Verses 18:65-82 in the Qur’anic chapter titled Al-Kahf (the Cave), which recount the story of Moses and the mysterious figure of Khidr, are among the well-known and frequently cited passages in the Islamic tradition. This story is frequently mined by scholars for the profound insights it offers into important themes such as divine wisdom, limitations of human knowledge, the position and role of revelation, and the mysterious workings of God's providence. A common thread that weaves through the rich tapestry of Islamic scholarship on these intriguing verses is a near total focus on the enigmatic character of Khidr. Scholars have meticulously dissected and expounded upon the nuances of every action and utterance of the enigmatic figure. However, amidst this scholarly discourse, there exists a compelling argument that the character of Moses has been somewhat overshadowed. This paper will attempt to recalibrate the lens through which we view this timeless story. Rather than perpetuating the dominant narrative centering on Khidr, it endeavors to shift the focus and illuminate the oft-neglected role of Moses. By carefully analyzing the verses and scrutinizing Moses' character and actions, this study seeks to unveil a fresh perspective, one that promises to enrich our understanding of the narrative's deeper meanings. At its core, the main contention of this paper is that some of Moses’ actions are out of step with his character and with what we know about him. A pivot towards Moses as the focal point of analysis engenders a significant shift in our interpretation of the story. By shining a spotlight on Moses' journey, dilemmas, and interactions, we open a new horizon of insights that might otherwise remain obscured.