered” (Mark 14:27). We find the same quotation in the same narrative context but in a slightly different form in Matthew (26:31), and we find an allusion to Zech. 13:7, again in a comparable narrative context, in John 16:32. Zechariah’s words return in a later phase of early Christian literature, in the Epistle of Barnabas 5:12, but now they have been recast considerably: “When they strike their own shepherd, then the sheep of the flock will perish.” A few decades later, Justin quotes Zech 13:7 in an almost correct Greek translation of the Hebrew text (Dialogue with Trypho 53:6).
In this paper, I will try to trace the development of the textual form and the interpretation of Zech 13:7 in the early Christian texts just mentioned. I shall start with some observations on the Hebrew text and on some of the ancient versions, notably the LXX, which offers a peculiar rendering. Next, I shall discuss the early Christian versions and interpretations, and try to detect their relations. Obscure apocalyptic texts often generate multiple meanings. Zech 13:7 proves to be no exception.
|
The Letter of Mara bar Serapion and Early Christian Studies
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
Annette Merz, University of Utrecht
The Letter of Mara bar Serapion to his son, probably written from Roman custody shortly after the conquest of Commagene in 72/73 CE is a document whose potential to make contributions to New Testament studies has been
highly underestimated in scholarship. The letter does provide what seems to be the first non Christian attestation of Jesus, called the wise king of the Jews who is not dead because of the laws he left behind and who is compared to Socrates and Pythagoras in a chain of paradigms which could be reflecting a (pre-Matthean) Christianising interpretation of divine punishment visited on the Jews. The letter is one of the few extant testimonies dealing with Roman Imperialism from a non-Roman point of view which provides interesting points of comparison with Christian utterances in the Synoptic tradition or by Paul and Ignatius. Mara's letter contains a unique fusion of Greek (in particular Stoic) philosophy and traditional Near Eastern wisdom in Syriac language which parallels early Christian attempts of merging Jewish and Hellenistic traditions in many ways.
|
Carl Schneider and the Apocalypse of John: A Chapter of Exegesis under the Shadow of National Socialism
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
Annette Merz, University of Utrecht
The exegetical works on John’s Apocalypse by Carl Schneider (1900-1977), who had been assistant professor for New Testament at Wittenberg College in Springfield, Ohio (1928) and professor in Riga and Königsberg (1929-1945), reveal the growing influence of Nazi-ideology on German New Testament scholarship. Schneider wrote his Habilitationsschrift on “Die Erlebnisechtheit der Apokalypse des Johannes” (Leipzig 1930), a work inspired by the Gestalt-psychological theory of Felix Krueger which is still free of any anti-Semitism and recognizes the Jewish-apocalyptic roots of the Apocalypse of John. This changed when Nazism became powerful. Being a member of the NSDAP since 1933 and of the “Entjudungsinstitut” in Eisenach Schneider defined Christianity as an “anti-Semitic movement” from the very outset and the New Testament as a “genuinely Hellenistic book”. In 1936 he drew the conclusions from this convictions for the interpretation of Christian apokalyptic literature in an essay titled “Antike Apokalyptik als Geschichtsphilosophie”. His platonic exegesis which characterizes of the Apocalypse of John as “completely un-Jewish” is still to be found in works which were published after World War II.
|
The Grammar of Sacrifice: A Generativist Description of the Ancient Israelite Sacrificial System
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Naphtali S. Meshel, Hebrew University of Jerusalem / Princeton University
The notion that rituals and natural languages both follow sets of implicit rigorous rules led scholars in the last century, harking back to pre-modern grammarians, to speak of a “grammar”, or “syntax”, of ritual, particularly sacrificial ritual. Despite insightful examples of ritual complexes that follow hierarchical rules akin to syntactic structures in natural languages, on the one hand, and ambitious attempts to imagine a Universal Grammar of sacrificial ritual on the other hand, no single, complete “grammar” of any ritual system has yet been composed.
This paper presents one such “grammar”—one that centers on the (idealized) Israelite sacrificial system formalized in the Priestly laws in the Pentateuch. It is argued that despite far-reaching diachronic developments, the sacrificial system in biblical and post-biblical texts (Hellenistic, Qumranic, rabbinic), historical as well as utopian, retains a highly unchangeable “grammar”—a rich set of unstated, simple, rigorous underlying generative rules. One example of the generativity of the system is offered from the sequences of blood-application acts in the sanctuary according to P and according to other biblical and post-biblical texts.
Thus, it is argued that the Israelite sacrificial system is describable in terms of a finite set of concise rules which are internalized in part unconsciously, and serve as the basis for the development of a potentially infinite number of sacrificial sequences. However, this finite set of rules is dissimilar form the rules that constitute the grammars of natural languages. Therefore, it appears that ritual systems may have grammars, but that these are very different from the grammars of natural languages.
|
Effect of Repeated Testing on the Development of Biblical Hebrew Language Proficiency
Program Unit: Applied Linguistics for Biblical Languages
Jari Metsämuuronen, Finnish National Board of Education
Karpicke & Roediger (2008) showed that delayed recall is optimized, not with repeated studying sessions, but with repeated testing sessions. The result was very soon re-interpreted by Lasry, Levy and Tremblay (2008), who hypothesized that repeated testing may lead to multiple traces in one?s memory, which facilitates recall.
The aims of the present study are,
(1) to test whether the results of the Karpicke & Roediger study of repeating similar tests are applicable in real life with dissimilar, though equated, tests of a gradually increasing level of difficulty in Biblical Hebrew language with no connection to the use of the spoken language in everyday life.
(2) to reveal the profiles of the students? proficiency levels of during the study process. Samples & Methods: Randomized, matched-pairs (N = 7 + 7) of students with the same teacher, the same lessons and the same routines participated in the experiment. The intervention for the experimental group consisted of a set of short, ten-minute tests during each three-hour study session held twice weekly. IRT modeling with linking items served to equate the test scores. ANOVA was used to analyze the gain score between the pre-test and post-test.
The experimental group improved statistically significantly more than did the control group. The learning curve was a nonlinear, wide U or J shape after the first elementary period of learning the letters and basic vocabulary.
The repeated testing sessions helped the students raise their language proficiency level more than without the repeated testing sessions. (Although the groups were small, the effect was high, depending on the indicator). One possibility to further elaborate on the results is to collect more data on novice Hebrew speakers from different countries. This could lead to international standards of language testing for Biblical Languages.
|
Why Jesus Used Parables? Jesus’ Teachings from the Cognitive and Constructive Psychology Viewpoint
Program Unit: Psychology and Biblical Studies
Jari Metsmämuuronen, The Finnish National Board of Education
Six of Jesus’ long teaching sessions as reported in the Gospel according to Matthew were read on the basis of cognitive and constructive psychology and Aristotelian rhetoric. The following question was posed: “What kind of mnemonic tools Jesus used in his talks to enhance retention?” The texts show, first, that Jesus used a wide variety of mnemonic tools. Second, using theories from cognitive and constructive psychology and classical rhetoric, it is evident that these mnemonic tools were effective. Third, there seem to be some techniques which are common to all six of these talks; namely, the expression of extreme values, the expression of counterparts, Argument, the expression of opposites and the weighing of important matter. Fourth, Jesus seems to use specific techniques in certain speeches; there are no parables in the speeches such as the “Commissioning” or the “Sermon on the Mount.” Fifth, examples of shorter sequences of Jesus’ teachings show that in one sentence there can be over ten different mnemonic triggers to help the audience store the message in their memory.
|
Challenging the Dichotomy between Halakah and Community Legislation
Program Unit: Qumran
Sarianna Metso, University of Toronto
It has long been recognized that the Damascus Document contains material quite similar to the communal and organizational legislation of the Community Rule, yet the bulk of the legal material in the Damascus Document bears the hallmarks of halakah. The material in the Community Rule, on the other hand, is often classified under rubrics such as "constitutional," "communal" or "organizational" rules. The simple picture, however, is blurred by a number of factors, such as the information included in the additional variant copies of these two documents and of related legal texts from Cave 4. While one may not be ready to abandon totally the terms "halakah" and "community legislation" as handy labels, the dichotomy represented by these terms needs qualification. At the very least, the two major documents should be viewed in a larger framework of Essene legal creativity and on the continuum of broader legal developments of Second Temple Judaism.
|
P. Macquarie inv. 375 and Sethian Gnosis
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Marvin Meyer, Chapman University
P. Macquarie inv. 375 and Sethian Gnosis
This paper introduces a soon to be published Coptic magical codex, P. Macquarie inv. 375 (M. Choat & I. Gardner, A Coptic Handbook of Ritual Power [Brepols, in press]), and discusses issues of provenance, contents, and relationship to other texts of ritual power. Of particular interest is a series of motifs in the magical codex recalling themes in gnostic texts, specifically Sethian texts, including names of exalted divine characters, descriptions of Seth and other heavenly figures, and a laughing Jesus reminiscent of Jesus in the Gospel of Judas and similar texts.
|
Sustenance and Sacrality: Household Foodways in Ancient Israel
Program Unit:
Carol Meyers, Duke University
The preparation and consumption of food are among the most quotidian of human activities; yet they are also cultural practices that have religious dimensions. Aside from the food prohibitions in the Pentateuch and except for the references to various foodstuffs, the Hebrew Bible provides little information about the foodways of ordinary Israelite households. This paper will begin by explaining the terms household and foodways from a social science perspective. Then, using archaeological and ethnographic materials, it will give several examples of Israelite food practices that can be understood as evidence for sacral aspects of daily meals. In addition, the relationship of household food practices to those of community shrines (insofar as comestibles and potables comprised sacrifices according to biblical texts) will be considered.
|
Ruth 2:14 and Grain Sacrifice in Folk Religion and Royal Cult
Program Unit: Sacrifice, Cult, and Atonement
Sheila Shiki-y-Michaels, Independent Scholar
In “Ruth” 2:14, at the commencement of the barley harvest, Boaz offers Ruth the foods that Exodus 12 and Leviticus 23 forbid during Passover. Exodus 12 and Leviticus 23 lay out the Paschal rites. Boaz directs Ruth--in his field--to ceremonially dip (tbl) a morsel (ptt) of bread in a leavening agent (chametz), as in Exodus 12:18-20. Biblically, tbl and ptt are predominantly used ceremonially. Using an hapax legomenon Boaz “grasps” (tsbt) [Sasson: Ugaritic,“tongs”] to Ruth parched ears of new barley (kli), which are forbidden until after the Passover’s Sabbath in Leviticus 23:14. Kli are prepared from green barley ears (abib), and the Hebrew word for Spring is taken from this stage of barley growth. By offering to Ruth the first fruits of harvest, following Passover, Boaz may be indicating that as an avatar of Naomi (1:16-17), Ruth can initiate and accept offerings. Or, perhaps, Boaz is reifying Ruth’s inclusion in the community of Israel as given in Exodus 12:48-49. Naomi tacitly accepted Ruth’s changed identity as an Israelite and a functioning member of Naomi’s own family in its own territory (1:18). Boaz’s instructions and offerings may formally signal that Ruth is a serving member of Naomi’s clan, qualified to eat ritually sanctified food, and with rights to tribal land’s sustenance. To my knowledge no one has remarked on the ceremonial freight of the food and apparent ritual context in Ruth 2:14. Ruth is here called n’arah (native-born indentured servant), shiphchah (woman’s handmaid), later ‘amah (man’s handmaid). Boaz and Ruth later beget the royal ancestor Obed (servant) for Naomi. Ruth 2:14 really demands close examination, probably revealing diverse Israelite religions.
|
New Standards and Tools for the Study of Syriac Authors: Preliminary Proposals for Syriac Authority Records in The SBL Handbook of Style
Program Unit: Syriac Literature and Interpretations of Sacred Texts
David A. Michelson, University of Alabama
This paper describes on an ongoing project to draft authority controls for Syriac Studies. Scholars have long recognized the value of Syriac sources both for Biblical scholarship and the study of Christianity in Late Antiquity. Perhaps as many as ten thousand manuscripts or manuscript fragments written in Syriac survive today, with a wide range in geographic origin stretching from the Eastern Mediterranean to Western China and South India. Recently scholarly access to these manuscript sources has increased dramatically due to digitization projects such as the work done by Hill Museum and Manuscript Library at St. John’s University. Much work remains to be done, however, to catalogue these manuscripts and make the texts and information in them useful to scholars and the communities who produced them. One major obstacle to cataloging is that most of the published finding aids and other scholarly resources for Syriac studies are now dated by more than half a century. For example, perhaps the most reliable reference work on the history of Syriac literature (by A. Baumstark) was published in 1922. In an effort to bring core data in the field of Syriac studies up to date, an international group of scholars have begun draft authority records for areas of the core date in the field of Syriac studies, particularly with regard to authors, titles of works, and toponyms. It is hoped that the authority records in their final form would be adopted as standards by the relevant academic bodies such as in future editions of The SBL Handbook of Style which currently does not make any specific recommendations with regard to Syriac (c.f. sections 5.8 and Appendix H). This paper proposes a methodology for the creation these authority records and invites constructive criticism and offers of collaboration on the project from scholars in the field.
|
Make It So, Number One! David’s Attempt to Retake the Bridge of the Starship Israel in 2 Samuel 7
Program Unit: Bakhtin and the Biblical Imagination
J. Richard Middleton, Roberts Wesleyan College
Biblical scholars have often regarded God’s unconditional covenant with David in 2 Samuel 7 as royal propaganda meant to bolster the claims of the Davidic dynasty. While the Davidic covenant historically may have came to serve this ideological function, a close reading of the text of 2 Samuel 7 reveals a less-than-flattering portrait of David, perhaps even a critique of David. The narrative of the Davidic covenant occurs in the context of 2 Samuel 5-8, which portrays the newly ascendant king taking a series of royal initiatives to consolidate his rule, including capturing Jerusalem, building the royal palace, expanding his family, defeating the Philistines (chapter 5), bringing the ark to Jerusalem (chapter 6), proposing to build a temple for YHWH (chapter 7), extending his empire over surrounding nations, and expanding his administration over Israel (chapter 8). Only three times is this series of initiatives interrupted—twice by God and once by Michal. This paper will focus on the third of these interruptions, when YHWH refuses David’s offer to build him a house/temple. Instead, God takes the initiative and proposes to build David a house/dynasty. Instead of accepting this gracious offer, David (much like Jacob at Bethel in Genesis 28) tries to retake the initiative from YHWH in a series of deft rhetorical moves that suggest either the young king is suspicious of the offer or is simply not satisfied to be the passive recipient of God’s hesed. The paper will trace David’s jockeying for control of the “bridge” of the “starship” Israel in the dynamic interaction between YHWH and David narratively presented in 2 Samuel 7.
|
Islands in the Sun: Overtures to a Caribbean Creation Theology
Program Unit: Islands, Islanders, and Scriptures
J. Richard Middleton, Roberts Wesleyan College
When Christian theologians in the Caribbean attempt to think theologically about the needs of their society, they often (understandably) focus on matters of human justice and liberation, to the exclusion of significant reflection on the natural environment. This is, however, an artificial polarization, since people only exist, live and work somewhere (both impacting and being impacted by their environment). It is also an unbiblical polarization, since humans are consistently understood by the Scriptures as part of the wider cosmos, which is both created by God and is the object of God’s saving activity. This suggests that the time is ripe for a Caribbean theology that grounds human liberation in God’s intent for creation and envisions a role for the earth within God’s purposes. But this theology will need to move beyond the typically abstract concerns of Caribbean theology, which has tended to ignore the concrete experience of ordinary Christians. Not only has Caribbean theology tended to take the form of public theology or reflection on the need for societal transformation (at a level somewhat distant from everyday concerns), but rarely has contextual theological reflection in the Caribbean engaged the Bible in a sustained way, which is how most church members develop and internalize their theology. Building on the nascent beginnings of my own theological development in Kingston, Jamaica, which combined my interest in biblical theology with attention to popular music, this paper proposes to sketch the contours of a creation theology for the Caribbean through interaction with Scripture, in dialogue with Christian hymns and the music of Bob Marley, that would move beyond professional theological concerns to address the pressing need of ordinary Christians to internalize a vision of being human in God’s world that could ground and orient life and work within God’s redemptive purposes.
|
Martyrdom and Discipleship: Two New Testament Perspectives on the Martydom of Jesus and His Followers
Program Unit: Violence and Representations of Violence in Antiquity
Paul Middleton, Chester University
Elaine Pagels long ago observed that certain ‘Gnostic’ groups’ views about the crucifixion of Jesus affected their views on the efficacy of martyrdom. As in some of such texts Jesus escapes crucifixion, so his followers should not only eschew radical forms of voluntary martyrdom, but do everything possible to avoid being killed. By contrast, in early Christian texts where martyrdom is promoted as exemplary behaviour for Christians, martyrs are often cast as imitators of Jesus, or even second Christs. However, further work is required to extend the question of how interpretations of the Jesus’ death relate to advocacy of martyrdom for believers in the New Testament. This paper seeks to begin to address this question by examining the relationship between the death of Jesus and martyrdom in both Mark and Revelation, two communities for which Jesus is independently a ‘first martyr’. First, it will be argued that both documents advocate martyrdom for their readers, and that both sets of readers are experiencing roughly similar levels of external hostility. Next, the paper will demonstrate that the contrasting responses to the situation of hostility rest on the writers’ differing emphases on Jesus’ death, which in turn affects the rhetoric of, and reasons for believers’ martyrdom. Markan Christians are asked to identify with a suffering martyr, whilst the Apocalypse invites its would-be martyrs to join in battle with an exalted warrior-martyr. These different interpretations of Jesus’ death, together with the promotion of martyrdom of his followers subsequently affect not only the ways in which the State is presented in the two texts, but also creates surprising and contrasting views of the violence employed by the State against the Church.
|
Refracting the Rhetoric of Colonization: The Enemy Within
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible and Political Theory
Johnny Miles, Texas Christian University
Only when threatened by the ‘alien’ perceived as an enemy among the colonizer does the colonizer act in such a manner as to remove the enemy within. The rhetoric in the colonization experience of Japanese Americans and Gibeonites alike contributes to their identity by circumscribing a social space for them that in turn reinforces same identity. Yet a closer analysis of a process resulting in the subservient status of the colonized reveals the true “enemy within.”
|
Mary, the Magnificat, and the Powers That Be: Status Reversals and Hidden Resistance in the Gospel of Luke
Program Unit: Jesus Traditions, Gospels, and Negotiating the Roman Imperial World
Amanda C. Miller, Union Presbyterian Seminary (Union-PSCE)
The relationship between Luke and the Roman Empire has often been regarded by many in the biblical guild as essentially positive, with the evangelist playing a conciliatory role between church and state. But as is becoming ever more clear, imperial negotiation is seldom that straight-forward and simple. The work of James Scott on hidden resistance is a valuable resource in bringing to light the complexity of Lukan engagement with Rome and its local elite allies. Specifically, songs and other folklore that announce, celebrate, and enact status reversals are a major theme in the third Gospel, particularly in special “L” material; they are also a major component of the hidden transcript of resistance and its veiled public declaration.
This paper will engage this connection through the lens of one pericope, Mary’s song in 1:46-55. Thus it will explore the impact of the subversive sentiments stated so boldly in this poem, which becomes almost a theme song for the rest of Luke. It will be shown that the status reversals of the Magnificat are indeed part of the hidden transcript, but with subtle changes to the usual tone of pure revenge. They indicate a dissatisfaction with Roman dominance, but also convey the evangelist’s vision of Jesus’ and the Church’s ministry as one which carries out status reversals without becoming oppressors themselves. According to the song’s tenets, Jesus embodies reversal, as he himself is both a ruler who is (voluntarily) thrown down, and one of the lowly whom God lifts up. The Magnificat sets the stage for Luke’s contention that resistance must work toward good for all, including not only non-elites, but also retainers and rulers willing to fully commit to and use their power in service of Jesus and his vision for a different social order.
|
"Not with Eloquent Wisdom": Democratic Discourse and Its Implications for Understanding Audience in 1 Corinthians
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
Anna Miller, Xavier University
In 1 Corinthians, the persuasive rhetoric Paul crafts is powerfully shaped and constrained by the democratic discourse he shares with his Corinthian audience, a discourse associated with the civic ekklesia or assembly. Greek literature from the classical period into the first century CE describes the democratic ekklesia as a volatile gathering in which citizen equality and leadership are realized through persuasive rhetoric directed towards an active and powerful audience. New Testament scholarship has largely dismissed this ekklesia as an institution that retained real authority or discursive power in the first century. By contrast, I find that democratic discourse centered on the civic ekklesia remained pervasive in the first-century and has important implications for understanding early Christian rhetoric and audiences such as the one Paul addresses in 1 Corinthians. In this paper, I analyze the discussion of speech and wisdom in the opening chapters of 1 Corinthians in order to illuminate the democratic context of Paul’s rhetorical conventions. Paul draws on speech as a dominant topos of democratic discourse in this discussion. The prevalence of this topos in Paul’s rhetoric supplies important evidence that Paul’s leadership and his relationship with the community are structured in part by democratic ekklesia discourse. As in the civic ekklesia, Paul’s argumentation suggests that he must negotiate the authority of the gathered community in order to gain legitimacy for his policies and leadership. Further, this argumentation reveals ways in which both Paul and the Corinthians themselves construct this community as a civic ekklesia that expects leadership in the form of persuasive speech, even as they assume the right to carry out debate and decision over the critical questions facing their community.
|
Mismatches of Definiteness between Appositional Noun Phrases used as Vocatives
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Cynthia L. Miller, University of Wisconsin-Madison
In Biblical Hebrew, a noun is described as grammatically definite if any of the following circumstances obtain: it is prefixed with the definite article, it is suffixed with a possessive pronoun, it is in construct with a definite nomen rectum, or it consists of a proper noun. Appositional phrases are generally described as juxtaposed noun phrases which refer to the same entity, have the same syntactic function within the larger phrase or clause, and agree in definiteness. The main reference grammars acknowledge, however, that not infrequently appositional phrases do not agree in definiteness (e.g., Joüon & Muraoka 2006: §138; Waltke & O’Connor 1990: §12c). This paper re-examines an important sub-set of those exceptional cases, namely, appositional expressions occurring within vocative expressions. Since vocative expressions are inherently deictic, they provide a unique and insightful syntactic and pragmatic context within which the patterns and limits of this lack of agreement can be explored.
|
The Power of the Name: A Possible Point of Contact between Ancient Egyptian and Israelite Cosmologies
Program Unit: Israelite Religion in Its Ancient Context
Daniel Miller, Bishop's University
Rather than being simply denotative, the name of a being/thing has been seen in many societies throughout history as a signifier of its very essence. In the ancient Egyptian incantation “The Legend of Isis and the Secret Name of Re,” Isis fashions a serpent of clay (animating it with fallen spittle from her aged father Re’s mouth), and when the serpent bites the supreme deity and no remedy can be found for his agony she compels him to reveal to her his secret name, the knowledge of which gives her power over him. That Re states that he has heretofore hidden this name to forestall the attack of magicians against him, and that this name is called “the Great One of Magic,” are indicative of a belief in what may be called “name-magic” in ancient Egypt, an idea also given expression in the group of pots and figurines called the execration texts. It is the purpose of this paper to argue that the Hebrew Bible provides evidence that at least some segments of the Israelite population may have shared the Egyptian cosmological assumption that the name could be used for magical purposes. The prohibition to make improper use of the divine name (Ex 20:17//Deut 5:11); the instances in which mysterious heavenly beings rebuff mortals who ask for their names (Gen 32:30 [ET 29]; Judg 13:18); the Deity’s cryptic reply of ehye asher ehye and then ehye in response to Moses’ request for his name (Ex 3:13–14); the tradition that the Deity did not reveal his true name “YHWH” until Moses’ time (Ex 6:3); the statement that an Israelite who naqavs the name of YHWH/“the Name” will be stoned to death (Lev 24:16)—all of these suggest an Israelite belief in name-magic akin to that found among the ancient Egyptians.
|
Both Written and Oral: the Dual Nature of Israelite Tradition
Program Unit: Orality, Textuality, and the Formation of the Hebrew Bible
Robert D. Miller II, Catholic University of America, The
Current models of scripturalization view the process as linear: First, oral stories circulated among storytellers, and eventually, these were written down. Those texts, perhaps as soon as they were written, were recited orally to the illiterate masses, a process that continued through the Masoretic vocalization in a step sometimes called “re-oralization.” This model must be abandoned. This paper applies current theory on orality (Ruth Finnegan, Lauri Honko, Terry Gunnell), evidence from the ancient Near East, and ethnographic analogy (Icelandic and Arabic) to describe ancient Israel’s dual nature as an oral-and-literate society. Most people in ancient Israel both before and after the Exile received the message of the “text” aurally. A narrative circulating by word of mouth only was virtually unknown, and one circulating by text only was equally rare. Written texts circulated in spoken form by recitation long after they were committed to writing, and those recited forms begat oral forms that were not in writing, or were once again recorded in writing. Transmission was through the interaction or combination of the concurrent oral and written versions. This paper also details the nature of the narrative modules that moved through this large and echoic pool of tradition and how they produced the narrative books of the Hebrew Bible. A detailed new understanding is presented that will move us beyond the image of stemma-like lines of traditions history that has lasted since Gunkel.
|
Poetic Reconstructions of Wiles of the Wicked Woman: A Stichometrical Analysis of 4Q184
Program Unit: Qumran
Shem Miller, Florida State University
Wiles of the Wicked Woman appears to be a fragment from a larger sapiential work which is influenced by many motifs from biblical wisdom literature featuring a woman who leads people to death in the same manner as Dame Folly in Proverbs. Since its initial reconstruction and sexualized translation by J. Allegro, several reconstructions have been proposed for this fragmentary text. One avenue that has not been pursued vigorously to help reconstruction is literary analysis. Only two articles, by Carmignac and Moore, have even considered the poetic nature of 4Q184. Both of these articles highlight that there are many poetic features that should be considered for a proper understanding and reconstruction of 4Q184. This paper will offer a stichometrical analysis of 4Q184 that will show that the extant portions are best understood as a poem with three stanzas. Furthermore, each stanza is constructed of strophes consisting of either two or three lines. The stanzas, strophes, and lines are each delineated by discernable literary features such as morphologic, syntactic, and semantic parallelism. One can also notice that each strophe is delineated topically, and there is a thematic progression between the stanzas and strophes. Lastly, this paper will suggest how sensitivity to these poetic features and structure can aid one in providing and analyzing reconstructions of 4Q184.
|
"Are You Not Also One of This Man's Disciples?" (John 18:17) Discipleship and Trial in the Gospel Traditions
Program Unit: Jesus Traditions, Gospels, and Negotiating the Roman Imperial World
Susan Miller, University of Glasgow
The gospels depict the trial of Jesus before the Roman governor, Pilate, and his execution as the rebel King of the Jews. This portrayal, however, raises questions about his followers. Why do the gospels not record any traditions describing the rounding up and arrest of the disciples? Does this omission imply that Jesus' disciples are not considered a threat to the Roman imperial world? In Mark and Matthew, the disciples flee at the arrest of Jesus but Luke does not include this tradition reflecting his tendency to omit negative views of the Twelve. In John's Gospel Jesus is in control throughout his arrest, and he commands the soldiers to let his followers go. In all four gospels, moreover, women are the witnesses to Jesus' death, and no member of the Twelve is present at the crucifixion. These features suggest that the Twelve feared that they too would be arrested and put to death. One of the key ways in which Jesus traditions are seen to negotiate the Roman imperial world is illustrated by the account of the denial of Peter. The questioning of Peter is modelled on the trial of Jesus. In Mark's Gospel, however, Peter begins to curse Christ, and in John's Gospel he specifically denies that he is one of Jesus' disciples. By the time the gospels were written Peter had died a martyr's death. The evangelists wish to highlight the unique identity of Jesus as the Son of God who has courage to stand alone against the Roman Empire. The remorse of Peter has the function of encouraging the gospel audiences to acknowledge their own fear of death, and also to overcome their terror of persecution as they know Peter has done.
|
"I Came That They May Have Life, and Have It Abundantly" (John 10:10): An Ecological Reading of John's Gospel
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Susan Miller, University of Glasgow
In the synoptic gospels Jesus proclaims the imminence of the Kingdom of God but in John's Gospel Jesus is concerned with the gift of eternal life. Interpretations of John's Gospel have emphasised the relationship between salvation and an individual's faith in Jesus. Several passages feature accounts of the meeting of Jesus and characters who come to faith in him such as the Samaritan woman, the blind man, Martha, and Thomas. The focus on the faith of individuals and their desire for eternal life has downplayed the importance of the natural world. An ecological strategy of identification, however, illustrates the ways in which Jesus is aligned with Earth. He offers the Samaritan woman living water, and he identifies himself as the bread of life (6:35), the light of the world (8:12), and the true vine (15:1). This strategy of identification highlights images of fruitfulness and abundant harvests. This approach, moreover, emphasises the presence of God in the processes of nature. God is present in the seed which falls to the ground and bears abundant fruit. The strategy of retrieval points to the ways in which the gift of eternal life is described in terms of the abundance of the natural world. An ecological interpretation of John's Gospel challenges the view that salvation may be defined purely in terms of the gift of eternal life to an individual, and points to an understanding of salvation as the restoration of the relationship of God, humanity, and Earth.
|
Deathscape and Lament in the Jeremianic Corpus
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Mary Mills, Liverpool Hope University
The paper continues the themes of pain and suffering in my previous work on Alterity, Pain and Suffering in the major prophets and adds into this discussion spatiality as a particular reading lens for the books of Jeremiah and Lamentations, exploring the narrative construction of text as ‘deathscape’. In my 2007 volume I addressed the topic of pathos, the fully embodied prophetic experience of grief, investigating the ‘traumatised messenger’ as a mirror image of the community existing on the border between life and death. I drew out from the study of Jeremiah an image of the unstable cosmos; meanwhile I also explored the issue of a wasted landscape, using the work of human geographers, as a means of understanding the imagery of Isaiah. This paper will take the latter perspective, that of literary landscapes as cultural representations, with regard to the subject of death. A deathscape is a narrative space which performs cultural meaning – the end of a community. In this context Lamentations is viewed as evoking both horror and attraction on the part of the ‘passers by’ who gaze on urban trauma.
|
Depicting Emotions in Biblical and Judeo-Hellenistic Narratives: The Body as Figure and Mirror
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
Françoise Mirguet, Arizona State University
Many studies, from Edouard Dhorme (1963) to Mark S. Smith (1998) and Ellen van Wolde (2008), have shown the embodiment of emotions in Biblical Hebrew: for example, anger is expressed by metaphors evoking the mouth or the nose, while compassion is represented by the plural of the word designating the maternal womb. In Judeo-Hellenistic narratives, or the so-called “novels” (Lawrence M. Wills [1995]) and associated literature, emotional depictions are even more frequent, and physical depictions abound. Even a simple reading, however, suggests that Judeo-Hellenistic narratives are not just simply more prolix in terms of emotional depictions, but that they reveal a different way to conceive the relationship between body and emotions. In this presentation, I will compare different examples of “embodied emotions”—fear, anger, love, and distress, represented with references to the body—both in biblical Hebrew and Judeo-Hellenistic narratives, as well as the conception of the human self that they imply. I will propose to regard the body as “figure” of the emotion in the first corpus of text, and as “mirror” in the latter. A comparison with the Hellenistic novels will show that the Jewish authors drew upon the contemporary Greek literature in their representation of emotions—an influence that is visible, for example, in the theatrical representations or in the conflicts of emotions (Massimo Fusillo [1999]). The Jewish novels therefore appear to constitute a unique intersection of two radically different conceptions of the human self, reflecting the degree of Hellenization of (a least a branch of) Late Antique Judaism.
|
David and Goliath: Shepherd or Warrior?
Program Unit: Bakhtin and the Biblical Imagination
Peter D. Miscall, Retired
I will develop a dialogic reading of the David and Goliath story as it stands in the MT focusing on the contrasting views of David, the different voices depicting him: the pious young shepherd of tradition who kills Goliath with the stone (1 Sam 17:50) and the violent, would-be usurper who kills him with the sword (v. 51). David, and we the readers, can have at least two views of Goliath: huge, fearsome warrior – the view of Saul and the army – or big oaf weighed down by his armor. I will locate this latter view in the text and its details. The two versions of the tale – one, the story in LXXB that is considerably shorter than that in the MT and, two, the extra material in MT – are significant since they point to the dialogism but I do not simply equate them with the two views of David since the latter are already in evidence in both of the versions. The chronotope is also important in the reading because of the play and tension between specific sites at the beginning and close of the story and the general “valley” and “battle line” of the rest of the story. The lack of specification of time, other than the “this very day” of vv. 10 and 46 and the “forty days” of v. 16, is integrally related to this tension between specificity and generality.
|
Restoration and Renewal: Vespasian and the Gospel of Matthew
Program Unit: Jesus Traditions, Gospels, and Negotiating the Roman Imperial World
Annelies Moeser, Brite Divinity School
Augustus cloaked the institution of imperial power by naming it a restoration of the republic. Through poetry, music, and visual representations on coins, a new Golden Age was proclaimed which heralded the renewal of the earth, the republic, and its people. Vespasian sought to legitimize his reign by linking himself to the Augustan program of restoration and renewal. In his coinage, Vespasian portrayed himself as restoring liberty, the res publica, Rome, and peace. A coin minted in Antioch bearing the legend “PAX AUGUSTA,” (RIC 1550) is a significant example of this iconography to be discussed in this paper. In his miraculous healing of a man with a withered hand, Vespasian restored the man to health. As sickness was used as a metaphor for the condition of the state, this healing also had political overtones. Suetonius recognized that this healing gave Vespasian the auctoritas and maiestas he had hitherto lacked (The Deified Vespasian 7.2).
I contend that the author of Matthew, writing from a location in Antioch, is aware of the symbolic claims of the deified emperor. In his gospel, Matthew presents the healing miracles of Jesus through a strategy that is both competing with and imitative of imperial claims. The agency of the emperor (supported by force) is contested by the agency of Jesus who effects healing through his life-giving word.
The healing of the Canaanite woman’s daughter (Matt 15:21-28) has strong visual echoes with restoration symbolism in coinage. The inclusion of a “foreign” woman represents an expansion of the kingdom not unlike that claimed on Vespasian’s coinage. The healing of a man with a withered hand (Matt 12:9-14) explicitly uses restoration language. Matthew ties both the ministries of Jesus (Matt 12:17-21) and John (Matt 17:11, identified with Elijah) to restoration of God’s kingdom through citations of Malachi and Isaiah.
|
Blood, Life, and Purification: Reassessing Hebrews’ Christological Appropriation of Yom Kippur
Program Unit: Hebrews
David M. Moffitt, Duke University
Recent work by scholars such as Jacob Milgrom on the relationship between ritual blood manipulation and purification, particularly as these inform the logic of the Levitical sacrificial system, has highlighted the importance of the victim’s life in the sacrificial process. While some have begun to explore the possible significance of blood imagery in Hebrews along similar lines (e.g., Christian Eberhart), this ancient homily continues to present a source worthy of examination. Indeed, no other New Testament text illustrates such a detailed and consistent application of sacrificial concepts to the Christ event. In this paper I argue that the commonplace assumption that “blood” language in Hebrews functions synecdochically for Jesus’ death potentially obscures the way the author develops the link between Jesus’ purifying offering (1:3; 9:14, 23) and Yom Kippur. The offering of blood in the Levitical system was not a presentation of death before God, but a presentation of life (Lev 17:11). Similarly, Hebrews’ application of the central blood ritual of Yom Kippur to Jesus’ offering is, I suggest, best understood in terms of the post-crucifixion life of Jesus. The author’s emphasis on Jesus’ ascension and living presence in heaven—the location identified in the homily for where Jesus offered his blood (9:11–14, 23–24; cf. 8:1–4)—implies that it is not Jesus’ blood/death that effects atonement, but (in keeping with Yom Kippur) the presentation of his blood/life before God in the heavenly holy of holies. If these points can be demonstrated, then Hebrews’ appeal to Yom Kippur appears to show more concern with explicating how the purification rites of the Mosaic Law elucidate the theological implications of Jesus’ resurrection, ascension, and exaltation than with how they provide a hermeneutical lens for understanding the event of his crucifixion.
|
Swahili Translation of the Africa Bible Commentary
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Aloo Osotsi Mojola, United Bible Societies
I am hoping that I can attend and would like to prepare a paper on the Swahili translation of the Africa Bible Commentary of which I have been the Translation Consultant. The translation is now complete and Swahili edition is due to be dedicated and launched in Dodoma Tanzania in June 2010.
|
Reconsidering the Ideology of Centralization in the Deuteronomistic Account of Josiah’s Reform
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Lauren A. S. Monroe, Cornell University
This paper is based on a book in progress on Josiah’s reform as defilement ritual, in which I argue that the use of ritual language in the account of the reform reveals two main compositional strata: an early priestly text generated by a scribe trained within the circles of the Jerusalem-centered, holiness school; and a post-monarchic, deuteronomistic revision that sought to transform Josiah into the paradigmatic example of ideal royal leadership in pre-exilic Judah.
In this paper I will argue that considering the deuteronomistic material in the account of the reform on its own terms, dissociated from the source material that underlies it, calls into question the widely held assertion that the deuteronomistic authors of 2 Kings 22-23 were working directly in the service of an ideology of centralization. I will propose that for the post-monarchic author of this text, the ideal of centralization, tied as it was to Yahweh’s covenant promise to David, did not resonate as powerfully as the ideal of limited kingship. This deuteronomist's revisions to the account of the reform sought to redraw the lines of royal power, rendering it subservient to textual authority, the latter having had the potential to transcend the spatial and political constraints of his day. While these two Deuteronomic principles are hardly mutually exclusive, they lived on differently in the post-monarchic imagination, and suggest a greater degree of heterogeneity within deuteronomistic writing than is generally understood to be the case.
|
Disembodied Women: Sacrificial Language in the Biblical Accounts of the Murders of Bat Jephtah, the Bethlehemite Concubine, and Cozbi the Midianite
Program Unit: Sacrifice, Cult, and Atonement
Lauren A. S. Monroe, Cornell University
Judges 11:30-40, in which Jephtah inadvertently promises his daughter as an offering to Yahweh and dutifully fulfills his vow, is often identified as a unique biblical example of child sacrifice. Bat-Jephtah, however, shares the company of two other women in the Bible, whose violent deaths are described in terms belonging to the sacrificial realm: the Bethlehemite concubine whose rape and dismemberment in Judges 19 draw us into a world of “unrelenting terror” (Bal 1988:43); and Cozbi, the Midianite at Ba’al Pe’or, whose slaughter at the hands of Phinehas the priest in Numbers 25 is not only condoned but rewarded. Examples of sacrificial language in these texts include: the roots KPR, “to atone,” and QRB, “to approach” in the description of the murder of Cozbi; Jephtah’s promise of an ‘LH, “burnt offering,” in the context of his vow; and the verb NT?, “to cut up,” and the rare noun M’KLT, for “knife” in the account of the Levite and his concubine.
Outside of anti-child sacrifice polemics, these texts provide the only examples in the Hebrew Bible of sacrificial language used to describe the death of single human being. The female gender of the victims is striking, yet to my knowledge scholars have not treated these texts together; nor, with the exception of Judges 11 have they fully explored the sacrificial nuances of each on its own terms. In this paper I examine the ritual semantics signified by the sacrificial language in each text and consider what the texts, taken together, illuminate about both gender attitudes and human sacrifice in ancient Israel. I conclude that while human sacrifice is not the primary focus in any of these texts, each, independently of the others, asks its audience to imagine the possibility that a woman’s body could be offered as a sacrifice to Yahweh.
|
Jesus in the Fourth Gospel as a King Solomon Redivivus: An Influence of the Wisdom Tradition on the Christology of the Fourth Gospel
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Wooil Moon, Claremont Graduate University
Inspired by Ernst Wilhelm Hengstenberg’s remark on the messianic hope rooted in the Song of Songs (1853), this paper proposes that the dominant type of messiah in the Fourth Gospel is a King Solomon redivivus, as in the Wisdom of Solomon, and this type radically stands against “the disciples of Moses” (John 9:28), possibly of the Mosaic tradition in Philo of Alexandria. For this purpose, it uncovers the echoes of the Song (LXX) in John from a mimesis-critical perspective to show that the Song provides framework for the intimacy of Jesus, not only with Mary Magdalene (cf. A. R. Winsor, 1999), but also with the other disciples throughout the Gospel. The verbal and thematic parallels between the two texts suggest an intertextuality, and the Johannine Jesus as the lover, bridegroom, shepherd, garden dweller, and king of the Jews resonates with the epithets of the lover in the Song. The fourth evangelist further uses the other canonical and non-canonical attributes of Solomon, such as the prince of shalom (eirene), emblem of wisdom, temple-builder, son of the Father, healer, and miracle worker (cf. 1Chr 22:9-10; Ps 72; Isa 9:6; Zech 9:9; Wis; Josephus, Ant. 8.42-49; etc.). Jesus in John more palpably represents a new Solomon, who rivals Solomon in temple-building (2:19-20), and walks in the stoa of Solomon (10:23). Moreover, some early Christian authors, such as Origen and Augustine, compare the Johannine Jesus to Solomon. This paper complements Wayne A. Meeks’s identification of the Johannine opponents with “Israel the Seer” in Philo (1976) by contrasting the Johannine king with the Philonic Moses. Notably, Philo the prolific author, mentions Solomon by name only once in his works, not as a king but as “one of Moses’s disciples” called “a man of peace,” who ironically supports Philo’s advocacy of slavery and reproach (Congr. 177).
|
Aristotle's Rhetoric: Usage of Metaphor in Biblical Texts
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible and Cognate Literature
Anne Moore, University of Calgary
Almost every study on metaphor proceeds from Aristotle’s theory as it is explained in his Poetics. This focus on metaphor, as it is discussed in the Poetics, emphasizes the creation or coinage of a metaphor; it concentrates on the creative genius of the original poet and the emotive impact of the metaphor as it illuminates the unknown through its interactive juxtaposition with the known. However, the Poetics represent only one aspect of Aristotle’s comprehension of metaphor. In Aristotle’s Rhetoric, the focus is on how metaphor is part of everyday discourse; metaphor serves a cognitive or pedagogical function in public oration and written prose. Aristotle even provides advice on how to improve the informative nature of metaphors within public discourse. This understanding of metaphor from Aristotle’s Rhetoric not only confirms the observations of G. Lakoff and M. Johnson about the ubiquitous nature of metaphor; it also implies that our study of metaphor in biblical texts should shift from coinage to usage; from literary analysis to rhetorical explanation; from the unique to the commonplace and from origins to trajectories of interpretation.
|
Divinanimality and (Post)humanity: Ruminations on Revelation’s Ruminant, Quadrupedal Christ; or, the Even-Toed Ungulate That Therefore I Am
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
Stephen D. Moore, Drew University
The Lamb has long been the elephant in the room of Revelation scholarship. What does it mean—theologically, philosophically, ecologically—that Jesus trots through most of Revelation on four legs? This paper will have recourse to Derrida’s two animal books to defamiliarize this animal Christology. Instead of the asymmetrical, antithetical human/animal dyad endemic to post-Cartesian modernity, Revelation presents us with a divine/human/animal triad, each of the three terms bleeding into the other two. Yet the triad is hardly symmetrical. All humans are now subject to the animal domesticated to serve humans (Rev. 5:11-14), that animal itself, however, having first been subjected to slaughter by humans (5:6, 9). If the crucial question is not whether animals can reason or speak but rather whether they can suffer, the Lamb both answers and complicates the question. It suffers without speaking, but it is also a source of suffering (e.g., 14:9-11). It is also singular in that it is an emblematic challenge to the logic, as ancient as Genesis 4 and as recent as factory farming, that sacrificing an animal, exploiting it to death, does not constitute murder. The Lamb presents us with the ethical paradox of a sacrificial animal whose slaughter constitutes unlawful killing. Derrida writes apocalyptically of a sacrificial war against the animal that, if unchecked, will result in a world without animals, without any animal worthy of the name, whose purpose is not altogether predetermined by human need. This both is and is not the world with which Revelation presents us in the end, and as the end (chs. 21-22), an animal-depopulated urban space containing but one animal—the only animal that has become other than a means to human ends because now all humans are its slaves (22:3). (This abstract has not been submitted to any other program unit.)
|
Samaritans:Past and Present: Current Studies
Program Unit:
Menahem Mor, University of Haifa
Samaritans:Past and Present: Current Studies
|
Deceptive Righteousness: A Scriptural Defense against the Good Deeds of Heretics in Ephraem of Nisibis
Program Unit: Syriac Literature and Interpretations of Sacred Texts
Robert Morehouse, Catholic University of America
In Ephraem’s heresiographical attacks against Daysanites and Manichaeans he acknowledges that his opponents manifest qualities of Christian virtue. Ephraem has a problem—how to address the righteous deeds of false teachers. His response is direct. He demonstrates that his opponents’ seemingly virtuous deeds are in actuality cunning traps with which they hope to ensnare the unsuspecting devotee. His response is also exegetical. He attacks his opponents’ interpretation of the synoptic passage that discusses good and bad trees bearing fruit in accordance with their nature (Luke 6.43-5/Matthew 7.16-20). Ephraem refers to this passage twice in his Prose Refutations, and in each case he quotes from this pericope after a long section in which he refutes the Manichaean teaching that there are two primal entities, often called roots, one good and one evil. The Manichaeans are known to have used this pericope to support this cosmological teaching. Ephraem, however, applies the passage to humanity rather than to eternal beings. In the first instance, he quotes Luke 6.43: “there is no good tree that bears evil fruit,” and applies it to the human condition generally, arguing that whether the human does good or evil, according to Manichaean teaching both a good soul and an evil body are complicit in the act. Ephraem, thereby, demonstrates that the Manichaean cosmological interpretation of this passage was inconsistent with Manichaean anthropology. The second instance, which comes in the conclusion to the Fifth Discourse to Hypatius, is applied to Ephraem’s opponents directly. Here, Ephraem quotes Matthew 7.16/20: “you will know them by their fruits.” He suggests that the “fruits” of his opponents are their teachings rather than their deeds, since their deeds are a deceptively innocent façade, while their teachings are obviously in error. In this way, his opponents are made to sound like the “false prophets,” of Matthew 7.15, “who come… in sheep's clothing but inwardly are ravenous wolves.” (exceeded 350 words)
|
Pistis, Fides, and Divine-Human Relations in the Late Republic and Early Roman Empire
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
Teresa Morgan, University of Oxford
This paper examines relationships of pistis/fides between human beings and gods in Graeco-Roman religious thinking. As in cult, pistis/fides is imagined in texts both as a quality of the gods (especially Zeus/Jupiter), and as a divinity in her own right. Pistis/fides may be a gift of the gods to human beings, but human beings can also acquire it for themselves by imitating or ‘following the god’. There is widespread agreement that the gods wish people to practise pistis/fides and that doing so is a good thing, but debate about whether the gods reward those who practise it, or punish those who do not. People exercise pistis/fides towards the gods whenever they need any kind of help, or simply because it is a good thing to do. They often turn to a particular god with pistis/fides for a particular purpose. Pistis/fides often seems to indicate a relationship of trust, with overtones of hope or obedience, but it can also refer to propositional belief. From a wide range of Greek and Latin literature, over several centuries, a complex, sometimes debated, but often notably coherent set of views emerges about the nature of the gods and of human relationships with them. I shall argue that the meaning of pistis/fides in Graeco-Roman religion is more complex, and its role more significant, than has hitherto been assumed. I shall also suggest that the earliest Christian understandings of pistis, whose complexity is notoriously difficult to derive from Old Testament language of trust and faithfulness, owed more to Graeco-Roman understandings of divine-human pistis/fides than to Jewish ones.
|
Pistis/Fides: Between Emotion, Cognition, and Action
Program Unit: Hellenistic Moral Philosophy and Early Christianity
Teresa Morgan, University of Oxford
This paper explores the way pistis and fides are represented in Graeco-Roman culture: as an emotion, a cognitive state, an action and a relationship. The interaction between these aspects of pistis/fides is subtle and revealing; it tells us a good deal about how relationships of trust are perceived to work in Roman imperial society, and why they are fundamentally important for that society’s success.
I shall give some examples of how pistis/fides operate in relations between people, between people and gods, and between people and ideas. I shall then draw some parallels between the use of the terms in Graeco-Roman culture in general and in early Christianity, and try to elucidate both how much Christian understandings of pistis/fides owe to their cultural context, and where they are distinctive.
|
Origen as an Exegetical Source in Eusebius' Prophetical Extracts
Program Unit: Eusebius and the Construction of a Christian Culture
Sebastien Morlet, University of Paris - Sorbonne
Since C. Curti’s hypothesis about the development of Eusebius’ exegesis, one generally assumes that the Prophetical Extracts date to a period when Eusebius, probably still in the circle of Pamphilus, was, more than ever, dependent on Origen. Some new studies recently showed that Eusebius’ dependence on Origen was anyway very important in all his works, though the bishop of Caesarea may be more original here and there. However, the state of Origen’s preserved exegesis is so poor, that the difficulty is often to know where Eusebius uses him, and where he does not. The case of the Prophetical Extracts will be an occasion to discuss the methodological issues of the problem, and to give an example of what may be extracted, in that work, from Origen’s (sometimes lost) exegesis. A precise philological analysis would thus make it possible to go beyond what is often assumed about Eusebius’ “origenianism”.
|
Deuteronomy 7 in Postcolonial Perspective: Cultural Fragmentation and Renewal
Program Unit: Warfare in Ancient Israel
William Morrow, Queen's School of Religion
In its canonical form, Deuteronomy 7 reflects the interests of the exilic and/or early post-exilic period to identify a program for recovery after the trauma of subjugation by foreign powers. Its demand for the destruction of Canaanite culture can be analyzed from a perspective that combines insights drawn from anthropology, the psychology of trauma, and postcolonial studies. There is a convergence between the colonial experience and forms of personal trauma because of the need to manage identification with the aggressor. The violent expulsion of the foreign is a manifestation of “nativism,” a term used in anthropology to describe various movements for cultural renewal. In Native American history, incidents such as the Pueblo revolt of 1688 and the Ghost Dance of 1889-90 are examples of nativistic movements which either dreamed of or attempted the expulsion of the foreign in order to reassert a fragmented cultural identity. Deuteronomy 7 expresses a desire for social renewal associated with the traumatic experiences of Judah’s captivity, deportations, and displacement. Both holiness thinking (cf. Deut 7:6) and the polemic against Canaanite culture fear “pollution” of the body (politic); for both uncleaness and idoltary represent foreign intrusions in an idealized Israel. It should not be surprising if biblical writings present its readers with programs for ridding the faith community of both sorts of contamination. In analyzing Deuteronomy 7 as an expression of nativism, it is important to note that there is no evidence its destructive program was put into practice by returning exiles; it remained a literary phenomenon. The concept of “imagined community,” drawn from postcolonial studies, helps to explain why Deuteronomy 7 was important for its first readers even if there was no intention or possibility to act upon its stipulations literally.
|
Is the Biblical Hebrew Long Imperative a Politeness Marker?
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Adina Moshavi, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
Although many consider the function of the long imperative in Biblical Hebrew to be unknown, S. Kaufman has suggested that this form, like the particle na, simply means “please.” From the perspective of modern theories of linguistic politeness, politeness markers like please can be understood as “face-payment” which symbolically compensates the addressee for complying with a request. In this study it is shown that the long imperative indeed functions as a politeness marker in classical Biblical Hebrew dialogue, although generally with a somewhat different effect from na. Analysis of the distribution of imperatives with and without na in Genesis-Kings shows that both the regular imperative with na and the long imperative are not usually found in speech acts where politeness would not be expected. Both na and, to a lesser degree, the long imperative, are common in requests, where they are frequently accompanied by other expressions of politeness. The most common use of the long imperative, however, is in proposals, where a directive is issued in the context of a mutually advantageous negotiation. The long imperative apparently pays respect to the addressee’s face by indicating that s/he is treated as an equal. When used in requests, the long imperative can be seen as strategically downplaying the attendant imposition by casting the request as something the speaker is entitled to in the context of a fair settlement. In orders and demands, the long imperative can be strategically used to foster an attitude of cooperation, suggesting that the speaker is negotiating rather than forcing his will upon the addressee. In a fair number of cases, particularly when the long imperative and na are combined, the two markers appear to be indistinguishable in function. In Psalms the long imperative has largely replaced na as the normal politeness marker in entreaties to God.
|
Sensing Jesus: The Construction of the Ideal Disciple in the Gospel of Mark
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Candida R. Moss, University of Notre Dame
This paper uses sensory criticism to examine intersection of language of audition and vision with the notion of discipleship in the Gospel of Mark. The language of audition and invocations to “hear” serve both to signify the Jesus-follower as hearer and also to demarcate certain pericopae as especially relevant for this ideal disciple. The construction of the ideal Jesus-follower as the one who uses his or her senses correctly creates a contrast between the disciples in the audience and the disciples in the account. Language of audition, for Mark, serves a rhetorical function in constructing the addressees as a community of hearers.
|
Oral Tradition and Q: Historical Complexity and the Synoptic Problem
Program Unit: Q
Terence Mournet, Ashland Theological Seminary
This paper will examine the relationship between oral tradition and the so-called double tradition in Matthew and Luke. Particular attention will be directed towards the problem of historical complexity and the role of oral
tradition in the development of a comprehensive theory of synoptic interrelationships.
|
Memory in Search of Dignity: Construction of Identity through Redescribed Traditional Material in the Letter to the Ephesians
Program Unit: Construction of Christian Identities
Elna Mouton, University of Stellenbosch
The letter to the Ephesians employs various communicative strategies in responding to the rhetorical situation of its implied recipients. The first half of the letter is distinguished by its epistolary use of liturgical forms and elements of anamnesis, while the second half is distinguished by a concern with parenesis. Focusing on the recipients’ new identity and ethos in Christ, the text emphasizes supernatural elements such as resurrection, ascension, heavenly places, revealed mystery, spirit and power. At the same time it adopts a rich mosaic of traditional materials, inter alia echoing the Hebrew Scriptures, Hellenistic traditions, and early Christian liturgical traditions.
Reference to motives from the Hebrew Scriptures as a possible explanation for the letter’s religious background has not previously attracted much scholarly attention. This was probably due to its few direct citations as well as the focus on Christian traditions and cultic language from Qumran. A widespread assumption that its audience was predominantly Greek has also frequently contributed to the notion that its roots mainly represent Hellenism and early forms of Gnosticism. Scholars such as Lincoln and Barth, however, challenged these ideas through their interdisciplinary studies on the functioning of Jewish material in Ephesians – particularly as expression of conflicting intercultural relations among Mediterranean religious groups during the first century CE.
The paper explores the dynamic yet complex intertextual fusion and reappropriation of (mainly Jewish) traditions in Ephesians, as the author’s experience and understanding of the crucified, resurrected and exalted Christ. Special attention is given to the use of LXX Psalm 68:19 in Ephesians 4:1-16 – analogous forms of contact with the supernatural in the construction of Christianity. Through the metaphorical processes of identification, estrangement and reorientation the implied receivers’ adherence to Christian convictions and values is intensified. In conclusion, the paper investigates the intended effect of the letter’s use of material from the Hebrew Scriptures as construction of Christian identity in continuation with the story of Israel.
|
Jesus in the Mirror of Nineteenth Century Nationalism
Program Unit: Redescribing Christian Origins
Halvor Moxnes, University of Oslo
The controversy over the historical Jesus in the 19th century has largely been seen as a threat to dogmatic Christology and a conflict with the authority of the churches. But the importance of the studies of the historical Jesus that emerged in the 19th century only becomes visible when seen within the context of larger political and ideological changes in this period.
I suggest that the historical Jesus studies represented a transfer of religious symbols, from Christ representing the old monarchic structure of rule and authority over subjects, to the human Jesus, who was portrayed in relation to citizenship and nation.
In the 19th century nationalism emerged as the central paradigm of ideology and political praxis, partly transforming old state-nations (France and England) and partly establishing nation-states (Germany). Questions related to territory, boundaries between “we” and “others”, ethnic identity and family and gender roles (masculinity) were all important aspects of nationalism. This was a set of issues that shaped the descriptions of the historical Jesus in the geographical context of Galilee and Palestine and the ethnic and religious context of the Jewish people.
The question to be explored is how different authors saw the relationship between Jesus and citizenship and what aspects of nation they emphasized. Important figures to study are F. Schleiermacher (his lectures on the historical Jesus 1819-32) in early, democratic German nationalism; the late D.F.Strauss (“Jesus explained for the German people”, 1864) representing a proto-Bismarck state-nationalism, with contrasts between “we” (Galilee, Protestants) and “others” (Jerusalem, Roman Catholics); E.Renan (Vie de Jesus, 1863) nationalism in the context of empire, and the issue of nationalism and race (“we” and Jesus = non-race, “others” and Jews = race). Finally, from the end of the century, G.A. Smith (Historical Geography of the Holy Land, 1894) presents Jesus as an image of Victorian ideals of home and masculinity in the social disturbances caused by industrialization.
.
|
“Neither Shores nor Borders": Re-imagining the Development of Ancient Scriptures through Modern Digital Text
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Eva Mroczek, University of Toronto
Textual historian Roger Chartier wrote that the electronic representation of texts “introduces a lengthy navigation in textual archipelagos that have neither shores nor borders.” This paper proposes that digital media's new metaphors and models for thinking about reading and text production can also help invigorate our understanding of the way the texts we now call “biblical” were produced and imagined in Jewish antiquity. Scholars have long argued that the concepts through which we view ancient texts – in terms of authorship, textual fixity and authority, canonical limits, and even “books” – are anachronistic, and based on notions of textuality more appropriate to the age of print than to a scribal, pre-canonical, scroll-based culture; but few alternatives have been proposed for how to imagine the way textuality might have been imagined in a world without codices, printing presses, publishing houses or intellectual property laws. Using the theme of the “canonical process” and the development of Psalms collections in the Second Temple Period as my example, I argue that insights from digital textuality can help provide the conceptual language for thinking about the fluid, interrelated, performed, and collective network of textual traditions in the context of which “the Bible” came to be.
|
Macrina and Socrates: Gregory of Nyssa's New Martyrs of the Majority
Program Unit: Violence and Representations of Violence in Antiquity
Ellen Muehlberger, University of Michigan-Ann Arbor
In the first three centuries, Christian writings that alluded to Socrates’ discourse before his death emphasized the theme of injustice: both Socrates and early Christian martyrs experienced a death suffered wrongly, but bravely, at the hands of an immoral majority. Evocations of Socrates’ death in Christian literature changed, however, after the first half of the fourth century. As Christians transitioned from being a minority liable to intermittent persecution and subject to the possibility, however distant, of martyrdom, toward being an ascendant political majority, able to experience public death primarily in their intramural conflicts, Christian texts discard evaluations of justice and turned to imitation of Socrates through form. Gregory of Nyssa’s works recounting the death of Macrina have long been seen as modeled on Socrates' death, especially given the Treatise on the Soul and the Resurrection’s formal resemblance to the Phaedo. Scholars have understood Gregory to be lending the weight of the philosopher’s mantle to his sister; I consider the alternate view, that Gregory adopted Macrina’s death as a way to lend authenticity to Socrates. In the later fourth century, simply overcoming the fear of death, as Socrates had, was not a courageous act in Christian culture; instead, withstanding bodily suffering with composure—a type well-developed in earlier Christian martyrologies—was the standard. Placing Macrina’s deathbed speech in a form reminiscent of Socrates, Gregory activated the exquisitely detailed aesthetic of female suffering to transform her, and Socrates', death. Macrina may be the first “martyr” of the post-majority Christian philosophy, but I argue Gregory’s portrayal of her points backward to authorize an even earlier figure as a martyr: Socrates himself. The paper explores Gregory’s framing of the post-majority Christian community separate from those who experienced persecution; the necessity of Macrina’s femaleness as a character; and the broader fourth-century difficulty of portraying martyrdom without martyrs.
|
Female Participation in Sacrifice and Meal: Hannah’s Story
Program Unit: Sacrifice, Cult, and Atonement
Monika Cornelia Müller, Kirchliche Hochschule Wuppertal/Bethel, Bielefeld
The Masoretic text of 1Sam 1:24 presents the only instance in the Hebrew Bible of a woman offering a bull to YHWH on her own account. This preeminent role constitutes a sharp contrast to Hannah’s rather marginalized position at the beginning of the story where she figures as but one among many participants in a sacrificial meal. In addition, the textual evidence suggests that, starting with the ancient versions, scribes and exegetes of all times have tried to downplay Hannah’s contribution. Even more, the informed reader who would expect Hannah to ask Asherah for help in fertility questions does not find the slightest hint at the cultic reverence of any other deity than YHWH. Is it too far-fetched to assume that YHWH and (His) Asherah were revered together in Shiloh, like in pre-Josianic Arad, but that the involvement of Hannah in the cultus of Asherah would have posed a severe problem to the portrayal of Samuel as the embodiment of a true prophet of YHWH in the final text? Stylistic features do not support the thesis of either a late origin or heavy deuteronomistic reworking of the story, though, and leave this observation unexplained. An adequate understanding of Hannah’s sacrifice thus calls for a multifaceted approach using legal, archeological and literary evidence as a conceptual framework for a close reading of 1Sam 1.
|
(Re-)Writing Prophecy: The Oracles Concerning Moab in Isa 15–16 and Jer 48
Program Unit: Transmission of Traditions in the Second Temple Period
Reinhard Müller, Ludwig-Maximilians Universität
The Moab oracles in Isa 15-16 and Jer 48 contain several parallel sections which provide insight into the re-arranging and editing of prophetic texts during the long process of transmission. This paper presents the textual evidence and explains the methods of editing that can be observed in both texts. The comparison shows how editors freely used older prophetic material to create a new prophetic text. This raises the general question: How did the editors perceive their own authority in relation to the transmitted texts they were working with? This paper deduces some preliminary answers from the example of the Moab oracles.
|
Raphael the Savior: Tobit, Angelic Mediation, and Early Christology
Program Unit: Function of Apocryphal and Pseudepigraphal Writings in Early Judaism and Early Christianity
Phillip B. Muñoa, Hope College
When Larry Hurtado’s book, One God, One Lord, was published in 1988, Martin Hengel observed that a new History of Religions school was forming, one that looked to Jewish literature and tradition for insight into the Jesus’ mediatorial significance. Most recently, Susan Garrett’s No Ordinary Angel (2008) has further explored a cognate interest of this “school” by setting Christology against the backdrop of angelology. In this vein, the apocryphal text of Tobit sheds light on concepts of angelic mediation that were emerging in the literature of Second Temple Judaism and provided a context for the early Christian conceptions of Jesus preserved in Gospel literature. In this familiar text, the misery of two Jewish families is overcome by the active presence of an angel in human disguise. This figure from heaven soon alleviates the suffering of two miserable Israelites and then returns to heaven. With this intriguing character, Tobit’s author has produced a provocative savior, who compliments and contrasts with angelic figures in other Jewish texts, and also shares many characteristics with Christian accounts of Jesus. While there have been a number of studies on the book of Tobit in recent years, few have explored its conception of angelic mediation in relation to early Christianity. This paper seeks to address this oversight by setting Tobit in the context of early Christology.
|
The Parallel Concentric Structures within Exodus
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Hajime Murai, Tokyo Institute of Technology
The parallel concentric structures within the Book of Exodus are revealed by applying methods of literary criticism. If Exodus is divided into 49 pericopes, the longest concentric structure consists of 24 pairs of corresponding pericopes. The central pericope within that concentric structure is “Crossing the Red Sea and the pursuers downed” (Ex14:19-31). If the text is dividing into three parts based on the pericopes of “Death of the Firstborn” (Ex12:29-36) and “The Israelites Reach Mount Sinai” (Ex19:1-9) (with these forming the first and final parts, respectively), then each of the three parts has a concentric structure consisting of 17 pericopes. The contents for the three sections are the stories relating to obtaining permission to travel, travelling from Egypt to Mount Sinai, and the events at Mount Sinai, respectively. The three parts of the text correspond to the division of the main narrative structure. Moreover, concentric structures are revealed when the text is divided into four parts. Also, such structures are observed when it is divided into seven parts. The interpretation derived from the central pericopes of those structures and the relationships of the pericope pairs does not conflict with the theological meanings of the Book of Exodus. The locations of the divisions correspond to the narrative structure of Exodus. Given this, it would seem that the parallel concentric structures are not incidental, but rather are intentional and inevitable structures that were encoded by the last editor.
|
Dead Sea Scrolls
Program Unit:
Catherine Murphy, Santa Clara University
Dead Sea Scrolls
|
Prophets, Politics, and Power: Elijah and Elisha through the Lens of Discourse Analysis
Program Unit: Social Sciences and the Interpretation of the Hebrew Scriptures
Kelly Murphy, Emory University
The stories of the prophets Elijah and Elisha focus on prophecy and power in Israelite society under the divided monarchy: namely, the intersection of the power of YHWH, the power of these two holy men, and the concerns and power (or powerlessness) of both royal and average Israelites. This paper will examine selections from the stories concerning Elijah and Elisha as found in 1 Kings 17-21 and 2 Kings 1-9, using discourse analysis in order to explore the ways language is employed to construct a “symbolic world” throughout these texts. Discourse analysis – used here as an umbrella term for such different methodologies as sociolinguistics, mental space theory, conversation analysis, frame analysis, and the like – provides a means by which the language of the biblical texts can be analyzed beyond the sentence and observed to sustain social identities. The paper will ask how the narratives about these two legendary figures express issues of power as connected to social identity via various cognitive elements such as relationships, speech, physical setting, and other social determinants. By approaching these elements through the lens of discourse analysis, the way 1 and 2 Kings uses language about prophets, politics, and power to construct a symbolic world will be demonstrated.
|
The Absence of a Prophet: 4QJudga and the Theological Significance of Textual Criticism
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
Kelly Murphy, Emory University
Scholars have long observed that the verses found in Judg 6:7-10 are an aberration from the normal cycle of apostasy, oppression, repentance, and deliverance found in the book of Judges. Here, rather than immediately sending a hero to deliver the errant Israelites after their cry for help, YHWH first sends a prophet to rebuke them. It is only after the arrival of this prophet and his formulaic reprimand invoking the Exodus tradition that the narrative introduces the newly appointed Gideon as the expected hero. The discovery of the Dead Sea Scrolls – with 4QJudga amidst them – raised the tantalizing possibility that there was an earlier literary edition of the book of Judges. In 4QJudga the aforementioned four verses are absent: the dominant recurring pattern of apostasy, oppression, repentance and deliverance follows without the interruption of the theologically laden prophetic appearance. The omission of 6:7-10 in 4QJudga provides an opportunity to reflect on the theological significance of textual criticism, a method that is often thought to be useful simply for attempting to restore the original text or for mere observations on errors and additions that crept into texts. This narrow view of the value of textual criticism detrimentally divorces the method from theological reflection. Yet Judges 6:7-10 is theological in nature, raising several questions: how does the absence of these verses in 4QJudga influence the text theologically? What does it mean if the theology of known manuscripts of the book of Judges has changed over time? This paper will explore the implications of 4QJudga, drawing connections between the theological significance of textual criticism and the very real possibility that the theology of the book of Judges has changed over time.
|
“Jesus Said to Them . . .”: Defense and Testimony in John 5:19–47
Program Unit: Speech and Talk in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Alicia Myers, Baylor University
This paper explores Jesus’ juridical speech in John 5:19-47, which is given in response to his first controversial Sabbath miracle in 5:1-18. More than simply a speech crafted to fit the specific situation that Jesus’ miracle creates, John 5:19-47 resonates with the larger themes of the Gospel and its characterization of Jesus. In this paper, I utilize rhetorical categories present in the Gospel’s milieu to analyze Jesus’ speech. There are noticeable points of connection with rhetorical conventions mentioned in handbooks, progymnasmata, and found in rhetorical practice. These similarities include: 1) prosopopoiia/ethopoiia, or the manner in which authors created believable speeches in their narratives; 2) ethos, or the orator’s construction of his/her own character, as a part of their methods of persuasion; 3) instructions concerning the use of testimony in the ancient world; and 4) and methods of refutation. There are, however, also significant points of contrast with these same categories, which serve to highlight the specific rhetorical goals of the Fourth Gospel. By employing rhetorical conventions, the evangelist makes use of common expectations regarding speech, even while he undermines them, in order to emphasize the unique character of his subject. Analyzing John 5 in light of these rhetorical practices both exposes the ways in which the evangelist makes use of his audience’s expectations, and the ways in which subverted them, in order to convince them of Jesus’ identity as the Word of God.
|
David's Sojourn in Keilah in Light of the Amarna Letters
Program Unit:
Nadav Na'aman, Tel Aviv University
The lecture examines the story of David's sojourn in Keilah (1 Samuel 23:1-13) in light of the episode of the sojourn of a band of ‘Apiru in the same city in the Amarna period. The biblical story is analyzed in the first part of the lecture, and is followed by a reconstruction of the 14th century BCE historical episode on the basis of some Amarna letters. The remarkable accord between the biblical and extra-biblical descriptions with regard to location and social conditions opens the way to a better understanding of both. The pro-Davidic character of the biblical story is evident from what the narrator includes in his story, as much as by what he left out. The extra-biblical source is the key to filling in the missing details that the narrator deliberately left out of his story
|
Inter-religious Resources in the Context of HIV/AIDS: A Case Study of Reading Genesis 34:1–31 with Zulu Indigenous Healers
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Sarojini Nadar, University of Natal
This paper is the second in a series of papers and is a result of research conducted as part of a combined research project between the Universities of Oslo and KwaZulu-Natal. The title of the project is “Broken Women, Healing Traditions? Indigenous Resources for Gender Critique and Social Transformation in the Context of HIV&AIDS in South Africa.” Although the aim of the research was to discover indigenous knowledge to assist in dealing with just power relations between men and women in South Africa in the context of HIV/AIDS, we discovered that religion in the Zulu understanding was far more fluid than the distinctions that academics make between “Christian” and “traditional” forms of knowledge. In fact, it was the group of 10 women and 10 men in rural Inanda at an African Independent Church which requested that we do bible study, as a way of opening up discussion on gender and HIV&AIDS. In this paper we will reflect on the knowledge gained and imparted during a contextual bible study on the story of the rape of Dinah in Genesis 34. We will show how the participants were able to engage and identify with the story, on a variety of levels including traditional practices such as lobola and polygamy. We will conclude with an appraisal of whether the bible can indeed be used as a resource for critiquing patriarchy in the context of HIV&AIDS.
|
Approaching Isaiah: Hugh Nibley's Use of Isaiah in Approaching Zion
Program Unit: Latter-day Saints and the Bible
Dustin M. Naegle, Brite Divinity School - Texas Christian University
Few names sound with greater honor among members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints than those of Isaiah, the Judean prophet, and Hugh W. Nibley, the Latter-day Saint scholar, author, and social critic. This paper examines Nibley’s use of Isaiah as a descriptor for both Zion and its counterpart Babylon. Volume nine of the Collected Works of Hugh Nibley, entitled Approaching Zion, contains many of his thoughts concerning education, politics, and society. While Nibley himself describes these essays as “disturbing and highly unpopular” and even “offensive,” he boldly stays his course in critiquing much of what is defined today as the “gospel of prosperity.” Nibley copiously utilizes the words of Isaiah in attempting to navigate through these controversial waters in displaying the role that monetary wealth plays in the lives of Latter-day Saints. Of the 18 essays in this volume, 13 reference Isaiah. This paper examines Nibley’s use of these scriptural passages by comparing and contrasting Nibley’s use of Isaiah with both the ancient historical background and also modern interpretations and literary and exegetical analyses of these passages. Additionally treated is Nibley’s habit of using other ancient scriptures, particularly the book of Revelation, to develop further his views of Zion and Babylon. These examples highlight the great influence that Nibley has had (and continues to have) among his readers and critics, as well as his perpetual exhortation to engage critically one’s own political and theological views.
|
Constellation of Elements in the Genesis Apocryphon
Program Unit: Qumran
Hindy Najman, University of Toronto
Genre classification has raised some significant problems in recent and past scholarship on ancient Judaism. In this paper, I will suggest an alternative model for considering the way we discuss texts and text forms. When we speak of “genre,” we focus on what Walter Benjamin might call an “idea,” which claims to provide a determining ground for understanding particulars, but which does not make use of criteria on which disputants can settle. The explanation of an idea consists not in a definition, but rather in the presentation of an exemplary particular: in our case, the Genesis Apocryphon. I suggest, in place of genre, that we consider here Benjamin’s concept of a constellation,
which is a “concept,” a universal instantiated by the particulars to which it applies in virtue of criteria that, once settled, could be put in the form of a definition. Consideration of the exemplary particulars enables us to employ the idea to illuminate other particulars. Thus my goal is not to define the concept of a genre or class of possible texts, but rather to illuminate an array of actual texts by means of an idea expressed by a constellation to be found in an exemplary particular.
|
Trade and Commerce
Program Unit:
Roger S. Nam, George Fox University
Trade and Commerce
|
Locating Paul on a Map of First Century Judaism
Program Unit:
Mark D. Nanos, Rockhurst University
*
|
Syntactic Patterns of Quantifier Float in Biblical Hebrew
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Jacobus Naude, University of the Free State
The quantifier kol may appear after the constituent with which it is associated, in which case it obligatory hosts a resumptive pronoun. The constituents are inter alia clausal subjects, direct objects of the verb, objects of subcategorized prepositions, objects of adjunct prepositions and vocatives. The paper will focus on two important syntactic features of quantifier float in Biblical Hebrew. First, it will be shown that although the floated quantifier ordinarily follows the constituent it modifies, other distributional patterns are also possible. Second, attention will be paid to the patterns of agreement between the resumptive pronoun and their referents. Although the resumptive pronoun ordinarily agrees with the constituent it resumes in person and number, there are significant and principled exceptions to this generalization, which will be described and explained.
|
Making Space for God: Performance, Call, and Transformation
Program Unit: Academy of Homiletics
Jerusha Matsen Neal, Princeton Theological Seminary
*
|
Exploring Mark’s Possible Literary Connection to the Epistles of Paul
Program Unit: Markan Literary Sources
Tom Nelligan, Dominican Biblical Institute
Mark’s literary sources have remained an enigma throughout modern biblical scholarship and Mark has, for the most part, been seen as relying on oral traditions and pre-Markan traditions about Jesus which are now lost. Some scholars, however, have noted similarities between the theology and literary style of the Gospel of Mark and the letters of Paul. This paper will seek to explore these similarities and assess their validity. From here we will be able to ask the question: What is the nature and extent of this possible relationship and did Mark have access to Paul’s letters? I will then propose that Mark’s text may have used Paul’s letters as a source and provide some specific examples. In doing this, I will take account of two basic factors: 1) Greco-Roman literary techniques and how Mark may have used these in the treatment of his sources. 2) A recent development in literary studies, namely the criteria for judging literary dependence. The ultimate aim of this paper is to show significant evidence that Mark may have had access to, and used Paul’s letters as a literary source and that the question of Mark’s sources needs to be re-assessed.
|
Creation, Dissonance, and Signification in Genesis Rabbah 1:1
Program Unit: Midrash
W. David Nelson, Independent Scholar
This paper will apply Orality and Semiotics critical theory to a reading and evaluation of Genesis Rabbah 1:1. This reading will reveal the signified meaning produced by the hermeneutical interaction among this midrashic tradition’s literary textuality, its oral/didactic employment, and its selection and methods of prooftexting. This, in turn, will shed light on the manner in which this tradition conceptualized the process of Creation anew, in order to facilitate the need and interest of early Rabbinic Judaism to incorporate an emerging reality of Jewish historical discontinuity and theological dissonance into its formative religious worldview.
|
Were You a Slave When You Were Called? Questioning Paul's Social Conservatism
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
K.B. Neutel, University of Groningen
Recent scholarship on New Testament attitudes towards slaves seems to reach a unanimous conclusion with regard to Paul: he is a social conservative who confirms the inferior position of slaves in society. This conclusion is predominantly based on what Paul does not say: he does not condemn slavery, or argue for its abolition. Rather, particularly in his metaphoric references to slaves, he accepts and confirms the social inequality associated with slavery.
While these recent studies rightly emphasise the gruesome historical reality of slavery and the physical suffering involved, they fail to place Paul’s statements in their appropriate historical context. The question of Paul’s attitude towards slavery, a largely anachronistic question, often obscures the view of Paul’s attitude towards slaves.
Although Paul indeed refers to the social reality of slavery in metaphor, he questions the existing hierarchy in those passages where he addresses the situation of slave and free as members of the communities. In these passages, Paul consistently denies the distinction between slave and free. He claims that slave and free are one in Christ, and that they form one body (Gal 3:28; 1 Cor 12:13). He reverses social roles by calling a slave a freedman and a free person a slave of Christ (1 Cor 7:22). Such statements about slave and free are not conservative, indeed they are hardly conventional. Although there are similarities with certain contemporary authors, such as Seneca or Philo of Alexandria, Paul’s attitude should be recognised as exceptional in a first century context. While Paul thus does not challenge slavery as a system or explicitly object to its degrading nature, he does offer an alternative community where slave and free interact on different terms.
|
Structure, Pattern, Rhetoric, and Meaning in the Qur’anic Text
Program Unit: Qur'an and Biblical Literature
Gordon D. Newby, Emory University
In the first part of this paper, I will briefly examine the reluctance in recent scholarship on the Qur’an to use structural and pattern analysis to elucidate the meaning of the text. In the second part, I will show how two different examples of pattern analysis can illuminate the meaning of the text and address issues of textual coherence and dissonance.
|
Startling Storm-Stilling (Mark 4:35–41): A Playful, Political, and Planetary Perspective
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Michael Willett Newheart, Howard University School of Divinity
Since this first session of Ecological Hermeneutics focuses on empire, justice, ecology and the Bible, with special attention to "mastery," Jesus' calming of the storm in Mark 4:35-41 seems to be a "natural.” The imperial implications of this passage appear when it is set alongside a passage from a generation earlier. The Jewish philosopher Philo of Alexandria wrote in his Embassy to Gaius that Caesar Augustus "calmed the torrential storms on every side." What might Mark's episode mean in light of Philo's comments? To what extent is Mark claiming imperial powers for Jesus? And to what extent did such a claim help the first-century hearers of Mark's Gospel negotiate both political power and the natural environment? And how does it help twenty-first centuries negotiate the same? In order to address these questions, I will offer a playful (i.e. full of wordplays and puns), political (i.e. focused on imperial negotiation) and planetary (i.e. ecological sensitive) perspective on this passage of Jesus tradition. In so doing, I will attempt to recover the voices of the silenced, that is, the wind and the waves. What are they saying to us as we try to shape an ecological hermeneutic for this neo-imperialistic age?
|
Covenant Rupture, Restoration, and Transformation in the Performance of 2 Corinthians and the Hodayot
Program Unit: Qumran
Judith H. Newman, University of Toronto
This essay pays particular attention to a central episode of rupture and restoration in the cultural memory of Judaism: the breaking and renewal of the Sinai covenant, narrated in one form in Exod 33-34. I will compare the way in which this crucial juncture is recalled in two early Jewish texts: 1QHa 4, 8, 12 and 2 Corinth 2:14-5:21 paying particular attention to the use of the divine attribute formula in the former and the inscribed tablets of a glorified Moses in the latter and how they may convey somewhat similar conceptions of embodiment and spirit. I will also discuss some implications for the way in which these embedded texts signal personal and communal transformation as part of their respective wholes: the 1QHa scroll and the composite letter in 2 Corinthians. We can understand both to be parts of larger performative scripts that were redacted for use in communal settings.
|
Memory and the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Carol Newsom, Emory University
This paper will consider how social memory theory can contribute to the study of the Hebrew Bible.
|
The Complicated Semantics of Evil in Biblical and Contemporary Discourse
Program Unit: Ethics and Biblical Interpretation
Carol Newsom, Emory University
Evil has become a hot topic in contemporary discourse in philosophy, theology, cultural studies, literature, social science, cognitive studies, and even neurobiology. But what do scholars mean when they talk about “evil”? Different scholars often seem to be referring to different phenomena when they use that term. An examination of the biblical discourses about evil discloses a similar ambiguity about referents for the variety of terms for evil. This paper attempts to clarify the semantics of evil in the wisdom discourse of Proverbs and to compare it with the semantics of evil in neighboring discourses (e.g., psalmic and apocalyptic discourses). The methods used include traditional semantic analysis and more recent approaches based in cognitive linguistics. The goal of the inquiry is not narrowly linguistic, however, but aims at laying the basis for a sound comparative study of the various ways in which “evil” was configured in ancient Israel and early Judaism.
|
Glimpses of Alex Haley’s Scriptural Roots
Program Unit: African-American Biblical Hermeneutics
Richard Newton, Claremont Graduate University
In modern parlance, the metonymy "scriptures" denotes worldview-orienting products of biblical proportions. However, the investigation of scriptures covers a broader set of data and a wider arc of questioning than often discussed in biblical studies.
The following paper examines the scriptural dynamics at play in Roots: An American Saga. Alex Haley's award-winning work broaches the contested role of black people in the country's history. The bicentennial novel locates blacks at the center of America's mythology and prompts readers to reimagine the country's historical reality under such terms. As the subject of literary criticism and pop- culture quips, Haley's work continues to serve as a scriptural resource for making sense of the black Atlantic experience.
Building on the methods and discoveries of the African Americans and the Bible project (1999), this paper discusses what Haley's Roots teaches biblical scholarship about the historical causes and effects of scriptures. By placing Haley’s scripture in conversation with Vincent L. Wimbush’s “Cycle of Life-in-Marronage Based upon the African America Lag,” this paper will present a paradigm for analyzing scriptures at work in past, present, and future contexts.
|
Hermeneutics of the Impossible: Reading Job through a Cameroonian Cultural Lens
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Kenneth Ngwa, Drew Theological School
The sorts of questions that the book of Job raises for Africans require serious reflection. This paper contributes to that reflection by arguing that the book of Job constitutes the sort of cultural artifact wrestling with the ambiguous role of religion in society. Given that the story transcends questions of national identity, it is perhaps the case that more than scholars of the politics of African nation states, scholars of African biblical hermeneutics need to ask how religion has played a role in constructing particular kinds of realities and images in continental Africa.
Anchoring my analysis on some religious aspects of two monumental events that took place on the African continent in 1990 and 1994, namely, the release of Mandela from prison and the Rwanda genocide, this paper will draw on a popular Cameroonian saying that “L’Impossible n’est pas Camerounais” (The Impossible is not Cameroonian), -- an expression with religious echoes— to examine the twin consciousness that characterizes post 1990-1994 African biblical hermeneutics.
To illustrate this hermeneutic, I will examine the book of Job which presents its readers with an unflattering portrayal of its presumed benevolent deity, writ large. Job’s suffering is not a random act of momentary violence but a result of sustained and well thought out deliberations by a council. The kind of suffering conjured by the book is systemic; writ large, it becomes genocidal. Yet, in the wake of his equally drawn out critique of the oppression he (and by extension, humanity) suffered from a dysfunctional theology of retribution guaranteed and contradicted from above, Job is approved by the same deity. Job and his interpreters are faced with the impossible hermeneutical challenge of interpreting this deity. In a country like Cameroon where the idea of the Impossible is not defined in terms of ethics but in terms of power—by all means necessary,— a particular sort of question arises: how is religious language and power best interpreted when they can be used to create both unimaginable (Impossible) suffering and unimaginable (Impossible) survival at the same time?
|
Personification as Pedagogy in Biblical Wisdom
Program Unit: Children in the Biblical World
Kenneth Ngwa, Drew Theological School
Significant research has been done on the use of such rhetorical strategies as logic, parallelisms (antithetic, synthetic, synonymous), numerical sayings, dialogue, repetition etc as pedagogical tools for instructing the children of Wisdom in Proverbs. What has not been adequately addressed is the use of personification as a pedagogical strategy. Very often, research on Wisdom’s personification centers around questions of historical development and the theological significance of personified Wisdom. This paper claims that the personification of Wisdom opens up new epistemological and pedagogical possibilities.
First, personification and its literary “embodiment” suggests a way of knowing not limited to instruction and memory but heavily focused on imagination; the children of Wisdom are taught not just to remember but to imagine. Second, personification allows the realities and cosmologies of the child’s world (of dualisms and of hierarchical structures) to be relevant but not overwhelming; the children of Wisdom are taught to engage.
The implications of this twofold conceptualizing are equally twofold. First, because the literary and social world inhabited by children of the Bible is generally unstable, even dangerous, personification demonstrates how characters speak to their textual realities. The different characters that populate the texts and stories become conversation partners, not necessarily role models. As the Zulus say, debate is the kernel of wisdom. And second, within the moral, legal, and ritual world of contestations that biblical children inhabit, personification highlights the ethical relationship between pedagogy and ontology; the relationship between multiple ways of creating knowledge and the multiple ways of embodying knowledge.
|
Slave of Christ and the Shaping of a Christ-like Communitarian Body
Program Unit: Paul and Politics
Valerie Nicolet-Anderson, Emory University
Paul describes himself as slave of Christ in several of his letters. This designation has often been analyzed by exegetes in particular in its relationship to the Greco-Roman world and to the manner in which it connects to ancient slavery. However, the manner in which the designation functions in Paul’s attempt to construct the identity of his addressees and of his community has been discussed more seldom.
I will look at several readings of Paul by NT exegetes that focus on the political aspect of Paul’s thought (sometimes using the designation as a starting point) and often read him with a subversive intent to regain Paul’s “revolutionary” dimension (see for example the series Paul in Critical Contexts, featuring Davina Lopez, Joseph Marchal, Neil Elliott). At the same time, I will take into account some continental philosophers (in particular Slavoj Žižek) who read Paul from a similar political and philosophical tradition and use him in a very political manner as well. Yet, both sets of readings do not engage each other very much and do not pay much attention to Paul’s construction of the self.
I will bring these political readings of Paul by exegetes and philosophers together and see how they function to refine one’s understanding of Paul, in particular when one focuses on the designation “slave of Christ” and its implication for the building of community and person. If one thinks of Paul as an “utopian” builder of community using the slave metaphor to define the body and the ethos both of the individual and of the community, then these political readings of Paul need to be and can be put into conversation in order to recapture Paul’s intention when choosing the metaphor in the first place.
|
The Importance of Seneca for Philo
Program Unit: Philo of Alexandria
Maren Niehoff, Hebrew University, Jerusalem
Seneca the philosopher lived at the same time as Philo, having spent time in his youth in Alexandria and starting in the 40s CE a public career in Rome. His works significantly shaped the Roman discourse, introducing a specific form of “orthodox” Stoicism. I shall argue that Seneca’s views were an important aspect of Philo’s intellectual environment, when he wrote his later works, especially the Exposition of the Laws. The paper will show that Philo changed his views on important subjects, moving from a more typically Alexandrian position in his earlier writings to a more Roman position close to Seneca in the Exposition.
|
Singular Readings in the Text of the 'Unknown Gospel'
Program Unit: Papyrology and Early Christian Backgrounds
Dave Nielsen, Duke University
The Egerton papyri have received much attention since their initial publication due to their relationship to the canonical gospels in connection with sensational claims of early dating. Like other issues these fragments raise, their provenance and authorship has been a disputed topic. This paper uses the methodology formulated by James Royse in evaluating singular readings in early Christian manuscripts to enter the discussion of authorship in a new way. By analyzing the vocabulary and phraseology unique to the document against Greek literature outside of the New Testament, more sure conclusions will be made regarding the community that produced the ‘unknown gospel’.
|
Singular Readings and the Community Behind the 'Unknown Gospel'
Program Unit: Jewish Christianity / Christian Judaism
Dave Nielsen, Duke University
The Egerton papyri have received much attention since their initial publication due to their relationship to the canonical gospels in connection with sensational claims of early dating. Like other issues these fragments raise, their provenance and authorship has been a disputed topic. This paper uses the methodology formulated by James Royse in evaluating singular readings in early Christian manuscripts to enter the discussion of authorship in a new way. By analyzing the vocabulary and phraseology unique to the document against Greek literature outside of the New Testament, more sure conclusions will be made regarding the community that produced the ‘unknown gospel’.
|
Signs and Signification in Ancient Philosophy and the Fourth Gospel
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Jesper Tang Nielsen, University of Copenhagen
One of the characteristics of the Fourth Gospel is its use of the concept semeion about Jesus’ miracles. These are signs that reveal his doxa (2:11). The book is indeed a collection of semeia with the purpose of evoking or confirming the pistis of the reader (20:30f). Although parts of this vocabulary have roots in the Septuagint (cf. 4:48), it also seems to have terminological and structural parallels in ancient philosophical discussions about signs and signification. The paper will introduce to these debates and read the Johannine concept of semeion on this ancient philosophical background. An important conclusion from the investigation is that the Johannine understanding of the signifying process includes three components: the sign, the signified and the effect of the sign. The incorporation of these three aspects in the Johannine understanding of semeion has important implications for the construal of the Christology in the Fourth Gospel.
|
Biblical Hebrew Influence on Syriac Poetry: Syriac Influence on Early Piyyutim
Program Unit: Syriac Literature and Interpretations of Sacred Texts
Ulrike-Rebekka Nieten, Freie Universitaet Berlin
Biblical psalms exerted great influence on the development of Syriac poetry. Evidence for this relationship can be found when one studies the area of imitation of poetic concepts e.g.: Chiasmus, poetic devices, and especially parallelismus membrorum. The parallelismus membrorum is connected with the rise of the Syriac troparia and hymns. Those were developed out of the reply to the psalm verses as a kind of a Christian interpretation. Vice versa specific elements of Syriac poetry like metre and strophic structures can be found in the early piyyutim. This paper discusses the intermediary role of Syriac in this process of development. Various examples clearly demonstrate the reciprocal reception.
|
The Literary Relationship between Deuteronomy and Joshua: A Reassessment
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Christophe Nihan, University of Lausanne
Martin Noth’s hypothesis of a “Deuteronomistic History” extending from Deuteronomy to Kings was inseparable from the abandonment of the classical theory of a pre-Priestly Hexateuch in Genesis to Joshua. Conversely, it is no coincidence if some of the most significant objections against Noth’s hypothesis in the last decade or so have been voiced by scholars promoting a revised version of a pre-Priestly Hexateuch. The following paper will address these issues by discussing some key aspects of the literary relationship between Deuteronomy and Joshua, especially Josh 23-24. On the basis of the textual evidence the discussion will seek to establish in which model the literary connections between Deuteronomy and Joshua are best accounted for: a “Deuteronomistic History”, a pre-Priestly Hexateuch, a Deuteronomy-Joshua composition (“DtrL”), or even a pre-Priestly “Enneateuch” extending to the books of Kings. Further comments will be offered as to the implications of this discussion for the relationship between “Torah” and “Prophets”.
|
Orality and Writing in the Context of the Two Ways and the Didache
Program Unit: Didache in Context
Perttu Nikander, University of Helsinki
The question of the relationship between orality and the Didache has been discussed in the recent literature. Building on this previous scholarship, this paper further discusses how oral tradition and writing intertwine in the context of the Two Ways teaching and the Didache. The problem will be approached from the theoretical framework of orality and literacy that stems from the discipline of anthropology. The discussion starts with a review of the recent studies and continues to the questions about the composition and the use of the tradition. Finally, the paper investigates why the Didache became a written text and how this process influenced the tradition.
|
"It Is Not Right for a Man Who Worships God to Repay His Neighbor Evil for Evil": Christian Ethics in Joseph and Aseneth (Chapters 22–29)
Program Unit: Ethics, Love, and the Other in Early Christianity
Rivka Nir, Open University of Israel
Chapters 22-29 in Joseph and Aseneth include a story about the unsuccessful attempt of Pharaoh's son and some of Joseph's brothers to abduct Aseneth. In this short story there is a formula, which is repeated four times: "It is not right for a man who worships God to repay his neighbor evil for evil". In my paper I will argue that this formula reveals the main issue with which this story deals – how a man should react to his enemy. The standpoint of this story is that one should not repay evil for evil but love his enemy and conquer hate with love and grace. Only God can judge evildoers for their evils. This conception is rooted in the Christian moral commandments as seen in many Christian sources (e.g. Rom. 12: 9-21; 1 Thess. 5:15;1 Pet. 3:9; Matt. 5: 43-48). Further light is shed on the meaning of this idea and its Christian background by the role of Aseneth as a "city of refuge", which is pointed out by Levi in the second story (22:13 ) and by Joseph in the first story (19.8). The depiction of Aseneth as the "city of refuge" presents her as a symbol of the church, and so the story in chapters 22-29 exemplifies the moral values on which this church is based. The Christian background to this command is stressed also through the repeated formula ‘it is not right for a man who worships God to…’ which is repeated twice in the first story - in the refusal of Joseph to kiss Aseneth (8: 5-7) and in his refusal to have sexual relations with her before their marriage (20:8). Contrary to the common opinion, I will argue that in both places Joseph exemplifies the recommended moral behavior of a faithful Christian.
|
Gender and Prophetic Agency in the Ancient Eastern Mediterranean
Program Unit: Prophetic Texts and Their Ancient Contexts
Martti Nissinen, University of Helsinki
In the patriarchal cultures of the ancient Eastern Mediterranean, societal roles were normally gender-specific. The prophetic role, however, could be assumed by women and men alike—even by people perceived as genderless. There must be features in the prophetic agency that explain the gender flexibility which makes prophecy different from the divinatory agency in general, enabling a non-gender-specific socioreligious role.
The prophetic role seems to have constituted a specific agency, an essential constituent of which was the idea of the prophets as intermediaries of divine words. The prophetic agency was probably related to the alleged divine agency in a way that diminished the significance of the human gender. This cultural theory notwithstanding, it is evident from the sources that speaking with divine voice enabled non-male people to raise their own voice as well. Prophecy, hence, appears as one of the few public, socially appreciated roles that were not inextricably linked with male gender and, therefore, could be assumed by non-males.
|
Embryonic Legal Midrash in Qumran
Program Unit: Qumran
Vered Noam, Tel Aviv University
Qumranic legal literature is not presented in a framework of a verse by verse interpretation of the Pentateuch. It lacks an interpretative rhetoric, disputes are absent and its laws are not attributed to specific, named personae. The most significant omission in the Qumranic material in comparison to Tannaitic midrash is the absence of the very fundamental infrastructure that we refer to as midrash – in other words a cited verse followed by differentiated interpretation that explicitly relates to the biblical text, and is characterized by a different lingual register and fixed, sophisticated terminology. It was this omission that prompted a number of scholars to determine that "the literary genre of the midrash halakhah does not exist in the Dead Sea Scrolls". However, the scholarly convention that the Qumran writings are totally devoid of midrashic terminology is only partially correct. The sectarian texts definitely feature a number of fixed linguistic formats that attest to an interpretative-halakhic process. This terminology is by definition hidden and subtle, but it does exist. Once we succeed in showing certain outstanding linguistic features attesting to the fixed ways of studying scriptures, we may be able to discover the existence of an embryonic "midrash", and attempt to evaluate its nature, its general tendencies, and certain strategies that characterize the terminology identified. I will try to demonstrate an example of this endeavor in my paper.
|
Did ‘Scripturalization’ Take Place in Second Temple Judaism?
Program Unit: Orality, Textuality, and the Formation of the Hebrew Bible
K.L. Noll, Brandon University
Endemic to biblical scholarship is the presumption that the documents later included in Tanak were widely disseminated among Jews in Second Temple times. Given the largely illiterate population of those centuries, it remains an open question as to how such dissemination could have taken place. Using recent research from cognitive studies and social anthropology as a model for the discussion, this paper reexamines the ancient data and argues that neither the scrolls nor the content of the scrolls had been disseminated prior to the Hellenistic era. From Ptolemaic times into the early Hasmonean period, some limited dissemination of texts began, but widespread Jewish familiarity with themes, tales, and poetry we know as ‘biblical’ emerged only gradually from Hasmonean to Roman times.
|
The New Perspective on Paul and the Academic Study of Religion
Program Unit: Paul and Politics
Brent Nongbri, Oberlin College
This paper explores connections between the so-called New Perspective on Paul and the dominant mode of studying religion in the American academy. Since the 1960s, departments of religion or religious studies in American colleges and universities have frequently been structured on a model of "World Religions" (by "structured on," I mean that the gateway introductory level class is often a "World Religions" class, and the faculty is divided by "religious tradition"), and even those departments that are not so organized have regularly encouraged the political value of religious pluralism associated with the World Religions model (a model that celebrates multiple different paths to salvation). This political ethos and academic structure dictate that the best way of carrying out the academic study of religion is to compare individual religions. I argue this outlook has decisively shaped the recent study of Paul (recall that the subtitle of E.P. Sanders’ Paul and Palestinian Judaism was A Comparison of Patterns of Religion) and hindered more complex approaches to situating Paul among other Judeans in the first century. Even scholars who have faulted Sanders for not going far enough in understanding Paul outside a Christian theological framework still seem to be locked into an ethos of religious pluralism that affirms the "paths to salvation" offered by individual religions (for example, the "two covenant" model of Gaston and Gager). I propose that consciously rejecting religious pluralism in the study of Paul will allow for a more subtle rereading of the apostle that sees him as one of many voices competing over the proper way to revere the Judean god. Thus, rather than solving the problem of Paul and Judaism, I try to show how and why "Paul and Judaism" comes to be perceived as a problem in the first place in the American academy.
|
The KJV at 400: Assessing its Genius as Bible Translation and its Literary Influence
Program Unit:
David Norton, Victoria University at Wellington
*
|
The Archaic Type of the System of Verbal Tenses in "Archaic" Biblical Poetry
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Tania Notarius, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
The analysis of verbal tenses in the corpus of poetic pieces in Pentateuch and Former Prophets reveals quite a diverse picture. Some phenomena are to be explained as discursively conditioned; others are not archaic at all. However, there are several texts that unmistakably indicate a relatively archaic type of the system of verbal tenses. The system has a well-balanced non-contradictory character. In this paper I will concentrate on indicative forms. What is the scope of the preterit *yaqtul use? How is the imperfective *yaqtulu to be identified? Why are there no traces of the modal we-qatal? What is the scope of the perfect qatal use in the narrative, report, and conversational framework? The research is based on the comprehensive approach to aspect and temporality formulated by Carlota Smith. The diachronic generalizations are measured on the three-fold scale of inner-biblical linguistic chronology, North-west Semitic setting, and the typology of grammaticalization paths.
|
Josephus, John, and the Way of the Cross
Program Unit: John, Jesus, and History
Steven R. Notley, Nyack College
During excavations of the Old City of Jerusalem, Nahman Avigad identified the remains of the
Gennath Gate under today's Cardo. Scant attention has been given to the significance of this discovery. Coupled with the recognition by Pierre Benoit and other Christian and Jewish scholars in the 1960's and 70's that Jesus was condemned by Pilate in Herod the Great's
Palace (not the Antonia Fortress as traditionally assumed), the route by which Jesus would have been led to his crucifixion (i.e. the site of the Holy Sepulchre) must necessarily be redrawn. In Josephus' description of the walls of first century Jerusalem, the historian only describes one gate on the northern approaches of the First Wall: the Gennath Gate. The etymology of the name means the Garden Gate, which suggests that the gate led to an agricultural area just outside of the northern city walls. This description echoes the Evangelist's unique detail: "Now in the place where he was crucified there was a garden, and in the garden a new tomb where no one had ever been laid" (John 19:41). The paper looks at the topography of the passion with special attention to the significance of the Gennath Gate for reconstructing the Way of the Cross and perhaps further commending the vicinity of the Holy Sepulchre for the site of Jesus' death and resurrection.
|
The Hebrew Scriptures in the Third Gospel
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
R. Steven Notley, Nyack College
.
|
Rereading the Past: Memory and Identity in Post-communist Croatia and the Genealogy of Jesus in the Gospel of Mathew
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Lidija Novakovic, Baylor University
Croatia, like other post-communist countries, experienced rapid transformation of its social and political structures. A significant part in the transition from communism to democracy played the modification of a shared, collective memory. Croatian leaders engaged in a radical evaluation of the past in order to modify the common perception of national belonging and identity. This reinterpretation of the collective heritage included storing the existing memories and substituting them with new, more appropriate, memories. As a result, a new symbolic world was created with the purpose of legitimizing the new regime and making a clear break between communist and democratic Croatian national identity. This was accomplished through a variety of means such as the rewriting of historical text-books, renaming of streets and city squares, erection of new monuments, creation of new myths, and public recognition of the victims of communism.
In this paper, I explore the genealogy of Jesus in the Gospel of Matthew from the perspective of new insights from post-communist Croatia, especially with regard to its transformation of collective memory and identity. By naming four women—Tamar, Rahab, Ruth, and Bathsheba—Matthew brings to visibility and thus to memory four obscure, even unsuitable, characters from Israel's past that decisively shape the identity of Mary and Jesus. At the same time, other, better known and generally admired, personalities that belong to their shared heritage—such as Sarah, Rebekah, and Leah—are passed over in silence and thus relegated from functional to stored memory. In addition, Israel's past is artificially divided and thus reinterpreted from the perspective of its ultimate purpose—the birth of the expected Messiah. This paper investigates these and similar methods of rereading the past employed by the author of Matthew's Gospel and their effects on the identity of Jesus and his followers.
|
Reconciling Messianic Traditions with the Careers of Historical Persons: Jesus in the New Testament, Bar Kokhba in the Talmud and Midrash
Program Unit: History and Literature of Early Rabbinic Judaism
Matthew Novenson, Princeton Theological Seminary
Lam. Rab. 2:2 §4 records the curious story that R. Akiba recognized Bar Kokhba as messiah because of the latter’s superhuman strength, namely, that he used to catch Roman ballistas and throw them back, crushing the enemy troops. As several interpreters have noted, this explanation is specious; we know of such messianic tradition in biblical or postbiblical Jewish literature. Meanwhile, it has often been noted that many of the things the New Testament authors say that the messiah had to do—especially die for sins—are similarly specious; there was no biblical or postbiblical tradition that said the messiah had to do those things, but Jesus did them, so from the authors’ perspective the messiah had to do them. In this paper, I argue that the Bar Kokhba accounts in the Talmud and Midrash are singularly illuminating in this respect. Together with some of the New Testament accounts of Jesus, they are evidence of an important literary phenomenon in ancient Judaism: the reconciling of messianic traditions with the careers of historical persons, where both the scriptural traditions and the details of the persons’ careers are made to bend in the process. Contrary to some influential accounts of “the messianic idea in Judaism,” then, it is not the case that the Jewish messiah is a literary ideal while the Christian messiah is a personality. Both Jesus and Bar Kokhba are rare ancient instances of historical persons reputed to have been messiahs about whom bodies of literature grew up to reconcile their lives with scriptural traditions.
|
A “Darke” Theology?
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Julia O'Brien, Lancaster Theological Seminary
The paper’s title alludes to Yvonne Sherwood’s comparison of prophetic poetry to that of John Donne (JSOT 27 [2002]: 47-74). While the poetry of Proverbs orders the world, she claims, that of Donne and the prophets slice and devour the eye, the ear, the flesh. This paper takes up Professor Miller’s challenge to consider the theological implications of biblical poetry by reflecting on the theological complexities of “darke” prophetic texts. What are the theological implications of this kind of poetry? What would it mean to do theology in a truly prophetic poetic mode?
|
Treacherous Waters: Jeremiah’s Confessions Revisited
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Kathleen O'Connor, Columbia Theological Seminary
Jeremiah is a multi-leveled symbolic figure in his biblical portrait: a proclaimer of the divine destruction of Judah, a sufferer at the hands of Judah, and a survivor whose many escapes from captivity augur Judah’s survival. His confessions interpret his suffering as the result of the nation’s rejection and of God’s mistreatment. Yet they conclude with a reaffirmation of trust in the divine, articulate an interpretation of national collapse under Babylon, and offer a liturgical practice for rebuilding the nation in the wake of disaster.
|
Waiting For His Promised Coming: Eschatology and Ethics in Chain-Link in 2 Peter 3
Program Unit: Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
Matthew P. O'Reilly, Jay United Methodist Church
The chain-link interlock is an ancient rhetorical transition device which, though long neglected in scholarship, has recently been identified by Bruce Longenecker. The chain-link transition involves two distinct textual units with overlapping material across the textual boundary which aims to effect a smooth rhetorical transition. This device is present in numerous New Testament texts and often affects how these texts should be interpreted and understood theologically. This paper will demonstrate that the transition in 2 Peter 3 from the argument of vv. 3:8-13 to the peroratio of vv. 14-18 is rhetorically structured by a chain-link interlock, and that this transition has been structured to link the author’s theology of the delayed parousia with the ethical and moral development of the recipients’ character of life. The argument will progress first by presenting primary source evidence for the chain-link interlock from the ancient rhetorical handbooks. It will then be demonstrated that 2 Peter 3 fits the chain-link model and that the author intends this rhetorical feature to govern the way the peroratio is understood by the recipients of the letter. The paper will conclude by offering an interpretation of the peroratio in light of chain-link structure of the text.
|
The Different Voices of Comforters: The Book of Job as a Model for Pastoral Counseling?
Program Unit: Bible and Practical Theology
Manfred Oeming, University of Heidelberg
The conflict of the comforters - the book of Job as a model for pastoral counselling
Preparing a historical critical commentary on the book of Job it became more and more probable that the ancient work was originally composed as a kind of “handbook” for pastoral care. The situation of the “patient” Job is a classical field for a presentation and discussion of different concepts of counselling. Job is not an intellectual glass bead play but a serious reflection on real psychological experiences. One can differentiate many strategies of comforting: Job himself, his wife, his four friends and God, but also the neighbours and the omniscient narrator. If one realizes that the book is part of this genre (accompaniment of traumatized dying persons) one can get guidelines or at least inspirations for a contemporary praxis. And vice versa from the insights of the modern thanatology (e.g. E. Kuebler-Ross; J.-C. Student) it’s easy to explain many putative “problems” (repetitions, contradictions, fractions) of the book as a literary work.
|
Singling Out Individuals Triggering Audience Interaction in Early Church Letter Events
Program Unit: Performance Criticism of the Bible and Other Ancient Texts
Bernhard Oestreich, Friedensau Adventist University
In several letters to early (house-)churches certain individuals are addressed and singled out for special tasks (e.g. Phil 4:2-3; Col 4:17). Other letters are mainly addressed to an individual but in some parts the author turns to all the church members whose presence is presupposed (e.g. Phlm, IgnPol). Since the reading of the letter was a social event the addressed individual receives public attention. On the other hand the whole community is hold accountable for the affairs of one of its members. What are the implications of this strategy? The paper investigates the audience reactions and social implications of such letter events.
|
“Grace and Peace” or “Come Out”? Islanders, Migration, and the New Testament
Program Unit: Islands, Islanders, and Scriptures
Margaret Aymer, Interdenominational Theological Center
Insularity and immigration are twin realities for islanders. We are bounded by the geographic reality of water; and as such have learned to create unique, bounded, insular cultures. At the same time, because of the limits—geographic and otherwise—island people tend to be migrants, (re)making cultural norms as we cross boundaries into other insular cultures. Thus, island people often take two competing world-stances: accommodation of a “new” world, perhaps even to the point of assimilation into it; and alienation from that world. In the culture of one of my home islands, Jamaica, one sees this tension reflected in the motto “Out of Many, One People” or the quip by Louise Bennett "oonoo all bawn dun a bun grun; oono all is Jamaican," on the one hand; and the presence of Maroon cultures and the Rastafarian promise that "one bright morning...Man will fly away home," on the other. A similar tension between accommodating cultural insularity, on the one hand, and creating an insular culture on the other, exists in the writings of the New Testament. Specifically, as I will argue, Paul of Tarsus and John of Patmos function as types of these two reactions: the former, accommodating the cultural insularity of a variety of Roman cities (bounded, no less, than by walls); the latter, calling for a Christian cultural insularity, a marronnage from the Roman Empire. Neither of these reactions is a perfect solution to the problems of insularity and immigration (and I will not propose such a solution). Nevertheless, they have profoundly influenced the stances (accommodationist, insular) that non-islander Christians take towards world.
|
The Ritual Reproduction of Space: Egyptian Cults and the Nile in Pompeii and Kenchreai
Program Unit: Archaeology of Religion in the Roman World
Jorunn Økland, University of Oslo
The paper takes as its points of departure: a) the notion that before the arrival of universalist religion, local deities of one region could be worshipped elsewhere through a spatial and/or ritual reproduction of their geographical matrix; and b) art historian John Clarke's observation that Roman interior decoration is more than just "decoration" in the modern sense of the word. The analysis focuses on the presence of Egyptian cults in Pompeii and the importance of Egyptian landscapes in the frescoes from the sanctuary of Isis as a part of the construction of a sacred space. In particular, the emphasis on gates, entrances, and exits in the frescoes allows them to function as windows into a different mythological landscape. As such, they represent a significant intersection between different geographical and mythological landscapes. The paper concludes with observations about the wall panels with Egyptian motifs found in Kenchreai, the port city of Corinth, in light of the frescoes from the Isis sanctuary in Pompeii.
|
A Contextual Reading of John 5:1–18 from an African Perspective
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Teresa Okure, Catholic Institute of West Africa
*
|
Jewish Followers of Jesus and the Bar Kokhba Revolt: A “Parting” or Converging of the Ways?
Program Unit: Social History of Formative Christianity and Judaism
Isaac W. Oliver, University of Michigan-Ann Arbor
Master narratives regarding the relationship between Judaism and Christianity have been built around the Bar Kokhba Revolt. If earlier scholarship tended to see a so-called “parting of the ways” between Jews and Christians after (or even before) 70 CE, subsequent scholarship has postponed the date to the Second Jewish Revolt in Palestine (c.132-135 CE). For many this event marks the defining moment for an alleged separation between Jews and Christians. As far as Jewish followers of Jesus residing in Palestine are concerned, scholarship has followed Justin Martyr by repeatedly portraying a simple one-sided “Jewish Christian” reaction to the Bar Kokhba Revolt: Jewish followers of Jesus simply could not have participated in this rebellion because of Shimon Bar Kosiba’s alleged messianic status. But in light of newer paradigms concerning Jewish-Christian relations in antiquity, it now seems legitimate to question this simplistic portrayal and to complicate this narrative by critically examining the scant and biased surviving evidence upon which later patristic and modern scholarship have built their descriptions regarding the interaction between Jewish followers of Jesus and their surrounding Jewish environment. If one analyzes the apologetic statements of Justin Martyr and Eusebius on the Bar Kokhba Revolt within their larger programmatic and rhetorical frameworks, critically assesses the archaeological remains which do not point to an apocalyptic-eschatological messianic status for Shimon Bar Kosiba, and notices how the Roman officials did not discriminate between Jewish followers of Jesus and other Jews in the aftermath of the Second Jewish Revolt, then it becomes possible to depict a more ambivalent, nuanced, and complicated picture and to even suggest the possible participation of some Jewish disciples of Jesus during the rebellion. To strengthen this thesis, the Apocalypse of Peter will be read as a document written during the Bar Kokhba Revolt which condemns the support of the rebellion among certain Jewish followers of Jesus. Modern representations of ambivalent responses of solidarity by groups who have been marginalized by their own people will be brought into consideration in order to illustrate the various ways Jewish followers of Jesus may have responded to the Bar Kokhba Revolt.
|
Is the Sabbath Only for Jews or Also for Gentiles? Jewish and Christian Appropriations of the Sabbath in the Genesis Creation Account
Program Unit: Sabbath in Text and Tradition
Isaac W. Oliver, University of Michigan-Ann Arbor
The ambiguous language of Genesis 2:1-3, which only indicates that the Sabbath was sanctified without explicitly connecting it with Israel, generated at least two main streams of interpretation within early Judaism regarding its pertinence for Jews and non-Jews. On the one hand, Jewish thinkers such as the author of the Book of Jubilees and certain rabbinic sages sought to highlight the special covenantal bond between the Sabbath and Israel. Other Jewish thinkers, however, including Aristobulus, Philo, Josephus, as well as the authors of Mark and Luke-Acts read Genesis 2:1-3 in a different light, arguing that the Sabbath was a universal gift granted for the benefit of all of humanity. The following paper seeks to explore these various interpretations by suggesting historical-social contexts which can illuminate the motivations behind amplifying or restricting Sabbath keeping. In the case of the Book of Jubilees, it seems that its author was especially preoccupied with Jews adopting a looser approach to Sabbath praxis which tended to either universalize its application or discard its observance all together. The rabbis, for their part, formulated a prohibition against Gentile observance of the Sabbath in their discussion of Noahide Laws. Although the rabbis had no means of enforcing their theoretical discussions about Noahides upon the variegated Jewish and Christian groups of their times, they implicitly reveal similar concerns about their surroundings as some of their Christian peers (e.g., John Chrysostom), who also preached in their churches against Christian observance of the Jewish Sabbath, apparently in reaction to those Jews and Christians who remained oblivious to patristic-rabbinic admonition and reification.
|
A Gospel for a New Nation: Once More, the Ethnos of Matthew 21:43
Program Unit: Matthew
Wesley Olmstead, Briercrest College
In defending the title for the monograph that presented many of the fruits of his lifetime’s research in Matthew’s Gospel, Graham Stanton wrote: “While Matthew does not use the phrase ‘a new people’, he did see Christians in his own day as a distinct entity over against Judaism. This is confirmed by the important redactional verse 21.43 and, as we shall see in several chapters below, numerous other passages. My title, ‘A Gospel for a New People’, does not correspond precisely to the evangelist’s terminology, but it does sum up his intentions” (Edinburgh: T & T Clark, 1992, 18). This conclusion has faced such serious challenges in subsequent years that it is possible to speak of a new consensus, which argues that Stanton’s reading is fundamentally anachronistic. Instead of the ethnos of 21.43 being defined over against Judaism, it is argued, for Matthew this ethnos instead refers to “a group of leaders . . . that can lead Israel well” (so, e.g., Anthony J. Saldarini, Matthew’s Christian-Jewish Community [Chicago: University of Chicago, 1994], 61.). This essay revisits this discussion and argues that, while Stanton’s conclusion should be nuanced, it more faithfully represents the position outlined in Matthew’s narrative than does the current consensus.
|
Eusebius, Porphyry, and the Testimonium Flavianum
Program Unit: Eusebius and the Construction of a Christian Culture
Ken Olson, Duke University
The Testimonium Flavianum, the passage about Jesus found in our manuscripts of Josephus’ Antiquities, is likely to be the work of Eusebius of Caesarea. The Testimonium is first attested in three of Eusebius’ surviving works and makes Josephus a witness to many of Eusebius’ apologetic themes developed in the Demonstratio Evangelica and elsewhere, and contains characteristic Eusebian language. It is part of an overall apologetic designed to answer pagan critics of Christianity and particularly Porphyry of Tyre. Porphyry had claimed that Jesus was a wise man of the Hebrews whom the Christians had mistakenly taken to be divine and misunderstood the prophecies about the Christ foretold for the Jews as applying to themselves, even though they were Gentiles. In the Demonstratio, Eusebius undertakes a massive counter-argument to show that the Christian understanding of biblical prophecy is correct. Jesus really was the Christ foretold in prophecy, his making miraculous works shows his divine nature, and the subsequent spread of Christianity would have been impossible without his resurrection appearances to his disciples. The Testimonium, long suspected to be partially or entirely a Christian interpolation backs up all of these claims in the voice of Josephus. The passage most likely originated in this context and should be ascribed to Eusebius, who played a central role in subsequent reception of Josephus’ works.
|
Defects (mumim), Holiness, and Pollution in Biblical Cultic Texts
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Saul Olyan, Brown University
This paper will explore the relationship of physical defects (mumim) to notions of pollution and profanation of holiness in biblical texts pertaining to the cult and the priesthood (e.g., Exod 22:30; Lev 21-22; Deut 15:19-23; 17:1; Malachi 1).
|
The King James New Testament: How a Translation Determined Christian Thought on Marriage and Celibacy for nearly Four Hundred Years
Program Unit:
Roger Omanson, United Bible Societies
*
|
Saved by Benefaction, Judged by Works? The Paradox of Rejecting Grace in 2 Corinthians
Program Unit: Second Corinthians: Pauline Theology in the Making
B. J. Oropeza, Azusa Pacific University
This study examines the theme of grace in relation to the conflict in 2 Corinthians, Paul’s warnings to the congregation, and the potential consequences of judgment related to the rejection of those warnings. The paradox of the Corinthians being called saints, belonging to Christ, and being saved on the one hand, and their being warned of the necessity to be reconciled with Paul or else face divine judgment on the other hand, is posed in this study. After a brief survey of scholarly interpretations of the tension between justification and judgment in Paul’s perspective, it is suggested that a key to this tension may be found in his warning that the Corinthians must not receive the grace of God in vain (2 Cor. 5:20–6:2). The concept of grace is viewed in light of ancient Mediterranean perceptions of benefaction (e.g., Seneca, Inscriptions, the LXX) to suggest that ????? may have been perceived by Paul and the Corinthians as a gift bestowed by God as their divine benefactor. Favor was expected to be reciprocated with tangible forms of gratitude, and the possibility of rejecting such a gift would be tantamount to apostasy.
|
From Monarchy to Citizen-State: The Copernican Turn in Ancient Judean Political Theory
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible and Political Theory
Wolfgang Oswald, University of Tubingen
Ancient Near Eastern political theory almost exclusively was royal ideology, all reasoning about stately conduct is focused on the king’s role and duties, while the role and the rights of the people are not even mentioned. As egyptologist Jan Assmann puts it: “In the political theory of Egypt the notion ‘people’ is not provided,” and the same is true for any ancient oriental society. Hammurapi of Babylon executes justice and righteousness for his people but not in cooperation with or on behalf of them.
This is totally different in the Pentateuch. These texts constitute a society without a king, instead there is a codified law (or better: a constitution), which to observe the people decide. Neither God nor Moses act as sovereign, who impose the laws on the people. At the mountain of God as well as in the plains of Moab it is the people’s office to enact the law. In Exod. 24:3 they pass a consensual resolution, in Deut. 26:17 Moses recites the people’s declaration to entry into the covenant.
From the viewpoint of political theory Israel as depicted in Exod. 18–24 and in the book of Deuteronomy is a constitutional citizen-state of the Greek polis type. The probable “Sitz im Leben” of these compositions is the reorganization of the Judean society after 587 BCE. This paper aims to profile the political concepts underlying the Pentateuchal lawgiving narratives, thereby further developing the assumptions introduced in my book “Staatstheorie im Alten Israel” (Kohlhammer: Stuttgart 2009).
|
Laying Ahiram to Rest: A New Reading of the Ahiram Sarcophagus Inscription
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Charles J. Otte III, University of Chicago
The brevity of the Ahiram sarcophagus inscription (KAI 1) belies its importance. This importance is due both to the proposed dates for the inscription and to the lingering epigraphic and philological problems associated with it. The earliest commentators, including Dussaud (1924), Torrey (1925), Ronzevalle (1927), and Vincent (1925), agreed on the epigraphic reading on most points. However, even as a near consensus has emerged over the date of the inscription, several epigraphic and philological problems have persisted. These problems have been complicated by the quality of the published photographs. The most significant of these is the understanding of the final two words of the inscription. Teixidor (1987) has proposed reading the final two words of the inscription as LPN GBL. Crucially, this is not an emmendation but a claim about what is actually inscribed. The latest edition of KAI also follows this reading. New high resolution photographs of the inscription available from the West Semitic Research Project's Inscriptifact database enable a new examination of these issues. However, no epigraphic study of the inscription has been published based on these photographs. This paper argues three epigraphic points on the basis of these photographs. First, I argue that the photographs provide epigraphic evidence to support the reading [']TB`L for the name of Ahiram's son. Second, I reject Ronzevalle's reading KŠTR in favor of KŠTH in the first line. Third, I argue that the final three words of the inscription are SPRH LPP ŠBL over against Teixidor's re-reading. In addition to the epigraphic work, I evaluate the philological suggestions concerning this reading. I conclude that the epigraphic reading can now be considered certain, but the meaning of the end of the inscription remains enigmatic.
|
The Mountain of the Sermon on the Mount
Program Unit: Matthew
Eric Ottenheijm, University of Utrecht
Since W.D. Davies, The Setting of the Sermon on the Mount, Cambridge 1964 much attention has been paid to Jesus as the new Moses in Matthew. In The New Moses: A Matthean Typology, Edinburgh 1993, Dale C. Allison reinforced this reading. He analyses relevant passages on the basis of possible intertextual references. The mountain of the Sermon on the Mount (Matt. 5:1) represents, in his view, a re-enactment of Sinai. There are some serious problems, however, with this analysis, both with regard to the narrative move in Matthew 5:1, the programmatic verses Matt. 5:17-19 and the intertextual evidence adduced. A more plausible reading will be defended in view of the interpretation of Isaiah in early Judaism. Its impact on both the narrative structure and the Christology of Matthew should be taken into consideration. In my paper I will focus on the figure of an eschatological prophet/Lawteacher in Isaiah, who has to climb the mountain (Is 40:9-11) in order to proclaim the Kingship of the Lord (compare Is. 52:7). It will be shown, that this intertextual reference finds support in the interpretation of Isaiah in early and Rabbinic Judaism (Enoch, Jubilees, 4 Q521, 11QM, Targum on Isaiah, Pesikta Rabbati 35, Midr.Ps. 146). Matthew presents Jesus as the messianic teacher as envisioned by Isaiah, indeed, as a ‘prophet like Moses’ (see Deut 18 and Bernard Jackson, Essays on Halakhah in the New Testament, Leiden 2008) but not as a new Moses. In this respect, Matthew’s Jesus shares a feature with the biblical Elia, who also re-enacts some Mosaic topics. Unlike Moses, however, Matthew’s Jesus is also a teacher of the nations (Matt. 28:19), a feature that accords with the role of the messianic teacher in Isaiah. Finally, some structural features in Matt. 4:23-8:4 can be explained for as well.
|
One Scripture, One God: Addai’s Proclamation of Christ at Edessa
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Aaron Overby, Saint Louis University
The Doctrine of Addai is a difficult text, much argued over among scholars. It offers an account of the beginnings of Christianity in the city of Edessa, an important center of Syriac Christianity. Scholarship on the Doctrine of Addai has focused on important questions pertaining to the historicity of the account and the politics behind its compilation. Yet it has left almost untouched other parts of the text, including a passage that purports to be a sermon the apostle Addai preached to the people of Edessa. This paper offers a close examination of this address. Specifically, it concentrates on Addai's main argument in that passage and how Addai uses Scripture to support his claims.
This paper proposes that in his first “Address to the People of Edessa” Addai brings together the Hebrew and Christian Scriptures as presenting two sides of the same argument, namely, that there is only one God who should be worshiped, and that this God became incarnate in the person of Jesus Christ for the salvation of humanity. First, the paper provides a summary of the sermon itself and identifies as a central concern the issue of idolatry. Then it analyzes the specific references the sermon makes to the Hebrew Scriptures and their use, as well as to the proclamation of Christ. This paper demonstrates how in this sermon, Addai sees these Scriptures as two parts of one whole that together teach true worship of one God in trinity, Jesus Christ together with his Father and the Holy Spirit. From this analysis this sermon emerges as a witness to Christian ideas about Scripture, idolatry, and true worship in the early Syriac-speaking Church.
|
Symbols as Agents in the Homilies of Jacob of Serug
Program Unit: Syriac Literature and Interpretations of Sacred Texts
Aaron Overby, Saint Louis University
The fifth-sixth-century writer and theologian Jacob of Serug received his training as a student at the exegetical school of Edessa. In his work he set down his thoughts on Scripture and on the feasts of the church in poetry, primarily in verse-homilies, the memre so distinctive of Syriac literature. Although he lived at a time of intense theological debate among Christians and served as a bishop, he chose to say little directly about questions of dogma but instead poured his understanding of the meaning of the Scriptures and the teachings of the church into his homilies. This paper focuses on Jacob’s exegesis and the hermeneutics he employed in his works.
Specifically, this paper studies how Jacob used types and symbols and what part these played in his preaching. It shows how Jacob’s dynamic view of symbols included a sense of historical agency where the symbols themselves become agents in the Biblical stories, acting to make manifest various aspects of Jesus' life and teachings. Although this idea of historical agency has been noted in passing in other scholarship, little has been said about it specifically. In order to highlight and work out the relevance of this aspect of Jacob’s exegesis, this paper will first review the concept of symbols as they are used in the Syriac tradition. It will then show how symbols appear as actors or agents in a selection of Jacob’s memre. The careful study of this aspect of Jacob's hermeneutics reveals its centrality to Jacob’s exegesis and facilitates a more nuanced study and appreciation of his work as a whole.
|
The New Fragments of the Gospel of Judas: Importance and Significance (Their Significance for Our Understanding of the Text as a Whole, and of the Figure of Judas)
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Louis Painchaud, Laval University
A preliminary transcription of digital photographs of the new fragments of the Gospel of Judas has been available on Gregor Wurst’s webpage since Nov. 2009, along with an English translation by Marvin Meyer. These fragments – especially the ones from pp. 41 and 42, but also those from pp. 55.1-18 / 56.1-18 and 57,1-10 / 58.1-10 - provide important new material that is extremely significant. Speaking generally, this material advances our understanding of the text as a whole and its use of Scriptures, both Old and New Testament; more specifically, it also provides new evidence for the interpretation of the crucifixion that is found in the text, and it allows us to resolve the much-debated issue as to the identity (Jesus or Judas) of the person who enters the luminous cloud at the end of the gospel (57.21-23). This paper will present a general overview of the new material and a preliminary assessment of its importance and significance.
|
Redaction History in Deuteronomy and 1–2 Kings
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Juha Pakkala, University of Helsinki
The redaction histories of Deuteronomy and 1-2Kings are in many ways similar. Both compositions contain successive redactional layers with very similar themes and motifs.
One of the main themes of the basic text in both compositions is the location of the cult. They were also later edited by several successive redactors who regarded the other gods and foreign cults to be the main sin again Yahweh. That the main way to serve Yahweh is to keep the law is a central theme of several successive editors in both Deuteronomy and 1-2Kings.
A shared redaction history implies that these works were edited parallel to each other possibly by the same scribal circles over a long period. The closer connection between them is highlighted by the dissimilar redaction history in other parts of the Pentateuch or other books of the so called Deuteronomistic history. For example, the centralization of the cult is not a theme in Joshua, Judges and 1-2Samuel. Similarly, the attack on other gods and foreign cults, a central motif in Deuteronomy and 1-2Kgs, is met in only isolated passages in these books. This implies that the same scribes who edited Deuteronomy and 1-2Kgs may not have been active in these books. Although a conclusive solution to the phenomenon cannot be offered in this paper, some preliminary consequences and possible solutions will be discussed and suggested.
|
Positioning the Future on the Tense-Modality Spectrum
Program Unit: Biblical Greek Language and Linguistics
Francis G. H. Pang, McMaster Divinity College
Specialized treatments on the Koine Future tense-form are scarce. The last substantial investigation on the topic, dated back to the beginning of the last century, was written in a strictly philological context without considering the advances of modern linguistics. The diachronic development of the tense-form has a direct bearing on the understanding of how it functions in the verbal system in terms of the Tense-Modality-Aspect (TMA) categories. The controversy that has surrounded the notion of futurity in philosophical discussion as well as general linguistic theory has fettered the studies of the function of the Koine Future. Several studies on the verbal aspect of the New Testament Greek downplay the significance of the diachronic development of the Future form and treat it in temporal category alone. Advances have been made in language typology, philosophical discussion and general linguistic theories in the past decades which greatly improve our understanding of the development of the Future. However, these treatments have yet to make their way into the study of the Koine Future. This study is an attempt to lay the ground work for a thorough and linguistically informed study of the Future. It provides an up-to-date discussion of the question regarding the diachronic development of the function of the tense-form in the Koine period, and particularly focuses on tense and modality. Advances from language typology and modern linguistics are reviewed and used in the discussion of the function of the Koine Future. It is argued that in a tense-modality spectrum, the Future is closer to the modality category than what many aspect theorists assumed.
|
The Shephelah Lamashtu Fragment, Inside Out
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Jacqueline Papour, University of Chicago
Based on photographs of the editio princeps (Cogan, 1995), this paper proposes a new reading and translation of the Neo-Assyrian cuneiform inscription found on the obverse of the Shephelah amulet fragment. The reverse of the fragment preserves iconography whose closest parallel was identified by Cogan as that of the Mesopotamian demon lamaštu, whose child-snatching activities are assumed by the later Jewish Lilith. Beyond presenting this new reading and translation, this paper explores the connection between this find – evidence on the ground of Assyrian cultural awareness in Judah – and the imagery and language of Isaiah 1-39 in general and 34:1-17 in particular. Recently Machinist (2006) has demonstrated an intentional reversal of power in the political rhetoric of Isaiah as compared to that of the Assyrian inscriptional tradition. In Isaiah 34:1-17, Edom takes the place of Assyria and Babylonia as the personified evil empire, but in the “fundamental inversion” of political rhetoric in Isaiah it is Edom that becomes the ravaged wasteland, and Judah, in the following section, that will bloom (Blenkinsopp, 2000). It is in this imagery of the evil empire turned wasteland at the hand of Yahweh that we find the singular attestation of Lilith in the Hebrew Bible. Within the Shephelah amulet itself, we are presented with an unparalleled fragmentary inscription and non-canonical iconography that clearly demonstrates knowledge of (and variation on) Neo-Assyrian magical genres. Can a better grasp on Assyrian cultural influences on Judah improve our understanding of the language and imagery of Isaiah 34:1-17?
|
The Encounter between the Israelite Girl in 2 Kings 5 and Baridegi in a Korean Myth
Program Unit: Asian and Asian-American Hermeneutics
Hye Kyung Park, Claremont Graduate University
Naaman is an example of extreme transformation for the sake of representing the Lordship of Israel’s God over the world. However, the attention of the main character of the Naaman narrative needs to move from Naaman to the Israelite girl, who recognizes the problem of the narrative and recommends Elisha to heal Naaman’s leprosy. The Israelite girl initiated Naaman's healing process with her braveness and her
words. She was the leader of the narrative, although she was a marginalized woman in a foreign nation. She knew how to survive in the midst of disaster and to deal with the
influence of a foreign nation. For Asian and Asian American Hermeneutics, the Israelite girl can be related to
Baridegi (????), who was the princess in a Korean myth. When she was born as the seventh daughter of King Okui (??) in Bulla (??) nation, she was abandoned by her father. The reason for her father’s action was because Baridegi was not a boy. Yet, Baridegi traveled in a foreign country to search for a divine medicine for her father. Later, a deity made her a goddess, since she accomplished her mission for her father by reviving him from the dead. To compare the two, the Israelite girl functions as a mediator between Naaman and Elisha to heal Naaman’s leprosy in Aram. Likewise, Baridegi plays a pioneer to cure her father in a foreign nation. One of Asian American contexts recalls either mediators or pioneers to interpret religious settings in the American multi-culture society. Both narratives of the Israelite girl and Baridegi are appreciated by Asian and Asian American communities, since these girls show them their braveness and wisdom in their diverse situations.
|
The Sequence of the Narrative of Naboth's Vineyard in the MT and in the LXX
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Historical Books
Hye Kyung Park, Claremont Graduate University
Across history there have been multiple traditions of the Bible, each of which has a different sequence of events that depends on the intention of the editors. The narrative of Naboth’s vineyard in the MT is in 1 Kings 21 and the LXX is in 3 Kings 20. This paper focuses on the role of the narrative of Naboth’s vineyard in the macro structure of 1 Kings 20-22. In order to analyze the role of the story in the MT, it is necessary to compare it with the sequences of the story in the LXX. From the comparison of the two texts, I will show that the MT follows a story-centered sequence to focus on Ahab’s sin, while the LXX has a story-developed sequence to emphasize Jezebel’s wickedness.
Sequential differences between the MT and the LXX emphasize Naboth’s vineyard as a separate narrative from the traditional collection, demonstrating the important role of the narrative, because the editors must have carefully considered the placement of the narrative. If the narrative were not important, the editors would not have pondered over the sequences. Moreover, there are also some different expressions about the main characters in the MT and the LXX. The MT considers the wickedness of Ahab by ascribing to Ahab different words than the LXX does. For the LXX, the nearness of the stories between Jezebel and Elijah helps us to recognize the significant role of Jezebel through chapters 19-20. The MT regards the narrative of Naboth’s vineyard as an independent story, while the LXX includes it in the process of the narrative between chapters 19 and 20 of the LXX.
|
Editing the Gospel of John: Challenges and Achievements
Program Unit: Novum Testamentum Graecum: Editio Critica Maior
David Parker, University of Birmingham
The IGNTP edition of John for the Editio critica maior is approaching a key phase. The editors are making a trial run by producing a preliminary edition of Chapter 18. The paper will describe the practical an dintellectual challenges involved, and the edition's significance.
|
The Levant Comes of Age: The Ninth Century through Script Traditions
Program Unit: Paleographical Studies in the Ancient Near East
Heather Dana Davis Parker, Johns Hopkins University
The prevailing assumption is that a diverse and widely generalized use of alphabetic writing in the early Syro-Canaanite region was replaced, no later than the ninth century BCE, by distinctive national scripts. Because these scripts emerged in the regions where national polities began to arise in the tenth-ninth centuries, they have been associated with state formation and political control. While the epigraphic data do demonstrate that there is a tendency for certain scripts to take on distinctive characteristics in this period, it might be that the initial emergence of these script features was more a phenomenon of geographic location than of polity formation. It was as regions became more isolated due to increased political division and the formation of distinct polities that regional scripts became more refined and took on arguable “national” standardization.
|
1 John 1:5–10 from a Cognitive Linguistic Perspective
Program Unit: Cognitive Linguistics in Biblical Interpretation
David Parris, Fuller Theological Seminary
The goal of this paper is to examine the five conditional statements in 1 John 1:5-10 from a Cognitive Linguistics perspective. Traditionally the conditional clauses contained in this passage have been interpreted according to a grammatical model that is based on a combination of the particular Greek conditional conjunction employed and the mood of the verb (indicative or subjunctive). I hope to demonstrate in this paper that Cognitive Linguistics provides us with hermeneutical resources that enable us to not only understand this passage more fully but grasp the performative force of what John was arguing in these sentences. This will involve a consideration of how these conditional ‘if’ sentences frame the manner by which the reader constructs the possible, and alternate, mental spaces that John utilized to present his argument. In doing so John appeals to the network of beliefs that his audience possesses in order to demonstrate the performative implications of what they say or believe. In order to accomplish this, the author carefully employed present, aorist, and perfect tense verbs to shape how the reader cognitively construes either a positive or negative epistemic space based on the protasis. The combined contributions from Cognitive Linguistic’s perspectives on verbal aspect and mental spaces allow us to understand the illocutionary and perlocutionary force of these sentences in a manner that traditional exegetical approaches have not fully appreciated.
|
The Shape of Primitive Gnosticism
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Douglas M. Parrott, University of California-Riverside
The shape of primitive Gnosticism has been unclear in large part because of the widely recognized lack of historical interest among the authors and composers of surviving documents, making it hard distinguish what is early from what is late. The Apocalypse of Adam, however, appears to be an exception to that. The earliest part of it now seems likely to have been composed in the area of ancient Palestine shortly after the initial success of the Maccabean rebellion against the Seleucid Empire in 164 B.C.E. It reflects an ideology that would have developed during a time of much ferment, when Jews and their religion were being seriously challenged by Greek ideas and customs brought to Palestine in the wake of the conquests of Alexander the Great. That ideology appears to have had two things at its core; 1) belief in the essential reliability of Torah as an account of the early events relating to the creation and early history of humans, although the “spin” given to those events differs greatly from that in Torah itself; and 2) acceptance of Platonic beliefs about the reality and nature of the human soul, as well as the nature of the invisible world beyond. In addition, the tractate shows that the early Gnostics believed they belonged to a different race from the three post-deluge races identified in Genesis (the progeny of Ham and Japheth [together, the Gentiles] and Shem [the Jews]). Theirs was the race of Seth, whose souls had a different and higher source than those of the other races, and, because of that, they believed they would continue to be protected by higher powers in times of trial and persecution.
|
Syntactic Aramaisms as a Tool for Internal Biblical Chronology
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Na'ama Pat-El, University of Texas at Austin
The influence of Aramaic on Biblical Hebrew is well known and needs no introduction. The focus so far has mostly been lexical: lexical replacement, loan words or calques, and many of which have already been identified (Wagner 1966, Hurvitz 2003). However, several scholars have expressed doubts regarding the validity of Aramaisms as indicators of textual dating (Young, I., R. Rezetko, et al. 2008) or pointed that there may be other explanations to the existence of Aramaic lexemes in the Biblical text (Rendsburg 2002, 2003). While lexical interference is very common cross-linguistically, syntax requires more extensive contact and is normally found only after some borrowed lexemes have already been naturalized. The influence of Aramaic on the Syntax of Biblical Hebrew has not been seriously investigated so far. In this talk I will argue that syntax is less easily transferable compared to lexemes and therefore is more reliable for internal dating. Furthermore, syntactic Aramaic dialectal variation can serve as a solid benchmark for dating; such variations are extra biblical evidence the dating of which is far less controversial. Moreover, while certain Aramaic lexical items in the Hebrew Bible may be an inheritance from a common ancestor, the syntactic patterns discussed in this study are not. A number of cases where assumed late biblical texts show Aramaic syntactic patterns attested later than the Babylonian exile will serve as examples. On the basis of material collected from official and middle Aramaic dialects, it will be suggested that when a Hebrew text shows innovative syntactic features otherwise attested only in Official Aramaic or later it must be considered a late text. Finally it will be argued that while lexical transference is on occasion ambiguous, syntax, though harder to detect, is a far more reliable tool for internal dating.
|
What’s Religion Got to Do with It?
Program Unit: Service-Learning and Biblical Studies
Bobbi Patterson, Emory University
Service-learning offers not only new content for our courses but may also open up new pedagogical and performative spaces within our classrooms. In dialogue with her experience with theory-practice learning partnerships between Emory College and the organizations in the city of Atlanta, Patterson will explore how the practices of local communities may inform our teaching practices.
|
Mark's Use of Matthew and Luke: Some Post-Oxford Considerations
Program Unit: Markan Literary Sources
David B. Peabody, Nebraska Wesleyan University
The latest major conference on the Synoptic Problem was held at Lincoln College, Oxford University, 7-10 April 2008. Published proceedings are currently anticipated from Peeters in 2010. Toward the end of that conference, some of the 40 specialists gathered there, even several who defend differing synoptic source theories, agreed that the state of some of the evidence used to argue for one or another solution of the Synoptic Problem, such as critical texts of the Greek New Testament and synopses of Mt/Mk/Lk, appeared to be less objective and more fluid following that conference than such displays of relevant evidence might have been thought to be prior to it.
This paper will demonstrate how and why these insights seem valid and how increased awareness and acceptance of these insights may affect future arguments made in debates over the sources of Mark. Here we will re-examine (1) the phenomenon of alternating order of pericopae between Mark and Matthew, on the one hand, and Mark and Luke, on the other, (2) the phenomenon of alternating agreements in wording within some, but certainly not all, Markan pericopae, likewise between Mark and Matthew, on the one hand, and Mark and Luke, on the other, and (3) the nature of the unique and some of the distinctive material in Mark's gospel (called "The Markan Overlay" by advocates of the Two Gospel Hypothesis). How these new views of the evidence have import, not only for advocates of the Two Gospel hypothesis, but also for advocates of Two Document Hypothesis will conclude the paper.
|
Gendered Nature and Priestly Ideals: An Analysis of the Primal Couple’s “Fall” in the Book of Jubilees
Program Unit: Bible, Myth, and Myth Theory
Angela Pearson, University of North Carolina at Charlotte
In his magisterial Theorizing Myth, Bruce Lincoln defines myth as the expression of ideology in narrative form. A myth articulates certain concepts and ideals that the author holds important. They are presented as “authoritative” and “natural,” as opposed to “contingent” and “cultural.” Chapter three of the Book of Jubilees and chapter three of the biblical Book of Genesis both narrate the “fall” of Adam and Eve and their expulsion from the Garden. These two narratives share a concern with the binary categories nature/culture and certain subcategories, such as man, woman, clothing, nakedness, honor, and shame. However, the value/status assigned to the categories appears to differ in each narrative. After identifying and analyzing these differences, this paper will argue that Jubilees expresses certain ideological claims (à la Lincoln) in its Eden myth about certain social institutions, such as priesthood and gender roles, thereby grounding these offices or responsibilities in its claims about the way the world is constructed.
|
Paul the Gentile? The Social Identity of Paul in Philippians 3
Program Unit: Social Scientific Criticism of the New Testament
Nina Pehkonen, University of Helsinki
Philippians 3 contains some of Paul’s most belligerent language against his Jewish Christian opponents. Paul calls them “dogs” and “evil workers”, and suggests their much valued circumcision is nothing but “mutilation”. In the same context Paul also launches into an extreme evaluation of his own Jewish past and Jewish identity markers in general. The aim of this presentation is to elucidate why Paul specifically in Philippians 3 offers such a negative assessment of his Jewish identity. Paul’s motivations will be explicated in terms of the concept of social identity. It will be proposed that Paul portrays himself in the passage as sharing the social identification of his Gentile addressees. There are two major motives for this. Firstly, by adopting the identity of the Philippian Gentile Christians Paul enhances the positive self-esteem of this group. He raises the purportedly inferior group to a superior position by depicting himself as actively and consciously choosing to be like the Philippians rather than like the opponents who value Jewish identity markers. This move intends to dissolve any need by the Philippians to join the ranks of the opponents. Secondly, Paul is driven by a need to secure his authority in the Philippian church in a time of crisis, which was brought on by his breach with the more authoritative Jerusalem church. In order to achieve this, he portrays himself as a prototypical leader, who, by definition, optimally epitomizes the social category of which he is a member.
|
Animals and Economics in the Book of Job
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Abigail Pelham, University of Glasgow
Questions related to economics are central to the Book of Job. Its story is set in motion when hassatan asks about the economic agreement made between God and Job: “Does Job fear God for nothing? Have you not put a fence around him and all that he has, on every side? You have blessed the work of his hands, and his possessions have increased in the land” (1:9-10). Whereas hassatan suggests that any such arrangement would be illicit, in the poetic section Job takes the opposite position, basing his complaint on the assumption that to be appropriately recompensed for one’s services is not only lawful but essential to the correct functioning of the world. When, in chapter 30, Job gives his account of the absolute breakdown of the world-as-it-ought-to-be, he focuses on the lack of deference shown him by a group of outcasts, the essential characteristic of which is its members’ refusal to participate in the economic agreements which sustain the human community. It is for this reason that Job classes them as wild animals. When God answers Job, his focus on wild animals can be seen as a direct response to Job’s chapter 30 claims about the animalistic group. Praising the wild animals for their refusal to participate in human economic arrangements, God answers the accusations about his economic involvement with the world brought by both Job and hassatan.
|
The Influence of the KJV in Chinese Bible Translation Work
Program Unit:
Kuo-Wei Peng, Nida Institute at ABS
*
|
The History of Caesarean Present: Eusebius and Origen Narratives
Program Unit: Eusebius and the Construction of a Christian Culture
Elizabeth Penland, Yale University
In the Ecclesiastical History, Eusebius portrays Origen as the
intellectual forbear and all-but teacher of his own teacher,
Pamphilus. This paper will examine the legacy of Origen as a pivotal
figure in the Caesarean inheritance of the Alexandrian tradition. It
will propose that the Christian philosophical school context of the
fourth century frames Eusebius's narrative of Christian philosophical
succession in the first through third centuries. As such, the stories
of Origen should be read as foundational myths and intellectual
narratives of origin for the school around Pamphilus and Eusebius.
|
Josephus on Daily Prayer
Program Unit: Josephus
Jeremy Penner, McMaster University
In this paper, I will challenge the commonly held view that Josephus includes a reference to the daily Shema liturgy, i.e. Deut 6:4-9 plus blessings, in his retelling of Moses’ farewell address (Ant. 4.212). I will argue that, instead of the Shema, Josephus refers to a tradition that developed in the Second Temple period that promotes a more general daily prayer practice of giving thanks in response to “the gifts that He [i.e. God] granted them when they were delivered from the land of the Egyptians” (cf. Wis 16:27-8). This reason for daily thanksgiving is demonstrated earlier in Josephus’ retelling of the Exodus, where he highlights Moses as the exemplar of daily thanksgiving; Moses gives thanks for quail in the evening and manna in the morning as a response to divine favour towards Israel. This, and the fact that Josephus describes daily prayer as euchristia (thanksgiving) and not eulogia (blessing), challenges the argument Josephus’ reference to daily prayer must be of the Shema. Some of the implications of this argument for the study of prayer in Second Temple period Judaism will be explored in the conclusion.
|
Contemporizing Interpretation in Greek Isaiah: Real or Imagined?
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Ken M. Penner, St. Francis Xavier University
Although the Greek translation of Isaiah differs considerably from the Masoretic Text, the reason for these differences has been hotly contested. Those who first studied these differences in Isaiah over a century ago (Scholz, Ottley, and Swete) noted that major differences between the Greek and Hebrew were very few, but minor discrepancies abounded. They therefore concluded that the Hebrew text from which the translator worked was very similar to our Masoretic Text, but they questioned the competence of the translator to render that text carefully. However, within the last century a new explanation for the differences has become dominant. Seeligmann, followed by das Neves, Hanhart, Koenig, and van der Kooij, argued that the translator found the fulfillment of Isaiah's "prophecies" in his own time. Recent proponents of this explanation claimed that many of the differences are intentional, a result of a method called variously "fulfillment interpretation," "actualization," or "contemporizing." Most recently, Ron Troxel has argued that the differences are not the result of a contemporizing "method," but the translator wanted the translation to convey the sense of the original oracles.
This paper argues that the significant differences between the Greek and the Masoretic Text are mainly the result, not of a contemporizing method, but rather of the translator's incompetence or carelessness. I will do so by first demonstrating that most of the differences are not readily explained by a contemporizing method, secondly by showing that the differences are explainable as either mistakes or updating with no change of referent, and thirdly by arguing that the mistakes are better attributed to the translator than to the copyist of the Vorlage.
|
Birthing Narratives: Critically Appraising Pedagogies of Christian Origins?
Program Unit: Construction of Christian Identities
Todd Penner, Austin College
Modern methods in the study of Early Christianity have functioned to produce a kind of fictional past that has much more to do with our own mapping of contemporary historical and social contexts onto the past than necessarily ‘accurately’ reflecting a historical reconstruction of Christian origins itself. In essence, then, this work tackles the genre of the ‘critical’ introduction to early Christian literature, pointing out the problems inherent with the conventional conceptual categories that these introductions have presented for students and scholars of early Christianity.
|
The Restoration of the Middle Voice: Test Driving the Theory in Some Key Texts
Program Unit: Biblical Greek Language and Linguistics
Jonathan Pennington, Southern Seminary
TBD
|
Apocryphal Women in the Dura Europos Baptistery
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Michael Peppard, Fordham University
The paintings preserved in the Dura Europos baptistery have often been interpreted through supposed correspondences with biblical texts. However, the analysis of this art often fails to appreciate the instability of Christian textual forms in the third century, not to mention the popularity in Syria of the Diatessaron and (what would later be called) apocryphal texts. My paper argues that two of the images from the baptistery can be fruitfully re-interpreted in dialogue with Christian apocrypha. First, the woman bent over a well is not marked specifically as the Samaritan Woman from the Gospel of John. There are women at wells all over the biblical landscape, an intertextual play already enacted by the Gospel of John itself. But more importantly, the Protoevangelium of James narrates a tradition of the Annunciation to Mary at a well. This interpretation of the painting is in line with liturgical traditions that were prominent in Eastern Christianity, while also being corroborated by later Syrian iconographic evidence. Second, my paper offers a more convincing and generative interpretation of the procession of women on the main panel of the artistic program. Though often interpreted as the women going to anoint Jesus’ body in the tomb, a minority interpretation has seen this painting as a procession of virgins to a wedding. Such a reading resonates with several Christian apocrypha that promote ideologies and perhaps ritual enactments of spiritual marriage in a bridal chamber. The Acts of Thomas and the Gospel of Philip, both of which are usually given Syrian provenance, champion the practice of spiritual marriage. Drawing on gender and ritual studies, my interpretation of the artistic procession suggests that the event occurring in this baptistery would have found textual support in these apocryphal texts.
|
From Tomb to Chuppah: Re-imagining Texts in the Dura Europos Baptistery
Program Unit: Archaeology of Religion in the Roman World
Michael Peppard, Fordham University
The interpretations of the artistic program in the Dura Europos baptistery have been fixed, more or less, since the magisterial archaeological report of Carl Kraeling in 1967. The interpretive conclusions of that report have been often repeated and anthologized, thereby becoming themselves a kind of data for future theories about early Christianity. There has been a small but growing body of skeptics, however, regarding individual arguments of that report and its overall methodology. This paper will interrogate a main theoretical presupposition of the received wisdom--that the images maintain one-to-one correspondences with biblical texts--and proceed to argue for a different interpretation of the main panel of the artistic program. Regarding the theoretical presupposition, recent scholars have brought methods from gender and ritual studies to bear on the text-image relationships enacted in religious spaces. My argument privileges texts that can reasonably be shown to play intertextually on common baptismal language, especially those that have Eastern provenance. In addition to the expected texts from the canonical Gospels, I consider apocrypha, the writings of Aphrahat and Ephrem, and the baptismal catecheses from the East. When the main panel of the baptistery, a procession of women, is reconsidered in the light of third-century theology and ritual imagination, one can see interpretations that are more convincing than those previously offered. In the end, my paper de-emphasizes the Pauline interpretation of baptism as death and resurrection and highlights the motifs of baptism as illumination and spiritual marriage.
|
Wisdom Psalms in the Tanakh and Literature of the Dead Sea
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Leo G. Perdue, Texas Christian University
While the debate concerning the presence and use of wisdom psalms in the Psalter has continued, most scholars of the sapiential corpora in Israel and the Ancient Near East agree that sages wrote a variety of psalms, which likely would have been sung in ritual contexts. I include in this category Psalms 1, 19, 32, 34, 37, 49, 73, 111, 112, 119, and 127. Wisdom Psalms may be identified by sapiential lexicography (specialized vocabulary of a group or genre), shared semantics (terms, grammar, syntax, and common forms, phrases, clauses, and brief sentences), and themes that clearly reflect the Hebrew wisdom texts in the canonical and deuterocanonical literature. Proverbs also contains wisdom psalms and poems, including the three aretalogies of Woman Wisdom in Proverbs 8 (8:2-11, 12-21, and 22-31), which are concluded by her paraenetic instruction to discover life and avoid death (8:32-36). Among other examples in Second Temple literature, Ben Sira composed numerous hymns that are not only to be read, but also to be used in corporate worship: 1:1-10, 17:1-24,18:1-14, 24:1-34, 36:1-33, 39:12- 35, and 42:13-43:33.
Wisdom psalms and poems are also found in the corpus of literature from the Dead Sea.
The Cave 11 Psalms Scroll (11QPsa) contains several Wisdom Psalms or psalms influenced by wisdom (11QPsa 18, 11QPsa 21:11-17 and 22:1, 11QPsa 26:9-15). In Cave 4 the literary personification of folly in the guise of the wicked woman (cf. the “strange woman” in Proverbs) is present in 4QWiles of the Wicked Woman (4Q184) who, presented as a mythological figure, seeks to keep people from observing the Torah and to lead them to their death in the Underworld. The occurrence of wisdom psalms in the literature of the Dead Sea adds evidence to the understanding that wisdom psalms in the Psalter were written by sages for ritual celebration.
|
Did the Exodus Translator Shape the Meaning of the Narrative through His Translation Decisions? Exodus 19–20 as a Test Case
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Larry Perkins, Northwest Baptist Seminary
Generally the Greek translator of Exodus is regarded as careful and conservative in his work. However, there are contexts where significant variations from the Masoretic text occur. Debate continues as to whether such variations result from the translator’s use of a different Vorlage or reflect his intention to embed a modified interpretation of the original text in his translation. Did the translator intend to guide the reader into a specific understanding of the sacred text by such strategies as adding material, lexical choice, and syntactical variation? This paper will examine the Greek translation of Exodus 19-20 and argue that the nature, type and frequency of such variations demonstrate that the translator did intentionally re-shape the narrative. For the most part the variations do not represent a different Hebrew vorlage. Traces of the translator’s intention can be retrieved by careful attention to translation technique and the cumulative impact of changes across a narrative segment, indicating that the translator did pay attention to the broader narrative context as his translation work proceeded.
As a result of this review we may conclude that the translator was careful, but not as conservative with respect to his text as previously proposed. Adjustments made to the text seem to be intentional, seeking to influence the reader to a certain understanding of the text. Explaining why the translator made these changes is much more speculative.
|
Recasting Moses in the Reworked Pentateuch
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
Andrew B. Perrin, McMaster University
The diverse cache of scrolls discovered in the Judaean Desert have indicated that scriptural interpretation in the Second Temple period was bound up in the transmission process of scripture itself. A corollary of this is that the modern dichotomy between scriptural lemma and subsidiary commentary is not always perceptible or applicable to some ancient texts; rather, it appears that the scribal intent was to seamlessly enmesh these two elements. Paramount among works exhibiting this interpretive scribal approach to scripture at Qumran are the five scrolls designated as the Reworked Pentateuch (4QRPa-e; 4Q158, 4Q364-367). When compared with the biblical text, 4QRP exhibits several large-scale interpretive innovations, often in the form of content expansions of several additional lines or rearrangement of material, and 437 smaller variant readings. Several recent studies have sought to clarify the scribal approach(es) to scripture operating in 4QRP by investigating how scribes negotiated the porous scripture-interpretation boundary as well as their motivations for engaging the text in this manner. This paper will contribute to this ongoing dialogue by asking the question, How were the 4QRP texts theologically conditioned by the scribal tradition that produced/transmitted them? I propose that among the numerous exegetical and editorial contours of 4QRP a distinct group of variant readings coalesces around a common theological theme: the elevation of Moses and the intensification of Sinaitic revelation. This study will trace five such interpretive features through 4Q158, 4Q364, and 4Q365. In so doing, I propose that this vantage point on 4QRP should inform both how we approach these scrolls as well conceive of the scribal interpretive tradition from which they emerged.
|
Disputing Enoch: Matthew 24:36–44, Relevance Theory, and Intertextuality
Program Unit: Intertextuality in the New Testament
Peter S. Perry, Lutheran School of Theology at Chicago
Relevance Theory (RT) is a theory of communication that provides a broad framework for understanding how people decide what is more or less relevant in a given context. Intertextuality, from RT’s point of view, is one aspect of an explicit or implicit cognitive environment shared by author and audience. For example, the constellation of vocabulary and themes in Matt 24:36-44 recalls language from 1 Enoch. The knowledge of angels, Noah, eating and drinking, marriage, flood, separation, and watching are optimally processed in a cognitive environment that includes 1 Enoch 6-11. RT suggests Matthew is interacting with Enochic Judaism. Specifically, this pericope addresses the trajectory of history and the inclination of humanity within an Enochic framework while rejecting social dualism and precise knowledge of the eschaton. Like other passages (e.g. the wheat and the weeds, foolish and wise bridesmaids, sheep and goats), Matt 24:36-44 presents the righteous and wicked side-by-side in the church, indiscernible until the moment of judgment. Instead of identifying who is saved or damned or when judgment will come, Matthew refocuses an audience sympathetic to 1 Enoch to “keep watch” on its piety and service in the present.
|
Relationships between the Canonical Acts and the Apocryphal Acts
Program Unit:
Richard Pervo, St. Paul, MN
*
|
Trajectories of Acts in the Second Century
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
Richard Pervo, St. Paul, MN
Paper will examine three responses to Acts: The D-Text (=Western), The Acts of Paul, and a source of the Pseudo-Clementines. Canonical Acts represents a perspective early in the reign of Hadrian. The D-Text exhibits (possibly through different editors) tendencies toward heroization like those present in Apocryphal Acts, stabilizing views of leadership and authority, yet with strong emphasis upon the Spirit. The Acts of Paul stress, against Acts, the independence of the Apostle and his charismatic authority, as well as some more radical (apocalyptic, authority of women, hatred of the empire) elements of the tradition not emphasized in Acts. The Source of the Pseudo-Clementines revises Acts in an intensely anti-pauline fashion.
|
The Slavery in the Gospel of John and Documentary Papyri
Program Unit: Papyrology and Early Christian Backgrounds
Mauro Pesce, University of Bologna
The papyrological documentation relating to domestic slavery shows not only the great diversity of functions of the slave, but also its structural importance in the Graeco-Roman society, and the complexity of slave status.
John proposes the master-slave relation as necessary for religious experience. The center of the Gospel consists of a process of initiation (the foot washing of the slaves) to which the disciples must be submitted for attaining the new religious condition.
In the documentary papyri words about the friendship of the masters to the slaves are lacking, but there are signs of friendly bounds and mutual affection. John has taken these human relations and has incorporated them in his religious project. It is the environment of domestic slavery that generates the Johannine idea of the friendly status of disciples.
The pattern of slave-liberation is central in order to make clear the essence of the process of initiation: only Jesus can give liberation to the disciple. Papyrological documentation give evidence about the fact that the slave constructs for himself the conditions for his liberation through a good behaviour towards his owners and in many cases through his independent economic activity that permits him to pay the price of his liberation. The active function of the slave in his liberation seems however to be almost completely absent in the Johannine model of initiation.
The concept of slavery of O.Patterson as social death seems to clarify the fact that John conceives the slave and also the disciple as someone basically passive. In fact, John has a positive vision of the slave, as a substitute of the master, as one who can do what for his master is impossible. Socially dead signifies then only socially dead for himself, inactive compared to his social self, but active, instead, in function of others. Only further research could clarify if John has a passive and authoritarian vision not only of the process of initiation of the disciples, but also of the house-slaves of his time.
|
In Whose Hand the Sword? War and Peace at Qumran
Program Unit: Qumran
Dorothy M. Peters, Trinity Western University
If the Zealots have been called the “militarists” of the Second Temple period, the Essenes have been called the “pacifists.” However, the unsettled dissonance between the Second Temple descriptions of the Essenes and the internal sectarian documents such as the War Scroll is notable. While judgment is normally left in God’s hands within the Enochic books at Qumran, the sword of judgment is given for a limited time into human hands only during the eighth week of the Apocalypse of Weeks, into the ever-receding future. Furthermore, the portrayals of Jacob as a reluctant warrior in Jubilees and of Levi as both a man of peace and a man of war in the Aramaic Levi Document betray an unease with the idea of taking up the sword before a future appointed time.
This paper surveys the Dead Sea Scrolls for ways that various retellings of Torah events and stories provided a ideological foundation for different points of view within the Dead Sea Scrolls concerning the group’s ideal present and future relationships – whether peaceful or warlike – with selected designated “outsiders.” Two significant observations are made.
First, interpreters in the Second Temple period who chose to retell stories from Genesis were more likely to concede the possibility of peaceful relationships (with attached conditions!) between Israel and the “outsider” than were interpreters depending more heavily on portions of the Torah more explicitly associated with Moses, such as Deuteronomy. Second, texts written in Aramaic reveal a stance that is more consistently peaceful or “hospitable” towards “outsiders” while texts written in Hebrew reveal a stance that is more adversarial.
|
Mary Ann Sadlier and the Protestant Biblical Other
Program Unit: Recovering Female Interpreters of the Bible
Janelle Peters, Emory University
In the eyes of 19th century American Catholics, the most threatening figure to their minority religious group might be the Protestant woman. The Protestant woman existed in Roman Catholic social consciousness as schoolteacher, society benefactress, and possible love interest for Roman Catholic immigrant men. Irish-American Catholic Mary Ann Sadlier was a popular novelist and catechetist who polemicized against the cultural adaptations Roman Catholics made to Protestantism. This paper seeks to explore the ways in which Mary Ann Sadlier appropriated the Bible from her cultural competitors by comparing them with negative female biblical figures. In keeping with Victorian ideals of womanhood, nineteenth century American women were held in high esteem as moral exemplars. Responsible for the educational and moral instruction of children, a woman’s access to biblical interpretation was implicit. Louisa May Alcott described the death of Beth with biblical allusions, a moment of revelation and salvation also found in contemporary British novels. Emily Dickinson wrote poetry in which she used biblical imagery and assumed the perspective of Jesus. Sadlier, therefore, in arguing against American Protestant women, is reflective of the moral authority and privileged access to biblical interpretation American Protestant women held practically—if not officially—in both Protestant and Catholic society. When discussing two Protestant women leaders in Old and New; or, Taste Versus Fashion, Sadlier compares these authorities with negative female figures from the Old Testament: “The ladies stood up, erect and nearly as rigid as Lot’s wife after her transformation.” She appropriates the biblical tradition in order to assume authority from cultural religious competitors, women.
|
Hope Leaves the Jar: The Goddess Spes, the Natural Order, and Women in the Roman Empire
Program Unit: Art and Religions of Antiquity
Janelle Peters, Emory University
In the Roman worldview, masculine Roman order overcame feminine natural habitats. Ancient Roman luxury villas were erected in the Campanian countryside outside of Rome to demonstrate the Roman control over nature even in otium. Garden frescoes in Rome itself also served this purpose. Finally, the goddess Spes (Hope), who may be identified by the flower she carries, supported imperial concerns throughout the Roman Empire. Examples include: Vergil, the Claudian and Flavian Spes Augusta, the coinage of Vespasian, the Hope Dionysos, and the iconography of Constantine. Yet, despite the male, imperial associations of this goddess, it was possible for women to appropriate the goddess and her control over nature. As priestess of Augustus’ cult, Livia is well-noted to have exerted her influence through architecture such as her Garden Room in Prima Porta. We find women being depicted as Spes to demonstrate their importance up to the fourth century diptych that portrays Serena, adopted daughter of Theodosius, in the guise of Spes. It is even possible that the exhortations in the New Testament to find hope in how flowers survive despite neither toiling nor spinning (cf. Matthew 6:28, Luke 12:27) reflect not only Stoic arguments from nature but also the feminine associations of Spes. Cloth-production was a feminine pursuit, and contemporary coinage and temples throughout the Greek East were adorned with Spes and Spes’ lotus. Using the work of Natalie Kampen and Ann Kuttner, this paper explores the cultural implications of the Roman invocations of the goddess Spes—who connected the imperial and the natural orders—and the ways in which actual Roman women could access her.
|
“The Ten Commandments": Contexts for Teaching
Program Unit: Service-Learning and Biblical Studies
David Petersen, Emory University
Beyond encouraging the incorporation of service-learning projects into individual courses, Candler School of Theology has introduced contextualized learning across its curriculum. Petersen will offer an overview of Candler’s contextual education program as a whole and then describe one particular course — “The Ten Commandments” — that includes a major component dedicated to Kieslowski’s “The Decalogue”.
|
Martha Shamoni: The Creative Adaptation in Seventh Maccabees
Program Unit: Syriac Literature and Interpretations of Sacred Texts
Sigrid Peterson, University of Pennsylvania
Martha Shamoni is the name by which the mother of the Maccabees is known and honored in the Syriac calendar of saints. That name is also represented in several literary pieces in Syriac; two are now named Sixth and Seventh Maccabees.
Seventh Maccabees is an original Syriac piece, apparently for an observance in remembrance of the Maccabean martyrs. The content is a reworked telling of the Maccabean martyrdoms, known from the Greek Apocryphal/Deuterocanonical Books of Second and Fourth Maccabees. Most notably, 7 Macc puts Martha Shamoni front and center throughout, although it is still the sons who dialogue with Antiochus. This piece is in Artistic Prose, perhaps an elaboration of the Greek chreia.
The co-presenters have translated this work for MORE OLD TESTAMENT PSEUDEPIGRAPHA, Richard Bauckham and James R. Davila, eds., forthcoming from Eerdmans.
We will present unusual features of the text/translation, and ask critical questions. One such question, "What is the religion of this text?" is a common question in explorations of pseudepigrapha. We will apply some of the text-critical/source-critical techniques used in the examination of pseudepigrapha to answer this question.
|
The Martyrs of Lyons as Exempla of Christian Leadership
Program Unit: Children in the Biblical World
James Petitfils, University of California-Los Angeles
The ethical curriculum of a traditional Roman education largely consisted of stories and descriptions of Rome’s own ancestral heroes. A typical Roman youth was socialized with a keen awareness of his/her ancestral tradition as he/she regularly encountered these late relatives both audibly (in frequently repeated ancestral anecdotes) and visually (daily encountering their imagines hanging in the family atrium). In the same way, when Roman authors wished to articulate their conceptions of ideal leadership, they called upon exempla generally drawn from heroes of their ancestral history—rather than, for example, philosophical propositions. In short, for Roman children, the leadership ideal was that of the mos maiorum. This ideal was thus a major feature of the ideological geography in which the early “Christians” began to organize their communities, socialize their boys and girls, and distinguish their leaders.
In this paper I will seek to address the following question: As the Christ-confessing communities of the first three centuries sought to inscribe their own identity in the Roman empire, to what extent did they adopt, adapt, or eschew both the form and content of this Roman pedagogical discourse on leadership? Focusing on the The Martyrs of Lyons and Vienne, I will seek to answer this question in three steps: First, I will examine the depiction of the martyrs in Mart. Lyon. within the broader framework of the Roman discourse of exemplarity—a discourse outlined by Roller (2004) and Morgan (2007). In light of the surge of recent scholarship on martyrology and the formation of early Christian identity, my paper will then explore how (or if) the second century martyrologist(s) utilized this largely Roman discourse to articulate a distinctively Christian notion of exemplary leadership. Finally, I will try to circumscribe and unpack such a “distinctively Christian” notion of ideal leadership (if such an ideological construct can be identified), observing both where the martyrs may embody familiar Roman leadership characteristics and, perhaps more notably, where they model a unique leadership ethic.
|
Acts for and/or against Empire
Program Unit: Book of Acts
Christina Petterson, Macquarie University
This paper is part of a larger project of engaging Acts critically with empire. I aim to assess the book of Acts within Biblical Empire Studies, as well as the empire within Acts studies and discuss the limited positions Acts is seen to take in respect to the Roman Empire, namely for or against.
Drawing on Žižek’s schema of “subjective” and objective violence, I attempt to complicate the debate, suggesting that it most often is the subjective violence, which is pounced upon in assessing the stance of NT texts towards empire, while the objective violence, and its systemic and symbolic manifestations are left untouched. I use this schema to explore Acts 16: 11-40.
|
Laconic Sages and Silent Philosophers at the Confluence of Jewish, Pagan, and Early Christian Wisdom
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Daniele Pevarello, University of Cambridge
Warnings against verbosity in Wisdom literature are already to be found in sources predating the Hebrew Bible and are a frequent motif in Jewish as well as pagan wisdom from the canonical book of Proverbs to Jesus Ben Sira and from Chilon of Sparta to the Pythagorean maxims of Clitarchus. Focusing firstly on proverbial material from canonical texts and subsequently on deuterocanonical Wisdom literature and Greek gnomic traditions, this paper will draw attention to similarities and differences between the Jewish condemnation of verbosity and the pagan philosophical concern with the short discourse, or brachylogy. The paper will show that while some of these invitations to concision are built around the commonplace assumption of talkativeness as an irritating social habit, other maxims seem to point at a deeper understanding of the meaning of brevity. In these sayings, wordiness is a sign of moral ineptitude and depravation, while concision, and ultimately restrain from every unnecessary word, becomes a byword for virtue and the necessary rule of conduct for every true sage. Finally, it will be argued that the interaction between the Jewish and the pagan tradition contributed to the construction of the ideal of the Laconic sage in Late Antiquity, anticipating the importance that concision and silence later had in early Christian asceticism.
|
“Render unto Caesar” according to Sextus, Clement, and Origen
Program Unit: Christianity in Egypt: Scripture, Tradition, and Reception
Daniele Pevarello, University of Cambridge
The second century CE "Sentences of Sextus", an anthology of Pythagorean sayings thought to have been compiled by a Christian teacher, contain the admonition to: "Accurately render unto the world the things which are of the world and unto God the things which are God's" (Sent. Sextus 20).
The paper will contribute to the unceasing debate about the Christian character of Sextus' collection of pagan proverbs by claiming that the aforementioned sentence contains Sextus' own rendition of the words of Jesus about Caesar's denarius in Mark 12:17 (par. Matt 22:21 and Luke 20:25). Following a comparison with interpretations of the same gospel saying in the work of Clement of Alexandria and Origen, it will be argued that Sextus' reading displays remarkable affinities with the interpretative tradition attested by the two Alexandrian teachers. Finally, taking into consideration this element, together with Origen's testimony concerning the popularity of the Sentences among Christian ascetics and the presence of a Coptic translation of the Sentences in the Nag Hammadi library, the paper will provide an up-to-date assessment of the hypothesis that the "Sentences of Sextus" might have originated within Christian circles in Egypt
|
Puns Intended: Aspects of Humor in Enuma eliš Tablet One
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Andrew Pfeiffer, Hebrew Union College-Jewish Institute of Religion
From the very first stanza and from the spelling of select words the author of the Enuma eliš brings out an element of humor. Directed toward both listening and scribal audiences, the presence of humor in tablet one makes important contributions to the epic’s setting, characterizations, and dramatic events. To clarify these contributions, this study of the first tablet of the Enuma eliš considers three questions: How does the author use the cuneiform signs to underscore the meaning of the poetry? What is the rationale for satirizing several deities? How does irony highlight a central theme for the epic?
|
Jerusalem Woman, Lebanon Woman, and the Poetics of the Song of Songs
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Jennifer Pfenniger, University of Toronto
Although most biblical scholars understand the Song of Songs in relation to interactions between one man and one woman, some have proposed a triangulated presentation of two men and one woman; and extremely few interpreters have apprehended two women and one man within the Song’s intricate textual demeanour.
This paper explores the poetics of the last option, and attends, in particular, to the epithetical structures within the Song’s Hebrew Text. These titles, beheld alongside the clusterings of Hebrew vocabulary that accompany them, suggest the presence of two woman—‘O Betrothed’, a foreign and Lebanese noblewoman, and ‘O Fair One’, a common Jerusalemite. The singular epithet employed by both in reference to a man, ‘The Beloved’, appears to address King Solomon of Israel. Their mutual address of this man, and he of them, supports the notion that Solomon is in relationship with both Lebanon Woman and Jerusalem Woman throughout the Song, although he appears to consummate his commitment to the former.
The above study procures significant direction from modern and post-modern literary specialists in regard to oral versus literary meaning mechanisms, the intrinsic contribution of spatial factors within poetical pieces, and the significance of repetition for ancient style. An exposition of Song 4.8–15, 5.1, and 4.1–4 is provided in order to demonstrate in detail this method of discerning characters according to epithets and lexical recurrences within the Song.
|
Acts and the correspondence of Pliny
Program Unit:
Thomas Phillips, Point Loma Nazarene University
*
|
Loving Neighbor, Loving One Another, and Loving Enemies: 3 NT Ethics of Love
Program Unit: Ethics, Love, and the Other in Early Christianity
Thomas E. Phillips, Point Loma Nazarene University
This paper will contrast the Johannine ethic of "loving one another" with the Markan ethic of "loving neighbor" and the Q ethic of "loving enemies."
|
Piecemeal or Principled? Mark's Treatment of Torah
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Victoria Phillps, West Virginia Wesleyan College
It is agreed that Mark represents Jesus as having the authority to redefine, abrogate or enforce Torah. This paper investigates to what extent Mark’s treatment of Torah is piecemeal or principled. Mark does not have present any systematic discourse about Torah, but has numerous instances of controversies and discussions in which Jewish leaders from various groups ask him to defend or to define his actions in light of their common commitment to Torah. Consequently, one could argue that Mark’s approach to Torah is piecemeal; issues taken up because of controversy. However, I will argue that Mark has a principled approach to Torah. Rather than trying to discern patterns in the midst of the numerous instances of Torah-related issues (cleansing of the leper, keeping of the Sabbath, food laws, defilement, the practice of divorce, and paying taxes, among others), I will show that three principles articulated by the Markan Jesus bring coherence to the array of issues. The first principle is the demand to repent in light of the good news that the kingdom of God is at hand (Mark 1.15). The second principle is that human traditions do not take precedence over divine commands (Mark 7:8). The third is Jesus’ summary of the law (Mark 12.29-31).
|
Formed in and Called from My Mother’s Womb
Program Unit: Latter-day Saints and the Bible
Dana M. Pike, Brigham Young University
This paper surveys and analyzes the eleven occurrences of babbeten, “in the womb,” and the twenty occurrences of mibbeten, “from the womb,” in the Hebrew Bible. Analysis and discussion of these phrases and their contexts includes (1) the meaning of the word beten and its use in relation to rehem, (2) the functional categories of usage of these phrases (e.g., strictly anatomical, theological), (3) the verbs employed in connection with these phrases (e.g., yasar), and (4) the Israelite views of conception and birth these two phrases might reveal. Particular attention is given to those passages with content involving a claim of divinely attributed in-womb creation (e.g., Psalm 139:13-15; Ecclesiastes 11:5) and divine in-womb election (Judg 16:17; Isa 49:5; Jer 1:5). In exploring what such claims meant to ancient Israelites this study also examines how the content of these passages coordinates with the Latter-day Saint tradition of Bible interpretation, with special consideration given to the biblical notion of YHWH electing individuals and collective Israel “from the womb.”
|
"The Reconciliation of the World": Exploring How Paul's Expansive Vision for Israel and the Gentiles Counters and Subverts Pretensions of the Empire
Program Unit: Romans through History and Cultures
Edward Pillar, University of Wales Trinity St. David
It is our contention that Paul’s articulation of reconciliation in Romans is undergirded and profoundly influenced by his anti-imperial gospel. In this paper we focus our attention on Romans 11:15, “For if their rejection is the reconciliation of the world, what will their acceptance be but life from the dead?” where Paul’s expansive vision for the reconciliation of the whole world has the effect of not only drawing together Jew and Gentile, but also countering and also subverting Imperial claims to world domination. Not only so, but Paul’s emphasis here on the reconciliation of the world is based upon his conviction that God has raised Jesus from the dead in a direct challenge to the claims of Empire. Paul can thus delight in the notion that the acceptance by the Jews of God's appointed Lord, will result one day in themselves being raised from the dead and standing vindicated over against the tyrannous rulers under whose oppressive rule they are presently suffering.
|
Aksum and the Bible: A Few Things You Should Know About
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Pierluigi Piovanelli, University of Ottawa
The Aksumite Bible, as a cultural product of Late Antiquity, is still relatively little-known. Thus, in spite of the most recent advances in the field of Ethiopian studies, old scholarly opinions – such as, e.g., the active role played by the famous “fourth (!) or fifth century Syrian Monophysite monks” – are still not only uncritically repeated, but also used to build up even more extravagant theories. The time has come to reassess some basic issues about the origins of the first missionaries; the nature of the texts and textual recensions they brought with them; the identities of the first translators; the chronological framework for their work.
|
"STRONG Sistas": Education through Teen Mentoring
Program Unit: Service-Learning and Biblical Studies
Tina Pippin, Agnes Scott College
While service-learning may involve adding a service component within a traditional course structure, another model involves learning that takes place primarily within the context of the service itself. Pippin shares her experience with an internship course associated with “STRONG Sistas,” a mentoring group for teen parents and other at-risk young people.
|
Pop-Up Apocalypse
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
Tina Pippin, Agnes Scott College
Beginning in the Middle Ages, book artists developed the first pop-up or movable books. An early example is Petrus Apianus’ 1524 Cosmographia, which offered readers a more interactive view of the world by using volvelles, or movable parts. An examination of the history of pop-up books shows their popularity as children’s books but also for adults (e.g. peep-show books). Pop-up books surprise and amuse, but they also instruct the reader on their journey through the book. There has been a modern resurgence of pop-ups for children (Robert Sabuda and Ann Montanaro and others), focusing on classic literature (e.g. Alice in Wonderland), alphabets, and dinosaurs, dragons and other monsters. In these books the story opens up with each page; there are amazing letters, maps, secret codes, dragon skin, fairy dust, and the open and fully toothed mouths of beasts.
A local artist and gallery owner, Syliva Cross and I are producing our own “pop-up apocalypse” that will reimagine the biblical Apocalypse of John with text and commentary and visuals in a movable and hands-on form. We are incorporating classic and contemporary apocalyptic art and art forms, cultural and political connections, critical theory, feminist imaginings of the end of time—all (in)formed by the art and mechanics of the pop-up forms. A pop-up book provides a kind of material hypertext, and we are playing with the possibilities of where the biblical text and its multiple interpretations might take the reader. The Apocalypse of John has been a popular theme in art, and we want to push the art and the text out of its flat page. The beasts of the Brussels Tapestry or William Blake already jump off their flat surfaces toward the viewer; we just want to nudge them even more. Through the pop-up form we are offering an invitation to the reader of the biblical text to connect with all the senses as a starting point for further interpretive—and emotional--apocalyptic journeys.
|
West Semitic Research, Cylinder Seals, and Clay Tablets: Better Lights and Moving Lights at the Spurlock Museum
Program Unit: Paleographical Studies in the Ancient Near East
Wayne Pitard, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
Collaboration between the West Semitic Research Project, directed by Bruce Zuckerman, and the Spurlock Museum and National Center for Supercomputing Applications at the University of Illinois, has opened the way for a number of significant projects designed to document ancient Near Eastern texts and artifacts in striking new ways. This paper will focus on three specific projects: (1) the documentation of the Spurlock Museum’s collection of Mesopotamian cylinder seals; (2) similar work on seals from the Amuq Valley excavations of the Oriental Institute; and (3) the use of Polynomial Texture Mapping to document the Ugaritic literary texts in the Louvre (pending permissions).
|
Joshua and Numbers and Priestly Material
Program Unit: Joshua-Judges
Pekka Pitkänen, University of Gloucestershire
This paper will examine the relationship of Joshua to Numbers and the priestly material. The paper will start by summarizing the history of scholarship that relates to the issue. Relying on the author's work on the book of Joshua (IVP: Apollos, forthcoming 2010, also Central Sanctuary and Centralization of Worship [Gorgias Press 2004]), it will then argue for links between Joshua and Numbers and the priestly material based on an examination of both literary connections and ideas that link Joshua to these traditions. It will argue that Joshua is literarily linked with Numbers (contra Noth, etc.) and that priestly concepts are also otherwise firmly embedded in many places in Joshua, speaking for a concept of a Hexateuch rather than a Deuteronomistic history in terms of trying to understand Joshua's position between The Pentateuch and Judges-Kings.
|
"For Many Days He Appeared" (Acts 13:31): Ascension Traditions in the First Two Centuries, Inside and Outside Acts
Program Unit:
Catherine Playoust, Jesuit Theological College (Melbourne College of Divinity)
*
|
Isa 41–44 as Autoethnography
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Callie Plunket-Brewton, University of North Alabama
The poetry of Isa 41-44 weaves together imagery, theme, and form in richly suggestive ways. Among the difficulties for the interpreter is the poet’s juxtaposition of the contradictory associations of the word ‘ebed throughout this series of poems. Drawing on the work of M. L. Pratt, I argue in this paper that the exile is a “contact zone,” a social space “where cultures meet, clash, and grapple with each other, often in contexts of highly asymmetrical relations of power.” For a community defined by the Babylonians as subjugated and treated as slaves, in Isa 41-44 we discover an artful redefinition of servanthood that draws on both west and east Semitic understandings of the term ‘ebed. Isa 41-44 can be helpfully understood as an autoethnographic text, that is, a text in which “people undertake to describe themselves in ways that engage with representations others have made of them,” to use the language of Pratt. Wrestling with the ambiguities of their past and present through conflicting representations of service and servants, the poet intuits for the exilic community a means by which to survive the debilitating effects of exile by means of a poetry that upholds the paradox of their lives. Yet this poetry allows them to redefine themselves as they constructively respond to what it means to be YHWH’s ‘ebed as well. Thus, the difficulties in the poetry are not, as some have proposed, the result of clumsy redaction but are in fact the result of the poet’s attempt to explore and re-imagine the reality of the people’s experience of exile. In Isa 41-44, the poet enacts a poetic violence, a cataclysmic re-invention of identity that defies the power of loss and oppression to define self and community.
|
Along with the Other Royal Books: The Letter of Aristeas and Colonial Discourse
Program Unit: Function of Apocryphal and Pseudepigraphal Writings in Early Judaism and Early Christianity
Don Polaski, College of William and Mary
The Letter of Aristeas may be seen as “apologetic” in nature: it envisions mutual respect between Jews and Greeks in Alexandria. But, from a postcolonial perspective, the Letter’s ideological stance is anything but simple. I read the Letter of Aristeas as an intriguing moment in colonial discourse, a moment that discloses ways Jews in Egypt formed their identity. In this text, a Jewish author in Egypt uses a narrator who is a Greek courtier. A colonized author imagines the voice of a colonizer and expresses himself through it, claiming to view his own (colonized Jewish) world through the eyes of an imperial official. And this text focuses on a major point of negotiation between colonized and imperial cultures: the status of a text (the Torah) putatively central to the ethnic identity of the colonized Judeans in Egypt. The King wishes to have the Torah “along with the other royal books” (Let Arist 38) in his library. But will the empire’s presumption to have all knowledge in its library succeed or fail? Will the Torah resist colonization if not translation?
I will attempt to answer this question by carefully examining the ways the Letter presents the power of both colonizer and colonized working through writing. In particular, I will look at the introductory episode, which parallels the king’s quest for a translation of the Torah with his edict freeing Jewish slaves; the interview with the high priest Eleazar, which focuses on the Torah and its interpretation; and the symposium with the king and the translators, which presents a blurring of boundaries between the Jewish priests and the imperial authorities, a blurring just prior to the translation/rewriting of the Torah.
|
Smelly, Yes, but Disgusting? Rhetorical Markers of the Avoidance of Bodily Waste in Rabbinic Sources
Program Unit: Senses, Cultures, and Biblical Worlds
Natalie Polzer, University of Louisville
Disgust as a response to a bad smell is both an emotional and a physical response, manifest in psychosomatic symptoms (headache, nausea, anxiety, faintness, shortness of breath, closing the eyes, hand across the mouth). In real life, a response of disgust to the sensation of a bad smell is indicated by overt physiological evidence (facial contortions, vomiting, retching, doubling over, fainting, panting). Such disgust is harder to communicate when textually encoded. To do so, the response of literary characters to objects of disgust is usually expressed in language meant to evoke a transferred sensation of disgust in the reader, or formulaic tropes are used, rhetorically signifying disgust.
While taboos involving the separation of bodily waste and its smell from prayer and Torah study were developed in rabbinic law, a rhetorical analysis reveals little evidence that such substances or their smells were considered disgusting, as we understand it, in rabbinic culture. Indeed, an examination of the rhetorical markers in both halakhic and aggadic sources evidence almost no formulaic language marking human bodily waste, its smell, other bodily secretions, or the process of evacuating as disgusting. In fact, content detail often shows that such substances were regarded as neutral and inert rather than provoking disgust or revulsion. While there is more rhetoric of disgust in aggadic sources, here disgust is associated with ideologies of human mortality and corporality, rather than human waste in and of itself.
Finally, hypotheses for the absence of human waste as a marker of disgust in rabbinic sources are presented.
|
A Mesopotamian Framework for Understanding Ancient Faith: Bonding with the Personal God
Program Unit: Hebrew Scriptures and Cognate Literature
Beate Pongratz-Leisten, New York University
This title reflects a contribution to collaboration between Beate Pongratz-Leisten and Daniel E. Fleming on "A Mesopotamian Framework for Understanding Ancient Faith." For all the evidence for the worship of deities in communities and households, by individuals from kings to scribes to those unnamed, in settings from palaces to remote shrines, ancient "faith" is difficult to define and investigate. The Bible is read as a book of faith, though here also, the category may be too easily forced into a conception from later religious worlds. For this project, we approach faith as the experience of the religious bond, a state of mind that finds expression in both individual and group dimensions that are best understood to overlap and blend. With this joine presentation, we will explore aspects of religious experience reflected in writing from Mesopotamia and Syria. Our contributions will play off one another, and we hope to provoke a wider conversation among participants.
|
How the Dragon and the Two Beasts in Revelation 12–13 Parody the Capitoline Triad, Jupiter, Juno, and Minerva
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
Joseph Poon, Sheffield University
This paper aims to argue that in composing Revelation 12-13, John constructs the two beasts and the dragon in a hierarchical structure, in order to parody the Capitoline Triad, Jupiter, Juno and Minerva, a group of three supreme Roman deities. Scrutiny to the passage reveals that the key of the two chapters is a hierarchical structure interweaving the three figures in which each contains a specific function: the beast from the land who involves economic productivity is subordinate to the beast from the sea who takes the warrior role, which in turn is subordinate to the dragon who governs the cosmological sphere. The same hierarchy with the same function allotted to each level is found in the Capitoline Triad. Its increasing threat to the early church is evidently shown by the dissemination of Capitola, shrines of the Triad, in Asia Minor as well as the whole Mediterranean, Vespasian’s replacement of the annual temple tax by a humiliating tax for rebuilding the Jupiter Capitolinus, and Hadrian’s establishment of a Jupiter Capitolinus over the ruins of Jerusalem Temple. By exploring the common hierarchy in John’s three figures and in the Roman deities, and by examining the archeological evidence for the Triad, this study demonstrates how John combats the symbol of Roman power with the dragon and the two beasts. Hence, the study contributes a more nuanced view to the topic that has been flooded with speculations of imperial cult by many scholars.
|
Databasing the Idumean Ostraca
Program Unit: Aramaic Studies
Bezalel Porten, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
The fourth century BCE Idumean ostraca constitute the largest amount of epigraphic material in the Land of Israel prior to the Dead Sea Scrolls. Of a total of some 2000 ostraca, ca. 1200 are commodity chits, of which over 700 are dated. Spanning a period of 60 years, the chits have a common format of date, payer, payee, commodity and measure, with sometime reference to agents, storehouse, signatory, and sealing sign. They record conveyance of grains, whole and processed; bundles and bales of chaff; a variety of wooden objects; wine and oil. Feeding this material into a database yields a wealth of correlations. The all-subsuming question is "What commodities are conveyed when, by whom and to whom, in what measure, and with what oversight?" Thus, these broken pieces of pottery yield information on the economic and social life of the small territory south of Judea not available to us in any other source.
|
The Power of Zotero for Student Learning
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Adam L. Porter, Illinois College
Zotero is a research tool that runs under the Firefox web browser. Developed by a consortium of libraries, it is free and very powerful. I will be demonstrating how Zotero can be used to enhance student research and learning, as well as sharing the experiences of myself and my students using Zotero for a journaling assignment.
|
Criteria for Determining the Concepts of Voice and Deponency in Ancient Greek
Program Unit: Biblical Greek Language and Linguistics
Stanley Porter, McMaster Divinity College
TBD
|
Bardaisan and the Bible
Program Unit: Syriac Literature and Interpretations of Sacred Texts
Ute Possekel, Gordon College
The theologian and philosopher Bardaisan flourished in the early third century CE at the court of King Abgar of Edessa in northern Mesopotamia. He acquired fame for his dialogues against Marcionites and other heretics, and for his rejection of astrological determinism. However, later generations of Syriac Christians rejected some of Bardaisan’s teachings as heretical and did not transmit his literary corpus. His works therefore survive only in fragments cited by later opponents, and in a dialogue known as the Book of the Laws of the Countries, compiled by one of his disciples. Although often categorized as a philosopher, Bardaisan understood himself as a theologian. He tried to give answers to philosophical questions from a Christian perspective, and he cited the Christian Scriptures in his arguments.
In this paper, I shall attempt to outline Bardaisan’s understanding of Scripture, a topic that has hitherto largely been ignored by scholars. Based on the limited material available, the paper will in its first part survey Bardaisan’s citations of Scripture and his allusions to biblical texts. The second part of the paper will evaluate Bardaisan’s exegesis and compared it both to Jewish readings of the Hebrew Bible and to contemporary patristic exegesis. It will be shown that Bardaisan was a theologian who took the biblical texts seriously and based much of his speculative theology on Scripture.
|
The Book of Job and "The Price of Milk": The Narrative Ethics of a Lactose-Tolerant Intertextual Reading
Program Unit: Bible and Film
Stephanie Day Powell, Drew University
In the history of biblical interpretation, scholars have ceded Job from the genre of narrative to that of philosophy, or in Levinasian terms, from the realm of Saying to the realm of the Said. Once an intrepid tale of one man’s courage of conviction, Job has become an unremitting discourse on human suffering. When we rediscover the book as narrative, however, we are engaged beyond the mode of intellect, on toward emotional and relational planes.
A method for recovering Job as narrative can be found in the strategic use of intertextuality towards a narrative ethics. Harry Sinclair’s 2000 film "The Price of Milk" (DVD, 2002) is a quintessentially Jobian tale told cleverly in the guise of a love story set against a luxuriant New Zealand landscape. “The tale of one man, one woman and 117 cows,” the film follows the journey of a modern-day ish tam, Rob, whose beloved, Lucinda, trades his livestock for a patchwork quilt in order to test his love. More than just complementary works, Job and "The Price of Milk" co-constitutively raise our awareness of human and divine vulnerability, life’s volatility and the experiential nature of faith.
In their narration of ethics, text and film mutually illuminate and refine the anthropodical and theological concerns raised by each work. Moreover, "The Price of Milk" provides a distinctive model for narration as ethics. Full of magic realism and produced without a predetermined script, the mythical, mystical and improvisational nature of the film engaged actors in a participatory experience evocative of the risks that we – God, Job and reader – take as we step into mysterium of the whirlwind. The film’s creative process suggests an intersubjective approach to biblical narrative that not only makes the reading of Job more tolerable but liberates us to inhabit the story-world in new and potentially transformative ways.
|
"Rise Up Ye Women": Harriet Jacobs and the Bible
Program Unit: Recovering Female Interpreters of the Bible
Emerson B. Powery, Messiah College/Wake Forest University
The Bible is central to Harriet Jacobs’ "Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl" (1861). From the inclusion of Isaiah 32:9 (“Rise up, ye women that are at ease! Hear my voice, ye careless daughters! Give ear unto my speech.”) on the cover of "Incidents" to her appropriation of Exodus, Ecclesiastes, Job, Matthew, Mark, and Ephesians, Jacobs offers a compelling narrative with engaged “conversation” with biblical texts interwoven into her story.
Recovering a meaningful interpretive strategy for the Bible included an engaging embodiment of those ancient stories about faith. "Incidents" is part of that manifestation; but, for Jacobs, this embodiment cannot (must not?) be limited to print text. Whether it was opening an anti-slavery reading room or founding a school for African American children, Jacobs’ activism exemplifies what it means to be a neighbor.
One of her earliest recollections of childhood was the memory of Jesus’ words “love your neighbor as yourself.” This verse was one of her fondest experiences with her former mistress, who taught her how to read. The recollection was part of a broader complicated remembrance as well. She recalled her mistress’ failure to treat her as a true “neighbor.” As she recalls, “I was her slave, and I supposed she did not recognize me as her neighbor.”
The psychological implications of this event linger, as Jacobs describes her life-long “bitterness” towards the broken “promise.” She ends, nonetheless, with thankfulness for the gift of literacy, which she gained from the same mistress. This gift allowed her not only to interpret the Bible for herself (i.e., the neighbor should include the enslaved), but also to tell her story, indeed the first “slave narrative” authored by a female writer. And, "Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl," in which Jacobs wrestles with exposing publicly the sexual exploitation inherent in the slave system, is a narrative unlike any in the genre of the day.
|
Hands Off! The Syriac Didascalia, the Israelite Priesthood, and the Quran
Program Unit: Syriac Literature and Interpretations of Sacred Texts
Michael Pregill, Elon University
In recent decades, scholars of the Quran have gradually moved away from the “influence” model of Islamic origins, which posits a more or less direct “borrowing” of material drawn from older scriptural traditions, to more organic, and less reductive, models of development. At the same time, rabbinic midrash seems to be falling out of favor as the primary source of comparanda for Quranic narratives, and contemporary scholars appear to be emphasizing the Quran’s relationship to the late antique Syriac Christian milieu more and more. While most scholars would reject the approach of “Christoph Luxenberg,” the pseudonymous author who has argued that the Quran be understood as a kind of mistranslation or even wholesale transcription of a Syriac hymnal, the revived interest in tracking and analyzing the Quran’s apparent similarities with or even allusions to Syrian Christian traditions appears to represent a paradigm shift in contemporary Islamic studies. I will discuss some recent scholarship on the Quran that reflects this trend, and discuss a pertinent example drawn from my own research. I have observed a conspicuous affinity between the Quranic portrayal of Aaron and the underlying understanding of the Israelite priesthood that informs it and that of the late antique Didascalia Apostolorum, which posits that the law is a punishment imposed on the Jews for the making and worship of the Golden Calf. I will argue not only that contemporary scholarship seems to be moving in a new direction by emphasizing Syriac Christian rather than rabbinic Jewish “sources” for the Quran, but also that scholars appear to be employing these texts as comparanda in a more responsible way when compared with older scholarship, in which midrashic “prototypes” for Quranic narratives were often invoked in order to highlight Muhammad’s “borrowing” from and “dependence” upon Jewish informants.
|
Pandita Ramabai: Insider or Outsider?
Program Unit: Asian and Asian-American Hermeneutics
D. N. Premnath, St. Bernard's School Of Theology And Ministry
This paper will explore the ambiguity of Pandita Ramabai’s (1858 – 1922) positionality simultaneously as an insider as well as outsider. In the thick of the colonial occupation of the Indian subcontinent by the British, and over against the backdrop of the male-dominated Indian society of that time, the life and work of Ramabai stands out rather unique. Throughout her life she battled with the patriarchy on many fronts: her problems with Brahmanical hierarchy; her conflicts with the male counterparts of the Indian nationalist movement because of their attitude towards her conversion to Christianity; and her conflicts with the Anglican hierarchy over doctrinal matters. Because of her exceptional scholarly abilities, the Brahmanical hierarchy and the Indian leadership of the nationalist movement took pride in the jewel in their crown and in a way expected her to conform to their expectations. Their attitude changed completely after her conversion to Christianity to the point of questioning her ulterior motives. After conversion, the Anglican hierarchy also took pride in showing off their “prized possession” and expected her to tow the line. Through it all, Ramabai remained her own person and insisted on thinking and making decisions for herself. This often gave rise to vicious criticisms and some diametrically opposite perceptions or characterizations: Was she a disprivileged widow and a marginalized Christian? Or was she privileged as a Sanskrit-educated Brahmin and English-educated Christian with an affinity with the hegemonistic Christian community worldwide? How is her Christian idiom and missionary rhetoric distinguishable from that of the western “orientalist” authors of her time? Did her motive of helping women disguise and legitimize her Christianizing agenda? The paper will explore these issues in an effort to seek bring further clarity.
|
The First Reader of Gal 3:28: Clement of Alexandria and the Doctrine of Apokatastasis
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Stephen O. Presley, University of St. Andrews-Scotland
In the second century, Clement of Alexandria stands out as the only noteworthy commentator on Gal 3:28 and his allusions to this passage are essential to his broader doctrine of apokatastasis, or restoration. While the doctrine of restoration has a contentious history in its development after Origen, Andrew Itter has recently noted little attention has been given to the peculiar accepts of Clement’s doctrine of restoration and, more importantly, the scriptural passages that inform his theological refection. This paper, therefore, will explore Clement’s use of Gal 3:28 as an essential tile in the broader mosaic of his doctrine of restoration, which interacts with variety of other texts including 1Cor 12:13 and, especially, Eph 4:13. Clement is drawn to the universalizing claims of Gal 3:28 as a component of the unifying nature of Christian faith received in baptism (Prot 11.112.3, 12.120.2-3; Paid 1.6.30.3-31.1; Str 6.5.41.6-7, 6,17.159.9). Those who receive this faith are unified in the one “whole Christ,” becoming one new human transformed by the Spirit and instructed by the true gnosis. In distinction from the rest of the second century writers, Clement is the first theologian to make use of Gal 3:28 and related texts in the fashioning of his theological framework. It is these passages that lay the groundwork for his theology of restoration that was influential in later controversies.
|
The Samaritans in Flavius Josephus
Program Unit:
Reinhard Pummer, University of Ottawa
This presentation will consist of a brief overview of the author's new book.
|
Postcolonial Studies and Biblical Studies: Methodological Reflections
Program Unit:
Jeremy Punt, University of Stellenbosch
The postcolonial optic has seen rapid growth in biblical studies over recent years. While the approach admits a variety of perspectives of method and orientation, scope and level, a rather generous use of the postcolonial notion runs the risk of deflating its specific value for biblical studies. In terms of understanding the social location of postcolonial biblical studies, both a strong connection and distinction was initially made between postmodernism (or at least, poststructuralism) and postcolonialism. But more recently questions are being asked about the relationship between postcolonial studies on the one hand, and cultural studies and Empire studies, on the other hand. Not only is it important to try and establish some defining lines, no matter how porous any borders between these approaches may be, but at least two immediate questions also frame a response: Why would one want to read the NT in a postcolonial way? and, What would such a reading entail?
|
1 Cor 7:17–24: Identity and Human Dignity amidst Power and Liminality
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Jeremy Punt, University of Stellenbosch
Paul’s concern with identity, and in particular the identity of the believer in relation to Jesus Christ, is an important concern in his writings. In the midst of an important section dedicated to advice and instruction on marriage in the letter, Paul encouraged his audience in 1 Cor 7:17-24 to remain in the state or position in which they were called, referring to circumcision (7:18-19) and slavery (7:21-23) by name. These Pauline instructions are investigated against the backdrop of both the first-century CE context and post-Apartheid South Africa, were issues of identity and marginality rub shoulders with claims to ownership and entitlement on the one hand, and issues of human dignity on the other hand.
|
Kierkegaard’s First Love: On the Role of the Epistle of James in Kierkegaard’s Authorship
Program Unit: Søren Kierkegaard Society
Richard B. Purkarthofer, Howard V. and Edna H. Hong Kierkegaard Library
As early as 1835-36, we find Kierkegaard translating portions of the Epistle of James from Greek into Latin. References and allusions to the Epistle are to be found throughout Kierkegaard’s subsequent writings. In what would become his last edifying discourse, in the last year of his life, Kierkegaard returned once more to a pericope from the Epistle, calling it “my first love.”
My proposed paper will survey the Epistle’s significance for Kierkegaard’s authorship as a whole. Following a brief historical account of Kierkegaard’s use of James, I will investigate a number of stylistic features common to the Epistle and to Kierkegaard’s writings (both published and unpublished). These include dialogical elements, the use of fictive interlocutors, rhetorical questions, and other features typical of the Cynic/Stoic diatribe form, along with the use of Stichwortverbindungen. I will then turn to a number of Kierkegaardian concepts that are heavily influenced by the Epistle of James, such as despair, purity/purification, and simple-mindedness.
By way of conclusion, I will comment on evidence from Kierkegaard’s own copies of the Bible. This includes underlining, notes, and other marks in the Epistle of James, presumably by Kierkegaard’s own hand. I will cite this evidence to support key details of my proposed account of the stylistic and conceptual influence of the Epistle of James on Kierkegaard.
|
Concerning the Nations: Postcolonialism and Propaganda in the Oracles against the Nations
Program Unit: Writing/Reading Jeremiah
Hugh S. Pyper, University of Sheffield
In this paper, the oracles against the nations in Jeremiah will be compared with the propaganda developed by emerging nations in post-colonial struggles against both the colonising powers and their neighbours as potential rivals. I will seek to show that the kind of rhetoric that appears in Jeremiah can be found in modern contexts. A key issue in analysing such propaganda is the potential audience for the material, both internal and external. One characteristic of the negotiation of identity against the realities of overwhelming power differentials is the appeal to secret sources of overwhelming military force. In this regard, comparison of these texts with contemporary propaganda from regimes such as North Korea may shed light on the similarities and differences of the approach to be found in Jeremiah.
|
The Lion King: Yahweh as Sovereign Beast in Israel's Imaginary
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
Hugh S. Pyper, University of Sheffield
Derrida’s series of seminars published as ‘The Sovereign and the Beast’ offer a rich vein of reflection on the way that the limits of the human are marked out both ‘above’ and ‘below’ in the exceptional categories of ‘sovereign’ and ‘beast’. This paper will trace the way in which the Hebrew Bible delimits the human through the double deployment of the figure of Yahweh as both sovereign and beast, a device most clearly demonstrated in the way that the lion is used as metaphor and as narrative element in biblical texts. This particular conflation of beast and sovereign informs subsequent political theology in the Western tradition in ways that have unexpected and underappreciated contemporary consequences for political life.
|
Nothing Left Out! The Interaction of Text, Illustration, and Popular Culture in R. Crumb's "Genesis"
Program Unit: Bible and Popular Culture
Phil Quanbeck II, Augsburg College
When Robert Crumb’s “The Book of Genesis Illustrated” was published in 2009 it drew widespread popular attention. Crumb is a graphic novel celebrity, areputation that began in the so-called underground “comix” of the late 1960’s. Reviewers noted the faux warning on the dust jacket: “adult supervision recommended for minors,” and the claim that all 50 chapters are graphically depicted with “Nothing Left Out!”
Crumb chose to engage the text of Genesis by means of the graphic novel. One result that this was not simply a “retelling” of the story such as the “Classics Illustrated Ten Commandments” a 1956 comic book meant to be a tie-in to the film. Neither is Crumb benignly illustrating a text as in a children’s Bible. What Crumb achieves is both a reading of the text and a performance of the text in graphic novel form.
My paper will explore the way in which Crumb’s Genesis is both a reading (an interpretation) and a performance of the text. The illustrations, I will argue, bring to awareness things in the text which are there but neglected. The sex scenes, for example, are all there in the text, but what does it mean to have them, even modestly, illustrated? The text does make mention of a translator for Joseph, but in Crumb’s illustration, Joseph always speaks to his brothers in hieroglyphs and the translator is visibly present interpreting. Genealogies fill frames and pages and names have faces. The interaction of the graphic novel form and the text, I will argue, creates new readings.
Second, my paper will address some ways in which Crumb’s Genesis can be a useful pedagogical tool in discussing the relationship of reading and imagination and making use of popular cultural forms.
|
Using Processing Instruction to Teach Biblical Hebrew Grammar: An Empirical Study
Program Unit: Applied Linguistics for Biblical Languages
Jennifer Quast, Hebrew Union College - Jewish Institute of Religion
This paper presents the results of an empirical study of the effectiveness of teaching methods for Biblical Hebrew. The study compares student outcomes when learning the Qal perfect through three different types of instruction: no instruction, Grammar-Translation Method, and Processing Instruction. The two experimental groups receiving instruction did so in a distance learning environment, with all instructional materials and exercises administered electronically.
All three treatment groups received a pretest and a posttest to measure their ability to interpret and produce sentences containing the Qal perfect in Biblical Hebrew. In addition, both the Processing Instruction group and the Grammar-Translation group received a delayed posttest. The results of these tests help to answer four different research questions. 1) Is there a difference in the way learners receiving different instruction interpret sentences containing the Qal perfect? 2) Is there a difference in the way learners receiving different instruction produce the Qal perfect? 3) If there are gains in the students’ ability to interpret sentences, are these gains sustained over time? 4) If there are gains in the students’ ability to produce sentences, are these gains sustained over time?
The paper will discuss the design of the study, the instructional materials used, and the empirical results of the study.
|
Stoic and Early Jewish Ethics in the Gospel of John
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Volker Rabens, Ruhr University of Bochum
John’s Gospel has recently been interpreted against the background of Stoic pneumatology (Gitte Buch-Hansen, BZNW 173, Berlin 2010). My paper will start with a critical appraisal of the role that is attributed to the ethical work of the Spirit in Stoicism and John’s Gospel by Buch-Hansen. The second part of the presentation will then expound how people are by the Spirit transformed and empowered for ethical living in early Jewish literature. We will look at the Dead Sea Scrolls (e.g. 1QH 8.14-20) and particularly at the mysticism of Philo Judaeus (e.g. Leg. All. 1.38-39; Quaest. in Exod. 2.29; Gig. 54-55). Against this background we will demonstrate in the final part of the paper that the Gospel of John was part of a milieu in which the ethical work of the Spirit was often implicitly or explicitly understood to be enabled by deeper knowledge of and an intimate relationship with God and with the community of faith. Accordingly, ethical conduct in the Fourth Gospel is not mainly based on how Jesus expects his disciples to behave, as it is sometimes claimed. Rather, the basis is the experience of God’s love. This relational model of transformation is supported, e.g., by Jn. 13:34c where the Johannine Jesus explains that the disciples ought to love one another as [kathos] Christ has loved them. An interpretation that reads this only as a comparative, requiring the disciples to imitate Christ’s love, misses the experiential dimension of the locution. It will be shown, also against the background of other passages (e.g. Jn. 15), that the experience of Jesus’ love is the basis of the disciples’ ability to love others (cf. Bultmann). The Spirit-Paraclete plays an important role in this process because he mediates the intimate presence of Jesus (cf., e.g., 14:15-18).
|
The Role of the Former Northern Kingdom in the Book of the Four
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Jason Radine, Moravian College
The Assyrian conquest of the Northern Kingdom and the rapid growth of the city of Jerusalem present two roughly contemporary events that radically changed life in late eighth-century Judah. The expansion of Jerusalem, presumably with refugees from both the former kingdom of Israel and the countryside of Judah, transformed life in the capital. This historical phenomenon has been a hitherto underexplored topic in the books of Amos, Hosea, and Micah. Internal evidence within the books of Amos and Hosea suggest that the first layer of these books may have been composed after, not before, the fall of Samaria. As such, their initial composition may be contemporary with that of Micah, rather than prior to it. Thus, all three books can be read through the conditions prevailing in late eighth-century Judah. The Book of the Four may have its origins in three roughly contemporary literary works that deal with the dangers that northerners or northern influence may have on a then more cosmopolitan Jerusalem. In this way, a text such as Micah 1:6-9 can be read in a new light.
|
The Stone Tablets, Visual Arts, and Biblical Scholarship from 1500 to the Present
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Art
Jesse Rainbow, Harvard University
For as long as visual artists have attempted to depict the stone tablets of Moses, they have had to grapple with biblical source material that resists any easy translation from the written word to image. On close inspection, Exodus provides remarkably little information regarding the appearance of these iconic objects, and it is not even clear what text was written upon them. For this reason, artistic representations of the tablets from antiquity forward represent a particularly rich repository of exegetical thought. With these generalizations in mind, this paper investigates a particular facet of the representation of the stone tablets in visual arts in the last 500 years: at the same time as post-medieval art has continued to deal with the perennial exegetical issues arising from an enigmatic biblical episode, it has also tracked and “graved” an image of the rise of modern Hebrew philology and post-Enlightenment critical Bible scholarship. In several notable cases, images of the tablets can be read as a sort of history of Jewish-Christian relations. This paper considers a broad range of visual media, including painting, sculpture, and film.
|
John, Elijah, and Naboth: What Does 1 Kings 21 Have to Do with Matthew 14?
Program Unit: Intertextuality in the New Testament
Jesse Rainbow, Harvard University
Numerous commentators have suggested that the figures of Ahab, Jezebel, and Elijah lie behind the Matthew’s account of Herod, Herodias, and John the Baptist (Matt 14:3-12), a theory that is in line with Jesus’ repeated identifications of John as the “Elijah to come.” While resemblances between the two monarchs and their wives are striking, little attention has been paid to the fact that unlike John, Elijah was neither imprisoned nor killed by his royal antagonists. Beginning with this observation, this paper explores the possibility that what Matthew has in mind is not a comparison between John and Elijah, but between John and Naboth, the unfortunate neighbor of Ahab who was swept up in a plot to seize his patrimony (1 Kgs 21:1-29). Like John, Naboth was imprisoned and eventually killed at the insistence of the king's wife, after he had publicly embarrassed the king. Several comparisons between Mark and Matthew suggest that Matthew has in several ways modified his source to improve the correspondences to 1 Kings 21. Finally, this assessment of the relevance of 1 Kings 21 requires us to reevaluate the importance of Elijah. Like Elijah after Naboth’s death, Jesus quickly receives word of the death of John. Moreover, the death of John comes at a point in the Gospel at which the identification of Jesus (rather than John) with Elijah is opportune: in the space of three chapters, Jesus will multiply food (twice), visit the region near Elijah's Zarephath to heal a woman's child, manifest powers in his cloak, and finally, appear transfigured with Elijah himself.
|
The Earliest Representations of the Apostle Addai
Program Unit: Syriac Literature and Interpretations of Sacred Texts
Ilaria L.E. Ramelli, Catholic University of Milan
My study addresses the theme of “ representation of apostolic and missionary figures in Syriac literature” and at the same time falls under the heading, "Syriac apocrypha and pseudepigrapha." I carefully investigate the representation of Addai in its earliest sources known and preserved, Syriac and Greek, that is, the Doctrina Addai, belonging to the genre of the so-called Apocryphal Acts of Apostles, and Eusebius in his own (probably composite) account of the Addai legend in his Historia Ecclesiastica. I draw a comparison between these two sources and tackle the thorny question of their possible sources in turn. In this connection, I shall present a hypothesis concerning the earliest nucleus of the Abgar-Addai legend in Edessa, its formation, and the milieu of its development. This also helps to explain the subsequent appropriation of the apostolic figure of Addai on the part of the newly constituted Edessan orthodoxy at the time of the composition of the Doctrina Addai (and, later on, of the Acta Maris).
|
Origen, Eusebius, and the Doctrine of Apokatastasis
Program Unit: Eusebius and the Construction of a Christian Culture
Ilaria Ramelli, Catholic University of Milan
I shall investigate Eusebius’ relationship to Origen first of all regarding eschatology. Although Eusebius accurately tries to avoid tackling the matter as far as possible (as is evident, for example, from his treatment of Bardaisan of Edessa, a supporter of the doctrine of apokatastasis), on the basis of a close analysis of some key texts I shall argue that Eusebius himself probably was inclined to embrace Origen’s theory of apokatastasis. Depending on time, I could also investigate Origen’s and Eusebius’ respective attitudes toward Greek philosophy, which in fact is a complex issue, and/or, if possible, their relationship to "subordinationism" and "Arianism." This is another thorny question for which a very careful reassessment is needed (both regarding Origen and, arguably, regarding Eusebius and his possible role at Nicaea).
|
Tit 2:2–4, Women Presbyters, and a Patristic Interpretation
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
Ilaria L.E. Ramelli, Catholic University of Milan
I would focus on Tit 2:3 availing myself of feminist analysis joined with a study of Patristic interpretations, also in the light of the socio-ecclesiastical context in which each Father, and especially Origen, lived. I shall argue that, both in the light of the existence of women presbyters in Origen’s day, called presbytides in the Didascalia Apostolorum, and in the light of two variant readings of Tit 2:3, available to him, Origen probably took Tit 2:3-4 to refer to women presbyters’ ministry. I shall examine in particular two passages in which he comments on those verses and I shall show how Origen ascribed the office of teaching to women presbyters. I shall also place Origen’s interpretation of Tit 2:3 against the backdrop of his understanding of female ministries in the church and his comments on the ecclesiastical ministry of Phoebe.
|
Between Rome and Alexandria: Clement, Eusebius, and Jerome on Mark and Philo
Program Unit: Philo of Alexandria
Ilaria Ramelli, Catholic University of Milan
For the section on “Roman Alexandria” I would explore Clement’s tradition on Mark and his Gospel between Rome and Alexandria. Clement seems to have drawn a close connection between Rome and Alexandria; he may have anticipated Eusebius’ view that the Therapeutae described by Philo were Christians living near Alexandria, as a result of Mark’s first preaching there. I shall include in my treatment a critical analysis of Eusebius' and Jerome's information about Philo; in particular, Eusebius' report on Philo is closely related to his report from Clement on Mark's work in Rome. If time permits, I would like to relate this to Clement's controversial letter on the so-called Secret Gospel of Mark, composed in Alexandria. I shall also discuss previous scholarship, in primis David Runia's fundamental work.
|
What's the Harm in Harmonization?
Program Unit: Teaching Biblical Studies in an Undergraduate Liberal Arts Context
Margaret E. Ramey, Messiah College
Whether they carry a picture of shepherds and wise men together adoring the infant Jesus or an image of a dying Jesus speaking seven statements from the cross, many students enter our classrooms with a harmonized portrait of the Gospels. One of the challenges facing biblical studies professors is to help them disentangle these images so that they can begin to appreciate and evaluate each of the four Gospels on their own terms.
Analyzing Jesus films is an excellent way to introduce this topic and to empower students to become critics capable of dissecting harmonizations for themselves and of recognizing how the harmonizations may actually hinder their full appreciation of the portraits constructed by each evangelist. Through this activity, students take on the roles of narrative critic (of the Gospels) and cultural critic (of the films) by examining pre-selected clips. Armed with an introductory knowledge of each evangelist's theological and literary interests and having read their different accounts of one particular event in Jesus' life, students are asked to watch cinematic portrayals of that scene. They then attempt to identify how the different Gospels are being harmonized and to analyze whether the director has relied more heavily on one account over the others. Through raising the issue of harmonization, other important topics, such as that of canonization, the literary and structural features of each Gospel, the theological interests particular to each evangelist, and the difference between the person and the various portrayals of Jesus, are also introduced.
In this session, we will examine a few clips from Jesus films and discuss the potential benefits and possible drawbacks of using such cinematic interpretations to examine the issue of harmonization.
|
Job's Attempt to Regain Control: Traces of a Babylonian Birth Incantation in Job 3
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Karen Rangel, Brite Seminary
In this paper I argue that the first part of Job’s opening speech (Job 3:1-10) is not a lamentation as it has been typically classified, but mimics a reversal of a Babylonian birth incantation. Job is trying to regain control of his life through the use of a magical incantation, directed at the womb, which, rather than a place to create and produce life, becomes the focus of Job’s curse. Job, rather than teach the goodness of creation, comments on the instability of creation and questions God’s control over his life. Others have suggested that Job’s “curse’ is intended to prod God to curse him, allowing him to die (cf. 2:9), or to allow him an audience with God so that he can vindicate himself. An exilic date for the piece, elements of Babylonian birth incantation imagery and Job’s own call to magicians to join him (verse 8), suggest the author is using a literary device to signify Job’s desire to regain the control he once had over his own life.
|
The Punishment of Thine Iniquity
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Rebecca Raphael, Texas State University
In recent years, a divine punishment interpretation (DPI) of natural disasters has been prominent in discourse about Hurricane Katrina, the Haitian Earthquake, and other natural disasters. The study first describes DPI, using videos, documents, and interviews. This task includes identifying proof-texts, narrative structures, and hermeneutical strategies; determining the range of events to which advocates apply DPI; and identifying the interpreters’ socio-political-religious position. Second, the political and rhetorical dimensions of DPI shall be examined. With American culture as the primary focus, I examine how public citations of DPI attribute divine anger to the alleged actions of the affected populations. These allegations encode racial, economic, religious, sexual, and other cultural differences. Thus, DPI articulates and justifies socio-political inequalities by representing them as a result of scarce divine love, for which the people themselves are responsible. The study will conclude by interrogating the biblical text for the accuracy of a divine punishment interpretation of natural disasters. I find that the Bible easily lends itself to this interpretation, and does not easily support counter-interpretations. In the respect, it is similar to the Bible’s easy patriarchal mode, and the relative difficulty of feminist interpretation; and for that reason, critiques of biblical authority itself, rather than reinterpretations, are called for. Even so, contemporary DPI ignores some biblical tension that occurs around the speaker’s position as insider or outsider to the communities subject to it. Finally, in the contemporary context, DPI and environmental science differ greatly not just in their explanatory processes, but also in how they configure the identities of human communities, the value of human actions, and the connections between actions and events.
|
Medicine and Judaism: Physical and Psychological Concepts
Program Unit: Psychology and Biblical Studies
Ilona N. Rashkow, New York University
Popular folklore has it that the watchword of every Jewish mother is, “Ess, ess meine kind” (“Eat, eat my child”), or the modern-day alternative, “Try it, you’ll like it.” Despite these favorite mottos, traditional advice from the Jewish sages was far more concerned with matters of health than is ordinarily assumed. Jewish dietary laws are not health laws, but religious laws addressing the spirit rather than the body, even though many of them contribute to the prevention of illness. Quite apart from all the mandated practices outlined in the Torah, the Talmud, Mishnah, and Midrashic writings that may have health advantages, Jewish sages have been concerned as well about health matters that do not have religious overtones. This paper deals with physical and psychological concepts of health in the Hebrew Bible. Although psychology is relatively new as a formal academic discipline, for many years scholars have pondered the questions that psychologists ask and probably shall do so for many more. Nowhere is this aphorism better exemplified than in the many centuries during which Jewish physicians and thinkers dealt with the problems of behavior and behavior disorders. Many current notions on classification and therapy were foreshadowed in biblical and Talmudic literature, and Jewish philosophers wrestled with the same psychological concepts that still occupy attention today.
|
Stoic Ingredients in the Neoplatonic Being-Life-Mind Triad: An Original Second-Century Gnostic Innovation?
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Tuomas Rasimus, University of Helsinki & Université Laval
In the 1960s, the French scholar Pierre Hadot suggested that Porphyry, the star-student of Plotinus, should be seen as a great innovator and reformer of Plotinus’ thinking, a veritable second founder of Neoplatonism. According to Hadot, Porphyry invented an array of conceptual tools, having combined the metaphysics of Plotinus and the Middleplatonic Chaldean Oracles in an ingenious way to solve the puzzle of how to derive multiplicity from unity, crafting such tools out of Stoic ingredients. These tools, in fact, consisted of various aspects of the famous being-life-mind triad, which Porphyry would have systematized and of which later Neoplatonists, as well as Christian theologians defending the “orthodox” doctrine of the Trinity, made much use. In this paper, I will, on the one hand, argue that Hadot was right in suggesting that the main aspects of the being-life-mind triad can be satisfactorily explained as having been based on Stoic ideas. On the other hand, I claim that Porphyry, in the third century, could not have been the Stoic-minded innovator and/or systematizer of the triad because the triad with its “Porphyrian” aspects is already attested in Sethian/Classic Gnostic texts from the second and third centuries (i.e., they predate Porphyry). The present state of our knowledge, based now also on sources not yet available to Hadot (the Coptic Nag Hammadi codices), strongly suggests that Christian Gnostics of a strong philosophical inclination contributed the being-life-mind triad to the history of Platonism by creatively crafting it out of Stoic elements.
|
Versions of Esther: Hebrew Satire and Greek Drama
Program Unit: Transmission of Traditions in the Second Temple Period
Angela Rasmussen, Catholic University of America
This paper explores the differences between the shared portions of the Hebrew and Old Greek forms of the book of Esther. These textual differences shed light on the striking differences between the two versions and the theology and literary form of each. The Hebrew version of Esther satirizes the Persian king’s feasting and rash legislation, the irrevocability of Persian law, and the self-destructive potential of the Persian Empire. The changes in the beginning and end of the Old Greek (chapters 1-3 and 8-10) remove satirical elements present in the Hebrew, and make the Greek text dramatic rather than satiric. The Greek translation portrays a wedding and failed coronation, followed by Haman’s manipulation of the king to have the Jews slaughtered, and ends with the Jews defending themselves against their enemies with wisdom and courage. These changes were made after the persecution the Jews experienced under Antiochus IV, a persecution that presumably made the original Hebrew story less humorous for the translator and his audience. The paper concludes with a possible meaning behind the satire of the Hebrew version.
|
Interpreting Violent and Voyeuristic Representations of Women within the Apocryphal Acts of the Apostles
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Rosie Ratcliffe, King's College London
Feminist scholars have long highlighted the prominence of chaste, liberated women within the Apocryphal Acts of the Apostles (AAA). However, in focusing on the liberative perspective of the texts there has been a tendency to overlook aspects of the texts which systematically present violent and demeaning images of women. The reality is that within all the stories of the AAA women are voyeuristically exposed, debased and treated violently. How do we interpret such representations of women? It is quite well known that the Roman system of death made a great spectacle of execution and punishment and whilst it is difficult, if not impossible, to evaluate the violent acts or representations of another culture in an objective way, by focusing on ancient art and artefacts scholars are able to glean sufficient data to illuminate the cultural norms that encouraged people to tolerate such images of violence and death. Shelby Brown in her essay ‘Death as Decoration’ focuses on the mosaic art of 2nd – 4th Century AD found in the private houses and villas of the relatively wealthy and persuasively argues that these mosaics provide an informative body of data about Roman attitudes toward violence and death. Similarly Eva Keuls in her Book The Reign of the Phallus examines the painted pottery of the Classical Athenians, perhaps the most widespread of their arts, which portrayed almost every imaginable form of sexual activity to reveal notions of human sexuality and patterns of social dominance. It becomes evident from both Brown and Keuls that such ‘art’ reflects something of real life in transmitting information that incorporates the values of the group to which it belongs. Within this paper I will examine what interpretative light artefacts and art can shed upon the violent and voyeuristic representations of women within the AAA.
|
Philo of Alexandria and the Peripatetic Good in De Somniis II
Program Unit: Hellenistic Moral Philosophy and Early Christianity
M. Jason Reddoch, University of Cincinnati
According to Philo's De Somniis I and II, there are three categories of godsent dreams: 1) those sent directly from God which contain a clear message; 2) those which occur when the soul of the dreamer is moved together with the World Soul and which are somewhat enigmatic; 3) those which are the product of an inspired soul, are particularly enigmatic, and thus, require specialized knowledge of dream interpretation.De Somniis II exclusively deals with dreams which fall in the third category, and Philo's exegesis consists primarily of the two dreams of the patriarch Joseph. Philo often associates Joseph with the Peripatetic notion of the mixed good in contrast to Isaac who is associated with the Stoic position which asserts that only the morally good is truly good and is often expressed in the well known Greek phrase µ???? t? ?a??? ??a???. Despite the fact that there is a clear reference to the philosophical dispositions of the biblical patriarchs in De Somniis II, scholars have failed to notice the close relationship between this association and the dream category in which he puts Joseph, and some have even gone so far as to deny that there is a relationship at all. Furthermore, scholars have also been unable to understand why Joseph's dreams are considered enigmatic when the symbolic meaning of the content seems relatively obvious to the modern reader. I will focus on Philo's treatment of Joseph in order to show that the reference to the enigmatic nature of the third class of dreams has more to do with Philo's evaluation of the clarity of the cognitive experience of the dreamer instead of the content of the dreams. I will also show that Joseph's lack of clarity is understood by Philo to be directly related to his association with the Peripatetic mixed good.
|
No Male and Female? Galatians 4:21–31 and the Allegorical Privilege of the Male
Program Unit: Feminist Hermeneutics of the Bible
Abigail April Redman, Vanderbilt University
Brigitte Kahl, Beverly Gaventa, and Susan Eastman, have argued that female imagery in Galatians “decenters the male” (Kahl, 2000: 41), subverts the male discourse of power under a female discourse of relationship, and is foundational for Paul’s self-understanding and apocalyptic theology. Yet for Paul, femininity is a foil for masculinity, as seen clearly in his allegory of Hagar and Sarah (4.21-31). In contrast to his declaration “no male and female” of Galatians 3.28, the apostle allegorically privileges the spirit over the flesh and the spiritual male over the embodied female. Paul introduces Hagar as the epitomic fleshly woman, whose son “born according to the flesh…persecuted the son born according to the spirit” (4.23, 29). Disgrace results from being born of a woman’s body, much less a Gentile slave woman’s body. Neither Hagar’s womanhood nor her motherhood provides a positive metaphor for Paul’s depiction of the freedom that comes from being sons of God. Amidst his female imagery, only Sarah is positively pictured, and Paul deprives her of physical gender identity. While Sarah remains a mother in Paul’s allegory, she does not give birth in the flesh – this according to Paul would be degrading (4.4, 23, 29); instead, she gives birth to spiritual children. By spiritualizing Sarah’s maternity, he removes the shame of the fleshly female body and reinstates her stigmatizing barrenness. Within an ostensibly female-centered allegory, Paul underscores Abraham’s fatherhood. Hagar and Sarah are vessels for their respective sons, Ishmael and Isaac, the seed of Abraham and the concluding focus of the allegory. Abraham’s literal, fleshly paternity and progeny are spiritualized, but the father-son lineage remains figuratively intact. Ultimately, Paul’s allegory co-opts the feminine for a figuratively male depiction of salvation. There is indeed male and female, and only the male truly represents freedom in Christ.
|
Virtue Ethics and Psalms 111–112
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Stephen A. Reed, Jamestown College
Scholars have often noted the parallels between Psalm 111 and Psalm 112. Both are alphabetic acrostics. Psalm 111 is a praise hymn of the virtues, character and actions of the LORD and Psalm 112 is a wisdom hymn describing the virtues, character and actions of a righteous person. Sometimes the virtues and actions of the LORD are the same as those of the righteous person. Both are gracious and merciful, both help those in need. But there are differences. Humans must fear the LORD and follow his commands. The LORD commands and is mindful of his covenant with humans.
The first question to explore relates to the reasons there are parallels between the two psalms and between divine and human virtues and behavior. What is the conceptuality that links these two psalms together and assumes some correspondence between divine and human ways of life? Is it that humans and the LORD share a common nature? Does the experience of the divine beneficence lead humans to respond in a similar way to others?
A second question is how the juxtaposition of these two psalms shapes how one reads them together. How do the parallels provide guidance for how one ought to live and motivation for why one should live this way? Is it obedience to divine commands, imitation of God, grateful response to God’s beneficence, or expectations of rewards or punishments?
This paper will survey the virtues, character and actions of God in Psalm 111 and compare these to the similar list for humans in Psalm 112. Then it will seek an explanation for the parallels between the two psalms and also address how these psalms function together as didactic psalms which motivate humans to emulate a way of life that mirrors the one of God.
|
Learning-Centered Preaching for Practice-Centered Congregations
Program Unit: Academy of Homiletics
Robert Stephen Reid, University of Dubuque
*
|
Seeing the Word: The Role of "This Book" in the Lived Experience of the Johannine Community
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Adele Reinhartz, University of Ottawa
In John 20:30-31, the Gospel reaches out beyond its own narrative framework to address its readership directly. In doing so, the Gospel is assigning to itself a major role as the foundation for faith in Jesus as the Messiah and Son of Man, on the basis of which its readers will attain "life in his name" (v.31). This paper will examine the implications of this role for the lived experience of the Johannine community, including its relationships with Jesus, the "synagogue" and Jewish practice, and one another. The paper will argue that the Gospel functions in at least two ways: 1. as a substitute for the direct witness of Jesus, to which post-Easter readers did not have access, and, 2. as a document through which community members from different ethnic backgrounds (Jewish, Gentile, Samaritan) could potentially forge a new identity as a distinct and unified group.
|
The Rhetoric of Exile
Program Unit:
David Reis, Bridgewater College
Wandering, displacement, and exile all receive attention in archaic and classical literature, yet it is not until the Hellenistic and Roman periods, when empires emerge to replace polis-based notions of identity, that these ideas become topics of more systematic inquiry. In these later periods, writers produce essays, consolatory letters, and fiction to explore the political, social, and religio-philosophical dimensions of dislocation. In order to appreciate these aspects of exilic literature, this paper will survey how various media (e.g. historiography, geography, poetry, and the built environment) instantiated an imperial ideology onto the late antique Mediterranean world. These “mappings” produced and (re)presented a worldview that linked citizenship with honor, status, and privilege while marking the exile as marginalized and “other.” Yet writings from the Roman Empire draw upon and reconfigure exilic topoi in order to contest, reimagine, and negotiate this imperial narrative. An analysis of these discourses will demonstrate that authors constructed new patterns for thinking about identity so that they might locate a place for themselves on the shifting terrain of the empire’s social map.
|
Recasting a Fish Story
Program Unit: Formation of Luke and Acts
Peter A. Reynolds, Baylor University
I propose that reading Luke 5:1-11 in light of Theon’s discussion of chreia expansion and elaboration (in addition to other elements of rhetorical training such as rhetorical plausibility etc.) sheds light on Luke’s transformation of the pericope from Mark 1:16ff. Theon describes the process of chreia expansion as follows: “We expand the chreia whenever we lengthen the question and answers in it, and the action or suffering, if any” (Prog. 103; Kennedy 21). In the example that he gives, the chreia is given a context that better explains the meaning of the chreia. This process of expansion is described in more detail in the more advanced exercises in which Theon describes the process of elaboration. Other progymnasmata deal with the elaboration of the chreia as a formal exercise with specific steps, but Theon deals with elaboration more generally as it could be applied beyond the chreia. Luke has not followed the exercise of the elaboration of chreia as found in Hermogenes, Libanius and others. What we find in Luke’s version of the calling of the first disciples is similar to the elaboration (exergasia) of a chreia as it is described by Theon.
I will focus particularly on Luke’s movement of this calling further back in narrative time, and the addition of the miracle of the great catch of fish, and how these changes can be better understood with the help of ancient rhetorical handbooks. The fruits of this inquiry can be summarized as follows: Luke’s carefully constructed narrative serves to create a more rhetorically credible narrative, to minimize the possibility of misunderstanding the metaphor of people-fishing, to elaborate on the meaning of the metaphor, and to invite the audience to participate in the mission which was modeled, initiated, and guaranteed by Jesus, and witnessed and taken up by the apostles.
|
Reflections on the Linguistic Dating of Biblical Hebrew Texts
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Robert Rezetko, Radboud Universiteit Nijmegen
All languages are subject to change over time, and ancient Hebrew was no exception in this regard. However, while I affirm diachrony in ancient Hebrew, I also argue that linguistic variation in the Hebrew Bible cannot be used to establish dates of origin of biblical literature. This is largely due to the complex textual and literary histories of biblical books. In this paper I will reflect on two issues related to diachrony in ancient Hebrew and linguistic dating of biblical Hebrew texts. First, some have proposed that the history of English and historical linguistic investigation of developments in this language provide a helpful analogy for the study of diachrony in ancient Hebrew. I will explore various aspects of research on pre-modern English in order to illustrate some of the difficulties with this proposal. Second, most efforts to date parts of the Hebrew Bible on the basis of language lay emphasis on the dating criteria of linguistic distribution and linguistic opposition. I will diagram the locations of a variety of linguistic features in the Hebrew Bible in order to highlight some of the difficulties with pinpointing chronological developments in the language of biblical literature.
|
The Authority and Function of Jewish Scripture in the Acts of Peter and the Pseudo-Clementine Homily
Program Unit: Greek Bible
Helen Rhee, Westmont College
My paper examines and compares the kinds of authority and function the Acts of Peter and the The Pseudo-Clementine Homily ascribe to the Jewish scriptures (the Septuagint) in the contests between Peter and Simon Magus. In the Acts of Peter, the contest between Peter and Simon Magus in Roman forum not only involves the contest of miracles but also centers on a Christological debate. In the latter context, Jewish scriptures, particularly prophetic texts, become Peter’s arsenal and shield in upholding Jesus’ divinity against Simon’s contempt for Jesus’ human nature. The fulfillment of prophecies here has to do with not Jewish messiahship of Jesus but his heavenly origin. Elsewhere in the Acts of Peter, however, where Peter mentions Jesus’ polymorphy, the prophetic texts function to heighten his humanity and passion. In the Pseudo-Clementine Homily, the contest between Peter and Simon in Caesarea revolves around theology—nature
of God and monotheism. In this case, it is Simon who appeals to the Jewish scripture to denigrate monotheism and to deny God’s sovereignty and transcendence. Much like Gnostic and Marcionite outlook, Simon highlights examples of God’s ignorance and inferiority from the first few chapters of Genesis and shows how the Jewish Scripture becomes God’s own enemy. Interestingly, Peter’s response to Simon’s scriptural charge is to prove
internal scriptural contradiction—how those passages used by Simon could be in fact overturned by others which assert the opposite. In these Christian apocryphal texts, Jewish scriptures (prophetic texts) carry important authority and function in (early Christian) Christological and theological disputations,
drawing boundaries between “orthodoxy” and “heresy.”
|
2 Samuel 21:1–14: Expiation for Saul, Ruler Punishment, or Delay of Justice?
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Carrie Rhodes, Andrews University
Execution of Saul’s descendents in 2 Samuel 21 has long been interpreted as resulting from David’s succession motives, and may appear to be posthumous ruler punishment or even expiation on Saul’s behalf. However, the narrative contains indications that Saul’s descendents died for inheritable corporate culpability that polluted the land as as result of his mass murder that violated an oath taken in YHWH’s name. The narrative begins with a famine and ends with the phrase God “was moved by prayer for the land,” which appears to give approval to the actions that precede it. This narrative demonstrates that restoration of justice is necessary for healing of the land. By delaying the famine until the reign of David, who enjoyed a positive relationship with himself, God facilitated limitation of retributive justice to a few individuals.
|
Progymnasmata for Biblical Studies: Literary Mimesis as a Pedagogical Tool in the Undergraduate Classroom
Program Unit: Teaching Biblical Studies in an Undergraduate Liberal Arts Context
James N. Rhodes, Saint Michael's College
In the Hellenistic and Late Antique periods, the basic techniques of prose composition were typically learned through a process of studied imitation (mimesis) of literary forms, with the mastery of basic exercises (progymnasmata) leading to more complex forms of imitation and composition. This paper explores both the potential and the pitfalls of literary mimesis as a teaching tool in the biblical studies classroom as creative writing assignments are designed around various literary forms of the Bible, ranging from the simple (beatitudes) to the moderately difficult (parables and speeches) to the complex (an entire gospel). When properly structured and guided, such exercises hold great potential for helping students develop an awareness of literary form, a sensitivity to the possibility of underlying sources (written or oral) and an appreciation of both the unity and complexity of biblical texts in their present form. The presenter concludes from personal experience that the process is of greater significance than the product, and that even "failed" experiments may have pedagogical value.
|
Clement of Alexandria and the "Catholic Epistle of Barnabas": Soundings in the Reception History of a Rejected Scriptural Text
Program Unit: Christianity in Egypt: Scripture, Tradition, and Reception
James N. Rhodes, Saint Michael's College
Scholarship on the Epistle of Barnabas has often favored Alexandria as a probable place of origin, due in part to Barnabas's predilection for allegorical interpretation. While such a provenance is far from certain, what is clear is that the Epistle found its strongest reception and afterlife among Alexandrian exegetes such as Clement, Origen, and Didymus--to say nothing of its inclusion at the end of Codex Sinaiticus, following Revelation and preceding the Shepherd of Hermas. This paper explores the reception history of the Epistle of Barnabas in Egypt, focusing especially on the explicit citations, implicit allusions, and putative authority of the text in Clement of Alexandria.
|
Law and Narrative in the Book of Esther
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Antonia Richards, Liverpool Hope University College
I propose that the book of Esther is a legal narrative grounded in legal language, including laws, edicts, decrees, administrative procedure, letters, and customs. This legal language does not simply add ambience to the story but in fact drives the structure of the narrative for the purpose of defining/redefining Jewish identity in the Diaspora. Allusions to royal edicts along with Persian and Jewish customs are the pivot on which the problems and resolutions are articulated throughout the book. It is within this legal context that Est. 4 places Persian law in apposition to Jewish law as a focal point for the delineation of Jewish identity. Esther 4 suggests the knowledge of casuistic forms of ANE and Covenant law, as well as apodictic law, and wisdom-law. Est. 4.13-14 serves as an implicit restatement of the covenant relationship in the Diaspora, which lies beneath the apparent secular nature of the book. Ultimately, a new precedent for laws, customs, and behavior is established for the Jews in colonial Persia, while reinforcing covenant as the core for their religious identity.
|
Mark/x after Marxism: Fernando Belo and Contemporary Biblical Exegesis
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
Lance Byron Richey, Cardinal Stritch University
In 1974 Fernando Belo’s _A Materialist Reading of the Gospel of Mark_ combined Marxist and structuralist ideas in order to uncover the revolutionary political themes encoded in Mark’s narrative. Although hailed at the time as a seminal and visionary exegetical strategy, it has been largely forgotten over the last generation due to the simultaneous collapses of structuralism as a dominant theoretical system within the academy and Marxism as a dominant political ideology across much of the globe. While some of Belo’s theoretical and political concerns are undoubtedly dated—how could those of any politically engaged exegesis not be after 35 years?—the widespread scholarly neglect of his work is quite undeserved. Far from being a relic of the leftist academy of the 1970s, Belo’s commentary remains an intellectually exciting and politically powerful attempt to build connections between religion, theory and political action.
In this paper, I will offer a two-fold discussion of Belo’s materialist approach to Mark. First, I offer an analysis of his theoretical discussion of the “Concept of ‘Mode of Production’” in light of subsequent developments in Marxist political theory. Second, I summarize and assess his historical reconstruction of the specific “Mode of Production” operative in first-century Palestine in light of contemporary historical research. I conclude that, while Belo’s work is certainly limited by the state of theory and historical knowledge of his time, his ground-breaking efforts to see the conceptual systems of the biblical world as essentially subversive of their socio-political context remains highly relevant to biblical exegesis in the twenty-first century.
|
Placing the Name, Pushing the Paradigm: A Decade with the Deuteronomistic Name Formula
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Sandra Richter, Asbury Theological Seminary
The 2002 publication of The Deuteronomistic History and the Name Theology: lešakken šemô šam in the Bible and the Ancient Near East (BZAW 318) demonstrated that the important deuteronomic phrase, lešakken šemô šam, is a loan-adaptation of the common Akkadian idiom šuma šakanu, and should be translated with that Akk idiom, "to place his name." By means of the Levantine corpus, the monograph further confirmed that lasûm šemô šam (the frequent biblical Hebrew reflex of lešakken šemô šam in Deut and the DH) is a first millennium NWS calque of the same. Since the 2002 publication, various scholars have attempted to draw out the literary implications of the occurrences of these formulae in Deut and the DH under one rubric of study or another. This paper will interact with the continuing conversation, drawing its own conclusions regarding the literary significance of this important formula in Deut and the DH.
|
Hugh Nibley and the Continuing Pursuit of the Forty-day Literature
Program Unit: Latter-day Saints and the Bible
Stephen D. Ricks, Brigham Young University
The theme of the “forty-day ministry” (or “mission”) of Jesus among his disciples following his resurrection is one of the most intriguing—and puzzling—in biblical history. Following the crucifixion, Jesus’s disciples remained to be persuaded of his literal resurrection in the flesh. But after the “forty-day ministry”—and following his ascension—his disciples were fully prepared to go forth into the world and preach his gospel, despite the appalling prospect of persecution and a nearly certain martyrdom. What occurred during the “forty-day ministry” to prepare the disciples to go forth into the world boldly and unafraid? The late Hugh Nibley articulately and eruditely examined this little known theme in an article that appeared in Vigiliae Christianae in 1966, but which still retains its feshness and relevance. This presentation will evaluate Nibley’s study of the “forty-day ministry,” using apocryphal and gnostic which Nibley did not include, to clarify the picture of this crucial episode; also, a new project to publish a full collection of 40-day texts will be launched.
|
More on Covenant Vocabulary in Akkadian
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Andrew J. Riley, Hebrew Union College - Jewish Institute of Religion
The antonyms râmu (to love) and zêru (to hate) pervade Akkadian documents and adopt numerous functions throughout. For example, it is widely discussed that râmu belongs to covenant vocabulary in certain contexts. Though somewhat overlooked, zêru is also part of rhetoric that is covenantal, legal, and political. This paper adduces several second and first millennium Akkadian texts (letters, annals, an extispicy text, and law codes) that exhibit this function of zêru.
|
The God Who Forsakes: Divine Abandonment in Mark’s Gospel
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Matthew S. Rindge, Gonzaga University
As an attempt to redress what Nils Dahl identified as the “neglected factor” in New Testament theology, this paper explicates Mark’s portrayal of a specific aspect of God’s character. This paper suggests that Jesus’ cry of dereliction (Mark 15:34) is one helpful starting point for providing insight into Mark’s understanding and depiction of God. Mark’s appropriation of Ps 22:1 in particular, and lament language in general, reveals a perception of divine abandonment that resonates with certain Jewish scriptural texts (e.g. lament Psalms, Lamentations, Job). Moreover, Mark’s perception of a forsaking God comports with and illuminates many other parts of the second gospel (e.g. the voice from heaven at the baptism, the three passion predictions, the disputed ending in chapter 16). I conclude by suggesting specific reasons why Mark may have portrayed a “forsaking” God to the specific community to whom he addressed his gospel.
|
Intertextual Wisdom: Luke 12:13–34 and the Sapiential Conversation on Death and Possessions
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
Matthew S. Rindge, Gonzaga University
Luke’s parable of the “Rich Fool” (12:16-21) cites Qoh 8:15 and alludes to Sir 11:14-19. Some interpreters have noted these parallels, but have paid scant attention to the specific ways in which Luke appropriates and reconfigures these Jewish intertexts. These texts in Qoheleth and Ben Sira belong to a broader sapiential conversation in the Second Temple period on the interplay of death and possessions. At the heart of this contested conversation are questions and recommendations regarding the meaningful use of possessions given death’s inevitability and uncertain timing. This paper shows how Luke’s parable and immediate literary context (12:13-34) illustrates this sapiential conversation by appropriating and reconfiguring elements of it for Luke’s own existential, ethical, and theological concerns.
|
Singing the Psalms to Profit the Soul: Psalmody and Ethical Formation in Athanasius of Alexandria
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
C. Rebecca Rine, University of Virginia
As Brian Brock has noted in his 2007 monograph, Singing the Ethos of God, the question of how one’s reading – or singing – of the Psalms relates to one’s ethical formation has, at times, been difficult to answer. Athanasius, bishop of Alexandria in the mid-350s, offers a multifaceted response to this question in his “Letter to Marcellinus on the Interpretation of the Psalms.” Athanasius presents the Psalms as distinctive: whereas each book of the Bible bears its own special kind of fruit, the Psalms are like a garden which bears not only a special Psalm-fruit, as it were, but also all the other kinds of “fruit” cultivated in scripture. Furthermore, the Psalms offer what the rest of scripture cannot, for the Psalms themselves are the means by which a person becomes virtuous. While other books describe or command virtuous living, the Psalms facilitate it. This function of the Psalms is rooted in their author – Christ. For Athanasius, Christ is not just the speaker of certain Psalms, but the writer of the whole book of Psalms. Thus, both the Psalms and Christ’s incarnation offer a model of virtue and a means to attain it. Further, the Psalms provide a lexicon for virtuous living, teaching the Christian exactly what to say in the varied circumstances of life. This lexicon, however, is not designed primarily for speaking, but for singing. For Athanasius, it is the singing of the Psalms that both reflects and brings about the proper ordering of the self. Athanasius’ claims about psalmody and ethical formation, when situated in the context of ancient music theory and Hellenistic spiritual training (via the work of Paul Kolbet, Brian Daley, and Peter Jeffrey), illuminate contemporary discussions about exegesis, ethics, and the role of the Psalter (via the work of Brian Brock and Jason Byassee).
|
Canon Lists Are Not Just Lists
Program Unit: Function of Apocryphal and Pseudepigraphal Writings in Early Judaism and Early Christianity
Rebecca Rine, University of Virginia
Scholars who are interested in the development of the biblical canon sometimes excerpt “canon lists” from ancient writings and submit them to side-by-side comparison. While this format facilitates comparison of the content of these lists, it also obscures the function of these lists in their original literary/rhetorical contexts. Closer examination of these contexts reveals that these lists are rarely presented as authoritative declarations of which books are “in” or “out of” the canon. Instead, they are presented in richly textured ways that suggest how certain books were read, who could/should read them, and the nature of their authority. The aim of this presentation, then, is to focus attention on the ways that books now considered “noncanonical” in one or more communities are presented in or alongside of “canon lists.” For instance, Cyril, Athanasius, Jerome, and Augustine provide lists of books in the Old and New Testaments – but each offers a distinctive perspective on the significance of such a list. Cyril and Athanasius are concerned with the line between scripture and writings which falsely purport to be scripture. Thus, Athanasius distinguishes between writings that are canonical, writings that are not canonical but are still edificatory, and writings that are apocryphal and thus should be avoided entirely. Jerome and Augustine, however, are more interested in the line between scripture and literature in general. Jerome compares the reading of scripture with the reading of literary classics, and seems to suggest a bipartite structure of written works: scripture, and everything else. Augustine acknowledges that some books are “more canonical” than others, and provides criteria by which to evaluate disputed books. In sum, rereading the so-called canon lists as more than just lists helps us understand the function of the “noncanonical” works. This presentation surveys the examples mentioned here in addition to others.
|
Wayyiqtol: An Unlikely Preterite
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Elizabeth Robar, University of Cambridge
In both form and function, the wayyiqtol form is widely considered to be a preterite, derived diachronically from Proto-Northwest Semitic short yaqtul, an earlier jussive and preterite (compared to long yaqtulu, an imperfective present/future). This view has significant syntactic and morphological problems. The syntactic distribution of wayyiqtol is severely restricted, unlike the standard narrative tense (preterite) of other languages. Morphologically, the long and short yiqtol/wayyiqtol forms do not align with their alleged derivations: wayyiqtol is sometimes long, long yiqtol forms can function as jussives, and short yiqtol forms can function as futures. These unexpected combinations of form and function force a re-evaluation of assumptions about short and long yiqtol/wayyiqtol.
Based on the comparative Semitic context (in particular, neo-Aramaic) and the presumed evolution of the Hebrew verbal system, the long versus short distinction appears able to function in multiple ways (semantic and pragmatic), aligning with different stages in the process of grammaticalization. Based on a broader linguistic context of verb forms with similar syntactic distribution to Hebrew wayyiqtol, the wayyiqtol form seems opposed to qatal not in terms of tense, aspect, or staging/foregrounding, but rather as a strategy for basic discourse organization. The syntactic constraints of the wayyiqtol form and the unexpected non-preterite semantics together argue that wayyiqtol in Biblical Hebrew functions not (or no longer) as a preterite. Instead, its discourse profile accords far better with that of an historic present, as in neo-Aramaic or even conversational English, in which a "tense-neutralized" form serves to mark discourse continuity, for the sake of facilitating discourse unit demarcation. With this view, the conundrum of both long and short wayyiqtol forms, and of wayyiqtol forms with clear non-preterite function, is no longer problematic.
|
Approaches to the Study of the Qur'an
Program Unit: Qur'an and Biblical Literature
Vernon Robbins, Emory University
**
|
The Category of Emotion in New Testament Studies
Program Unit: Redescribing Christian Origins
Erin Roberts, University of South Carolina
This paper provides a critical examination of the concept of emotion as a category of analysis in modern gospels scholarship. It argues that the study of emotion and the gospels is marked by a failure to account for cross-cultural and trans-historical varieties of emotion theory, and that this problem stems from the relative isolation of New Testament (NT) studies within the human sciences. Although other areas of the academic study of religion actively engage in cross- and multi- disciplinary theorization and research, scholars of the NT are often set apart (either by their own impetus or by departmental structures) from the humanistic enterprise of the modern university. Through a focused account of the ways that other disciplines within the human sciences have conducted the theoretical legwork necessary to create an academic conception of emotion, the paper offers a set of theoretical and methodological correctives for the use of the category of emotion in the study of the NT gospels. The proposed correctives are then illustrated through the example of the emotion of anger in the Gospel of Matthew in order to demonstrate how a rectified conception of the category of emotion can contribute to the intellectual and social history of the synoptic gospels.
|
Considerations of Hamartia as “Sin” in Proto-Christian Texts
Program Unit: North American Association for the Study of Religion
Erin Roberts, University of South Carolina
Modern English translations of the New Testament consistently render the Greek term hamartia as “sin.” English translations of Greek philosophical texts, however, consistently avoid such translations of hamartia and gravitate, instead, toward terms such as “mistake,” “error,” or “things we get wrong.” I argue that this bifurcation reflects modern interests rather than ancient ones and that it has several unappealing consequences. First, the palpable difference in translation implies that the New Testament texts are unique departures from the dominant discourse of the time. Second, this difference reifies an imagined divide between emergent or proto- Christian texts (i.e., “Jewish” and “religious”) and those penned by non-Judean cultural producers (i.e., “pagan” or “philosophical”). Third, the unqualified use of the translation “sin” brings with it the possibility that readers will import Christian doctrines about sin onto texts written well before these doctrines were even developed.
|
God's Melancholia
Program Unit:
F. Morgan Roberts, Retired Pastor, Presbyterian Church, U.S.A.
*
|
Shaking Out the Past: Anthropological Approaches to Natural Disaster in the Eighth Century
Program Unit: Social Sciences and the Interpretation of the Hebrew Scriptures
Ryan N. Roberts, University of California Los Angeles
The recent massive earthquakes in Haiti and Chile are further reminders of the devastating realities of natural disasters. While the Levant has experienced a number of earthquakes, due to its close proximity to the Dead Sea Transform, the Hebrew Bible appears to record clearly only one earthquake known as “Amos’s,” “Uzziah’s,” or “Zechariah’s” (Amos 1:1; Zech 14:5). This earthquake, however, has been postulated as an ancient “Big One” due to the twenty plus archaeological sites with purported seismic damage. While it is difficult to identify actual seismic damage, it is clear that the quake must have had a profound effect on Levantine culture. The psychological and social impacts from this quake however have lacked adequate treatment. This paper will use anthropological advances in the study of natural disasters as a means to help illuminate the societal impact of this quake. Particular importance will be placed on how the natural disaster was a totalizing event impacting almost all facets of life. Specific attention will be given to passages in the eighth century prophets, some of which have been studied more through the lens of Assyrian military incursions and/or social injustice, rather than a result of a large natural disaster.
|
Stretched to Its Limits: Clarifying the Scope of Amos’s Earthquake
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Ryan N. Roberts, UCLA
The extent of the eighth century earthquake during the reign of Uzziah that is recorded in Amos 1:1 (“two years before the earthquake”) remains difficult to quantify. While archaeologists have suggested over twenty sites with seismic damage ranging from Hazor to Timna and from the Mediterranean coast to the Transjordan, the sheer scope of the purported damage borders on unbelievable. Indeed, while Hazor appears to have clear seismic damage seen in tilted walls and pillars, sites further south lack lucid evidence and results are often tied to tentative suggestions. This study therefore will first survey recent seismological approaches to the extent of the quake illustrating the difficulties in assessing ancient quakes. Next the study will turn to archaeological data with special attention given to evaluating the type of damage listed in the excavation reports in order to suggest a more regionalized earthquake. Lastly, seismic language from eighth century prophets will be adduced as an avenue to assess one of the world’s first textually recorded earthquakes. In this way, it is possible to reconstruct historical memories of the quake in biblical literature and provide another avenue for delimiting the area of the 759 BCE earthquake.
|
The Ritualized Rhetoric of Priestly Transformation
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Amy H.C. Robertson, Emory University
This paper examines the way in which the establishment of the priesthood and the associated transformation of lay Israelites into priests is described in Exod 28-9, Exod 39, and Lev 8. Because this ritual was presumably an infrequent occurrence – and one for which most Israelites would not be present as witnesses in any case – I pay particular attention to the way in which the priestly garments and ordination are described in a manner that increases readers’ willingness to accept that ritualized transformation. This is accomplished by using both ritualized language and ritualized action to create indexical and symbolic connections between the priesthood and the tabernacle.
I argue in this paper that the ritualized, ekphrastic account of the tabernacle in which the priesthood is embedded offers a rhetorical tool for the subject of the priesthood to be introduced in a way that is unlikely to inspire dissent. Rather than direct discourse about the importance of the priesthood, which might be perceived as unseemly, the priesthood is introduced in a way that discourages the reader from paying direct attention to its importance. Instead, the text creates strong connections between the priesthood and the tabernacle, an emblem of stability, timeless, and a godliness. Tapping into the sense of shared community purpose and the positive emotions associated with constancy in relation to God, the priests are indexed as part of the tabernacle furnishings in terms of how they are clothed, how they are anointed, and in the patterns of speech used to describe their priestly garments. The body of the high priest carries upon it the name of God and the name of each tribe, suggesting it is his body, more so than the tabernacle, that serves as the symbolic space in which Israel and God meet. According to the rhetoric of Exod 25-40, a reader who considers him or herself to be part of the community of the tabernacle must also consider him or herself to be part of the community supporting the priests. If they buy into the one, they have essentially bought into the other.
|
De-Spiritualizing Pneuma: Modernity, Religion, and the Consequences of Anachronism
Program Unit: North American Association for the Study of Religion
Paul Robertson, Brown University
Bible translators and scholars across the English-speaking Western world translate pneuma as “Spirit” (note the capitalization) or even “Holy Spirit.” This translation, however, is an importation of modern Lutheran/Protestant Christian thought into the ancient material. In this paper, I argue that this anachronistic distortion is part of a theoretically unfortunate feedback loop, wherein ancient sources are read using modern lenses, and these (now-distorted) ancient sources are then used to undergird modern definitions, translations, and theories of religion. Further, I argue that the problems of distortion and translation are directly related to modern dependence on mind/body dualism. The modern concept of “spirit,” irrespective of any understanding of pneuma, is one that implies a complete separation between the earthly and the divine, which in turn is related to the separation of mind and body. Yet these two separations would have seemed strange to ancient philosophers and writers. Recent work has shown that ancient thinkers envisioned a psycho-physical holism instead of the modern dualism. Furthermore, the concept of pneuma in the ancient world was envisioned as part of an ontological hierarchy of substances, not a strict separation of earthly and divine. Finally, religion was not an individual, private, interior activity, but one that was more widely integrated into the broader social sphere. By translating pneuma as Spirit, modern writers de-contextualize the word from its ancient context and thus misunderstand pneuma’s function in ancient texts. Through a brief investigation of pneuma in several ancient thinkers – the Stoics, Paul, Philo, and Galen – I offer a methodological corrective and seek to rectify the category of pneuma.
|
Philo and Sacrifice in the Roman World
Program Unit: Philo of Alexandria
Paul Robertson, Brown University
This paper attempts to theorize Philo and his comments on Jewish sacrifice in the light of broader ideas of sacrifice and society in the Roman world. While many scholars have described Philo’s theory of sacrifice as purely spiritual, I argue that the physical/spiritual distinction is an anachronism with little explanatory power. Philo’s theory of sacrifice is the product of a cosmology common to the Roman world, and I review both the primary and secondary literature on the subject in coming to my own conclusions about Philo’s understanding of sacrifice. It is useful in explaining Philo’s approach to theorize his intellectual, cultural, and material position in the Roman world, paying special attention to the work of Bourdieu, Foucault, and Rappaport. Comparisons will be made with the approaches and understandings of such Roman thinkers as Cicero, with discussions attendant to their differences as well. I will then also attempt to explain why Philo focused on sacrifice at all. I suggest that the Roman world evidences certain common practices and conceptions with regard to sacrifice that both constrain Philo’s ability to speak of sacrifice and open up new avenues for his thought. I conclude that Philo is very much a product of his Roman world, despite some modern views that see him as ‘uniquely Jewish’. I end with some reflections on the role that sacrifice plays in the intellectual and social worlds of intellectuals and philosophers such as Philo and Cicero.
|
The Decorative Program in the Non-royal Tombs at Akhetaten in Egypt
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Iconography and the Bible
Gay Robins, Emory University
In 18th dynasty non-royal Theban tombs, the decoration in the outer room of the chapel is where the tomb owner presents himself to visitors, displaying his status, official duties, and relationship to the king in the so-called daily life scenes. The decoration in the inner spaces relates to the funeral rituals and on-going funerary cult. Throughout the chapel, the major figure in the decoration is the tomb owner himself. When the court moved to Akhetaten in the reign of Akhenaten, tombs were constructed there for many of the city’s high officials. At first sight, the decorative program of their tomb chapels appears to have completely changed. The dominant figures are those of the king and queen, while the tomb owner’s figures are minute by comparison. “Daily life” scenes all but disappear to be replaced by the activities of the royal couple under the Aten disk, set in the temples, palaces, and streets of Akhetaten. In this paper, I will demonstrate that despite these changes the outer room remains the place of self-presentation by the tomb owner and the inner room the location of scenes relating to the funeral or funerary cult. I will argue that in each chapel, the decoration of the outer room is designed to showcase the owner’s office, the location of his official duties, and his relationship to the king, while the inner room, most often never finished, was intended to relate to the funeral or funerary cult of the owner. Thus, although the subject matter used to decorate officials’ tomb chapels at Akhetaten changed, the basic division between the self-presentation of the owner in the outer room and the funerary ritual in the inner spaces still underlay the design of the decorative program.
|
The Valley of the Muses by Helicon: Affective Landscape to Rural Sanctuary
Program Unit: Archaeology of Religion in the Roman World
Betsey Robinson, Vanderbilt University
Mount Helicon’s greatest claim to fame is as the place where Hesiod was inspired to write the Theogony. The poet reported that he was grazing his sheep in an upland valley when the Muses appeared and inspired his song (Theog 22-34). Although Hesiod claimed to have dedicated a tripod in Helicon’s shadow (Works 654-659; Paus. 9.31.3), excavations have revealed limited evidence of Archaic-Classical activity at the site. It was only later that a sanctuary developed, under Ptolemaic, local Greek, and later, Roman patronage. Despite broad interest, continued benefaction, and visits from increasingly diverse pilgrims and participants in the Mouseia, the sanctuary in the Valley of the Muses never grew beyond a small core-group of buildings. A review of archaeological remains and comparison to literary and artistic sources suggests that the site was consciously preserved as a locus amoenus, an appropriately "pleasant place" for the spiritual home of the Muses and their favored sons. In exploring this hypothesis, I hope to shed light on relationships between the realia and representations of rural sanctuaries and to engender discussion about affective landscapes and religious institutions.
|
The Dynasty of Jehu in Chronicles
Program Unit: Chronicles-Ezra-Nehemiah
Jonathan Miles Robker, University of Erlangen
The kingdom of Israel plays an interesting role in the Book of Chronicles, appearing
generally only as the redactor of the Book saw fit in the contexts of Judean narratives. However, based
on the appearances of Israel in Chronicles, one can identify specific tendencies of the Chronicler
regarding Israel. Recently, an essay based on a lecture by Ehud ben Zvi focused on the image of the
House of Omri within Chronicles. Using this as a starting point, we will make an examination of the
house of Jehu as presented in Chronicles. As the Jehuide kings of Israel were the longest reigning
dynasty in the Northern Kingdom, one could anticipate extensive narrative interaction within the Book
of Chronicles. Not only will we find this to be untrue, but the Chronicler has also de-constructed the
House of Jehu as presented with the Book of Kings.
|
Elisha and the ‘Voice’ at Horeb (1 Kgs 19:1–13): Narrative Sequence in the Massoretic Text and Josephus
Program Unit: Josephus
Max Rogland, Erskine Theological Seminary
The account in 1 Kings 19 of Elijah’s flight to Mt. Horeb and his encounter there with Yahweh is one that has long fascinated – and challenged – Biblical interpreters. Of the many puzzles presented by this text, this study will focus on the peculiar narrative sequence encountered in vv.11-13, in which Elijah appears to delay obeying the “still small voice” which instructed him to exit his cave in order to stand before Yahweh. This delay on Elijah’s part has been explained in various ways, whether as a negative characterization of the prophet, as an indication of textual corruption, or as evidence of multiple sources from which the Biblical narrative has been composed. Josephus’ presentation of the account, however, indicates an understanding of the narrative sequence of events which is quite different than the Massoretic Text as it is typically interpreted. This paper examines Josephus’ presentation of the account and argues that it represents a reading of Biblical material that is not only viable but is, in fact, exegetically superior to the common understanding.
|
The Strategy of Q: A Postcolonial Analysis?
Program Unit: Q
Sarah Rollens, University of Toronto
This paper analyzes the rhetoric of the early Christian source document Q under the theoretical framework of postcolonial theory. Although many scholars have commented on aspects of the social situation that Q reflects (e.g., violence, deracination, marginality), there has been no coherent effort to read these features within the
framework of postcolonial theory or to describe the ideology (i.e., the nexus of mainly unspoken assumptions about social and economic relations) that makes sense of Q's overt
statements and attitudes. This paper aims to use the framework of postcolonial theory as a focusing lens for understanding the logic and efficacy of Q's social critique. As a text, Q appears to be generated by a somewhat subaltern group, unlike many elite literary
products that make up most ancient literary remains, and thus it offers the opportunity to look closely at the ways in which dispossessed figures viewed key categories that
later became standard Christian rhetoric (e.g., kingdom, oppression, poverty). Accordingly, this paper views Q as a strategic response to certain colonizing forces
(both social and political), and suggests how this response, which entails an overt social critique and an imagined alternative social order, benefits from a postcolonial
analysis: the imagined social order in some ways accommodates the dominant social and political powers by recommending ways to navigate them (e.g., 6:29?30), but at the same time, the text also appears to resist or avoid these oppressive powers (e.g., 12:58?59).
Thus, the main thrust of the paper focuses on how?-by what particular strategies?-Q's rhetoric accommodates, resists, or confronts the systemic oppression that the authors
experienced. In short, postcolonial theory, as a framework made possible by the recognition of the consequences of external powers imposed on peoples, helps sharpen the
conclusions about Q's social critique and its efficacy.
|
The Assessment Thus Far: Critique of Capps and Helsel
Program Unit:
Wayne Rollins, Hartford Seminary
*
|
An Inscription Does Not a Kingdom Make: Methodological Musings about Statecraft and Writing
Program Unit:
Christopher Rollston, Emmanuel School of Religion
During recent years, it has become rather common for scholars to use modest epigraphic discoveries as the basis for grandiose claims about statecraft. For methodological reasons, this is problematic. Rollston's paper will be methodological in nature, focusing on the sorts of epigraphic remains that are cogent bases for discussions about statecraft, and those that are not.
|
Northwest Semitic Epigraphic Evidence of the 10th and 9th Centuries BCE: A Critical Review
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Christopher Rollston, Emmanuel School of Religion
Because the 10th and 9th centuries are an axial age in the Levant, the epigraphic evidence from those horizons is of particular importance for constructs of society and culture. Within this presentation, selected epigraphs in Phoenician and Aramaic will be discussed and set in the context of the broader Levantine world. Among the foci will also be the subject of the security of the methodologies for dating epigraphic materials.
|
Justification and Protest: Two Components of the Theodical Discourse, or – the Need for Tanakh (Hebrew Bible) Theology
Program Unit: Theology of the Hebrew Scriptures
Dalit Rom-Shiloni, Tel Aviv University
Theodicy is one good example for the superimposition of Christian biblical terminology on Hebrew Bible theology. Based on historiographic, prophetic and poetic sources of the early sixth century BCE, sources that discuss the roles God played in the destruction of Judah and Jerusalem, this paper re-examines the terminology coined by G. W. Leibniz and adopted by biblical theologians. Restricting theodicy to “divine justice” and to justifying God, brought (Christian) scholars to exclude laments from the theological discourse, and subsequently to question whether the book of Lamentations advances perceptions of theodicy (Johan Renkema, 2003). The multifacet theological deliberation within biblical sources brings me to suggest to broaden the definition of theodicy by content and by “tone”. By content, theodicy means not only “God's justice”, but “the justification of God” referring to all the roles God plays in events of national defeat and destruction. By “tone”, I argue that theodicy is not restricted only to the justification of God, but covers the entire spectrum of theological reactions, including doubt and protest as genuine components of the efforts to justify God. Re-coining the theological terminology from within, I suggest to transform the term “theodicy” with “theodical discourse,” which thus reflects the constant interaction between justification, doubt, and protest within the talk to and about God in the Hebrew Bible.
|
The Covenant in the Book of Jeremiah: On the Employment of Marital and Political Metaphors
Program Unit: Covenant in the Persian Period
Dalit Rom-Shiloni, Tel Aviv University
The covenant conception governs prophecies of judgment and serves at the background of prophecies of consolation in the book of Jeremiah. This paper presents the marital and political metaphors, two interchangeable metaphoric patterns to the relationship between God and His people, which were in use in contemporaneous biblical literature of the early sixth century BCE. Yet between the two patterns, the political metaphor prevails in both poetic and prose passages in Jeremiah. It illustrates the initiation of the covenant between God and the people in the past, the deity's and the people's past and present commitments to it, the responsibility for its current violation, the judgement that awaits its violators, and the prospects for its future re-establishment. The study addresses authorial questions that challenge scholars in the book of Jeremiah, and points out the wide idiosyncratic Jeremian interpretive usage of the Deuteronomic (political) covenant and the utilization of legal traditions in Jeremiah to support the prophetic message.
|
Book-Endings in Joshua and the End of the Deuteronomistic History
Program Unit: Joshua-Judges
Thomas Römer, University of Lausanne
In the Hebrew Bible several cases of Books with multiple conclusions can be detected. Most scholars agree that the book of Leviticus initially ended with chapter 26, and that chapter 27 is a later conclusion, the aim of which is still debated. The Septuagint of Jeremiah probably reflects a Hebrew Vorlage with a double conclusion. Another example can be found at the end of Malachi (Mal 3:22-24). The end of the book of Joshua compares to these cases. In chapters 23 and 24 Joshua holds two final discourses addressed to the people, and critical scholarship agrees on the fact that these speeches were written by different authors. But these two chapters are not the only possible conclusions of the book. Joshua contains indeed an impressive number of passages that look like attempts to conclude earlier versions of the book or parts of it. Before discussing the relationship between Josh. 23 and 24 the paper will have a look at these texts and locate them in the process of the book’s formation.
|
Moses, Israel’s First Prophet, and the Formation of the Deuteronomistic History
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Thomas Römer, University of Lausanne
In Deut 18 :15-20 Moses is presented as Israel’s first Prophet who inaugurates a succession of nebiim, who are understood as mediators between Yhwh and his people. This idea fits well with the statement that Yhwh sent permanently his « servant the prophets » in order to teach Israel to live according to the divine law (2 Kgs 17 :13-15 ; Jer 7 :25-26). It fits less with the Prophetic stories in the book of kings, which are not very interested to present Elijah or Elisha as law preachers. This raises the question of the insertion of this material in the book of Kings. It seems in fact the “Deuteronomists” had a certain conception of prophecy that occurs especially in the book of Jeremiah, which they may have edited. Other prophetic books probably arose first in a different sociological group.
|
The Legion Narrative of Mark 5: The Interiorization of Oppression and Distortion of Identity in the Postcolonial Caribbean
Program Unit: Islands, Islanders, and Scriptures
Garnett Roper, Jamaica Theological Seminary
The reading of the Gospel of Mark as an anti-imperial document among minority voices in the locus imperium coincides with, and finds resonance with, voices from the margin. In particular Mark 5, which is a day in the life and ministry of Jesus, and a day—any day—in the far flung places of the Roman empire, is typical of the lived experience of the Caribbean: violent men, exploited women and children whose future is at risk. This paper takes a special interest in Legion. It suggests that both the question “What is your name” and the answer “My name is legion for we are many ” are useful points of departure to reflect upon the issues of multiple identity and the distortion of identity that bedevil the postcolonial Caribbean.
The paper posits Legion as resonating with the legacy of resistance and struggle through such figures as Marcus Garvey and Alexander Bedward and movements like Rastafarianism. It will explore the role of big business, political power and the agents of cultural impositions in the perpetuation of the legacy of inequality and self-rejection in the Caribbean. It will discuss the expansion of gun culture and the collapse of economic models as the new evil spirits and the sources of the demonization of Caribbean young people. Finally it will explore the ways in which God’s grace and power through Jesus Christ can make a difference at this time in the Caribbean.
|
Blood, Virginity, and Impurity: The Use of Menstrual Laws in Response to the Violence of Sex
Program Unit: Social History of Formative Christianity and Judaism
Michael Rosenberg, Jewish Theological Seminary of America
The biblical tradition inherited by the Rabbis reveals a very clear stance towards the blood caused by the rupture of a woman's hymen: it is a desired outcome, verifying the virginity of a bride on her wedding night. Significantly, this hymenal bleeding is never mentioned in priestly literature, and it would seem that it was not considered relevant for purposes of purity and impurity.
However, a trend with its roots in the early Rabbinic period, but which really takes hold in Babylonian Rabbinic texts from approximately the fourth century CE and later, upends this biblical paradigm. Later Babylonian Rabbis and/or their editors come to treat hymenal bleeding as if it were menstrual blood, generating both ritual impurity and a prohibition on sexual relations. At the same time and place, the significance of hymenal blood as a means of verifying virginity decreases. These developments are the mirror images one of the other: on the one hand, hymenal blood had been irrelevant in the realm of purity laws, but by the late Talmudic period, it was held to generate impurity; on the other hand, the rupture of the hymen had been a legally sought-after phenomenon in the context of personal law, but becomes, again by the late Talmudic period, irrelevant. These two inverse developments, it will be argued, represent a Rabbinic attempt to influence a culture to reconsider its valorization of males’ causing of bleeding on the wedding night.
|
The Table and Early Judaism III
Program Unit: Meals in the Greco-Roman World
Jordan Rosenblum, University of Wisconsin-Madison
This paper will propose a set of theses defining the table as a generative locus for social formation in early Judaism.
|
The Text of the Lord's Prayer in Marcion's Gospel
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Dieter T. Roth, Johannes Gutenberg-Universität Mainz
In text-critical studies of the Lukan version of the Lord’s Prayer (Luke 11:2–4), one of the most interesting, and at the same time most problematic, witnesses is Marcion’s Gospel. As is well known, in attempting to evaluate readings in this gospel a significant problem immediately presents itself in that there are no extant copies of Marcion’s text and the only testimony of it is found in the writings of Marcion’s opponents. An additional difficulty when considering the Lord's Prayer in Marcion’s Gospel is that apart from the attestation of one petition in an Origen fragment, Tertullian is the only witness for these verses in Marcion’s text, and unfortunately Tertullian has rephrased the prayer’s petitions as questions. Despite numerous scholarly discussions of individual elements in Marcion’s text of the Lord’s Prayer, including two particularly valuable contributions by Joël Delobel and Ulrich Schmid, considerable lack of clarity remains concerning Marcion’s testimony. This lack of clarity is evidenced not only in the literature on the Lord’s Prayer, but also in problematic references in the apparatus of NA27 and UBS4. This paper, therefore, focuses on providing insight into methodological considerations when analyzing Tertullian’s testimony and attempting to clarify and more firmly establish what readings are actually attested for Marcion’s text of the Lord’s Prayer. In this way, this study hopes to contribute to advancing the status quaestionis and dispelling some of the present misunderstandings concerning the witness of Marcion’s Gospel to the Lukan form of the Lord’s Prayer.
|
Embryology, Plant Biology and Divine Generation in the Fourth Gospel
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
Clare Rothschild, Lewis University
Adele Reinhartz and Turid Karlsen Seim propose that that ‘Aristotelian epigenesis’ constitutes the background for ‘birth’ in the Gospel of John. In this essay I explore the validity of this thesis, arguing rather that the ancient scientific theory of plant generation known as parthenogenesis better explains the evidence. Medical theories attempting to explain animal and plant generation loom in the background of a wide range of ancient theological and philosophical texts. Although the argument must be made, not assumed, the latter often demonstrate reliance on the former. For example, John 1:12—13 (sans variante) presents a principle of divine generation for Jesus and his followers that is built on a model of plant parthenogenesis. John 3:3—10 offers a pedagogical illustration of the generation theory and John 1:14, 3:16 and 18 feature an adjective (µ????e???) denoting it. In terms of the tradition’s origin, it may be possible to trace a connection to the Synoptic Gospels. That is, the Fourth Gospel may shift parthenogenesis from an explanation of Jesus’ biological birth (attested in Matthew and Luke) to an explanation of Jesus’ divine birth.
|
Paul's Designations for Members of the Jesus Movement
Program Unit: Extent of Theological Diversity in Earliest Christianity
Eric Rowe, University of Notre Dame
In recent years, scholars addressing the unity and diversity of earliest Christianity have become increasingly cautious in their use of the designations "Christian" and "Christianity" with respect to the earliest stages of the Jesus movement. In so doing, they usually adopt generic outsider labels, such as "Jesus followers" and "the Jesus movement" instead. Surprisingly little attention has been given to the labels the earliest Jesus followers themselves used, and how those labels can inform our understanding of their sense of group identity. This paper addresses some of Paul's designations for members of the Jesus movement. Special attention is given to his reference to the schisms of the Corinthian church and the evidence they provide for labels designating separate groups within the movement as well as labels designating the movement as a whole, comprised of members whose belonging to the group was defined by their union with Jesus Christ.
|
The Return of Allegory: Scholarly Exegesis and the Literal Sense of Luke-Acts
Program Unit: Book of Acts
Kavin Rowe, Duke University
This paper will explore how the construction of a community of readers of Luke-Acts is materially similar in intellective procedure and content to allegorical interpretation of a text; that is, the community who reads Luke-Acts is, in terms of its actual content, the product of an allegory. Doing "historical reconstruction," then, is better conceived as allegory in the guise of a modernist historical grammar.
|
The Grammar of Life: the Areopagus Speech and Pagan Tradition
Program Unit:
C. Kavin Rowe, Duke University
*
|
John Howard Yoder’s Missional Exiles and Jeremiah 29: A Case Study for Missional Hermeneutics
Program Unit: GOCN Forum on Missional Hermeneutics
Andrew D. Rowell, Duke University
In my doctoral work at Duke with ethicist Stanley Hauerwas, New Testament scholar Richard Hays, and missiologist Laceye Warner, I have been exploring John Howard Yoder’s missional ecclesiology. At the 2008 and 2009 GOCN forums at SBL, there has been significant discussion about what constitutes a missional hermeneutic. This paper argues that Yoder’s use of Jeremiah 29 represents the potential and pitfalls of a missional hermeneutic. Mennonite theologian, ethicist and biblical interpreter Yoder (1927-1997) argued forcefully that the church should establish an identity distinctive from the surrounding world. He argued that God’s people should always see themselves as people in exile but that this stance has often been lost since Constantine. However, the church is not distinctive for its own sake. Rather, it is For the Nations as he titled one of his last books. The people of God are told by God to “seek the welfare of the city where I have sent you into exile” (Jer 29:7). The distinctiveness of the Christian community’s life together will embody the good news of the reign of God to the world. This set of ideas constitutes a missional exile hermeneutic which has fueled rich and evocative readings of Scripture by Yoder which New Testament scholars like Hays have praised. Furthermore, the Christian ethics Yoder promoted continues to inspire; at least seven books were published in 2009-2010 on Yoder. However, Yoder’s emphasis on the exilic character of Christian identity has begun to receive significant criticism. His critics argue that Yoder’s presupposition that the church is always to be on the move in mission has led him to downplay biblical texts that seem to support settling down, institution building, structure, and formation. Peter Ochs, Paul Kissling, and Michael Cartwright have noted how his use of Jeremiah 29 is a particularly egregious example of the imposition of his presuppositions on the text. Yoder’s example suggests the vitality of a type of missional hermeneutic and cautions against its potential excesses.
|
Protesting Imperial Influence in the Temple in John 2:15
Program Unit: Jesus Traditions, Gospels, and Negotiating the Roman Imperial World
Gilberto Ruiz, Emory University
In what is a welcome and overdue development, publications reading John’s Gospel within its Roman imperial context are appearing with greater frequency. However, a neglected entry point into elucidating the relationship between John and the Roman Empire is economics and money matters. This paper examines the monetary language and imagery in John 2:14-16 to show that such language and imagery invites the reader to consider that Jesus’ actions in the temple are directed at imperial realities that stand in conflict with the Johannine worldview.
Scholars like Richard Cassidy and Warren Carter have demonstrated that John’s Gospel stands in considerable tension with the Roman Empire. Building on their insights, I contend that Jesus’ act of pouring the coins of the moneychangers on the floor in John 2:15 is yet one more instance of the Gospel’s response to Roman realities and a further example of what Carter has named John’s “rhetoric of distance,” by which John exhorts his audiences to resist accommodating to the Empire’s ideologies and practices.
To develop this point, I will first show that John’s version of the temple scene calls distinctive attention to the presence of the moneychangers’ coins. I will then briefly sketch out some well-known characteristics about coins in the Roman Empire that suggest Jesus’ pouring of the moneychangers’ coins on the floor is a vivid protest against the Empire’s presence on temple grounds. Referring chiefly to Josephus, I will then elaborate upon Rome’s influence over the temple cult and its leadership in Jerusalem. Returning to the scene at hand, I will conclude that Jesus’ act of spilling the coins is a protest against the Jewish temple leadership’s accommodative relationship toward Rome and point out how Jesus’ critique coheres with John’s “rhetoric of distance” elsewhere in the Gospel.
|
The Ruptured Self: War, Psychic Trauma, and the Promise of Narrative Repair
Program Unit: Warfare in Ancient Israel
Janet Rumfelt, University of Denver
Displaced and exiled people endure a twin trauma. The physical removal from their homeland inflicts a psychic wounding. Their pre-war sense of self is itself displaced and becomes a casualty of war. They live with a ruptured sense of self, the self before exile or displacement and the self after. In this paper, I explore the consequences of this rupture and examine the promise that narrative psychology and philosophy hold for the repair of identity.
|
The Good, the Bad, and the Proselyte: Divine Judgment and ‘the Other’ in the Gospel of Matthew
Program Unit: Matthew
Anders Runesson, McMaster University
Christianity, in all its historical diversity, has traditionally been a religion whose adherents have almost exclusively been non-Jews. It is therefore hardly surprising that Christian theologians through the ages have tended to highlight positive aspects related to groups and individuals described in the New Testament as non-Jewish. Reversely, a historical survey of exegesis on passages depicting Jews indicates the opposite trend: a predominantly negative portrayal. It seems clear that this ancient and powerful interpretive matrix, into which the texts included in the Christian canon have been thrown, has been anchored in a need for Christians—and also, by implication, for Jews—to establish and confirm contemporary group boundaries expressing distinct identities. More recently, the Gospel of Matthew, in particular, has been the centre of much debate in this regard, and Graham Stanton was a key player in these discussions. Not only did he contribute major studies identifying the (socio-religious) location of the Mattheans (intra or extra muros), he also suggested early on that this field of Matthean studies would continue to thrive in the future. In this he was surely correct. The present paper, offered in memory of Stanton, aims at contributing to this discussion, focusing on the relationship between Jews and non-Jews in the first Gospel. It will be argued that Matthew conveys a complex picture of non-Jewish individuals and groups, and does so from a distinctly Jewish perspective. In order to understand and appreciate a Matthean theology of ‘the Other,’ we need first to alter what James Dunn has metaphorically compared to an interpretive ‘default setting,’ tainted as it often is by anachronisms. Via analysis of divine judgment discourse, Matthean portraits of and attitudes towards non-Jews will be reconstructed and placed in a larger frame in which first century concerns about identity and colonization will be highlighted.
|
Paul and Jewish-Christianity: Terminological and Conceptual Issues
Program Unit:
Anders Runesson, McMaster University
*
|
Torture by the Book: Psalm 137 after Abu Ghraib
Program Unit: Biblical Criticism and Literary Criticism
Erin Runions, Pomona College
This paper explores the work of lament in the context of war. It starts from the little remarked report that the song Rivers of Babylon, by Boney M, was repeated at high volumes at Abu Ghraib in the attempt to break prisoners. Between WW II and the events of Abu Ghraib, scholars have often read this psalm in the context of the Holocaust, to try to understand the violent ending of Psalm 137 as an understandable response to acute oppression. The implications of that interpretation and the violence that it might inadvertently have facilitated in the Iraq war are considered, before looking at how the language of the Psalm might contribute to, and also resist, such violence.
|
Regularizing Sexuality in the Biopolitical: Babylon as Political Symbol in U.S. Culture
Program Unit: Gender, Sexuality, and the Bible
Erin Runions, Pomona College
Babylon is a puzzlingly multivalent symbol in U.S. culture. It tends to represent both a love and hate of social unity (often understood as control), and a love and hate of social diversity (often understood as freedom). Moreover, because Babylon is regularly associated with sexuality thanks to the book of Revelation’s Whore of Babylon, its use as a political symbol highlights the way in which debates over sexuality get mobilized in negotiating these central tensions in U.S. liberal democracy. One way of understanding the conflicting ideals of governance, self-regulation, and sexuality symbolized by Babylon is through Michel Foucault’s analysis of the historic shift from disciplinary society into what he calls biopolitical: i.e., the concern with regularizing and securitizing life, populations, and human capital. Two films, standing at roughly both ends of Hollywood history, reveal the contradictory ways in which Babylon works to come to terms with the shift into the biopolitical. D.W. Griffith’s 1916 film Intolerance: Love’s Struggle through the Ages, and Alejandro González Iñárritu’s 2006 film Babel both treat Babylon both positively and negatively. I read these films to explore the ways in which Babylon as political symbol works both to dramatize and facilitate the tensions between unity and diversity, control and mobility, rights and interest, disciplines and regularization at work in biopolitics. The way these films treat Babylon produces the dynamics wherein the regulation and regularization of populations via biopolitics can be detested and yet pursued. I will suggest that these films seem to critique the biopolitical through a return to the normative sexual relations of the heteronormative family; yet if we read with attention to the way that Babylon appears, we start to see that they also participate in the dynamics of power they wish to critique.
|
Memorizing History and Historicizing Religion in the Roman Republic
Program Unit: Memory Perspectives on Early Christianity and Its Greco-Roman Context
Jörg Rüpke, University of Erfurt
Roman religion is usually seen as a static system, modified only by additions or oblivion. This factors are not to be denied. However, this religious system is characterized by crucial elements of self-historicization. By the 2nd century BC the growth of the Roman pantheon is mapped in chronological terms by the combination of calendar and lists of magistrates (fasti). Ritual performances are recorded and consciously repeated or modified. There are, as C. Ando has shown,"empirical" elements in the ritual system. At the same time, a sort of philosophy of history starts to be developed. The paper will draw these factors together to paint a new image of a historicized religion contemporary to Judaism and early Christianity.
|
The Spatial Fix in the Development of Biblical Monotheism
Program Unit: Space, Place, and Lived Experience in Antiquity
Stephen C. Russell, University of California-Berkeley
Biblical monotheism, whether the result of a more or less gradual process of evolution or an epistemic rupture of the kind elaborated by Michel Foucault, posed a significant challenge to the traditional spatial conception of Yahweh as a deity tied to a particular land and people. This conception of a fixed deity is witnessed as late as Ps 137, for example, where Yahweh’s people refuse to sing his song in a foreign land and regard their captors’ invitation to do so as inherently absurd. Independently of questions of immanence and transcendence, the problem remained: how could Yahweh be god of the whole cosmos and yet be tied to a particular place? Drawing on Henri Lefebvre’s work on the social production of space, I suggest that at least two spatial fixes to the problem of monotheism emerge in the Bible, one emphasizing Yahweh’s movement through space, and the other emphasizing the movement of the structure of space itself. First, the Priestly description of the desert shrine, drawing on the old tradition of the ark as a mobile war standard, for example witnessed in 1 Sam 4-6, portrayed Yahweh as independent of particular geospatial coordinates but as always at the center of his people. The fix is accomplished by freeing Yahweh from a specific locality and connecting him instead to his people who are free to move through space. Second, Isa 66:18-23, drawing on the old tradition of Yahweh’s mountain abode, for example witnessed in Exod 15:1b-18, imagines a future in which all the nations will come up to Zion to pledge allegiance to Yahweh. The fix is accomplished by freeing the nations from their specific localities and having them habitually move to and from Jerusalem. This continuous flow restructures space itself so that the whole world becomes represented in microcosm on Yahweh’s mountain.
|
The Narrative Significance of Samuel's House Burial in 1 Sam 25:1
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
Stephen C. Russell, University of California-Berkeley
The Iron Age II Judahite preference for extramural burial, i.e., burial outside the settlement area, is well known, both from the archaeological record and from the Hebrew Bible. A number of exceptions are attested, however, including the mention of Samuel’s intramural burial in his house in Ramah (1 Sam 25:1). Although the distinctiveness of this notice has been remarked upon occasionally, its significance within the narratives about Samuel has not received scholarly attention. In dialogue with Henri Lefebvre’s work on the social production of space and the location of death, with Michel Foucault’s observations on the heterotopia of the cemetery, and with Gaston Bachelard’s reflections on the enchanted space of home, I suggest that whatever its historical significance, Samuel’s reported house burial extends his narrative role as a boundary-crosser in the Books of Samuel. The several biblical formulae for burial emphasize the deceased’s connection to the ancestors and thus maintain a clear ontological separation between the world of the living and the world of the dead, a separation echoed in the spatial arrangement of Judahite graves, and in the Pentateuchal instructions for the handling of corpses. In contrast, 1 Sam 25:1 emphasizes the deceased Samuel’s connection to his household and spatially blurs the worlds of the living and the dead. In this way the burial notice foreshadows the boundary-crossing that will take place when the dead Samuel converses with the living Saul, as detailed in the famous episode of the necromancer of Endor (1 Sam 28:3-25). In blurring the worlds of the living and the dead, 1 Sam 25:1 echoes Samuel’s broader role as a boundary-crosser who straddles the roles of prophet and judge, the periods of judges and kings, and the spatial ascendancies of Shiloh and Jerusalem.
|
Reading 1QS 1 and 1QS 11 as Backdrop to the Johannine Prologue
Program Unit: Qumran
Serge Ruzer, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
The religious outlook reflected in the Prologue of John has been discussed with reference to Wisdom-tradition, Hellenistic Jewish and broader Greek patterns, as well as to Targumic elaborations on the first lines of Genesis. The possibility of links to certain ideas, e.g., the fateful division between (those of) light and (those of) darkness, attested in the Dead Sea Scrolls has also been suggested. Continuing the latter path of investigation, this paper focuses on the opening and closing paragraphs of the Community Rule as possible backdrop to the themes elaborated in John 1:1-18 – without necessary presupposing literary dependence or a historical connection beyond what is provided merely by the common late Second Temple Jewish milieu. The comparison is based on the appraisal that both Qumranic and New Testament passages in question constitute programmatic "wrappings up" tailored to provide the hermeneutical key for understanding the rest of the Rule and of the Gospel respectively. This presupposition allows highlighting both the shared cluster of core motifs and the ways in which each tradition reinterprets them.
|
The Role and Influence of the KJV in the African American Churches
Program Unit:
Rodney Sadler Jr., Union Presbyterian Seminary
*
|
Is the Larger Cambridge Septuagint (Brooke–McLean) Still Important for Scholarly Work in the Former Prophets?
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Richard J. Saley, Harvard University
Although it is no longer fashionable to use the Larger Cambridge Septuagint in Septuagint research, this paper asserts that such remains indispensable for serious scholarly work in the Former Prophets. Examples from Joshua, Judges, 1-2 Samuel and 1-2 Kings, comparing Rahlf’s text with that derived from a critical use of the Larger Cambridge Septuagint, will comprise the body of the presentation.
|
Religious and Civic Violence in the Fifth Century Roman Empire
Program Unit: Society for Ancient Mediterranean Religions
Michele Salzman, University of California-Riverside
The civic disturbances of the fifth century exacerbated intra-group religious violence. The letters and sermons of Pope Leo (440-461 CE) elucidate this phenomenon in fifth century Rome. As this paper will show, religious violence within a civic context strengthened episcopal authority.
|
On the Agricultural Imagery in Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Descriptions of Catastrophes
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Nili Samet, Bar Ilan University
Biblical depictions of war, destruction and other calamities often refer to the ceasing of agricultural activity. Against this background, it is rather surprising that favorable agricultural activities, such as vintage, harvest, threshing, and wine-pressing, have, at the same time and in similar contexts, an opposite function as well: they serve as metaphors for the actions of killing and slaughtering people involved in the catastrophe. The current paper seeks to review this remarkable utilization of agricultural imagery in the Hebrew Bible and its ancient Near Eastern parallels. We will examine the origins of the imagery under discussion, and present the relevant examples from the Bible and ancient Near Eastern sources, tracing the development of this curious metaphor, and analyzing the different meanings attached to it in different contexts.
|
The Syriac Text of the Gospel of Mark: Evidence from a XVth Century Maronite Manuscript
Program Unit: Syriac Literature and Interpretations of Sacred Texts
Gaby Abou Samra, Université Libanaise
This paper offers an analysis of the fragmentary syriac text of the Gospel of Mark that is contained in a Maronite manuscript, dated to the end of XV century. The paper discusses text-critical questions of the Syriac text. It compares the Syriac text with the arabic translation (Karshuni) that accompanies it. Moreover, it comments on and situates the evidence of this text critically in its time and place.
|
Character Ethics in the Book of Proverbs
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Timothy J. Sandoval, Chicago Theological Seminary
This paper will present how ethical character formation is being promoted in the book of Proverbs (30 minutes + 15 minutes discussion).
|
Jewish Domestic Spaces
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Juhana Markus Saukkonen, University of Helsinki
This paper examines the differences in spatial arrangements of Jewish and non-Jewish homes in Roman Judaea. Attention will be paid to the socio-religious dynamics behind these differences, particularly the ways in which Jewish purity regulations affected the use of space in Jewish households. Jewish religion is largely practiced at home, and many of its practices also become visible in the spatial arrangements of Jewish households.
Spatial configuration of a home is obviously dependent on several other factors besides religion – financial and social status of its inhabitants being some of the most important ones. Moreover, these different factors often intermingle, perhaps most evidently in the case of wealthy priests in pre-70 C.E. Jerusalem. While religious purity regulations and social expectations stipulated and wealth facilitated many of the complex arrangements in their households, the latter two of these factors also made these households more akin to wealthy non-Jews, in terms of material culture. This is, once again, visible not only in artifact assemblages but also spatial arrangements of these households.
|
Review of Isaac Kalimi, The Retelling of Chronicles in Jewish Tradition and Literature
Program Unit: Midrash
John Sawyer, Perugia University
My contribution to the panel discussion will consist mainly of a critique of Dr Kalimi's new book as a case study in the reception history of the Bible
|
Reception History: Theory and Practice in the Blackwell Bible Commentary Series
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
John F. A. Sawyer, University of Perugia
The primary aim of this panel discussion is to inform and support those currently working on the reception history of the Hebrew Bible, particularly writing commentaries. It will also show the value of reception history, not only as an integral part of our own discipline, but also within theology, politics and the arts.
|
Mary Magdalene Research in the Twentieth Century
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Jane D. Schaberg, University of Detroit Mercy
Research on the figure of Mary Magdalene in the 20th century prepared the way for the work of the 21st century. This paper will attempt to contextualize the 20th century work in terms of (1) the discovery of the nag hammadi library's treatments of Mary Magdalene and reinterest in the gospel of mary; (2) the Vatican's quiet declaration that MM was not the sinner of legend; (3) feminist treatments - especially that of Schussler Fiorenza in 1975 and 1983 - that provided a way to reconceptualize women's agency in this earliest kingdom of god movement; (4) interest in christian anti-judaism and how to combat it with knowledge of judaism; and (5) discussion of sexuality in this phase of the women's movement and of jesus' sexuality in religious studies.
|
Fronted Word-Order in Phoenician Inscriptions
Program Unit: Ugaritic Studies and Northwest Semitic Epigraphy
Aaron Schade, Brigham Young University Hawaii Campus
Within this presentation I will examine fronted word-order in Phoenician inscriptions, simultaneously considering both syntactic and pragmatic functions underlying this phenomenon. I will demonstrate that syntax and pragmatics work cooperatively to convey and establish the information structure of Phoenician inscriptional material. Within the inscriptions fronted subjects frequently mark new syntactic units, and often introduce (or re-introduce) information that is fronted for Focus contrast, or in the case of thematic material, fronted for Topic. The fronted constituent is thus intentional and is a syntactic descriptor motivated by pragmatic features. In the inscriptions we also witness fronted prepositional phrases, adverbs, and direct objects. In each instance one can detect layers of Rheme and Theme, and often in conjunction with these elements, Focus or Topic. In a significant number of these occurrences, the fronted constituent is instrumental in marking the onset of a new syntactic unit or its conclusion.
|
Toward an Ecofeminist Theology of Preaching
Program Unit: Academy of Homiletics
Leah D. Schade, Lutheran Theological Seminary at Philadelphia
*
|
Co-creaturely Associates and Peers: The Nature of Animals as Portrayed in Isaiah
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
A. Rahel Schafer, Wheaton College
This paper attempts to determine how animals are portrayed in the book of Isaiah, especially as they relate to God and humanity. The multiplicity of hints throughout the Old Testament suggests that we must look beyond standard anthropocentric explanations given for apparent animal consciousness of accountability before God, and perhaps even worship of God. The frequency and range of usage of animal metaphors in Isaiah compels us to investigate the reality concerning the nature of animals that is assumed behind the primary meaning or significance of the metaphors.
There is a broad spectrum in the book of Isaiah with regard to how living creatures are portrayed as relating to God and each other. On the one hand, domestic animals are considered more as associates to humans, ones who have a subordinate status but are joined in purpose on a nearly equal basis, though more accountable to humans than to God. As associates, domestic animals often display similar emotions and characteristics to humans, while remaining responsible and accountable to their masters, perhaps even honoring them in some fashion by serving them faithfully. On the other hand, wild animals are portrayed more as peers to humans, with metaphorical comparisons being made between their actions and God’s actions. Like humans, they can possess the land, be accountable to God for their actions, and honor God in contrast to rebellious persons. After categorizing all passages concerning animals in Isaiah, I will focus upon Isa 60:6-7 and Isa 43:20, which most clearly illustrate the differences between domestic and wild animals. Therefore, not only do animals serve a didactic function in Isaiah, but the book’s portrayal of animals also gives us a glimpse into the nature of animals as associates and peers of humans, both responsible to authority and capable of honoring God.
|
The Nations and Israel in the Twelve: A History of Research
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Aaron Schart, University of Duisburg
The relationship of Israel to the nations is an important topic within the Book of the Twelve. In contrast to the other prophetic books Isaih, Jeremiah, and Ezekiel that contain lengthy cycles comprising oracles against the nations, the topic is much more complicated within the Twelve. The Book of the Twelve shows the reader how the prophets dealt with the nations differently over time.
This paper will give an overview over the history of research to this topic, from Wolfe to Woehrle, and thereby identify the main issues that should be addressed in future research.
|
Beyond Rhetoric: Self-Praise in Plutarch, Paul, and Red Jacket
Program Unit: Second Corinthians: Pauline Theology in the Making
Ryan S. Schellenberg, University of St. Michael's College
In his seminal commentary on 2 Corinthians, Hans Windisch drew attention to Plutarch's De laude ipsius, noting that Plutarch's discussion of self-praise illuminated the cultural background of Paul's hesitant boasting in 2 Cor 10–13. Windisch’s appeal to Plutarch was taken up by Hans Dieter Betz in his Der Apostel Paulus und die sokratische Tradition, but Betz transposed the discussion into the key of rhetoric: Where Windisch referred rather vaguely to a shared “outlook,” Betz spoke of Paul’s conformity to rhetorical dictates. It is Betz's rhetorical perspective on periautologia that has entered the mainstream of Pauline scholarship, but compelling justification for treating Plutarch's moral-philosophical treatise as evidence for rhetorical precepts has not been offered. In fact, a rereading of Plutarch's treatise demonstrates that he is concerned not with eloquence but with honourable statesmanship, and his recommendations for speech about oneself derive not from rhetorical theory but from political and cultural observation. His goal is the mitigation of the envy and social rivalry to which unrestrained self-praise inevitably leads. It is thus necessary to reevaluate the significance of Plutarch's treatise for interpreting 2 Cor 10-13: First, Paul's use of the strategies for self-adulation recommended by Plutarch is not surprising, and tells us nothing about his knowledge of contemporary rhetoric; indeed, speakers as far removed from Greek rhetorical precepts as the Iroquois orator Red Jacket know that it is best to insist on the urgent necessity of self-praise and to appear to indulge in it hesitantly. Second, it is intriguing that where Plutarch—and Philodemus, the Homeric scholia, Aristotle, and Demosthenes—are concerned with the nexus between self-praise and envy, Paul is concerned with the appearance of foolishness. This key difference in their attitudes toward boasting is a window onto the very different social locations they occupy.
|
Marcion’s Penknife Reconsidered: Paratexts and the Perception of Textual Corruption
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Eric Scherbenske, Independent Scholar
Among our earliest reports about Marcion are allegations that he corrupted the Gospel of Luke and Paul’s letters to make these texts conform with his “heretical” interpretation of Christ and Christianity. Recent scholarship has demonstrated not only that such characterizations were symptomatic of heresy charges, but that many of the distinctive readings found in Marcion’s text of the Corpus Paulinum were likely received and transmitted, rather than created by Marcion. In this paper, I move away from questions concerning the veracity of such allegations of corruption leveled against Marcion or possible origins of readings that appeared consistent with Marcion’s theology; rather, I ask how such readings, irrespective of their origins, came to be perceived as “heretical” corruptions designed to reinforce Marcion’s hermeneutic. I argue that at least one factor in shaping perceptions of textual corruption was the deployment of the Antitheses intended as a supplementary paratext to be read before or alongside Marcion’s text. An analysis of a few variant readings from Marcion’s text in relation to his theology demonstrates how this paratext shaped readings by providing rubrics for interpretation before encountering the actual text. Focusing on the interrelationship between texts and ancillary paratexts, some of which frequently came to be transmitted alongside the former in MSS, opens up new possibilities for exploring the role of paratexts in the hermeneutical reception of texts other than Marcion’s.
|
The Christian Bible – A Jewish Perspective
Program Unit:
Lawrence Schiffman, New York University
*
|
The Discourse on Wisdom and Torah and the Composition of the Book of Proverbs
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Bernd Schipper, Humboldt Universität, Berlin
The post-exilic discourse on Wisdon and Torah could be found in different parts of the book of Proverbs, as for example Prov. 1-9 or Prov. 30f. The paper develops the thesis that the final composition of Proverbs has to be seen against the backdrop of a theological debate in post-exilic time where the interplay of Wisdom and Torah as well as the relationship between human understanding and (further) divine revelations was important.
|
Guilt Offerings and Ritual Impurity in Isaiah 53
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Jeremy Schipper, Temple University
Isaiah 53 describes the servant as a guilt offering (v. 10) and yet, throughout the passage, also describes him with language that indicates that he is ritually impure and thus unfit to serve as a guilt offering based on priestly standards. After exploring this apparent tension, this paper will consider how Isaiah uses ritual impurity as a metaphor that expresses hope for a divine atonement. Then, it will show how the servant as both ritually impure and a guilt offering may engender hope not only for Israel but the foreign nations as well.
|
The Urban Landscape of Iron Age Sam'al
Program Unit:
David Schloen, University of Chicago
Recent excavations at the site of ancient Sam'al (modern Zincirli), 100 kilometers (60 miles)north of Antioch, have yielded new information about the fortifications and residential areas of this 40-hectare (100-acre) walled city of the biblical period, about which David Ussishkin himself has written. Sam'al was the capital of a wealthy, ethnically mixed Iron Age kingdom that, like its neighbors throughout the Levant, was eventually incorporated into the Assyrian
Empire. For 200 years or more, before it was made a directly governed Assyrian province in ca. 700 B.C., Sam'al was ruled by a West Semitic dynasty that adopted the prevailing Neo-
Hittite style of art and architecture and ruled a population that included people of non-Semitic Luwian (Anatolian) extraction. During the ninth century B.C., probably in the aftermath of the initial devastating Assyrian invasion of the northern Levant by Shalmaneser III in 858 B.C., the city was dramatically expanded and fortified by the erection of a remarkable, perfectly circular double wall 2,200 meters long
with three monumental gates and 100 towers. This created a protected zone of 32 hectares (80 acres), in what had been open farmland, between the outer walls and the 8-hectare (20-
acre) walled royal citadel in the middle of the city. This paper will discuss the colonization of the lower town of Sam'al and the political, social, and economic context of this sudden change in settlement policy and urban landscape, which has parallels in the Iron Age urban expansions and lower town constructions throughout the Levant in the early
Assyrian period.
|
The Presence of Absence: Roman Religion and the Destruction of the Jewish Temple in 70 CE
Program Unit: Archaeology of Religion in the Roman World
Emily A. Schmidt, University of California-Santa Barbara
This paper reconsiders the destruction of the Jewish temple from the Roman perspective by analyzing the significance of the presence of the temple ruins and the absence of a functioning temple on Roman understandings of the city. Building on recent work on Flavian religious policy, this paper integrates Roman religious thought with theories of space and memory to analyze the significance of the destruction and desolation of the Jewish temple in terms of Roman religious ideology. If, as recent work suggests, the Jewish god was represented as a captive or subject when the Jewish sacred goods were deposited in the temple of Jupiter Optimus Maximus in Rome, then the presence of temple ruins and the Flavian refusal to rebuild any temple on the Temple Mount served to emphasize that the Jewish god no longer inhabits Jerusalem. The presence of the ruins of the Jewish temple in Jerusalem were a constant reminder that the Jewish God is gone – defeated, or even killed by the Roman gods so that he no longer exists. In the Flavian triumph and the Arch of Titus, however, we see the opposite view. Represented by the menorah and the table of the show bread, the Jewish god most certainly exists as a god who is weaker than and defeated by the Roman gods. The major Flavian claim on Jerusalem is an absence that reshapes the city, and points to the city of Rome, with the relocation of the sacred goods and with the redirection of the temple tax to the temple of Jupiter Optimus Maximus. Not all roads, but even voids may lead to Rome.
|
The Problem of Magic and Ritual Healing in the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Rüdiger Schmitt, University of Muenster
The paper will examine the problem of ritual healing and magic both from the textual evidence and with regard to the history of scholarly perception of ‘magic’ in the Hebrew Bible In the Hebrew Bible we find a sharp distinction between legitimate – mostly therapeutic magic rituals – performed by legitimate ritual specialists like Elijah (1 Kgs 17-18), Elisha (2 Kgs 2:19-22; 2:23-24; 4:1-7; 4:8-37; 4:38-41; 4:42-44; 5:1-27; 6:1-7) and Isaiah (2 Kgs 20:1-11 = Isa 38:1-8.21) which were considered magia licita and practices considered illegitimate like those mentioned in the prophetical law Deuteuteronomy 18: 9-22 and the practices of the female prophets attacked in Ez 13:18. The scholarly perception of magic in the Hebrew Bible has followed in many respects the deuteronomistic and priestly verdicts against magic (Hebrew kašap) and the biblical discourse about ritual authority. The aim of the paper is a.) to evaluate the scholarly approaches to magic in the OT, and b.) to show that ‘magic’ healing as ritual practice in the OT is an integral part of religion and an important expression of the cultural system (cf. Ruediger Schmitt, Magie im Alten Testament, AOAT 313, Muenster: Ugarit-Verlag, 2004).
|
Nascent Scripturalization in the Neo-Assyrian Period
Program Unit: Orality, Textuality, and the Formation of the Hebrew Bible
William Schniedewind, University of California-Los Angeles
The process of scripturalization--that is, a community's embedding of tradition and values within the biblical text-- is readily discernible during the Second Temple Period. In this paper, we explore whether this process can be pushed further back into the neo-Assyrian period. Karel van der Toorn has brought examples of a "revelation paradigm" in the neo-Assyrian period that compel us to examine evidence for a similar paradigm in contemporary Judah. The emergence of the writing prophets, notions of the "word of the Lord," the use of the Mesopotamian treaty and legal genres as well as social and political processes are examined. Finally, the paper concludes that the process of scripturalization began already in the neo-Assyrian period.
|
“Belonging to All Humanity”: Postcolonial Reconciliation, Androcentrism, and La Genèse by Cheick Oumar Sissoko
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Susanne Scholz, Southern Methodist University
In 1999, the Malian filmmaker, Cheick Oumar Sissoko, created a movie entitled La Genèse that focuses on Gen. 23-37. Since the film transforms the biblical stories into “a template for understanding the lived experience of contemporary Africans,” some commentators maintain that La Genèse offers a “radical rehistoricization” of the biblical tales and turns them into “a post-colonial allegory about fratricide in Africa.” This paper aims to move this point even further and suggests that an analysis of La Genèse has to deal with the film’s extensive androcentrism. It marginalizes women despite the fact that Dinah and Gen. 34 play a significant role in the film, and it limits La Genèse’s creative potential to envision just, peaceful, and democratic societies built by both women and men in postcolonial African countries.
Three sections develop this proposition. First, the paper describes how Sissoko interprets Gen. 23-37 as stories about African fratricide. Second, the paper illustrates the pervasive presence of androcentrism in La Genèse, especially as seen in the characterization of Dinah. Third, the paper reflects on the film’s omission of dealing with sexual violence in times of war and genocide when so many women in Congo, Rwanda, Guinea, and Darfur suffer from such violence. Since Sissoko aimed to contribute to postcolonial reconciliation with this film, his cinematic adaptation of the Genesis stories represents a lost opportunity to create awareness that efforts toward postcolonial reconciliation must include women’s experiences. Accordingly, the film limits the imaginary potential of breaking through androcentric assumptions and practices in the cinematic appropriation of the Hebrew Bible and in the world despite its significant accomplishments as an African film on the Bible.
|
Quotations from Origen and the Theologies of Textuality in Eusebius’ Apology for Origen, against Marcellus, and on Ecclesiastical Theology
Program Unit: Eusebius and the Construction of a Christian Culture
Jeremy Schott, University of North Carolina at Charlotte
Eusebius of Caesarea was a master of others’ words. From early works like the Prophetic Eclogues to later treatises such as the Ecclesiastical Theology, Eusebius developed a poetics of quotation that many modern scholars still discount as a lack of originality and theological/literary skill. Yet, the practice of patristic quotation in support of one’s theological position that we see in Eusebius’s work would go on to influence ecclesiastical writers from Athanasius onwards. And of course, Eusebius’ love of the block quote also makes his corpus a veritable archive of otherwise-lost ancient writings. Scholars have only infrequently, however, examined Eusebius’ method in its own right. This paper offers an analysis of the ways in which Eusebius deployed quotation in three polemical works: the Apology for Origen (co-authored with his master Pamphilus circa 309 CE) and Against Marcellus and On Ecclesiastical Theology (written circa 336 CE). In all three of these texts, the quotation of Origen figures crucially. By examining the ways in which Eusebius handles quotations of Origen, and his objections to others’ quotations of Origen, this paper will work towards outlining the (sometimes explicit, but more often implicit) ethics and theology of textuality at work in Eusebius writing.
|
When Harlots are Embarrassing and the Villainesses are Inconvenient: Seventeenth-Century Female Writings about the Bad Women of the Bible
Program Unit: Recovering Female Interpreters of the Bible
Joy A. Schroeder, Trinity Lutheran Seminary and Capital University
Women in the 1600’s had to contend with a proliferation of male-authored misogynistic pamphlets accusing womankind of villainy and immorality. In response, female writers such as Arcangela Tarabotti (1604—1652) and Bathsua Makin (c. 1600—after 1675) set forth examples of honorable, heroic woman of scripture as proof of women’s virtue. The presence of wicked or ambiguous figures, such as Jezebel, Lot’s daughters, Bathsheba, and Tamar (Gen. 38), made women’s attempts to defend and valorize their gender more problematic. This paper explores the ways that seventeenth-century female authors dealt with biblical women’s villainy and irregular sexual behavior. Strategies included ignoring the bad women altogether; the omission of details (e.g., discussions of Lot’s incest without mentioning his daughters’ role in initiating the activity); creative explanations for women’s bad behavior; and challenges to traditional male readings of scriptural passages about “bad” women. In certain cases, seventeenth-century women’s interpretations of texts, such as Tarabotti’s description of Bathsheba as a victim of David’s abusive power and lust rather than his seducer, anticipated contemporary feminist readings of biblical passages.
|
Mother Wisdom's Daughter: Rebecca Cox Jackson as Biblical Interpreter
Program Unit: Recovering Female Interpreters of the Bible
Joy Schroeder, Trinity Lutheran Seminary and Capital University
Mother Rebecca Cox Jackson (1795-1871) was an African-American preacher who eventually became a Shaker elder. Between 1831 and 1864, she kept a private journal—a sort of spiritual autobiography with fascinating accounts of external events in her life, as well as her interior thoughts, dreams, and visions—including revelations about Holy Mother Wisdom, a maternal aspect of God. This paper explores Jackson’s use of the Bible, especially her use of Proverbs 1-9. She found, in the biblical figure of Wisdom, the divine validation she needed to assert her public voice in the face of internal and external opposition.
|
Hearing Jesus in Historical Time and Geographical Space: The Scores for Quo Vadis and The Passion of the Christ
Program Unit: Bible and Film
Linda K. Schubert, University of Wisconsin-Stevens Point
The scores for QUO VADIS (1951, music by Míklós Rózsa) and THE PASSION OF THE CHRIST (2004, music by John Debney) illustrate a dramatic change in musical emphasis, style and interpretation that has occurred in Jesus films since the 1950s. In this musicological paper, I will discuss how early music helped aurally locate some narratives within Western historical time, and later on, how world music was used to shift the emphasis to non-Western geographical space. In QUO VADIS, which focused on Roman Christians in the time of Nero, Rózsa incorporated music from approximately the first century CE to make the film sound more historically accurate. In contrast to this, Debney’s score for the controversial THE PASSION used elements selected from various world musics to emphasize the location of the story in a vaguely defined “Middle East”. This score is also important to the film’s view of the salvific importance of Jesus’ death for the world, with the world metaphorically represented by the music and so present and witness to Jesus’ (cinematic) death.
Both scores evoked an impression of ancient times and places convincing to their audiences, while using a wide range of musical elements often not historically or geographically accurate. This paper raises the issue of how fluid musical constructs of time and place can be and how strongly they depend on contemporary stereotypes and tastes, while also considering some of the unique sounds used in these scores.
|
Wisdom Elements in the Hodayot
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Eileen Schuller, McMaster University
It has long been widely recognized that “though not a wisdom document in itself, the Thanksgiving Hymns contain many wisdom elements” (Harrington, Wisdom Texts from Qumran, 79). In this paper, I will analyze and compare the extent of wisdom components (both specific terminology and broader concepts) in individual Hodayot collections (in particular, 1QHa versus 4QHa), and will explore how specific wisdom elements might be related to the overall shape of the most complete manuscript, 1QHa, as it has now been reconstructed.
|
Exile to Damascus and the Community at Qumran
Program Unit: Exile (Forced Migrations) in Biblical Literature
Lucas Schulte, Claremont Graduate University
This paper proposes to examine the concept of exile within one of Qumran's foundational texts: the Damascus Document. Past studies of Qumran have not focused primarily on perspectives about exile, forced migration, or displacement at Qumran. This paper will address the question of "what is exile to Damascus?" as presented within the Damascus Document. After first presenting a brief introduction to the Damascus Document, the paper will then address this question by examining what perspectives about exile are offered by the text. Finally, the paper will briefly discuss what implications if any the question of "exile to Damascus" within the Damascus Document might have for our understanding of the community at Qumran.
|
Reflections on the Galilee Greek Immersion Seminar, Israel
Program Unit: Applied Linguistics for Biblical Languages
Brian Schultz, Fresno Pacific University
Nineteen people met for ten days between 31 March 2010 and 11 April
2010 in Migdal, Galilee, Israel, where Greek was the language of
communication from breakfast to dinner. The presentation will briefly
describe what took place through annotated video clips. Interviews and
comments of particpants will be included. The video clips provide
insight into potential gaps between current training and what may be
required for immersion pedagogy. Many issues and questions arise for
further discussion. How useful, efficient, or desirable will this
become for Koine Greek teaching? How will the gaps between current
skills and future goals be addressed or bridged? What should the
dialectical scope be for the language and what skill levels should
become the goals in various situations? What is the impact or payoff
for preaching and exegesis?
|
Character Ethics in the Book of Ecclesiastes
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Richard L. Schultz, Wheaton College (Illinois)
This paper will consider how ethical character is being promoted in the book of Ecclesiastes (30 minutes + 15 minutes discussion).
|
Improving Unicode Input Methods for Polytonic Greek in Windows Operating Systems
Program Unit: Computer Assisted Research
John Schwandt, New Saint Andrews College
Everyone agrees that Unicode is the standard for the foreseeable future for all typefaces. The difficulty for Greek has been how to access all of the possible diacritic combinations on a standard keyboard. The Windows standard keyboard for polytonic Greek, has proven to be so difficult that it deterred many from using Greek Unicode or pushed people to develop their own keyboard with third party software.
To address these issues, I developed a Windows based alternative to the standard Windows polytonic Greek keyboard that is developed and refined by those who actually type in polytonic Greek. This keyboard retains all of the standard Greek locations for letters but provides a more intuitive method of accessing the diacritic markings. It is my intention to make this keyboard freely available to anyone wishing to type in polytonic Greek.
The only solution to the problem of having so many glyphs to access with our limited keyboard that only allows one dead-key combination (two keystrokes to produce one glyph), was to use shift states for accenting rather than capitalization. This is a paradigm shift from the current windows keyboard that uses shift states like English.
However, there is no need to keep such a relationship between two languages that use capitalization in very different ways. Once we are allowed to use shift states for accenting the process of typing in polytonic Greek can more closely approach the process of hand writing Greek. The current windows keyboard mandates that a key with the correct combination of breathing, accent, and possibly subscript is selected prior to pressing a vowel. This is the opposite method of producing the symbol by hand and thus is not intuitive. By using shift states for accents the accent keys are far more memorable and are produced simultaneously with the vowel, which is a better approximation of writing by hand. The result is a far more intuitive and useful keyboard for typing in polytonic Unicode.
|
Towards a Standard National Biblical Hebrew Examination
Program Unit: Applied Linguistics for Biblical Languages
John Schwandt, New Saint Andrews College
Towards a standard national Biblical Hebrew examination
|
Jesus, Memory, and the Problems of History
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Barry Schwartz, University of Georgia
Consideration of social memory theory in the reconstruction of history.
|
Memory, Media, and History
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Barry Schwartz, University of Georgia
This paper will examine the the complex relationship between memory, media and history.
|
"D", the Torah, Dtr, the Pentateuch, and Deuteronomy
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Baruch Schwartz, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
Recent scholarship is characterized by a lack of conceptual, terminological and historical clarity surrounding the Deuteronomists and their contribution to the Biblical collection. Menahem Haran's distinctive approach to the process of composition of the Biblical books urges scholars to make orderly and sensible distinctions between the Josianic reform as an historical event, the Torah-book purportedly found in the Temple, the complex literary legacy of the Josianic reformers, the Torah-book referred to in their writings, the laws now found in D, the historiographical sources employed by the Deuteronomistic historians, their own literary output, the Torah-book referred to in their writings, the composition of this work and its original function, the Pentateuchal source D identified by critics, and the canonical book of Deuteronomy. Only by properly defining each of these, carefully distinguishing them from one another, and confining each to its own historical context, Haran insists, are we able to describe accurately the process by which the Torah and the Former Prophets came into existence.
|
Philo and Josephus on the Violence in Alexandria in 38 CE
Program Unit: Philo of Alexandria
Daniel Schwartz, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
Philo, in his In Flaccum, claims that the anti-Jewish violence of 38 CE broke out in response to Agrippa I's ostentatious appearance in Alexandria; along with Flaccus he blames the "Alexandrians," whom he largely equates with"Egyptians," not with Greeks; and he allows Gaius Caligula the role of just avenger of the wrongs done to the Jews. Philo's Legatio, which is built as a diatribe against Gaius, ignores Agrippa's role (mentioning his visit only in passing -- §179), sidelines Flaccus, and has the Alexandrians attack the Jews only after they learned of Gaius' hostility to the Jews -- but it too agrees with In Flaccum insofar as it fails to identify the Alexandrians as "Greeks." In neither work does Philo blame "Greeks," or the Jews of Alexandria, for the violence in the city. As for Gaius' decision to erect a statue in the Temple of Jerusalem -- Philo reports that it was the emperor's response to the provocative behavior of the Jews of a town in Judaea, Jamnia. Josephus, for his part, makes no reference to Agrippa's visit to Alexandria, to Flaccus, or to the Jamnian incident. Rather, he structures his narrative so as to indicate that Gaius' decision to erect the statue derived from his hearing about the Jewish-Greek violence in Alexandria; Josephus has no problem with characterizing that violence as a "stasis" between the Jews and "the Greeks" who resided in Alexandria (Ant. 18.257), just as later he has no problem about reporting a Jewish-initiated armed stasis "against the Greeks" in Alexandria at the outset of Claudius' reign (19.278-279). It seems, accordingly, that Philo and Josephus express some significant differences concerning the Jews' neighbors in Alexandria and the allocation of responsibility for the Jews' difficulties in the days of Gaius. Whether or not Josephus used Philo's narrative, his own perspectives, nurtured first in Jerusalem and later in Rome, and the needs of his own narrative, made him tell a story that differs from Philo's substantially.
|
Reading Utopia in Ezra-Nehemiah
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible and Political Theory
Steven Schweitzer, Bethany Theological Seminary
Historical reconstruction and literary analysis are at the forefront of current studies on Ezra-Nehemiah. Another approach to reading this book focuses on the world desired or created by the text. Utopian literary theory examines the better alternative reality presented by the text, a reality that does not exist in the author’s present, but instead is projected for the community’s future. This innovative methodology has already been applied to prophetic texts and the book of Chronicles, with intriguing results. By using this perspective in my research, the political, cultural, and sociological implications of Ezra-Nehemiah are seen through a different lens, one less concerned with historicity and more concerned with the ideology of the text and how it could be manifested in society.
|
Paul’s Use of Self-Presentation as a Defense of His Oratorical Abilities in 1 Corinthians 1:10–4:21
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Kevin Scull, University of California-Los Angeles
Since the foundational work of Margaret Mitchell, most scholars have noted that in 1 Corinthians 1:10-4:21 Paul focuses on re-establishing the unity of the Corinthian community. However, it is my assertion that in order to achieve this unity, Paul employs extensive self-presentation in defense of his oratorical ability and authority with the Corinthian community. That is, unless Paul can convince the community that he is a reputable and trustworthy agent of God, his call for unity will be disregarded. Specifically, in 2:1-5 Paul defends himself against the perception of some in the Corinthian community that he lacks the oratorical abilities of a convincing speaker. While scholars such as Litfin and Dahl have described this section as apologetic and have noted Paul’s perceived lack of oratorical abilities as a primary reason for his defense, Paul’s self-presentation has not been a focus of these studies. An examination of Paul’s use of self-presentation is critical because Paul repeatedly emphasizes his status as an agent of God who does in fact teach wisdom, however it is a wisdom which should not be evaluated in terms of rhetorical abilities but rather one which stems from God. In fact, Paul presents himself as sent by Christ, privy to a secret wisdom, a servant of the lord, a steward of the mystery of God, and even having the mind of Christ. Thus, Paul’s extensive use of self-presentation confirms the apologetic nature of 1:10-4:21 and confirms that there is a perception among at least one of the factions in the Corinthian community that his rhetorical abilities and his status as a reputable authority figure are in question.
|
Paul and the Philippians’ Gift: Self-Presentation as a Tool for Avoiding Reciprocity
Program Unit: Social Scientific Criticism of the New Testament
Kevin Scull, University of California-Los Angeles
The Philippians placed Paul in a particularly difficult situation by sending him a gift while in prison. Although this gift was certainly appreciated by Paul, social norms dictated that such a gift was accompanied with obligations. The rules of reciprocity and patronage associated with gifts, as highlighted by Peter Marshall, made it difficult for Paul to accept the Philippians’ gift without responding with an even larger gift or accepting the Philippians as his patron. Paul was unwilling to accept either of these options. However, societal norms did not allow him to reject the Philippians’ gift either, without serious ramifications. Thus, while Paul expresses appreciation throughout the letter, he never directly thanks the community with the standard e??a??st? response, and this omission has prompted many scholars to term Paul’s appreciation a “thankless thanks.” My paper addresses Paul’s method for accepting the Philippians’ contribution while avoiding the standard obligations associated with gifts and continuing to maintain a positive relationship with the community. Paul accomplishes this difficult task with his rather incredible claim that God, rather than Paul, would repay the Philippians for their generosity. In a society so concerned with patronage and reciprocity, the Philippians could have interpreted Paul’s statement as an insult and a refusal to properly acknowledge their gift. However, Paul prepares the Philippians to accept his redirect of their Gift to God via his self-presentation throughout his letter to the Philippians. Specifically, by presenting himself as an agent of God in Philippians 1:1, 1:13, 1:16, 1:20, and 3:12, Paul is able to make his statement more palatable to his audience. In these passages, Paul establishes his status as God’s agent by stating that he is a slave of God, a defender of the Gospel, and one chosen by Christ.
|
The Death of a King: Mesopotamian Perspectives on Isaiah 14
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
JoAnn Scurlock, Elmhurst College
Isaiah 14.1-22 sets out the following scenario: The faithful of Israel are destined to return home bringing with them aliens who will serve them in Israelite territory, just as Israelites once served the aliens in alien territory. The “aliens” in question are, fairly clearly, one or both of the two imperial powers, namely Egypt and Assyria, among whom Israelites did indeed live as “aliens.” This return of the exiles is to be accompanied by a taunt song that is to be delivered, according to the text, against the King of Babylon (14.3). Since Israelites are going to be enslaving their former oppressors, presumably the return is to take place after the fall of Assyria and the defeat of Egypt by Babylon. One might, therefore, expect the taunt song to be directed against Assyria and/or Egypt rather than Babylon, which would appear in this scenario to be the agent of deliverance rather than an appropriate object of derision. The text as we have it, however, says “Babylon”, and we must consider the possibility that it actually means Babylon. In this paper, I shall attempt to bring Assyriological evidence, some old and some new, to bear on the question of which of the four prime candidates for the king whose death is described in Isaiah 14, namely Sargon II, Sennacherib, Nebuchadnezzar, and Nabonidus, is the evil tyrant of the prophecy. My conclusion is that, when Isaiah 14.3 says “Babylon”, it means Babylon.
|
Race Relations and the Parable of the ‘Good’ Samaritan
Program Unit: African-American Biblical Hermeneutics
Love L. Sechrest, Fuller Theological Seminary
Luke’s interest in the Gentile mission is well known given his focus on Paul in the latter half of Acts, while his posture vis-à-vis the Jewish mission has been the subject of decades of debate. That Luke’s interests engage both of these communities, however, is beyond dispute. This paper relates evidence of tensions between the Jewish and Gentile Christian communities in Luke to race relations in the modern era by exploring ethnic and social analogies between the world of the text and this present historical moment. The paper concludes with reflection on the ethical imperatives that flow from the parable and the tradition that names the Samaritan “good.”
|
Inclusion and Exclusion in the Parable of the Prodigal Son
Program Unit: Ethics, Love, and the Other in Early Christianity
Love Sechrest, Fuller Theological Seminary
n/a
|
What Would Jesus Eat?: Ethical Vegetarianism in Ancient Christianity
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
Robert Paul Seesengood, Albright College
In biblical text, animal sacrifice addresses both animal husbandry and the consumption of animals. Although recent scholarship has demonstrated that animal sacrifice in the Bible is multivalent, a number of studies have linked sacrifice, in part, with concerns over blood libel and the consumption of animals; ritual is invoked to alleviate the taboo of slaughter and to restrain or control the techniques of slaughter. Early followers of Jesus abandoned animal sacrifice. Yet, while some ancient Christian texts argue animal sacrifice is unnecessary (Heb. 9-10), others (Acts 15:29) still restrict and control the slaughter and consumption of animals in ways congruent with Leviticus 17.
I will argue that Acts 15 can be read as evidence that some early followers of Jesus felt that to slaughter an animal outside of a ritual context made one guilty of murder (also expressed in Lev. 17). This concern over blood libel may be (at least one) motivation behind the advocacy of some for vegetarianism (as per Rom. 14:2-3). It may also be invested in ancient Christian notions of the fulfilled messianic age or Paradise, a return to Edenic, antediluvian purity.
Recent work linking Animal Studies and Food Studies, particularly work influenced by Peter Singer, has explored the ethical treatment and husbandry of domestic food animals. This paper will contrast Singer's arguments with ancient Christian views on animal sacrifice and consumption. Singer argues that to privilege human life over animal life is "speciesist;" how we treat animals reflects how we understand their relationship to humans, even how we define "human." For different reasons, some early Christians might well have agreed. Some early Christians may have advocated vegetarianism not simply to avoid participation in idolatry, but also because they viewed the slaughter of animals as murder and as antithetical to the values of the new, messianic age.
|
Review of the Bible Illuminated
Program Unit: Ideology, Culture, and Translation
Robert Seesengood, Albright College
Review of the Bible Illuminated
|
Qumran Evidence for a Semitic Vorlage of LXX Daniel 4
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Michael Segal, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
The Old Greek version of Daniel 4 presents a version of the text vastly different from the Masoretic Text (and Theodotion). Due to “internal” considerations, primarily Semitic syntax and lexicography, scholars (e.g. Montgomery, Grelot) have posited that these differences between the OG and MT are not solely the work of a translator, but rather can be traced back to a Semitic substratum which served as the Vorlage of the OG.
This paper will address the “external” evidence for the existence of this Semitic Vorlage. While there is some fragmentary evidence of Daniel 4 in Qumran biblical manuscripts, it is textually affiliated with the MT version and therefore does not attest to the Vorlage of the OG. However, I will suggest that in two Qumran parabiblical compositions, the Genesis Apocryphon and the Apocryphon of Jeremiah, one can identify the use of Daniel 4, and specifically secondary readings found in OG Daniel 4. Since these authors did not read the Greek translation of this chapter, then it stands to reason that they indeed relied upon a Semitic Vorlage of LXX Daniel 4.
The closing section of the paper will address the potential contribution and pitfalls of the use of parabiblical compositions as corroborating evidence for the textual evidence provided by ancient biblical translations in general, and LXX in particular.
|
Solentiname: Ernesto Cardenal and Nicaragua
Program Unit: Latino/a/e and Latin American Biblical Interpretation
Fernando Segovia, Vanderbilt University
Solentiname: Ernesto Cardenal and Nicaragua
|
Speaking the Truth and Yet Lying? Possessions and Speech in the Python Episode (Acts 16:16–22)
Program Unit: Speech and Talk in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Turid Karlsen Seim, University of Oslo
In Acts 16:16-22, a slave girl has the gift of divination referred to a spirit/demon Python, and she is a source of profit to her owners. She is indeed “possessed”. Women were often employed in mantic oracular activity, in which they were without will or senses of their own, totally submitted to divine powers and/or to those with the power of the key, that is those with the authority to interpret their otherwise senseless speech. Also in early Christian communities women were seen to be disposed to frantic possession by the Spirit. The paper will explore the power game involved in such communicative interdependence but also how the Python episode differs in that slave girl speaks the truth about Paul and his mission clearly and soundly. In stead of enrolling her support, her speech somehow annoys Paul and out of irritation he expels the spirit and renders the slave girl – and himself - in peril as she by loosing the voice of Python has been made useless to her mighty possessors. How is her speech act situated? Is Paul being conned? Could she possibly be speaking the truth and yet lying? How is it possible – if at all - to distinguish the pneuma pythona from the Holy Spirit, when as in this case, they seem to bear witness to the same truth?
|
The Deuteronomist and King Asa: Sources, History, and Historiography
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Omer Sergi, Tel Aviv University
The Deuteronomist's portrait of king Asa is highly favorable (1 Kgs. 15: 9-24). Asa is depicted as a righteous king, who was the first cultic reformer in Judah. The vocabulary used in the Deuteronomistic theological evaluation of Asa resembles only the vocabulary used for Kings Hezekiah and Josiah. Thus, it seems that for the Deuteronomist, Asa was the forerunner of the great reforming kings of the Deuteronomistic History. However, the account of Asa includes also the story of his war against Ba?asha, king of Israel (1 Kgs. 15: 17-22), during which he appealed for the intervention of an Aramaean king. Asa was harshly criticized for his deeds during this war and for its consequences. Why did the Deuteronomist moderate his evaluation of Asa by criticizing his acts during the war and what did he actually know about the affairs of Israel, Judah and Aram in the early 9th century BCE?
In this paper I will first present the relevant archaeological and historical data regarding Asa's war with Ba?asha in order to evaluate the historical reality behind this account. Accordingly, I will discuss the possible historical sources that were available to the Deuteronomist about the early kings of Judah and the way he interpreted them. It will be demonstrated that only fragmentary information was available to him, while gaps in it were filled according to patterns he developed for other Judahite kings. Thus, the Deuteronomistic moderated presentation of Asa as a righteous king is part of a whole historical concept demonstrating the deterioration of the kingdom of Judah after the schism which led directly to the reign of Athaliah and almost to the demise of the Davidic dynasty.
|
Violating the Household: Kidnapping, Ransoming, and Remarriage in Fifth and Sixth Century Italy
Program Unit: Violence and Representations of Violence in Antiquity
Tina Sessa, Ohio State University
During the fifth and sixth centuries, families living in the Italian peninsula suffered successive waves of war and invasion. Barbarian forces such as the Visigoths, Huns, Vandals, and Lombards attacked Italian cities and abducted Roman citizens. Some of these captives made their way back home, though their return often came at a considerable price to their households. Many families were forced to pay high ransoms, and those who could not afford the price were required to borrow funds – a process that legally placed their redeemed loved-one in a quasi-servile relationship to the redeemer, who in some cases was the local church. Still other returning captives discovered that their spouses had remarried in their absence and had no interest in reuniting. While this situation was potentially legal within the context of Roman civil law, it clashed with emerging Christian marital ethics, which emphasized the sanctity of first marriages. This paper will explore the social, economic, and religious impact of kidnapping and ransoming on the late Roman household, with a particular focus on the complex and sometimes problematic role of clergy in resolving these domestic emergencies.
|
“Woman, Why Are You Weeping?” The Prostitute’s Ever-Present Need for the True Mary Magdalene Narrative
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Mary Setterholm, Harvard Divinity School
As a theology student examining the tools of feminist deconstruction, the myth of Mary Magdalene, the whore, was an example of a subversive patriarchal narrative. While Mary Magdalene’s liberation from Whoredom was a great day for feminist scholarship and maligned honorable women, my sisters and I, who are recovering from prostitution, lost an empowering symbol of redemption for prostitutes. Members of our group, Serenity Sisters, experienced betrayal from all sides with the loss of Mary Magdalene as ‘one of us.’ There was anger at ecclesial power for the promulgation of the myth; suspicion of feminist agenda to dissociate her from our experience; and a return to a tomb of shame with no heroine to lead us out. But the question for myself and fellow prostitutes, past and present, is just what did the Legend of Mary Magdalene really do for us and to us? Perhaps the liberation of Mary Magdalene from Whoredom has also liberated the prostitute from faulty redemption myths. It is time to expose the myth that demonization and prostitution seem inextricably linked in many minds due to the conflation of Luke 8:2 with the Mary Magdalene prostitution myth: perhaps we despaired of self agency to make safe choices believing only a miraculous “Magdalene deliverance” that relies upon a patriarchal figure could save us. It seemed that the pimp got us in “the life” and only another power broker could bail us out. Either way, we were powerless. I will present further articulations of these travesties but more importantly, present concepts of how my sisters and I , the prostitute, stripper, and call girl, (trafficked or ‘consenting’) can reclaim Mary Magdalene as Jane Schaberg outlines MM’s powerful attributes (Schaberg 2004, 129) in The Resurrection of Mary Magdalene.
|
Religious Practices of the Enslaved in Antonine Ephesos: Re-evaluating Slaves in Image, Object, and Text
Program Unit: Archaeology of Religion in the Roman World
Katherine A. Shaner, Harvard University
Archaeological analysis of slavery in antiquity often assumes that slaves were merely subjugated bodies. Thus such analysis is also frequently limited to objects that were used as a means of containment (collars, shackles, stocks, etc.), depictions of workers, hand tools, and other instrumentalizing materials. In contrast, monumental architecture, imperial representations, and benefaction inscriptions are often dismissed as the purview of the elite and therefore thought to have little to reveal about enslaved persons. My presentation will explore the ways in which enslaved persons factor into so-called elite archaeological finds in the city of Ephesos.
I draw on a variety of inscriptions and architecture from Antonine Ephesos in order to illustrate the complexity of slaves' roles in religious practices throughout the city. More specifically, I draw on the Parthian reliefs, several benefaction inscriptions, and early Christian texts such as 1Timothy. Building on the work of art historians and archaeologists who admit the likelihood that enslaved persons appear in depictions of imperial sacrifice and benefaction inscriptions, I ask how our understanding of religious practices changes if we analyze reliefs, inscriptions, and texts with enslaved persons in view. My thesis is that enslaved persons helped shape the civic and religious life in the city despite the fact that monumental architecture, inscriptions, visual representations, and texts deploy various strategies for controlling and even occluding their presence.
|
The Varieties of Resurrection Beliefs
Program Unit: Social Scientific Criticism of the New Testament
Colleen Shantz, Toronto School of Theology
Many cognitive scientists argue that cognition, like other human characteristics, has been shaped by evolutionary selection. Thus, cognitive science distinguishes among beliefs in part by their degree of “naturalness.” Concepts that are well suited to evolved capacities and constraints are often called “cognitively optimal.” In contrast, “cognitively costly” beliefs or practices are not automatically supported by these evolutionary habits of thinking and require other sorts of explanations for their appearance and persistence. One of the most interesting aspects of early Christian perceptions of resurrection is the diversity of concepts that existed side-by-side—fueling, as Ramsay MacMullen argues, the first (official) church and the “second church” (the popular form) by the 4th century. This paper examines some of the afterlife beliefs and practices that existed in earliest Christianity, especially the Pauline assemblies, in light of the hypothesis of “cognitively optimal” thinking. It considers the role that cognitive constraints may have played, alongside social factors, in generating and supporting a variety of views on life after death.
|
Philo and the Controversy Concerning the Passions
Program Unit: Philo of Alexandria
Sharon Weisser, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
What is the role of Philo of Alexandria in the philosophical debate between the Stoics and the Aristotelian-Platonic tradition about the passions? Does Philo advocate an ideal of “suppression of the passions” in the line of the Stoics or does he tend to agree with the Aristotelian-Platonic “moderation of the passions”? In order to answer this question, it is necessary to place Philo in the historical context of the controversy, which is known in particular thanks to the testimony of Cicero (Tusculan Disputations III and IV) and Plutarch (On Ethical Virtue). Does Philo’s employment of the Stoic terminology regarding the passions reflect an understanding of the passionate phenomenon that matches the Stoic position as presented by Cicero? Conversely, do the arguments in defense of the passions found in Philo’s writings echo the Aristotelian-Platonic point of view? To what extent has Philo absorbed the polemical arguments formulated by the protagonists of this controversy?
Through an examination of some key passages in Philo’s oeuvre (such as Mos. 1, 25-29; Praem. 71; QG 4.15; Leg. All. 2, 8-12;101-102; 3, 114-150) in comparison with Cicero’s Tusculan Disputations and Plutarch’s On Ethical Virtue, we should observe that Philo does not only witness and echo this ethical polemic, but that he also integrates and rearticulates different elements stemming from this controversy in order to shape a new and original discourse on the passions.
|
Embodying Moab: Jeremiah's Figuring of Moab (Jer 48) as Reinscription of the Judean Body
Program Unit: Writing/Reading Jeremiah
Carolyn J. Sharp, Yale Divinity School
Interpreters have long pondered the question of the implied audience(s) in biblical prophetic oracles against foreign nations. Were these elaborate polemical poems intended as taunts directed to the actual enemy, or did they find their chief rhetorical purpose in internecine discourse instead? A useful catalyst for consideration of this issue is Julia Kristeva’s observation that ancient Israel’s covenantal relationship with God “harbors in its very essence an inherent inscription of foreignness” (Strangers to Ourselves [Columbia Univ. Press, 1991], 65). Building on work by Lori L. Rowlett and L. Daniel Hawk on the construction of insider and outsider status in the Book of Joshua, this paper explores rhetorical dimensions of Jeremiah’s oracle against Moab, paying special attention to theopolitical implications for identity formation of an implied Judean audience. First, I analyze semantic links between Jeremiah’s oracle against Moab and oracles to Judah, arguing that Jeremiah 48 portrays Moab in terms that mimic Jeremianic diction about Judah’s own salvation and doom. Second, I consider ways in which the oracle against Moab may serve to destabilize Judeans’ self-understanding. Here, I am particularly interested in the force of the explicit comparison of Moab with Israel and Bethel (48:13), the construction of a violated, broken, and drunken Moabite body writhing in labor (48:18, 25-26, 41) as warning to Judah, and the sardonic poeticizing of the despised enemy as a faux Judah over whom the LORD weeps (48:31-36). Jeremiah’s blurring of discursive boundaries between the “native” subjectivity of Judah and the “foreign” subjectivity of Moab may be read as problematizing any simplistic insider/outsider distinction in the cultural imagination of an implied Judean audience: if Moab is depicted as a faux Judah, so too the Judean theopolitical body is being reinscribed as potentially Moabite.
|
A Greek Medical Narrative and the Figure of Paul in Acts
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
Chris Shea, Ball State University
One area of Roman Imperial narrative that has not regularly been explored with regard to the development of Christianity is the large corpus of often-unedited medical texts. (Judith Perkins’s "The Suffering Self: Pain and narrative representation in the early Christian era" is a notable exception.) Texts, such as the massive collection of Greek material attributed to the physician Galen, may have been neglected because earlier scholars regarded the date (late 2nd century CE) assigned to the works as too late to contribute much to our understanding of primary Christian texts. But, now that recent scholarship, such as that of J. Tyson and R. Pervo, has expanded the discussion of the dating of the canonical Acts to include 2nd century works (even late 2nd century works), it seems reasonable to plumb the Galen corpus for healer and healing tales the early Christian writers might have used as mimetic exempla. (This I would argue despite the fact that our Galen corpus is actually rather impoverished with regard to lengthy straightforward narratives.)
This paper will argue that one such narrative from the Galen corpus can illuminate the narrative technique and structure of the Paphos episode of Acts 13 and can perhaps be instructive to our study of the controversial figure of Paul in the canonical Acts. The paper will also comment on the naming of the Paul figure in Acts.
|
The Social Status of Levite Women
Program Unit: Cultic Personnel in the Biblical World
Sarah Shectman, Independent scholar
The place of women in Israelite society, including their place in the cultic system, has long been understood as one of subordination to men, finding its ultimate expression in the exclusion of women from the priesthood. Such assessments generally treat women together as a group, in opposition to men, albeit with gradations of status between women who are minors, married, divorced, widowed, or prostitutes. However, the binary opposition of women to men leaves aside other social distinctions at play in ancient Israel, in particular between Levites and lay Israelites (or between priests, Levites, and lay Israelites). In this scheme, the tribe of the Levites, as well as the priestly families, occupy a special status; the men of these groups make up the various cultic officiants, but what of the women? Since women derived much of their status from the men with whom they were affiliated, it stands to reason that Levite women would occupy a different social niche than non-Levite Israelite women; texts such as Lev. 21:9 and 22:12–13 indicate that, indeed, women in priestly families were subject to different rules than were lay women. As Saul Olyan has observed in his book Rites and Rank (Princeton, 2000), “Distinctions in status, whether significant or minor, are the building blocks of hierarchy” (115) and affect the access of individuals to community activities, including participation in the cult. This paper will explore the particular and unique status of Levite women through this lens.
|
Remember Me by Means of This Letter: The Audience and Function of the Epistle of 2 Baruch
Program Unit: Function of Apocryphal and Pseudepigraphal Writings in Early Judaism and Early Christianity
Shayna Sheinfeld, McGill University
The (Syriac) Apocalypse of 2 Baruch, written in wake of the destruction of the Temple in 70 CE, utilizes the collective memory of the Babylonian exile to exhort its audience to both maintain the law and to believe in the imminence of the eschaton. While the exhortation itself might be fairly clear, how the message was originally used is not. The epistle found at the end of the apocalypse, 2 Baruch 78-87, serves as a summary of the apocalypse as a whole, and more specifically as a letter with a specific audience and function, which thus makes it an ideal place to look for clues about the function of the text. However, deriving the function of the epistle is not necessarily intuitive: the letter, for instance, is addressed to a mythic audience, the “nine-and-a-half” tribes, and is also transmitted to them on the “neck of an eagle.” This paper will provide a literary analysis of the epistle of 2 Baruch gathering evidence both from within the text itself and through a discussion of genre in order to determine the intended audience and function of the epistle.
|
The Story of the Healing of the Centurion’s Servant (Luke 7:1–10) as Dependent on the Story of the Healing of Naaman (2 Kings 5:1–19)
Program Unit: Formation of Luke and Acts
John Shelton, Dominican Biblical Institute
Several scholars have noted the connection between the story of Naaman (2 Kgs 5) and the story of the centurion’s servant (Luke 7). Both stories are about a Gentile military commander seeking a healing from Elisha/Jesus and the declaration that is made regarding faith and Israel. However, little discussion or progress has been made of such a connection. First, by taking into account specific techniques of Greco-Roman imitation, this paper will closely analyze the two texts to determine how deep the connection goes. Thus, the key goal of this paper is to account for Luke’s text as far as possible. This accounting will occur through invoking: (1) 2 Kgs 5:1-19; (2) the larger Elijah-Elisha narrative (e.g., 1 Kgs 17 and 2 Kgs 4); and (3) Luke’s general style and purposes. Finally, after applying the criteria for establishing literary dependence (plausibility, similarity, and intelligible differences), this paper will claim that the healing of Naaman should not be a mere footnote marking an interesting similarity to the healing of the centurion’s servant, but rather that the healing of the centurion’s servant is strongly dependent upon the healing of Naaman and should be studied accordingly; i.e., 2 Kgs 5:1-19 is constitutive of Luke 7:1-10.
|
Cloak and Finery: A Survey of Three New Testament Passages against the Backdrop of the Roman Textile Trade
Program Unit: Early Christianity and the Ancient Economy
Beth M. Sheppard, Garrett-Evangelical Theological Seminary
Peter Garnsey and Richard Saller in their treatment of pre-industrial Roman economy indicate that during the Empire dress was inextricably linked with status. References to clothing occur within the New Testament frequently enough to warrant an in depth investigation of the textile trade in an attempt to uncover hints of the socio-economic context of individual early Christian authors. The first task will be to review what is known of the Roman garment industry by surveying the works of E Barber, M. Hoffman and others and includes an assessment of some of the primary sources such as textile remnants preserved in the provinces, representations of clothing in art, and references to clothing manufacture and trade in Latin literature. Particular focus will fall on innovations of the first century CE that revolutionized textile commerce including the emergence of the upright loom and the advent of new styles such as the 'amphimallum'. Methodological concerns about the limits of visual depictions in art and the inability to accurately access local variations between Rome and the provinces; urban centers and rural enclaves will be noted. Following this background information, three passages will be analyzed. These include Luke 5:36, which hints at the prosperity of Luke’s community as opposed to that of Matthew or Mark, “Paul’s” request for traveling cloak in 2 Timothy 4:13--a passage that is eerily reminiscent of a similar request by Catullus in one his poems, and finally 1 Peter 3:3, which will be examined within the context of luxury textiles such as those mentioned in the 'Edictum De Pretiis Rerum Venalium'. Some tentative conclusions will be draw about the relative economic class of some of the early Christians in the late 1st and early 2nd centuries given this limited evidence.
|
The Lives of Biblical Animals
Program Unit: Ethics and Biblical Interpretation
Phillip Michael Sherman, Maryville College
The Hebrew Bible has a great deal to say about the lives of animals. Biblical scholarship, broadly speaking, does not. The so-called “question of the animal” has emerged as both a philosophical and ethical matter over the past several decades. For many modern philosophers, ethicists, and theologians concerned with the nature, welfare, and ethical treatment of non-human animals, the biblical writings (both Hebrew Bible and New Testament) constitute a problem to be overcome, seldom a resource upon which to draw. The general presentation of the “biblical” view of the lives of animals by such thinkers, however, is too often crude and overly simplistic. The biblical texts are presented as unrelenting texts of animal terror; the liberationist voice with regard to animal lives too often lies un-reclaimed.
The following paper seeks to sketch one possible way to relate biblical constructions or images of “animals” and their lives—especially by drawing on texts from the Hebrew Bible—with contemporary concerns about the “rights” of animals. Modern dialogue partners in this regard include Tom Regan’s seminal work, The Case for Animal Rights and Peter Singer’s Animal Liberation. I will demonstrate that a select number of those biblical materials which deal with animals are not as hostile to the lives of animals as some modern thinkers tend to suggest.
The goal of the paper is not to argue that the texts of the Hebrew Bible clearly or unambiguously argue for the “rights” of animals. (It may not claim such “rights” for human lives, either!). Rather, the argument advanced will be that biblical scholarship—caught up in Western culture’s penchant for “speciesism”—has failed to attend to the full range of materials dealing with animals and their lives in the biblical writings. The Hebrew Bible certainly does not claim that animals have “rights” after the fashion of modern advocates for animal welfare. These biblical texts may, however, claim considerably more than our current culture does.
|
A Discourse Analysis of Ephesians 3:1–13
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
Aaron Sherwood, Durham University
In Eph 3:2, the author of Ephesians is moved to interrupt his prayer for the audience by something he has said in verse 1, and he does not resume the prayer until 3:14, after the digression of verses 2–13. To date, the reason for the author’s digression and how it satisfactorily addresses whichever concern prompted it represents a lacuna in Ephesians scholarship. This paper engages in a discourse analysis of Eph 3:1–13 to clarify its structure, thereby revealing the purpose it serves in its immediate context, as well as its role within the letter as a whole. Careful attention to key terms and repeated language in the text reveal the logic of the two sentences of verses 2–7 and verses 8–12. The digression is an argument unpacking the phrase “the prisoner of Christ Jesus for the sake of the Gentiles” from verse 1. In order that the audience might accept Paul’s instruction, the author feels he must demonstrate that because Paul’s imprisonment is defined by his apostleship, his imprisonment is not a source of shame that undermines God’s purposes, but rather a source of honor that confirms God’s eschatological plan. Consequently, the prayer in 3:1, 14–19 now has behind it not just the audience’s narratio of 1:20–22, but the joint force of the audience’s narratio together with Paul’s narratio in 3:1–13, guaranteeing that they will know the love of Christ and be filled with God’s fullness.
|
Isaiah 2:2–5 and Micah 4:1–5 Once Again: Worship and the Unification of Israel and the Nations as the Eschatological Restoration of Humanity and Creation
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Aaron Sherwood, Durham University
The parallel texts of Isaiah 2:2–5 and Micah 4:1–5 are well known for their so-called universalism and remarkable visions of worldwide peace. So much so, that rarely have scholars paused to question the underlying logic of the event described in these oracles. What is the relationship between the eschatological restoration of Zion, the pilgrimage of the nations (rather than Israel) and the resultant shalom? Moreover, inadequate attention is often paid to the distinct functions of these oracles within their respective prophetic contexts. Whereas Isaiah is concerned with Jerusalem’s political situation and unrighteousness regarding wisdom and idolatry, Micah is concerned with social justice and with piety and cultic purity regarding the Jerusalem Temple. In its Isaianic occurrence, the oracle introduces the chiaroscuro pattern of judgment and hope for the literary unit of Isaiah 1–12, and depicts Israel’s future eschatological restoration in terms of the nations. In Micah, however, the oracle introduces the core of the book and is positioned at the center of the Hebrew text of the Twelve, and discloses God’s intentions in his eschatological restoration of the Temple (in a radical reversal of 3:1–12). Nevertheless, in both occurrences, the internal logic of the oracle and the coherence of its wider context are predicated upon the creational relationship between Zion and humanity. A comparison of Isaiah 2:2–5 and Micah 4:1–5 reveals for both prophets a shared pattern of thought, wherein the restoration of Israel, Jerusalem and the Temple mean the eschatological restoration of Zion and unification of humanity in worship of Israel’s God.
|
Fractures and Fissures of Sacrifice; or The Sacrifice that Therefore I Am
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
Yvonne Sherwood, University of Glasgow
Sacrifice is a potent site for stabilising the distinctions between the human and the animal, the beast and the sovereign and the devilish and the divine. We sacrifice to erect such distinctions, or sacrifice to our anxiety concerning them. Thinkers from Augustine to Elaine Scarry and Slavoj Zizek have affirmed, in different ways, that nothing witnesses to/creates a god more incontrovertibly than sacrifice: ‘I sacrifice; therefore God is/the gods are’. Sacrifice clarifies and purifies fundamental categories of Being around answers to the questions ‘Who/what commands sacrifice (to whom/what do I sacrifice)?’; ‘Who/what offers sacrifice?’; and ‘Who/what is on the fire or under the knife’? Both by definition and practice, sacrifice asserts itself as a form of killing that is nothing like acts of mutual devouring in the realm of ‘nature red in tooth and claw’. The intricacy and craft of sacrificial rites asserts the status of sacrifice as a rite for those with tools and hands.
Yet sacrifice as the site of alterity/altarity (so Mark Taylor) is also the place where categories become porous and volatile. Even more interestingly, it can be the place where they are self-consciously offered up. Sacrifice closes the fundamental cut between nature and culture marked by law and signification (two key guardian-markers of culture). The sovereign joins hands/paws/hooves with the beast in the place of the outlaw, undecideably above and beneath the law. In the civil realm of signs and language, sacrifice becomes a place for surrogacy, substitution (e.g. a lamb stands in for a man, and vice versa) and a site of shuffling between sacrifice as an actual practice and sacrifice as a sign. This paper explores such fractures and fissures of sacrifice using a range of biblical texts in conversation with Derrida’s The Beast and the Sovereign, ‘Eating Well’ and ‘The Animal That Therefore I Am’.
|
Theology of Choice
Program Unit: Theology of the Hebrew Scriptures
Zvi Shimon, Bar Ilan University
Theology of Choice
Dr. Zvi Shimon, Bar Ilan University
What stands at the heart of the biblical narrative? The answer provided by most theological works has invariably been considered in relation to God. Our study challenges this common assumption. The consistent dwindling of God's appearances and the difficulty in presenting God as the dominating figure behind history make the suggestion that God lies at the center of the narrative questionable.
This paper suggests, in contrast to the dominant position in the field of theology, that man and not God stands at the heart of the biblical narrative. The binary pair good/bad underlie the majority of narratives in the Bible. A literary analysis of an extended biblical narrative that has been understood to be a religious polemic theologically focused on God - the Elijah/Jezebel narrative - reveals that the essence of the tension and the central topic of this narrative is the distinction between good and bad and the contrasting outcomes stemming from a person's choosing between good and bad. The paper proposes an alternative theological outlook, a theology that may be termed a "theology of choice", according to which man's central task is to choose between good and bad. Theology of choice leads to biblical narrative's focus on the internal conflicts of people, their struggles and the choices that they must make. The principle that a person's choices determine one's destiny lies at the foundation of all biblical narrative and is one of the basic tenets of Israelite belief. In contrast to the belief in a predetermined destiny evident in many ancient mythologies as well as Greek tragedy, the outlook underlying many biblical narratives is that a person is a free being and is responsible for one's actions and one's ultimate destiny.
|
A Tale of Two Households: Mark 3:22–30 and 13:32–37
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Elizabeth E. Shively, Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary
I suggest that a key foundation for the parable of the householder in Mark 13:32-37 is 3:22-30. In that passage, Mark establishes the ministry of Jesus as the offense in a cosmic battle between the Kingdom of Satan and the Kingdom of God. The parable in 3:27 portrays Jesus liberating people from Satan’s household. Juxtaposed to this rescue operation is the depiction of Jesus establishing a new household consisting of people who are not characterized by blood or religion, but by doing God’s will (vv. 34-35). I argue that the parable of the householder in 13:33-37 reflects a development of the formation of Jesus’ family begun in the earlier passage. The language and imagery in this parable evokes that of 3:22-30. In 13:33-37, the Markan Jesus envisions his followers as part of the new household with work to do faithfully until he appears. Whereas the parable of the strong man portrays Jesus coming to Satan’s house to liberate captives, the parable of the householder portrays the coming of the Lord Jesus as the Son of Man to his own household, which he has liberated to do his will. Or, while the parable of the strong man depicts Jesus’ sudden coming to Satan’s household, the parable of the householder depicts Jesus’ sudden coming to his own household, because living in Jesus’ household requires a certain way of life (9:10-13; cf. 8:34-38). Key to my argument is that the primary subject matter of the Olivet discourse is not the destruction of the temple, but the behavior of Jesus’ followers in light of the imminent appearance of the Son of Man.
In this paper, narrative analysis is my key approach. In addition, a significant portion of the paper demonstrates that Mark’s distinctive purpose is illuminated when compared to the synoptic parallels.
|
Can Narrative be Normative? Marking a Way
Program Unit: Homiletics and Biblical Studies
Elizabeth Shively, Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary
We may hear the term “normative” and identify the Bible with modes of command, proposition, and principle. The Bible contains a variety of modes, however,and the most extensive is narration. In this paper, I demonstrate how narrative can
perform a normative function through preaching, using the ending of Mark’s Gospel as a test case. The sense of incompleteness upon arriving at 16:8 is an invitation to
reconsider the Gospel anew. The Markan Jesus promises to meet his disciples in Galilee (16:7). We, on the other hand, return to the Galilee of the text, where the story began.
Rereading the Gospel through the lens of the empty tomb account, we may pause at the story of the Gerasene demoniac. This story now appears as a resurrection account, by
which a person is brought new life and a restored mind through the divine power of one who has overcome Satan and conquered death. The Gerasene demoniac is evocative of the robed young man who sits at the tomb to announce what the Lord has done (16:5). The correspondences suggest that it is through an encounter with the resurrected Jesus in Galilee that disciples are restored and brought into community. As
with the Gerasene demoniac, this Jesus in whom God has manifested power will rescue them to put them in their right mind to proclaim what the Lord has done. This offers
possibilities for contemporary people who hear, that they might find restoration and power through an encounter with the risen Christ. Meaning is in the story and in its
appropriation by and transforming effects upon hearers. The narrative can be normative by challenging us to imagine a way of being in the world that calls us to new standards of living and shapes the way we think and act concerning God.
|
Canonization and Criticism: The Collection of the Qur'an and the Resistance to Methods from Biblical Studies in Qur'anic Studies
Program Unit: Qur'an and Biblical Literature
Stephen Shoemaker, University of Oregon
As John Wansbrough has rather pointedly observed, the Qur'an “as a document susceptible of analysis by the instruments and techniques of Biblical criticism…is virtually unknown.” This is no mere accident, however, as scholars of the Qur'an have long defended the isolation of their text from the methods of historical criticism. In fact, resistance to the use of methods from Biblical Studies in the investigation of the Qur'an and Islamic origins established itself quite early and has remained remarkably persistent. The relative quarantine of these methods from study of the Qur'an may in part reflect the early marriage of the investigation of Islamic origins with philology (Semitics) and study of the Hebrew Bible, rather than with New Testament and Early Christian Studies, during the nineteenth century. Accordingly, such comparisons as Qur'anic scholars have drawn to study of the Bible tend to compare the Islamic sacred text with the Christian Old Testament. To be sure, if one’s model is the Pentateuch, then the process of the Qur'an’s formation is indeed radically different. Nevertheless, the synoptic gospels of the Christian New Testament present a much better analogue to the formation of the Qur'an, albeit one that has been persistently overlooked. Presumably, many of the methods developed for studying the gospel traditions could be profitably applied to study of the Qur'an. Such an approach, however, would require Qur'anic Studies to abandon its more or less tacit acceptance of the traditional Islamic account of the Qur'an’s serial revelation and its wholesale ascription to Muhammad in largely the same format that it has come down to the present day. Yet significant evidence for the Qur'an’s final redaction only at the end of the seventh century under `Abd al-Malik seems to open the way for a more historical-critical approach to the Qur'an.
|
Mary at the Foot of the Cross: The Earliest Life of the Virgin and the Origins of Marian Lament
Program Unit: Lament in Sacred Texts and Cultures
Stephen J. Shoemaker, University of Oregon
The tradition of Mary’s lamentations at the cross has long been thought to belong primarily to the medieval period, emerging in the Christian East only around the end of the ninth-century and in the Latin West even later, in the twelfth and thirteenth centuries. Nevertheless, a long overlooked text, the earliest Life of the Virgin, reveals the origins of this celebrated medieval tradition already at the end of late antiquity. Attributed to Maximus the Confessor, this first complete Marian biography was almost certainly composed in Constantinople or its environs in the early seventh-century. In its meditations on the Passion, this Life imagines the horror of this spectacle as witnessed through the eyes of Jesus’ mother. The Virgin’s overwhelming sorrows reach the peak of their expression in four formal laments, two of which are voiced by Mary herself: the first after the appearance before Annas and Caiaphas, two at the foot of the cross, and finally one as the Virgin Mary sees to her son’s burial. These contain all the stock themes of lament in the Classical tradition, including the contrast between past and present, old and new, the innocent victim beset by wild beasts and wicked monsters, the ingratitude and injustice of the tormenters, the abandonment and isolation of the one lamenting, the sympathy of nature, and a considerable amount of anti-Jewish polemic. Although an earlier dialogue between Mary and her Son bearing the title “Mary at the Cross” was composed by the sixth-century hymnographer Romanos the Melode, this brief text has neither the characteristics of a formal lament nor was it particularly influential on the later tradition. By contrast, the lamentations from the Life of the Virgin largely determined the subsequent Byzantine tradition of Marian lament, and distinct echoes of this seventh-century composition still continue to be heard in the contemporary Eastern Orthodox service for Good Friday.
|
Shifting Sands and Paradigms: Early Jewish/Christian Relations and Mormons?
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Jeffrey Siker, Loyola Marymount University
Between the "parting of the ways" (Dunn, et al) and the "ways that never parted" (Becker, Reed, et al) discussions of early Jewish/Christian relations have staked out a variety of approaches to how best we should understand and describe the religious development that resulted in the formation of "Judaism" and "Christianity" as distinct and often adversarial religious movements in late antiquity. In this paper I propose a different, perhaps complementary, approach to the discussion by looking at a more recent development within the Christian tradition that, I will argue, parallels in many ways what transpired between early Judaism and early Christianity. The advent of Mormonism in 19th century American Protestantism provides a helpful heuristic device for understanding some of the dynamics at work in the advent of early Christianity as an offshoot within early Judaism. In particular, the parallels include: 1) a focal revelatory figure, 2) claims that this figure mediates a new covenant with God, 3) the formation of a new set of sacred writings, 4) the formation of new rituals and patterns of worship, and 5) the claim to fulfill and supersede all that came before. Reflecting on these parallels provides us with another vantage onto various aspects of the development of the Christian religious movement within and without its Jewish context. There are limits to the comparisons, and these will also be important to note. One way, however, that modern Christians in particular might get a feel for how the early Christian movement felt to Jews in antiquity is through a comparison of how the Christian tradition has responded to the development of Mormonism over the last two centuries.
|
Anonymity, Pseudepigraphy, and Auteur Theory
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Jason Silverman, Trinity College
The phenomenon of pseudepigraphy is a feature of Second Temple Judaism which has long eluded adequate explanation. Part of this topic's challenge is due to its intersections with how one understands the complex problems of authorship, fidelity to tradition, and the creative formation of new works. Particularly troubling is how (or
whether) pseudepigraphy relates to anonymity or the traditional ascription of works to a well-known figure. This paper attempts to bring to bear the debates on 'the Auteur' in Film Studies to the authorial persona and voice in the Jewish and early Christian writings of the Persian to Roman Periods. Using the discussion which has surrounded the creation of individual films and the appropriate frameworks for understanding said creation as a conceptual background (e.g., 'the auteur,' collaboration, and 'art'), this paper seeks to analyze pseudepigraphy by dissecting three layers related to authorship and text: background, creation, and product. When these three aspects are separated, pseudepigraphy and related authorial issues can be addressed in a less ideologically charged manner and with more focus on the many ways in which creators interact with their society, both intellectually and practically. The debates surrounding the Auteur in film-and the ways it has highlighted these three layers-should enable the removal of the creator from a status as isolated to genius and move towards one which is more situationally constructed, without insisting on the 'death of the author' as such.
This opening up of the concept of 'author' should have valuable implications not just for the apocalypses and pseudepigrapha, but more broadly for redaction and source criticism and the literary work of scribes, schools, and evangelists.
|
The Apostle Paul and Lament: Godly Sorrow as a Pedagogical Tool
Program Unit: Lament in Sacred Texts and Cultures
William Simmons, Lee University
The many problems and conceptual dislocations of the believers in Corinth challenged the Apostle Paul on a number of levels. In particular, their inordinate appropriation of a “theology of glory” and how this theology was pitted against Paul and his “theology of the cross” explains much of the difficulty in
Corinth. In response, Paul marshals a formidable array of tools to first deconstruct the many miscues of the Corinthians and then next to programmatically piece together a more authentic theological platform for them. In the main, his goal is not punitive but pedagogical. Among the many rhetorical strategies
employed by the apostle, his use of lament in 1 Cor 4:7-16 is striking. In this section, Paul posits that the preeminent realization of the Kingdom of God is not to be found in conventional understandings of power, wisdom and the dazzling effects of spiritual gifts so cherished by the Corinthians. Rather, God’s presence in the here and now is made real through weakness, apparent foolishness and suffering. All of
this means that the song of lament may well be the clearest expression of God’s redemptive work and power in the world.
|
Inner-Biblical Interpretation in the Redaction of Jeremiah 33:14–26
Program Unit: Covenant in the Persian Period
Matthew Sjoberg, Pennsylvania State University
Despite the difficulties in determining the compositional history of the book of Jeremiah (as shown by the very different conclusions McKane, Carroll, and Holladay argue for in each of their commentaries), we are in the uniquely fortunate position of having textual evidence for two different recensions, the shorter, earlier Greek recension (supported by 4QJer b,4QJer d) and the longer, later MT. This paper will examine the longest passage found in the MT but not in the Greek, Jer 33:14-26, and suggest that this passage, which adapts earlier covenantal language to fit a new time period, was composed in the early postexilic period (contra Lust and Holladay, who would date it later, and Nicholson and Lundbom, who would date it earlier), possibly in part as a reaction to oracles by the prophet Zechariah, at a time when the priesthood was in a position of greater influence. It is generally recognized that composer of Jer 33:14-26 based this passage on earlier Jeremianic oracles. This paper will show that the reworking of these earlier oracles places a greater emphasis on the priesthood and that the oracles would fit best in a situation where the line of David had little to no official role and the priesthood exerted real authority, such as was the case during the early postexilic period.
|
The ‘Leap’ According to Kierkegaard, St. John, and Bultmann
Program Unit: Søren Kierkegaard Society
Rebecca Skaggs, Patten University
Many theologians and some philosophers have interpreted Kierkegaard’s ‘leap’ as a ‘leap in the dark’, the abandonment of reason in order to believe. In doing this, they have missed the rich complexity of his concept of the ‘leap’. I suggest that, in fact, Kierkegaard’s idea echoes the notion of faith as commitment as expressed in the Gospel of John. John indicates this by his peculiar construction of pisteuo eis. John also uses the verb rather than the noun, which indicates believing as action rather than as a static state, implying experiential commitment as distinct from mere intellectual assent. I maintain Kierkegaard’s concept of the ‘leap’ sheds light on John’s idea (and perhaps vice versa) – that believing is not irrational but rather suprarational. I will also consider Rudolph Bultmann’s idea of ‘demythologizing’ in regard to John’s concept of believing and Kierkegaard’s notion of the ‘leap’.
|
The Apocalypse of John: A Lament?
Program Unit: Lament in Sacred Texts and Cultures
Rebecca Skaggs, Patten University
The lament form, although it functions quite differently in the New Testament than the Old, has serious implications for the study of the New Testament, including the Apocalypse of John. In fact, according to Scott Ellington, this form is “fundamental to the shape and content of their [the New Testament writers’] message”. In the Apocalypse, rarely if ever, is the lament form used in a complete or comprehensive way. John Christopher Thomas suggests that such forms exist as fragments, and even constitute an inclusio – a framework for the entire book.
From an investigation of the customarily agreed upon form of lament in the Old Testament, we suggest that it is comprised of three parts, although these may appear in different sequences and a variety of modes of expression: (1) invocation or call upon God; (2) description of the lamenter’s situation and the wicked intentions of the enemy; and (3) vow of praise/thanksgiving.
From applying this study to Revelation, we observe that John’s Apocalypse itself generally conforms to that description, even though complete lament forms are not actually part of the text.
We note further that both Ellington’s concept of ‘prophetic lament’ and Heschel’s ‘divine pathos’ indicate that the prophet shares and expresses the anguish of God over his people’s rejection. We maintain that John functions in this Jeremian role; he participates in God’s anguish. The pain of God, reflects the conflict between his justice and mercy –because of his justice, he must destroy the one he loves. The Apocalypse makes it clear that when no one responds to God’s signal activities, his judgment follows. Hence, God’s judgment is not reflective of his anger and vengeance upon the wicked; it is his final call for repentance; the absence of which leads to the outpouring of his judgment, in devastation and destruction.
2-12-10
|
Eluding Judgment: The Political and Christological Significance of Shifting Judicial Roles in the Markan and Matthean Narratives of Jesus’ Trial
Program Unit: Jesus Traditions, Gospels, and Negotiating the Roman Imperial World
Matthew L. Skinner, Luther Seminary
The trials of Jesus in the Gospels according to Mark and Matthew offer, among other things, a critical assessment of Pilate’s and the Jerusalem chief priesthood’s exercise of authority. This assessment comes particularly through Pilate’s attempts to reinforce his power over the Jewish leadership and through both parties’ efforts to distribute and confuse responsibility for the trial’s outcome. Judicial roles shift in the scenes. With these shifts, the trial narratives illuminate the nature of the sociopolitical authority to which Jesus becomes subjected. Given the christological import of these scenes, the sociopolitical contours emerge as hardly coincidental to Jesus’ identity as “Christ” and “king of the Jews.” This paper explores the narrative dynamics of these scenes to highlight their ways of integrating sociopolitical critique with the articulation of Jesus’ identity.
|
Atonement in the Pentateuch, How Does It Happen?
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Jay Sklar, Covenant Theological Seminary
*
|
Exile of the Body, Salvation of the Soul
Program Unit:
Brent Smith, Claremont Graduate University
The concept of withdrawal, both real and theoretical, is generally assumed to have been a prominent feature of early Christian asceticism, inviting legitimate comparisons between the retreat of the ancient philosophers and anchoritic retirement. Yet such comparisons cannot be pushed too far. The city (and its concomitant responsibilities) presented an occasion for philosophical exilic critique, but was the Christian counterpart a metropolitan concern? As a religion in transit, Christians already embraced the idea of transcendent citizenship, but in the fourth century exile became a prominent feature among ascetic exemplars and the ancillary literature that grew around them. Did the ascendancy of Christianity within the Empire transform theoretical exile into corporeal, where body replaces the polis as the locus of philosophical critique? This paper explores the “exilic turn” of Christian asceticism.
|
The Rhetorical Function of Interrupted Speeches in Luke-Acts
Program Unit: Formation of Luke and Acts
Daniel Lynwood Smith, University of Notre Dame
A surprising number of the longer discourses in Luke-Acts end abruptly, due to the interruption of the speaker by an emotional audience. While several scholars have noted the presence of these interruptions in both the Gospel of Luke and the Acts of the Apostles (e.g., in Luke 4, Acts 7, 22, and 26), there has been little effort put forth either to explain them or to explore their consequences for theories of the unity of Luke-Acts. I understand these frequent interruptions as instances of a rhetorical device, intended both to heighten the drama of the narrative and, more importantly, to highlight the pivotal closing words of these discourses.
To shed further light on these rhetorical interruptions, I examine their function in a wide range of Greco-Roman historical works and novels. The literary device of (intentional) interruption was not unique to the author of Luke-Acts, for interruptions are also present in Greek literature ranging from Homer to Josephus to Achilles Tatius. Still, even though the device is employed by other authors, the function of the interruptions found in Luke-Acts is rhetorically innovative. The interruptions magnify the conflict between speaker (Christ, or a follower of Christ) and audience (those who reject the early Christian message), thus underscoring major elements of Lukan theology (Christ’s resurrection or the mission to the Gentiles) through the dramatic violence of the audience’s reaction.
|
Rethinking Last Supper/Lord's Supper I
Program Unit: Meals in the Greco-Roman World
Dennis E. Smith, Phillips Theological Seminary
This paper will provide a set of theses for rethinking the origin and development of the Last Supper texts in the New Testament.
|
Zilpha Elaw and Her “Peculiar Circumstances”: Pauline Scripture and a Hermeneutics of Vocation
Program Unit: Recovering Female Interpreters of the Bible
Mitzi J. Smith, Ashland Theological Seminary
For some Nineteenth Century black female preachers the apostle Paul’s call experience as revealed in the scriptures functioned paradigmatically for understanding and articulating their own calls to a preaching ministry. Zilpha Elaw (like Old Elizabeth and Julia Foote) appropriated scripture and images from Galatians and the book of the Acts of the Apostles to formulate a special hermeneutics of vocation. The book of Galatians relates Paul’s exceptional experience as an Apostle “called not by a human nor through humans” but through divine revelation. Similar to Elaw, Paul received a special calling distinct from the other apostles. Additionally, the book of Acts provides three versions of Paul’s Damascus Road experience. Together with scriptures from Galatians Elaw used images from Paul’s Damascus Road encounter to construct her sanctification and calling narrative. Like the Apostle Paul, Zilpha Elaw understood her calling as a unique and a special giftedness. Thus, Elaw interpreted Paul’s injunction in 1 Tim. 2:12 for women to learn privately and in silence through the lens of her own “peculiar” experience. While the lens of her “peculiar” experience allowed Elaw to transcend scriptural injunctions and socio-cultural prohibitions against her own call to a preaching ministry, such an existential lens would not prove universally liberating when interpreting other Pauline texts such as I Cor. 7:21.
|
Christ will Come: The Function of Jesus’ Messianic Identity in the Logic of Paul’s Parousia Expectation
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Murray Smith, Presbyterian Theological Centre
Paul’s recognition of Jesus as the exalted Messiah is a central element in the logic of his parousia expectation. Generally, however, scholars have emphasized two other sources for Paul’s parousia logic. Many, following T.F. Glasson (The Second Advent 1945; Theophany and Parousia 1988), recognize that Paul’s parousia expectation has important roots in the theophanic tradition of the Hebrew Scriptures (Black 1973; Kreitzer 1987; Plevnik 1997; Wright 2005; Adams 2006). On this reading, Paul took over the OT doctrine of the Advent of the Lord, making the single adjustment that the Lord was the Lord Jesus' (Glasson, Second Advent, p. 183). Others, following Peterson (Die Einholung des Kyrios 1930), emphasize the ‘polemical parallelism’ evident in Paul’s parousia constructions, and highlight the function of the parousia motif within his counter-imperial polemic (Krentz 1996; Donfried 1997; Koester 1997; Harrison 2002). These two readings are, of course, not mutually exclusive, and they are both relativized and subverted in Paul’s new Christian construction (Brown 2000). Nevertheless, the emphasis on these two sources for Paul’s parousia expectation has obscured another significant element in Paul’s eschatological reasoning. This paper argues, therefore, that Paul’s recognition of Jesus as the exalted Messiah played a no less important role in his parousia logic. On the basis of a close examination of 1 Thess. 1.9-10; 4.13-18; 1 Cor. 15.20-28 and Phil. 3.20-21 it is demonstrated that Jesus’ messianic identity provided a crucial centre around which Paul integrated the theophanic tradition of the Hebrew Scriptures with counter-imperial polemic to produce his characteristic parousia doctrine.
|
Living in Two Worlds: Envisioning the Daniel Court Tales through the Lens of W.E.B. Dubois’s Double-Consciousness
Program Unit: African-American Biblical Hermeneutics
Shively Smith, Emory University
This paper, through analysis of the Daniel court tales, seeks build upon the work of W. Lee Humphreys, D. L. Smith-Christopher, and D. M. Valeta. Scholars such as Valeta and Smith-Christopher argue the tales reflect a period of imperial resistance. In contrast, Humphreys argues the court tales represent a more conciliatory period. Using W.E. B. Dubois’s notion of double-consciousness this paper seeks to introduce a new conceptual framework for identifying the features of both resistance and accommodation in the court tales. The paper will probe the following questions: Do the court tales reflect a group of people who are waiting for the ultimate downfall of their oppressors? Or, do they reflect a group of people who are successfully negotiating two different worlds and managing to live in both simultaneously. Could it be a world in which double consciousness exists rather than complete resistance or complete accommodation?
|
A Very Present Absence: Histories of Preaching in the Wake of the Ascension
Program Unit: Academy of Homiletics
Ted A. Smith, Vanderbilt University
*
|
Did Kemosh Have a Consort (or Any Other Friends)? Re-assessing the Moabite Pantheon
Program Unit: Archaeological Excavations and Discoveries: Illuminating the Biblical World
Josey Bridges Snyder, Emory University
It is clear that the Moabites worshipped a deity named Kemosh, but what of other gods? Did Kemosh have a consort and is there such thing as a Moabite pantheon? This paper seeks to identify other deities who may have been worshipped alongside Kemosh in Moab. While all forms of evidence (including the Hebrew Bible, Mesha Inscription, and various archaeological discoveries) are considered, special attention is given to Moabite personal names, drawn mostly from seals identified as Moabite in Avigad and Sass’s Corpus of West Semitic Stamp Seals. Forty-two such names are considered: 13 containing the theophoric element Kemosh, 6 possibly containing theophoric elements of other deities, and 6 containing the familial terms father or brother in the place of a theophoric element. After considering each name in turn, this paper concludes that though ancestor worship in Moab seems likely, there is not enough evidence to assert the worship of any deity other than Kemosh in Moab on a national scale. The implications for such a conclusion on the study of Israelite religion are clear: if the Moabites worshipped a “bachelor” deity with no consort and no pantheon, it seems more likely that their neighbor, the Israelites, did as well.
|
Music and Preaching in Conversation: Possibilities and Pitfalls
Program Unit: Academy of Homiletics
Noel A. Snyder, Fuller Theological Seminary
*
|
Whiteness and an Ethics of Reading the Bible in Africa: A Hermeneutics of Vulnerability
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Gerrie Snyman, University of South Africa
This paper is an effort to work through the issue of white privilege and proposes that that “something systemic” in our make-up that masks privilege relates to the issue of a non-reflected whiteness amongst European Diaspora in South Africa. The paper proposes a hermeneutics of vulnerability that aims to facilitate a Bible reading process with people whereby the focus shifts from an alignment with power to an alignment with those who become vulnerable because of the exercise of that power. Such a hermeneutic will enable the Bible reader to take into account the effect a particular explanation of Scripture will have on people for which he or she need to take responsibility.
With The Africana Bible as dialoguing partner, this paper will look at the possibility to use whiteness as a heuristic key to understand the socio-political location of those who would be labeled “white”, yet regard themselves inextricably (South) African. Secondly, on the basis of the focus on whiteness as a response to African hermeneutics, the paper will inquire into the question of how whiteness is to respond to a project such as The Africana Bible which exposes a vulnerability of those who fall outside the ambit of Yahweh’s grace in the face of the exertion of power with divine legitimization. Thirdly, the paper will argue that the recognition of whiteness within a hermeneutic of vulnerability will enable the “white” reader to come to consciousness of him or herself as white and work through that embarassment while inhabiting Africa.
|
Between Hero and Monster: The Role of Enkidu in the Death of Huwawa Narrative
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Karen Sonik, University of Pennsylvania
One of the most popular episodes from the narratives featuring Gilgamesh, and the one which has the longest history, is that recounting the Death of Huwawa/Humbaba. Recorded in two of the earliest known Sumerian Gilgamesh texts, dating to the late third to early second millennium BCE, it continues in circulation until its incorporation into the first millennium BCE Standard Babylonian epic.
The role of Enkidu in the narrative, his character and background reflecting aspects of both Gilgamesh and Huwawa, places him firmly in the middle of that triad of agents, and leads us to question where exactly the boundary between the monstrous and the heroic stands and if and how it might be transgressed. In at least one Sumerian version of the narrative, after all, it is Enkidu who not only is acquainted with Huwawa's abilities and power where Gilgamesh is not, suggesting a prior acquaintance, but also is the one who strikes the first blow in the death of the monster. In the Akkadian version of the narrative, Enkidu is more definitively represented as the physical equal and adopted brother of Gilgamesh, but is also depicted as one well familiar to and sharing a common background with Humbaba, growing up fatherless in the wild until his later taming by Shamhat and knowing the ways of the forest as well as the monstrous guardian of the Cedars.
Utilizing the available textual evidence, this project examines the differing presentations of a crucial episode in the Gilgamesh narrative, the Death of Huwawa, in the surviving visual and textual sources to elucidate the changing nature of the heroic and the monstrous – and what lies between - in the context of this narrative.
|
The Iconography of Usmu, Vizier of Ea, in the Art of Mesopotamia
Program Unit: Art and Religions of Antiquity
Karen Sonik, University of Pennsylvania
The boundaries between realms, the heavens, earth, and the netherworld, were immutable in ancient Mesopotamia: neither mortals nor gods could transgress them with impunity. In The Descent of Inana to the Netherworld, while Inana is able to enter the realm of Ereškigal she is not able to assert her dominion there, and is allowed to leave only after offering Dumuzi as her substitute. Similarly, the trio of Enlil, Ninlil, and Suen must be ransomed from the netherworld in Enlil and Ninlil by the three netherworld gods borne by Ninlil. If immutable, however, these boundaries were not utterly impassable, and several classes of intermediate divine being functioned, whether legitimately or illegitimately, as boundary-crossers. On the illegitimate side were numerous monsters and daimons originating in and properly inhabiting peripheral or chaos zones that nevertheless managed to intrude on the natural or divine realms to threaten the divine order or to harass hapless mortals; on the more legitimate side were the viziers of the gods, who transgressed boundaries in the service of divine order and communication and who have occasionally been classed as “angels.” Despite their importance, most viziers are not depicted – or have not yet been identified – in the art of Mesopotamia. This paper focuses on the iconography of one of the few viziers who are represented, Isimud/Usmu, vizier of Enki/Ea: it considers his two-faced form and the scenes in which he is depicted, delineating his sphere of agency and comparing it with that of the Mesopotamian daimons.
|
The Rhetoric of God’s Amendments in the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Orality, Textuality, and the Formation of the Hebrew Bible
Jean-Pierre Sonnet, Gregorian University
The paper will seek to scrutinize the rhetoric of God’s amendments in a dozen of passages of the Hebrew Bible where Yhwh is reformulating previous words, whether his or words uttered by a human character (in Genesis 1 and 6–9, Genesis 18, Exodus 32–34, Numbers 14, 2Sam 7, etc.). The working hypothesis is that the ways and means of inflection in God’s speech are analogical to the scribes’ hermeneutical techniques in biblical Fortschreibung, primarily in the context of law. In other words: God, in the biblical world, reasserts spoken words (and especially his own) in the very process of changing them, just as the scribes, in the authorial world, reassert canonical or authorized words in their way to mend them. What does it mean, for the critical reader, to watch God relating to words “just as” the scribes? And what did it mean, for the scribes, to project a God at their image?
|
The Principle of Analogy and Biblical Interpretation in the Renewal Tradition
Program Unit: Society for Pentecostal Studies
Kevin Spawn, Regent University
After assessing recent developments of the use of the Troeltschian tenets of historical research in recent Old Testament scholarship, this essay appropriates the principle of analogy to biblical interpretation in the renewal tradition. Since both natural and supernatural phenomena inform the hermeneutical lens of the interpreter, analogical thought in the renewal tradition is based upon both of these realities. In this essay, analogy is contextualized by the principle of correlation and examined against a continuum of comparable and unique events. In conclusion, a brief example of renewal interpretation is sketched in this essay.
|
A Woman's Right to Choose? The Blessed Mary as Deliberative Mother, Prophet, and Theologian in Luke 1–2
Program Unit: Feminist Hermeneutics of the Bible
F. Scott Spencer, Baptist Theological Seminary at Richmond
Luke’s birth narrative stresses divine agency in selecting and “overshadowing” Mary to bear God’s Son and Israel’s Messiah. God’s choice is primary. But that doesn’t mean that Mary’s role is entirely passive or that “let it be with me according to your word” (1:38) captures the full range of Mary’s involvement. Indeed, Luke repeatedly highlights Mary’s deliberative, “pondering” and prophetic engagement with God’s word and events surrounding the birth and childhood of Jesus (1:29, 46-55; 2:19, 34-35, 51). Drawing on feminist-theoretical assessments of women’s agency, feminist-theological appraisals of divine providence and power, and feminist-critical interpretations of Luke 1-2, this paper seeks a thick-textured, constructive understanding of human freedom and responsibility disclosed in Mary’s responses to her God-chosen maternal vocation. Methodologically, it seeks to negotiate both suspicious (deconstructive) and transformational (redemptive) strategies of feminist hermeneutics in the interest of deepening Christian theology and spirituality.
|
Reggae Transforming Exegesis
Program Unit: Islands, Islanders, and Scriptures
Althea Spencer Miller, Drew University
The history of Jamaican music correlates to the contours of major social changes and transformations that had nothing less than revolutionary impact in Jamaica. The music is inseparable from the Rastafarianism. Through music, Rastafarianism effected a transvaluation of Christian hegemony into Rastafarian radicalism by a lyrical re-signifying of Biblical texts thus propelling Rastafarian categories and ethos from social marginalization to the front lines of identity, ethics, and a re-definition of empire within Jamaica. By analysis of lyrics and themes that utilize the Christian Scriptures for the Rastafarian message this paper will demonstrate this transformational subversion. The Rastafarian use of Christian texts and themes is a form of locational hermeneutics that transforms interpretation into event. Considering Rastafarian music and lyrics as biblical critical events transcends the analytical moribund of the secular/sacred, profane/holy, divides because this music is also popular music. Their approach critiques and dethrones traditional interpretive authority. Rastafarian lyrics reflect a paradoxical mix of assent to and dissent from Christian theological, social, and ethical dominance. Lyrics express assent and dissent by referencing the Bible through allusion, citation, and intentional paronomia. Although citations are usually recognizable, they nonetheless defuse the Christian grand narrative, transforming text into texture, rendering it the “text-u-r.” Allusion and paronomia also re-fuse the text for explosive and catapulting independent social alterations that transform Christian interpretation into refuse. This paper will explore the texturing and re-fusing of Biblical texts, in Jamaican music and lyrics, as focalizers for the cartography of revolt, subversion, and social transformation.
|
Joshua Recapitulated: The Relation between Judges 1–2 and the Book of Joshua
Program Unit: Joshua-Judges
Klaas Spronk, Protestant Theological University
In discussion with recent publications by among others M. Rake (Juda wirdaufsteigen, 2006) and S. Frolov ("Joshua's Double Demise", VT 2008) I want to present an interpretation of Judges 1:1-2:10 as completely dependent upon the book of Joshua. The introduction of the book of Judges should be read as a recapitulation of the whole preceding book of Joshua, from the reference at the beginning of the death of the leader to the final sermon and death of the leader. The different roles of the tribes, the story of the messenger in Bochim, and also the repeated reference to the death of Joshua fit within this framework. By means of this recapitulation the author wanted to emphasize that Judah is the rightful successor of Joshua. It was probably composed relatively late: after the completion of both the books of Joshua and Samuel in their present form. There are no compelling reasons to assume that the first part of the book of Judges is based on sources different from and older than the book of Joshua.
|
The Codico-liturgical Approach of Byzantine Bible Manuscripts
Program Unit: Bible in Eastern and Oriental Orthodox Traditions
Klaas Spronk, Protestant Theological University
At the Protestant University of Kampen an ambitious project has started to describe the field from a codico-liturgical perspective. An important source for researchers is the Byzantine liturgy of the Eastern Orthodox Churches, in which one can still find these same codex forms in use today; the forms of the printed editions closely resemble the manuscript forms. From here one can trace the tradition of those factors that contributed to forming the codices. The corpus of Byzantine manuscripts is characterized by diversity, but within this, standard codicological forms can be distinguished; those containing text items from the Greek NT or OT corpora, or both, and those containing biblical texts combined with other specific liturgical and patristic books and texts, that comment on the biblical monuments in an extremely rich and varied way. The codico-liturgical approach can redirect the study of the Byzantine manuscripts to a system of cataloguing that allows for a far more complete and inclusive picture of the state of affairs of the codex forms in which the biblical and other ecclesiastical texts were handed down to us.
|
Mosaic Prophecy and the Place of D in the Torah
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Jeffrey Stackert, University of Chicago
Recent scholarship has renewed debate concerning the Deuteronomic (D) source’s use of earlier Torah source material. In line with these discussions, this paper will examine the presentations of Mosaic prophecy in D and its main resource, the Elohistic source (E), and consider their implications for D’s perception of itself and its relationship to its sources. It will argue that D restricts future licit prophecy by carefully defining what features of E’s presentation of Moses are determinative. In so doing, D also introduces an exclusivism that defines its own work over against all of the other Torah sources.
|
Healing Miracles in DeMille, Ray, and Stevens: A Synoptic Reading of Three Hollywood Jesus Films
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Jeffrey Staley, Seattle University
Nicholas Ray’s 1961 film "King of Kings" explicitly evokes Cecil B. DeMille’s 1927 film "The King of Kings" by its choice of titles. The title of George Stevens’s 1965 "The Greatest Story Ever Told" does not hint of its connections to either DeMille's or Ray's films. Nevertheless, one can argue that this trilogy of Hollywood Jesus films is nearly as closely intertwined as the Synoptic Gospels themselves. "King of Kings" builds upon, “corrects,” and interprets "The King of Kings"; and "The Greatest Story Ever Told" builds upon, “corrects,” and interprets both of the earlier Hollywood Jesus films.
Utilizing the first two miracles in these three films (healing of the lame, healing of the blind), I will show how particular American religious and socio-political issues get translated into the scenes. Viewing these three films in conversation with each other can raise students’ awareness of how the Synoptic Gospels themselves might be inter-related, and how they might be reshaping their sources for changing circumstances.
For the past ten years I have taught an undergraduate Theology course called “Hollywood Jesus”—sometimes offering as many as five sections of the course in an academic year. This proposal is an outgrowth of that course, and is based on a research topic that I have often had students explore in papers.
|
The Theme of the “Twin” in the Literature of Thomas, Mani, and Plotinus
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Charles Stang, Harvard University
This paper will explore the theme of the “twin” in three bodies of literature: the so-called ‘Thomas’ Christian literature, the Cologne Mani Codex, and the Enneads of Plotinus. In all three corpora—Christian, Manichaean, Neoplatonic—the theme of the twin reveals a broader theological anthropology according to which the inauguration of an intimate relationship with the divine is marked by a certain dissociation from self, a splitting, a doubling, or as it often appears in these texts, a “twinning.” My paper will focus less on the diachronic genealogy of the theme of the “twin” and more on the synchronic account of the human self as being simultaneously one and two—what Henri Corbin calls a unus-ambo or “bi-unity.” Thus, for example, I will read the theme of the “twin” in The Gospel of Thomas against the backdrop of those many logia that speak of “the one and the two,” “standing alone” or “singly,” “images” and “likenesses,” and “division.” I will investigate Mani’s visitation by a heavenly syzygos in the Cologne Mani Codex (and corroborating Manichaean literature) with an eye to discerning whether and how this famous visitation suggests a peculiar anthropology centered on our each having a divine counterpart, a “twin” of sorts. Finally, I will turn to the Enneads of Plotinus and argue that his account of the human nous in continuous but occluded contact with the divine Nous (the second hypostasis of the Plotinian "trinity") reveals a similar anthropology as the Gospel of Thomas and the CMC, but in a philosophical idiom. I will conclude with some speculations as to whether and how the theme of the “twin” and the unus-ambo anthropology might shed light on the development of Christology in the 4th and 5th centuries.
|
Introduction to the Proposed Section
Program Unit:
Christopher D. Stanley, Saint Bonaventure University
This brief paper will explain the development, purposes, and plans for the proposed section on "Postcolonial Studies and Biblical Studies," focusing particularly on (a) its concern for methodological consistency and clarity, i.e., engaging postcolonial scholarship on its own terms vs. simply mining postcolonial studies for points that might appear relevant to biblical scholars, and (b) its openness to all potential points of connection between postcolonial studies and biblical studies, including the use and influence of the Bible in modern colonial/postcolonial settings and the application of postcolonial insights to the historical (colonial) contexts of the biblical authors/editors/audiences.
|
“Lord Lord!” Jesus’ Use of the Divine Name in the Synoptics
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Jason A. Staples, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
It has long been established in New Testament studies that Jesus does not directly claim divinity in the Synoptic Gospels, only doing so in John. Some recent works have argued that the Synoptics do in fact present Jesus as divine, but these studies have continued to run into the problem of Jesus making no clear and direct claim to divinity in the Synoptics.
This paper examines the “Lord Lord” sayings in Matt 7:21–22, 25:11, and Luke 6:46, arguing that the double "kurios" in these passages in fact reflects Jesus’ self-referential use of the divine name, serving as the Greek equivalent for the "adonai YHWH" formula so often used in the Hebrew Bible. Because adonai was used as a circumlocution for YHWH, this formula was read “adonai adonai” and was often translated into the LXX as "kurios kurios," most notably in LXX Ezekiel, where "kurios kurios" says that he himself will come down as a shepherd, restoring Israel and Judah (Ezek 34–36), passages that will also receive some attention in the paper.
The paper shows that the double use of kurios is unknown in Greek literature outside the LXX’s translation of adonai YHWH, suggesting that these Gospel passages would ring in the ears of hearers familiar with the Greek Bible (or even its Hebrew Vorlage). Because modern translations avoid such repetitions in translating the Hebrew Bible and most New Testament scholars do not often read Old Testament texts in their ancient languages, the once-plain echo has been obscured by the deafness of the modern audience, which has not had “ears to hear” Jesus’ use of divine name in the Synoptic Gospels.
|
Displaying Dismemberment: Reading the Levite and His Lover
Program Unit: Cultic Personnel in the Biblical World
Francesca Stavrakopoulou, University of Exeter
The story of the Levite and his lover in Judges 19 is well known for its power to unsettle present-day readers: in order to stave off his own rape, the Levite gives his lover to a mob to be gang-raped before dismembering her body and dispatching its parts to the tribes of Israel. Whilst the relationship between the Levite and his lover has attracted a great deal of attention from feminist critics and queer-theorists, the socio-religious dynamics of the relationship between the Levite and the corpse itself are frequently overlooked. This paper will employ socio-anthropological and religio-cultural perspectives to explore (i) the biblical portrayal of the Levite’s interaction with the corpse; (ii) the social agency of the corpse and its parts; and (iii) scholarly responses to this provocative text. In doing so, it will suggest new ways to conceptualize both biblical and scholarly perceptions of the role of cult functionaries in dealing with the dead.
|
To Worship the Johannine "Son of Man" (John 9:38): Refining Early Christian Devotion to Jesus
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Martijn Steegen, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Belgium
Recently, scholarly studies have focused on the emergence of the devotion to Jesus during early Christianity as one that arose from “an explosion in devotional innovation” against the background of monotheistic Second Temple Judaism (Hurtado, 2003: 136). Of the Johannine believers, it is said that they “attributed to Jesus a status in their religious life and thought that exceeds anything we know by way of analogy in… Jewish traditions about… agents of God…” (Hurtado, 2003: 360). In the Gospel of John, Jesus seems to function most clearly as a deity (1:1.18; 20:28) and therefore as a recipient of worship (see Keener, 2003).
In the recent debate, a great deal of attention has been given to a wide range of distinct divine agencies in Second Temple Judaism to elucidate the possible background of early Christian devotion. In current scholarship, there is a notable absence on the semantic range of relevant Greek terms designating worship (latreuo-latreia, leitourgeo-leitourgia, thrèskeia, proskyneo) to Jesus in the Gospels. In this paper, I shall study the use of the term “proskynèsen” of Jesus as “Son of Man”, by the man born blind, in the text-critically difficult passage 9:35-38. Although the term proskyneo frequently describes respect given to a variety of figures and therefore, is usually not an implied deification given to the recipient, some commentators argue that the worship of the man born blind (9:38) “fits the Johannine portrait of Jesus’ deity and invites John’s own audience to worship Jesus” (e.g. Keener, 2003: 795).
It is my contention that John’s Christology is less innovative and explosive in comparison with Jewish thought and praxis found within the arguments of Hurtado. Therefore, in this paper I will provide an in-depth exegetical study of the use of the verb proskyneo in John 9:38. Through this study, I will defend the notion that the use of proskyneo, by the man born blind, should not be understood as directly and exclusively addressed to the Johannine Jesus but alternatively, as an acknowledgment and recognition that the Father is made known in the person of Jesus (cf. 9:3).
|
The Eyewitness Testimony in John 19:35 as Mediation to Revelatory Experience of God
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Martijn Steegen, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
By means of an aside in John 19:35, the Fourth Evangelist presents his readers with an eyewitness testimony confirming the last events at the cross, in particular, the piercing of Jesus’ side and the flow of blood and water from this wound (cf. 19:34). However, historical scholarship of the eyewitness testimony in 19:35 has been more concerned with verifying the accuracy of the witness, and as a result, has failed to note the very nature of the witness itself.
In this paper, I intend to elaborate an understanding of the eyewitness testimony in the Gospel of John (cf. 19:35; 20:30-31), in which the verbs ‘to see’ (horao), ‘to testify’ (martyreo) and ‘to believe’ (pisteuo), all important Johannine keywords, function as hermeneutical concepts. I will explore the ways in which an encounter with God, through Jesus, is not necessarily limited to the historical Jesus event, just as revelation is not limited primarily to Scripture. The eyewitness testimony in 19:35 summons the reader to enter actively into a revelatory process by reading the Gospel. The reader is challenged to believe (pisteuo) in the act of seeing (horao) or reading the eyewitness testimony (martyreo) of the first disciples (cf. 1:19-34). Just as the historical Jesus was the symbolic place of encounter between his followers and the Father (cf. 3:12-13), the textual presence of the Johannine eyewitness testimony now functions as a revelatory medium between God and all future generations of believers. It is my contention that this perspective is an essential aspect for one to gain a further understanding into the nature of the Johannine testimony in 19:35. I will demonstrate that the testimony shifts from the confessional and the narrative to the manifestation of that to which testimony is given. Through this shift, the eyewitness testimony functions symbolically and illuminates a reality that is fundamentally unnoticeable and unutterably present: an encounter with the risen Lord. It is my contention that experiencing God in the Gospel of John occurs through the dynamics of testimony (horao and martyreo) and by a faithful response (pisteuo) to this historical eyewitness account.
|
The Lord’s Day of Revelation 1:10 in the Current Debate
Program Unit: Sabbath in Text and Tradition
Ranko Stefanovic, Andrews University
During 1960s and early 1970s there were several exchanges of opinion in scholarly journals regarding the possible meaning of the expression kuriake hemera in Revelation 1:10. The difficulty with the expression is that it is a lectio originalis found only here in the book. The majority of commentators today commonly hold it to mean Sunday, taking such a meaning almost for granted. Such an understanding is problematic, however, for the simple reason that the historical evidence to support such a meaning is very slim and that it does not fit the historical reality regarding the Sabbath/Sunday observance in the late first century. Several alternative proposals have emerged ranging from Easter Sunday, the Emperor’s day, the seventh-day Sabbath, or the figurative meaning of the phrase as the eschatological “Day of the Lord.” It appears that no constructive proposal has been offered yet which does justice to the meaning of the expression in its biblical and historical context. This paper briefly reviews and evaluates the major views on the expression and suggests a plausible meaning behind this enigmatic phrase in the Apocalypse. The paper suggests a twofold meaning of kuriake hemera within which the seventh-day Sabbath and the eschatological Day of the Lord are blended into one eschatological concept. Evidence which supports this includes the eschatological purpose of the Apocalypse (cf. 1:1-3; 22:6, 12, 20), the eschatological statements that permeate the messages to the seven churches anticipating their fulfillment in chaps. 21-22; the eschatological connotation of the Sabbath both in the Hebrew Scriptures (Isa. 58:13-14; 66:23) and the New Testament (Heb. 4:4-11; Matt. 24:20) as well as the Jewish tradition (i.e. The Life of Adam and Eve and the Rabbinic sources: Sanhedrin 97a, b; Tamid 7:4; Midrash on Psalm 73:4; Str.-B 3.687). Together this explains, in my view, the reason the revelator coined the expression kuriake hemera for the purpose of incorporating the two biblical concepts into one.
|
Hellenistic Epistemology and the Epistle of 1 John
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Romulus D. Stefanut, University of Chicago
From a simple comparative analysis, the epistle of 1 John contains an impressive epistemological vocabulary in relation to other New Testament books. Verbs of sense perception are paired with nouns designating sensory organs; verbs of knowledge are scattered amidst adjectives denoting the truth value of things; these are just some of the linguistic "garden" varieties. If the vocabulary is well suited, the form of argumentation is equally serving an epistemologic agenda for our author. The main form of reasoning employed in 1 John is the categorical implication, typical of Stoic logic. This paper, therefore, will argue that both the content and the form of 1 John reveal an important interest in the pursuit of knowledge. The prologue, with its epistemologic tour de force will be illustrative for the epistemic content of 1 John, as several of the themes introduced in the prologue are further developed in the rest of the ‘epistle.’ The basic forms of categorical implication, modus ponens and modus tollens, are very well represented in our text, in what appears to be a series of tests of orthopraxy meant to edify the Johannine community. This combination of form and content makes 1 John one of the most interesting NT writings in relation to Hellenistic epistemology.
|
The Criterion of Truth and the Truth of the Criterion: Hellenistic Epistemology in 1 John
Program Unit: Hellenistic Moral Philosophy and Early Christianity
Romulus D. Stefanut, University of Chicago
The major epistemological debate of the Hellenistic age, with the Epicureans and the Stoics on the one hand and the Skeptics on the other, can be summarized under the rubric of the ‘criterion of truth.’ The Skeptics (both academic Skeptics and Pyrrhonists) rejected the possibility of knowing the truth. The Epicureans and the Stoics argued for the possibility of knowledge, but differed with respect to the method of doing so.
Using insights about the ‘criterion of truth’ from Epicurean and Stoic epistemology (in particular, Epicurus’ Letter to Herodotus and the reports on Zeno recorded by Diogenes Laertius in his Lives, book vii), the philosophically attuned reader will notice how 1 John uses epistemological language in the service of his theological argumentation. My thesis is that 1 John uses at least two of the “criteria of truth” found in Hellenistic Epistemology: “sense-impressions” (aisthesis) and “feelings” (pathe). The importance of sense-impression is traceable right from the prologue of 1 John (1:1-4) with its epistemological tour de force. The “feelings”, though dressed up in Christian theological guise as “love”, function as a “criterion of truth” in the epistle (1 John 4:8, for example). The extent to which these arguments are convincing from a rhetorical and theological standpoint remains to be determined. At any rate, 1 John is by far one of the most interesting NT writings employing epistemological language.
|
Did Something Go Wrong in the Beginning? Some Reflections on the Emergence of Christianity
Program Unit: Construction of Christian Identities
Ekkehard Stegemann, Theologische Fakultät der Universität Basel
Tying in with the late Krister Stendahl’s notion, that “something went wrong in the beginning”, I’ll try to discuss some models or metaphors (mother-daughter, twin birth etc.) which were used to describe the emergence of Christianity as a flawed parting away from Judaism.
Using recent discourses on ethnicity (vs. religion) I will suppose a reading in which a collective identity is based on a notion of “organic cohesion” (D. Konstan) notwithstanding the attendant circumstances of belonging for instance to different ethnic identities – at least until the /parousia/. There is especially in Paul a possibility of coexistence of different identities within a process of a shared “apocalyptic”) transformation. This process is connected with the expectation of becoming a "son of God" or "children of God." But as long as this transformation has not come to an end Paul constructs earthly cohesions orientated at sibling-language. A special organic cohesion in spite of different ethnic identies is constructed by Paul via his reading of Abraham as a "hybride" forefather of a "hybride" progeny. It is probably the historization of this "apocalyptic" program due to which something went wrong in the beginning.
|
Angels among Us: Angelic Aspiration in the Ideology of Rabbinic Halakhah
Program Unit: Religious World of Late Antiquity
Jonah Steinberg, Hebrew College
Rabbinic Midrashim redacted in Roman Palestine of the Fifth Century C.E. carry forward a much more ancient theme associating the line of Israel, its Levitical Priests, and other storied Jewish leaders with the angels of heaven, and granting them near-divine identity. These midrashim make claims about Jewish humanity and its utmost possibilities that are no less dramatic, vivid and ontological than the heavenly speculations of pre-destruction apocalyptic literature. Yet midrash gives us distinctly rabbinic accounts of the Jewish person’s angelic and divine potential. I suggest that a trope of angelic aspiration in this-worldly Jewish action arose in knowing tension with early Christian notions of divinization and partly in response to Christian polemics against rabbinic halakhah. To borrow terms from Patristic literature in a way both outrageous in the outlook of early fathers of the Church and indicative of points of contention between them and early rabbinism, we might name our midrashic theme: “Theosis through Works of the Law.”
|
“One of These Things Is Not Like the Others”: Uses of Interdisciplinary Research in Studies of Second Temple Orality and Textuality
Program Unit: Orality, Textuality, and the Formation of the Hebrew Bible
Elsie R. Stern, Reconstructionist Rabbinical College
In the past several years, there has been a surge in scholarship exploring the ways in which awareness of the role of texts in largely oral cultures should inform contemporary understandings of biblical texts. The scholars exploring this question draw on material from the various disciplines that engage the relationship of orality and textuality. They apply the work of communications theorists, anthropologists, cognitive psychologists,performance theorists,historians of memory and literacy and scholars who focus on issues of orality and literacy in the Ancient Near East and Greco-roman worlds. The data and findings from these various disciplines are certainly relevant to the question of how issues of orality and textuality should shape our understandings of the composition, transmission and reception of biblical literature in the second temple period. However, none of the data that ground the findings of these various disciplines is a “perfect match” for this particular case. Rather, a complex Venn diagram maps the intersections and divergences that exist between the second temple situation and the data on which the multi-disciplinary findings are based. This paper will provide a methodological model for analyzing this interdisciplinary “Venn diagram” by comparing selected second temple descriptions of the transmission and reception of scriptural material with the situations of orality/textuality that generated the paradigms and axioms invoked most frequently in biblical research. This model will provide a tool for delineating more carefully which aspects of the various methodological models are present in the ancient depictions and, consequently, which findings are most relevant to our attempts to reconstruct the oral/textual situation of second temple Judaism.
|
Tagging Sacred Space: Graffiti and Devotional Practice in the Dura Europos Synagogue
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Karen B. Stern, Brooklyn College of City University of New York
Discovery of the synagogue in Roman Dura Europos transformed the study of Jewish populations throughout the Greco-Roman world. Most ancient synagogues are documented through architectural and mosaic fragments alone, but the Dura synagogue was discovered nearly intact. The most striking decorative feature of the synagogue — elaborate murals that depict biblical stories — have continued to dominate scholarship on the remarkable structure. This paper, however, advocates renewed attention to several neglected features of the synagogue, which include incised and painted graffiti that mark the synagogue’s walls and architectural features. Closer examination of these texts and figurative images, moreover, reveals distinct patterns in their deposit. While graffiti offer poor competition for the glamour of the synagogue murals, I suggest that joint consideration of graffiti contents and contexts offers important and otherwise unattested evidence for the use, dedication, and decoration, of the synagogue space in Dura Europos.
|
Memory, Theology, and the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Marti Steussy, Christian Theological Seminary
This paper will consider the implications of the science of memory for biblical studies.
|
This Abled Priestly Body: ‘Pure’ and ‘Unblemished’?
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
David Tabb Stewart, California State University, Long Beach
The categories of ‘(im)pure’ and ‘(un)blemished’ raise the questions: “What is the idealized or ‘whole’ priestly body?” and “How does this differ from any other Israelite body?” The Priestly Work analogizes the body’s skin and hair system to thread, cloth and leather; the body itself to house walls in Leviticus 13 and 14. Some skin anomalies with discolorations akin to the work of mold and fungus disqualify priests though not as ‘blemishes’. Leviticus 16 carries forward the analogy of body coverings to the Tent of Meeting. If the priest’s body has not been initially dappled with blood like the altar or Tent it remains conceptually ‘impure’ even though, inchoate in potential to act, ‘unblemished’, and free of polluting discharges and skin anomalies. The ideal of the priest’s body is made complete by oil placed on the Aaronide’s head, vesting, blood placed on his right ear-ridge, thumb, and big toe, and sprinkling blood with oil on his person and vestments. That is, the otherwise “perfect” body must still undergo purgation and sanctification.
|
Emendation and Anomalies in the Qur’anic Text
Program Unit: Qur'an and Biblical Literature
Devin Stewart, Emory University
This paper will examine and evaluate conjectural emendations of the Qur’an proposed in medieval Islamic scholarship as well as emendations proposed by modern Western scholars including Bellamy, Luxenberg, and others, and then look at textual anomalies in the the Qur’an—violations of grammatical, linguistic, and stylistic rules, unattested words, extraordinary turns of phrase, and so on—that might be resolved by conjectural emendation. Reference will be made to emendations of the Hebrew Bible, the New Testament, and classical texts, drawing on Metzger’s work on editing the New Testament, Madvig’s Adversaria critica (1870-71), etc. The main point is that conjectural emendation has been applied to the Qur’an before the twentieth century, with some success. Several modern scholars have applied conjectural emendation to the Qur’an, but most of their suggestions are not very convincing. Nevertheless, a small number appear to provide improved readings. In addition, my own investigation of the Qur’an suggests that there are many anomalies in the Qur’an that could possibly be rectified by conjectural emendation. Though many pre-modern scholars were against emendation and endeavored to treat any anomaly as expressing a unique meaning different in some manner from other similar passages, some recognized that conjectural emendation could serve to bring an anomalous text in line with those similar passages. This procedure was, after all, based on a standard traditional approach to the Qur’anic text termed tafsir al-Qur’an bi’l-Qur’an “explaining the Qur’an by the Qur’an.” Modern scholars, both Islamicists and scholars of religion in general, as well as lay Muslims, unfortunately lack awareness of the breadth of pre-modern Islamic scholarship, including critical approaches to the text of the Qur’an, such as emendation, historical criticism, form criticism.
|
Paul of Tarsus and Ignatius of Antioch: Pathological “Peas in a Pod”?
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
Todd Still, Baylor University
Near the conclusion of his learned, oft-cited essay “Mori Lucrum: Paul and Ancient Theories of Suicide” (Novum Testamentum 30 [1988]: 263-86 [on 285]), Arthur J. Droge
offers the following comparison: “Like Ignatius after him, Paul seems almost pathologically fascinated with his sufferings and possible death, and he devotes considerable space to their theological implications.” In addition to Phil
1:21-26, upon which Droge focuses in an effort to establish his provocative thesis that Paul pondered the possibility—indeed, the desirability—of suicide, Droge appeals to a
pastiche of Pauline passages both within and beyond Philippians to buttress his contention that Paul lusted after death (note esp. pp. 281-82, 285). What Droge does
not do in his article, however, is to cite and treat representative texts from Ignatius (see, e.g., his letter To the Romans) to support his contention that these two apostolic figures had an unhealthy preoccupation with and fixation upon suffering and death. I will do so in this paper. This, along with my economic treatment of pertinent Pauline texts, will enable one to judge for oneself how
apposite Droge’s comparison between Paul of Tarsus and Ignatius of Antioch is along the aforementioned lines.
|
“Since We Believe That Jesus Died and Rose Again”: The Death and Resurrection of Jesus in 1 Thessalonians
Program Unit: Extent of Theological Diversity in Earliest Christianity
Todd Still, Baylor University
In a letter where the parousia of Christ (1:10; 2:19; 3:13; 4:13–5:11; 5:23) and the eisodos of Paul and his fellow missioners (1:5, 9; 2:1-12; 2:17–3:13) feature, it is possible to overlook, among other matters, the frequent mention of Jesus’ death and/or resurrection (note 1:10; 2:15; 4:14; 5:10; cf. 3:2). This paper focuses upon those passages in ostensibly Paul’s oldest surviving letter where he speaks of the death (2:15; 5:10) or the death/resurrection of Jesus (1:10; 4:14). This exegetical investigation yields two significant conclusions: 1. The death and resurrection of Jesus were part and parcel of Paul’s gospel proclamation among the Thessalonians; and 2. Paul’s eschatological and ethical instructions are inextricably connected to his conviction that God raised Jesus from the dead.
|
A Triptych of the Table: Sin, Judgment, and Restoration in the Book of Isaiah
Program Unit:
Michelle Stinson, Simpson University
The book of Isaiah is richly laden with imagery drawn from the table, appearing nearly a hundred times and distributed across the book as a whole. In some sense, this emphasis should not be surprising as life in ancient Israel was bound up in the cycles of food production and consumption. However, in the book of Isaiah the table becomes a central image used for reflecting not only on agricultural life, but also theological realities. This paper will explore how the language of eating and drinking is used in the book of Isaiah to depict the experience of sin, judgment, and restoration, as well as to discuss the organic interconnections of these experiences. I will argue that imagery drawn from the table possesses powerful rhetorical value for theological discussion as it bridges the essential and theological realities of human existence.
|
THALES: A Database of Ancient and Medieval Jewish and Christian Lectionaries
Program Unit: Bible in Eastern and Oriental Orthodox Traditions
Daniel Stoekl Ben Eza, CNRS - National Institute for Scientific Research
In Late Antiquity and the Middle Ages, the common person usually became familiar with texts by hearing them recited or by seeing them represented artistically in liturgical, theatrical and ritual performances. Lectionaries – broadly understood as texts of different genres which inform the regular liturgical performance of one or more biblical passages – are the key link between the Bible and people, between intellectuals and the uneducated, between theory and praxis and, therefore, between the fields of literary and ritual studies. Despite their significance, lectionaries have been severely understudied. Part of the problem is the dispersion of data and the variety of modern languages involved.
THALES, an international database project founded by the Fritz Thyssen Stiftung, aims to assemble the vast data contained in ancient lectionaries, both Jewish and Christian, and make them easily accessible for and conveniently searchable by scholars interested in liturgy, the reception history of of biblical texts, as well as by historians. A preliminary version in test during 2010 shall be presented here.
|
Why Did Judges Call the Judges Judges?
Program Unit: Joshua-Judges
Lawson Stone, Asbury Theological Seminary
Current accounts of the characters figuring centrally in the book of Judges have not adequately integrated the military heroes (so-called major judges) and the tribal sheikhs (so-called minor judged) both of which are described with the root ??? “judge.” Nor have current discussions adequately accounted for the inconsistent religious characterization of the judges, e.g. the role of the spirit. Redactional and literary explanations fail to related their account to the ancient social realities while explanations based on comparisons with other ANE texts derive from sources produced by centralized urban cultures, not analogous to the village and clan social environment portrayed in Judges. This paper relates the texts of Judges to the philological data in conjunction with an analysis of the needs of the pre-monarchic social order of ancient Israel, as it is portrayed in the texts and as reconstructed historically as a society fluctuating in its forms and for which its traditional leadership structures prove inadequate. The judge represents an improvised role addressing the specific weaknesses and needs of this society while adapting to specific circumstances.
|
Six Measures of Barley: Seed Images and Inner-Textual Interpretation in Ruth
Program Unit:
Timothy Stone, University of St. Andrews-Scotland
In the book of Ruth seeds unify and interpret the significance of Naomi’s reversal from emptiness to fullness. YHWH gives two things in Ruth. In chapter one he gives bread and in chapter four he gives a baby. It has often been observed by commentators that Naomi moves from emptiness to fullness in the narrative. Chapter one makes it clear that Naomi has lost her sons and there is no hope that she will have more. Yet in a move that has confounded interpreters, in chapter four, Naomi is given Ruth’s son. The use of seed images in the intervening chapters not only ties this reversal together, but also foreshadows and gives an inner-textual interpretation of the significance of Naomi’s reversal. For instance, in chapter three Boaz tells Ruth to hold out her garment and then places six measures of his seed on her—surely an unrealistically heavy amount to carry. Ruth carries it in front of her, in her garment, thus appearing pregnant. On her return back to Naomi, Ruth says that Boaz did not want her to return to her mother-in-law “empty.” This final use of “empty”—playing off of the other occurrence of this word in chapter one—is pregnant with meaning and implies that Obed’s birth fills Naomi’s emptiness.
|
The Arm of the Lord Gathers the Lambs: The Metaphors of Shepherd and Divine Warrior in the Book of the Twelve Prophets
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Beth M. Stovell, McMaster Divinity College
Much scholarship has been written separately on the topics of God as Shepherd and God as Divine Warrior, yet the two metaphors have rarely been read in light of the other. Many scholars identify the “God as Shepherd” concept with the gentle, caring character of God. This would appear to be at odds with the Divine Warrior image as one who vanquishes his foes with might and power. Yet recently, Van Hecke has suggested a more nuanced view of “God as Shepherd,” finding three examples of “reversed pastoral metaphors” in the Book of the Twelve Prophets. Building on Van Hecke’s findings, this paper will analyse two further sections: Micah 2:12-13; 4:14-5:8, and Zechariah 9-11. First, it will examine the passages that establish the interaction of the Shepherd and Divine Warrior metaphors in the Old Testament and then examine the use of the Shepherd and Divine Warrior metaphors in Micah 2:12-13 and 4:14-5:8 and Zechariah 9-11. This paper will apply a literary-linguistic approach to metaphor that incorporates elements of the conceptual metaphor theory of George Lakoff, Mark Johnson, and Mark Turner with elements of the systemic functional linguistics of M. A. K. Halliday. This approach allows for the analysis of the metaphors in these two passages at the conceptual and the pragmatic levels within the larger discourse. Based on these findings, this paper will assert that a new configuration of conceptual domain, “God as Divine Warrior-Shepherd,” is formed by the interrelationship between the two conceptual domains of God as Shepherd and God as Divine Warrior and further assert that this new conceptual domain has important implications for reading the corpus of the Twelve Prophets as a literary whole.
|
“Church of the Living Dead”: Apocalyptic Imagery and the Goth Subculture
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
Beth M. Stovell, McMaster Divinity College
The conceptual metaphor theory of George Lakoff and Mark Johnson has demonstrated that the metaphors we use impact the way we view the nature of reality. Scholars have often noted the themes of inclusivity and exclusivity in the book of Revelation and in the Johannine corpus more broadly, but few have explored how these themes are realized through the metaphors of Revelation and how this impacts the modern and ancient readers’ perspective of their place as “insiders” or “outsiders” to the text and its world. Using conceptual metaphor theory, this paper will examine these themes of inclusion and exclusion by analyzing three ways metaphors are used in Revelation: 1) as a reaction against mainstream culture, 2) as a reaction against exploitation, and 3) as a form of paradox and irony that subverts expectation. This paper will then analyze the similar use of metaphors in subcultures by focusing on the use of apocalyptic metaphors in Goth subculture. This paper will assert that Revelation’s use of metaphors creates an inside group, while rejecting the culture of its time, and this lends itself to the cultural critique prevalent in modern subcultures, especially within the Goth subculture. Just as the ancient early Christians found solace in Revelation’s themes of inclusion codified in metaphor, modern Goths use these apocalyptic metaphors to question today’s society and create a community of insiders. Through a close examination of the use of apocalyptic imagery in Goth music, movies, and writings, this paper will provide a new way of reading and re-reading Revelation that also allows for the reading (and re-reading) of today’s society.
|
Theorizing Paul's Cosmology
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Stanley Stowers, Brown University
This is an invited paper for a panel on ancient cosmologies and the Pauline epistles. It will be presented for discussion along with papers by Troels Engberg-Pedersen and Edward Adams.
|
Misch-metaphors: Complex Divine Images, Conceptual Blending, and Ancient Near Eastern Mischwesen
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible and Cognate Literature
Brent Strawn, Emory University
This paper investigates instances of complex (or mixed) divine metaphors in textual sources in the light of complex divine images in iconography (focusing especially on the phenomenon of Mischwesen). The notion of conceptual blending from cognitive theory will also be discussed in order to suggest that what is happening in both data sets (literary and artistic) is an attempt to both (i) make manifest what is, in principle, not “manifest-able” (the divine) and (ii) demonstrate that all manifestations (textual or visual) are, in fact, not the (divine) thing itself.
|
Let Me Hear Your Body Talk: Female Speech and Silence in Church and the Arena
Program Unit: Speech and Talk in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Gail Streete, Rhodes College
The Greek term martys denotes "witness" in two senses: to watch or to make a spectacle for watching, and, in the sense of “testimony,” to speak. In Dying for God (1999), Daniel Boyarin proposes that “we think of martyrdom as a ‘discourse,’ as a practice of dying for God and of talking about it.” Death is a way of spotlighting the "witness," inviting visual participation in it, and, as Allison Goddard Elliott has pointed out, aural participation by hearing the martyr "speak the martyrdom” (Roads to Paradise, 1987). Martyrdom thus needs to be public, so that the witness can be "published" effectively. Speech is as important as spectacle. Both Boyarin and Elliott note the “central act” of the martyrdom is the “verbal agon,” the “ritualized and performative speech act." The verbal and the physical action of the martyrdom focus upon the challenge to and potential subversion of the values and norms of the dominant culture. In fact, the martyrs undergo their trials because they present a challenge to the value system of the dominant culture. One of the purposes of the written martyrdom is thus symbolically to overcome or subvert this value system. By their very definition, then, martyrs behave “inappropriately” according to the dominant norms of late antique society. Nonetheless, by their very liminality, martyrs may also tend to reinforce these norms, particularly those of gender. “Parrhesia,” the value of open or bold speech, is an important attribute of free men, for example. How does it apply to women? In many female martyrdoms, it is the bodies of women who “speak” when their verbal witness is silent. This silence both corresponds to and contrasts with the gradual restriction of women’s speech in the churches of emerging Christianity.
|
The Pastorals in Rehab; Why They Are Important to Feminism (And It’s Not What You Think)
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
Gail Streete, Rhodes College
In the past three decades, the Pastoral Epistles (1 Timothy, Titus, and 2 Timothy) have usually served in feminist exegesis as illustrating the culturally conservative and religiously apologetic side in the “battle over Paul,” usually contrasted to their detriment with the proto-feminist Acts of Paul and Thecla. Often, they are dismissed or totally ignored by feminist scholars as irretrievably patriarchal; on occasion, they become the means of contrasting a more authentic, radical and egalitarian Paul with his later incarnation as an authority for conciliation or compromise with Roman respectability. While there is little chance that the Pastoral Epistles can be retrieved as feminist documents, there are ways in which these letters can contribute a good deal to the understanding of the constructions of identity and authority in developing Christianity, including those of patronage, marriage, family life, and the dangers attendant on “new” religious movements. Feminists who are willing to abandon the more “romantic” view of the “true” Paul who abjured gender hierarchy in order to view the Pastoral Epistles in their contexts (within the “Pauline” tradition, within the Greco-Roman world, and within the canon itself) may find much that contributes to a broader view of status and gender in the early Christian world.
|
Is Biblical Greek Oral-Aural Pedagogy Worthwhile?
Program Unit: Applied Linguistics for Biblical Languages
Daniel R. Streett, Criswell College
Oral-aural pedagogy is slowly becoming increasingly popular among teachers of Biblical Greek. My paper will ask whether such methods merit the large investment of time and energy they require. For example, how is it beneficial to learn to speak and listen to a “dead” language which presently exists only in written form? If the main goal of most learners is only to read, exegete, analyze or translate the text of the NT (or LXX), is it worthwhile to work toward communicative ability? We and our students will never need to order a meal in Koine Greek, or to ask for directions in first-century Corinth; so is it really profitable to develop the ability to do so?
|
How to Arrange a Proper Marriage: The Case of the Identity of Herodias' First Husband—Philip or Herod?
Program Unit: Social Scientific Criticism of the New Testament
Fred Strickert, Wartburg College
In the death of John the Baptist story, scholars have long debated the identity of Herodias’ first husband, before she married his brother Antipas. The problem: Mark and Matthew identify him as Philip and Josephus identifies him as Herod, son of Mariamme 2. A classic case of historical debate, various scholars line up behind Philip the Tetrarch or Herod, the Son of Mariamme 2, depending often on their presuppositions of the value of Josephus or the Synoptics in historical research. A growing tendency is to harmonize these views, creating a Herod Philip—though without historical backing. The result is that a majority have left Philip the Tetrarch as a bachelor most of his life.
Oakman and Hanson’s research on the family relationships of the Herodian family are a reminder that readers need to strip away modern notions of marriage as individual decisions when reading these ancient texts. Cataloguing 49 different marriages over eight generations they demonstrate that marriage is a family affair and, in this case, a political affair. The 22 endogamous marriages—between fellow members of the Herodian family—were designed to retain property and wealth and to consolidate power. Of the 27 exogamous marriages only six were to non-elite families with the majority arranged to improve family status or to ensure positive political relationships among allies, rivals, and even enemies. In his patriarchal role, Herod arranged no less than ten marriages and prevented another.
This paper will examine Herod’s role in arranging marriages before his death, including Herodias, and will analyze why some of those arrangements were annulled. Similarly, we will examine what role Augustus may have played in matchmaking at the reading of Herod’s will for Archelaus, Antipas, and Philip. Finally we will question the proposition that Philip the Tetrarch remained a bachelor until late in life.
|
Why Bethsaida? Economic and Political Reasons for the Establishment of Philip’s Second City
Program Unit: Archaeological Excavations and Discoveries: Illuminating the Biblical World
Fred Strickert, Wartburg College
In Jonathan Reed’s book, Archaeology and the Galilean Jesus, he suggests that a major change took place in lower Galilee when Antipas built Sepphoris as his capital. This developed a symbiotic relationship between the city and surrounding villages. Taxes from the villages helped to pay for public building projects in the city that sometimes benefitted visiting villagers. With the establishment of Tiberias as Antipas’ second city in 20 CE, Reed notes that all of Galilee then fell within a 25-kilometer radius of these two cities and thus under their sphere of influence.
When Antipas’ brother Philip built his capital in the northern part of the Golan, it left much of his tetrarchy far beyond such a 25-km radius sphere of influence. As a result the lake economy was easily monopolized around the city of Tiberias—thus the name Sea of Tiberias (John 6:1; 21:1)—and even Philip’s southern territory (where the largest number of Antipas coins have been discovered) fell under his influence (coming within 25-km of Tiberias).
Philip’s establishment of his second city at the village of Bethsaida (named Julias), thus follows the second-city Galilean pattern and seems best interpreted as a response to the founding of Tiberias in 20 CE. With Philip’s death in 34 CE shortly after the founding of Julias in 30 CE, his success in balancing the influence of Tiberias was limited. Coin patterns from two decades of excavation at Bethsaida show a clear shift from the influence of Tyre and Banias to the north in the direction of Tiberias and cities to the south.
|
The God that Ezekiel Inherited
Program Unit: Book of Ezekiel
John T. Strong, Missouri State University
My thesis is that Ezekiel did not re-envision God, but understood Yahweh to be the same God that he inherited from his youth and as a young priest in the temple court of Jerusalem, namely, that Yahweh is the Divine King. In defense of this thesis, I will summarize my paper published in our earlier volume, "God's Kabod: The Presence of Yahweh in the Book of Ezekiel" (Theological and Anthropological Perspectives), but I will also add to this argument. Specifically, I will discuss Ezekiel's oracles against Tyre in relation to the theology seen in the eighth century prophecies of Isaiah in Isa 7. Then, I will turn to Ezek 43:1-7, specifically discussing this as a re-enthronement of Yahweh, and defending this position against recent commentaries which argue that the vision of 40-48 was not intended to be realized on earth. This proposal will present a unique picture of Ezekiel's theology, one that, while perhaps not finally accepted by all, will (I believe) stimulate thought and conversation.
|
A New Perspective on the Synoptic Problem from the Dead Sea Documents: Exploring an Analogy
Program Unit: Qumran
Loren T. Stuckenbruck, Princeton Theological Seminary
A comparison of manuscripts belonging to same documents and to related or different documents among the Dead Sea Scrolls reveals a number of close analogies to differences that can be observed between the Synoptic Gospels. This paper identifies and discusses several of these analogies and raises the question anew of how much a document can undergo revision and change before being transformed into another. What levels of analogies to shifts in Gospel tradition are evident amongst the Scrolls and how might they be compared to other models against which to understand the development of ancient writings: the emergence of text-critical variants, different recensions (cf. Daniel, Tobit, Slavonic Enoch, Testament of Abraham, Joseph and Aseneth, Life of Adam and Eve, 1 Enoch, Testament of the Twelve Patriarchs, 4 Ezra, etc.), the growth of separate documents (e.g. Chronicles from Kings in the Hebrew Bible). Unlike some of the documents just listed and like the Synoptic Gospels, some materials among the Scrolls offer evidence for a number of shades among these models and provide insight into how, during a relatively short period of time, documents could grow, contract and be transformed into new works.
|
The Challenges of Doing Text-Critical Work in the Ethiopic Tradition: The Case of 1 Enoch
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Loren Stuckenbruck, Princeton Theological Seminary
There have been a few, largely unsuccessful, attempts at doing text-critical work on the Ge'ez text of 1 Enoch. This lecture describes the problem posed by the manuscript traditions and proposes next steps forward in addressing the matter, taking the present state of the evidence into account.
|
Deaf Communities: Considering the Ethical Cost of Losing Lament
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
W. Derek Suderman, Conrad Grebel / University of Waterloo
In “The Costly Loss of Lament,” Walter Brueggemann draws on psychological and sociological insights to demonstrate that the contemporary tendency to drop lament language allows victims to remain voiceless and the status quo unchallenged. However, by limiting his analysis to two parties—God and the psalmist—Brueggemann overlooks Westermann’s category of the ‘others’ and the rhetorical function of social address to this broader community within individual laments. This paper extends Brueggemann’s argument by paying increased attention to the social audience rhetorically present within these psalms, which provides both an audience for the cries of the individual and a discerning, ethical community that seeks to embody just living. In doing so the paper identifies yet another cost of losing lament: by muting lament language the faith community deafens itself to the potentially justified cry for justice and social support of those within and beyond itself, thereby squandering an opportunity for empathy, self-critique, and action. Over time the faith community loses its commitment and ability to discern the complex ambiguities reflected in such laments, which further erodes its potential for an appropriate ethical response.
|
Hearing Jussives at Work: An Exploration of Rhetorical Function in Individual Lament Psalms
Program Unit: Lament in Sacred Texts and Cultures
W. Derek Suderman, Conrad Grebel / University of Waterloo
Psalms scholarship has paid less attention to shifting address from one audience to another than to formal elements. In one particularly striking example, Anneli Aejmelaeus links “traditional prayer” with imperative address to God. By doing so she both dismisses address to a social audience and explicitly eliminates jussives from her discussion, due largely to the inherent ambiguity of the latter. In contrast, this paper will argue that it is precisely this ambiguity that imbues jussives with the significant rhetorical function of simultaneously addressing both divine and human audiences. Thus, rather than being sidelined, jussives should be recognized as highly significant for their rhetorical function within individual laments.
|
A Post-Colonial Assessment of the KJV as Bible Translation
Program Unit:
R. S. Sugirtharajah, University of Birmingham
*
|
A Proto-Canaanite Ostracon from the Jacob Kaplan Excavations at Jaffa: The Prelimary Report
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Matthew J. Suriano, University of California-Los Angeles
An ostracon with an incised inscription written in Proto-Canaanite letters was recently identified among the artifacts from Jacob Kaplan’s excavations in Jaffa. The potsherd comes from an assemblage collected in 1962 in a deep sounding within the earlier (1950s) excavation area. A preliminary reading of the inscription reveals that it records a personal name. The short text represents a small yet significant addition to the growing corpus of proto-alphabetic scripts originating from West Semitic cultures found throughout Egypt and the southern Levant during the second millennium. Furthermore, the inscription comes from a secure archaeological-stratum, as it was found in the context of reused Ramesses II façade-fragments within the Iron I gate complex. The probable 12th century B.C.E. date of the ostracon offers a firm historical benchmark for further epigraphic research into the development of the alphabet.
|
Paradoxical Presence: The Concealed Revelation of God’s Activity in the Second Gospel
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Laura Sweat, Princeton Theological Seminary
Previous scholarship in the Gospel of Mark has been quick to emphasize the secretive, concealed qualities of the Second Gospels’ christology and theology. God’s absence at particular points in the narrative is often taken for granted, and God’s presence in the Gospel can be neglected. This paper begins by considering one of the Gospel’s most theologically difficult texts, Mark 4:10-12, and argues that paradoxes are fundamental and necessary in Mark’s portrayal of God. One of the primary paradoxes evident in the Gospel is the paradox of concealment and revelation.
The outlines of this paradox emerge from Mark 4:10-12 and are subsequently traceable in 15:29-39. Though the Evangelist contrasts Golgotha with two previous theophanic episodes, Jesus’ baptism and transfiguration, Mark also reveals that God is still active after Jesus’ death, even though this action is not explicitly attributed to God. The paradox of concealed revelation in the Gospel demonstrates that God’s activity is more pervasive in Mark than we might expect, even though this activity remains concealed.
Through his paradoxical theology, Mark brings together the theological affirmation of God’s freedom as well as the anthropological claim that, though humans are frail and faulty, they too participate in this kingdom. While wholly sovereign, God nevertheless invites humans to be part of this kingdom that has come near. Mark uses paradoxes because his theology demands it: to explain the inexplicable until all that is hidden comes to light (4:22).
|
Prophets and Priests in the Deuteronomistic History
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Marvin A. Sweeney, Claremont School of Theology and Claremont Graduate University
King Jeroboam of Israel is roundly condemned in the Former Prophets or Deuteronomistic History for a number of alleged sins, such as his promotion of the golden calves for worship at Beth El and Dan, his changes to the liturgical calendar of Israel, his appointment of non-Levites as priests, and others. Nevertheless, it is striking that Jeroboam’s actions are largely defensible, e.g., the golden calves function as a mount for YHWH much as the ark of the covenant does in the south, Numbers 9 allows for the celebration of Passover a month later for those who are away from the land at the time of the holiday, and certain priests in the north, such as the celebrated Samuel, do not seem to be Levites. Indeed, a number of northern prophetic figures in the Former Prophets, such as Samuel, Ahijah, Elijah, Elisha, and others appear to act as priests. This paper will examine a number of northern prophetic figures in an effort to demonstrate their priestly functions and perhaps identities. On the basis of this examination, the paper will posit that northern Israel employed a very different conceptualization of the priesthood from that of southern Judah and many northern prophets in the DtrH in fact function as priestly figures. The implications of this observation for our understanding of the differences in Israelite and Judean religion will be considered.
|
The Chronicler's Debate with the Deuteronomistic History Concerning the Question of Exile
Program Unit: Exile (Forced Migrations) in Biblical Literature
Marvin A. Sweeney, Claremont School of Theology and Claremont Graduate University
The Chronicler’s History has suffered greatly during the history of modern biblical scholarship as interpreters have tended to dismiss it as a historical and theological source during much of the late-nineteenth and early twentieth centuries when read in relation to the better known Former Prophets or Deuteronomistic History. Increasing attention by a variety of scholars during the second half of the twentieth century demonstrates a shift in this attitude as scholars have come to recognize both the historical and theological sophistication of the Chronicler’s presentation. My own prior research has pointed to differences in the portrayals of Kings Manasseh and Josiah of Judah in the Chronicler’s work. These differences and others point to a very different understanding of the theological question of exile in the Chronicler’s History. Whereas the Former Prophets or Deuteronomistic History holds earlier generations of Israel and Judah accountable for the exile of later generations, whether it be the exile of the northern kingdom of Israel or the southern kingdom of Judah, the Chronicler’s work holds that exile may be explained only by the sins of the generation that suffered the judgment. This paper will attempt to demonstrate this thesis by examination of the regnal accounts of a number of kings in both histories.
|
Covenant Priesthood: A Cross-Cultural Legal and Religious Study of Biblical and Hittite Priesthood
Program Unit: Cultic Personnel in the Biblical World
Ada Taggar-Cohen, Doshisha University
God has conferred his priesthood, as presented in the Bible, on a chosen tribe out of the entire Israelite community. That tribe has received through its leaders a special status of relationships with the divine termed ???? and translated “covenant” (Num. 18). The separate covenant the priesthood has with YHWH has equivalent only in those with Abraham and David, beside the covenant the people of Israel have with their God.
The Hittite textual evidence includes a term for loyalty commitment ishiul-, equivalent to the Hebrew word ????, which has been discussed in the past regarding the general idea of biblical covenant. However, that term has not been compared with the biblical priestly covenant. There are a couple of Hittite texts titled ishiul- for the Hittite priesthood. They are legal texts determining the obligations of the priesthood towards the king and the gods. The priesthood in these texts is treated as priesthood under the service of royalty. This paper will suggest an interpretation for the status of biblical priesthood in light of these Hittite texts.
In the past there has been an attempt by J. Milgrom to compare the Hittite priesthood to the biblical two groups of Priests and Levites according to the Hittite text CTH 264. My new edition of that Hittite text [Hittite Priesthood, (Texte der Hethiter 26) 2006] does not support that supposition. However, as will be shown, other components of the covenantal duties and obligations are a source for reciprocal interpretations.
|
The Rhetorical Strategy in 1 Tim 2:8–3:1
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
Elsa Tamez, United Bible Societies
I intend to show the author’s rhetorical ability to impress on the mind of his readers an instruction against women. I begin here because generally the common readers remember this brief section of the letter and not the other contributions. Therefore, I propose to make a semantic analysis beginning with a semantic inventory by observing the units of meaning and their implications. I will then observe the author’s organization of this semantic inventory, the blocks of meaning and their implications. Finally, I consider the way the blocks of meaning are articulated and the implications of this articulation. I conclude with the general structure of the instruction, its significance and implications.
|
A Data-Driven Approach to Word Sense Differentiation
Program Unit: Computer Assisted Research
Randall Tan, Asia Bible Society
Current search in Biblical texts are mostly word-based with no differentiation between the different senses of words. To move beyond this limitation and attain higher accuracy in computer search, Asia Bible Society used data-mining methods to distinguish different senses of words by leveraging our data on the syntactic analysis of the Hebrew OT and the alignments between the Hebrew text and various translations.
Our approach is built on two basic assumptions: (1) Words used in the same sense tend to occur in similar linguistic contexts (playing similar grammatical roles and having similar lexical collocations); and (2) Words used in the same sense tend to be translated to the same word in another language. Using the linguistic context supplied by our syntactic treebank and the sense distinction data from translations that are word-linked to the Hebrew text, we implemented the following procedures: (1) Collect linguistic contexts of all content words; (2) Collect English and Chinese translations of the words in 8 different versions; (3) Build a feature set of contexts and translations for each occurrence of the words in the Bible; (4) Use clustering methods to group word occurrences into different sense groups; and (5) Manually clean up the data.
The end results are: (1) the number of senses for each content word in the Hebrew Bible is identified; and (2) each occurrence of the word in the text is linked to a particular sense. The data is being used to build a sense-based concordance and eventually a sense dictionary that lists all senses and the specific instances of each sense. The data is created quickly and efficiently and the results are based on actual data with no pre-conceived subjective categorization. Moreover, the granularity of sense divisions can be flexibly adjusted by the values of similarity metrics in the clustering process.
|
God as a Merciful Redeemer: A Divine Concept in the Elihu Speeches in Job 32–37
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Tanja Pilger, Humboldt University of Berlin
The paper is looking for a new perception of a divine concept in the Book of Job and focusses on the Elihu speeches. The merciful angel and the redeeming God are two aspects Elihu aims to integrate into his concept of God: God educates by means of dreams and suffering on the one hand and God intends the suffering human's redemption mediated by an angel as advocate on the other hand. Elihu disagrees with God who according to the heavenly scenes makes a pact with Satan and as a result of it the pious Job has to suffer. Instead, Elihu introduces an angel as a divine mediator for the restitution of the suffering man. Elihu depicts God as having the intention to redeem the human being who is threatened by death and to lead suffering humankind back to life. This perception of God is new within the Book of Job.
The paper examines the unique theological profile of the Elihu speeches in Job 33:15-30; 36:8-11 compared to the other parts of the Book of Job like Job 2:1-7; 4:12-21; 5:17-18.
|
Greek Deponency: The Historical Perspective
Program Unit: Biblical Greek Language and Linguistics
Bernard Taylor, Loma Linda University
TBD
|
Nineteenth-Century Women’s Wrestlings with the Enigmas of the Unladylike Jael (Judges 4:17–23, 5:24–31)
Program Unit: Recovering Female Interpreters of the Bible
Marion Ann Taylor, Wycliffe College
The story of Jael's murder of Sisera has provoked great controversy throughout history. Some nineteenth-century readers were appalled by Jael’s apparent “treachery” toward Sisera, the gruesome violence in the story, and Jael’s unladylike behavior with the tent peg. This paper will examine nineteenth-century interpretations of Jael, focusing especially on the writings of women who left behind the traditional figural readings of Jael as a type of the Church and even the Virgin Mary who ushered in redemption triumphing over sin and the devil. Instead, using a literal-historical approach to the text, they wrestled with the social, cultural and moral issues arising out of Jael's actions toward Sisera and her subsequent blessing by Deborah. The authors considered include Sarah Trimmer, Elizabeth Whately, Eliza Smith, Clara Balfour and Harriet Beecher Stowe.
|
Embodied Biblical Scholars: A Reflection on Isaiah 47:1–7 through the Experiences of African-American Slaves
Program Unit: African-American Biblical Hermeneutics
Rubertha Taylor, Independent Scholar
Although the Exodus narrative of YHWH’s liberating power played a central role in the way African-American slaves and their descendants understood their experiences in the Americas, the intense focus on Exodus has deflected attention away from other important texts. Similarities in the lived experiences of ancient Israelite and North American slaves may be found in a range of biblical texts. For example, a careful reading of exilic writings through an African-American hermeneutic reveals at least four shared themes: 1) a separation or uprooting of an individual or a group, 2) an individual’s or a derelict group’s cry for help, 3) a God who hears the cries; and 4) a restoration of hope. We can assume on the basis of certain biblical texts African-American slaves read, interpreted, preached, or sang about that slaves made connections between their experiences and the Israelites’. Beyond parallel lived experiences of oppression, their writings express a language of resistance against dominant forces. The similarities in these languages of resistance are so uncanny, one can argue that African-American slaves embodied biblical texts. For this reason, African-American slave narratives bring insights to biblical texts.
Frantz Fanon’s work on languages/colonization and James Scott’s work on hidden transcripts undergird my work by teasing out a language that deviates from the “norm” but functions effectively in allowing subordinates to name and articulate a different normativity. I will also draw from contemporary African-American biblical scholars, including Allen Dwight Callahan and Brian Blount. I argue that ancient Israelites and African-American slaves deviated from their respective oppressors’ languages to develop a language of resistance. Specifically, I will focus on mockery and acts of negation against Babylon in Isaiah 47:1-7 and compare this to selective writings in classic African-American slave narratives.
|
Constructing Yahweh: A Case Study in the Cognitive-Critical Method of Biblical Studies
Program Unit: Psychology and Biblical Studies
John Teehan, Hofstra University
Cognitive science is providing a new paradigm for the study of religion. It may also serve as a new hermeneutical method—a cognitive-critical method—for Biblical studies. A foundational premise of such a method is that the cognitive and emotional mechanisms that shape and constrain human psychology, also shape and constrain the construction of religious texts. If this is accurate, then a critical study of Biblical texts employing the findings of the cognitive sciences may allow for an understanding of such texts that is both psychologically richer and more empirically grounded than that provided by more traditional hermeneutic tools or other social scientific theories.
After setting out a general framework for a cognitive-critical method, this paper will discuss how the cognitive predispositions that give rise to god-beliefs, in tandem with those predispositions that underlie moral intuitions, have shaped Biblical conceptions of God. Specifically, it will look at the concept of Yahweh as a jealous god who demands exclusive loyalty. This conceptualization of the divine being has raised many concerns. Believers and skeptics alike point out the moral problems with such a conception of god. However, if we understand the construction of Yahweh as constrained by evolved cognitive predispositions, serving evolutionary moral objectives, Yahweh’s reputation as an angry, and at time vindictive god, makes this a powerful and morally effective construct.
Cognitive science allows us to see the Biblical portrayal of Yahweh as a construction of a god-belief following the constraints imposed by our evolved psychology, answering to the particular situations of the ancient Hebrew community. Given a different historical/social environment those same cognitive predispositions will result in the construction of different god-beliefs. The paper will conclude by suggesting how this cognitive-critical method may contribute to our understanding of religious diversity.
|
Literary Form, Exegetical Function, and the Dynamics of their Correlation
Program Unit: Qumran
Andrew Teeter, Harvard University
This paper reflects on the problems of relating specific textual categories or genres to various notions of interpretive function in Qumran texts. In what precise sense is any particular mode of literary production “exegetical,” and what does such a description imply in each case? What are the interpretive correlates of various literary categories attested? To what extent do exegetical methods and motives determine literary form? With a view toward the history of scholarship, the paper analyzes fundamental issues at stake while attempting to outline a descriptive typology of relationships that obtain.
|
Ethiopic Manuscript Collections in Need of Catalogues
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Melaku Terefe, Ethiopic Manuscripts Imaging Project
This presentation will report on the need for catalogues of several known collections of Ethiopic manuscripts: Some of these are collections of microfilms of manuscripts (EMML, UNESCO). Some of these are of collections that have recently been digitized (the IES, the Mekane Yesus seminary collection in Addis, Capuchin Friary in Asko, the GwendaGwenda collection). And some of these are collections that have yet to be digitized (Library of Congress, Howard University School of Divinity). We will also make mention of two important cataloguing projects under way at Princeton and Duke and of the status of the collection at UCLA.
|
Prophetic Speech and Sacred Time in Johannine and Anti-Christian Religious Experience
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Tom Thatcher, Cincinnati Christian University
This paper will utilize media and collective memory theories to identify and describe two varying approaches to the experience of Christ in Johannine Christianity. The authors of the Fourth Gospel and 1-2-3 John adopt a "dogmatic" approach to collective memory, arguing that God's presence was localized in the activity of the historical Jesus. John's approach to tradition postures prophetic speech as a ritualized re-enactment of events that are distinctly past from the audience's perspective. Another Johannine group, the "AntiChrist's," adopted a "mystical" approach to collective memory, one that collapsed the temporal distance between Jesus and present experience. The AntiChrist's approach to tradition postured prophetic speech as an enactment of Jesus' living presence for the audience. Ultimately, John and the AntiChrists used different time maps to organize a common Jesus tradition, creating different experiences of prophetic speech. These differing approaches to tradition created the tensions and divisions evident in the Johannine Epistles.
|
Babylon as Judah’s Doppelgänger: The Identity of Opposites in the Book of Jeremiah
Program Unit: Writing/Reading Jeremiah
Rannfrid Thelle, Wichita, KS
Because Jeremiah 50-51 has traditionally been considered to be a late, ‘inauthentic’ addition, it has not been highly regarded, for the most part. In the past couple of decades many scholars have countered this view, stressing the importance of these chapters for the overall scheme and structure of Jeremiah. In this paper, I am following their lead to present a reading of Jeremiah 50-51 that focuses on the relationships between YHWH and Babylon on one hand, and Babylon and Judah on the other.
In Jeremiah 50-51 YHWH is on a mission to destroy Babylon. It is the time to pay back Babylon for what it did. Nowhere is there any direct indication in this text that YHWH himself has used Babylon as his servant to attack Judah and destroy Jerusalem (Jer 21-25), or offered Babylon as a place of refuge (Jer 21-29). As readers we assume this background, and it shapes our reading of Jer 50-51. In addition, we are given hints that Judah/Jerusalem/Israel/Jacob has suffered (50,6-7.17; 51,5.24.49.51). All in all, the dominant message in Jer 50-51 is YHWH’s rage and commitment to his plan of destroying Babylon. Babylon is the enemy of Judah, and the destruction of Babylon is Judah’s revenge. Thus, Babylon is portrayed in opposition to Judah, and the restoration of Judah is a sub-theme that mirrors this.
At the same time, Babylon is also like Judah. This identity is communicated both through the book’s structural features, and through the use of the same stock of motifs in the preaching of judgment, such as the figure of the enemy from the north. Like Judah, Babylon now stands under the judgment of YHWH. In this common fate, Judah identifies with Babylon and may express solidarity, such as in 51,8-9. Finally, in being the place from which the exiles will return, the concepts of return and Diaspora both become identified with Babylon in an antithetical way through this text.
|
Johannine Jesus-Sayings as “Metatexts” to the Synoptic Jesus-Words? Considerations on a Reception-History Category
Program Unit: John, Jesus, and History
Michael Theobald, Universität Tübingen
The creativity of the Johannine communities in dealing with primitive Jesus traditions should not be underestimated. Admittedly, it is difficult to explain why large sections of Synoptic sayings-materials (e.g. the Sermon on the Mount/Plain or Jesus' parables about the Kingdom of God) have left few if any traces in John's Gospel. Were they unknown in the Johannine communities, or were they intentionally ignored there? All the more interesting are those Johannine texts in whose background one may suspect synoptic materials. This paper considers selected examples (images such as John 10:9, cf. Matt 7:13f/Luke 13:24; also John 21:22f /Matt 9:1; etc.) in the context of a "hierarchy of proximity" to explore a new tradition-critical category: Johannine words as "Metatexts" to the Synoptic words of Jesus, with variations including "Deepening, Explication, Surpassing, and Critique." Such movements are also found within the Synoptic tradition (e.g., compare Matt 13:24-30 with Mark 4:26-29) and in the tradition of the Gospel of Thomas (e.g., compare GTh 2 with Luke 11:9f) and help us to profile the Fourth Evangelist's rendering of Jesus-sayings in Johannine terms.
|
A New Fragment of Romans from Oxyrhynchus
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Michael Theophilos, Australian Catholic University
It is of some consequence that of the one hundred and twenty-six currently published Greek New Testament papyrus fragments, fifty-four were discovered at Oxyrhynchus (i.e. c. 43%). Furthermore, of the sixty-four manuscripts dated to the first half of the fourth century or earlier, Oxyrhynchus contributes to over 60% of the material (i.e. forty fragmentary papyri). Given Oxyrhynchus’ prominence, prosperity and significant Christian influence in the first five centuries of the first millennium, this is perhaps understandable, even if it is equally as baffling as to why so much literature, both biblical and otherwise was "thrown out" en masse, only to be found centuries later by two Oxford graduates, B. P. Grenfell and A. S. Hunt of Queen's College.
The primary research that will be undertaken in this study concerns an assessment of a previously unknown New Testament fragment of the epistle to the Romans (inventory number 123/102a). The significance of this study is to offer original and focused research into the history of the textual tradition of the New Testament. Discussion of the fragment will be divided into three sections. Firstly, an extended introduction which will note, among other things, the paleographic points of interest - roll/codex, recto/verso, date, lines/width/height of columns, estimated length of roll and significant reading marks (accents, breathings, quantity marks, punctuation). Secondly, an edited Greek text, both diplomatic and transcriptional (with a short description of how multi-spectral imaging aided in this process, and finally, a section devoted to issues which require further treatment, including exegetical comment, notable paleographic details and collation with other extant manuscripts. Images of the fragment will be included in the presentation.
|
Proselutos in Light of the Translation Techniques of the LXX Translators
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Matthew Thiessen, Duke University
One of the more heated lexical debates in LXX studies surrounds the meaning of the Greek term proselutos. Yet the only thorough examination of the word in the LXX is W.C Allen’s 1894 article, “On the Meaning of proselutos in the Septuagint.” Allen argues that the LXX translators distinguish carefully between two different uses of ger in the Hebrew Bible: the first is rendered by the Greek word paroikos, and is used in contexts where a convert to Judaism cannot be intended; the second is rendered by the Greek word proselutos, and is used in contexts where a convert to Judaism could be intended. Most modern treatments of conversion in early Judaism rely heavily upon Allen’s conclusions, often indirectly through Karl Georg Kuhn’s Theological Dictionary of the New Testament entry on proselutos, without reassessing the methodology or evidence Allen uses to support his argument.
This paper provides a critique of Allen’s methodological assumptions and a reassessment of LXX renderings of ger by utilizing recent studies on the significance of the varying translation techniques of the LXX translators. I will argue that Allen’s methodology, which treats the entirety of the LXX as a translational unity, leads him, and those who rely upon him, to misinterpret the evidence of the LXX. In contrast, this paper argues that analyzing the evidence of the individual books of the LXX as discrete translations by different translators demonstrates that Allen anachronistically renders proselutos in the LXX as “proselyte,” when in fact it should be translated as “alien.”
|
Circumcision in the Early Church According to Acts
Program Unit: Book of Acts
Matthew Thiessen, Duke University
This paper will reexamine Luke’s view of the law, particularly as it pertains to one of the most disputed aspects of law observance in early Christianity: circumcision. Although Luke’s view of circumcision has been overshadowed by the writings of Paul, he is the only other New Testament author to devote more than a passing reference to the rite. Consequently, this paper provides a comprehensive analysis of Luke’s view of circumcision.
I will argue that the references to circumcision in the Acts of the Apostles need to be read in light of the references to the circumcisions of John and Jesus in Luke’s infancy narrative. Luke 1:59, 2:21 and Acts 7:8 each stress the timing of circumcision. It is this stress on the timing of the rite which helps Luke to create a coherent account of the Jerusalem Council’s denial of the necessity of circumcision for Gentile believers (Acts 15) despite the ongoing commitment of the Jerusalem Church and the apostle Paul to the practice of circumcision amongst Jewish believers (Acts 21). Additionally, this paper will help to provide an interpretation of Paul’s surprising circumcision of Timothy in the wake of the Jerusalem Council, and Luke’s ambivalence toward this action in Acts 16.
|
The Case of the Jonah's Missing Prophecy (2 Kgs 14:25): Mapping Prophecy and Fulfillment in the Book of Kings
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Benjamin D. Thomas, University of Chicago
Many discussions of prophecy and fulfillment in the Book of Kings treat it as a unifying feature of Kings and even of the Deuteronomistic History. However, scholars writing before and after Martin Noth have remarked that prophecy and fulfillment had developed already in earlier prophecy and was also used after the Deuteronomistic redaction of Kings. Noth himself attributed various fulfillment notices to at least four sources or hands: notices from the "Books of the Chronicles of the Kings of Israel," (1 Kgs 16:12, 34; 2 Kgs 14:25); notices in the prophetic stories themselves (1 Kgs 12:15; 2 Kgs 9:25-26, 36; 23:16); Dtr himself (1 Kgs 15:29-30; 22:38); and a hand later than Dtr (1 Kgs 12:21-24). The example of the fulfillment notice in 2 Kgs 14:25 concerning Jonah's prediction of the extension of Israelite borders is interesting because it is the only case where a fulfillment's prophecy is lacking in the MT version of Kings. Based on a comparison with three other fulfillment notices that lack initial prophecies (1 Chr 11:3; 2 Chr 10:15; and 1 Kgs 15:29 of the LXXA account), it is likely that the fulfillment notice in 2 Kgs 14:25 did refer to an earlier prophecy that has been omitted from the Book of Kings. Several questions remain: was this earlier prophecy part of the "Books of the Chronicles of the Kings of Israel" along with the fulfillment notice, as Noth had contended? Was there a version of Kings that originally contained Jonah's prophecy? Or was the prophecy contained in some other source now lost in time, which may have been part of the Jehu history? Was the fulfillment notice already in Dtr's source, or was it Dtr's own contribution (or even a later hand)? Should the development of prophecy and fulfillment surrounding Kings cause us to alter our conception of the unity of the work as a whole?
|
New Jerusalem and the Conversion of the Nations: An Exercise in Pneumatic Discernment—Revelation 21:1–22:5
Program Unit: Society for Pentecostal Studies
John Christopher Thomas, Pentecostal Theological Seminary and Bangor University
This paper seeks to discern the effect of the text upon the hearers (both implied and actual) with regard to the relationship between the 'Conversion of the Nations' and 'New Jerusalem'. Specifically, the study attempts to determine how the tension between the 'Destruction of the Nations', an event that has been described at numerous points in the Apocalypse, and the indications that the nations are part of New Jerusalem despite their previous destruction is understood by the hearers,owing to its impact upon them.
|
Transforming Vision: Teaching Sermon Content and Structure to Challenge the World
Program Unit: Academy of Homiletics
Katherine Thomas Paisley, Vanderbilt University
*
|
Strangers on the Earth: Philosophical Perspective on the Promise of God
Program Unit: Hebrews
James W. Thompson, Abilene Christian University
The acknowledgement that “we do not see all things in subjection to him” (Heb. 2:8b) addresses the cognitive dissonance of the first readers of Hebrews, whose experience conflicts with their confession. The author responds by reinterpreting the promise, making it the leitmotif of the argument. Unlike Paul, the author does not describe the promise as fulfilled in the coming of Christ (cf. Gal. 3:19) or in the inclusion of Gentiles (Rom. 4:16), but as “things not seen” (11:1), the heavenly city and
homeland (11:14-16), which remain unfulfilled for believers. The example of the patriarchs, who never obtained the promise during their lifetime (11:13, 39), is a guide for the disoriented readers. Those who do not see all things in subjection to the son may, however, see the invisible (11:1, 26-27) in the distance (11:13). While believers have not obtained the promise, the death of Christ is the guarantee of their hope (6:19-20; 7:22). In the meantime, to be a believer is to be a refugee and a stranger on the earth.
The author has reframed the community’s understanding of the promise with images derived from the philosophical categories of the first century. Middle Platonists recognized the distance between the visible and invisible realities, maintaining that one may see the invisible. Those who see the invisible will be “strangers on the earth” (cf. Heb. 11:13). While the author maintains the eschatological hope of the earlier Christian tradition, he interprets the community’s situation with images drawn from Middle Platonism, pointing to the stable reality of the unseen in order to restore its confidence in the promise.
|
Anti-Judaism 'In the Round'
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Tracy Thorpe, Harvard University
When the Christians began to rule Jerusalem after Constantine became the sole ruling emperor in 324 C.E., the new city leadership had to make some decisions about what to build and where. During at least the first half of their control of the city, literally dozens of churches, monasteries, and martyria appeared throughout Jerusalem. Yet interestingly, all of these new religious buildings stood, quite noticeably, opposite the large, centrally-located, thirty-three acre Temple Mount.
It has been hypothesized by some scholars that the Temple Mount was irrelevant for the Christians. Others have suggested that they left the ruins alone as a means of censuring the Jews. However, beyond these general assumptions, no one has yet examined what fourth-century theologians were actually saying about the Temple Mount. Here, I look closely at the writings of Eusebius of Caesarea and Cyril of Jerusalem since they were present during the early, developmental stages of Christian Jerusalem. It is clear that for both of these bishops, the Temple Mount functioned significantly as a monumental anti-Jewish monument, one that uniquely conveyed their own contra Iudaeos sentiment. Moreover, the Temple wreckage was used to "prove" Jesus had indeed been a true prophet. Much like our modern ‘theater in the round,’ pilgrims would visit the Mount, walking among the drama of the destroyed Jewish Temple, and Eusebius (although most likely Cyril too) was aware of this. Thus, far from being peripheral and irrelevant, I believe that these two men saw that the obvious scar of destruction could be a compelling anti-Jewish symbol, one that amplified uniquely their own beliefs regarding the Jews.
|
Philosophy in, with, and under: Reassessing Justin’s Christian Identity
Program Unit: Hellenistic Moral Philosophy and Early Christianity
Runar M. Thorsteinsson, Copenhagen University
The relationship between Early Christianity and the ancient philosophical schools is (still) often referred to in terms of “either–or” categories. By contrast, the present paper emphasizes the intimate ways in which the philosophical schools and Christianity were (and still are) weaved together, not only at an intellectual level as systems of thought, but also at the level of actual social practice.
As a test case, the paper focuses on Justin Martyr who, according to his own account (Dial. 2), started out from the philosophical schools (Stoic, Peripatetic, Pythagorean, and especially Platonic) before he eventually turned to Christianity. His writings suggest that by becoming Christian Justin did not (in his understanding) turn away from philosophy as such. On the contrary, his wish to become a “philosopher” was fulfilled precisely when he became a Christian (cf. Dial. 8.2: “Thus it is that I am now a philosopher”). He turned from one kind of philosophy (Platonism) to another (Christianity), the latter being for him the only “true” philosophy.
But what was it that drove Justin away from Platonism to Christianity? Was there, in his view, something “wrong” with the former? Or was there perhaps something “missing” in it? In other words, was Platonism in some ways insufficient as a philosophy (unlike Christianity), according to Justin’s understanding of it? This paper aims to shed some light on these challenging questions by examining Justin’s relationship to contemporary (Middle) Platonism. Furthermore, in light of Justin’s own description of his intellectual journey, it is argued that the usual question of the way in which Platonism (or other philosophical schools) influenced Justin’s Christian thinking should be reversed: the question is rather how Christianity came to affect his traditionally philosophical foundation. Philosophy was “in, with, and under” his whole identity as a Christian.
|
Love Your Brother, Live with the Other: The In-Group Ethics of 1 Peter in Context
Program Unit: Ethics, Love, and the Other in Early Christianity
Runar M. Thorsteinsson, Copenhagen University
Any analysis of the moral teaching of 1 Peter is bound to show that love (agape) is presented as the primary virtue of the letter. The author of the text makes it very clear that Christians should above all love one another. But what is the proper scope of the Christian love, according to 1 Peter? Does the author require love of outsiders, too? Or is the virtue of love somehow confined to fellow believers?
Having analyzed the pertinent passages in 1 Peter, the present paper suggests that the latter is the case, namely, that for “Peter” the virtue of love (agape) is an in-group term, used only of proper relationships within the Christian “brotherhood.” Outsiders never come into view when agape is under discussion.
But if “love” is not the right concept to describe the proper attitude and behavior toward “the others,” what exactly does the author say about out-group relations? How are Christians to behave in the larger society and how are they to meet fellow residents (probably) of Rome? It is suggested that while 1 Peter certainly encourages good behavior and friendly attitude toward outsiders, the writing advocates a fundamental distinction between ethical obligation toward fellow believers, on the one hand, and non-believers, on the other, expressed by the presence and absence, respectively, of the primary virtue of love. Ethical obligation toward “the others” is basically characterized and constrained by passiveness.
Where does this conception come from? Is such a fundamental distinction between “us and them” the result of external influences, i.e. from Roman society? Having shown that the most prominent contemporary ethics in the city of Rome (Stoic ethics) does not make such a distinction, it is argued that the main influence in this regard derives from the community ethic of Paul’s letter to the Romans.
|
In the Eye of the Beholder: Reading Biblical Texts through an “Embodied” Literary Approach
Program Unit: Senses, Cultures, and Biblical Worlds
Nicole Tilford, Emory University
In this paper, I will demonstrate that an “embodied” literary approach can provide a fresh
angle from which to read biblical texts, one that recognizes both the literary artistry of the text as
well as the various levels upon which that artistry has operated. Many prior literary readings
seem to contain the unspoken assumption that the “mind” and the “body” are two distinct
spheres of study. Texts are seen as mental discourses, with little or no direct relationship to the
lived, corporeal experiences of the people that produced or received them, while the body is
regulated to the realm of sociology or anthropology. Yet, unlike Western traditions, early biblical
authors did not envision a sharp distinction between “mind” and “body”; for them, cognition,
emotion, and perception lay within a very concrete, corporeal existence. To separate the words of
the Israelites from their concrete experiences risks misunderstanding the meanings that the texts
are attempting to convey.
On the contrary, this paper will argue that words, especially those that reflect the human
sensorimotor processes (movement, taste, sight, etc.), are effective means by which to convey
meaning precisely because they invoke the embodied experience of the authors and audiences
who utilized and encountered them. Building upon the work of cognitive philosopher Mark
Johnson, I will examine one particular text, Jacob’s encounter at Jabbok in Gen 32:23–32, and
demonstrate that biblical texts create meaning for various audiences by skillfully weaving
together the wholistic, multimodal experience of the human sensorimotor realms. In doing so, I
will show that an “embodied” literary approach can help scholars recognize the way biblical
texts appeal to both the particular embodied experience of its author and original tradents and
also more universally to the lived experiences of the various peoples who have encountered the
biblical texts throughout history.
|
God and Nineveh, Jonah and Nahum: Odd Pairs and the Literary and Theological Coherence of the Twelve
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Daniel Timmer, Reformed Theological Seminary
Several decades after its appearance, the question of how one might read the Book of the Twelve as some sort of unity continues to foment discussion. The relationship between Jonah and Nahum is an interesting facet of that question given the varying proximity of the two books in the manuscript traditions and the contrasting images of Nineveh that they present, especially since both relate the contrasting fates of Nineveh that they envisions to the same archetypal description of the divine character in Exodus 34. This paper will focus on intertextual (especially via Exodus 34:6-7 and Nineveh) and theological (God and non-Israelite nations) aspects of these two prophets with a view toward determining how best to describe their coherence within the Twelve. The findings of this limited study will provide raw material that can be integrated into the larger question of the interpretation of the Twelve. Along the way limited attention will be given to a chronological approach to the Twelve, the place of Jonah in the collection, and the import of those books’ historical setting for their interpretation.
|
Zephaniah and the Re-definition of Israel: The Supra-Ethnic Reconfiguration of an Oracle against the Nations and an Oracle of Salvation
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Daniel Timmer, Reformed Theological Seminary
The plasticity of Israel’s identity in the Hebrew Bible’s writing prophets, and the mechanisms behind its transformation, are significant but undervalued elements in the theology of those books. This is particularly true of Zephaniah, which has received comparatively little attention in recent decades despite the fact that its treatment of Israel and the nations is among the most creative of the writing prophets. This paper focuses on the penultimate section of Zephaniah (3:8-13) and explores how it identifies Israel, the nations, and the remnant of Israel in its description of God’s definitive act of judgment and salvation in the Day of the Lord. Particular attention is given to the themes of return to the land, repentance, and the remnant, and to the ways that the ethnic identity of some Israelites (and of some non-Israelites!) is recast in religious or theological terms.
|
Seal and Comforter: On the Apocalyptic Prophethood of Elkasai, Mani, and Muhammad
Program Unit: Qur'an and Biblical Literature
Alexander Toepel, Sankt Georgen Graduate School, Frankfurt am Main
In this paper I wish to elucidate the origin of one strand of early Islamic prophetology in the heterodox Christian movements of Mesopotamia. Taking Muhammad's identification with the “paraclete/comforter” of John 14:16-17, 26; 15:26; 16:13 as a starting point, I will trace this term's evolution through Manichaeism back to Syrian baptists of the early second century CE and Syriac baptismal theology such as can be found in the Acts of Thomas. In this context the seal-imagery makes its appearance which likewise will rise to prominence in early Islam in so far as Muhammad is termed “seal of prophets”. Again a Manichaean background is likely, and as the investigation proceeds a rather coherent picture emerges: The terms “seal” and “comforter” seem to have stood in an intimate relationship. Both make their appearance in a baptismal context, and there is a rather large body of writings which identify the two by understanding them as referring to a heavenly double of the neophyte, which reveals knowledge of one's true nature. This would on the one hand entail knowledge about one's origins, presumably in an extra-mundane realm, and on the other hand is understood in the sense of a transformation which re-shapes a person according to the image of his/her heavenly twin. The seal metaphor seems to refer especially to this latter procedure: As a seal leaves its impression upon wax, so the “seal” is imprinting its shape upon the baptised person, the implication being that the seal's image would be the truly real form which a human being can attain only by being modelled after it. It is clear, therefore, that “seal of the prophets” in this sense can never refer to an actual human person; it is rather a thoroughly eschatological reality which opens a gateway to the heavenly realm.
|
The Protevangelium of James as Aretalogy
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Alexander Toepel, Sankt Georgen Graduate School, Frankfurt am Main
Protevangelium of James, together with other infancy gospels, was classified by Helmut Koester in his and James M. Robinson's now classical Trajectories through Early Christianity as “aretalogy”, i.e. as an attempt to safeguard Jesus' status as theios aner by highlighting his miraculous birth, impeccable lineage, and flawless family background. In the present paper I aim at substantiating this view by presenting both Greco-Roman and Rabbinical polemic against Jesus' birth and ancestry, and showing how such views are being refuted by PJ. I will focus especially upon polemics found in Celsus' True Word and early Rabbinical tradition, even though PJ in all probability does not respond precisely to this literature. The procedure is validated, however, by the fact, that many of PJ's peculiar traits, such as Mary spinning wool in her own house, being submitted to a priestly trial, and giving birth to Jesus in a cave, make sense if understood as being directed against allegations such as can be found in Celsus and the Talmudic tradition. PJ thus emerges as a text seeking to answer hostile exegesis of the canonical gospels by filling in the gaps left by Matthew and Luke: Who was Jesus' mother Mary; why was she not suspected of adultery by the larger community; how was Jesus son of David, even though he was not Joseph's son? These questions are being answered in a characteristic way which sets PJ apart from both the “Jewish-Christian” (in a narrow sense) and the “Gnostic” solution and makes this text a witness to an emerging tradition later called “orthodox”.
|
The Sabbatical Year and the Yearning of the Land for Rest
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Sigve K. Tonstad, Loma Linda University
The Sabbath, the Sabbatical Year, and the Jubilee constitute a remarkable ecological resource that promises rest for the land and economic relief for its inhabitants (Exod. 23:10–11; Lev. 25 and 27; Deut. 15:1–11). In this closely related calendrical triumvirate, the ecological and social intent seem explicit already within the biblical text and is not merely an afterthought generated by the felt need of reader responses in the 21st century. On the other hand, the ecology crisis that belongs to the paradigm of the contemporary reader liberates these stipulations from the stigma that these stipulations are creations urban scribes and desk theologians who had no understanding of agrarian realities and therefore no relationship to actual life. The texts outlining these ordinances teach dependence and interdependence between human and non-human creation. In the prophetic perspective, non-observance of the Sabbatical Year is presented as the reason for the exile, suggesting that if human beings will not allow the land to rest, God will (2 Chron. 36:21).
|
Allusion as Oracle: Textual Authority and Scripturalization in Ezekiel 38–39
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
William A. Tooman, University of St. Andrews
Ezek 1-37 alludes to a wide variety of texts from the Torah and Prophets. The human or literary sources of these allusions are never mentioned. Rather, they are depicted as part of the communication between God and the Prophet. The only source of consequence is the immediate divine source. The Gog Oracles (Ezek 38-39), a late addition to the book, are fundamentally different. Ezekiel 38.17 appeals to a recognized deposit of prophecies accessible to both author and reader. It ties the Gog oracles to this longstanding tradition of prophecy, making a de facto claim of continuity with past prophets and their authority. Further, an examination of the implicit allusions in Ezek 38-39 reveals its dependence upon a body of literature from the Torah, Prophets and Psalms, which are treated as authoritative texts. The Gog Oracles, then, are a witness to an emergent body of authoritative literature that corresponds in certain ways with the witness of other Second Temple Literature, including 4QMMT, the Community Rule, and many Rewritten Scriptural Texts.
|
John's Gospel as a Defense of Jesus' Honor? Some Reflections out of Intercontextual Analysis with the Maori Concept of "Mana"
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Derek Tovey, St. John's College - Auckland
Within traditional Maori culture, the concept of "mana" denotes (among other aspects) the honour, or place (status) that a person holds within his or her social group, or setting. Mana is both ascribed, through birth or descent, and acquired through deeds. In this respect, mana provides useful analogies to models of honour and shame within the first-century Mediterranean world. This paper draws upon contextual analogy with the Maori concept of mana to undergird an understanding of "doxa" (“glory”) in John’s Gospel as ascribed and achieved honour, and to illuminate the Gospel’s rhetorical claim for Jesus’ “mana” as God’s Son. Thus, this paper argues that the presentation of the doxa of Jesus in John’s Gospel is, in fact, a defence of the honour and status of Jesus. (Following Ronald Piper, "doxa" is understood less as a theological term, as often held by exegetes, but as a term around which social scientific aspects surrounding “honour” may adhere.) The Gospel’s narrative is structured to demonstrate how Jesus’ honour is both ascribed and achieved. Through the narrator’s rhetoric, depiction of events, and represented dialogue/discourse, the “mana” of Jesus’, as a human character, is made evident. As a result of an intercontextual analysis of the core value of honour, and its rhetorical function in John’s Gospel, the paper concludes with some implications the Gospel’s understanding of Jesus’ honour carries for approaching honour as a contemporary social value.
|
Review of the Bible Illuminated
Program Unit: Ideology, Culture, and Translation
Philip H. Towner, American Bible Society
Review of the Bible Illuminated
|
The Singular Abrahamic Seed and the Law’s Supplementing of the Promise in Gal 3:15–20
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Bradley R. Trick, Duke University
Scholars have trouble accounting for Paul’s emphasis on the singular nature of the Abrahamic seed in Gal 3:16b: “It does not say ‘And to seeds,’ as concerning many, but as concerning one: ‘And to your seed,’ who is Christ.” This difficulty arises in large part, I suggest, because most interpreters assume that 3:16b serves primarily to identify Christ as the sole seed. In such interpretations, the seed’s singular nature typically functions either to support this identification by denying the possibility of a collective reference to Israel or to emphasize the corporate solidarity of those in Christ. The former option results in an arbitrary argument that ultimately proves inconclusive since it cannot challenge Isaac’s status as Abraham’s seed. The latter option results in an argument that has no relevance to the surrounding discussion of the law’s relation to the Abrahamic diatheke.
This paper suggests that Paul instead establishes the singular nature of Abraham’s seed because of its implications for the law. Galatians 3:15-20 accordingly becomes a tightly composed argument for the law’s inability to qualify a person for the Abrahamic inheritance. The first two verses (3:15-16) connect the general legal principle that no one annuls or supplements a ratified diatheke to the specific case of God’s promises to Abraham and his singular seed. The subsequent verses then use this principle to invalidate the law as a basis for the promised inheritance on the grounds that it would 1) annul the earlier promise made to Abraham (3:17-18) and 2) supplement the promise made to the single seed by adding heirs (3:19-20). As the paper will show, not only does this interpretation account for Paul’s emphasis on the singular seed, but it also enables us to make sense of the otherwise puzzling claim about the mediator in 3:20.
|
The KJV and the Development of Text Criticism
Program Unit:
David Trobisch, American Bible Society
The KJV and the Development of Text Criticism
|
I Once Was Found, But Now I’m Lost: The Call to Preach as Disorientation and Reconfiguration
Program Unit: Academy of Homiletics
Thomas H. Troeger, Yale University
*
|
The Problem of Time in Joel
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Ronald Troxel, University of Wisconsin-Madison
The pendulum has swung again in the study of Joel, with most recent research regarding the book as a composite of editorial layers (Barton, Beck, Jeremias, Wöhrle). A frequent debate in these studies concerns the temporal value of verbs, especially in 2:18-19, a conundrum that has vexed scholars since Ibn Ezra and prompted Barton, in his commentary, to conclude that "little notice was taken of the tenses in prophetic books, since it was assumed that everything, even narrative, had also a future reference."
This paper focuses on Joel 2:18-27, demonstrating that there is coherence in the temporal value of its verbs. And it argues, more specifically, that the waw-consecutive imperfect forms of vv. 18-19 are sensible when viewed within their discourse setting.
|
Metaphor, Grammar, and Parallelism in the Song of Songs 5
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
David Toshio Tsumura, Japan Bible Seminary
In this paper I discuss a type of metaphor which is integrated into the vertical grammar of parallelism in the Song of Songs 5.
For example, in 5:15b
mar?ehû kall?banôn (His appearance is like Lebanon, AX) //
ba?ûr ka?arazîm (choice as the cedars.(NRSV, ESV, NIV) BX')
the two metaphors "like Lebanon" and "like the cedars" are parallel to each other, the second being a detail restatement of the first. However, the other items are vertically dependent to each other, constituting a sentence nucleus: "His appearance is choice".
Thus, the parallelism of this verse is patterned after AX//BX', in which B depends vertical grammatically on A, while X' is simply a restatement of X (see JBL 128 [2009], 167-81). The entire parallelism conveys the meaning, "his appearance is choice like Lebanon, i.e. like [its] cedars."
Such a pattern can be extended to four line parallelisms (quadracolons) as A//X//B//X' which we see in 5:12:
?ênâw k?yônîm (His eyes are like doves A) //
?al-?apîqê mayim (beside streams of water, X) //
ro?a?ôt be?alab (bathed in milk, B) //
yoš?bôt ?al-mille?t (sitting beside a full pool. (ESV) X')
or A//X//X'//B in 5:5:
qamtî ?anî liptoa? l?dôdî (I arose to open to my beloved, A) //
w?yaday na??pû-môr (and my hands dripped with myrrh, X) //
w??e?b??otay môr ?ober (my fingers with liquid myrrh, X') //
?al kappôt hamman?ûl (upon the handles of the bolt. (NRSV) B)
In these verses, metaphor, grammar and parallelism are highly integrated in a sophisticated way. A thorough understanding of these verses leads us to a more balanced and unforced interpretation of poetic metaphors in the Song of Songs.
|
The Concept of Social Identity in Corinth: Wisdom, Power, and Transformation
Program Unit:
J. Brian Tucker, Moody Theological Seminary
*
|
Runaway Slave, Fugitive Rebel, or Enemy King? Rethinking Baal's Relationship to Yamm in KTU 1.2 I
Program Unit: Ugaritic Studies and Northwest Semitic Epigraphy
Aaron Tugendhaft, New York University
This paper will reevaluate the relationship between Baal and Yamm as depicted in KTU 1.2 i (Yamm's envoy to the assembly of the gods). It will be argued that the scene colors the relationship between these two antagonists by means of a complex combination of motifs taken from the political realities of the day. By reading this scene in light of ancient Near Eastern texts that deal with runaway slaves, rebels and enemy kings--from Ugaritic letters to Hittite diplomatic texts to the biblical story of Sheba ben Bichri--Baal's relationship to Yamm at this point in the narrative emerges in sharper detail. Furthermore, by recognizing how the scene taps into the political discourse of its day, the paper will contribute to a finer understanding of how the political themes at the heart of the Baal Cycle connect to the actual political issues of its world.
|
Baal among the Storm-Gods: Distinguishing Mythic Meaning from Mythic Motifs
Program Unit: Bible, Myth, and Myth Theory
Aaron Tugendhaft, New York University
The story of the storm-god's travails is found throughout the ancient Near East and eastern Mediterranean---from Babylon to Greece, from Hatti to Mari and Israel. The Ugaritic version of the story, which tells of Baal's battle with Yamm, has often been read in light of the other extant tellings. In particular, reading through the lenses of the Babylonian creation story, Hebrew poetry, and a letter from Mari, scholars have taken the Ugaritic storm-god's defeat of the sea to be a "Chaoskampf" aimed at legitimating the ruling monarch. This paper will argue that such procedure conflates mythic motifs and mythic meanings. By adopting a more nuanced approach to mythic signification---one that recognizes each of our extant versions as a unique message that plays off of, but cannot be identified with, a particular code---I will show how the Ugaritic Baal Cycle adapts common motifs for an uncommon purpose: calling into question the political rhetoric of myth itself.
|
Proverbial Disability and the Structure of Reversal in 2 Sam 5:8b
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Craig W. Tyson, University of Michigan-Ann Arbor
This paper builds on recent analyses of 2 Sam 5:8b by Ceresko and Schipper that emphasize its literary and rhetorical function within the passage and DtrH. I argue that the passage is structured chiastically and combines the rhetoric of disability and an insider-outsider motif in order to create a narrative reversal whereby David ends up in Jerusalem and the Jebusites end up “disabled” and outside Jerusalem. The chiastically structured reversal is effected by a set of repeated vocabulary and syntactical structures that bind the proverb in 2 Sam 5:8b tightly to the narrative. The whole passage is enclosed by paronomasia. The attachment of the proverb to the narrative shows that it was deployed purposefully as part of the literary and rhetorical structure of 2 Sam 5:6–10 and was not a textual accretion.
|
The Motif of Bat Qol in Rabbinic Literature
Program Unit: History and Literature of Early Rabbinic Judaism
Frauke Uhlenbruch, University of Derby
Throughout rabbinic literature a motif is found referred to as Bat Qol -literally translated “daughter of a voice.” This voice, detached from any visible speaker, communicates celestial decrees and divine judgment to humans. Although the motif, which is strikingly feminine, is generally known, it has attracted relatively little scholarly attention, despite contemporary interest in gender issues. This paper approaches the motif of a feminine divine intermediary by discussing its linguistic, semantic, literary, and cultural origins. The motif will be compared to better-known conveyors of God's will - prophets and angels - to shed light on the issue of its implied gender.
The term Bat Qol will be regarded linguistically at first, being most likely a diminutive construction. On the semantic level, the term can refer to the echo of a human voice or it can denote the prophetic phenomenon. The literary origin of Bat Qol referring to a divine communicator can be traced back to Tosefta Sotah 13:2, where the phenomenon is explicitly described as the only remaining means of prophecy left in Eretz Israel after the death of the last prophets, thereby placing the phenomenon clearly in the realm of prophecy. Referring to one of the most recent discussions of Bat Qol by Tal Ilan, I will speculate on the possibility of Greco-Roman influence on the motif, that may explain its femininity.
In order to resolve the mystery of the seeming superfluousness of Bat Qol as yet another prophetic entity in passages where angels and prophets appear alongside Bat Qol, the intermediate conclusion of Greco-Roman influence on the formation of the motif will be called upon to conclude that we have to do with a mix of motifs from different cultural backgrounds.
|
Qualifying Rabbinic Ritual Agents: Cognitive Science and the Early Rabbinic Kitchen
Program Unit: Religious Competition in Late Antiquity
Daniel Ullucci, Wesleyan University Connecticut
Complex rules governing the preparation and consumption of food exist in nearly all cultures to a greater or lesser extent. Sociological analysis of such rules has proven to be a fruitful way of elucidating social and religious hierarchies and identifications in ancient Mediterranean cultures. Judean food laws, in the Hebrew Bible, Mishna, and Tosefta, have proven particularly constructive. This paper expands such analysis by arguing that cognitive theories of ritual can elucidate the logic behind such texts and the social realities of their production. Rabbinic sources show a deep concern with the agent of food production. Specifically, these texts assert that the agent of food production must be a proper Jew (as defined by the texts themselves). This paper argues that this concern for agency parallels the role of agency detection in ritual, as outlined by McCauley and Lawson’s ritual form hypothesis. McCauley and Lawson argue that participants’ evaluation of the wellformedness and efficacy of a ritual is dependent on their evaluation of the ritual’s agent. This observation allows an analysis of the Rabbinic sources as examples of imagined or idealized ritual. These Rabbinic texts, therefore, are an example of the cognitive logic of ritual being worked out in a textual medium.
|
Paul’s Use of Bodily Stigmata and Social Stigmatization in His Letter to the Galatians
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Kristi Upson-Saia, Occidental College
Paul wrote his letter to the churches of Galatia in order to urge them not to listen to competing missionaries, but rather to hold fast to the version of Christianity he taught them. As he contrasted his gospel with that of his opponents, Paul culled several images of bodily wounds—circumcision, castration, and stigmata—in order to provide physical evidence of his gospel’s superiority and to define the true “marks” of Christian identity. With the help of disability theory and sociologists Erving Goffman and Gerhard Falk’s analysis of social stigmatization, this paper focuses attention on how Paul employed images and interpretations of bodily wounds in an effort to vilify his opponents and valorize himself. Throughout the letter, Paul interprets bodily wounds in some surprising ways. While at times he follows the conventional devaluation of bodily wounds—linking circumcision to the practice of deliberately scarring or wounding delinquent slaves as a sign of subjugation and to the shame of castration—at other times he strains to invert the devaluation of bodily injuries in order to venerate his own wounds, which he re-reads as imitatio Christi. This paper shows that, despite Paul’s somewhat unconventional significations of circumcision, castration, and stigmata, he consistently and methodically employs images and interpretations of bodily wounds in an attempt to stigmatize his opponents, as well as the Galatians who turned to their gospel, while at the same time alleviating the social stigma of his own bodily wounds.
|
Jezreel of Ahab and Jezebel
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
David Ussishkin, Tel Aviv University
The excavation of Tel Jezreel was carried out by John Woodhead and by me on behalf of the British School of Archaeology in Jerusalem and the Institute of Archaeology of Tel Aviv University. A large compound, rectangular in plan and heavily fortified, was built here in the first part of the ninth century BCE. It is assumed that this was the central military base of the Omride kings which was later destroyed by the Aramaeans. It now seems possible to try and assess the different roles of Jezreel, Samaria and Megiddo in the northern kingdom of Israel. The pottery assemblage of Jezreel forms a cardinal datum in the debate on the chronology of the tenth and ninth centuries BCE. Finally, it is interesting to compare the biblical description of Jezreel to the finds on the ground.
|
Gal 3:28 and Its Alleged Relationship to the Three Blessing of Gratitude Found in Rabbinic Writings
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Gesila Nneka Uzukwu, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
In Paul's explicit use of the statement, ouk eni Ioudaios oude Hellen, ouk eni doulos oude eleutheros, ouk eni arsen kai thelu, in Gal 3:28, scholars have noted similar sayings found in rabbinic writings and proposed that the latter could be a possible insight for a discussion of the meaning and theology of Gal 3:28. According to Frederick F. Bruce (1982: 187) and a few others, in Gal 3:28 “Paul makes a threefold affirmation which corresponds to a number of Jewish formulas in which the threefold subdivision is maintained, as in the morning prayer in which the male Jew thanks God that he was not made a Gentile, a slave or a woman.” This parallel, though interesting, is more assumed than proved. Scholars usually speak of the possible connection between Gal 3:28 and the three blessings of gratitude found in rabbinic texts, but they devote too little attention to the question of establishing what kind of connection there is. Others allow their interpretation of the three blessings of gratitude found in rabbinic texts to influence their exegesis of Gal 3:28 without questioning in what way this Pauline passage in question reflects a similar expression found in rabbinic writings, and whether or not there is any relationship between these Christian and Jewish texts. The present study seeks to re-examine the assertion of the connection between Gal 3:28 and the three blessings of gratitude found in rabbinic writings, asks deeper questions concerning the social-historical context of these alleged sources and shows that the discussion of the relationship between Gal 3:28 and the three blessings of gratitude found in rabbinic texts is much more complex than scholars have thus far imagined.
|
Negotiated Values for Paul and the Corinthians
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Katy Valentine, Graduate Theological Union
I propose to examine 1 Cor 7 through the lens of cultural adaptation in the Roman East. Interpreters often see this chapter as narrowly dictated sexual morals by Paul for the Corinthians; a more expansive view is possible by seeing it as carefully negotiated values by Paul and the Corinthians who were both products of cultural adaption, or “Romanization”. Both parties experienced similar phenomena of “Romanization” due to living in the Roman East, such increased urbanization. The specific manifestation of their adaptation differed due to their local settings, which may account for the struggle experienced between Paul and the Corinthians. 1 Cor 7 shows the negotiation of both parties in a world of changing identities under the Roman Empire. This will show that Paul was not solely critical of empire, but was a product of Hellenistic Judaism and cultural adaptation within the Roman Empire. I propose three explorations of this chapter. First, I will explore the Roman concept of self-control and examine it within the context of 1 Cor 7, as it is invoked in 1 Cor 7:5 and 7:9 while also being disseminated across the Roman East. Second, I will explore the cultural negotiations of the Corinthians and Paul. The letter gives evidence that both parties had adopted certain values through the process of Romanization, but were forced to re-examine these values (such as asceticism, marriage, slavery and circumcision) once they entered the Christian community. Third, I will briefly explore similar cults in Corinth and other locations in the Roman East (such as Isis and Mithra) which struggled with negotiating values and cultural identity within a context of Romanization. This demonstrates that Romanization was far from monolithic, and values were constantly negotiated both by both the colonizers and the colonized in local settings under the Roman Empire.
|
Reading the Temple Warning as a Greek Visitor
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Dionysia van Beek, Macquarie University-Sydney
The interpretation of the temple warning (CIJ 2.1400) has focused on the question of authorship and not that of readership. The present paper seeks to redress this oversight. Because of the inscription’s provenance and function in marking off the outer court, it has in the
past been assumed that authorship was to be found within the temple hierarchy. See, for example, P. Segal, “The Penalty of the Warning Inscription from the Temple of Jerusalem”, IEQ (1989): 79-84. However, recent work on Herod’s architecture, which has argued his extensive fashioning of the outer court, should cause one to pause.
The paper will ask how a Greek visitor to the temple would understand the inscription. It will argue that the inscription’s text shows no trace of translation Greek, but rather that in terms of pragmatics, grammar and lexicography, the reader would naturally assume that its concepts are those of Hellenistic law. Their assumption would be further confirmed by the architectural display of the outer court. In other words, the Greek visitor would assume that the inscription was issued on the authority of the king, rather than the priest.
|
Matthew’s Story of the Rich Young Man (19:16–30) in Light of the Two Ways
Program Unit: Didache in Context
Van de Sandt, Huub, Tilburg University
The story of the rich young man in Matt 19:16-31 falls into two main parts. In the first part (19:16-22) the man asks Jesus what he must do to have eternal life. Jesus tells him to keep the commandments and specifies which ones. The young rich man claims that he has observed them. When Jesus then instructs him to sell his possessions, give to the poor, and follow him he goes away sad. In the second part of the story Jesus teaches his disciples about wealth and discipleship in vv. 23-30. He emphasizes that it will be impossible for a rich man to enter the kingdom, as impossible as it is for a camel to go through the eye of a needle. He then contrasts the rich young man’s refusal to sell his wealth with the disciples’ response of leaving family and possessions. It is true that the Matthean version of the story as a whole is based upon Mark 10:17-31 but Matthew has exercised considerable freedom in rewriting the account. As my paper will hopefully show, one may understand Matthew’s version of the story of the rich young man in the perspective of the Two Ways. This approach will shed new light on Matthew’s text.
|
From the Ganges to the Thames, and the Orontes to the Tiber
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
Gerhard van den Heever, University of South Africa
Juvenal’s Satires decried the flood-tide of ‘oriental’ immigrants with their strange religions and customs, as well as the fact that this phenomenon provoked a redefinition of the face and fabric of Roman imperial society. The Romanization of the Levant was essentially a two-way street: even as the ‘Orient’ was (re-)invented by Rome into an imperial image of itself for its own consumption, so the steady ‘orientalizing’ of Rome opened the door to new social, cultural, and religious discourses—to the resulting new identity construction the Egyptian philosopher Celsus testified, including disturbing tales of resurrections from Syria describing emergent Christian social formations and discourses that resulted in a new conception of Roman identity and habitus. The establishment of ‘oriental’ cults in the Roman world, indeed the marriage of Rome and Orient, changed the character of what should be regarded as Roman. By cult migrations we denote the ways groups transplant and become established in new contexts, the ways individuals elect to change allegiance between groups, and the ways they evoke the constant changes in social identity constructions and maintenance attendant on demographic changes and recontextualizations and reinventions of older traditions. With the goal of theorizing this process, this paper compares and contrasts the ‘orientalization’ of the Roman Empire with the British imperial invention of Hinduism and the resultant massive migration of individuals and groups from the Indian subcontinent, exploring religious production along with issues of cultural sociology, social rhetoric, and discourse. Especially relevant is the maintenance of cultural identities while simultaneously recontextualizing old traditions into new religious formations as well as the dissemination of new religious traditions in ‘British high street’. This self-reflexive theorizing aims in the end to contribute to theory of religion.
|
A Culture of Religious History: The Romantic Invention of Mystery Religions
Program Unit: Redescribing Christian Origins
Gerhard van den Heever, University of South Africa
The invention of religious history in the nineteenth century was deeply embedded in contemporary cultural discourses, in fact, was a product of these. The new discipline of religio-historical study traced the origins of Mediterranean and oriental religions (and thus the mysteries) to an origin in vegetative religion of a dying and rising god as the expression of seasonal cycles of nature, and this view became hugely influential due to the influence of the Pan-Babylonian School later at the beginning of the twentieth century. The path to this construction of the mysteries was paved earlier in the nineteenth century. The emerging picture of the religious history of the ancient Near East was an answer to cultural, social, and political developments in Europe, especially Romanticism. Romanticism as style and as cultural movement itself was a reaction to two centuries of rationalism and increasing industrialisation. The alienation resulting from these social and political upheavals led to the birth of history in a two-fold sense: the birth of the modern scholarly discipline of history and history as a popular sense of a longing for a long-lost paradisal time of wholeness. On the plane of popular culture this ranged from rediscoveries of the “merrie England” of the Middle Ages (in fiction as well as in cultural movements such as the Arts and Crafts movement), to the wholesale revival of Gothic in architecture and literature, and followed by Romanesque, and Byzantine styles, as well as classical revivals of Greek and Roman styles. Simultaneously this period also saw the wholesale importation of the Orient into the “imaginative repertory” of the arts and architecture, and this at a time when discoveries in the field of archaeology and text collection and translation began to transport the exotic Orient into the historical scholarly consciousness of religious origins.
|
The Difference between Hen, Hinneh, and Re'eh
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Christo van der Merwe, University of Stellenbosch
At first glance hen, which occurs 100 times in the Hebrew Bible, appears to be a short form of hinneh. However, although hen has, like hinneh, primarily a deictic character and is in some contexts a near-synonym of hinneh, it differs in many ways from hinneh. hen, for example, has typically the character of an affirming modal word. It expresses the attitude of speakers as far as the epistemic modality of the content of an utterance is concerned. In contrast, hinneh functions more often as a discourse marker and is typically used by speakers to point to entities (things, locations or events) which they regard their addressees would find newsworthy to observe. Narrators also often use hinneh to point to a state of affairs or event which characters were unprepared for and which they found surprising to observe. Although not all 1060 instances of hinneh has this mirative sense, instances where it functions as a presentative, or where it is not used as a marker of mirativity, could be explained as secondary shifts of meaning. The question that remains is: Where does the 84 instances of re'eh fit in? By means of a profile of the use of re'eh, it is illustrated that re'eh differs significantly from hen. It also has a more restricted meaning potential than hinneh. re'eh is indeed sometimes a near-synonym of hinneh. However, this applies predominantly to a specific sub-set of uses of hinneh – a subset where hinneh and hen do not overlap.
|
What is Ethical According to the Johannine Jesus?
Program Unit: John, Jesus, and History
Jan Van der Watt, Radboud University Nijmegen
The Gospel of John gives evidence of different conflicts, both externally and internally. Within this framework, Jesus explains what the will of God is and expresses it mainly in terms of love. He offers a relational ethics in which Jesus should be evident in the believers like branches that stay in the vine and vice versa. This view should determine the behavior of believers towards one another and the world. Although it is not possible to trace the words of Jesus in this regard directly to the historical Jesus, this is at least the message the congregation accepted and practically applied (or at least was expected to apply) in their everyday lives.
|
Flavius Josephus’ Jewish Antiquities 15: A Narratological Approach
Program Unit: Josephus
Jan Willem van Henten, University of Amsterdam
Tamar Landau introduced a narratological approach in Josephus studies in her analysis of the Herod narratives in The Jewish War and The Jewish Antiquities (T. Landau, Out-Heroding Herod: Josephus, Rhetoric and the Herod Narratives, Leiden: Brill, 2006). Landau clearly demonstrates the usefulness of a narratological reading of Josephus, but she applies this approach to selective passages only (mainly speeches, passages about natural and supernatural phenomena and obituaries and accounts of death). In my commentary on The Antiquities 15-17 for the Brill Josephus project I attempt to include a narratological perspective for the entire narrative, focusing on how Josephus tells his story about Herod and Archelaus. My contribution will deal with Josephus’ narratorial voice (he is clearly an overt narrator), with his use of time and space as narratological tools as well as with focalization as a narratological technique (the narrator looks at an object, situation etc. through the eyes of one of the characters in the narrative). I will briefly explain these narratological devices and will give examples of how Josephus uses them in Book 15 of The Antiquities.
|
The Church as ‘Assembly’
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
George van Kooten, University of Groningen
Recently scholars have put much emphasis on the church as a voluntary association in the Graeco-Roman world. Although this understanding has proven to be very illuminating, at the same time it is not without significance that Christians called this organization ‘assembly’, ‘ekklesia’. According to Origen, this terminology has been consciously chosen and implies an implicit antithesis between the Christian assembly (‘the Church’, ‘the assembly of God’) and the political assembly.
According to Origen,‘everywhere in the world in order that men might be converted and reformed He [i.e. God] made the gospel of Jesus to be successful, and caused assemblies (‘churches’) to exist in political opposition to the assemblies (genesthai pantachou ekklesias antipoliteuomenas ekklesiais) of superstitious, licentious, and unrighteous men. For such is the character of the crowds who everywhere constitute the assemblies of the cities. And the assemblies of God which have been taught by Christ, when compared with the assemblies of the people where they live, are “as lights in the world”’(Origen, Against Celsus 3.29-30; transl. Chadwick 1953, with alterations).
In this paper, I will sketch the development of Christian ecclesiological reflection between Paul and Origen, compare it with Graeco-Roman regulations of the political assemblies, and show that already Paul’s exhortation of the Christians at Corinth to speak in the assembly rather a limited amount of words with the mind, than many in a tongue (1 Cor 14.19) should be understood against the background of the proper use of one’s mind in the political assembly. Similarly, the factionalism in the Christian assembly, already deplored by Paul, is reminiscent of the ‘ecclesiastical strife’ in the political assemblies, as described by, among others, Plutarch (Quaestiones convivales 713F), who describes discussions which are moving ‘pros agonas ekklesiastikous’, ‘in the direction of “ecclesiastical” controversy’. This paper will compare Christian ‘ecclesiological’ language with the terminology of the political assembly.
|
The Quest for the Historical Leviathan: Truth and Method in Biblical Studies
Program Unit: Theological Interpretation of Scripture
Raymond C. Van Leeuwen, Eastern University
Most biblical scholars pursue their work largely in terms of the traditions of the guild as handed down to them in graduate school, often in an uneasy relationship with the traditions of our churches and synagogues. This is not necessarily good or bad; it is simply a statement of the obvious. We humans inevitably walk on paths we have inherited. While affirming the value and even necessity of historical enquiry, this paper seeks to examine critically some of our guild's tacit assumptions concerning the role "history" in understanding biblical texts. Positively, I will underscore the benefits 1) of consistently distinguishing reality from representations of reality, and of accepting the implications of this distinction; 2) of carefully discerning the role of ancient cultural conventions and genres, including mimetic historical "fiction," in biblical representations of reality; and 3) of not reducing the question of "truth" or meaning to history. In conclusion, I call for a confrontation with historicism, the unacknowledged "Leviathan" in the house of scholarship.
|
Eusebius and Images of Truth in the Life of Constantine
Program Unit: Eusebius and the Construction of a Christian Culture
Peter Van Nuffelen, Ghent University
The Life of Constantine has been under scholarly scrutiny for a long time. Although the question of its genre has been debated and attributed an important role in judging the historical value of the Vita, little attention has gone to a literary analysis of the work. This paper hopes to show that close attention to modes of presentation may help to shed light on the general interpretation of the life. It will focus in particular on the visual imagery used by Eusebius, a characteristic that permeates the work. This visual imagery serves to establish a link between Constantine and the truth as it is embodied in Christianity.
|
“He Is Risen. He Is Not Here:” He Is in the Text: Understanding Resurrection in the Gospel of Mark as a Form of "Heterotopia"
Program Unit: Extent of Theological Diversity in Earliest Christianity
Geert Van Oyen, Universite Catholique de Louvain
The end of the Gospel of Mark is very abrupt: the three women at the tomb are overcome with fear, flee away and keep silent (16,8). There are no appearance stories, and any form of theological approach to the resurrection is lacking. This is a real challenge for the reader: what is the place of the resurrection in the oldest gospel? Mark does not give any direct answer - neither at the level of history nor at the story level. The real reader should try to find the clue to understanding at the discourse level, and more specifically through the reception of the text by the implied reader. Thus, the final clauses 16,7-8 of Mark’s Gospel invite the reader to a "re-lecture" of the gospel from the perspective of the unrecorded meeting after Jesus’ death. If "he is not here", he should be in another place, a heteros topos. That is why we would like to apply the idea of "heterotopia", as defined by Michel Foucault "by way of contrast to utopia" (see Diacritics 1986, 22-27), to this second reading process. We will ask whether the consequences of the idea of the abrupt ending of Mark have been pushed to their limit with regard to the identity construction of the Markan readers. The women’s reaction should lead the reader to interpret the presence of the risen Lord as a real but symbolic presence here and now, more than as a real meeting in the future. This radical narrative reading of the end of Mark opens up new insights on what might be the real distinctive marker in the identity building of the Markan communities: in the imitation of Jesus’ life as it is told by Mark in his gospel, those who follow Jesus meet the risen Christ and bring him alive into the world.
|
The Interpretation of the So-Called Maccabean Psalms by Išô`dâdh of Merv
Program Unit: Syriac Literature and Interpretations of Sacred Texts
Herrie F. van Rooy, North-West University (South Africa)
It is well known that Išô`dâdh made use of the commentary of Theodore of Mopsuestia for the compilation of his own commentary on the Psalms. This was demonstrated with relation to the Syriac translation of Theodore's commentary by Leonhard in 2001. Theodore's influence with regard to the other Psalms has not yet been studied in detail, partly
due to the fact that the fragments of the Syriac translation of his commentary contain only a few Psalms. However, it is possible to discuss Theodore's influence on Išô`dâdh by comparing his work to the commentaries of Diodore and Theodore available in Greek. This paper will discuss the interpretation of the Psalms identified as Maccabean Psalms
by Išô`dâdh. Theodore regarded sixteen Psalms as belonging to the Maccabean period, following the interpretation of Diodore. In the East Syriac Psalm headings seventeen Psalms are related to the Maccabean period, Psalms 44, 47, 55, 56, 57, 58, 59, 60, 62, 69, 74, 79, 80, 83, 108, 109 and 143. This paper will explore the interpretation of the
Psalms by Diodore, in his commentary on Psalm 1-50, and the interpretation of Theodore of the Psalms up to 81, while the focus is on the work of Išô`dâdh's with regard to Psalm 83, 108, 109 and 143. His interpretations of these Psalms reflect the Antiochene tradition, but in some instances his interpretations were informed by readings from the Peshitta and from other sources as well. In some instances therefore his interpretation differs from that of Theodore.
|
The Tokachat "Disputation" of Habakkuk as a Contrarian Argument in the Book of the Twelve
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
David Vanderhooft, Boston College
A rhetorical analysis of Habakkuk’s tokachat "disputation" (2:1)—along with other genre markers in Habakkuk and evidence of connections to other books in and outside of the Twelve—shows that the book’s argument offers a contrarian position in response to the problem of foreign invasion. The dominant position reflected in the Twelve, one widespread in the Near East, asserts that impending attack or defeat by a military foe could be interpreted as the consequence of the patron deity’s displeasure with the defeated party. Punishment of the erstwhile conqueror and restoration for the conquered community would follow when the deity changed course. Habakkuk, however, rejects the logic of this ubiquitous formulation and asserts that YHWH ought not to act in accord with it, even though he is poised to raise up the Chaldeans (1:6). Instead, through persuasive argumentation and engagement with other biblical traditions, the prophet urges YHWH to eliminate the Chaldean aggressor. The prophet severs the causal connection between an invading foreign host and the malfeasance of God’s people.
This interpretation has significance for reading the Twelve. Scholars have recognized that the books share many linguistic, literary and ideational elements, and a series of redactional hypotheses have emerged to account for these connections. Yet the Twelve hardly speak univocally even about the most central subjects, such as foreign invasion. Perhaps the search for unity has dulled our appreciation for another possible function of the connections between these books. I suggest that such connections establish the parameters of interpretive options concerning the most fundamental issues addressed by Israelite and Judean prophets.
|
“Doctrines” in Traditional Narratives and Exemplary Figures: Rethinking “Belief” in Roman Religion
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
Zsuzsanna Varhelyi, Boston University
Within the study of Roman religions it has now become the consensus that we cannot apply the modern terms of belief or doctrine when discussing ancient material (Beard, North, Price 2008). While this has led to a primary focus on ritual practices and a generally functionalist approach, in my paper I wish to reopen the discussion concerning the content that went into the ritual practices. In particular, my interest is in narratives about Roman religion as they crystallized in the first century BCE and in the figures marked as exemplary in them, whether they offer positive or negative examples. I highlight the rich evidence for such religious narratives from Rome’s early Republican history, even if the form they now survive in, for example in Livy or Valerius Maximus, only offers us the definitive version of what must have been at least somewhat contested incidents (Davies 2004: 138-142, Mueller 2002: 175-181). Despite the difficulty of reconstructing the actual early narratives, I argue that we can see evidence for an earlier paradigm of exemplary religious behavior even in the late versions of the stories as well as in the few remains of inscriptions, which suggests that there was a certain religious content presented through such exemplary language. Ultimately, we can see proof of the significance of such religious narratives and exemplary figures for Romans in the fact that Augustus, upon becoming emperor, laid claim not only to all religious priesthoods as sources of his new imperial authority, but also to all traditional narratives, whether through representations of exemplary figures of the past in his new Forum and sponsoring Livy’s history or through the collection and burning of the many circulating oracular documents.
|
“Is Your Eye Evil Because I Am God?” Matthew 20:15 in the Context of Seneca’s On Benefits
Program Unit: Hellenistic Moral Philosophy and Early Christianity
Erin Vearncombe, University of Toronto
In Matthew 20:15, at the conclusion of the parable of the laborers in the vineyard, the landowner shames the grumbling full-day workers by demanding, “Am I not allowed to do what I choose with what belongs to me? Or are you envious because I am generous?” (literally, “Is your eye evil because I am good?”). While the landowner’s payment of an equal wage to all workers may not be overly “generous,” his bestowal of a full-day’s wage upon the last-hour workers is an unexpected benefit for these workers. This paper will argue that this “the kingdom of heaven is like” parable can be examined fruitfully in the context of Seneca’s writings on benefits and benefaction and his interest in gratitude as the primary form of reciprocation. Seneca states that the benefactor must imitate the gods who, acting according to their divine nature, bestow innumerable benefits upon the entire human race, “helping all alike,” even those who do not respond to their kindnesses or who are undeserving of their bounty. Following the gods, human benefaction must be independent of response; the landowner, as benefactor, does what he chooses with what belongs to him. Though virtue is defined as the bestowal of a benefit without expectation of return, those who respond to benefaction with ingratitude are worthy of much censure; when the full-day laborers respond negatively to the householder’s benefit, the householder shames them accordingly.
|
“Rights” in Interpretation and Interpreting “What Is Right”: A Bakhtinian Reading of the Laborers in the Vineyard
Program Unit: Bakhtin and the Biblical Imagination
Erin Vearncombe, University of Toronto
In Matthew’s parable of the laborers in the vineyard (Matthew 20:1-16), a householder leaves his estate to hire workers for his vineyard. He agrees to pay the first group of workers the wage of one denarius a day. Upon hiring a second group of laborers, he contracts to pay them “what is right”; successive groups of workers receive no wage agreement at all. “What is right” turns out to be a denarius a day for all of the laborers, regardless of time worked. This equal payment was not the “right” the full-day workers were expecting, and a conflict with the landowner is therefore initiated. This paper will examine the interpretation of “what is right” in Matthew’s parable in the context of Bakhtin’s discussion of reaccentuation. While a speaker has a right to the word, the word does not belong to the speaker; rather, the word belongs to previous speakers who populated it with their own intentions, to the speaker who “reaccentuates” the familiar word, giving it a new interpretation, and to the listener of the word, who is granted the authority of interpretation. In Matthew’s parable, there are many different authorities on the word: “what is right” is spoken by the householder as part of the narrative and interpreted internally by the workers; through the parable, Jesus as speaker offers a familiar yet reaccented interpretation of “what is right”; the Gospel writer interprets the parable, which as a parable demands interpretation and response; and the audience of the Gospel text in turn has rights over “what is right.” The focus on “rights” and “right” in the parable will help to highlight the polyvalent nature of the parable and the dramatic and dialogic nature of “parable” more generally.
|
God's Second Speech in the Book of Job: An Inquiry into the Greek Rendering of Hebrew Hapax Legomena
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Elke Verbeke, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
The book of Job has the second highest number of hapax legomena in the Hebrew Bible (Isaiah having the most). It carries between 150 and 180 – absolute and non-absolute – hapaxes for a total amount of about 11000 words. F.E. Greenspahn (1984) put forward the hypothesis that this high incidence of hapaxes in the book of Job is a matter of style. He believed that the number of hapaxes is higher than expected when Job is speaking, and that this number increases even more in the God speeches. A closer look, however, at the relative proportion of hapaxes in the different parts of the book in relation to their specific character, makes one question this supposedly stylistic nature.
The present paper wishes to address this question by focusing on the Greek rendering of the hapaxes. It will investigate whether the LXX translator of the book of Job noticed the peculiarity of his Vorlage. Did he try to remain faithful to the text’s characteristics to the extent that he imitated the use of hapaxes or rare words or by the use of non-idiomatic Greek constructions? And does the LXX give any clues to the supposedly stylistic use of rare words?
This study will be based on a newly compiled list of hapax legomena. It will focus solely on the second speech of God (Job 40,7-41,26) which displays an impressive density of 21 hapaxes for about 460 words. It is argued that this focus on the Greek rendering of Hebrew hapaxes can contribute to the characterization of the translation technique of LXX Job. The results of our investigation will also suggest that Greenspahn’s predominant hypothesis concerning the stylistic use of hapaxes is in need of refinement and that attention for the technical and detailed character of the God speeches is needed.
|
Panelist for Isaac Kalimi, The Retelling of Chronicles
Program Unit: Midrash
Joseph Verheyden, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
I have been asked by the author to confirm my participation as a panelist in the discussion session on Isaac Kalimi's The etelling of Chronicles in Jewish Tradition and Literature: A Historical Journey (Winona Lake, IN: Eisenbrauns, 2009).
|
A Road to Nowhere? A Critical Look at the "Matthean Posteriority" Hypothesis and What It Means for Q
Program Unit: Q
Joseph Verheyden, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
The hypothesis according to which Matthew's may be "the last" of the synoptic gospels and depend not only on Mark but also on Luke has never been a popular one. It once had been toyed with by C.G. Wilke (1838) and it made a hesitant appearance again more than a century later in an article by H.Ph. West (1967). In the past twenty years, however, the hypothesis seems to have gained some interest again going on the comments by R.V. Huggins (1992), M. Hengel (2000), and most recently, J.R. Edwards (2009). The paper examines the strenghts and weaknesses of the hypothesis and focuses on the way these authors deal with Q in this perspective.
|
Mothers in Men's Monasteries: Early Medieval Cases in the Church of the East
Program Unit: Syriac Literature and Interpretations of Sacred Texts
Cynthia Villagomez, Winston-Salem State University
In the second half of the sixth century, the ecclesiastical hierarchy of the Church of the East became increasingly dominated by major proponents of Christian asceticism who advocated the spread of monastic institutions that they would closely monitor. Legislation was enacted in this period to reverse the anti-monastic policies that had been initiated at the Synod of Acacius in 486. Repeated legislation banning the permanent residence of women at men’s monasteries was one of the most important responses of the later sixth century church leaders to problems they perceived as due to lapses in the ascetical discipline of monks. However, the monastic rules generated in this period by the leaders of the reformed monastic movement such as Abraham of Kaskar are surprisingly silent on the issue of the presence of women among monks in general, and their long-term occupation of male monastic spaces.
This paper focuses on evidence from early medieval Syriac hagiographical literature such as the writings of Thomas of Marga, which indicates that there were violations of the Church of the East’s rulings on women living in men’s monasteries. The incidents involving these violations are treated in the context of the influence of pious mothers on sons who eventually become not only ascetically perfect monks, but also miracle-working saints. Special attention is given to the celebration in the Syriac sources of mothers who not only initiate their sons into the ascetical life intensive prayer and fasting, but whose sacrifices enable their sons to train in the interpretation of the holy scriptures for an extended period of time prior to their entrance into monastic communities. Finally, the paper will discuss the justification of the pious and scripturally-minded mother’s residence in a son’s monastic cell through the hagiographical device of connecting her to Biblical holy women such as Hannah.
|
Navigating a Forest of Idols: Jews and Cult Statues in Greco-Roman Antiquity
Program Unit: Art and Religions of Antiquity
Jason von Ehrenkrook, University of Michigan-Ann Arbor
This paper begins with a simple fact: Jews in Greco-Roman antiquity were living in a realm saturated with sculpted representations of the divine, cult statues that were woven into the fabric of daily life. How did they navigate this "forest of idols"? What did they think about this sculpted population? How did they respond to these iconic deities? The conventional answer, taking its cue from the Mosaic prohibition of images (the so-called second commandment), pivots on the language of antithesis, resistance, conflict, and enmity: Jews were iconoclasts, if not always literally, then at least literarily. Jews "destroyed" images with the derisive sneer of language and rhetoric, especially manifest in the numerous idol polemics from the period in question. While non-Jews foolishly ascribed power and divinity to images, the Jews alone recognized their true nature, nothing more than sticks and stones, impotent symbols of pagan absurdity. Iconic vitriol thus becomes a marker of Jewish exceptionalism. Focusing on a selection of Jewish sources from the late Hellenistic and early Roman periods, I will argue that complexity is lurking beneath the surface of this seemingly static hostility. More specifically, a close examination of Jewish discourses on statues within a comparative framework underscores the extent to which Jews were full participants in a broader cultural discourse, giving voice to what may be described as an iconic lingua franca in the Greco-Roman Mediterranean, a common language used to describe, assess and recount daily encounters with these sculpted artifacts.
|
Fleeing Sin: Embodied Conceptual Blends in 1 Corinthians
Program Unit: Cognitive Linguistics in Biblical Interpretation
Robert von Thaden, Jr., Mercyhurst College
Cognitive science approaches to religious studies recognize that human brains are located within, not apart from, human bodies. Human bodies are critical for understanding human cognition, since, as Raymond Gibbs argues, "embodiment provides the foundation for how people interpret their lives and the world around them" (Embodiment and Cognitive Science [New York: Cambridge University Press, 2005], 2). Any means for investigating the production and understanding of meaning by humanity must simply take into account the fact that humans are embodied, social agents. Conceptual integration theory (also called conceptual blending), the linguistic end of the cognitive science spectrum, takes embodied cognition seriously and thus provides a fruitful way to enact a full bodied analysis of biblical texts. In this paper I engage two passages from 1 Corinthians in which Paul exhorts the Corinthian Christ believers to "flee" from some detrimental activity – porneia (6:18) and idol worship (10:14). Paul's use of a spatial metaphor in these passages allows his rhetoric to achieve human scale. Gilles Fauconnier argues that an optimal conceptual blend has the following properties: "human scale, only two objects, simple concrete action, clear-cut outcome" ("Compression and Emergent Structure," Language and Linguistics 6 [2005]: 531). The blends created by Paul's rhetoric in these two sections of 1 Corinthians fulfill these properties with amazing proficiency. Moreover, not only does a general recognition of the importance of human embodiment help us to understand the metaphor of fleeing employed by Paul's rhetoric in these passages, but the conceptual networks Paul's arguments create push the hearer/reader to understand this metaphor through a special kind of embodiment – the Corinthian Christ believing community as the singular body of Christ. The identification of Corinthian bodies with the body of Christ provides Paul's use of this spatial metaphor with an emotional valence that strengthens Paul's rhetoric.
|
The Temple Persists: Collective Memories of Sacred Space, Ritual Practice, and the Polluting Power of Menstrual Blood
Program Unit: Religious Competition in Late Antiquity
Lily Vuong, Valdosta State University
This paper looks at the continued importance of the temple, the idea of sacrifice and sacred space, and the preoccupation with temple and priestly rhetoric in the third century by focusing on the idea of the polluting power of menstrual blood. In Hippolytus’ Apostolic Tradition female candidates for baptism must select a different day to be baptized in the event they are menstruating. In Dionysius of Alexandria’s letter and the Didascalia Apostolorum, menstrual blood is presented as being incompatible with the sacred space of the church and the sacred activities of the community (e.g., participation in prayer, study of Scripture and the Eucharist), respectively. Finally, in the apocryphal narrative the Protevangelium of James, Mary the mother of Jesus is required to leave the temple precinct because there is fear on the part of the priests that her approaching menstruation will pollute the temple of the Lord. I’ll explore how these Christian and “Jewish-Christian” texts written long after the destruction of the temple reconstitute, redescribe, and remember the sacred space of the Jerusalem temple and its ritual practices by examining the practice of excluding menstruating women from participating in the Eucharist and limiting their participation in the church.
|
The Old Testament through the Mouth of Jesus according to the Gospel of Matthew
Program Unit: Intertextuality in the New Testament
Erik Waaler, NLA School of Religion, Pedagogics and Intercultural Studies
The Jesus of Matthew is presented with multiple quotations from the Old Testament. Many authors touching on this phenomenon focus on the Old Testament in Matthew in general. However, there is a significant difference between how the author of Matthew present the Old Testament in his own summary statements, and the way the figurant Jesus present the Old Testament in the dominical sayings in Matthews text. This paper focus on the dominical sayings: The choice of OT texts for use, their introduction, and the way the OT is interpreted. It also takes the sitz im leben into consideration and evaluates the influence of the literary context, such as the difference between conflict dialogues with the Jews and sermons. A main focus is put on the Sermon on the Mount. It will be argued that whereas Matthew, in his authorial comments, put emphasis on the messianic fulfillment of prophesies; Jesus’ main focus is on the interpretation and application of the Mosaic Law. The main issue will be the literary reuse of the Old Testament, focusing on continuity and change.
|
The Intertextuality of First Enoch, Paul, and the Gospel of Matthew: Modeling Early Jewish Messianic Systems
Program Unit: Intertextuality in the New Testament
Jim Waddell, University of Michigan-Ann Arbor
“When the Son of Man comes in his glory, and all the angels with him, then he will sit on his glorious throne.” Intertextual links between First Enoch and the Gospel of Matthew have been widely recognized for over a century. These connections suggest conceptual relationships regarding messianic beliefs both in terms of their difference and their similarities. To understand these intertextual relationships between the Enoch literature and Matthew, one must also include Paul’s views of the messiah, developed in the period between the Book of the Parables of Enoch and the composition of the Gospels. Older critical approaches to Paul once drove a wedge between Paul’s views of a crucified and risen messiah as Apostle to the Gentiles and the kinds of Jewish intellectual messianic traditions we have in First Enoch and Matthew. More recent critical approaches have a renewed appreciation for reading Paul in his Jewish context. This study will explore connections between First Enoch, Paul, and the Gospel of Matthew by examining these three messianic systems on the basis of both intertextuality and conceptual developments of Jewish messianic belief in the first century CE.
|
Review of the Bible Illuminated
Program Unit: Ideology, Culture, and Translation
Matt Waggoner, Albertus Magnus
Review of the Bible Illuminated
|
"Septuagint Hermeneutics" and Greek Isaiah
Program Unit: Greek Bible
J. Ross Wagner, Princeton Theological Seminary
Interpreting a translation is not just different from interpreting an original work; it is much less certain an endeavor. Clarity about goals and methods is indispensable, as is a chastened sense of the limitations of one’s investigation. Not without reason, then, has Albert Pietersma predicted that "the hermeneutics of the Septuagint will become one of the central issues (if not the central issue) in the discipline for some time to come.” Pietersma and other advocates of the "Interlinear Paradigm" have proposed five working principles to guide Septuagint hermeneutics: (1) The principle of original text; (2) The principle of original meaning; (3) The principle of the parent text as arbiter of meaning; (4) The principle of translator's intent; (5) The principle of linguistic parsimony. This paper considers the usefulness and adequacy of these principles for investigating the Greek translation of Isaiah.
|
Reading the Gospel of Matthew Ecologically in Oceania
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Elaine M. Wainwright, University of Auckland
The 2009 United Nations Climate Change Conference in Copenhagen focused world attention on what had become a growing awareness internationally of the threat that industrialization and the squandering of Earth’s resources poses for all life on the planet. In the academic world, many different disciplines have taken up the challenge posed by the need for a consequent ecological ethic. For biblical scholars, this has entailed a reading of the biblical text anew but not always with attentiveness to the many different reading contexts with their unique ecological issues.
Oceania as a “Sea of Islands” is particularly under threat as many of its atoll nation-states face destruction of their homelands as sea levels rise and more severe storms threaten. As an Australian citizen, resident in New Zealand and working with many Pacific Islanders who know the urgency of the present ecological imperative, I propose in this paper to point to ways of reading the Gospel of Matthew ecologically in Oceania.
I will briefly address the shift to ‘ecological thinking’ that is necessary to read beyond the androcentrism which characterizes biblical studies and theology, highlighting aspects of such thinking that are particular to Oceania. The bulk of the paper will demonstrate how the use of ‘habitat’ as a critical category within the context of an eco-rhetorical reading of the text focused on the ecological texture of the text will facilitate new interpretations of selected Matthean texts. These interpretations will not only be shaped by ‘ecological thinking’ but will, in their turn, function to shape new ecological thinking into the future. I will argue that such contextual reading is an eco-ethical reading.
|
Healing a Centurion’s Servant: Reading Matt 8:5–13 in Light of Earth and Empire
Program Unit: Biblical Criticism and Literary Criticism
Elaine Wainwright, University of Auckland
Currently there are a number of ecological hermeneutics being developed which provide frameworks for reading biblical texts in light of the current ecological crisis and human violation of so many of Earth’s fragile eco-systems. In order that such readings contribute to the development of a new social imaginary that Lorraine Code calls ecological thinking, it is important that biblical scholars read not only texts explicitly encoding Earth but all texts ecologically. This paper seeks to address this imperative by turning the lens of an ecological hermeneutic onto the story of Jesus’ healing of the centurion’s servant in Matt 8:5-13. Initially, I will briefly outline an ecological hermeneutic and related methodology which will guide the reading of the Matthean text. The subsequent reading of the text will give attention to healing within an ecological hermeneutic and to this particular healing. This will be combined with an analysis of power which permeates this text and which is a key element in an ecological reading.
|
A Sufficient Grace: 2 Corinthians 11:21–12:10 in the Eastern Orthodox Liturgical Tradition
Program Unit: Bible in Eastern and Oriental Orthodox Traditions
James Buchanan Wallace, Christian Brothers University
This paper will examine the use of 2 Corinthians 11:21-12:10 in Greek and Russian Orthodox liturgical traditions. In this passage, Paul juxtaposes his ascent to the third heaven and paradise with his life of hardship, suffering, and weakness. The passage, minus 12:10, serves as the lectionary reading on the Feast of the Holy Apostles Peter and Paul, and this particular lectionary choice signals the importance of the passage for the Eastern Orthodox Church’s liturgical construction of Paul. This paper will examine how this passage proves important not only for this particular feast day but also for other times of the liturgical year. For example, the ikos for matins on the Exaltation of the Cross alludes clearly to 2 Cor 12:1-4. Moreover, the language of the passage features prominently in a hymn on the feast of St. Andrew the Fool for Christ, and in this case, the language is appropriated to describe St. Andrew rather than St. Paul. In addition to exploring how the passage proves important in the liturgical construction of Paul, the paper will investigate how various hymns and other readings in the liturgical year provide explicit or implicit interpretations of the passage and, in so doing, seek to shape the lives of those who hear, sing, chant, and pray in the Eastern Orthodox Churches.
|
Paul’s Catalogues of Suffering in 2 Corinthians as Ascetic Performances
Program Unit: Second Corinthians: Pauline Theology in the Making
James Buchanan Wallace, Christian Brothers University
This paper will examine Paul’s lists of suffering in 2 Corinthians through the lens of Richard Valantasis’s theory of Asceticism. In an influential article, Valantasis defines asceticism “as performances within a dominant social environment intended to inaugurate a new subjectivity, different social relations, and an alternative symbolic universe” (JAAR 63 (1995): 775-821; see 797). The catalogue of sufferings in 2 Cor 4:7-18 and 11:16-12:10 fit this definition well, and this lens proves helpful by highlighting the social implications of Paul’s rhetoric. By offering a rhetorical performance of his own suffering, Paul reinterprets suffering and physical deprivation as life and divine power. The rival missionaries, by contrast, rely on letters of recommendation, and hence on human approval, while disparaging Paul’s weakness. The rival missionaries thereby continue to validate the dominant culture’s assumptions about power and authority. By reinterpreting weakness and fragility as prerequisites for true life and divine power, Paul is not simply defending the legitimacy of his ministry but offering an ascetic performance that resists the dominant constructions of social power. Moreover, by aligning themselves with Paul and validating his reinterpretation of hardship, his audience is not merely affirming its loyalty to Paul but embarking upon an ascetic performance as well. By validating Paul’s interpretive performance, they, too, will be withdrawing from the dominant structures of power to develop an alternative communal identity prone to seeing the resurrecting power of God where the dominant culture sees only weakness, death, and despair. Moreover, this alternative identity should lead to the shaping of a community in which endurance, gentleness, and mutual care become the hallmarks of those who are truly powerful. While acknowledging an apologetic dimension of the rhetoric, this approach takes seriously Paul’s insistence that all he does is for the building up of the Corinthians (12:19; cf. 10:8; 13:10; 4:15).
Note: If there is interest in this paper specifically for the session on chapter 4, I will be glad to focus more heavily on 2 Cor 4:7-18 rather than 11:16-12:10.
|
When the Christ Just Won't Stick
Program Unit: Bible and Film
Richard Walsh, Methodist University
While critics lament scholars’ undisciplined discussion of Christ images in film, filmmakers do sometimes slather (other film) Christs onto their “heroes” provocatively. This intertextuality shifts the discussion from isolated (cruciform) visuals and (messiah/martyr) characterizations to the vagaries of hermeneutics and to the constructed nature of messiahs (heroes) (cf., e.g., Being There; The Life of Brian). In Donnie Darko, e.g., the titular hero is a violent, psychotic teenager who lives two lives. In the first, he narrowly escapes a bizarre death, becomes increasingly violent, and is finally responsible for his girl’s death. The film’s finale rewinds this story so that Donnie, in a second life, can accept the previously avoided death to save the girl. At a crucial moment, the filmmakers anoint the seemingly non-messianic Donnie by having him linger under a Halloween Frightmare movie marquee advertising The Evil Dead and The Last Temptation of Christ. Like Donnie, Scorsese’s Christ lives two lives and chooses death to become messianic. Joining the two, however, reconfigures both more as tortured, suicidal souls, than Christs. The Wrestler smears Christ even more blatantly. Its Randy the Ram is initially a Christ-figure only because he has a tattoo of Jesus’ head on his scarred back. In a seedy strip club, however, an aging dancer anoints Ram with Isa. 53 during a lap dance. For the dancer, the reference is to The Passion of the Christ, and Ram is a Christ figure because of his name, his suffering, and his hair. Despite the comedy, subsequent visuals further affix Christ imagery to Ram. This connection reduces the suffering of both to (entertaining) spectacle and the “heroes” to “One Trick Ponies.” In these cases, film’s Christ whitewash wears thin as its too visible application covers all too human “heroes.” In such intertexuality, what happens to the Gospel Christ?
|
(Carrying the Fire on) No Road for Old Horses
Program Unit: Bible and Popular Culture
Richard Walsh, Methodist University
Three “major” movies have been based on the novels of Cormac McCarthy: All the Pretty Horses; No Country for Old Men; and The Road. All are set in a post-apocalyptic or post-American Dream world and have an aura akin to that of Thomas Cole’s Expulsion from Eden. As the allusion to Cole (and to the American Dream) suggests, the nostalgic remythologizing in these fictions has a biblical cast. Critics often refer to McCarthy’s content and style as biblical, and the films have this tenor as well. Obvious biblical elements include the nostalgic quest to replace the lost tradition (Pretty Horses) or simply to live with its loss (No Country; Road). While this tenor is broadly mythic, not merely biblical, the films/novels also employ explicit biblical symbolism (e.g., Eden, exodus, and apocalypse). That the fictions’ quests are unrealized and that, therefore, God is absent from their worlds are less obvious biblical motifs. The fictions ask how one is to live in the absence of God and with thwarted promise. The films’ answer is unrelenting peasant stoicism in the face of fate and inexplicable evil and a call to “carry the fire” (in both No Country and Road). The latter expresses a tenuous hope in “the generations” (cf. the child god of Road and the dreams of No Country). This ethic is quite distinct from the typical American emphases of individualism and triumphant empire, and it may bear some similarity to “biblical” stories oft neglected in the dominant American myth/theology. Specifically, these fictions recall the similar fictional “worlds” of, e.g., the first wilderness generation, the absent Jesus at the end of Mark, the long Lukan road that does not bring the kingdom to Jerusalem; and a Revelation that is more dreams, than signs and wonders.
|
Revisiting the Synagogue-Basilica of Elche (Ilici), Spain
Program Unit: Archaeology of Religion in the Roman World
Robyn Faith Walsh, Brown University
A basilica in the ancient Roman city of Ilici (now Elche or Elx) has been a source of considerable controversy since its discovery in 1905. It is clear that this space, a large rectangular hall with an appended apse, was converted for Christian use at some stage in its history. A number of scholars have maintained that it was once a synagogue, based on three inscriptions found in its polychromatic mosaic floor employing terms thought to be self-evidently Judean (proseuche, archons and presbyteron). If true, this would make it the sole known diaspora synagogue from this period on the Iberian peninsula. Critics of this theory have often argued for the Christian use of these terms and have championed the site as the earliest Christian basilica in Spain. Due in large measure to improper excavation and cataloguing techniques, these inscriptions have long stood as the primary identifying feature of this site and their ambiguity has led to a scholarly deadlock. However, findings from a January 2009 site visit may shed some new light on a previously overlooked aspect of site— namely, the identification of a monochromatic mosaic repair in the northeast corner of the building which features what appears to be a menorah, badly damaged but still clearly visible. This apparent menorah, coupled with the mosaic inscriptions and a detailed re-examination of the stages of construction evident in the remains of the foundations of the building and the mosaic’s relevant figurative motifs, strengthen the argument that this structure was indeed likely a synagogue at one time. This presentation will review the extant archaeological evidence for this building and pose some new theories as to its stages and possible functions in light of this fresh re-evaluation of the evidence.
|
Irreconcilable Distances: A Challenge to the Assumed Authorial Unity of Luke and Acts
Program Unit: Book of Acts
Patricia Walters, Rockford College
This paper re-examines the universally held assumption that the gospel of Luke and the Acts of the Apostles were written-edited by a unitary author, traditionally known as “Luke.” Reassessment of the internal and external evidence for single authorship reveals a shakier foundation than previously thought and, hence, calls for further scrutiny.
A newly designed analysis of Luke and Acts suggests the existence of highly significant differences in prose style. In particular, selected from each book is a set of key passages that comprises the least contested authorial stratum, namely, seams and summaries. Functioning as literary sutures, seams and summaries unite texts or complexes of text and thereby provide prime “soil” for analysis.
Since these texts were composed in the first century (or probably second century, in the case of Acts), it is fitting to examine them for the presence of prose compositional conventions in use at that time, for example, hiatus, dissonance, prose rhythm, and structural elements.
Results of this fresh analysis show that prose compositional patterns in Luke and Acts deviate sharply and actually distinguish the two books’ authorship beyond a reasonable doubt. Although generally undisputed, the authorial unity of Luke and Acts must be called into question and the far-reaching implications of such a claim fully investigated.
|
Eliphaz’s Attitude toward Job in Job 4:2–11
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
John Walton Burnight, University of Chicago
It is widely held that Eliphaz affirms Job’s righteousness in his first speech (chapters 4-5), and only later accuses him of wrongdoing. Interpreters cite his opening words in 4:2-7, in particular, as evidence that Eliphaz is seeking to reassure his suffering friend. One prominent exegete, for example, remarks that Eliphaz “begins considerately, and proceeds with notable gentleness and courtesy,” while another writes that he “appears to concede that Job’s piety and conduct have been exemplary.” Given this “gentle” beginning, the subsequent emphasis on the punishment of the wicked in 4:8-11 has been viewed as puzzling and even mean-spirited by some commentators, but is generally explained as a contrast to Job’s own, more hopeful fate.
In this paper it is proposed that Eliphaz’s opening words are neither gentle nor reassuring, but rather sharp and accusatory. The references to Job’s “exhaustion” (4:2) and “reverence” (4:6), for example, do not indicate Eliphaz’s concern for his friend’s mental state and praise of his piety, respectively. Instead, they are tacit responses to Job’s complaints that he can find no “rest” (3:26) and that what he “feared has come upon him” (3:25): in essence, Eliphaz is implying that Job has brought his suffering on himself. This reading brings the tone of verses 1-7 more in line not only with what follows in verses 8-11, but also with the more explicit accusations of the friends in all of their subsequent speeches. It also explains Job’s angry denunciation in 6:14-18.
|
Mark as a Sectarian Document? An Investigation into Mark’s Views on the Law
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Timothy Wardle, Duke University
This paper will explore several ways in which the gospel of Mark may be understood as a Jewish sectarian document. Though Jewish sectarianism was a multi-faceted phenomenon, inclusive to all sectarian thinking were negative appraisals of the Jerusalem temple and differing interpretations of the Jewish law. Though this paper will not delve into Mark’s negative evaluation of the Jerusalem sanctuary and its chief priests, it is clear that on this issue Mark shares a strong commonality with other first century sectarian thinkers, most notably the covenanters at Qumran. But what of Mark’s view of the law? Throughout his gospel Mark has sprinkled hints that Jesus, and by extension Mark and his community, were also not among the mainstream in terms of Jewish legal interpretation. Drawing on passages such as Mark 2:1-3:6 and 7:1-23, I will argue that Mark’s elevation of the conflict between Jesus and the religious leaders of his day and embellishment of the legal issues at odds between these two parties points to a distinctively Markan view of the Jewish law. I will then tease out some of the implications of these legal disputes in order to more precisely situate the gospel of Mark in the broader world of Jewish sectarian thinking.
|
Does Temple Architecture Determine a Proper Sacrifice? The Case of the Jerusalem, Samaritan, and Oniad Temples
Program Unit: Sacrifice, Cult, and Atonement
Tim Wardle, Elon University
Though Josephus declared Jerusalem to be the home of the “one temple for the one God” (Ag. Ap. 2.193), this was decidedly untrue. In point of fact, several Jewish temples were constructed during the Second Temple period, with each appearing to conduct their own sacrificial system. In this paper I will compare the physical site of the Jewish temple in Jerusalem, on the one hand, with the Samaritan temple on Mount Gerizim and the Oniad temple at Leontopolis, on the other, and explore the ways in which the configuration of sacred space likely played a role in legitimating the sacrificial systems which occurred at these latter two temples. While the archaeological remains and literary evidence for both of these temples is uneven, the extant material suggests that the ideological struggles these two disparate communities waged with the Jerusalem temple and its priestly authorities had architectural repercussions, and the apparent replication of the Jerusalem temple in these other locales likely played an integral role in validating the sacrifices performed in each respective temple.
|
Paul's Gospel of the Empty Tomb: The Resurrection in 1 Corinthians 15
Program Unit: Extent of Theological Diversity in Earliest Christianity
James Ware, University of Evansville
According to one influential reconstruction of Christian origins, the earliest Christ followers understood Jesus' resurrection as a non-physical or spiritual event. In a later development, Mark invented the story of the empty tomb, and at a yet later stage Luke and John introduced the accounts of the disciples encountering, touching and eating with the physically risen Jesus. The major piece of evidence undergirding this account of Christian origins is Paul's purported understanding of the resurrection as involving a spiritual rather than a physical body. I will argue in this paper that this reconstruction is founded on a misreading of Paul, in particular of the key text 1 Corinthians 15, and is thus without historical foundation. Paul, like all other Christ followers of the first generation known to us, believed that Jesus had been physically and bodily raised from the tomb.
|
The Qumran Community as a Temple, or Not
Program Unit: Qumran
Cecilia Wassen, Uppsala University
The importance of the metaphor of the Qumran community as a temple, or sanctuary, in the Dead Sea Scrolls has been thoroughly examined by scholars. Although the metaphor of temple is spelled out explicitly only in a few documents (e.g., 1QS VIII-IX; XI; 4QFlor 1-2 i 6) it makes up a root metaphor from which a system of metaphors emerge. As a dominant root metaphor it had a deep impact on the construction of the identity of the sect and on the organization of communal life. But how does the image of the community as a temple compare to the rich flora of speculations about the temple(s) elsewhere in the Qumran literature (e.g., 11QT; 1QM; CD)? Many commentators suggest that the Qumran community considered itself as a substitute for the Jerusalem temple, and as an interim temple the community was preparing itself for participation in a future, purified cult. Yet the conflicting imageries of temple in the texts are seldom noted. I will argue that the two domains, expectations of a future temple and the descriptions of the community as a metaphorical temple, cannot easily be harmonized. Instead, the two concepts are in tension with each other whereby an emphasis on the one diminishes the impact of the other. It is therefore not surprising that 1QS, the document that develops the temple metaphor most elaborately, does not entail any evidence of expectations of a future, physical temple. In my presentation I will highlight the conflicting ideologies of the temples that we encounter in the Dead Sea Scrolls. Specifically, my paper will address two questions: First, what does the metaphor of the community as a temple mean in the Qumran texts? Second, how does the temple metaphor compare with other views on the temple?
|
Cosmic Hierarchy and Rebellion in 1 Corinthians 15
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Emma Wasserman, Rutgers University
Scholars like Alexander Koyre and Stanley Stowers have argued that ancient
Mediterranean writers understand the cosmos as a closed hierarchy of different
substances, realms of being, and value. With few exceptions, a wide range of ancient
texts from philosophical cosmologies, astrological texts, Greek myths, to Jewish
apocalypses and wisdom literature share organizing assumptions about the cosmos as a
finite, cascading series of different realms, levels, and types of beings. These shared
premises facilitate the creative synthesis and adaptation of different traditions but such
syntheses in turn frustrate simplistic scholarly categorizations of traditions into
oppositional categories like Judaism versus Hellenism or Jewish apocalyptic versus
Greek intellectual traditions. This paper argues that Jewish apocalyptic inflections of
more basic hierarchical assumptions shed light on 1 Cor 15:23–28. Though reflecting
broader ancient Mediterranean premises, texts like The Book of the Watchers, The
Astronomical Books, and Daniel 10 assert the ultimate perfection, power, and rule of a
single all-powerful being while using subordinate realms and agents to contain and
delimit rebellion and conflict. Rather than envisioning a cosmos in rebellion against
God, the texts imagine instances of rebellion as temporary aberrations, problems created
and resolved by subordinates, and they extend this hierarchical vision into the human
sphere by differentiating a special group as protected from bad agents by their allegiance
to good ones. Such patterns illuminate texts like 1 Cor 15:23–28 as a battle between
super-human beings that restores and perfects the larger cosmic order while the true
Christ followers are protected from harm. Though many scholars understand Paul’s
thought in terms of apocalyptic dualisms, I conclude that seeming dualisms such as that
between insiders and outsides, the present and the future, what is and what should be,
also reflect and generate these larger hierarchical patterns.
|
A Comparative Textual Analysis of P4 and P64–67
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Tommy Wasserman, Lund University
In a 1997 article T. C. Skeat suggested that P4 comes from the same four-gospel codex as P64+67. Subsequently, Peter Head and Scott Charlesworth have argued against this identification, mainly on the basis of codicological data * it is still possible that they were copied by the same scribe. However, no one has made a comparative textual analysis of these papyri. In his original publication, Skeat included a brief analysis of the text of P4, providing "some basic facts." Unfortunately his analysis is unsatisfactory in two ways: it concerns only P4 and it is based only on deviances from the Textus Receptus. This paper presents a fresh textual analysis of P4 and P64+67, in order to examine the textual quality, transmission character, and the nature of the readings in these papyri. The textual data supplements codicological and palaeograhical data that will help us to situtate these papyri in a sociohistorical context.
|
How the Animal Groans: An Examination of Animal Laments in Israelite Literature
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Douglas Watson, Emory University
The book of Joel opens with a lament-themed speech (1:2-2:17), encouraging the people of Jerusalem to 'return' to the Lord through cultic mourning rituals. The prophet/poet details in graphic images how the natural world is caught up in the devastation wrought by the deity--the trees dry up (1:12a); the vines wither (1:12b); the grain is destroyed (1:10); and even the heavens and earth tremble at the deity's destruction (2:10). One of the more striking images of Joel's rhetoric, though, is that of the wild animals (1:20) and the ground itself (1:10) joining the prophet in lamenting the devastation. Though the created order is invoked to join in praise routinely in the psalms (Pss 65:12-13; 66:1-4; 148; 150:6), the image of the created order joining in mourning rites is less pervasive. This essay explores the theme of a created order that laments, beginning with the book of Joel but drawing on other laments from the Bible and the ancient Near East. An attempt will be made to retrieve the voice of the created order in Israel's laments, presenting a theological challenge that resists the exploitation and devastation of the natural world. To gain purchase on this issue, the essay will focus on Joel 1:18-20, particularly with an eye toward identifying the speaker of v. 19.
|
Socio-rhetorical Commentary on the Johannine Epistles
Program Unit: Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity
Duane F. Watson, Malone University
This session is dedicated to examining the new contributions to the interpretation of particular texts facilitated by socio-rhetorical interpretation as this has been developed by the Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity Group under the leadership of Vernon Robbins. Three scholars engaged in writing commentaries for the Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity Series (Deo Press) will present what they believe to be the fresh perspectives or insights into particular passages from Colossians, Ephesians, and 1 John developed as a result of engaging the passage through socio-rhetorical interpretation. Respondents who have written commentaries from more traditional hermeneutical approaches will assess the relevant section of the presenter's commentary. The session as a whole seeks to nurture dialogue between practitioners of socio-rhetorical interpretation and scholars located in more traditional methodologies within the larger guild.
|
A Short Study of Greek Diminutives
Program Unit: Biblical Greek Language and Linguistics
Jonathan M. Watt, Geneva College
Diminutive lexical variants, frequently formed by suffixation, are common occurrences in the world’s languages. Substantial studies specifically addressing Greek diminutives were published by Walter Petersen (Greek Diminutives in –ION, 1910) and Donald C. Swanson (“Diminutives in the Greek New Testament,” 1958) with regard to the classical and biblical literature, respectively; other grammarians also have commented briefly on the same. Swanson concluded that the New Testament employs diminutive forms more frequently than previously thought, and he suggested that Petersen’s (and Moulton-Howard’s 1929 Grammar) assessment of diminutive semantics could best be handled under four classifications/meanings (deteriorative, endearing, smallness, and “true/faded”).
This paper compares Swanson’s four-fold classification – published a half-century ago, and interacting with a work now dated by a century – with a selection of more recent cross-linguistic studies. It will discuss interpretive relevance of the New Testament diminutive variants that often occur with familial (e.g. paidion, teknion, thugatrion) and animal (e.g. probation, kunarion, strouthion) words. It then shows there is considerable positive correlation between Petersen’s and Swanson’s inductive conclusions about Greek diminutives and what others have observed about these forms in modern languages, while adding the suggestion that diminutives may function as cultural commonality markers for native language speakers.
|
The Scripturalization of Torah in the Persian Period
Program Unit: Orality, Textuality, and the Formation of the Hebrew Bible
James W. Watts, Syracuse University
Much evidence indicates that it was in the Persian period that Pentateuchal materials were transformed into a scripture, the Torah. The story of Ezra reading the scroll of law in Nehemiah 8 exemplifies that transformation by its description of his manipulation of the physical scroll, his oral reading of it before the people of Jerusalem, and his arrangement for its professional translation/interpretation by Levites. These rituals have characterized the function of the Torah from that time forward, but they are also typical of the treatment accorded other texts widely regarded as religious scriptures. Studies in comparative scriptures should therefore be employed for investigations of the scripturalization of Torah and other biblical texts. A functional analysis of the use of contemporary scriptures in iconic, performative and semantic dimensions sheds considerable light on the transformation of Torah that took place in the Persian period.
|
Reconstructing Mark: Problems with Getting behind the Text
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Joseph Weaks, Brite Divinity School
In Synoptic Studies, often the examination of a pericope includes our attempts to get behind the text. We rely upon standard criteria for reconstructing source texts. However, we need to improve our capability to assess the reliability of a text that has been reconstructed from potentially independent witnesses that used it as a source. For example, how well could we reconstruct Mark based upon its use in Matthew and Luke?
This paper will survey the findings of a dissertation which established a complete reconstruction of Mark from the evidence in Matthew and Luke. The results come from structural analysis and a comparative stylographic statistical comparison between the fully reconstructed Mark and the canonical text of Mark. Assessing what is lost in the reconstruction, what is introduced, and what is changed in relation to canonical Mark helps us understand the limitations of source analysis within the Synoptic gospels.
Among the findings is the recognition that a reconstructed text will not reflect many of the dominant features of its predecessor, and likewise, a reconstructed text will bear features unique to its form that have no relevance to the original text it approximates. These findings point to strong implications for how we assess the primitivity of one tradition against another, the presumptions made regarding an underlying textual form of a given pericoope, as well as the reliability of the text of a reconstructed Q source as it is used in other historical inquiry into early Christianity.
|
The Rules of the Game: History and Historical Method in the Context of Faith
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
Robert Webb, McMaster University
Numerous scholars who engage in historical Jesus research have some type of faith perspective with respect to the subject of their inquiry--including myself. This may be one of the factors motivating our personal interest in the subject. But the question arises, should this presupposition affect or alter our understanding of either the concept of history or our application of historical method? This paper will respond to this question in the negative. The “rules of the game” of history should preclude historians who have a faith perspective altering either the concept of history and or historical method.
|
History and Historical Method in the IBR Jesus Project
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Robert Webb, McMaster Divinity College
*
|
The Cambridge Introduction to Biblical Hebrew
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Brian L. Webster, Dallas Theological Seminary
A presentation of the TekScroll program and the pedagogical and linguistic theories that shaped The Cambridge Introduction to Biblical Hebrew. CIBH intends to maximize comparisons that can be made within Hebrew, explain forms from a minimal number of syllabic principles, capitalize on the moving graphics possible with today’s computer programs, provide enormous amounts of available practice items, and stay flexible for the varying requirements of teachers in their programs.
|
Teaching with Meta-questions
Program Unit: Teaching Biblical Studies in an Undergraduate Liberal Arts Context
Jane S. Webster, Barton College
In seminaries and graduate schools, students study the Bible for a specific purpose, such as to prepare sermons, to think theologically, or to conduct historical-critical research. Biblical Studies in the undergraduate Liberal Arts context, however, is not so purpose-driven, especially in a diverse student population. Its value lies mainly in cultural literacy and the development of critical thinking. But as Barbara Walvoord (2008) has demonstrated, students take introductory courses in Religion, not to learn how to think critically as their instructors had long imagined, but to make personal meaning. Can teachers engage all students with a critical question that will be meaningful for them in their own particular context?
One option is to design a course that intentionally starts with a "meta-question" and leads students through the discipline into self-discovery. Such "meta-questions" might include: Why do people suffer? What can we know to be true? What is authority and how do people get it? How do we make choices? Instructors often have a "meta-question" in the background of their course design but it is obscured in the details of the syllabus or de-contextualized from the rest of the curriculum; students are left searching for meaning through the gaps in their education. This paper will describe a course called “The Life and Teachings of Jesus” designed around such a question: “What is truth?” The paper will reflect on what worked and what did not, offering suggestions for further experiments.
|
The Chronicler’s View of Providence as Seen in Isaac Kalimi’s Writings Dealing with the Use of Chronicles in Religious Ritual
Program Unit: Midrash
David Weisberg, Hebrew Union College - Jewish Institute of Religion
Citations from Chronicles in post-Biblical Jewish Liturgical Texts brought together by Isaac Kalimi in his "The Retelling of Chronicles . . ." highlight a “complete and coherent collection of verses” (p. 179) used by those who composed the Jewish prayer-book.
We want to study Kalimi’s organization of these passages in order to identify an emerging “reverence toward the book” (p. 186) by liturgists.
|
Unraveling Mixed Metaphors in Jeremiah: Theology or Poetry?
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Andrea Weiss, Hebrew Union College-Jewish Institute of Religion
One of the remarkable features of biblical poetry, particularly in the Prophets, is the frequent juxtaposition of diverse metaphors for God and Israel. While a number of existing studies have considered theological reasons for this phenomenon, this paper will explore how the mechanics of biblical poetry contributes to the combination of different metaphors within a given passage. For example, to what extent do the dynamics of poetic parallelism influence the prevalence of mixed metaphors in biblical poetry? To begin to answer this question, this paper will examine selected passages in the book of Jeremiah that contain multiple metaphors for God or Israel within the same or subsequent verses.
|
Metaphoricity Indicators in Biblical Poetry and Prose
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible and Cognate Literature
Andrea L. Weiss, Hebrew Union College-Jewish Institute of Religion
In the 2008 book, Metaphors Dead and Alive, Sleeping and Waking, Cornilia Müller argues that metaphoricity is a dynamic property of a lexical item, not a static quality. She observes that the perception of metaphoricity largely depends on context, on the presence of “verbal activation devices” that in various ways call attention to the metaphorical nature of a given utterance. This paper will examine how this notion of “metaphoricity indicators” plays out in a select sample of biblical metaphors, some found in poetic texts and others in prose narrative.
|
Sacred Space: The Fig-Tree in Mark in Mark 11:12–14 and 20–21
Program Unit: Art and Religions of Antiquity
Annette Weissenrieder, San Francisco Theological Seminary
I will attempt to reconcile the “literal interpretation” with an “intertextual or symbolic interpretation” by utilizing an emblematic interpretation (emblematische Interpretation). Examination of material artifacts bearing images and texts will demonstrate that in Roman antiquity the fig-tree is encountered in relation to foundation myths. Stemming from legends about Aeneas and about Romulus and Remus, these foundation myths were in a special way again taken up in the rule of Augustus. The association of the fig-tree image with the founders of Rome is especially striking on coins, which are documented in the first century B.C. and the first century A.D. represent a particularly well defined tradition and which are documented as late as the time of Alexander Severus.
The fig-tree can appear in combination with the founding fathers to stand for Rome, but can also by itself refer as a symbol to the foundation sagas. Thus fig-trees became an emblem which was appeared as the so-called “holy tree” in the Roman Forum at four locations. We can see the meaning of the fig-tree for the 1st. century A.D. in a specific locale, as well as the background of the story in the legends about Rome’s founding fathers. From this, the story of the withered fig-tree might have been located in Rome rather than in Palestine and refer as a symbol to the founding fathers to stand for Rome rather than to the Holy Temple of Jerusalem.
|
The Kairos, The Awakening: Pauline Soteriology in Nero's Rome
Program Unit: Pauline Theology
Larry Welborn, Fordham University
Invited Paper
|
Studying, Translating, and Transmitting the “Orality” (Oral-Aural Dimension) of Scripture, with Two Case Studies: Solomon’s Song and John’s Apocalypse
Program Unit: Bible Translation
Ernst R. Wendland, University of Stellenbosch
This paper undertakes a broadly based exploratory study that focuses on the manifold subject of “orality” as it pertains to the contemporary analysis, translation, transmission, and engagement of the ancient texts of Scripture. After a brief survey of some notable past and present works in this broad interdisciplinary field, I will turn to a presentation of several of the main areas of current controversy, coupled with a selection of the major challenges that confront researchers and practitioners alike, especially those who are engaged in the interlingual, cross-cultural, oral-aural oriented communication of the Bible. These topics are then considered in more concrete terms with reference to a pair of key passages found in the Song of Songs (ch. 8) and Revelation (ch. 1). The preceding overview should be sufficient to stimulate a concluding discussion concerning any outstanding points that require some clarification, correction, and/or complementation.
|
Tokens of Mystery? Redescribing Roman Exotica in Terms of Social Practices and Material Signatures
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
Heidi Katherine Wendt, Brown University
Plutarch warns that dressing the part of an Isiac cult initiate does not a true initiate make, just as one should not presume that every person garbed as a philosopher, in fact, is. When Apuleius issues his apologia against practicing magic he first proffers a convoluted etymology of the term magus – which, he explains, is a priest possessing specialist knowledge, but also a figure who illicitly manipulates immortal beings, ‘you know, like a philosopher’ [sic] – then produces tokens he has received as an initiate into various mysteries. Lucian takes the very blurriness and cachets of these categories as the starting point for his most scathing satires of Roman society.
These preoccupations with negotiating a ‘Roman’ landscape inundated with ‘foreign’ cultural commodities elucidate entrepreneurial figures, strategies, and material conditions involved in massaging such products into coherent and specialized, if idiosyncratic, new cultural offerings. My paper considers instances of exotic bricolage in order to tease out dynamics underlying the apparent fungibility, even rivalry, between phenomena classed variously as mystery cults, exotic wisdom, oriental religions, and philosophies. The processes whereby attempted cultural innovations actually engendered ‘religious’ or intellectual groups with regular contours, members, and leadership figures involved considerable social work on the ground. Against projects trained narrowly upon the inaccessible mental content (sc. beliefs and experiences) of these groups, I advocate a redescription grounded in their distinctive social practices and material signatures.
|
Paganism Must Really End, and Not Because Theodosius Says So! Methodological Implications of the Term “Pagan” in Modern Academic Vocabulary
Program Unit: North American Association for the Study of Religion
Heidi Wendt, Brown University
We all know whence the term “pagan” came, about its polemical past, imprecision, and explanatory impotence. Nevertheless, scholars of the imperial Mediterranean world continue to invoke the term rather uncritically in the absence of a definitive substitute for naming and describing the complex religious fabric in that world. Whereas the terms “Christianity” and “Judaism” now enjoy more subtle categorical nuances, our so-called pagans seem to have fewer advocates. Rather than proffering a thorough genealogy of paganus—a task executed invaluably in recent work—this paper addresses methodological implications of using a collective catchall for the diverse religious practices and institutions of the majority Mediterranean world. Bracketing all religious phenomena that are not Christian or Judean (rubrics not without their own baggage and debates) as pagan, even for the sake of convenience, encourages us to ride roughshod over practical subtleties ripe for comparative work, for theorizing religious innovation, and more generally, for enriching Mediterranean social history. In studies of early Christianity “pagan” fabricates a holism that can too easily, perhaps only, be cast as the villainous opponent for an emerging group whose own coherence is optimistic at best. The responsible historical work entailed in delineating consistently between actual religious phenomena and polemical labels ultimately positions scholars of late antiquity to explain with greater sophistication the strategic appropriation of this term when pagan religion does emerge as a coordinated contender-in-kind with Christianity and Judaism.
|
Popular Reading: Reception in Africa
Program Unit: Latino/a/e and Latin American Biblical Interpretation
Gerald West, University of KwaZulu-Natal
Popular Reading: Reception in Africa
|
Senzenina? From Lament to Restoration in Job 42:10–17 and in the Context of HIV and AIDS
Program Unit: Biblical Criticism and Literary Criticism
Gerald West, University of KwaZulu-Natal
Senzenina? What have we done? This haunting, lamenting, protesting, resisting song has been sung at funerals in South Africa for too long. Deaths due to apartheid gave birth to this song, and deaths due to AIDS have nurtured its words and rhythms after liberation. What have we done? Like Job, this paper will argue, those who sing this song are interrogating themselves, God, and their local communities. The public articulation of lament, this paper will go on to argue, enables not only the afflicted individual and God to reconsider, but also enables the local community to reassess their stigmatising attitudes towards the afflicted with HIV. Though we are told in 42:10 that "the Lord restored the fortunes of Job", God actually does nothing directly. Job is restored by his community. Working with groups of organised HIV-positive people in KwaZulu-Natal, the epicentre of the HIV pandemic in South Africa, we will reflect together on the capacity of public lament to reorient the community, enabling it to turn from stigmatising and discriminating against those to HIV-positive, embracing them and restoring them to community.
|
How Jewish Is Esther? Or: How Is Esther Jewish? Tracing Ethnic and Religious Identity in a Diaspora Narrative
Program Unit: Social Sciences and the Interpretation of the Hebrew Scriptures
Anne-Mareike Wetter, Universiteit Utrecht
‘Esther seems to be Jewish in a sense more ethnic than religious’ – this quote from Carey A. Moore’s commentary in the AB still expresses the general consensus about the Hebrew version of this narrative. More recently, scholars such as Sidnie White Crawford and Katrina L. Larkin have reached much the same conclusion – in their and many other analyses of the narrative, the lack of overt references to the God of Israel in Esther is regarded as sufficient evidence to identify the ubiquitous 'yehudi' as an ethnic term. This consensus is unexpected – after all, the fervent debate over the concept of ‘ethnicity’ in the social sciences seems to preclude any such clear-cut conclusions. It comes as no surprise, then, that a precise definition of ethnicity is often conspicuously absent in extant readings of Esther, resulting in rather vague, generalizing statements. This paper is an attempt to consistently apply sociological conceptualizations of ethnicity to the book of Esther. Basing myself on the (slightly updated) definition of an ethnie developed by Richard Schermerhorn, I trace notions such as ‘common ancestry’, ‘shared historical memories’, ‘homeland’, and ‘solidarity’ in the text. Throughout this analysis, I also look for hints of intersectionality between ethnicity and other aspects of identity. This leads me to understand the self-designation 'yehudi' as a term that is indeed close to current definitions of ethnicity, but also subtly touches upon a religious layer. Surprisingly, this religious layer becomes visible precisely by reading the text through an ‘ethnic’ lens - not in an incidental referral to some benevolent higher power, but rather in the pervasive use of intertextual allusions to the cultural religious memory of Israel.
|
Who Is Pleasing the King? Eunuchs, Queens and Drag Queens in Apocalyptic Esther
Program Unit: LGBTI/Queer Hermeneutics
Kelly Whitcomb, Vanderbilt University
This study examines the boundary transgressions in the Greek apocalyptic version of Esther. With the understanding that boundary transgression is typically problematic in apocalyptic literature, this paper will attempt to answer two major questions. First, where do boundary transgressions occur in the text? In asking this question, both the types of boundaries which are or are not transgressed, as well as how the text rhetorically constructs these boundaries will be investigated. Second, what role does the apocalyptic genre play in conjunction with the literary and rhetorical aspects of boundary transgressions? This question will be undertaken with the assumption that the Greek apocaplytic version is distinct from the Hebrew version, and thus the boundary transgressions at times are played out differently and take on different meanings. Such boundary transgressions can be informed by queer theory which challenges heteronormative assumptions about gender. With this in mind, this study will how the text of Esther destabilizes the interconnected social constructs of identity and gender; thus, a queer reading of the text can inform both our understanding of the text, as well as our own social presuppositions about gender and identity.
|
Pedagogical Iconoclasm: The Role of the Upper-Level Seminar in the Context of Undergraduate Religious Studies Programs
Program Unit: Teaching Biblical Studies in an Undergraduate Liberal Arts Context
Benjamin White, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
How does one move a Religious Studies major from the simplistic, reified, and always deceptive, scholarly narratives of an introductory course in New Testament (or Hebrew Bible) toward the skills needed to engage the primary sources in all of their difficulties? Pedagogical iconoclasm is the role of the upper-level seminar. But how should one structure such a seminar to foster these critical skills? This paper shares some of the successes and failures I have experienced in the past year as a first-time instructor of an upper-level seminar on “Paul and Early Pauline Traditions” at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. The course has three goals. By the end of the semester, my students, ideally, 1) attain a high-degree of proficiency in researching and writing for the field of New Testament and Early Christianity; 2) develop an understanding of the interrelationship between the historical-critical study of Paul and the ideology of his interpreters (both modern and ancient); and 3) master the contents and background issues pertaining to each of the “Pauline” texts and traditions they encounter. This paper includes reflections on course organization, assignments, and evaluation as they relate to developing in undergraduates the required bag of tools for becoming successful, life-long students of Biblical texts.
|
Hearing Galatians 3:28c for the First Time: Gender, the Galli, and the Northern/Southern Galatia Debate
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Benjamin White, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
Scholarship on Galatians, historically, has focused its energy on the relationship between Paul’s gospel and that of his opponents. One consequence of the opponent-driven approach is that it is normally pursued at the expense of the primary audience of the letter: Paul’s Galatian converts from paganism. The last decade, however, has yielded an increasing interest in the formerly pagan audience of Galatians. Studies by Thomas Witulski, Susan Elliott, Clinton Arnold, and Justin Hardin attempt to read the language of Galatians in light of various aspects of pagan religion in Galatia. With this recent shift toward an audience-driven approach, new questions are on the table. This paper asks the following: Does the specific location of Paul’s Galatian converts affect their understanding of Galatians 3:28c: “there is no longer male and female”? The Northern vs. Southern Galatia debate has a long-standing history. But too often this debate is limited to Pauline chronology. Through an exploration of the material remains of the Mother Goddess Cult in Antioch, Iconium, Lystra and Derbe, in contrast to the remains in regional Galatia, I will argue that her cults in these Roman colonies were performed without the presence the emasculated galli. This was no coincidence, but driven by a Roman ideology of gender, causing the more “gender-bending” aspects of the cult to disappear from its manifestations in these colonies. These findings should bear on any reading of Galatians that sees references to Attis or the galli lurking beneath the text. More broadly, I will argue that attempts to explore the pagan environment of Paul’s converts in Galatians should be sensitive to the Northern/Southern Galatia debate. This is not just a problem for Pauline chronology. There are cultural and religious differences that are relevant to how the earliest hearers of Galatians would have received Paul’s letter.
|
The Building History of the Ostia Synagogue: New Evidence from the UT Excavations
Program Unit: Archaeology of Religion in the Roman World
L. Michael White, University of Texas at Austin
Since 2001 new study and excavations of the Ostia Synagogue have been undertaken by a team from The University of Texas. The project operates under the auspices of the Soprintendenza per i Beni Archeologici di Ostia and the Italian Ministry of Culture, and is affiliated with the American Academy at Rome. The first several seasons undertook a GIS survey of the entire area around the synagogue and detailed masonry analysis of all excavated remains (2002-2004). Three seasons of excavations (2005, 2007, and 2009) and intervening seasons of lab study have now opened and evaluated 22 new trenches in the synagogue complex. These are the first stratigraphic excavations of the complex. Several new findings may now be reported concerning building phases, construction methods, and evidence of new structural features not previously known or reported from the 1960’s excavations. Based on numismatic finds and ceramics analysis, we are now able to establish a provisional phasing and chronology for the building from first usage to construction of the synagogue proper and to subsequent stages of renovation lasting into the 6th cent. ce. The first phase of usage as a synagogue edifice seems to be no earlier than the beginning of the 3rd cent. ce.
|
One Half of His Great Office and Employment’: The Call to Preach in Bishops’ Instructions to Clergy in the Post-restoration Church of England
Program Unit: Academy of Homiletics
Raewynne J. Whiteley, George Mercer School of Theology
*
|
Peace with God and the Pax Deorum: Hearing Romans 5:1 in Rome
Program Unit: Romans through History and Cultures
Jason A. Whitlark, Baylor University
The Old Testament concept of shalom has often been proposed as the background for understanding Paul’s declaration of “peace with God” in Rom 5:1. The language of Paul’s declaration and the structure of his argument from 1:18-4:25 have closer affinities to the Roman imperial boast of a renewed pax deorum. This article attempts to hear Paul’s statement in Rom 5:1 against its imperial background. Such an examination will demonstrate certain theological, sociological, and political implications Paul’s gospel had for his Christian audience living in Rome.
|
The Apostles and the Spirit as Witnesses in Luke-Acts and the Johannine Writings
Program Unit: Formation of Luke and Acts
Timothy Wiarda, Golden Gate Baptist Theological Seminary
Jesus’ statement that both the Paraclete and the disciples will testify to him (John 15:26-27) is strikingly similar to Peter’s declaration in Acts 5:32, “We are witnesses to these things and so is the Holy Spirit.” Both passages set the witness of the apostles (disciples in John’s terminology) and that of the Spirit side by side, and both express directly and succinctly a theme that plays a major role within the larger bodies of literature in which they appear. Luke reveals the importance he attaches to this theme by the way he structures his narrative of the birth of the church at the beginning of Acts, juxtaposing the account of selection of Matthias, with its heavy stress on the apostles and their role, and that of the outpouring of the Spirit at Pentecost. Further evidence of Luke’s interest in the Spirit and apostolic testimony lies scattered throughout the rest of Acts. In the case of the Johannine writings, the theme announced in John 15:26-27 is developed most fully in 1 John, through a series of passages that begins with the opening affirmation of history-grounded witness to Jesus (1:1-4) and culminates with the description of the threefold (or is it in effect twofold?) witness of Spirit, water, and blood (5:6-8).
The relationship between the Lukan and Johannine writings continues to be debated, with the discussion usually focusing on the two Gospels. While it will not resolve questions about dependence or influence or the direction of influence, a comparison of the way each corpus emphasizes and develops the theme of the Spirit’s witness vis-à-vis that of the original disciples offers one additional source of light on these matters.
|
The Unspeakable Mysterion in Mark and the Unveiled Mysteria in Matthew and Luke
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Peter Wick, Ruhr-University of Bochum
In Mark the mystery of the kingdom “is given” to the disciples of Jesus (Mk 4:11), whereas in Mt 13:11 and Lk 8:10 the mysteries of the kingdom “are given to know” to the disciples. In opposite to Mark the mysteries do not remain a secret for the disciples. They comprehend them. These secrets are social secrets (only secrets outside the group). But Mark’s secret is an epistemic one (nobody can comprehend it; cf. 4:27). This distinctness of Mark is not always considered in commentaries. But the difference is eminent: In Matthew and Luke the disciples know the mysteries of the kingdom, whereas in Mark they do not – because it is only possible to receive it and to see it (in the sense of a deeper insight; cf. Mk 4:24).
In this paper I propose that in the centre of the whole gospel of Mark there is the unspeakable mystery of the kingdom. It reveals itself as a way (to the followers of the way of Jesus Christ) and as a power (the power of resurrection: through death to life). But it does not reveal itself as knowledge. It is – in contrast to Matthew and Luke – not knowable, but it functions as the key for all deeper knowledge. Jesus often rebukes his disciples for their lack of understanding. They have the key and they do not use it. At the end of this gospel the three women see the unspeakable power of resurrection at the grave and cannot speak. The observations that led to the theory of the “Messianic Secret” are part of the central secret of the kingdom. In Matthew and Luke we can observe a conscious strategy of changing the epistemic secret of Mark into social mysteries. In reworking the secret of Mark they generate deep theological differences.
|
Martyr Theology in Hellenistic Judaism and Paul's Conception of Jesus' Death in Romans 3:21–26
Program Unit: Function of Apocryphal and Pseudepigraphal Writings in Early Judaism and Early Christianity
Jarvis J. Williams, Campbellsville University
This paper offers a contribution to two questions to which scholars continue to give attention: namely, did the Martyr Theology of Hellenistic Judaism, most explicit in 4 Maccabees, shape Paul’s conception of Jesus’ death in Romans 3:21-26? If so, does Martyr Theology provide any support that Paul conceives of Jesus’ death in Romans 3:21-26 as an atoning sacrifice and as a saving event for Jews and Gentiles? My thesis is that the Martyr Theology of Hellenistic Judaism, which is most prevalent in 4 Maccabees and which arose during the Hellenistic crisis under the reign of Antiochus Epiphanes IV, shaped Paul’s conception of Jesus’ death in Romans 3:21-26 and that Martyr Theology provided Paul with the fundamental (not the only) concepts that he needed to present Jesus’ death as an atoning sacrifice and as a saving event in Romans 3:21-26 to his Hellenistic Jewish and Gentile audience.
I develop five arguments to argue the thesis. (1) A Martyr Theology tradition existed in Hellenistic Judaism outside of 4 Maccabees. (2) The authors of 2 and 4 Maccabees most clearly develop a Martyr Theology and interpret the Jewish martyrs to function as atoning sacrifices for Israel’s sin. (3) The authors of 2 and 4 Maccabees interpret the martyrs’ deaths as a saving event for Israel. (4) Paul ascribes to Jesus’ death language that closely parallels and is similar to the martyrs’ deaths in 2 and 4 Maccabees. (5) The parallels with and similarities between the martyrs’ deaths in 2 and 4 Maccabees and Paul’s presentation of Jesus’ death in Romans 3:21-26 offer evidence that the Martyr Theology tradition in Hellenistic Judaism provided Paul with the categories that he needed to explain to his Hellenistic Jewish and Gentile audience in Rome the significance and meaning of Jesus’ death for others.
|
A Feminist Reading and a Queer Re-reading of the "Cities' Destruction" in the Book of Jeremiah
Program Unit: Writing/Reading Jeremiah
Jennifer Williams, Vanderbilt University
Focusing on the metaphors and imagery in the oracles of doom in Jeremiah 2:1-25:14 and also in chapters 30-33, this paper first engages in a feminist reading and then provides a re-reading influenced by queer theory. These different readings demonstrate that the ideology of a text is not so clearly defined and that rhetoric can work on multiple levels.
In order to effectively outrage an intended male audience, female imagery and language dominate the descriptions of cities’ violent destruction throughout the Book of Jeremiah. This is to the detriment of women. Yet when masculine language and imagery interrupt this trend, the rhetorical effect is ultimately disorienting to the audience and to expected gender boundaries.
Feminist readers tend to agree that these Jeremiah texts are “anti-woman” because of the specific usage of marriage metaphors and feminine “city” imagery. This reading assumes that a male/female polarity exists in the text in which men are the implied subjects and women are objectified and lack subjectivity. However, the metaphors of the cities’ destruction do not work in such a neat and tidy way.
Using subversive tactics to denaturalize and deconstruct gender constructions, a queer reading notices the constant shifting of gender language and imagery in the description of cities’ destruction. This method shows that the text actually challenges and breaks from established binary structures and gender boundaries. Jeremiah’s text demonstrates a blending of gender roles, to the point of biological ambiguity. A breakdown occurs: not just a breakdown of social norms, but a breakdown of biological certainties. Because of the cities’ destruction, the world has become so disordered that all clear binary opposition ceases to function as expected.
|
The Meaning of the Word `ebed
Program Unit: Biblical Lexicography
Peter J. Williams, Tyndale House
This paper will consider the changes that have taken place in representing the Hebrew word `ebed in a wide range of European languages, and in particular the increase in use of the word 'slave' (and cognates in other languages) as its equivalent in translations and lexica in the 20th century.
It will be argued that the word 'slave', while it may appropriately represent the social reality, is a problematic rendering for several reasons:
1) Even the translations that use the word 'slave' most frequently, still only use it for a small minority of all occurrences of `ebed, but these translations lack criteria for determining which occurrences are to be rendered 'slave' and which are not;
2) Where languages in antiquity and in the recent past have sought to use varied equivalences to translate the term `ebed, they have not only differed greatly from each other, but have also disrupted thematic unity in core texts (such as the book of Exodus);
3) The most basic elements of the meaning of `ebed are to do with work and with submission to authority and not to do with ownership or social liminality.
Although a case might be made for varied representation of a single Hebrew word, in this case the instances that it has become customary to render in varied ways still show significant commonality which, ideally, any translation would bring out. The paper concludes with a discussion of the various possibilities for a logical and consistent rendering of this term and for its representation in lexica.
|
A New Perspective on "Good Works" in 1 Peter
Program Unit: Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
Travis B. Williams, University of Exeter
For years, scholarship has been divided on the overall strategy of 1 Peter. Representative of this disagreement was the Balch-Elliott debate, which dominated much of the discussion during the 1980s and 90s. Both positions marked opposite ends of the interpretive spectrum—assimilation to the wider society on the one hand and distinctiveness on the other. What has yet to be recognized, however, is the fact that considerable agreement seems to exist with regard to one particular topic: “good works.” In most treatments of the subject, interpreters have tended to concentrate on “good works” as an appropriate response to the hostility facing the Anatolian readers. The author’s call to “do good” is thus viewed as an attempt to bolster the group’s waning reputation and to abrogate existing tensions through adherence to an agreed upon standard of behavior. Standing behind this interpretation is a view that equates “good works” with behavior modeled according to a Hellenistic standard wherein one’s actions or activities were performed for the benefit of the wider civic community. Inherent within this interpretive trend, however, are a number of problems that have yet to be fully surfaced. In this paper, we will seek to expose some of these weaknesses and to offer an alternative reading of this important theme. We will show that “good works” in 1 Peter have first and foremost an individual, theological dimension—focused on what is pleasing to God—which must be understood through the lens of the topic’s development within Second Temple Judaism and its adoption by early Christianity.
|
Isaiah’s Writing Materials in Isaiah 8:1
Program Unit: Biblical Lexicography
H. G. M. Williamson, University of Oxford
The definition of the gillayon on which Isaiah is commanded to write the name of his son in Isaiah 8:1 has been disputed since earliest times. All the ancient versions render differently and modern commentaries are equally divided. In this paper, some of the main previous suggestions will be briefly reviewed, the relevance of the writing implement, cheret, will be noted, and philological considerations will be evaluated. The suggestion by S. Norin that the word should be derived from gll (rather then the usual glh) is noted, though Norin’s suggestion that it therefore means a cylinder seal has to be rejected for various reasons. Instead, a new proposal is advanced to link the word with Aramaic and Palmyrene gll and Akkadian galalu, and a recently published Moabite stone inscription from Hirbet el-Mudeyine is adduced as an appropriate parallel. The first two words of Isaiah 8:1 may thus be rendered ‘a large stele/block of dressed stone’.
|
“The Wise Die along with the Fool”: Terror Management Theory and the Book of Qohelet
Program Unit: Psychology and Biblical Studies
Robert Williamson Jr., Hendrix College
Recent developments in Terror Management Theory (Solomon, Greenberg, and Pyszczynski) have demonstrated a strong correlation between mortality salience and worldview defense. Following the theoretical work of Ernest Becker (The Denial of Death), these studies suggest that death anxiety is minimized in the presence of cultural worldviews that assure their adherents of being persons of value in a meaningful universe. Conversely, the breakdown of such symbolically immortalizing cosmologies, which deprives people of their distal defenses against mortality salience, may produce an outpouring of death anxiety and, in some cases, a general cultural malaise. Following the work of TMT, Ernest Becker, and Robert Jay Lifton (The Broken Connection), this paper attempts to frame the death anxiety apparent in the book of Qohelet within the breakdown of the immortalizing cosmology of the Hebrew Wisdom tradition as evident in Proverbs 10-29. The results have significant implications for our understanding of Qohelet, particularly with regard to the book’s focus on death as an ultimate annihilation of the self, its apparent self-contradictions, its occasional statements of preference for death over life, and the symbolic merger of personal and cosmic death that occurs in its final chapter.
|
“Tweading” the Gospel of Mark: An Experiment in Reader-Response Criticism
Program Unit: Teaching Biblical Studies in an Undergraduate Liberal Arts Context
Robert Williamson, Jr., Hendrix College
One of the challenges facing any teacher of the Bible is to move students away from a foundationalist perspective on the biblical text toward a recognition that texts are perpetually open to multiple interpretations as they interact with their readers. This paper presents the results of a pedagogical experiment in reader-response criticism in which students employed the social networking site Twitter to capture readers’ real-time responses to a reading of the Gospel of Mark (a Tw[itter-R]eading, if you will). The learning goal addressed by the exercise is: “Students will be able to recognize and reflect upon the role of the reader in interpreting the Biblical text.” By using a live Twitter feed to display readers’ real-time reflections upon hearing the Gospel of Mark read aloud, students are able to observe the ways in which particular readers interact with Mark as its story unfolds. On the one hand, the exercise helps students see how Mark interacts with readerly expectations to guide its reader toward certain conclusions. On the other hand, it shows students how different readers respond differently to the story, creating meanings that vary from reader to reader. Students come away from the exercise with a heightened sense of the role of the reader in making meaning in the Gospels.
|
Peter and Paul and the Encounter in Antioch
Program Unit: Extent of Theological Diversity in Earliest Christianity
Wendell Willis, Abilene Christian University
The three verses of Galatians 2:14-16 have exercised great influence upon the understanding of the development of early Christianity, since the reconstruction of F. C. Baur a century and a half ago. Even without the Hegelian foundation of Baur, the common assumption still today is that after Paul rebuked Peter in Antioch, there was a sharp break between the two apostles. This interpretation tends to isolate Paul as an outsider in the early church, except within those churches he established (and within some of those).
This paper is a reconsideration of this widely held reconstruction and its influence on the development of the early church. I begin by surveying how the Baur /Bauer interpretations of the Galatians passage have become almost canonical in describing Paul and Pauline Christianity. Then I look at how this compares with other reconstructions of church development, beginning with the Acts of Apostles. but including also some modern ones that do not follow Baur. Then I will explore how Paul otherwise describes his relationship to other apostles, including Peter, in I Corinthians as well as Galatians.
|
The Twelve Disciples in Matthew's Gospel
Program Unit: Matthew
Joel Willitts, North Park University
*
|
Famous Last Words: The Intersections of Forgiveness and Lament atop Golgotha
Program Unit: Biblical Criticism and Literary Criticism
Andrew Wilson, Mount Allison University
Is forgiveness integral to lamentation? This paper follows the tradition of the seven last words of Christ on the cross, with attention given more specifically to those that evoke lament (references to Psalm 22 and Psalm 69) and those that invoke forgiveness (namely, Luke’s account). Of particular importance will be Derrida’s development of the notion of forgiveness, a concept which forms part of his so-called “ethical turn.” Is lament an attempt to voice the unforgiveable? Does forgiveness gesture towards the same point of impasse that lament marks? Ultimately, this paper raises theological questions relating to incarnation, the im/possibility of divine-human encounter and the locations spanned by the inter-textual cross.
|
An Emasculating Muteness: The Silencing of Zechariah in Luke 1
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Brittany E. Wilson, Princeton Theological Seminary
As it is often noted, Luke’s birth narrative has a prominent focus on women, especially when compared to Matthew’s birth narrative. Unlike Matthew’s account, in which Joseph is the more prominent character and Mary is subsidiary, Luke portrays Mary as the more prominent character and Joseph as subsidiary and he also casts an additional woman, Elizabeth, in a prominent role. What is not often noted, however, is that Luke only turns his attention to these two women after _silencing_ an important male character; namely, Zechariah, the father of John the Baptist. In the ancient world, speech was a power endowed to elite males, and in Luke 1, Luke strips Zechariah of this power and has two women speak in his stead. This paper traces Zechariah’s depiction in Luke 1 from his initially positive portrayal and subsequent downfall, to his specific punishment of being silenced, and then his eventual restoration of speech at the end of chapter one. In exploring this characterization, this paper will demonstrate that Luke effectively undermines Zechariah’s manhood in order to reorient expectations of where power dwells. As a muted male who eventually recognizes the power of God, Zechariah not only subverts ancient mores regarding the gendered nature of speech, but also challenges the relationship between masculinity and power. Power does not ultimately reside, Luke maintains, with men, but with God. God is the one who wields supreme authority, but it is a subversive authority, for God dismantles traditional power structures; bringing down the strong, lifting up the lowly, and silencing those who typically speak.
|
The End of Preexilic Judah and the Sociology of Exile
Program Unit: Exile (Forced Migrations) in Biblical Literature
Robert R. Wilson, Yale University
Contemporary studies of migrations, whether forced or voluntary, indicate that migrants bring with them a narrative dealing with their experiences and focusing on how they came to be in their present condition. These narratives are shared with others and passed on to the next generation of migrants. The second generation of migrants, however, sees these narratives differently than does the first generation, and the third generation has still a different perspective on them. The existence of migration narratives and the ways in which they are perceived by different generations of migrants suggest that sociological studies of migration might be able to enrich scholarly study of the Bible’s accounts of the end of preexilic Judah, which are now found in 2 Kings 24—25, Jeremiah 52, and 2 Chronicles 36. Scholars have usually traced the shape of these narratives and their variations to literary or theological roots. However, the sociological studies of migration narratives suggest that other interpretations are possible. This paper will investigate this possibility.
|
David’s Initiation into Manhood: Reading 1 Samuel 17 as a Rite of Passage Narrative
Program Unit: Children in the Biblical World
Stephen M. Wilson, Duke University
The subject of rites of passage accompanying a boy’s transition to manhood, first taken up by Arnold Van Gennep, is no longer only of interest to cultural anthropologists. Since the appearance of Vidal-Naquet’s “The Black Hunter” in 1968, classicists, in particular, have engaged in a rich discussion on the topic. Biblical scholarship, however, has yet to produce a study on the process of becoming a man in ancient Israel. My paper attempts to address this lacuna by offering a rereading of the story of David and Goliath (1 Samuel 17), showing that the text has a primary concern with narrating David’s transition from boyhood to manhood. I draw upon Van Gennep’s work on rites of passage and its appropriation by classicists like Vidal-Naquet, also incorporating the enlightening work of medievalist Jeffrey Cohen on the important role of giants in myths concerned with retelling the story of a boy’s rite of passage into adulthood. Applying the insights garnered from these studies, I identify six points within the narrative of 1 Sam 17 that strongly suggest that the story should be read as relating a rite of passage, marking David’s metamorphosis into manhood. Central among these points is a focus upon the frequent repetition and dynamic interplay between words for “boy,” “man,” and “young man” (na‘ar, ’îš, and ‘elem, respectively) in the text, a literary feature indicating that the chapter be read in light of the relationship between boyhood and manhood.
|
INTERPRETERS: ENSLAVED/ENSLAVING/RUNAGATE
Program Unit:
Vincent L. Wimbush, Institute for Signifying Scriptures, Claremont Graduate University
*
|
The Impact of the KJV in Caribbean Bible Translation Work
Program Unit:
Marlon Winedt, United Bible Societies
*
|
Orality and Bible Translation in the Carribean Region
Program Unit: Bible Translation
Marlon Winedt, United Bible Societies
This paper will be a response to Ernst Wendland's paper during the session on "Orality and Bible Translation". The presenter will engage the different queries and positions which Dr. Wendland will present from the perspective of the Carribean reality, drawing especially from his experience with Bible translation in Creole languages and the oral nature of these languages. Research from the linguistic field of Creolistics will be drawn upon to engage the whole topic of "Orality and Bible Translation" in a productive manner.
|
A Mesopotamian Background for Divine Blood and Its Shedding in Genesis 1–11?
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Abraham Winitzer, University of Notre Dame
It is widely recognized that, in matters of cosmogony, the so-called Primeval History (Genesis 1-11) builds substantially on Near Eastern ideas, particularly those from ancient Mesopotamia. No different is the depiction of humanity’s creation in these chapters: as many have shown, in this respect too the Biblical accounts develop from and respond to external traditions, especially those from the most venerated of Israel’s neighbors. Indeed, from the very formation of mankind, to institutions designated to withstand life’s vicissitudes, to more philosophical questions concerning the nature of man, at times one feels hard-pressed to locate something meaningful that may confidently be declared free of Mesopotamian influence in these opening chapters. In fact, in this paper I will suggest that in the depiction of humanity’s creation the Biblical indebtedness to Mesopotamia may run even deeper than previously appreciated. The issue to be considered involves the meaning of blood in the establishment of Biblical cosmic order. I shall argue that the Bible’s interest in this topic stems in large part from an awareness of a parallel tradition from Mesopotamia, one that the Biblical text incorporates and refashions in accordance with its own worldview.
|
Markan Sources: Reviewing the History of Scholarship
Program Unit: Markan Literary Sources
Adam Winn, Azusa Pacific University
This paper will trace the surprisingly brief history of scholarship for the issue of Markan source material, beginning with nineteenth century source criticism and ending with contemporary scholarly efforts. Particular attention will be paid to the way in which the results of source, form, and redaction criticism have impacted the search for Markan sources. The paper will conclude by offering a means by which Markan interpreters might move past the legacy of source, form, and redaction criticism in their search for Markan source material.
|
Bereshit Basic Biblical Hebrew (3BH): Interactive Technology for Language Learning
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Nicolai Winther-Nielsen, Copenhagen Lutheran School of Theology
New applications to Hebrew language learning promise to change and improve the way we learn Biblical Hebrew, because the learner can now decide how he wants to engage with the text and how well he wants to do. This is the potential in the learning environment at 3BH Moodle (cf www.3bm.dk under English section).
The learner can study the text and the morphology of the Amsterdam database in his SESB or Logos Bible software and they are available to him in videos and learning objects that he will use in the Web 2.0 Moodle LMS. He will then enter a learning environment with free or cheap programs for the PC: The learner can enter into the Hebrew text and click his way around at the levels of clause, phrase or lexeme and aspect the syntactic trees through the Linguistic Tree Constructor (LTC). The learner can then choose to test his or her language skills in the parsing of a text and will therefore choose to have the text formulate random exercises of his own choice through the Ezer Emdros-based Exercise Tool (3ET). He may discover that he needs to brush up his knowledge of the paradigms of nouns and verbs and will therefore do a bit of training in the Paradigms Master Pro (PMP). He train himself in writing Hebrew in the EzerKB virtual keyboard. He may then want to do the tests provided in his Moodle environment.
This learning environment has given great results for tests and it is being implemented for learners at a graduate school in a technologically poor country like Madagascar. It seems to offer a possibility for learners to tailor their own learning to their individual level of motivation and ability.
The workshop will allow you to try out how Moodle, learning objects and training tools interact with each others, and we will discuss its learner-centered potential.
|
Sacred Texts in Oral Contexts: The Living Word and the Scripture
Program Unit: Paul and Scripture
Ben Witherington, Asbury Theological Seminary
This paper will investigate the views of sacred texts held by Jews in a largely oral culture, including: 1) the preference for the living voice, and when it comes to God's Word the oral proclamation over the written; 2) the function of the nomena sacra in such a text; 3) the beliefs about how God's Word had inherent power and ability to accomplish what it states; 4) the rhetorical function of a sacred text in a culture that has such a text, in contrast with most Greco-Roman religion which had not such sacred book; 5) the importance of oracular prophecy in sacred texts as the closest thing to the verbatim of the living voice, and 5) what scriptum continuum tells us about the character of ancient texts.
|
The Death of Sin in the Death of Jesus
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Ben Witherington, Asbury Theological Seminary
*
|
Role Reversal, Binding Formulas, and the Use of Names in Two of Jesus’ Exorcisms
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
Amanda Witmer, McMaster University
Jesus’ exorcisms are now widely viewed as belonging to the earliest strata of the tradition. Based on close textual analysis and on the application of the criterion of embarrassment, I will argue in this paper that particular elements found in the exorcisms in Mark 1 and 5 are not only early but may reflect the experience of the historical Jesus in his initial encounters with unclean spirits. In fact, when compared with other ancient Mediterranean exorcisms, the encounters described in Mark reveal some unusual features which suggest that the roles of the demon and the exorcist (Jesus) are actually reversed. This is evident from the use of the defensive phrase ti hemin kai soi/ti emoi kai soi; (“What do you want with us/me?”) by the demon in both exorcisms as well as the use of identity markers as binding formulas. Typically in ancient incantations it is the exorcist who attempts to disarm the demon by using these techniques. However, in both of these exorcisms, it is the demon who takes on this role. The use of these strategies by the demon along with indications of overlapping dialogue in Mark 5:7-8 and Jesus’ request for the demon’s name in v. 9 suggest that Jesus was severely challenged by the evil spirits he encountered.
|
Women, Work, and Wilderness: Gleanings of an Ecocritical Reading of Genesis 3:14–19
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Kellyann Falkenberg Wolfe, Union Theological Seminary
This paper offers a reading of the curses of Gen 3.14-19 from an ecocritical perspective, that is, a perspective that highlights a text’s underlying attitudes toward nature. In doing so, it uncovers parallels between the substance of the curses and the Agricultural (or Neolithic) Revolution, in which the human species made a transition from a lifestyle of migratory foraging to one of settled agriculture. In this transition, what had been an undivided world with no separation between “nature” and “culture” was fragmented into separate domains. Gen 3.14-19 describes these domains as wilderness (the outer domain, represented by the serpent), culture/home (the inner domain, presided over by the woman) and, between them, the agricultural domain, which is the province of the man. In the parallels between the Eden narrative and the Agricultural Revolution, this paper also finds an interpretational framework that helps to make sense of the way gender is portrayed in Gen 3, especially in terms of the relegation of women to the domestic interior, the male-female hierarchy, and the diminished contact between women and wilderness.
|
The Notion of kpr in the Book of Leviticus and Chinese Popular Religion
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Sonia Kwok Wong, Vanderbilt University
The meaning of kpr (pi‘el), often rendered as “to atone/expiate,” is disputed. In the Book of Leviticus, kpr occurs only in sacrificial contexts in relation to ?a??a?? “purification offering,” ?ašam “reparation offering” and yôm kippurîm “the Day of Atonement.”
As a key concept in offerings that are specifically prescribed to effect
forgiveness in behalf of those who have committed expiable moral faults and physical
ritual impurities, kpr carries a dual sense of ransoming (as the denominative of kop¯er
“ransom”) and purging. kpr offerings stand as ransoms paid by the offerers (the guilty
party) to YHWH (the offended party) and serve as a means to remove certain
impediments that hinder the divine-human relationship. Since its related noun ?????? o is
also used to denote “bribe” or illegitimate payment (see 1 Sam. 12:3; Amos 5:12), this
raises a question on the legitimacy of the ransoming power of kpr offerings. Is it
legitimate for YHWH to have faults and guilty people forgiven through sacrificial
offerings? Why are purification and reparation offerings regarded as proper ransoms
and not illegitimate bribes? In what ways can the legitimacy of these rituals be
justified?
This paper puts the Book of Leviticus and Chinese popular religion in dialogue. I aim to show that there is no parallel notion of kpr in the sacrificial rituals of Chinese popular religion and how the legitimacy of such notion becomes questionable in the light of Chinese three-realm worldview, the imperial bureaucratic metaphor in Chinese pantheons, and the ambiguous moral nature of deities, ancestors, and ghosts. In Chinese popular religion, offerings for the purpose of averting or mitigating punishment would be regarded as an act of bribe or extortion. However, the legitimacy of the ransoming notion of kpr in the Book of Leviticus is safeguarded by the presuppositions undergirding the purification and reparation offerings.
|
Theological Response to Sklar and Witherington
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Telford Work, Westmont College
*
|
Second Temple Period Biblical Interpretation: An Early Pneumatic/Renewal Hermeneutic
Program Unit: Society for Pentecostal Studies
Archie Wright, Regent University
This essay discusses what appears to be an early pneumatic hermeneutic during the Second Temple Period of Early Judaism. The author suggests that many current scholars in the area of Pentecostal and Charismatic hermeneutics have overlooked this valuable area of literature and thus claim that the 20th century Pentecostal/Charismatic hermeneutic is ‘the’ way to read Scripture. As it is, the sectarian community at Qumran in the 2nd c. BCE through the 1st c. CE were incorporating a spirit inspired reading of Scripture in an effort to incorporate Spirit, Scripture, and Community into their understanding of the biblical text and its significance to the Israel and in particular the Qumran Community. The author also identifies a few examples of a similar hermeneutic at work in the NT. He concludes that rightly so are the claims of the present Pentecostal/Charismatic communities that the Spirit must be the guide in interpreting Scripture but that we have a lot to learn from the 2TP Jewish and early Jewish Christian communities.
|
The Kingdom and the Cross
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
N. T. Wright, University of St. Andrews
*
|
Paul on Praying and Prophesying: Sacrifice and the Ritual Construction of Gendered Roles in Corinth
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Richard A. Wright, Oklahoma Christian University
One of the more complicated passages in Paul’s letters is his discussion of the men and women praying and prophesying in 1 Corinthians 11:2-16. Previous scholarship has focused primarily on trying to explain Paul’s exhortation to the women and men praying and prophesying in the Corinthian assembly. What has received less attention are the possible social circumstances that might have permitted or even encouraged the women’s (and men’s?) behavior.
Recent work in ritual theory and in the place of sacrifice in constructing gendered roles points us to what must have been a major contributing factor to the Corinthian behavior. In the ancient Mediterranean world, sacrificial meals provided occasions at which gendered roles were created and reinforced. Men separated themselves from women and established inheritance rights between fathers and sons. Catherine Bell has described the ways in which rituals construct power relationships within social organizations. These relationships, however, are always negotiated with specific people, groups, places, and events.
In this paper I argue that what we witness in 1 Corinthians 11:2-16 is the renegotiation of the power relationships between men and women in the specific context of the Corinthian Christian assembly. Paul had claimed that in Christ there is neither male nor female. The removal of sacrificial meals from the Corinthian Christian assembly created ritual space for them to explore how that non-gendered ideal might be embodied. Paul is pleased that they have tried to express the ideal but disagrees with their application.
|
Gal 3:28 in Thomas Aquinas' Lectures on the Pauline Letters
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
William M. Wright IV, Duquesne University
The biblical commentaries of Thomas Aquinas have been an underexplored topic in the study of the history of interpretation. Aquinas lectured on all the Pauline letters (as well as Hebrews) and understood their canonical collection as a theologically coherent exposition of grace and its communication. An examination of Aquinas’ treatment of Gal 3:28 in his Lectures on Galatians, as well as other uses of Gal 3:28 and related passages (esp. Col 3:11) in his lectures on the Pauline corpus, shed light on how Aquinas negotiates the claims of unity and difference. Aquinas understands Gal 3:28 to elaborate 3:27, which speaks of the transformation and unity effected by baptism. Aquinas takes up the differences named in 3:28 as potential obstacles to baptism and the unifying effects of grace. He argues that these differences do not in themselves impede the unifying effects of baptism in part because of the underlying sameness in all human beings: human nature created in the image of God, which is common to all and prior to these differences. The grace communicated through baptism (which Aquinas also associates with the Spirit’s action of new creation) works restoratively on the image of God in the human being irrespective of extant differences. These differences are also equalized because all people, created in God’s image, have access to same grace in Christ, who provides for all. Renewing and elevating human nature, grace unites baptized individuals through faith and charity into the one Body of Christ, making them heirs to the Abrahamic promises of salvation.
|
Righteous Anger: The Shunammite Woman as a Companion in Grief
Program Unit: Bible and Practical Theology
Stephanie Wyatt, Brite Divinity School
How does one reconstruct relationship with God when divine power seems a hindrance rather than a help in restoring one’s own or one’s community’s well-being? The story of the Shunammite Woman and the Prophet Elisha in 2 Kgs 4:8-37, interpreted in light of post-Shoah discourse, constitutes one helpful theological strategy. I argue that the Shunammite woman is a model of faith for those who experience the divine as painfully absent in times of personal or communal loss. This project is anchored in an exegesis of 2 Kgs 4:8-37, post-Shoah methods of reading, as well as my own personal and pastoral experiences of grief.
|
Finding Asherah: The Goddesses in Text and Image
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Iconography and the Bible
Jackie Wyse Rhodes, Emory University
Much has been written concerning Israel’s regard for goddesses. Did the ancient Israelites, at any point in their history, worship one or more goddesses alongside Yahweh? Was Yahweh commonly thought to have a consort, and if so, who was she? Such questions have been addressed with fervor during the past decades and, along the way, no goddess has received more press than the elusive Asherah. Something of a consensus seems to have developed that, in all likelihood, Asherah was worshipped in ancient Israel (though there are dissenters). Scholars making determinations about whether (and when) Asherah was worshipped in Israel generally do so on the basis of textual evidence, especially material from Ugaritic mythological literature and the Hebrew Bible, as well as epigraphic/iconographic evidence, especially the findings at Khirbet el-Qom and Kuntillet ‘Ajrud. Is it problematic, however, that these disparate sources are often brought into conversation with one another on the basis of nothing more than the word “asherah” itself? A brief survey of these sources will demonstrate that were it not for that one word – significant though it may be – there is little that unites this material. Indeed, this paper will suggest that scholars have been too quick to posit Asherah as the Hebrew goddess; the iconographic evidence for Syro-Palestinian goddesses writ large tells another story. Drawing on this evidence, I will argue in this paper that, much of the time in the Hebrew Bible, Asherah functions as a scapegoat, a rhetorical mitigation of the real threat posed by other goddess cults.
|
The Liberative Power of Silent Agency: Reading Mary through the Eyes of Cameroonian Rural Women
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Alice Yafeh-Deigh, Azusa Pacific University
This paper will argue that Mary’s attitude in Luke 10:38-42 interrupts the busy-body agency of Martha and thereby demonstrates a countercultural liberative agency for rural women in Cameroon.
The story of Mary and Martha (Luke 10:38-42) has given rise to a plethora of competing interpretations. Some feminist and gender-critical interpreters believe that the Lukan Jesus has an affirming view of women's discipleship; other thinks the Lukan Jesus undermines the agency of women by silencing them and by reinscribing patriarchal values and structures; still others see him both as affirming of Women’s agency and as undermining it. The plurality of scholarly approaches and sometimes overlapping perspectives need not necessarily be mutually exclusive. The plurality in meaning can be explained by interpreters move toward an intentional sensitivity and commitment to reading the story with and for a particularly community.
After evaluating how the social structures of honor and shame affected gender relationships in the world of Luke’s Gospel, this paper goes on to use that framework as a lens through which to reexamine and reevaluate the various cultural scripts inherent in narrative of Luke 10:38-42 and to reinterpret the nature of gender roles between the Lukan Jesus, Mary, and Martha. I will suggest that, in a context where the community evaluates a woman’s self worth by the extent to which her behavior conforms to cultural expectations of honor and shame, Mary models the appropriate countercultural response, through her enacting of a different, perhaps unexpected form of agency, namely, undermining the “busy-body” cultural norm. Therefore, her attitude should be hermeneutically retrieved for emancipatory practices; it should specifically serve as a principle for social critic and not as a principle for maintaining the status quo. Mary becomes the hero of the narrative in two ways: 1) she represents a countercultural model to the busy-body cultural expectations about women’s behavior in the community; and 2) for the rural women in Cameroon, her silence provides an opportunity to claim Mary’s space and articulate their own agency in the emerging Christian community.
|
A Homiletical Project: A Critical Methodology for Preaching to the Episodic Congregation
Program Unit: Academy of Homiletics
Sung Gu Yang, Emory University
*
|
Resist No Evil and Save No Money: Reading the Sermon on the Mount for Social-Economic Ethics in China
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
John Yieh, Virginia Theological Seminary
*
|
Sympathy for the Devil? Philo on Flaccus and Rome
Program Unit: Philo of Alexandria
Joshua Yoder, University of Notre Dame
In his treatise _In Flaccum_, Philo offers a multivalent portrait of Flaccus, the Roman prefect of Alexandria at the time of the anti-Jewish pogrom in 38 CE. On the one hand, Flaccus is a tyrant who acts against the Jews with malice aforethought. On the other, Flaccus is a victim of political events for whom Philo, while not condoning his choices, seems to feel some amount of sympathy. This paper explores the contours of this multivalent portrayal, and the view of the Roman empire that it suggests. I conclude that Philo’s attitude toward the Roman Empire is too complex to be seen solely in terms of a dichotomy between “pro-Roman” and “anti-Roman” sentiments.
|
Emphasis of the Last Component of the Unit in Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Shamir Yona, Ben Gurion University of the Negev
The ancient Semitic phenomenon known as Concluding Inversion or Concluding Deviation is peculiar in that it stems from a complex process of conveying a message within a literary unit (short or long), leading to a changeover in style, structure or syntax at the end of the literary unit. Such a phenomenon is quite often linked to other stylistic or structural patterns which may be found in the literary unit, thus contributing to the coherence of the unit’s components, and aiding in unfolding and promoting the
idea that it conveys.
Since the main feature of the phenomenon is the modification of the last component of the unit, this modification is better delineated or emphasized when it is introduced in a unit in which the components display a certain repetitive pattern (i.e. anaphora or epiphora). In such a case, the change constitutes a deviation from the familiar, routine pattern and the innovation is thus enhanced, as it foils the expectation of the audience (listener or reader) for the customary pattern and focuses their attention on the end of the unit.
|
Eating Mother, Whore, and Bride: Queering War, Sex, and Food in Revelation
Program Unit: LGBTI/Queer Hermeneutics
Joonho Yoon, Drew University
The issue of food and eating in Revelation has not been sufficiently and simultaneously treated against the backdrop of war and sex. Revelation can be deconstructed, intersected, and queered by the triad of war, sex, and food. Like the city and the female, food is represented as an object to be attacked, seized, penetrated, and conquered. Revelation is about the war for “eating,” i.e., the war for “sexing” the celestial mother (ch. 12), the great whore (ch. 17), and the pure bride (ch. 21). Eating and fighting revolves around sexing, especially with homo-transgendered partners. Food language overlaps with sexual imageries and haunts warfare symbols. In spite of John’s thorough effort to reserve feminine imagery for the enemy, femininity and queering emerges incessantly out of military messianism and cosmic festivity in the text.
|
Among Deborah, Esther, and Jezebel, Who is the Literary Predecessor of Herodias?: Multi-Intertextual Reading of John’s Beheading in Matthew 14
Program Unit: Intertextuality in the New Testament
Joonho Yoon, Drew University
The beheading narrative of John the Baptist has been intertextually read against the Elijah cycle. The characterization of Jezebel as femme fatale is identically applied to Herodias, and thus, the triangle of Jezebel-Ahab-Elijah corresponds to that of Herodias-Herod-John. But this intertextuality has two defects. There is no space for the role that Herodias’ daughter (known in tradition as Salome) plays. And because of Matthew’s intentional omission of the name Elijah right before the beheading narrative, it becomes less relevant to the Matthean narrative than the Markan one. The Matthean narrator, at least in this unit, seems to distance John from Elijah, and the Herodias-Herod couple from the Jezebel-Ahab couple.
Some alternative intertextualities are suggested by scholarship, among which the Esther story is most prominent. There are three possibilities in relating the Esther story to the beheading narrative. One is to use the Esther-Mordecai-Ahasuerus-Haman chain which primarily considers the female initiator and provides a space for Herodias’ daughter. Another is to apply the Mordecai-Esther-Ahasuerus-Haman chain to the narrative, which pays attention to the relationship between the powerful initiator and the submissive seductress. The other is to construct the Memucan-Ahasuerus-Vashti chain, which focuses on the unjust death of the innocent.
My new intertextual reading is to parallel the Deborah narrative (Judg 4-5) with the Herodias narrative. The pentagonal casting of Deborah, Jael, Barak, Sisera, and Sisera’s mother is in perfect accordance with that of Herodias, Herodias’ daughter, Herod, John, and Jesus. There are various correspondences or reversals in gender, position, ethnicity, plot, setting, evaluation, and so on. The demasculinization or effeminization of the dead, the transformation from or into the food, and the fatal attack on the head are the culmination of the intertextuality.
|
The Bringing of the Bible to the Caribbean Basin: Some Historical and Postcolonial Probings
Program Unit: Islands, Islanders, and Scriptures
Gosnell Yorke, Northern Caribbean University
The Caribbean, to which Christopher Columbus, the Italian explorer, drifted in the late fifteenth century in his search for gold and other “goodies” in the East on behalf of the Spanish crown, encompasses Anglophone, Francophone, Hispanophone and Nederlanderphone (Dutch-speaking) Islands. In addition, the area has been historically shaped in its identity formation by Africa, Asia, Latin America and Europe and is therefore home to four major linguistic groups, a plurality of Afro-religious traditions including some indigenous ones and is a kaleidoscope of races, cultures and histories.
What runs like an ariadne’s thread throughout the history of this complex Caribbean region, however, especially since its contact with Europe as empire, is the pivotal but ambivalent role which the Bible has played (and continues to play) in the lives of both people and places. In this presentation, an attempt will be made to outline the features of this pivot and ambivalence. Essentially, it is one in which the Bible has been used as both a “text of terror” and an instrument of liberation throughout the history of the islands; one in which it has served not only as sacred text in the various churches or as textbook among the newly-emancipated illiterates but also as a document whose language and idioms have impacted (and continue to do so) the larger socio-political and cultural discourse of its peoples—sometimes in rather creative and colourful ways as demonstrated in its musical and other aesthetic traditions.
|
An Afrocentric Approach to the Translation of the Bible: An Idea Whose Time Has Come?
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Gosnell Yorke, Northern Caribbean University
Bible translation is a complex exercise and, among other things, it articulates with disciplines such as biblical studies, feminist studies, translation studies, performance criticism and postcolonialism. As an exercise which, heretofore, has been dominated by those who have tended to be both male and white, it is not in the least surprising, perhaps, that there have been clarion calls for a much greater sensitivity to both sexism and racism as two pathologies which, sometimes unwittingly, have tended to mar the work of Bible translation over the years.
For those of us who share a common African ancestry, however, our settled conviction is that there is a dire need to abandon the dominant eurocentric paradigm and, as Ngugi wa Thion’go, the outstanding Kenyan writer contended years ago, embrace even more fully the afrocentric alternative.
With the recent publication of two groundbreaking volumes , to wit, True to Our Native Land: An African American New Testament Commentary (2007) and The Africana Bible: Reading Israel’s Scriptures from Africa and the African Diaspora (2010), two confident and competent steps have been taken in that direction.
As excellent as these volumes are, however, what they both have in common is that they are based on an already translated biblical text. What is being proposed in this presentation in stead is that, perhaps, the time has come for us to embark, as an international and interdisciplinary team of “afro-scholars” (women and men,) on the complete re-translation of the Bible in ways that are not only faithful to the original languages in which it was first written, namely, Hebrew, Aramaic and Greek, but also in ways which resonate with the afro-existential realities that continue to shape and surround us. By way of illustration only, we will also present a few practical examples drawn from both the Hebrew Bible and the New Testament.
|
Text Critical Observations on the (Im)Possibility of Linguistic Dating of Hebrew Biblical Texts
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Ian Young, University of Sydney
The main argument of Linguistic Dating of Biblical Texts (2008) was that, while diachrony in ancient Hebrew is beyond doubt, the data brought forward in support of current systems of linguistic dating of Hebrew biblical texts is better explained according to a model whereby so-called Late and Early Biblical Hebrew were co-existing styles of Hebrew throughout the biblical period. However, the book made the further suggestion that linguistic dating of Hebrew biblical texts might actually be impossible due to the nature of the biblical texts. This paper explores a key element of that claim by measuring linguistic dating theories against new data for the scholarly consensus in both text critical and literary critical fields that the biblical texts, especially in regard to such a peripheral feature as their language, were written and rewritten over time. According to this consensus of general biblical studies, therefore, the attempt to locate the date of the “original author” of a work according to the language of the current texts represents a serious methodological error.
|
Some Epigraphic Comments on the New Ktmw Inscription from Zincirli
Program Unit: Paleographical Studies in the Ancient Near East
K. Lawson Younger, Jr., Trinity International University
This paper will address some of the epigraphic and interpretive issues in the new KTMW Inscription from Zincirli. Included will be discussions of the vocalization of the name, the possible identity of one of the deities, a possible explanation of the mater lectionis in KBBW based on cuneiform evidence, and the role of the named deities in the ancestor cults of north Syria.
|
Spreading the Wealth? Negotiating Israel’s Jubilee Laws and Political Opposition to the Federal Estate Tax
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Colin Hans Yuckman, United Presbyterian Church of New Kensington
Debate about the Federal Estate Tax has become a staple of American politics. Known among its critics as the “Death Tax,” this kind of inheritance tax has been present in one form or another since the 19th century. Criticism of the tax argues income earners have sovereignty (before the government) over their money, whereas supporters believe the tax incentivizes labor and promotes social equality. As of early 2010 the Federal Estate Tax has not been renewed; however, some form of the tax is expected to be approved soon which will have retroactive authority. As a result last decade’s debate over the law will likely resume. More interesting than the debate itself, however, is how the ideologies underlying the debate are influenced by biblical precedent. This paper explores how jubilee laws in Leviticus 25 and related wealth and property regulations have been received in American politics since the 19th century with regard to expressions of federal inheritance tax. It will further explore the social implications—including racial, ethnic, and economic equality—of such regulations for both ancient Israel and present day America.
|
NAPH: Hebrew Grammars
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
H. Daniel Zacharias, Acadia Divinity College
Invited to participate in the panel celebrating two new introductory Hebrew grammars.
|
Literary Function of Rituals at the Ends of Narratives in Genesis
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Susan Zeelander, University of Pennsylvania
In 18 of the nearly 40 narratives in Gen 1-35 and 38, irrespective of the documentary source(s), the key character participates in a ritual, and sometimes in more than one ritual, in the “end-section” of the narrative. The end-section begins with the resolution of the key destabilizing event or perception that precipitates the action in the story; that together with additional information that the writer adds forms an “end-section.” This study focuses on the narrative function of these rituals in their stories.
The Genesis rituals sometimes provide the key transformation that re-stabilizes the conditions in a narrative. Treaty rituals effectively accomplish this. Most of the rituals occur after the narrative’s key transformation; they bring qualities of finality or stability or integrity to the end of the story. This suggests to the reader that the events of the narrative are over and the story is concluded. When a character in the narrative invokes the divine in an altar-building ritual, for example, this reinforces a sense that the outcome of the narrative will be stable; for the reader this suggests that the events of the plot are over. When a ritual articulates the hierarchy between people, it projects a stabilized society. Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob build altars and raise pillars; Lot does not. When demonstrating the ritualized behavior of life-cycle events a ritual marks the finalizing action that completes a process, as for example the wedding ceremony that completes the betrothal of Isaac, or the circumcision that Abraham performs that brings himself and his people into the covenant with God.
Because they are common as endings readers recognize that the mere presence of a ritual, sometimes marked with formulaic language, can signify the end of a story.
|
The Reception of the Fourth Gospel in Gospel of the Savior
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Lorne R. Zelyck, University of Cambridge
The newly discovered Gospel of the Savior (Papyrus Berolinensis 22220 + Strasbourg Coptic Papyrus) is an extra-canonical gospel from the third century CE that has been influenced by the Fourth Gospel. This paper will address the claims of Jacoby, Hedrick and Mirecki, and Schenke who suggest that Gos. Sav. was written independently of the canonical gospels and relied on oral tradition from the first half of the second century CE, but will agree with Schmidt, Frey, Emmel, T. Nagel, P. Nagel, and Plisch that Gos. Sav. is dependent on Matthew and the Fourth Gospel. Previous examinations of Gos. Sav. have not focused on its use of the Fourth Gospel. This paper will examine how Gos. Sav. uses passages from the Fourth Gospel in order to determine the author’s theological motivation. There are striking similarities between the interpretations of John 10:30 in Gos. Sav. and Praxeas (Prax. 20), as well as John 19:34 in Gos. Sav. and other literature from the second and third century CE. I conclude that the author has supplemented and omitted Fourth Gospel material, as well as arranged Fourth Gospel passages in order to extend the “Johannine trajectory” by glorifying the salvific role of the Savior and minimizing his fleshly suffering.
|
Paul as a First-Century Jew: The State of the Question
Program Unit:
Magnus Zetterholm, Lund University
*
|
The Trace of God in Song 8:6
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Sarah Zhang, Princeton Theological Seminary
To solicit meaningfulness from the Song of Songs that is appropriate to its canonical context, one cannot circumvent the turn from eros to a love without eros. For despite its significance of awakening subjectivity, of provoking responsibility, of concretely staging what it extends in abstraction, eros, in and by itself, remains locked in the private garden of an erotic relation. But do the lyrical texts warrants, or at least sustain, such a turn? If the allegorical key were suspended for the sake of a close reading, the controversial –yh in šlhbhthyh (8:6) offers the only possibility for the book to strike a theological note. In this paper I will focus on Song 8:6 in order to trace a poetic saying of God. In the case of –yh, for instance, though it is capable of evoking the abbreviated form of “YHWH,” it does not assimilate God in the lyrical text through the correlation of the thought and the real, as a science or philosophical text would do. In its polyvalence, it shows responsiveness to, while refusing to betray, the Transcendent in the said. More essentially, the declaration of eros, of its devotedness and exclusiveness, imbues the reader’s sensibility and cultivates it for a love without eros. That is to say, the absorbed alters that which absorbs. In short, through poetic saying and receiving, the poet is able to evoke, in an erotic declaration, the love for the other, whose otherness reveals the trace of God.
|
The Sexploitation of Adam and Eve
Program Unit: Bible and Popular Culture
Valarie Ziegler, DePauw University
For millions of people who regularly cruise the Internet, Adam and Eve are synonymous with the adult entertainment industry. How and when, one might ask, did Gen 2-3 become a platform for porn? And what does mean for Genesis' interpretation when Adam and Eve become commodities for consumers' sexual fantasies and satisfaction? While the assumption that Adam, Eve, and sex are intrinsically linked can be seen in a variety of mediums, no one has done more to solidify this connection in our consumer culture than Philip D. Harvey-the founder of Adam & Eve.com and a chain of Adam and Eve stories that feature, among other items, an Adam and Eve line of adult products. This presentation explores: 1) how a philanthropist funded his philanthropic activities by becoming the largest and most successful seller of sex toys and erotic merchandise in the United States, and 2) what are the consequences when biblical characters-- Adam and Eve--become commodities and are reduced to a brand name.
|
"Fatale—Exploring Salome," Or: Why Exegetes Should Play Videogames
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Thimo Zirpel, University of Muenster
Seldom exegetes play video games out of a professional interest. Yet, with "Fatale – Exploring Salome" they now have ample reason to do so. Using Oscar Wilde’s drama Salomé as vantage point, Tale of Tales, an independent developer duo, turned the biblical narrative about the gruesome beheading of John the Baptist (Mk. 6:14-29 par. Matt. 14:1-12) into a complex and fascinating (post-)modern video game. In a bald move they created an “interactive vignette” which also draws on their own and the players experience to convey its meaning. Obviously, the numerous levels at play in this electronic medium greatly enrich the biblical text. But what exactly happens when a story changes into another medium?
This paper seeks to foreground the interplay between New Testament texts and the video game "Fatale," thus, unravelling dimensions of meaning added to the discussion by the electronic medium. Besides questions of visualizing and musically interpreting biblical content, on the one hand filling gaps of the story on the other creating new ones, one major focus will be interaction as a distinctive feature of video games and how it affects our understanding of the story surrounding the originally unnamed daughter of Herodias. Consequently, a second focus will be on ‘reversing the hermeneutical flow’ (Larry Kreitzer); i.e. starting from the pop-cultural medium and its analysis this paper will revisit the ancient text shedding new light on its interpretations and interpretative possibilities. This way I hope to present convincing reason why exegetes should play video games.
http://tale-of-tales.com/Fatale/
Thimo Zirpel works as assistant and doctoral student in the biblical section of the Institute for Catholic Theology and its Didactics, University of Muenster, Germany.
|
Tatian’s “Second-to-Last” Supper: The Diatessaron and the Crucifixion Chronology
Program Unit: Syriac Literature and Interpretations of Sacred Texts
Nicholas J. Zola, Baylor University
Tatian’s Diatessaron is probably the first representation of the Gospels in Syriac. Yet as a gospel harmony, it does not present the Gospels in their traditional form, but rather weaves them together into one majestic narrative, smoothing over differences and harmonizing parallel events. As such, it offers interesting readings of apparent discrepancies within the Gospels, including the famous debate over the nature of the Last Supper and the date of the crucifixion. In this case, Tatian does not harmonize John’s foot-washing meal and the Synoptic Passover meal into one long Last Supper, as we might expect. Instead, Tatian separates the accounts into two distinct suppers, creating a Last Supper and a “Second-to-Last” Supper, as it were.
Is this innovation simply Tatian’s creativity at work? Or is there more involved? Around the same time Tatian was compiling his Diatessaron, the Quartodeciman controversy erupted over when to celebrate Easter—on Passover itself, or the Sunday following? Turning to the Gospels for support, both sides quickly discovered the calendrical divergence, triggering a secondary debate over the nature of the Last Supper. I believe Tatian joined this debate by offering a solution in his Diatessaron.
There is one problem, however, with consulting the Diatessaron: it no longer exists, as such. The Syriac Diatessaron succumbed to a fifth-century campaign that systematically replaced it with orthodox-approved copies of the separated Gospels. Fortunately, witnesses to the Diatessaron survive. But some of these witnesses separate the two Last Suppers, and some do not. So I seek to discover: (1) The original Last Supper sequence of Tatian’s Diatessaron; and (2) What factor the Quartodeciman controversy played in that sequence. I suggest that Tatian, aware of the Quartodeciman controversy and the resultant exegetical problem it uncovered, used his Diatessaron to propose what remains a unique solution to this gospel discrepancy.
|
Recent Developments in the Science of Memory
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Stuart Zola, Emory University
This paper will present recent developments in studies of memory from the perspective of neuroscience.
|
Can the Masculine Mesopotamian King be a Feminine Vessel?
Program Unit: Prophetic Texts and Their Ancient Contexts
Ilona Zsolnay, University of Pennsylvania
In the majority of extant cuneiform reports of prophetic activity the reported deliverers of divine messages are either patently women (as indicated by the determinative MÍ) or, when not obviously so, persons deemed of ambiguous gender. Fundamental to this latter categorization is the theory that only women, or those of a feminine gender (read: not masculine), can be the vessels through which the divine may speak. Seeming to contradict this assumption are a multitude of literary examples which plainly state that the divine comes directly into the minds of kings, ostensibly the very embodiment of masculinity, in the form of dreams. This paper seeks to examine this apparent contradiction and to once again investigate the role of gender in oracular messages.
|
"Hazor Once…": Ruin-Cults in Iron I Hazor?
Program Unit: Archaeological Excavations and Discoveries: Illuminating the Biblical World
Sharon Zuckerman, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
Two cult-places dated to the Iron I were excavated on the acropolis of Tel Hazor in northern Israel. Both are open cult-places (bamoth), consisting of standing stones (Masseboth) serving as the focus of an aniconic ritual activity, and other related finds. They are located close to each other, on the acropolis of the ruined Canaanite city. Previous treatments addressed their chronology and their function, against the background of early Israelite settlement of Canaan. The present paper highlights several aspects of these cult-places, and suggests a new theoretical framework within which their existence might be explained.
|
Between Chester and Capetown: Transformations of the Gospel in "Son of Man"
Program Unit: Bible and Film
Reinhold Zwick, Westfaelische Wilhelms-Universitaet Muenster
Inspired by the Mystery play-tradition in Chester (UK) and drawn to a dialogue with the recent past and present of South Africa, Mark Dornford-May created with his feature film “Son of Man” (2006) an equally fascinating and complex rereading of the Gospels. With its unique mixture of genres and film-styles joined with a consequent contextualisation and inculturation of the biblical message “Son of Man” is the most innovative Jesus film since Denys Arcand’s “Jesus of Montreal”. Via the powerful acting of the entirely black cast and an idiosyncratic blend of realism and theatrical stylisation the film manages to uncover anew the topicality and invigorating energy of the Gospel and encouragingly conveys it to its audience.
Beginning with a reconstruction of the strategies used to transform the Jesus-narratives, specifically selection and focusing of the biblical material as well as merging of medieval Mystery play-traditions and contemporary real life, this paper seeks to discuss central aspects of the film in comparison to earlier interpretations from the Jesus-film genre, esp. Pier Paolo Pasolini’s “The Gospel According to St. Matthew”: firstly Jesus Christ’s image and the contours of his mission and message, but also the profiles of other selected characters (such as Satan’s prominent role). An additional focus will be on the realisation of passages which have continuously challenged the cinema (e.g. miracle-traditions).
Following a reception-aesthetic approach, which understands texts as dynamic and meaning-generating processes, a final point will be to reverse the hermeneutical flow and take the transformed text, i.e. the film, as a vantage point to re-evaluate the source text: Does the film and its interpretation trigger a deeper understanding of the Gospel itself?
|
| |
|
|